Mohammad Ali Jinnah Universality (Islamabad Campus)

Electronic Engineering Department

FINAL YEAR DESIGN PROJECT PANEL ASSESSMENT (Part I)
1

Project Title

Students Name &

Student 1

Student 2

Student 3

Registration No.

Referees Name
& Signature

Assessment Criteria

Ability to Identify and

formulate Design
Problem
Design Innovation and
complexity

Problem Analysis

Fail
1

Poor
2
Insufficient identification of
Design Problem, inadequate
project objectives.
Project has no design
innovation Design complexity
is not acceptable for a Final
year project

Satisfactory
3

Good
4

Partial identification of
Adequate identification of
Problem, lack of specifics does problem; any lack of
impair design solution
specifics does not impair
design solution
Project contains few
innovative aspects. Design
complexity is acceptable

Problem analysis part is skipped Problem Analyses performed is

or does not contribute to creating haphazard and design
an effective design
parameter selection is
spontaneous

Excellent
5

Score
Student
1

Score
Student
2

Score
Student
3

Clear and complete

identification of design goals
and project objectives

Project contains some

innovative aspects.
Design complexity is
appropriate.

Project contains significant

innovative aspects and design
complexity is sufficient for a
Final year project

Problem analysis
performed correctly and
design parameters are
chosen accordingly

Multiple design alternatives

are analyzed and effective
problem analyses is performed
to choose design parameters.

Page 1 of 2

Project does not follow any

design procedure. No evidence
of how design has evolved over
time

Project demonstrates little use

of design process in parameter
selection, intermediate design
steps up-till final working
prototype

Project demonstrates some

use of design process from
parameter selection,
intermediate design steps
up-till final working
prototype

Project demonstrates effective

use of design process from
parameter selection,
intermediate design steps uptill final working prototype

Project plan and

Resource Management

No project plan is followed.

Some resource persons have no
contribution in project
completion

Project Plan is made but not

followed. Some resource
persons have done more work
as compared to others

Project completed
according to a plan. All
resource persons are
involved in project design
and implementation

Project is well executed

according to a project plan,
tasks are distributed and
resource persons are allocated
according

Design Documentation

Project Report has no proper

format. Report chapters are
incomplete with poor English

Project Report attempts

appropriate format. Some
chapters in report have missing
information

Project Report is according

to format. All chapters in
report are complete with
references.

Project Report exactly follows

format. All chapters in report
are well organized with
references

Design Procedure

Page 2 of 2