Professional Documents
Culture Documents
History of war and conflict often entails incidents of sexual acts and violence
against women, and this is still true to modern day wars. The difference
between rape in pre-1990 conflicts and modern day wars, such as the incidents
in Yugoslavia, Sudan and Rwanda, is the intention to transfer HIV to the victims
as a weapon of war. Although there are debates whether the intention to
transfer HIV is conclusive, there is evidence confirming the deliberate nature of
these acts. The evidence provided includes unofficial statistics and data, and
victim accounts. In efforts to reconstruct post conflict societies, the
disarmament, demobilization and reintegration (DDR) process assists in
providing resources and programs to help victims of war rehabilitate. However,
this treatment is not available for victims of rape and the authors argument is
that these victims of rape should have the right to financial reparation,
psychological and physical rehabilitation (Objiofor Aginam, 2012).
Brief discussion of theory:
Idealism is a specific form of liberalism that debates the need for states to
pursue moral goals and to behave ethically in the international community. It is
believed that behaviour considered immoral on a social level is also immoral in
foreign policy. It believes that by following morality and moral values, nations
can help the world to eliminate war, inequality and violence. The main features
of idealism are that; global efforts are needed to violence, and that human
welfare and advancement of civilization are the concerns of all.
A world full of human happiness is not beyond human power to achieve.
Bertrand Russell
Analysis of the application of the theory:
Unlike realism or liberalism, idealism deals with individuals and societies rather
than states or the international system. Idealism concerns itself with rejecting
the harmful nature of human nature in favour of new ways determined by
knowledge, reason and compassion. Idealism and realism are complete polar
opposites as the realist approach rejects the idealist view of a utopia.
Liberalism is not the same as idealism but it does have similarities. Both
liberalism and idealism are based on the need to protect and improve the
individual. However, the liberalist approach requires actors to strategically
calculate the costs and benefits before acting, following a logic of
consequences. This is unlike idealism as actors behave in accordance with
their sense of appropriateness.
In this case, the author is arguing about the moral obligation to provide victims
of rape with financial reparation, psychological and physical rehabilitation.
Thus, in this case, the most suitable theory to be applied would be idealism.
However, there is a slight hint of liberalism as well. The fact remains whether or
not transmission of HIV through rape was intentional or not. If it is so, liberalists
would argue that states should cooperate to prevent this and are responsible
for protecting victims of war from such atrocities.
What aspects of the case do you need to emphasize and what aspects
are not as important?
The author seems to include the fact that HIV is to be seen as a weapon of war.
The author then argues later on that victims of rape should have the right to
financial reparation, psychological and physical rehabilitation. What I believe,
however, is that the main argument of this case should not be whether or not
HIV is to be seen as a weapon of war, but the issue of violence and rape should
be the most forefront topic. From an idealist approach, rape resulting in HIV
and rape not resulting in HIV are both atrocities which need to be addressed.
References:
Andrew Moravcsik, Liberalism and international relations theory. Harvard
Univeristy. pg, 92-96
Emilian Kavalski, (2015). Encounters with world affairs. An introduction to
international relations. England
Objiofor Aginam, (2012). Rape and HIV as weapons of war. UNU Press.
SparkNotes Editors. (2010). SparkNote on International Politics. Retrieved
October 30, 2015, from http://www.sparknotes.com/us-government-andpolitics/political-science/international-politics/
Yourarticlelibrary. (2015). Idealism: Idealism in international relations. Retreived
from October 19, 2015, from http://www.yourarticlelibrary.com/internationalpolitics/idealism-idealism-in-international-relations/48471/