Professional Documents
Culture Documents
The point is not to equate, excuse or balance abuses but to demonstrate that "
reporting is based on human rights principles rather than partisan considerations."
:(HRW's Position Paper on the Durban Preparatory Committee (April 21, 2008
The following analysis demonstrates that HRW's own activities related to Israel
continue to fall short of this basic standard of universality
:Summary
Analysis of Human Rights Watch's use of the rhetoric of international law•
and other terminology shows continued double standards and misleading
.or false claims
HRW accuses Israel of “collective punishment” of Palestinians in a way•
that is inconsistent with both international law and past and present usage
.of the term by HRW itself
HRW’s focus on Israel in 2007 dropped to 2005 levels after 2006 marked a•
return to the extreme bias of the 2000-2004 period. The change in 2007
allowed more resources to be focused on countries committing major
.human rights violations
However, disproportionate emphasis on Israel continued, with major•
reports covering 400 pages in 2007, using the same methodologies as in
.2006 that lack credibility
This contrasts with the limited attention on human rights violations in•
.Libya, Syria, and other countries in the region
Israel was the focus of more multimedia items (audio, video, graphics)•
.than any other country in the region
Reports on Israel continue to be based on unverifiable evidence provided•
by “eyewitnesses,” selected journalists, and other inappropriate sources. In
.some cases hard evidence has shown this testimony to be blatantly untrue
HRW mentioned one or more of the kidnapped Israeli soldiers in a total of•
only 6 publications. Of these, only two refer to them by name; the other
.references are in passing
This report includes quantitative analyses of publications from HRW’s Middle East
and North Africa section, using a weighted scale methodology consistent with NGO
Monitor’s previous analyses, and an assessment of the use of language in the HRW
.publications
Agenda Analysis: Focus on Israel returns to 2005 levels
NGO Monitor’s analysis of Human Rights Watch's (HRW) output devoted to each
country in the Middle East and North Africa region shows that the focus on and
condemnations of Israel in 2007 returned to 2005 levels (see 2005 report). This
follows a sharp increase in 2006 (see 2006 report). However, Israel is still the focus of
nine percent of HRW's output on the region– significantly greater than Libya, Syria,
Hamas, Hezbollah and other chronic human rights violators. The evaluation is based
on a point system which accounts for both the volume of publications and their
significance (a report clearly being much more significant and requiring more
.(resources than a press release –see the methodological section of the appendix
Figure 1 provides a comparison of the relative output (weighted as described in the
methodology section in appendix) of countries in the Middle East over the past three
years. Figure 1 demonstrates the degree that an increased focus on Israel correlates
with a decreased focus on other countries in the region, such as Iran and Egypt.1 In
absolute terms, HRW’s total output on the Middle East and North Africa has increased
steadily over the period 2005-2007, the results presented here are in percentage terms
.to enable comparison
Footnotes
Lebanon and Iraq have been excluded from this longitudinal analysis due to the 1
impact and separate reporting on external actors in these countries. These factors
make data analysis on these countries between years inconsistent. This does not
.impact on the accuracy of reporting within a given year
of 1260 points were devoted to Israel in 2007, compared to 59 of 702 points in 121 2
2005. In 2006 223 of 1088 points (over 20%) were focused on Israel, this is partly
explained by the Second Lebanon War. The total publications (in terms of both
weighted score and in terms of actual number of documents) has steadily increased
across the region over the last three year. The percentage of these documents
.dedicated to Israel has been erratic over the three year period
The pictures and audio alleging that Israel prevented residents of Gaza from leaving 3
to seek external medical treatment are also linked at the top to a press release. This
.has been included as a multimedia item in this report
".Indiscriminate Fire" and "Why they Died" 4
One on the Lebanon War (Why they died), one on Iraqi refugees (Rot here or die 5
(there) and one on domestic workers (Exported and Exposed
According to the data published by B’tselem, 351 Palestinians were killed by other 6
Palestinians
(http://www.btselem.org/english/Statistics/Casualties_Data.asp?Category=23)
compared with 379 casualties from clashes with Israeli security forces
(http://www.btselem.org/english/Statistics/Casualties_Data.asp?Category=1). Such
data is not reliable, and if anything, underestimates the extent of internal Palestinian
(.violence
Examples include "Hospitals offer no safety in Gaza strip," ABC News, 13 June, 7
.2007 and "Crowd loots Gaza home of Arafat," Ali Waked and Reuters, 16 June, 2007
To avoid double counting, publications with attention given to at least one of: the 8
Palestinian Authority / Fatah, Hamas or “Palestinian armed groups” were included in
.the Palestinian count
In the language analyses of previous years, NGO Monitor included “torture”. In 9
2007, HRW did not use the term torture in any reports on Israel, while Palestinian
torture related to factional violence received a single mention. This data is presented
.in a separate graph in the appendix
See methodology section for more details 10
Is Israel Bound by International Law to Supply Utilities, Goods, and Services to" 11
Gaza?" Abraham Bell, JCPA Vol. 7, No. 33 28 February 2008
Peter Finn, Russia Cuts Off Gas to Ukraine In Controversy Over Pricing, 12
Washington Post, Monday, January 2, 2006, Page A07
Is Israel Bound by International Law to Supply Utilities, Goods, and Services to" 13
Gaza?" Abraham Bell, JCPA Vol. 7, No. 33 28 February 2008
See "International Law and Gaza: The Assault on Israel's Right to Self-Defense," 14
Jerusalem Viewpoints (Jerusalem Center for Public Affairs) Vol. 7, No. 29, Abraham
Bell, January 28, 2008; and Dr. Avi Bell, "Is Israel Bound by International Law to
Supply Utilities, Goods, and Services to Gaza?" Jerusalem Viewpoints (Jerusalem
,Center for Public Affairs) Vol. 7, No. 33, 28 February 2008
When searching site:hrw.org blockade and "collective punishment" +Israel 77 15
results are returned. When searching site:hrw.org blockade and "collective
punishment" -Israel 63 results are returned. The 77 documents represent 55% of the
total. (Some publications include separate sections in which both terms are used, and
are counted twice.) These are heuristic measures only as HRW reports may be listed
.two or more times due to posting as pdf files as well as web pages
See IDF Spokesperson reports of trucks entering Gaza with supplies; Aluf Benn, 16
Dichter: Israel to allow aid supplies, food into Gaza, Haaretz, 16 June, 2007
Ethiopia and the State of Democracy: Effects on Human Rights and Humanitarian” 17
Conditions in the Ogaden and Somalia,” HRW, October 2, 2007
See "Ethiopia's dirty war," Tom Porteous, London director HRW, Published in 18
.Guardian Unlimited August 05, 2007
Indiscriminate Fire: Palestinian Rocket Attacks on Israel and Israeli Artillery" 19
.Shelling in the Gaza Strip," HRW, July 1, 2007
See "Gaza beach incident: Timeline of HRW involvement and activities June 9-21 20
2006," NGO Monitor, June 21, 2006
Yaavoc Katz, IDF not responsible for Gaza blast, Jerusalem Post, Jun 13, 2006 21
Yaakov Katz and Judy Siegel-Itzkovich, Gaza beach blast victim wakes, Jerusalem 22
(Post, June 19 2006 (updated June 20th
HRW has a history of publishing “facts” despite being aware of contradictory 23
evidence. For example after the July 30, 2006 Qana incident in the Lebanon War,
Lucy Mair of HRW disregarded the Red Cross estimate of 28 casualties in favor of
the higher estimate of 54 provided by an alleged “survivor” [see Kim Murphy,
“Warfare in the Middle East: Officials Say 28 Die in Qana not 54,” The Los Angeles
.[.Times, August 4, 2006
Why They Died: Civilian Casualties in Lebanon during the 2006 War," HRW," 24
September 5, 2007