Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Black Camera
A Micro Journal of Black Film Studies
The Black Film Center/Archive
VOL. 21, NO. 1 ISSN 1536-3155 Spring/Summer 2006
the BFC/A’s last seven years, a highlight of which has been the ATM: This has remained a troubling divide of the ancestral wa-
growth of the archive, particularly the number of special named ters exacerbated by perceptions that Africans are being favored
collections and our expanded focus on African diaspora cinema. by White America.
We feature an interview with Manthia Diawara, a filmmaker and
MD: Yes, that’s true. So I want [my children] to learn African
scholar who bridges African and African American cinema, and an
culture, but I want them primarily to learn Black American cul-
insightful essay by Akin Adesokan on Nigerian Cinema. Profes-
ture here, not only to get ahead but also to defend themselves
sor Adesokan introduced the films in our recent film series, ‘“Nol-
against racism. That’s important to me.
lywood:’ Nigerian Cinema on the Rise.”
As I prepare to pass the torch to the very able Dr. Michael ATM: That thought brings me back to something that you said
Martin, I am reminded of the countless people who have enhanced earlier about meeting poet Ted Joans in France and your friend-
my experience at the BFC/A. Although there are too many to ship with him.
name here, without them this journey would not have been so full
MD: Yes.
of pleasure and drifting memories.
ATM: He seemed to be telling you to go to America because
-Audrey T. McCluskey, Director BFC/A they [the French] don’t like you [Africans] here. They liked
him because he was from America. How did you understand
that complicated notion?
MD: At that point, I took it as a poetic statement. I said: “This
Special Collection Acquisitions guy’s crazy all the time.” He was a kind of an older brother,
2000-2006 and so wise. I had to listen to him. I saw an opportunity in
his advice. He said, “Go to America because they will accept
S. Torriano Berry Collection- June 2005 you all there, and they don’t like us there. Leave France be-
cause they don’t love you here, and they like us here.” Lit-
St. Clair Bourne Collection- September 2002 erally I understood it, but I didn’t understand at that time the
complicity that he was creating between us, the bond that he
William Greaves Collection- October 2003 was creating between us—that is, we wink at each other, we
know where something worked for someone in this place or
Alile Sharon Larkin Collection- January 2003 that place. He had that kind of intelligence, and I didn’t know
that. I didn’t know that he was telling me: “Young man, you
Jesse Maple Collection- June 2005 are not an American here. You will make it in America, but you
won’t make it here. And I want you to make it, so this is what
Edward Mapp Collection- June 2000 I’m going to advise you to do even though I don’t like America
myself.”
ATM: That was in 1974…?
Black Film Center / Archive Endowment
We appreciate your generous contributions to the BFC/A Endow-
MD: 1974. I always apply this statement to affirmative ac-
ment to support collections development and special projects. tion because the way affirmative action is conceived nowadays,
where there is an attempt to dilute the concept and bypass Afri-
Name can Americans and get people from India, Africa, everywhere.
Address
ATM: Yeah. A broad, ahistorical lumping of people to divide
Please mail your check (payable to BFC/A Please check box: and conquer.
Endowment Account No. 37-AS59-02-2): ٱBenefactor
BFC/A Endowment - IU Foundation ($1,000 and above)
MD: You have to figure out how you can keep the spirit of af-
c/o IU Foundation ٱPatron ($500 and above) firmative action while at the same time build this complexity
Showalter House ٱSupporter when, if a Nigerian can do the work sometimes, you go with a
1500 N. State Roade 45/46 Bypass ($200 and above)
Nigerian because you know that the White professors may not
Bloomington , IN 47402 ٱFriend (any amount)
go for an African American and that Nigerian would have to
work to be an African American later and so on. So you have to
continued on page 9
Volume 21, Issue 1 Black Camera Page 3
Feb. 7 Osuofia in London (Part One), (2004), dir. Kingsley Ogoro. Running time: 110mins
Osuofia is a farmer often at odds with his demanding family. When he receives the news of the death of his
brother in London, an under-prepared Osuofia sees an opportunity to escape the troubles of home and enrich
himself from the huge bequest of his late brother’s will.
Feb. 14 Thunderbolt: Magun (2001), dir. Tunde Kelani. Running time: 105mins
Thunderbolt: Magun tells the story of Ngozi, a young wife who, because of her job as a school teacher, has
to divide her time between two towns. Her husband suspects her of infidelity, and when she is discovered to
be suffering from a deadly affliction, her marriage and life are at risk.
Feb. 23 Agbeke, (2004), dir. Abbey Lanre; prod. Bukky Wright. Running time: 120mins.
A rich but childless man takes advantage of a naïve girl, and dies thereafter, but not before his own barren
wife claims to have become pregnant at last. Agbeke, the girl, is separated from her child who grows up
as Tobi. When the teenage Tobi develops a serious illness, the question of who will donate a spare kidney
arises, bringing a long-neglected Agbeke back into the foray.
ASankofaExperience...
The BFC/A looks back on the major events during the
years 1999-2006
2000-2001
Why Do Fools Fall in Love (1998) screening with IU graduate Gerald “Real to Reel: Urban
question and answer featuring screenwriter/producer/ Harkness gives lecture and Hip Hop Culture in
actress Tina Andrews titled: “The Art and Pas- American Film” film se-
sion of a Filmmaker” ries and panel discussion
Academic/Cultural Projects
Occasional Papers Series Volume 1: Urban Testimonials- Hip Hop Culture in Film
by Audrey T. McCluskey and Tyrone Simpson
Frame by Frame III: Filmography of African Diaspora (forthcoming IU Press)
edited by Audrey T. McCluskey
Imaging Blackness:Film Poster Art and Racial Representation (forthcoming IU Press)
edited by Audrey T. McCluskey
“Imaging Blackness”- National Touring Exhibit of BFC/A Poster Art (check website for details)
Volume 21, Issue 1 Black Camera Page 5
2003-2004
2004-2005
2005-2006
loid features, one of which he only produced. As an active and private broadcasting has since become a catalytic feature
filmmakers he commands a stable, consistent, and formalized of mass media in Nigeria.
structure—Mainframe Productions. His cinematic practice is The earliest films were produced on shoestring budgets
firmly rooted in Yoruba cultural identity even when he makes that the established filmmakers, who were accustomed to cellu-
a foray into a cross-cultural ambience, as in the film Magun: loid filmmaking with all its costs, could not embrace. Granted
Thunderbolt, his first ‘English-language’ film. At the same that technical expertise was lacking in most cases, those early
time (a suitable Nigerian phrase), he travels regularly to film films suffered more from an inability to the requisite capital
festivals inside and outside the continent. In 2004 he was the than from an inability to tell a good story. Acting in Nigerian
subject of a mid-career retrospective at the New York African cinema has always been excellent, if often quite theatrical, but
Film Festival, and in Los Angeles later in the year. One of his the overall quality was greatly affected by the technology of
films, Agogo Eewo (The Sacred Gong), was screened around shoulder-borne video camera.
the United States as part of an African trav- Even the breakthrough work of this peri-
eling series. For a country with a od, Living in Bondage (1992) produced and
But there is a limit to holding up an indi- directed by the electronics merchant Kenneth
vidual filmmaker as the paradigmatic figure widely misunderstood Nnebue, was technically flawed. Its success
in a context as stunningly diverse as Nigeria. international image derived in part from its appeal to an audi-
There are producers such as Francis Onwo- and quite susceptible to ence broader than the ones that the Yoruba
filmmakers had pleased for years. The story
chei, Kingsley Ogoro, Kabat Esosa Egbon
and others who work the European circuit, resentment from outsiders, of Paul, a jobless man who becomes rich by
while being active in Nigeria-focused initia- the self-adulation is not sacrificing his wife to a secret cult, Living in
tives like filmmakers’ cooperatives and gov- Bondage cannily mixed a dramatic example
ernment-sponsored professionals’ retreats
entirely useless. of personal tribulation with the pervasive
and workshops. There are actors’ caucuses presence of Pentecostal fervor, and through
and cliques unevenly spread across Lagos, Onitsha, Aba, and the judicious deployment of English subtitles rendered the
Osogbo; in sprawling markets of Idumota and Alaba cartels and Igbo speech accessible in the multi-ethnic context of Nigeria.
mafias proliferate as regularly as the videofilms are released. In Haunted by the wife’s ghost to the point of mental breakdown,
terms of actual productivity, these different formations put out Paul finds deliverance in a Pentecostal church. On this purely
over a thousand titles in a year, although given the scarcity of didactic level, the film was an unqualified success. The rest is
reliable statistics in Nigeria, this estimate is at best rough for a cinematic history, an on-going rehearsal and one of the most
sector firmly in private hands. Their target markets spring from fascinating in contemporary Africa.
the road-side tuck-shop to transnational trade networks that the Little of this history has received the kind of rigorous at-
anthropologist Brian Larkin has questionably characterized as tention that it deserves3. Instead, what abound are celebratory
‘disembedded from the official global economy’2. claims regarding Nigeria as a ‘force’ in filmmaking circles.
The introduction of SAP had two immediate effects on the Hence the chest-beating honorific of Nollywood, ‘the third
economics of filmmaking in the middle of the 1980s. In the first largest film industry in the world’, as an otherwise well-mean-
place, hitherto-active filmmakers like Ola Balogun, Eddie Ug- ing commentator recently opined4. For a country with a widely
bomah, and Bayo Aderounmu (with whom Kelani had worked misunderstood international image and quite susceptible to re-
as a cinematographer) found it difficult to fund new films. When sentment from outsiders, the self-adulation is not entirely use-
they were able to complete a project, the costs of postproduc- less. In the rest of this essay, I attend to misconceptions whose
tion, which could only be done abroad, were too prohibitive. correction I judge as crucial to a productive engagement with
Even if the filmmakers could hope to sell these works to local the videofilm practice.
television stations for broadcast, there was the other effect of It is common to describe these films, indeed the cinema
SAP. The Nigerian National Television Authority, NTA, was of Nigeria, as apolitical. This is unhelpful. The sense of the
one of the public corporations from which subsidies had been political implied in such descriptions is conventional. The
withdrawn, and most of the television producers were increas- films are political, but not always in the explicitly anti-imperial
ingly looking elsewhere for work. mode which we see in much of better-known African cinema,
In the early 1990s, there was an exodus of professionals from Ousmane Sembène to Jean-Marie Teno. Politics here is
from the television houses. But as it happens in such situations, conceived philosophically as a sub-category of morality, so it
this was also the time that video and digital technologies were is a foundationalist kind of principle, over and above specific
becoming more and more available and affordable (deregu- political or social situations. There is some truth in the assump-
lated, in fact, like the economies of the developing regions), tion that, since volatile political themes do not often or easily
continued on page 8
Page 8 Black Camera Volume 21, Issue 1
Diawara Interview
continued from page 2
look at these complicities and this was those cultural connections and feelings. really want to work together, you get to
what Ted Joans was trying to make with know each other. You create a new re-
me. He is in France and it works well MD: Right. My position is not roman-
lationship, and it’s this new relationship
for him, and he sends me to America. tic. My position is that Africans and
that’s most important to me and this is
African Americans, first of all, share
ATM: That’s a wonderful complicity. what I have created with African Ameri-
similar fates. With all the problems in
Let’s now talk about film and filmmak- cans.
Africa, people think that African Ameri-
ing. I recently saw your new film Dias- cans have something to do with it in the ATM: Do you think your film actually
pora Conversations (2000). sense that they stereotype them and they moved to that position?
MD: Diaspora Conversations. say “Yeah, Black people are this, Black MD: Yes, because I went to Africa with
people are that.” So, problems in this Danny Glover and Clyde Taylor and
ATM: There is such a contrast with your country, too, sometimes reflect on the
film and a film we just screened in our then we met Ted Joans there. Ted Joans,
image of Africa. We need to struggle, to his credit, knew Africa better than the
series. We featured films such as Raoul to fight together, to do things together,
Peck’s Lumumba (2000), and Wil- rest of them. He’s been going there for
and I don’t want to do this romantical- years. Everybody laughs, everybody
liam Greaves was here to screen Ralph ly. I think that if you go to Africa as an
Bunche: An American Odyssey (2001). loves him. But first, Danny and Clyde,
But then another film in the series that they raise their questions about Africa,
was troubling to some was Little Sen- My position is not which is the kind of rejection that I’m
egal (2001) by Rachid Bouchareb. Do talking about and Africans do look at
romantic. My position is them in certain ways. Once they got to
you know the film?
that Africans and African know each other, people realized what a
MD: Little Senegal, yes, I know that kind person Danny Glover is. He never
film. You have to make a decision. I Americans, first of all, really acts like a star. He’s just such a
made a decision to be part of the African share similar fates. normal person.
American community. The director of
Little Senegal made a decision to say ATM: Yeah, you can tell that.
that Africans and African Americans African American and get rejected, you MD: And then Clyde Taylor is the same
have nothing in common and he want- should not be surprised because in Af- way. So they gradually began to come
ed to make [the film] to prove that. If rica, people have gone through several home because they began to know each
you notice in the film, toward the end changes. This idyllic fixed Africa is not other as human beings, not as Black
all the relations break down except for there. So if you go to the Motherland, Americans and Africans. It was a very
the Black American woman and an Arab you must remember that the Mother- rewarding thing to see. Through the
woman and nothing that was taking place land has already been colonized by Is- documentary, we ourselves got pos-
between Black Africans and African lam, by French people, by different par- sessed by African rituals and it trans-
Americans came to fruition. The film titions of the nation-state—then where formed us and that includes me.
is consistent with the usual French pro- are you going to go? But if you take
paganda to say that it’s America that’s history into account and look at contem- ATM: It is a really a powerful film to
racist, America is where nothing works porary realities and as a Black Ameri- teach; to create a dialogue among dia-
and even African Americans have noth- can you say: “I feel implicated by the sporan Africans, like the dialogue Af-
ing to do with Africa and so on. It was situation in Africa. I want to go and do ricans and African Americans don’t of-
very troubling to me, too. But I love the something.” So you go and first you get ten engage that followed your talk. We
idea of a film that sends an African to rejected. “Who are you? I don’t know share the same space, but we don’t often
America to look for his roots. you.” You know, that’s what people do engage each other.
to each other. When an African comes MD: That’s a shame because when you
ATM: A great notion. here, first African Americans will reject look at what African-America can do for
MD: I love this idea! But suddenly the you. You are not like the Africa they Africa, it’s incredible. African Ameri-
film begins to give moral lessons to Af- had imagined and then somewhere the cans are in the most powerful country in
rican Americans. African-American goes to Africa and the world and they have an incredible,
it’s not what the African-American had powerful lobby in Washington D.C.
ATM: Your film comes from a vastly
imagined. So that initial rejection to me They can influence America in its deci-
different point of view. It’s still about
is so normal. It’s ok. But then if you
continued on page 10
Page 10 Black Camera Volume 21, Issue 1
Diawara Interview
continued from page 9
sions toward African countries—wheth- specifically in Africa. Showing also that can Cinema] back in the early nineties. I
er it’s trade, politics, or getting rid of this is the country where W.E.B. Dubois should have paid more attention to that.
dictators—African America can make was born. Martin Luther King, Malcolm
ATM: What is your assessment of current
America do things for Africa. Africa, X and these people have contributed more
African American cinema?
too, can do incredible things for Afri- to the changing world history than any
can-Americans in terms of finding one’s philosophy in the world. Africans do not MD: I was at a conference recently and
roots, one’s identity—African cultures know these figures, these giants and Ida B. many of these ideas here are not just mine.
and their contribution to the world cul- Wells; they do not know Angela Davis and But the thrust of the discussion was that
ture. Not only music and art but also a so on. Documentaries, films like Eyes on Black American independent cinema of
kind of [African] humanism. The idea the Prize (1987), fictional films on these the ‘70s and ‘80s—particularly around
in Africa that we are a family. It’s not issues would be very, very good [to show] UCLA, called the LA Rebellion with
because you are an old person that we in Africa. Making films on Africans who filmmakers like Charles Burnett, Billy
have to cast you out, put you in the old have civilizations, who have rich cultures, Woodbury, Julie Dash etc. These film-
folks home, everybody takes care of you. showing them in Black communities— makers were using films in a very pow-
That family relation would be a very im- these are things we can do. We don’t have erful manner. They drew their resources
portant notion in America. the power to change the world right away, from the Italian neo-realism, from African
but as academics and professors and with cinema, Brazilian cinema—but they had a
ATM: Yes, there is acceptance of this, our relations to people like Danny Glover, Black aesthetics that one could compare
but there’s still a resistance to becoming we can do things like that. Danny Glover to Black music—you know, the Blues, the
acculturated. not only is helping filmmakers like Ous- vernacular. They were working within
MD: What I still try to do is to show is mane Sembene, he also gave one million the community and they were creating a
that Africans do not know Black Ameri- to TransAfrica to work to change US pol- film language that produced some clas-
cans. They don’t know much about slav- sics like Burnett’s Killer of Sheep (1977)
ery, they don’t know much. The only thing It killed independent and Haile Gerima’s Bush Mama (1976).
Then came Spike Lee’s She’s Gotta Have
that they know about Black America that cinema but it did not (1986). Very edgy. Very interesting.
is important is the stereotype. The things
that they see on CNN: people getting ar- replace it with a new Also, independent—and it’s a movie that
rested, people with guns, rap music and artistic cinema that people could be shown in movie theaters—and
this kind of thing. the argument was made at the conference
could describe... that that changed the force of Black cine-
ATM: And that brings us back to film. ma. People just threw everything out until
MD: Yes. That’s right! icy toward Africa and Haiti and Central Spike Lee and they began to watch Spike
America and South America. Lee and he becomes the Black filmmaker
ATM: Because film can produce or dis- because of She’s Gotta Have It. The argu-
rupt stereotype. I was in South Africa re- ATM: What do you think about the con-
ment continued that in a way that was both
cently and was surprised by what Africans tent of a lot of the films coming out of
positive and negative for Black cinema. It
are actually watching on television and at other parts of Africa these days? Is there
was positive because Black filmmakers
the cinema. a kind of homogenizing of the stories and
were shown on the big screen and She’s
plots? Is that globalization all over again.
MD: Unfortunately, it is bad films. Bad Got to Have It was a watershed film. All
(I say again because we often forget that
films with negative stereotypes with Black the Spike Lee films brought to people’s
the slave trade was global and so was co-
people as thieves, as drug dealers and so attention many Black actors who are now
lonialism).
on. great actors—Halle Berry, Sam Jackson,
MD: That’s right, its this new global- all these guys. But it was unfortunate be-
ATM: Where is this coming from? Amer-
ization. That’s what’s happening. They cause it did not lead to a new language of
ica?
only make films that are not threatening to Black cinema. It killed independent cin-
MD: It’s coming from America most- [power holders] and African filmmakers ema, but it did not replace it with a new
ly—mostly American old movies and have learned to respond to that. It’s a gift artistic cinema that people could describe
new movies—but not enough redeeming to the global market—something light. as they could describe the LA Rebellion
images. Black filmmakers can make an Something easy to consume. So the best films, for example. Our whole conference
incredible contribution to changing the African cinema was actually being pro- was based on the question of where we
image of Black America in the world— duced when I was writing my book [Afri- are going after She’s Gotta Have It.
continued on page 11
Volume 21, Issue 1 Black Camera Page 11
ATM: It’s an interesting and provocative discussion because there one sense, this demand is a reflection of the integrated role of the
are certainly more Black filmmakers than ever right now, more arts as social phenomena, and cultural brokers in the 20th century
blacks making a living in the film industry, not to mention the had many field days perorating on the functionality of African arts.
recent academy awards to black actors. But is the quality better or In another sense, Nigerian videofilms stand at the crossroads of
worse? What is black cinema doing for black people? capital as casualties of their own success.
At this strange pass, how much can one hope to see by way
MD: Yeah. That’s exactly what they were saying. Black film-
of the auteur tradition that preserves the independence of a film
makers are interested in one thing—to be a filmmaker and to go
as a singular work of art? Is not this social requirement a way
to Hollywood and make money. So they left behind the com-
of further severing the form’s open-ended, inclusive politics from
munity to go to Hollywood. You make films that compromise
the critical traditions in global cinema? Or, to take a more opti-
and leave behind certain artistic and political concerns. This
mistic view, does this suggest a reconfiguration of the politics of
was the argument at the conference. I was fascinated by some
mass forms on a global level, in very much the same way that
of these ideas.
new technologies and the wide dispersal of peoples are unsettling
ATM: Potent ideas. entrenched cultural notions?
MD: We said Black cinema is dead. The film they showed was Akin Adesokan is an assistant professor of Com-
like Kasi Lemmons’ The Caveman’s Valentine (2001) Films parative Literature at IU
like that, that’s what was shown and, you know, people say
“Where is that edgy Black cinema beyond the Hollywood cin-
ema?” But again, people say “Every Black filmmaker wants to
go to Hollywood, that’s the problem.”
ATM: But a filmmaker with real passion wants to make films-
most of them have Hollywood dreams—but the new technol- 1
Haynes, Jonathan. “Nigerian Cinema: Structural Adjustments”, Re-
ogy—internet, DVDs, digital cameras, and lower costs create search in African Literatures, Vol. 26, No. 3, Fall 1995, 111.
more options. I wonder if we are creating new models of suc- 2
See his “Degraded Images, Distorted Sounds: Nigerian Videos and
cess in filmmaking. the Infrastructure of Piracy”, Public Culture, Vol. 16, No 2, Spring 2004,
293.
MD: Well, you know, that’s what’s happening in Nigeria. 3
For an early attempt to characterize the films along thematic lines,
The Nigeria video films, they used to make them literally for
see Nigerian Videofilms, Jonathan Haynes (ed.), Jos: Nigerian Film Cor-
$2,000. Now the price has gone up because they are making a
poration, 1997. Contributors included Larkin, Onookome Okome, film-
lot of money. Now it’s got to be at least $25- 50,000, so they
maker Afolabi Adesanya, and others.
make these films and it’s a huge market right now. It’s like a 4
Toyin Akinosho, “Don’t envy the South Africans” (Artsville), The
$70 million a year market—
Guardian on Sunday, Online edition, March 6, 2005.
ATM: Yes, it is often compared to what has happened in In-
dia.
MD: It’s like India, but the paradigm is very interesting be-
cause remember in the ‘80s, Black writers used to do this.
They would write books published by the Black press and they
would distribute them themselves. With the development of
Submit an Article for Black
video and the potential of video, digital video cameras, I think Camera
what you just said—DVD, movies can be created and they can
be sold on alternative markets and a new cinema can be born. For more information regarding contributing writer submis-
sions please contact:
At least that is the hope.
Damien Strecker, Graduate Assistant for the Black Film Center/
Archive email: dstrecke@indiana.edu; phone: (812) 855-6041
Page 12 Black Camera Volume 21, Issue 1
The Constant Gardener general, the plot encourages genuine re- put into proper context, leaves the aver-
flection on this discrepancy in regards to age audience member feeling as though
A Review the respect of life. the situation is hopeless because of the ir-
By Damien Strecker In addition to the broad issue of the rational blood lust and feuding going on
worthiness of life, the film focuses on ‘over there’ instead of an example of the
white guilt and the idealism necessary for complex Muslim-Christian relations in the
The Constant Gardener (2006), di- change in Africa. This is a position that ig- region. The filmmakers could have devel-
rected by Fernando Meirelles, is a film nores the structural reality of the situation. oped a more nuanced African perspective
that tries to mix love, suspense, and po- In truth, the English “white guilt” can still by perhaps making Arnold a central char-
litical consciousness. While the narrative be highly profitable as well as palatable, in acter.
succeeds in conveying the first two objec- the form of Kenyan coffee grains and tea The solution given by the film in-
tives, the political aspect is ripe for inter- leaves. Economic policy is constructed volves Europeans looking inward and
rogation. While it does attempt to shed accordingly. While the tag line, “Love. changing their moral outlook instead of a
light on the negative tendency of Western At Any Cost,” has a nice romantic ring fundamental critique of the system initi-
governments to value life on a relative ba- to it, it ultimately sends the message that ated by intolerance of the status quo. This
sis, there remains problems with the Eu- only if enough do-good Europeans had the “love conquers all” solution, combined
ropean idealism, as well as the lack of a right amount of brotherly love, the unequal with the paucity of African characters
developed African character. power structure could be challenged. The of substance leaves much to be desired.
The story centers on Justin Quayle reality suggests otherwise. According to
(Ralph Fiennes) and Tessa Quayle (Acad- the CIA Fact book, 67% of the nation’s Damien Strecker is pursing a
emy Award winning Rachel Weisz), an
gross domestic product goes towards the Master’s degree in AAADS and is a
English couple living in Kenya. Justin, a
repayment of debt and the unemployment graduate assistant at the BFC/A
diplomat, is an unassuming public servant
rate is around 40%. With these sorts of
who avoids confrontation at all costs. Tes-
embedded disadvantages fostered by or-
sa, a passionate, pro-active idealist, inves- ganizations such as the International Mon-
tigates the dealings of a foreign pharma- etary Fund, one would be foolish to invest
ceutical company that is conducting drug hope in the concept of Europeans em-
research on unsuspecting Kenyans. Her bracing love as the answer. This
detective work leads to trouble and Justin idealism that relies on the moral
is compelled to find the courage to con- pangs of Europeans for change is
tinue his wife’s whistle blowing efforts. a feel-good thematic ploy on the
The issue of a pharmaceutical compa- part of the writers that fails to ac-
ny’s trial testing drugs on humans is tack- knowledge the powerful entities
led as an international conspiracy driven behind the widespread scenes of
by greed. While this particular scenario poverty shown in the film.
of drug testing was created for the plot, Along with not offering a
it underscores a general theme to which structural critique of the issues
the historical record can attest. That is, in facing Kenya, there is not a sin-
the eyes of many white policy makers, an gle African character that is de-
impoverished African life is not worth as veloped thoroughly. Aside from
much as a European or American life. One Arnold (Hubert Kounde), who
need not be a paranoid conspiracy theorist dies early in the film, the only ex-
to make the logical leap that something posure the audience has to Afri-
similar to The Constant Gardener could cans is in examples of corruption,
exist today. Giving small pox infested extreme poverty (sometimes in
blankets to Native Americans, promoting a voyeuristic fashion), and un-
opium addiction in China, and testing the mitigated aggression. This gives
effects of syphilis on black men in rural the impression among audience
Georgia is a random snapshot that illus- members that Africans are more
trates the point. Supposedly ‘civilized’ of the problem than the solution.
countries have shown a long track record The scene involving the Suda-
of not valuing the lives of non-whites. In nese raiders on horseback, not
Volume 21, Issue 1 Black Camera Page 13
Hustle and Flow critical eye can easily be led to believe that gangs, pimps, drugs,
and prostitution are the Black status quo. It is not enough that a
“Black song” has won when the song in question happens to glo-
Is it Hard out Here for a rify a pimp culture that will undoubtably be imitated by misguided
Blacks and their white counterparts. This is not cause for celebra-
Pimp? tion.
-Garlia Jones, playwright and graduate student
The Memphis group, Three 6 Mafia and their protege Fray- AAADS
ser Boy recently took home the 2006 Academy Award for Best
Achievement in Music Written for Motion Pictures, Original Song The fact that these men were black is critical in the acclaim and
with “It’s Hard out Here for a Pimp.” Used in a crucial scene accolades they receive for this song. Would whites, Latinos or
for the film Hustle and Flow, the song has raised discussion in Asian Americans be awarded for such a song? I would find such a
regards to its depiction of pimping and the implications for the scenario hard to believe. Also, the accepted exploitation of wom-
Black community. The BFC/A posed this question to several IU en, foundational to this song, is disturbing to say the least. The
students: physical, sexual, and mental abuse associated with prostitution
and pimping is deemed as a regrettable but ultimately understand-
“How do you feel about the song ‘It’s Hard Out able means of survival in the ghetto. The academy has awarded a
Here for a Pimp,’ winning an Academy Award?” song that promulgates a misinformed, muddy theme at best. One
can only hope that this is seen for what it is by our society: the
proclamation of African Americans as agreeably sexualized, vio-
The film’s tagline reads, “Everybody gotta have a dream.” In lent, and crude. With messages like this, they are telling the coun-
the case of Terrance Howard’s character Deejay, the scope of try wholly that the African American predicament is a product of
his dreams are extremely limited due to a lack of an equality of their culture instead of an historical legacy of inequality.
opportunity. It is telling of the broader societal situaton that -Jeremy Gilmore, graduate student, AAADS
within the ghetto, some of the only percieved options out are
via music or sports. I think the song should not be judged too I’m amped. All the uproar over the issue shows people are still
harshly in that it tries to capture the essence of the struggle to trying to ignore the biggness of hip-hop. Three 6 Mafia may not
survive amidst limited circumstances that is usually lacking in the be the particular type of hip-hop I am in to, but I have mad love for
largely cartoonish popular images of the Black pimp. anyone bringing hip-hop to different audiences and mediums. That
power can be tapped into to get more relevant stuff out there.
-Damien Strecker, grauduate student, AAADS -Versiz, slam poet/hip hop artist who
I have a problem with any music, or movie for that matter, that performs regularly at IU
would glorify such a despicable profession without critique of
the larger social issues that contribute to the crime. I think
that pimping is one of the highest crimes that a black man can
commit, because he is willingly exploiting the women who have
already been dehumanized in this society. It’s sad that this image
has been glorified in the pop culture marketplace. Historically,
African Americans at the Oscars have been awarded for roles
that conform to the America’s archetypal fantasy of “black life.”
So far, the academy has “awarded” us for staying in our roles:
a mammy, a handy man who risked his life for German nuns,
a child-abusing poor woman who found salvation in a white
southerner, a dirty cop exposed by a good white cop, an enter-
tainer, and now, a pimp. Because of the scarcity of black roles in
pop culture, I am disturbed when the exalted images are ones like
these.
From left to right: Jordan “Juicy J” Houston, Paul “D.J. Paul”
-Asha French, M.F.A. candidate,
Beauregard, and Cedric “Frayser Boy” Coleman
Creative Writing program
Page 14 Black Camera Volume 21, Issue 1
Enclosed is my check for $ __________________ . Send my gifts and BLACK CAMERA to:
Name
Address
Please mail this coupon with your check payable to: I.U. Foundation - c/o BFC/A
We invite you to send inquiries to: Visit our Web Site at:
Black Film Center/Archive http://www.indiana.edu/~bfca
812.855.6041
Fax: 812.856.5832
email: bfca@indiana.edu