Professional Documents
Culture Documents
GEST 79/82
11th Edition
July 2013
GEST 79/82
11th Edition
Euro Chlor
Euro Chlor is the European federation which represents the producers of chlorine
and its primary derivatives.
Euro Chlor is working to:
***********
This document has been produced by the members of Euro Chlor and should not be reproduced in
whole or in part without the prior written consent of Euro Chlor.
It is intended to give only guidelines and recommendations. The information is provided in good
faith and was based on the best information available at the time of publication. The
information is to be relied upon at the users own risk. Euro Chlor and its members make no
guarantee and assume no liability whatsoever for the use and the interpretation of or the
reliance on any of the information provided.
This document was originally prepared in English by our technical experts. For our members
convenience, it may have been translated into other EU languages by translators / Euro Chlor
members. Although every effort was made to ensure that the translations were accurate, Euro
Chlor shall not be liable for any losses of accuracy or information due to the translation process.
Prior to 1990, Euro Chlors technical activities took place under the name BITC (Bureau
International Technique du Chlore). References to BITC documents may be assumed to be to
Euro Chlor documents.
July 2013
Page 2 of 21
GEST 79/82
11th Edition
July 2013
Page 3 of 21
GEST 79/82
11th Edition
Section
3.
4.1.1.
TABLE OF CONTENTS
1.
INTRODUCTION
2.
GENERAL COMMENTS
3.
4.
MATERIALS
4.1. Metallic Materials
4.1.1.
4.1.2.
4.1.3.
4.1.4.
4.1.5.
4.1.6.
4.1.7.
4.1.8.
4.1.9.
4.1.10.
4.1.11.
9
9
Carbon Steel
Cast Iron
Ductile Iron
Stainless Steels and Cast Steels
Nickel Alloys
Titanium
Tantalum
Copper
Silver, Gold
Lead
Aluminium, Tin, Zinc
9
11
11
11
12
13
13
13
14
14
14
4.2. Plastics
4.3.1.
4.3.2.
4.3.3.
4.3.4.
4.3.5.
July 2013
Rubber or Ebonite
Graphite
Stoneware, Glass, Enamel
Brickwork
Silicon carbide
14
14
15
15
16
16
16
17
17
17
17
17
18
18
18
18
Page 4 of 21
GEST 79/82
11th Edition
5.
GASKETS
19
6.
19
7.
PRECAUTIONARY COMMENTS
19
8.
REFERENCES
20
July 2013
Page 5 of 21
GEST 79/82
11th Edition
1. INTRODUCTION
This recommendation is written to provide general advice on the suitability of
various materials for industrial application with chlorine. It does not attempt to
define the various corrosion processes but indicates the conditions under which
certain materials can be used or should be avoided. Care must however be taken
to consider the possibility of the presence of other constituents in either the
chlorine or the materials of construction, as the presence of certain trace
components can considerably influence the corrosion behaviour. Practical testing
under service conditions is therefore the best guide to the suitability of any
particular material. Temperature and velocity may modify corrosion resistance.
The guideline deliberately covers only materials which have been used
successfully by at least 2 Euro Chlor companies for more than 2 years. It is
recognised that individual companies may have good experience with materials
not covered in this guideline, or with a wider range of operating conditions.
The limits quoted should be taken as a guide rather than being treated as
accurately defined.
Mechanical properties are dealt with in more detail in specific engineering
recommendations such as those issued by Euro Chlor. These recommendations,
in any case of uncertainty, should not be taken as a firm guide but reference
should be made to a chlorine producer to confirm the suitability of any material
for a given duty.
2. GENERAL COMMENTS
Materials of construction must be chosen to suit the conditions under which
chlorine is being handled
Wet or dry
Gaseous or liquid chlorine
Temperature
Pressure
For dry chlorine gas (see definition in GEST 10/362 Corrosion Behaviour of
Carbon Steel in Wet and Dry Chlorine) steel is the usual material. For liquid
chlorine and cold dry chlorine gas, steel with suitable toughness (fine grain
carbon steel) should be used, taking into account the possibility of low
temperatures from potential depressurisation of the system.
For wet chlorine gas, the usual materials are titanium, rubber lined steel, Glass
Reinforced Plastics (GRP), PTFE lined steel, PVC/PVC-C externally reinforced
with GRP (PVC/GRP) and PVDF.
When plastic materials are selected, the following items must be taken into
account:
resistance to ageing
July 2013
Page 6 of 21
GEST 79/82
11th Edition
July 2013
Page 7 of 21
GEST 79/82
11th Edition
WET
CHLORINE
GAS
N
N
N
N
N (*)
Graphite
COMMENTS
G
G
G
G
G
to 120C
to 120C
to 120C
to 150C
up to 300C
G to 90C
LIQUID
G
G XX
G XX
G
G
4.1.1
4.1.2
4.1.3
4.1.4
4.1.5
4.1.6
G to 150C
N
N
N
A to 20C
N
N
N
N
G to 150C
G to 150C
A to 150C
G to 150C
A to 20C
G to 100C
N
N
N
G to 90C
G to 90C
4.2.1
A to 60C
G to 80C
G to 120C
G to 200C
G to 100C
G to 180C
N
N
N
G
A
N
G
G
G
G
G
G
N
N
N
G
G
G
N
N
N
N
N
N
4.2.2
4.2.3
4.2.4
4.2.5
4.2.6
4.2.7
4.2.9
4.2.8
4.2.8
4.3.1
4.3.1
4.3.1
4.3.2
to 60C
to 80C
to 120C
to 200C
to 100C
to 180C
N
A to 30C
A to 30C
A
A
N
G to 200 C (with
PTFE impregnation)
G
G
G
G
G
A XX
N
N
N
4.1.7
4.1.8
4.1.8
4.1.8
4.1.9
4.1.10
4.1.11
4.1.11
G XX
G XX
G XX
4.3.3
G XX
G
G to 100C
G
G XX
G
G to 100C
G
G XX
G XX
N
G
4.3.3
4.3.3
4.3.4
4.3.5
July 2013
Page 8 of 21
GEST 79/82
11th Edition
Comments:
1. Temperatures stated above give an indication of the typical
recommended maximum values; they can be influenced by the specific
surface area, texture .
2. The above table refers to the non-reinforced plastics without any
plasticiser or filler.
3. See definition in GEST 10/362 Corrosion Behaviour of Carbon Steel in
Wet and Dry Chlorine
4. For all plastic materials where it applies, the temperature limit could be
lower, depending on the supporting material (FRP for example).
4. MATERIALS
4.1.
Metallic Materials
Steels cannot be used with wet chlorine, or when moisture can accidentally be
present, due to the risk of severe corrosion (pitting in the case of stainless
steel),
4.1.1.
Carbon Steel
Carbon steel is the most commonly used material for handling liquid chlorine or
dry gas.
A grade of steel must be chosen to suit the temperatures which can arise in each
case. The use can be restricted by the impact toughness of the steel.
For liquid chlorine and cold dry chlorine gas, fine grain carbon steel with
guaranteed low temperature impact properties should be used, taking into
account the possibility of depressurising the system (vaporisation of residual
liquid chlorine at minus 34C at atmospheric pressure or lower if pressure can go
sub-atmospheric).
The following are general requirements for steel used for tanks, pipes, transport
equipment ; for valves components, specific requirements are given in the
GEST 06/318.
Chemical composition
July 2013
Page 9 of 21
GEST 79/82
11th Edition
Mechanical properties
The actual maximum tensile strength Rm of any component should not exceed
the lesser of:
Average impact
energy for 3 tests
J
Minimum impact
energy for any one
test
J
355
27
19
460
40
28
July 2013
Page 10 of 21
GEST 79/82
11th Edition
In contact with dry chlorine, carbon steels become covered by a layer of ferric
chloride. It is this layer that protects the underlying carbon steel from further
attack2; it can nevertheless be destroyed by different mechanism, resulting in
the corrosion of the underlying steel (see GEST 10/362 Corrosion Behaviour
of Carbon Steel in Wet and Dry Chlorine).
In certain circumstances where there is a risk of traces of hydrocarbon based
oils, water or rust being present, reaction with chlorine can increase the
temperature sufficiently to lead to spontaneous ignition of steel.
The use of steel with a high specific surface area, such as steel wool, should be
avoided. When chlorine reacts with iron, the temperature can increase
sufficiently to cause ignition of steel.
Forged or cast steel can be used on condition that the mechanical property of
the fabricated components have been studied for the range of temperatures and
stress which might be encountered.
4.1.2.
Cast Iron
In the past cast iron was frequently used for dry chlorine, but it is not the case
anymore and its use on pressurised chlorine duties should be abandoned for
safety reasons due to its low fracture toughness.
The corrosion behaviour in the presence of chlorine is similar to that of normal
steels, and the temperature should be below 120C.
Its use in chlorine, however, is not advisable except under specific well defined
circumstances for the manufacture of components where there will be no
problem due to mechanical shock (poor impact toughness) or tensile forces. With
cast iron components, the material needs to be checked for absence of defects
which could cause porosity to chlorine under pressure.
4.1.3.
Ductile Iron
Rarely used, its corrosion behaviour in the presence of chlorine is similar to that
of carbon steel. Its use in chlorine is however not advisable, except under
specifically well-defined circumstances for the manufacture of components
where there will be no problem due to mechanical shock (poor impact
toughness) or tensile forces, e.g. for PTFE-lined valves for wet chlorine. The
operation temperature is also limited to 120C.
4.1.4.
Stainless and cast steels are suitable for use with dry chlorine.
They should not generally be used if there is the likelihood of contamination
with water. Chlorine contaminated with moisture forms HCl which results in
pitting corrosion on stainless steel. For this reasons, stainless steels are not
recommended for thin section applications e.g. bellows and bursting disc.
2
Hammink, M.W.J. and Westen, P.C. - Modern Chlor-Alkali Technology [3] 71-81 (1985)
July 2013
Page 11 of 21
GEST 79/82
11th Edition
When used at elevated temperatures (>50C) the risk of chloride stress corrosion
cracking (SCC) shall be considered. SCC can lead to serious failure of equipment
even in the absence of obvious corrosion damage. Chlorides from the external
environment that become trapped in damp lagging on stainless equipment can
cause particular SCC problems. The risk can be reduced by protecting the
stainless steel with a suitable paint system, and by wrapping the equipment in
aluminium foil under the insulation.
Duplex stainless steel and high alloyed stainless steels (super stainless steels)
have greater resistance to pitting corrosion, Stress Corrosion Cracking and also
higher temperature limits in gaseous chlorine.
4.1.5.
Nickel Alloys
4.1.5.1. Alloy 200, 400, 600 and 625
July 2013
Page 12 of 21
GEST 79/82
11th Edition
4.1.6.
Titanium
The water content in the gaseous phase has to be always kept at least
equal to the water partial pressure at 15C3,
There are many different types of titanium used on plant, both pure (e.g. grade
2) and alloys e.g. alloys with palladium for increased resistance to crevice
corrosion (e.g. grade 7,11). The grade used should be selected based on the
specific application.
4.1.7.
Tantalum
Tantalum is the only metal that can be used without restriction on wet and dry
chlorine but its limited mechanical strength and the possible risk of creep have
to be taken into account. Due to its high price, however, it is used only for
special equipment parts such as transmitter membranes and bursting discs.
Tantalum can also be affected by hydrogen embrittlement, for example as a
consequence of the corrosion of adjacent materials.
4.1.8.
Copper
Copper is resistant to dry chlorine gas or liquid (but not to wet chlorine). The
use of copper is restricted to flexible connections for drum and cylinder filling,
but it becomes embrittled by frequent stressing and requires regular stress
relieving by moderate heat treatment. The operating temperature is limited to
40C maximum.
Certain alloys of copper (such as brass or bronze) have been proved acceptable
by long service experience (e.g. certain cylinder valves) but require regular
inspection and frequent replacement (risk of cracks). Ammonia in the
atmosphere (e.g. from leak-testing chlorine joints) can cause stress corrosion
cracking in copper and its alloys.
Taking a safety margin with respect to the 13C minimum referred to in the TSEM 93/192
July 2013
Page 13 of 21
GEST 79/82
11th Edition
4.1.9.
Silver, Gold
These metals are resistant to dry chlorine (not to wet chlorine) but they have
poor mechanical properties. They are sometimes used for protective membranes
and bursting discs.
4.1.10. Lead
Lead is resistant to dry chlorine and the rate of attack upon lead by moist
chlorine is low.
Lead can be used as a trapped gasket in some circumstances, but otherwise its
use with chlorine is not recommended on safety reasons because of its poor
mechanical properties.
Lead-antimony alloys are sometimes used for protective membranes, because
they are resistant in the presence of moisture.
4.1.11. Aluminium, Tin, Zinc
None of the above metals should be used for chlorine, nor should, in general,
alloys based on these materials. They are not resistant to chlorine (poor
mechanical properties, risk of severe corrosion with wet chlorine and/or risk of
fire).
4.2. Plastics
The following comments deal only with the use of the materials on construction
duties or as a lining. Their behaviour when used on specialised duties is dealt
with in sections 5 and 6. Most of these plastics cannot be used with liquid
chlorine.
They are slowly attacked by chlorine and require a schedule of inspection and
replacement before they become defective. Many of them are liable to stress
corrosion cracking and the fabrication of components or systems from plastics
should avoid regions of high stress during manufacture or service.
4.2.1.
Certain chemically resistant resins, such as vinyl esters and modified polyesters,
exhibit excellent performances in wet and dry chlorine gas environment at
temperatures up to 80C, The GRP laminates can suffer from chlorination in
service, which lead to thinning, and an additional corrosion allowance should be
considered in the design to provide an economic operational life.
With precautions, the material can be used down to minus 20C, but there is a
risk of embrittlement below 0C.
Long term performance of GRP equipment is highly dependant on the method of
construction. For example all chopped strand mat (CSM) constructed equipment
tends to have longer operational lives than CSM/woven roving construction
July 2013
Page 14 of 21
GEST 79/82
11th Edition
equipment (woven roving constructions are usually thinner with a higher glass
content resulting in greater loss of strength per unit thickness of chlorination).
There are a number of commercially available materials that have been
confirmed as suitable for use on chlorine. As not all resins are equivalent, advice
on the type used, its method of fabrication and use should be checked with an
experienced chlorine manufacturer before selection and installation. The
operational life depends on laminate construction and resin type.
GRP must not be used where liquid chlorine may be present.
4.2.2.
PVC has a fair resistance to gaseous chlorine, and is especially good for wet gas.
After prolonged use the wall thickness will reduce due to surface
chlorination/corrosion (periodic check is recommended). The material may
become brittle below 0C and therefore can be susceptible to cracking and
failure due to impact.
Exposure to chlorine containing liquor that experiences wide variations in pH can
lead to rapid thinning as the chlorinated layer is removed.
PVC has low fracture toughness and pressure containing equipment should be
reinforced externally with GRP to improve mechanical strength.
PVC is subject to stress corrosion and it is recommended that the material
should be stress-relieved before use.
PVC is susceptible to environmental cracking with welds being particularly
vulnerable.
Operating pressures must be limited and support must be provided. The
acceptable temperature range is between minus 5C and 40C, but PVC is
generally externally reinforced with GRP to improve the mechanical strength,
and can then be used to 60C.
As the thermal expansion of PVC is different from that of GRP, the
reinforcement is often adhered to the PVC (but take care of cracking risk). This
is achieved by using a priming coat in the PVC/GRP interface so that PVC and
GRP are chemically bond to each other. This procedure unfortunately gives a
brittle behaviour in the PVC which can be dangerous4.
PVC and PVC/GRP must not be used where liquid chlorine may be present.
4.2.3.
July 2013
Page 15 of 21
GEST 79/82
11th Edition
PVDF has good resistance from minus 40C up to 120C on wet or dry chlorine
gas. At the upper end of this temperature range it stands up better than PVC
and polyesters, but is subject to chlorination.
Like most plastics already listed, the material is liable to stress corrosion
cracking. The stress cracking problem for PVDF is caused by caustic soda and
also atomic chlorine radicals (for example due to UV light or in certain chemical
reaction conditions).
PVDF grades specified as "Atomic chlorine resistant" should be used on chlorine
duties. PVDF can also be reinforced externally with GRP to give improved
mechanical strength for applications at higher pressures.
PVDF can be used as lining of steel pipes and equipment, but care must be taken
due to the permeation of chlorine which may attack the support material.
PVDF and PVDF/GRP must not be used with liquid chlorine.
4.2.5.
PTFE - PolyTetraFluoroEthylene
PTFE resists wet, dry and liquid chlorine from minus 50C till 200C.
Due to its poor mechanical properties, PTFE should always have a supporting
material. However, it should be noted that chlorine can diffuse through PTFE,
which is not completely impervious (particularly at elevated temperatures). The
problem of permeability can be reduced by using greater material thicknesses.
Where PTFE is used as a protective layer, the integrity of the supporting
material must be regularly inspected.
4.2.6.
ECTFE (ethylene-chlorotrifluoroethylene)
July 2013
Page 16 of 21
GEST 79/82
11th Edition
As the permeation of water is one of the lowest, this product is good for wet
chlorine applications.
ECTFE is susceptible to stress cracking in sodium hypochlorite.
4.2.7. FEP (TFE/HFP-copolymer), PFA (Perfluoro-alkoxypolymer),
ECTFE (Ethylene chloro-trifluoro-ethylene)
Various fluorinated copolymers are also used because of their corrosion
resistance to wet or dry chlorine. They can be more easily fabricated than PTFE
with fewer problems of permeability. The maximum allowable temperature is
usually 180C, and the minimum minus 50C.
PFA is more permeable to water than PTFE (and especially at higher
temperature) which needs to be considered for wet chlorine service.
4.2.8.
Polypropylene, Polyethylene
Polypropylene and polyethylene have some resistance to dry chlorine gas at low
temperature but must not be used with wet chlorine gas. Both are more
severely attacked by chlorine above 30C (maximum allowed). The minimum
temperature for polyethylene is minus 5C, but polypropylene can be used till
minus 40C.
These materials are subject to embrittlement; they are less resistant than PVC
and are mostly used in low chlorine concentration environments.
It is recommended that polypropylene be stress-relieved before use.
They must not be used with liquid chlorine.
4.2.9.
Other Plastics
Several other specialised plastics have been developed and tested on chlorine
duty (e.g. Acrylonitrile/Butadiene/Styrene copolymers). Their use with chlorine
gas can only be recommended where practical experience has been
demonstrated as suitable for a particular duty (check with experienced chlorine
manufacturers).
Remark: PEEK (polyether-ether-ketone) is commonly used in valve shaft bearing.
This material has inadequate resistance to chlorine and can swell, leading to
seizing of valves).
4.3.
Other Materials
4.3.1.
Rubber or Ebonite
All forms of synthetic or natural rubber lack mechanical strength and chemical
resistance to chlorine is strongly dependant on rubber formulation. Any rubber
should be thoroughly evaluated before use. The slow rate of attack on some
July 2013
Page 17 of 21
GEST 79/82
11th Edition
rubber grades in chlorine gas means that it is frequently used as a lining material
for chlorine duty up to 85C (depending on the grade of rubber).
It must not be used on liquid chlorine duty.
4.3.2.
Graphite
Ceramics and glass show good resistance to wet as well as to dry chlorine, but
their breaking strength is so low that their use in technical applications has
constantly declined. They are still used today in laboratories and to a small
extent for lining steel vessels, also for enamelled steel containers.
These materials must not be used on liquid chlorine duty since they are very
sensitive to thermal shocks.
4.3.4.
Brickwork
Anti-acid bricks are used for lining of wet chlorine towers. Cement should be
chosen with good chemical resistance to all the chemicals which are present. An
impervious lining should be used between the brickwork and the steel vessel.
These bricks have a poor shock resistance.
Brickwork will not be used on dry gaseous or on liquid chlorine.
4.3.5.
Silicon carbide
Silicon carbide is chemically resistant to dry and wet chlorine, and is normally
used for the liquid chlorine canned motor pump bearings, but has a poor
resistance to mechanical and thermal shocks.
July 2013
Page 18 of 21
GEST 79/82
11th Edition
5. GASKETS
For gas containing systems (wet or dry), a certain amount of corrosive attack on
rubber based on a synthetic elastomer is acceptable so long as the jointing
system retains the necessary seal under service conditions. However, for liquid
chlorine systems, whatever the pressure, reactive gasket materials such as
rubber must not be used.
See GEST 94/216 - Experience of Non-Asbestos Gaskets on Liquid and Dry
Chlorine Gas Service.
for dry chlorine : nickel, tantalum, Alloy 400 and Alloy C4, C22 and
C276 (stainless steel 316S/S is used, but with risk of stress corrosion
cracking)
7. PRECAUTIONARY COMMENTS
The above comments under sections (mainly 4.2) concern the pure materials,
without plasticisers, fillers, coatings, greases or other potentially reactive
ingredients. Therefore the choice of materials of construction for many systems
must be controlled to avoid the introduction of materials which could react with
chlorine.
It is also important when using any component (which is itself made from a
satisfactory material for use with chlorine) that separates chlorine from another
fluid that account is taken of the potential for leakage. This could occur in
components associated with heat transfer or hydraulic systems, where it is
important to make sure that the fluid is not reactive with chlorine and to avoid
products such as water, silicone fluids, hydrocarbon oils, etc. Suitable materials
for lubrication or hydraulic or heat transfer fluids are fully chlorofluorinated
fluids which are non-reactive to chlorine gas or liquid, e.g. fluids based on PFPE
(Perfluoro-polyether) or PCTFE (Polychloro-trifluoro-ethylene).
All ancillary equipment (instruments, sealing arrangements, etc.) should always
be made from materials which are compatible with chlorine. Materials used for
thermal insulation should also be selected from those, which do not react readily
with chlorine or generate corrosive products under service conditions.
July 2013
Page 19 of 21
GEST 79/82
11th Edition
8. REFERENCES
GEST 80/84 - Code of Good Practice for the Commissioning of
Installations for Dry Chlorine Gas and Liquid
July 2013
Page 20 of 21
GEST 79/82
11th Edition
July 2013
Page 21 of 21