Professional Documents
Culture Documents
According to the AAA, the third most common cause of roadside breakdowns in the USA is
engine trouble, with the bulk of engine related issues involving the cooling system. While
there are many possible causes of cooling system failures and malfunctions, many cooling
system problems can be avoided or prevented with nothing more than regular maintenance
and servicing.
More good news is that all liquid-based cooling systems are essentially the same- they work on
the same principles, and what applies to one, largely applies to all others- the only exception
being that some radiator cooling fans are belt-driven, while others are electrically operated. In
this article then, we will take a closer look at the major components of water-based cooling
systems, how they work, and what happens when they fail. There are however, no components
that are more important than others, so let us begin at the beginning...
As with any automotive additive, the rust inhibitors in anti-freeze degrade during contact with
heat and oxygen, and after about twelve months or so, they cease to work. For this reason, it is
vitally important to replace the coolant in any engine at least once year.
The engine may not overheat because the rust inhibitors have stopped working, but the engine
WILL overheat if the engine corrodes from the inside, and coolant is lost through a leak in any
number of possible locations, including seeping past the cylinder head gasket. However, an
abnormally hot engine causes excessive pressure that can rupture hoses and/or spilt the
radiator. When this happens, the sudden pressure loss causes the coolant to boil instantly, which
in turn, expels all the coolant from the system in an explosive manner.
One more function of anti-freeze is to lower the freezing point of water- hence the term, antifreeze. When engine coolant freezes, the expansion of the liquid mass can fracture an engine
block; however, the ability of glycol and other additives to prevent freezing also degrade after
about a year, and when they do, you run the very real risk of destroying your engine in sub-zero
temperatures.
The last thing to keep in mind regarding engine coolant is that excessive amounts of glycol can
paradoxically lower the boiling point of water, which is why car manufacturers specify a certain
concentration of anti-freeze to be used in their vehicles. Twice the amount does NOT work twice
as well, which means that you could suffer severe engine overheating even in the depths of
winter.
heat to be dissipated by the radiator. On the other hand, if it circulates the coolant too quickly,
the coolant cannot absorb heat fast enough, and the engine will overheat, even though
everything else in the system is in perfect working order.
The drive pulley diameter on any water pump is what determines the rate of circulation of the
coolant, and this pulley must therefore never be replaced with a pulley of a different diameter.
or damaging this critical component can cause the radiator to fan to become completely
ineffective, so NEVER make, or allow modifications to the shroud to be made.
Some radiator fans are still belt-driven, but to decrease noise and limit engine power losses,
these fans are connected to a viscous clutch that uses oil to transfer power from the hub to the
fan itself. Over time, this oil can leak out, or evaporate, which causes the fan to rotate too slowly
to generate the air flow required to effectively cool down the coolant passing through the
radiator. There is no way to fix a viscous fan, and replacement is the only reliable, long-term
solution.
Electric radiator fans on the other hand, depend on a thermal switch to start working. This
switch is sometimes located on the engine, but it is more commonly located in the bottom tank
of the radiator. When the coolant reaches a pre-determined temperature, the switch closes a
circuit, and the fan starts to rotate, thus cooling down the coolant passing through the radiator.
Similarly, when the coolant reaches a predetermined, lower temperature, the switch breaks the
circuit, and the fan stops.
In an ideal world, this thermal switch should last forever, but they are in fact the most common
components to fail in modern cooling systems. Moreover, cooling fan thermal switches almost
always fail without any advance warning, and since a failure does not trigger a dedicated
warning light, the first visible sign of trouble is when the CHECK ENGINE light comes on because
the engine has overheated since
the fan no longer works.
More bad news is that the fan
switch is not a service item that
gets replaced every so often,
which means that as long as it is
out of sight, it is out of mind as
well. Therefore, it is always a
good idea to replace the fan
switch every two years or so. This
may not guarantee that the
replacement will not fail, but
there is a smaller chance of the replacement failing than there is of your current, several-yearsold fan switch failing any time from now.
Thermostats explained
The function of the thermostat is to control, or more precisely, regulate the rate at which the
coolant is allowed to pass through the radiator to prevent the coolant either from cooling down
too much (or too rapidly), or not to absorb enough heat from the engine.
4
All thermostats do this by means of a bi-metal switch, or valve, that reacts to the coolant
temperature. However, thermostats are designed to work within a narrow temperature range,
which means that if the moving parts of a thermostat are stuck, and cannot open or close fully,
the rate of circulation of the coolant is no longer regulated, and therefore, its temperature
cannot be controlled.
Nonetheless, a thermostat that is stuck in a partly open position is also stuck in a partly closed
position, and it can happen that an engine may not overheat as a result, because the coolant is
still allowed to circulate, albeit at a reduced rate. The real trouble however, is that thermostats
most commonly remain stuck in either the fully closed, or fully open position.
Either of these conditions can result in engine overheating, since if the thermostat is closed, the
coolant cannot circulate at all. If it is stuck in the open position, the coolant may circulate too
quickly, with not residual time in the radiator to cool down. In such a case, because the coolant
cannot shed its heat, an engine
could overheat even though the
coolant is circulating freely.
As
with
fan
switches,
thermostats are also not service
items,
and
although
a
thermostat can, and often does,
last for the life of a car, it can
also fail at any moment. In fact,
thermostat failures account for
about 50% of all cooling system
failures, and even if you replace
your thermostat every year,
there is no guarantee that the
replacement wont fail.
The only possible protection against thermostat failures is to maintain the quality of the coolant,
since it keeps the moving parts lubricated but beyond that, there is nothing you can do to
prevent a thermostat failure.