Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Roberval Laboratory, Universit de Technologie de Compigne (UTC), BP 20529, 60205 Compigne Cedex, France
BOA Flexible Solutions, 14 rue de la Goutte dOr F-02130 Fre-en-Tardenois, France
a r t i c l e
i n f o
Article history:
Received 14 July 2010
Accepted 30 November 2010
Available online 8 December 2010
Keywords:
Fatigue
Residual stress
Braid
a b s t r a c t
This work presents the virtual simulation of the hoses hydroforming; the main objective is to predict
when and where cracks can appear during a cyclic loading.
A methodology has been proposed to investigate the effects of plastic strain and residual stress after
hydroforming on cyclic life fatigue.
First, an axisymmetric simulation of the hydroforming of exible metal hoses was accomplished using
the nite element method, then a cyclic loading is applied, nally the life cycle is estimated using a model
based on Chaboches model.
The results are compared with experimental data, a good agreement is found if we take in account the
residual stress and the hardening due to hydroforming.
A mechanical behavior model has been developed to study the braid which is the second element of the
braided corrugated hoses; they are added to corrugated hoses in order to improve its radial and axial
stiffness.
2010 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
1. Introduction
Flexible corrugated hoses of stainless steel (Fig. 1) are mechanical components which are used in many applications, for example
they are used to minimize the effect of vibrations on piping and car
engines, doing well for this purpose, these components can suffer
dynamic loads from gas and liquid pulsation and fail.
It is well-known that the metallic material is subjected to large
irreversible deformation in hoses hydroforming, this leads to high
strain and high stress localization areas, these two parameters
have great impact on cyclic life fatigue of the hydroformed hoses
[112].
Signicant advances have been made in recent years for obtaining more accurate and reliable determinations of residual stress
distributions. These include both experimental and numerical
methods [1316].
The failures of the corrugated hoses frequently happen in the
form of small holes or cracks, therefore the conditions of leak before break is generally most frequent in prediction of damage; this
enables the reduction of the failure consequences in a working
environment [17]. Wang et al. [18] studied the effect of stamping
on fatigue life FEM prediction using plastic strain and thickness
variation Zapatero et al. [19] studied the inuence of maximum
load, the crack length and stress ration on the fatigue crack closure
Corresponding author at: Roberval Laboratory, Universit de Technologie de
Compigne (UTC), BP 20529, 60205 Compigne Cedex, France. Fax: +333 44 23 46
89.
E-mail address: hakim.hachemi@utc.fr (H. Hachemi).
0261-3069/$ - see front matter 2010 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.matdes.2010.11.075
1958
preforming step is made without tools displacements then a second forming, using the same pressure as in the preforming, with
tools displacement is performed, nally the pressure is canceled
and the tools are removed.
In order to validate our simulation, the geometrical dimensions
after hydroforming are compared to the measured one; as we can
see in the Table 2, the Geometrical dimensions carried out from the
simulations are very close to the measured dimensions; in fact the
maximum error does not exceed 1.2%.
Table 1
Mechanical properties of AISI 316L.
Young modulus
Yield stress
Tensile strength
Poisson coefcient
Density
193000 Mpa
250 Mpa
1170 Mpa
0.3
7800 kg/m3
ff AII AII
r
1 3 dev
v
v
dev
rijmax rde
rde
AII
ijmin
ijmax rijmin
2 2
r
i
1h
a1 a2 2 a2 a3 2 a3 a1 2
dev
The damage starts when ff becomes positive, rdev
ijmax ; rijmin are
respectively the maximum and minimum deviatoric tensors of
stresses in a cyclic loading, the amplitudes of the principal stresses
are dened as:
ai Dri =2
H
AII rl0 1 3br
An eight-node axisymmetric element with nine point of integration is used to simulate the hydroforming process, this element
is the most powerful element in axisymmetric calculus; it gives
more accurate results for less rened mesh both for geometric
non-linearity and plasticity [24]. The focus of this study is to include the hydroforming effects of plastic strains and residual stresses in the subsequent fatigue FEM model. Fig. 3 shows the effective
plastic strain and the Von Mises residual stress. The axisymmetric
element is used in the simulation of the hydroforming process for
the consideration of time saving.
The hydroformed hose is made by multiple steps (see Fig. 4),
rst the straight tube is xed by tools called anges, after that a
AII
M1 D
B
dN
H
M M 0 1 3br
AII AII
a1a
ru reqmax
r!
3 dev
reqmax max
r : r dev
2
1
1
reqMax Max p r1 r2 2 r2 r3 2 r3 r1 2 2
2
5
6
7
8
9
AII
M
b 11 a
10
As in one dimension [25,26], we can introduce the inuence of initial hardening on the coefcients: ru ; AII ; M.
1959
Table 2
Geometrical dimensions for PARNOR 1 in. and PARNOR 6 in.
Inner diameter
Thickness
Outer diameter
Pitch
Measure
Simulation
Measure
Simulation
25
0.20/0.24
36
7.1
24.95
0.22/0.25
36.01
7.0
150
0.45/0.485
174
15.70
149.95
0.47/0.5
173.8
15.60
AII AII q
ru q reqMax
H
AII r0 1 k1 :Zc1 3br
arM ; q; r 1 a
ru q ru0 1 k2 zc
Mq M 0 1 k3 Zc
p
Zc c
11
12
13
14
15
k1, k2, k3 are coefcients which are obtained from experiments, the
values of ru0, rl0 were xed from the experimental Wohler curves
1960
Table 3
Materiel coefcients.
Parameter
rl0
r0
k1
k2
k3
M0
Value
1170 Mpa
222 Mpa
0.4
2.2
1.6
1650 Mpa
0.9
0.25
[25], 316L Steel has the coefcients values shown in Table 3. For the
tests with an initial hardening, c is equal to the initial effective plastic strain.
First we assess the life cycle fatigue at each integration point of
each element of the modelized corrugated hose. The life cycle of
the tube is the minimum of the fatigue lives for each integration
point. The stress used in life cycle estimation is the algebraic
sum of the residual stress and the stress due to cyclic loading.
the organigram of this method is shown in Fig. 6.
4. Experiment results
In order to validate the model, we have performed some experiments, see Fig. 7.
Each hose used in these tests have 10 waves, for every
displacement Xf, a sample of six hoses is used to get the mean life
time.
The numbers of cycles indicated correspond to the appearance
of a crack which we can see by eyes in the corrugated tube.
1961
The difference between the estimation results and the experimental results is due to several parameters, rst The assumed
assumptions in the simulation, for more correct results we must
take into account all the manufacturing processes of the tube in
simulation (rolling, welding. . .etc.), these processes give residual
stresses and strains which could be added to the hydroforming
strains and residual stresses, also the results obtained by experiment are for large cracks whereas those obtained by estimation
are for micro cracks, secondly we can attribute the differences between the experiment and computation results to the damage
model used in calculations; indeed it is difcult to identify the constants of the model of damage with sufcient precision. Finally a
rened mesh is required to get more precise stresses and strains
which are very important in the estimation of cylic life fatigue.
As shown in Fig. 10, the calculated fragile area corresponds well
to the experiments
it is located in the hollow of the wave, close to the blank, on the
external surface of corrugated hose for the PARNOR 1 in.
it is located in the hollow of the wave, on the interior surface of
the corrugated hose for the PARNOR 6 in.
6. Braid modeling
It is well seen that the computation results can be used to predict the life fatigue estimation of tubes in a given loading condition; in fact the estimated values are lower than those carried
out by experiment.
The second part of our work is to model the braid which is the
second most important part of the corrugated braided hoses. This
part is used to improve the radial and axial stiffness of the tube.
Extensive investigation of textiles has been conducted these the
last two decades, Most of these efforts were concerned with
weaves with orthogonal tows, modeling based or not on the nite
element method have been developed to characterize the effective
engineering properties [2737] and few focused on braids [3845],
but the braids in the form of tubes, as shown in Fig. 11, are less
studied especially to get a macro mechanical behavior.
The braid is manufactured by the diagonal intersection of several units of wires which are called spindles, in the conventional
machine of braiding, half of the bundles turn clockwise and other
half in the counterclockwise direction, and different braids are
manufactured as shown in Fig. 12. [46,47].
In this study, we present a non-linear macro mechanical behavior for 2 2 helicoidal braid.
6.1. Linear elastic behavior of the braid, Hookes law
6.1.1. Density of the braid
The density of a braid is dened as the volume of the braid divided by the volume of the enveloping cylinder:
2
U
N1 N 2 cos
a
D 5U2 D2
where
N1: The number of spindles
N2: The number of wires of each spindle
U: The diameter of wire
a: The angle of braiding
Fig. 10. Crack initiation area: simulation and experiment for PARNOR 1 in.
16
1962
C wires
ljkl
2
60
E cos4 a
E sin a cos2 a E cos3 a sin a
6
6
2
4
2
6 0 E sin a cos a
E sin a
E cos3 a sin a
6
60
0
0
0
6
6
40
0
0
0
E sin a cos a
E sin a cos a
0
0
0
0
0
C braid
ijkl
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
4
En
0 0
2
2 E n cos4 a
2 E n cos2 a sin a
2 E n cos2 a sin a 0 0
2 E n sin a
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
e11 3
7 6 e22 7
0
7 6
7
7 6
7
7 6 e33 7
0
76
7
7
7
6
0
7 6 c12 7
7 6
7
5 4 c13 5
0
2
c23
E cos2 a sin a
0
The longitudinal strain e22 is calculated from the length variation of the braid.
e11 3
7 6 e22 7
0
7 6
7
7 6
7
7 6 e33 7
0
76
7
7 6c 7
0
7 6 12 7
7 6
7
5 4 c13 5
0
2
c23
2E n cos2 a sin a
0
Fig. 14. Representative unit cell (left) and braiding angle change (right).
1963
1964
Fig. 16. Evolution of the braid during traction and numerical simulation results.
da
17
With:
e22
dp
p
18
q
OA0 cosa da dP cosda p2 PD2
p
ef cosa da q e22 cosda 1
p2 PD2
da2
2
19
20
21
When the pressure loading is applied the braid elongates without plastic deformation until it reaches a critical angle ac.
The relation between the initial diameter D0, the current radius
D, the current and initial angle a and a0, is obtained by using the
representative unit cell (see Fig. 14a).
1965
D D0
sin2b
sinb20
D0
References
sina
sina0
22
L L0
cos2b
cosb20
L0
cosa
cosa0
23
1
W
arcsin
2
24
where is the length of the unit cell measured along the tows and W
is the width of the spindles.
The model has been incremented in ABAQUS using the UMAT
subroutine, as shown in Fig. 15.
A traction test on a universal testing machine was carried out to
validate the developed model; the measures are taken from three
different positions, the Fig. 16 illustrates this test.
The Characteristics of the braid used in testing and simulation
are:
Length of the braid
(mm)
Diameter to be
braided (mm)
Diameter of wire
(mm)
Number of wire by
spindles
Number of the
spindles
Braiding pitch (mm)
250
41
43
0.4
Density (compactness)
0.54
10
Braiding angle
37.17
48
1.25
174
0.6
[1] Webster GA, Ezeilo AN. Residual stress distributions and their inuence on
fatigue lifetimes. Int J Fatigue 2001;23 [S375-S383STP 1004, 1988].
[2] Glinka G. Residual stresses in fatigue and fracture: theoretical analyses and
experiments. In: Niku-Lari A, editor. Advances in surface treatment and
residual stresses. Pergamon Press; 1987. p. 41354.
[3] Webster GA. In: Lieurade HP, editor. Fatigue and stress. France: IITT
International, Gournay-sur-Marne; 1989. p. 920.
[4] Suresh S. Fatigue of materials. Cambridge University Press; 1991.
[5] Newman JC. Fatigue-life prediction methodology using a crack-closure model.
Eng Mater Technol 1995;117:4339.
[6] Almer JD, Cohen JB, Winholtz RA. The effects of residual macrostresses and
microstresses on fatigue crack propagation. Metall Mater Trans
1998;29A:212736.
[7] Webster GA, Ezeilo AN. Principles of the measurement of residual stress by
neutron diffraction. In: Furrer A, editor. PSI proceedings of the 96002. ISSN
1019-6447, new instruments and science around SINGQ, November 1996. p.
21734.
[8] Sadananda K, Vasudevan AK. Short crack growth behavior. In: Piascik RS et al.,
editors. Fatigue and fracture mechanics, vol. 27. ASTM-STP; 1997. p. 30116.
1296.
[9] Sadananda K, Vasudevan AK. Application of unied fatigue damage approach
to compressiontension region. Int J Fatigue 1999;21(Suppl. 1):26373.
[10] Moshier MA, Hillberry BM. The inclusion of compressive residual stress
effects in crack growth modeling. Fatigue Fract Eng Mater Struct 1999;22(2):
51926.
[11] Wang H, Buchholz F-G, Richard HA, Jagg S, Scholtes B. Numerical and
experimental analysis of residual stresses for fatigue crack growth. Comput
Mater Sci 1999;16:10412.
[12] Almer JD, Cohen JB, Moran B. The effect of residual macrostresses and
microstresses on fatigue crack initiation. Mater Sci Eng 2000;A284:26879.
[13] Webster GA. ECRS-5, Holland. Role of residual stress in engineering
applications. September 1999. Materials Science Forum, 347349, 19.
Switzerland: Trans Tech Publ; 2000.
[14] Webster GA, Ezeilo AN. Neutron scattering in engineering applications.
Physica B 1997;234236:94955.
[15] Tauchert TR, Webster GA, Reed RC. Thermoelastoplastic analysis of a stainless
steel plate considering phase transformations. In: Crespo da Silva MRM,
Mazzilli CEN, editors. Mechanics Pan-America 1993. Appl Mech Rev 1993; 46
(Part 2): S12S20.
[16] Tauchert TR, Webster GA, Ezeilo A. Residual stresses in a surface-heat-treated
steel specimens. In: Godoy LA, Idelsohn SR, Laura PAA, Mook DT, editors.
Applied mechanics in the Americas, vol. III. Santa Fe (Argentina): AAM &
AMCA; 1995. p. 1859.
[17] Wener Aichberger, Harlard Riener, Helmut Dannbauer. Regarding Inuences
Processes on Material Parameters in Fatigue Life Prediction. MAGONA POWER
TRAIN-Engineering Center Steyr GmbH&CoKG, St. Valentin, Austria 2007-011650.
[18] Wu-rong Wang, Guanlong Chen, Zhong-qin Lin. The study on the fatigue
FEM analysis considering the effect of stamping. Mater Des 2009;30:
158894.
[19] Zapatero J, Moreno B, Gonzalez-Herrera A. Fatigue crack closure determination
by means of nite element analysis. Eng Fract Mech 2008;75:415.
[20] Ryosuke Matsui, Yoshiyasu Makino, Hisaaki Tobushi, Yuji Furuichi, Fusahito
Yoshida. Inuence of strain ratio on bending fatigue life and fatigue crack
growth in TiNi shape-memory alloy thin wires. Mater Trans 2006;47:75965.
[21] Li B, Reis L, de Freitas M. Simulation of cyclic stress/strain evolutions for
multiaxial fatigue life prediction. Int J Fatigue 2006;28:4518.
[22] Murakami Y, Kanezaki T, Fukushima Y, Tanaka H, Tomuro J, Kuboyama K, et al.
Failure analysis of SUS316L exible hose for hydrogen station and fatigue life
prediction method. The Japan Society of Mechanical Engineers, No. 08-0544;
2009.
1966
[23] Marron Guy C, Patou Pascal F. Effect of forming in the design of deep-drawn
structural parts. In: Proceedings of the 1998 TMS annual meeting, February
1998. p. 2536.
[24] ABAQUS Documentation V 6.7.1.
[25] Lemaitre J, Chaboche JL. Mcanique des matriaux solides. 3me dition; 2001.
[26] Chaboche JL. Sur les effets dinteraction de lcrouissage et de
lendommagement dans lacier 316L. Rech. Arosp, MiJuin 1980.
[27] Bathias C, Bailon JP. La fatigue des matriaux et des structures. 2me dition,
Herms, Paris; 1997.
[28] Dumonta Franois, Hiveta Gilles, Rotinata Ren, Launay Jean, Boissea Philippe,
Vacherb Pierre. Field measurements for shear tests on woven reinforcements.
Mcanique Ind 2003;4:62763.
[29] Cox BN, Flanagan G. Handbook of analytical methods for textile composites.
NASA CR 4570; 1997.
[30] Tan P, Tong L, Steven GP. Modeling for predicting the mechanical properties of
textile composites a review. Composites: Part A 1997;28A:90322.
[31] Bystron J, Jekabsons N, Varna J. An evaluation of different models for
prediction of elastic properties of woven composites. Composites: Part B
2000;31B:720.
[32] Ishikawa T, Chou T-W. Stiffness and strength behavior of woven fabric
composites. J Mater Sci 1982;17:321120.
[33] Naik NK, Shembekar PS. Elastic behavior of woven fabric composites: I
lamina analysis. J Compos Mater 1992;26:2196225.
[34] Whitcomb JD, Tang X. Routine three-dimensional analysis of woven
composites. In: Proceedings of the 12th international conference of
composite materials. Paris, France; 1999.
[35] Tang X. Micromechanics of 2D woven composites, Ph.D. Dissertation,
Department of Aerospace Engineering, Texas A&M University, College
Station, Texas, December; 2001.
[36] Whitcomb JD, Chapman CD, Tang X. Derivation of boundary conditions for
micromechanics analyses of plain and satin weave composites. J Compos
Mater 2000;34(9):72447.
[37] Tang X, Whitcomb JD. General techniques for exploiting periodicity and
symmetries in micromechanics analysis of textile composites. J Compos Mater
2003;37(13):116789.
[38] Whitcomb JD, Tang X. Effective moduli of woven composite. J Compos Mater
2001;35(23):212744.
[39] Tang X, Whitcomb JD, Goyal D, Kelkar AD. Effect of braid angle and waviness
ratio on effective moduli of 22 biaxial braided composites. In: Proceedings of
the 44th AIAA/ASME/ASCE/AHS structures, structural dynamics, and materials
conference, April 710, 2003. Norfolk, Virginia, AIAA-2003-1877; 2003.
[40] Ma CL, Yang JM, Chou TW. Elastic stiffness of three-dimensional braided textile
structure composites. In: Proceedings of the composite materials: testing and
design (7th conference), ASTM893; 1986.
[41] Naik RA. Failure analysis of woven and braided fabric reinforced composites. J
Compos Mater 1995;29:233463.
[42] Byun J-H. The analytical characterization of 2-D braided textile composites.
Compos Sci Technol 2000;60:70516.
[43] Cox BN, Carter WC, Fleck NA. A binary model of textile composites: I
formulation. Acta Metal Mater 1994;42:346379 [(2009) Nihon Kikai Gakkai
Ronbunshu, A Hen/Transactions of the Japan Society of Mechanical Engineers,
Part A, 75 (1), pp. 93102].
[44] Miravete A, Clementeand R, Castejon L. Macro mechanical analysis of 3-D
textile reinforced composites. In: Miravete A, editor. 3-D Textile
reinforcements in composite materials. Cambridge (England): Woodhead
Publishing; 1999.
[45] Mrquez A, Fazzini PG, Otegui JL. Failure analysis of exible metal hose at
compressor discharge. Eng Fail Anal 2009;16(6):191221.
[46] Potluri P. Geometrical modeling and control of a triaxial braiding machine for
producing 3D performs. Composites: Part A 2003;34:48192.
[47] Tada Makiko. Structure and machine braiding procedure of coupled square
braids with various cross sections. Composites: Part A 2001;32:14859.