You are on page 1of 13

ORIGINAL ARTICLE

Effectiveness of William's flexion exercises in


management of low back pain
1

Muhammad Usman Khalid , Mahvish Rafiq , Nosheen Zehra

Muhammad Usman Khalid

Student of Post Professional Doctor in Physical Therapy, Ziauddin University


Email: dr.usman_khalid@yahoo.com
Contact #: 0323-2097104
2

Mahvish Rafiq

Student of Post Professional Doctor in Physical Therapy, Ziauddin University


Email: mahvish_rafiq@hotmail.com
Contact #: 0322-2243384
3

Nosheen Zehra

Assistant Professor
Department of Community Health Sciences, Ziauddin University
Email: nosheen_zehra130@hotmail.com
Contact #: 0300-2427127
Corresponding Author
Nosheen Zehra
Assistant Professor
Department of Community Health Sciences, Ziauddin University
Email: nosheen_zehra130@hotmail.com
Contact #: 0300-2427127
Pakistan Journal of Medicine and Dentistry 2013, Vol. 1 (01): 21-33

21

Effectiveness of William's flexion exercises in management of low back pain

ABSTRACT
Background: Low back pain is a common musculoskeletal disorder affecting 84% people once in third life time. It
may be acute or chronic. Among various available options for management of low back pain, William's flexion
exercise is one of them. Williams flexion exercises the set of physical exercises use to enhance lumbar flexion to
avoid lumbar extension, and strengthen the abdominal and gluteus musculature to manage low back pain
Objective: To assess the effectiveness of William flexion exercise in management of patients with low back pain.
Methodology: A cross sectional study was conducted among 250 patients with low back pain from different hospitals
of Karachi. Sample was selected by convenience sampling technique and data was collected on structured
questionnaire. These patients were provided Williams Flexion Exercise and changes in pain and posture were
noticed before and after exercise. Data was analyzed by SPSS version 17and P value <0.05 was considered as
significant.
Result: Pain intensity was significantly (p value = 0.03) reduced in those who took more than 5 sessions of Williams
Flexion Exercise. Of total 96 (38.4%) patients with severe pain before exercise, no Pain was found in 20 (8%)
patients after exercise. From 107 (42.8%) and 47 (18.8%) patients with moderate and mild pain respectively, no pain
was found in 9 (3.6%) and 11 (4.4%) patients respectively. Spine flexion and extension was improved completely in
45 (18%) out of 132 (52.8%) patients with mild restrictions, in 24 (9.6%) out of 93 (37.2%) patients with moderate
restrictions and in 9 (3.6%) out of 25 (10%) patients with severe restrictions.
Conclusion: William flexion exercise provided benefits to most of the participants in the study, thus it may be an
effective technique to reduce the intensity of low back pain.
Key Words: Williams Flexion Exercise, Low Back Pain

INTRODUCTION

affect both the gender. Normally the pain is


divided on the basis of its duration3.The pain

Participants Low back pain (LBP) can be defined


lasting less than a week is called acute pain and
as the pain and stiffness in lower back. LBP is a
the pain which lasting more than a week to
common musculoskeletal disorder affecting 84%
months is called chronic low back pain. The
1

people at some point in their lives. LBP can


acute pain resolves within a week with specific

Pakistan Journal of Medicine and Dentistry 2013, Vol. 1 (01): 21-33

22

Muhammad Usman Khalid, Mahvish Rafiq and Nosheen Zehra


treatment. If this pain is not treated then become

damage.

chronic pain.4A chronic low back pain disturbs

pharmacological treatment may be treatment of

the individual during his working environment.

choice and beneficial for pain management.

Sometimes this pain becomes so severe that it

During the past two decades, the advice for LBP

So, due to these reasons non

will affect the daily activity. And for a while this

given by primary care physicians has changed.

pain becomes so extreme that person is unable

Adams

to move and outcome is complete bed rest.

minimizing bed rest or stays active and to avoid

There are numerous structures that surround the

bed rest.9

lumber supine like ligament and muscles. Spine

The rehabilitation program of chronic LBP is

when loses its stability by straining of these

beneficial

structures results in back pain.6The risk factors

MA

in

for

the

his

study

recommended

management

pain10.

of

Exercise therapy, can be effective after the

for straining are poor body posture, overweight

acute stage of LBP as well. The positive results

and weak back and abdominal muscle.

have been known with specific types of exercise

Various treatment options are available for

used by physical therapists.11

management of LBP.7Short term use of pain and

Among these specific exercises, one is Williams

anti-inflammatory medications may help relieve


flexion exercises (WFE) also called Williams
the symptoms of lower back pain. NSAIDs are
lumbar flexion exercises. These are the set of
slightly effective for short-term symptomatic
physical exercises use to enhance lumbar
relief in patients with acute and chronic low-back
flexion

to

avoid

lumbar

extension,

and

pain without sciatica. Muscle relaxants for acute


strengthen

the

abdominal

and

and chronic1 pain have some benefit, and are


musculature to manage low back pain.

gluteus
12

more effective in relieving pain and spasms


when used in combination with NSAIDs. 8

Scheermesser M, in his study found that

Chronic use of these medications may result into

physical therapy treatment can improve the

various adverse effects. Certain medicines are

patient ability to function .The effectiveness of

unsafe during pregnancy and may cause side

physical therapy can reduce the disability. The

effects including drowsiness, or may lead to liver

studies also showed that the patient totally

13

14

Pakistan Journal of Medicine and Dentistry 2013, Vol. 1 (01): 21-33

23

Effectiveness of William's flexion exercises in management of low back pain


dependent on medication may lead mild to

were included in the study.

moderate disability which can effect on daily

Sample size was calculated by WHO sample

activity. So role of physical therapy is also

size estimation calculator. For sample size

important in low back pain. Manual therapy is

calculation prevalence of LBP was taken as

also more effective in low back pain. The aim of

80%, at 95% confidence level and keeping 0.05

physical therapy treatment is to improve pain

margin of error. The minimum number of

15

free activity of daily lining

participants required for inclusion in the sample


was calculated as 246 but 250 patients were

This

study

will

help

in

identifying

the

effectiveness of Williams flexion exercises. As

included in the study.


Non-probability convenient sampling technique

this maneuver is among available management


was used to enroll participants in the study.
plans for LBP so the results of this study will
Patients aged between 18 to 90 years having
help all health care providers to modify their
LBM for at least three to four months but less
practices. Most of the time doctors prescribed
than 9 months were included in the study. Only
medications for LBP management but with the
those patients of LBP were be the part of study
help of this research their knowledge regarding
where LBP was associated with nerve root
exercise based management of LBP will be
impingement at inter vertebral foramen, spinals
improved. So the aim of this study is to assess
tenosis and postural changes and they were
the effectiveness of William flexion exercise in
declared medically fit by their doctors to
management of patients with low back pain.
undertake the exercise. Patients with any

METHODOLOGY

potentially serious pathology, who have spinal


tumor, prior surgery back pain, and back pain

A cross sectional study, spanning over a year


start after road traffic accident, females with
from February 2011 to January 2012, was
conducted among patients of LBP. All those

pregnancy and anyone who would have been


unable to attend or participate in the exercise

patients taking physical therapy treatment from


program were excluded from the study.
different private and public hospitals of Karachi

Pakistan Journal of Medicine and Dentistry 2013, Vol. 1 (01): 21-33

24

Muhammad Usman Khalid, Mahvish Rafiq and Nosheen Zehra


A brief history of patients was taken via

taken before including these patients in the

interview and physically examination was done

study.

to exclude possible serious spinal pathology

Data was entered and analyzed by using SPSS

and collect baseline data by means of health

version

measures. Data was collected on structured

calculated for qualitative variables while mean

questionnaire enclosing questions targeting to

and standard deviation for quantitative variables.

assess the type, intensity, duration and pattern

Chi square test was used to find association for

of pain. There were questions on relieving

qualitative variables and p vale <0.05 was

factors, occurrence of pain and the worse time

considered as significant.

17

. Frequencies and percentages were

of pain. As this study was aimed to assess the

RESULTS
effectiveness of William's Flexion Exercises so
there were questions on before and after

Total n= 250 patients were included in the study

results of exercise. We use visual analogue

with mean age of 43 + 13 years. Out of them 90

pain scale to measure the intensity of pain

(36%) were male and 160 (64%) were females.

before and after the treatment, that is a simple

From the sample 124 (49.6%) patients were

assessment tool consisting of a 10 cm line with

from private clinics, 85 (34%) were from private

0 on one end, representing no pain, and 10 on

tertiary care hospitals and 41 (16.4%) were from

the other, representing the worst pain ever

government hospitals.

16

Location and type of pain was

These patients were inquired about the

marked using the provided key as (0000 = Pins

characteristics of pain and it was found that

and needles, /////// = Stabbing, XXXX =

80(32%) had pins and needles type pain,

Burning, ZZZZ = Deep Ache). In addition, we

79(31.6%) had deep ache, 78 (31.2%) had

also evaluate patients spine flexion and

burning pain, and 13 (5.2%) experienced

extension before and after the treatment and

stabbing pain.

also analyze pain intensity after William flexion

severe pain, 107 (42.8%) had moderate pain

exercise. Purpose of the study was explained

and 47 (18.8%) had mild pain. Duration of pain

to participants and informed consent was

was found from 3-4months in 102(40.8%), 4-

experienced.

Pakistan Journal of Medicine and Dentistry 2013, Vol. 1 (01): 21-33

Among them 96 (38.4%) had

25

Effectiveness of William's flexion exercises in management of low back pain


6months in 92(36.8%) and 6-9months in 56

Most of the patient 189 (75.6%) used lying

(22.4%) patients. Those patients who had

position to relief their pain while 26 (10.4%)

localized back pain were 138 (55.2%), those

preferred standing, 20 (8%) sitting and 15 (6%)

whose pain radiate to leg were 96 (38.4%) and

used different posture to relief their pain.

others were 16(6.4%). Constant pain was found


Patients took different patterns of William
in 114 (45.6%) patients, intermittent pain in 90
Flexion Exercises as partial sit up by 30(12%)
(36%) and occasional pain in 35 (14%) patients.
patients, pelvic tilts by 70(28%), knee to chest
In 50 (20%) patients pain was worse at morning,
by

223(89.2%),

hamstring

stretch

by

in 46 (18.4%) patients at night, in 32 (12.8%)


153(61.2%),

hip flexor muscle

stretch

by

patients in evening, in 16(6.4%) patients in


118(47.2%), and squatting by 17(6.8%). (Table
afternoon and in 106 (42.4%) patients pain was
1)
not associated with any particular time of day.
Table 1: William flexion exercise component
Percentage

Frequency

(%)

(n= 250)

Partial sit up

12

30

Pelvic tilt

28

70

Knee to chest

89.2

223

Hamstring muscle stretch

61.2

153

Hip flexor muscle stretch

47.2

118

Squat

6.8

17

These patients in sample took various sessions

pain, 115 (46%) had mild pain and 1 (0.4%) had

of William flexion exercise as 5 sessions were

moderate pain after completion of treatment. Of

taken by 30(12%) patients, 6 to 10 sessions by

30 (12%) patient who had 5 sessions, among

134 (53.6%) patients and more than 10 sessions

them 6 (2.4%) had no pain, 22 (8.8%) had mild

were taken by 86 (34.4%) patients. It was found

pain and 2 (0.8%) had moderate pain. While 86

that those 134 (53. %) patients who took 6 to 10

(34.4%) patients who took more than 10

sessions of physiotherapy, 18 (7.2%) had no

sessions among them 16 (6.4%) had no pain, 63

Pakistan Journal of Medicine and Dentistry 2013, Vol. 1 (01): 21-33

26

Muhammad Usman Khalid, Mahvish Rafiq and Nosheen Zehra


(25.2%) had mild pain and 7 (2.8%) had

exercise and post pain intensity P<0.00 (Table

moderate

2).

pain.

There

was

significant

association between sessions of William Flexion

Table 2: Association of William Flexion Exercise and Post Pain Intensity


Number of William Flexion
Exercise Sessions

Intensity of Pain after Exercise


No Pain

Mild Pain

Moderate
Pain

Total

n (%)

n (%)

n (%)

n (%)

6 (2.4)

22 (8.8)

2 (0.8)

30 (12)

6 to 10

18 (7.2)

115 (46)

1 (0.4)

134(53.6)

More than 10

16 (6.4)

63 (25.2)

7 (2.8)

86 (34.4)

P- Value

0.037

To assess the effectiveness of Williams flexion

(1.6%) after exercise. In 107 (42.8%) patients

exercise for LBP, pain intensity was measured

pain was moderate before exercise which was

before and after the sessions of exercise. Before

reduced to mild pain in 94 (37.6%) patients and

exercise 96 (38.4%) patients had severe pain

in 47 (18.8%) patients pain was mild before

which was reduced to no pain in 20 (8%), mild

exercise that was reduced to no pain in 11

pain in 72 (28.8%) and moderate pain in 4

(4.4%) patients. (p > 0.000) (Table 3)

Table 3: Pain Intensity before and after William Flexion Exercise


Pain Before Exercise

Pain After Exercise

Mild Pain
Moderate Pain
Sever Pain

No Pain
n (%)
11 (4.4)
9 (3.6)
20 (8)

Mild Pain
n (%)
34 (13.6)
94 (37.6)
72 (28.8)

Moderate Pain
n (%)
2 (0.8)
4 (1.6)
4 (1.6)

Total
n (%)
47 (18.8)
107(42.8)
96 (38.4)

Total

40 (16)

200 (80)

10 (4)

250 (100)

of

which

0.079

At the start of physiotherapy of patients, flexion

(52.8%)

and extension of spine was measured to

completely in 45(18) and slightly in 87 (34.8%)

observe the effect of exercise after treatment.

patients. Moderate restriction was found in 93

Initially mild restrictions were seen in 132

(37.2%) that was completely improved in 24

Pakistan Journal of Medicine and Dentistry 2013, Vol. 1 (01): 21-33

patients

P- Value

was

improved

27

Effectiveness of William's flexion exercises in management of low back pain


(9.6%) patients and similarly sever restriction

completely improved in 9 (3.6%) patients. (P-

was found in 25 (10%) patients that was

value=

0.360)

(Fig

2)

Spine Flexion and Extension after Exercise %

Figure 1: Improvement in Spine Flexion and Extention after William's Flexion


Exercise

40
34.8

35
30

27.6

25
20

18

Completely Improved

15

Slightly Improved
9.6

10

6.4
3.6

5
0

Severe
Moderate
Mild
Spine Flexion and Extension Restriction

From the sample of 250, only 70 (28%) patients

in their life experienced low back pain.17 Most of

returned with complain of pain reoccurrence.

the time LBP is of acute type and resolve

Patients

the

immediately or within few days but sometimes it

improvement in their life quality, and 121

is of recurrent type and in some individuals it

(48.4%)

complete

becomes chronic.18 LBP is an important cause

improvement while 129(51.6%) said there was

of activity limitation and according to Ponte DJ

partial improvement.

for every 100 subjects aged 25 to 44, an

were

also

replied

that

inquired

there

about

was

average of 28.6 works day are lost per year due

DISCUSSION
to low back pain.

19

Among various available

Low back pain is such a common problem that

options for management of LBP, Williams

every adult once in a life time affected by it.

flexion exercise may helps in improving LBP as

Nachemson A reported that about 80% people

reported in literature.

Pakistan Journal of Medicine and Dentistry 2013, Vol. 1 (01): 21-33

20,21

28

Muhammad Usman Khalid, Mahvish Rafiq and Nosheen Zehra


Therefore this study was focused in assessing

muscles which maintain the all structure alien

the effectiveness of Williams flexion exercise in

and prevent the over loading of the posterior

management of patients with low back pain.

element of the lumbar spine.

Recent management guidelines for chronic LBP

Results of our study showed that Williams

recommended exercise for returning to physical


flexion exercises had beneficial effect in chronic
22

activity.

Significant improvement in patients of


LBP which was measured by visual analogs

LBP was reported in literatures who have


scale (VAS) and spinal restriction observed
received Williams flexion exercises.

21

Results of
before and after the treatment. Pain intensity

our study also supported that Williams flexion


when measured before therapy, reflected that
exercise can lead to improvement in low back
38% patients had severe, 43% had moderate
pain.
and 19% had mild pain. Improvement in pain
Exercise intervention with patient education, are

after therapy was found in most of the case as of

first in the conservative approach to treat

those with severe pain, 8% had no pain and

musculoskeletal conditions of the lumbar spine.

29% had mild pain. Similarly patients with

By the exercise, body tissues adapt to the

moderate

stresses and demands of everyday living. In

improvement as shown in table 3. In our study,

most cases the back pain are mechanical in

patients were given number of Williams Flexion

nature so, a functional approach will produce the

exercise sessions and significant improvement

long-term benefit.

(p-0.03) in pain intensity was found in those who

According to the Williams these exercises

and

mild

pain

also

showed

took more than 5 sessions. Various studies also


reported improvement in LBP after Williams

reduce the pressure on the posterior element of


flexion exercise.

20, 21,24

the lumbar spine. These exercises restore


motion and strength of lower back is helpful in

Different patterns of Williams flexion exercises

relieving pain and preventing reoccurrence of

were performed by patients with LBP as partial

low back pain.


also

20, 23

strengthen

Williams flexion exercises

the

back

and

abdominal

sit up, pelvic tilt, knee to chest, hamstring


stretch, hip flexor stretch and squat. Participants

Pakistan Journal of Medicine and Dentistry 2013, Vol. 1 (01): 21-33

29

Effectiveness of William's flexion exercises in management of low back pain


reported that pelvic tilt, knee to chest and

management of LBP as this exercise helped

hamstring stretching gave them more relaxation

patients effectively and not only reduce LBP

and reduction in pain and squatting was more

but also improved daily activities. It is,

difficult for more individuals.

therefore recommended to properly investigate


and diagnosed patients with LBP and for those

Along with exercise patient education is also


patients who require physiotherapy may be
very important. Posture is a vital component for
treated with Williams flexion exercise. It is also
the management of low back pain during the
working environment and daily living.25 In

suggested that preventive strategies should be


introduced for managing LBP that will in return

posture education we educated the patients


improve the daily pain free activities of
regarding activity of daily living and postural
individuals and reduce economic burden of
improvement in occupation. After the complete
society.
session of treatment we gave a home exercise

CONCLUSION

program with demonstration.

Results of our study highlighted that Williams


As this study was focused on effectiveness of
Williams flexion exercise and it was performed
on patients with LBP. Although results of this
study showed improvement in pain but there
was no comparison group so findings may not
prove cause effect relationship. On the other
hand, this study will open future avenues for

flexion exercise was beneficial for most of the


participants in the study. This exercise with more
than

five

sessions

showed

significant

improvement in pain intensity. Along with


improvement in pain intensity there was also
improvement in spine flexion ad extension after
this exercise.

further research to do comparative analysis

REFERENCES

between Williams flexion exercise and other


management therapies.

The results of this study will also help those

Approach to the diagnosis and evaluation of low

patients

who

are

taking

. Wheeler G, Wipf E, Staiger O, Deyo R.

medication

for

Pakistan Journal of Medicine and Dentistry 2013, Vol. 1 (01): 21-33

30

Muhammad Usman Khalid, Mahvish Rafiq and Nosheen Zehra


back pain in adults.[internet][cited 2012 April 5].

7.

Available from: URL:

Rosenquist. For the American Pain Society Low

Chou, Roger, Loeser, John,Owens, Dougla,

Back

Pain

Guideline

Panel

Interventional

http://www.uptodate.com/contents/
Therapies,
2.

Surgery,

and

Interdisciplinary

Youdas JW, Hollman JH, Krause DA. The

Rehabilitation for Low Back Pain: An Evidence-

effects of gender, age, and body mass index on

Based Clinical Practice Guideline from the

standing lumbar curvature in persons without

American Pain Society 2009: 34; 1066-1077

current low back pain. Physiother Theory Pract

8.

2006; 22: 229-37.


3.

Bogduk M. Management of chronic low back

pain. Med J Australia 2003; 180: 7983


4.

Malanga GA, Dunn KR. Low back pain

management:

approaches

to

treatment.

Musculoskel Med 2010:27; 305-15.


9.

Adams, May S, Freeman BJ, Morrison HP,

Dolan P. Effects of backward bending on lumbar


May S. Handbook of Pain and Palliative Care.
intervertebral

discs.

Relevance to physical

Biobehavioral Approaches for the Life Course.


therapy treatments for low back pain. Spine J
New York: Springer; 2012:231-45
2000; 25: 431-8
10

Carita K, Katri L, Jouko SJ, Tuominen, Risto.

. Stphane P, Marie DJ, Anne-Marie C,

Perceived relative importance of pain related

Tousignant, Michel. Guidelines on Low Back

function among patient with low back pain. J

Pain Disability: Inter professional Comparison of

5.

Rehab Med 2012; 44: 158-62


6

. Tuchinsky D, Back pain: its all in your neck,

Use

between

General

Practitioners.

Occupational Therapists, and Physiotherapists


2012; 37: 12529

pine lake road suite 100 USA. Writers Club


11.

Press 2000:59-77.

Koumantakis G, Watson P, Oldham J Trunk

Muscle Stabilization Training Plus General


Exercise

Versus

General

Exercise

Only:

Randomized Controlled Trial of Patients With

Pakistan Journal of Medicine and Dentistry 2013, Vol. 1 (01): 21-33

31

Effectiveness of William's flexion exercises in management of low back pain


Recurrent Low Back Pain Phys Ther 2005; 85:
209-25

16

.The Visual Analogue Pain Scale. [internet]

[cited 2013 Feb 23]. Available from: URL:

12

. Matsudaira K, Hara N, Arisaka M, Isomura T.

Comparison of Physicians Advice for Nonhttp://www.fibroaction.org/Images/content/Pain_


specific Acute Low Back Pain in Japanese
Assessment_VAS_lrg.png
Workers: Advice to Rest Versus Advice to Stay

17.

Nachemson A: The lumbar spine: an

Active. Industrial Health 2011; 49: 203-8


orthopaedic challenge. Spine 1976; 159:71
13.

Scheermesser M , Bachmann S, Schmann


18. Dunn KM, Croft PR. Epidemiology and

A, Oesch P, Kool.J. A qualitative study on the


natural history of low back pain. Eur Med 2004;
role

of

cultural

background

in

patients'
40:913.

perspectives

on

rehabilitation.

BMC

19.

Ponte DJ, Jensen GJ, Kent BE. A Preliminary

Musculoskelet Disord 2012: 13; 5


Report on the Use of the McKenzie Protocol
14.

Kuczynski J, Schwieterman B, Columber K,


versus Williams Protocol in the Treatment of

Knupp D, Shaub L, Cook

C. Effectiveness
Low Back Pain. JOSPT 1984; 6: 130-9

of physical therapist

administered

spinal

20.

Williams P. Examination and conservative

manipulation for the treatment of low back pain:


treatment for disc lesions of the lower spine. Clin
a systematic review of the literature. Int J Sports
Orthop1955; 528: 40
Phys Ther 2012; 7: 647-62.
15.

21.

Mannion FA,Caporaso F,Pulkovski N and

Williams P. Low Back and Neck Pain: Causes

and Conservative Treatment. 3rd ed. Springfield:

Sprott H. Goal a ttainment scaling as a measure

Charles C Thomas, 1974

of treatment success after physiotherapy for

22.

chronic

Management

low

back

unknown].[

updated

February

2,

pain
April

2010]

[internet].[place
27,

2010][cited

Available

from:

Esther JO, Therapeutic Exercises in the


of

Non-Specific

Low

Back

Pain.[online] [cited 2013 Feb 13]. Available from:


URL: www.intechopen.com

http://rheumatology.oxfordjournals.org

Pakistan Journal of Medicine and Dentistry 2013, Vol. 1 (01): 21-33

32

Muhammad Usman Khalid, Mahvish Rafiq and Nosheen Zehra


23.

Low back pain. American academy of

orthopedic

surgeon

[Online]

updated

May

2009[cited 2013 Feb 22]. Available from: URL:


http://orthoinfo.aaos.org/topic.cfm?topic=A00311
24.

Ghiasi F,

Mehraeen M. The effect of

William's exercise on non-specific and chronic


referral low back pain. SID [online] [cited 2013
Feb

12].

Available

from:

URL:

www.sid.ir/en/ViewPaper.asp?ID=140699&varSt
r
25

. Pillastrini, Mugnai R , Bertozzi L, Costi S,

Curti S, Guccione A, etal. Effectiveness of an


ergonomic intervention on work-related posture
and low back pain in video display terminal
operator. Applied Ergonomics 2010;41: 436-43

Pakistan Journal of Medicine and Dentistry 2013, Vol. 1 (01): 21-33

33

You might also like