Professional Documents
Culture Documents
613-623
Journal of Civil Engineering and Architecture, ISSN 1934-7359, USA
DAVID
PUBLISHING
1. Introduction
Expansive soil is a disaster for the light
construction
industry
in
developing
and
underdeveloped countries. The problem is diagnosed
since more than five decades and yet the treatment is
not well established. Understanding the mechanism of
heave and the factors affecting the swelling behaviour
was studied extensively. The swelling of soils, in
general, is due to the presence of expanding clay
minerals, hydration of cations on clay surfaces, and
release
of
intrinsic
stresses
caused
by
overconsolidation or consolidation of soils [1]. Works
covering nano to microfabric features of clay to well
documented engineering properties and behaviour is
now present in the literature. How to utilize this
wealth of information in practice is the todays
challenge for practicing geotechnical engineers. It is
very essential to geotechnical engineer to know what
investigations shall be performed and what parameters
need to be determined. The solutions to be applied for
Corresponding author: Muawia A. Dafalla, assistant
professor, geotechnical consultant, research field: geotechnical
engineering. E-mail: mdafalla@gmail.com.
614
Swelling Characteristics of Saudi Tayma Shale and Consequential Impact on Light Structures
32
39o
42o
45o
28o
48o
54o
57o
60o
200
400 km
24o
20o
16o
N
Regions with expensive formations
Fig. 1 Expansive soils in Saudi Arabia.
Swelling Characteristics of Saudi Tayma Shale and Consequential Impact on Light Structures
615
616
Swelling Characteristics of Saudi Tayma Shale and Consequential Impact on Light Structures
3. Experimental Work
Two clay samples were collected from two sources
in Tayma town in Saudi Arabia. These are referred to
as trench site and a hospital site both located at
Rawoda district. A range of index and classification
tests were carried out and compared to works carried
out by others. Table 2 summaries the test results.
Standard proctor test was carried out in accordance
with ASTM D698 for a sample from the trench site.
Fig. 2 presents the grain size distribution including
Hydrometer for Tayma shale. The maximum dry
density obtained was 18.3 kN/m3 at an optimum
moisture content of 14.6% (Fig. 3).
The free swell index of Tayma Hospital site and
Trench site were found to be 18.518% and 42.22%,
respectively.Table 3 presents the free swell data.
Soil properties
LL (liquid limit) (%)
PL (plastic limit) (%)
PI (plasticity index) (%)
SL (shrinkage limit) (%)
Gs (specific gravity)
Dry unit weight (kN/m3)
Natural moisture content (%)
Gravel (%)
Sand (%)
Silt (%)
Clay (%)
% passing sieve # 200
USCS (soil classification)
Trench sample
33.8
25.4
8.4
24.91
2.71
23.2
1.6
0.4
2.4
64.2
33
97.20
ML
Hospital sample
35
26.7
8.3
20.63
2.77
23.2
1.6
0.3
4.14
70.56
25
95.56
ML
Swelling Characteristics of Saudi Tayma Shale and Consequential Impact on Light Structures
617
100
90
80
70
60
50
40
30
20
10
0
0.001
0.01
0.1
10
Sample location
Kerosene
Tube reference Volume (cm3)
5
13.5
11
11.25
Hospital site
Trench site
Water
Tube reference Volume (cm3)
1
16
3
16
Sw
welling Chara
acteristics of Saudi Tayma
a Shale and Consequentia
C
al Impact on L
Light Structures
Intensity
618
Two thetta
Fig. 4
Swell percent
The swell
s
percent variation
v
with initial
i
moldingg moisture conttent.
Swelling Characteristics of Saudi Tayma Shale and Consequential Impact on Light Structures
619
y = -0.4661x + 16.949
Fig. 6
y = -23.693x 405.95
3 3
Initial dry density (kN/m
) )
(kN/m
Fig. 7
620
Swelling Characteristics of Saudi Tayma Shale and Consequential Impact on Light Structures
Rate of swell
Tayma claynatural density 22.9 kN/m3 at w.c 1.6%
Time (min)
Fig. 8
160
140
120
Komornik &
David
100
Tayma Soil
80
60
Nayak &
Christensen
40
20
0
16
18
20
22
24
3
Dry density
of Soil
Dry density
of (kN/cubic
soil (kN/m )meter)
Fig. 9
Comparing Tayma shale measurements to predictions by Komornik, David, Nayak and Christensen [9, 10].
Swelling Characteristics of Saudi Tayma Shale and Consequential Impact on Light Structures
e - log p curve
0.60
0.56
0.52
0.48
0.44
0.40
0.36
0.32
0.28
0.24
0.20
0.16
0.12
0.08
0.04
1.0
1.0
10.0
10.0
100.0
100.0
1,000.0
1000.0
2
Pressure (kN/m )
PRESSURE (kN/m 2)
Fig. 10
621
10,000.0
10000.0
622
Table 4
Swelling Characteristics of Saudi Tayma Shale and Consequential Impact on Light Structures
Level of damage classification in Tayma.
Type of construction
Two storey villas (main built area)
One storey villas (main built area)
Boundary walls
Pavements
Slab on grade
Asphalt pavement
Form of damage
Nil
Variable cracks, hair (0.1 mm) to medium (2 mm), diagonal
Medium wide (2 mm) to wide (> 10 mm) cracks , diagonal
Upheaval and distortion, cracks variable
Upheaval and distortion, cracks variable sizes
Upheaval and distortion, cracks variable sizes
Level of damage
No damage
Medium
Severe
Medium
Medium
Low to medium
5. Conclusions
The classification approaches based on routine
index properties is made for general guidence only
and shall not be used for quantifying the risk.
Prediction methods based on index properties are of
local validity. Tayma shale was found to behave
differently when compared to two swelling pressure
prediction equations. Clay soils classified within
groups of low degree of expansion can introduce
troubles to light structures. Mineralogy study using
x-ray diffraction on Tayma shale confirmed the
presence of smectite group clay minerals. Direct
measurement of undisturbed samples simulating the
field conditions is the most appropriate method to deal
with expansive soil. Confinement, site environment
and performance history of structures within the area
shall be taken into account.
The influence of moisture content on the swelling
pressure is not significant. Increase in the dry density
is associated with the increase in the swelling pressure.
Tayma shale is expected to generate an upheaval force
on wetting equal to 50 kN/m3. It is suggested to
suppress the swelling pressure with superstructure
concentrated loads or placing the foundation at a deep
level so that overburden pressure can counter balance
the swelling pressure. Preventing water from seeping
under pavements, walkways or near foundations is
Swelling Characteristics of Saudi Tayma Shale and Consequential Impact on Light Structures
Acknowledgments
The authors wish to acknowledge BRCES
(Bugshan Research Chair in Expansive Soils), King
Saud University, for supporting this study and to
Engineer Mohammed Al Sharary of King Saud
University for performing most of the laboratory
testing during his study under the supervision of the
authors.
[5]
[6]
[7]
[8]
References
[9]
[1]
[10]
[2]
[3]
[4]
[11]
[12]
[13]
623