Professional Documents
Culture Documents
PRACTICE
BULLETIN
CLINICAL MANAGEMENT GUIDELINES FOR
OBSTETRICIANGYNECOLOGISTS
NUMBER 56, OCTOBER 2004
(Replaces Educational Bulletin Number 253, November 1998)
This Practice Bulletin was
developed by the ACOG Committee on Practice Bulletins
Obstetrics, the Society for
Maternal-Fetal Medicine and
ACOG Joint Editorial Committee with the assistance of
Katharine Wenstrom, MD, and
contributors John Elliot, MD;
Roger Newman, MD; Alan
Peaceman, MD; and Suneet
Chahaun, MD. The information
is designed to aid practitioners
in making decisions about
appropriate obstetric and gynecologic care. These guidelines
should not be construed as dictating an exclusive course of
treatment or procedure. Variations in practice may be warranted based on the needs of the
individual patient, resources,
and limitations unique to the
institution or type of practice.
Multiple Gestation:
Complicated Twin,
Triplet, and High-Order
Multifetal Pregnancy
In 2002, more than 130,000 infants were born of multifetal gestations in the
United States (1). Since 1980, there has been a 65% increase in the frequency
of twins and a 500% increase in triplet and high-order births (1). Most of this
increase results from increased use of ovulation induction agents and assisted
reproductive technology (ART); the risk of multiple gestation associated with
these therapies may be as high as 25% (2). Similar increases in multifetal gestation have occurred worldwide (36).
Although multifetal births account for only 3% of all live births, they are
responsible for a disproportionate share of perinatal morbidity and mortality
(Table 1). They account for 17% of all preterm births (before 37 weeks of gestation), 23% of early preterm births (before 32 weeks of gestation), 24% of lowbirth-weight infants (<2,500 g), and 26% of very-low-birth-weight infants
(<1,500 g) (1, 79). Although twins do have an increased risk of morbidity and
mortality, a far greater proportion of triplet and high-order multiple gestations
have poor outcomes. All survivors of preterm multifetal births have an increased
risk of mental and physical handicap.
The purpose of this document is to address the risks associated with these
pregnancies and present an evidence-based approach to management when
possible. Because the literature on high-order multiple gestation is still largely
composed of case reports or small series, experience is important in the decision-making process for complicated twin or high-order multiple gestations.
869
Background
Infant and Maternal Morbidity
One fifth of triplet pregnancies and one half of quadruplet pregnancies result in at least 1 child with a major
long-term handicap, such as cerebral palsy (10). Cerebral
palsy occurs 17 times more often in triplet pregnancies
and more than 4 times more often in twin pregnancies
than in singleton pregnancies (10, 11). This risk is not
solely related to preterm birth. When matched for gestational age at delivery, infants from multifetal pregnancies
have a nearly 3-fold greater risk of cerebral palsy (12,
13). One confounding factor may be growth restriction,
which complicates approximately 5060% of triplet and
quadruplet pregnancies (14). Growth-restricted preterm
infants, regardless of plurality, have a significantly higher risk of morbidity (including an excess of neurodevel-
opmental abnormalities) and mortality than appropriately grown infants of the same gestational age (1519).
Multifetal gestations also are associated with significantly higher maternal morbidity and associated health
care costs. Women with multiple gestations are nearly
6 times more likely to be hospitalized with complications, including preeclampsia, preterm labor, preterm
premature rupture of membranes, placental abruption,
pyelonephritis, and postpartum hemorrhage (2026).
Hospital costs for women with multiple gestations are on
average 40% higher than for women with gestationalage-matched singleton pregnancies because of their
longer length of stay and obstetric complications.
Neonatal intensive care unit (NICU) admission is
required for one fourth of twins, three fourths of triplets,
and virtually all quadruplets, with average NICU stays of
18 days, 30 days, and 58 days, respectively (20, 2325,
2729).
Twins
1
Triplets
Quadruplets
2,347 g
1,687 g
1,309 g
35.3 wk
32.2 wk
29.9 wk
1425
5060
5060
25
75
100
18 days
30 days
58 days
20
50
Martin JA, Hamilton BE, Sutton PD, Ventura SJ, Menacker F, Munson ML. Births: final data for 2002. Natl Vital Stat Rep 2003;52(10):1102.
Mauldin JG, Newman RB. Neurologic morbidity associated with multiple gestation. Female Pat 1998;23(4):278, 30, 356, passim.
Ettner SL, Christiansen CL, Callahan TL, Hall JE. How low birthweight and gestational age contribute to increased inpatient costs for multiple births. Inquiry
199798;34:32539.
4
McCormick MD, Brooks-Gunn J, Workman-Daniels K, Turner J, Peckham GJ. The health and developmental status of very low-birth-weight children at school age. JAMA
1992;267:22048.
5
Luke B, Bigger HR, Leurgans S, Sietsema D. The cost of prematurity: a case-control study of twins vs singletons. Am J Public Health 1996;86:80914.
Albrecht JL, Tomich PG. The maternal and neonatal outcome of triplet gestations. Am J Obstet Gynecol 1996;174:15516.
Newman RB, Hamer C, Miller MC. Outpatient triplet management: a contemporary review. Am J Obstet Gynecol 1989;161:54753; discussion 5535.
Seoud MA, Toner JP, Kruithoff C, Muasher SJ. Outcome of twin, triplet, and quadruplet in vitro fertilization pregnancies: the Norfolk experience. Fertil Steril
1992;57:82534.
9
Elliott JP, Radin TG. Quadruplet pregnancy: contemporary management and outcome. Obstet Gynecol 1992;80:4214.
10
Grether JK, Nelson KB, Cummins SK. Twinning and cerebral palsy: experience in four northern California counties, births 1983 through 1985. Pediatrics
1993;92:8548.
11
Luke B, Minogue J. The contribution of gestational age and birth weight to perinatal viability in singletons versus twins. J Mat-Fetal Med 1994;3:26374.
12
Kiely JL, Kleinman JC, Kiely M. Triplets and higher order multiple births: time trends and infant mortality. Am J Dis Child 1992;146:8628.
13
Luke B, Keith LG. The contribution of singletons, twins, and triplets to low birth weight, infant mortality, and handicap in the United States. J Reprod Med
1992;37:6616.
870
Maternal Age
The a priori risk of a poor perinatal outcome in a highorder multiple gestation is further increased by the
womans age. The growing proportion of older women
successfully undergoing fertility treatment has resulted
in an increase in pregnancies complicated by adult-onset
diseases, such as hypertension and diabetes, labor abnormalities, and cesarean delivery.
Multifetal gestations in older women also complicates prenatal genetic screening and diagnosis. Increased
maternal age alone increases the risk of fetal trisomies,
such as Down syndrome. The presence of multiple fetuses increases the mathematical probability that 1 or more
fetuses will be affected and, thus, results in a higher risk
for the pregnancy than that attributed to maternal age
alone. For example, because either 1 or both fetuses in a
twin pair could have Down syndrome, the ultimate risk
Prenatal Diagnosis
Amniocentesis or chorionic villous sampling may be
technically difficult to accomplish in patients with multiple gestations (3742). Technical problems unique to
high-order multiple gestation include the need to traverse
another fetus sac to reach a different fetus for sampling,
incorrect fetal karyotype caused by cross contamination
with other sacs, difficulty in accurately mapping the
fetuses and determining which fetus is being sampled,
difficulty in accurately determining whether any of the
fetuses are monochorionic twins, and difficulty in locating and reducing only the affected fetus in the event an
aneuploidy is diagnosed and termination chosen.
Complications of
Pregnancy
Gestational Diabetes
The incidence of gestational diabetes in twin pregnancies is higher than in singleton pregnancies (43), and the
incidence in triplet pregnancies is higher than in twin
pregnancies; up to 2239% of triplet pregnancies are
complicated by gestational diabetes, compared with
36% of twin pregnancies (44, 45). One study of 95 twin
and 26 triplet pregnancies, which controlled for other
factors that influence the incidence of gestational diabetes, such as maternal age, weight, and parity, estimated
that each additional fetus increases the risk of gestational diabetes by a factor of 1.8 (45). Another study has
shown that pregnancy reduction significantly reduces the
incidence of gestational diabetes from 22% in triplet
pregnancies to 6% in reduced twin pregnancies (44).
Many aspects of the diagnosis and management of
gestational diabetes in multiple gestation remain unexamined. The best time for testing, the ideal number of daily
calories, the optimal weight gain, whether women treated
with oral hypoglycemic agents for polycystic ovary syndrome should continue taking them, the best form of
insulin to use, the best method of fetal surveillance, and
the ideal time for delivery are all currently unknown.
Consultation with an obstetriciangynecologist who has
expertise in the management of pregnant women with
diabetes, such as a maternalfetal medicine specialist,
and with a dietitian would be helpful.
871
872
High-order multiple gestation creates a medical and ethical dilemma. If a pregnancy with 4 or more fetuses is
continued, the probability is high that not all fetuses will
survive intact and that the woman will experience serious
morbidity. However, fetal reduction to triplet or twin gestations is associated with a significant risk of losing
either another fetus or the whole pregnancy. Most studies
have concluded that the risks associated with a quadruplet or higher pregnancy clearly outweigh the risks associated with fetal reduction.
The largest report of perinatal outcome after fetal
reduction, which included 1,789 reduction procedures
over a period of 9 years, noted an overall postprocedure
pregnancy loss rate of 11.7% and a very early preterm (ie,
between 25 and 28 weeks of gestation) delivery rate of
4.5% (65). The chance of losing either an additional fetus
or the whole pregnancy, and the chance of early preterm
delivery, increased according to the starting number of
fetuses; 23% of pregnancies that started with 6 or more
fetuses were lost before 24 weeks of gestation, and only
20% were delivered at 37 weeks of gestation or later.
Whether to reduce high-order multiple gestations to twin
or triplet gestations and whether to reduce triplet gestations at all are both areas of controversy.
Fetal reduction of a high-order multiple pregnancy
has been associated with an increased risk of intrauterine
fetal growth restriction (IUGR) in the remaining twins in
some studies but not in others (6669). One study found
the incidence of IUGR was 36% in twins reduced from
triplets, 42% in twins reduced from quadruplets, and
50% in twins reduced from quintuplets or greater, compared with 19% in twins who had not been reduced (67).
Another study found a significant risk of IUGR in the
remaining twins only when the starting number of fetuses was 5 or more (70).
Monochorionicity can complicate the reduction procedure; if one fetus of a monochorionic twin pair is inadvertently reduced, sudden hypotension and thrombotic
phenomena could result in death or damage of the
remaining twin fetus. This is illustrated by one series of
high-order multiple gestations (quadruplets and quintuplets) in which every pregnancy included a monochorionic twin pair (71). In each case, although the authors
selectively reduced only 1 of the monochorionic twins by
injection of potassium chloride, subsequent demise of all
the co-twins was confirmed.
Selective fetal termination is the application of the
fetal reduction technique to the selective termination of an
anomalous or aneuploid fetus that is part of a multiple gestation. The risks of this procedure are higher than those
associated with multifetal reduction (72). The pregnancy
usually is more advanced by the time the anomaly is diagnosed (ie, 1822 weeks of gestation compared with 1012
weeks of gestation), and the location of the anomalous
fetus may be associated with increased risk. The risk of
losing the whole pregnancy, having a preterm birth, or having an infant with a birth weight less than 2,500 g is highest when the reduced fetus overlies the cervix and when
the pregnancy is at or beyond 20 weeks of gestation (73).
873
Fetal Fibronectin
Fetal fibronectin is a high-molecular-weight extracellular
matrix glycoprotein that is normally found in fetal membranes, placental tissues, and amniotic fluid. Its presence
in cervicalvaginal fluids at concentrations higher than
50 ng/mL is abnormal and has been shown to predict
preterm delivery in singleton gestations. Four studies
examining the utility of measuring fetal fibronectin in
twin or triplet gestations showed that a single fetal
fibronectin test had a high negative predictive value, and
serial tests had a fairly high positive predictive value
(range: 3853%) (74, 8082). However, at least 1 study
found that fetal fibronectin levels were not predictive of
preterm delivery in twin gestations after controlling for
cervical length (74).
874
The value of prophylactic cerclage in prolonging highorder multiple gestation has not been assessed, but its use
in twin pregnancy has been studied in at least 2 prospective trials, including 50 and 74 sets of twins, respectively;
cerclage did not prolong gestation or improve perinatal
outcome in either study (85, 86). The studies of cerclage
in triplet pregnancies are all retrospective, making bias in
assignment of this therapy highly likely.
Routine Hospitalization
No trials of routine hospitalization of high-order multiple
gestations have been published. Four prospective randomized trials and one retrospective study have shown
that bed rest in the hospital does not prolong twin gestation (54, 8790). Retrospective series assessing the value
of elective hospitalization for triplet pregnancies also
have failed to identify any significant differences in perinatal outcome after hospitalization (91, 92).
Prophylactic Cerclage
Tocolytics
If effective tocolytic therapy were available, identifying
women at risk of preterm delivery could reduce the incidence of preterm birth. The use of prophylactic tocolysis
in twin gestations has been examined in at least 7
prospective studies (96102). These trials showed no
consistent effect on preterm birth, birth weight, or neonatal mortality. Importantly, the risks associated with each
tocolytic are amplified in multiple gestations. Betamimetics are associated with increased maternal and fetal
cardiac stress and gestational diabetes; these complications occur more frequently in multiple gestations even
without -mimetic therapy (103, 104). In addition,
women with multiple gestations are at increased risk of
developing pulmonary edema resulting in severe respiratory distress when tocolytic agents, steroids, and intravenous fluids are administered together (105, 106).
Corticosteroids
The effect of antenatal steroid administration and the
possible effects of steroid dose on efficacy in multiple
gestations have not been examined. Nevertheless, the
National Institutes of Health recommends that all
women in preterm labor who have no contraindications
to steroid use be given one course of steroids, regardless
of the number of fetuses (107).
Multiple gestations, especially high-order multiple gestations, are at increased risk of losing 1 or more fetuses
remote from delivery. One report described the outcome
of every twin, triplet, and higher order multiple gestation
delivered at one perinatal center during a 5-year period
(113). Of 310 twin and 45 triplet or higher pregnancies,
19 were complicated by the spontaneous demise of one
fetus, a loss rate of 6%. Six losses occurred in the first
trimester and 13 in the second or third trimester; an additional 9 pregnancies underwent fetal reduction, and one
of these pregnancies was miscarried afterward. The
causes of the first-trimester losses could not be determined, but the later losses were caused by twintwin
875
876
tain to high-order multiple gestations. Additionally, several issues have not been resolved. For example, it is not
known at what gestational age testing should be initiated, whether testing should be performed once or twice
per week, or whether there is a need to test normally
growing dichorionic twins. At present, antepartum fetal
surveillance in multiple gestations is recommended in all
situations in which surveillance would ordinarily be performed in a singleton pregnancy (eg, IUGR, maternal
disease, decreased fetal movement). Further studies are
needed to determine whether routine antepartum fetal
surveillance provides objective benefit in the absence of
other high-risk conditions.
transfusion syndrome (n = 4), severe IUGR (n = 3), placental insufficiency (n = 4), and placental abruption
(n = 1); the cause of 1 loss was unknown. Because highorder multiple gestations are significantly more likely to
sustain the complications causing fetal demise in this
study and others, the loss rates for high-order multiple
gestations may be considerably higher than 6%.
No fetal monitoring protocol has been shown to predict most of these losses. In addition, authorities disagree
about the preferred antepartum surveillance method and
management once a demise has occurred. Some investigators have advocated immediate delivery of the remaining fetuses (114). However, if the death is the result of an
abnormality of the fetus itself rather than maternal or
uteroplacental pathology, and the pregnancy is remote
from term, expectant management may be appropriate.
The most difficult cases are those in which the fetal
demise occurs in 1 fetus of a monochorionic twin pair.
Because virtually 100% of monochorionic placentas
contain vascular anastomoses that link the circulations of
the 2 fetuses, the surviving fetus is at significant risk of
sustaining damage caused by the sudden, severe, and
prolonged hypotension that occurs at the time of the
demise or by embolic phenomena that occurs later (115,
116). By the time the demise is discovered, the greatest
harm has most likely already been done, and there may
not be any benefit in immediate delivery, especially if the
surviving fetuses are very preterm and otherwise healthy.
In such cases, allowing the pregnancy to continue may
provide the most benefit.
Although maternal disseminated intravascular coagulopathy (DIC) remains a theoretical risk, it rarely
occurs. One series of 28 multiple gestations complicated
by the demise of one fetus remote from term included no
cases of DIC (113). Fibrinogen and fibrin degradation
product levels can be monitored serially until delivery,
and delivery can be expedited if DIC develops.
Rare Complications
Summary of
Recommendations
The following recommendations are based on limited or inconsistent scientific evidence (Level B):
877
The following recommendations are based primarily on consensus and expert opinion (Level C):
Women should be counseled about the risks of highorder multiple gestation before beginning ART.
13. Mauldin JG, Newman RB. Neurologic morbidity associated with multiple gestation. Female Pat 1998;23(4):
278, 30, 356, passim. (Level III)
Because the risks of invasive prenatal diagnosis procedures, such as amniocentesis and chorionic villus
sampling, are inversely proportional to the experience of the operator, only experienced clinicians
should perform these procedures in high-order multiple gestations.
5. Platt MJ, Marshall A, Pharoah PO. The effects of assisted reproduction on the trends and zygosity of multiple
births in England and Wales 197499. Twin Res
2001;4:41721. (Level II-2)
References
1. Martin JA, Hamilton BE, Sutton PD, Ventura SJ,
Menacker F, Munson ML. Births: final data for 2002.
Natl Vital Stat Rep 2003;52(10):1102. (Level II-3)
2. Jewell SE, Yip R. Increasing trends in plural births in
the United States. Obstet Gynecol 1995;85:22932.
(Level III)
3. Ho ML, Chen JY, Ling UP, Chen JH, Huang CM, Chang
CC, et al. Changing epidemiology of triplet pregnancy:
etiology and outcome over twelve years. Am J Perinatol
1996;13:26975. (Level III)
4. Westergaard T, Wohlfahrt J, Aaby P, Melbye M. Population based study of rates of multiple pregnancies in
Denmark, 198094. BMJ 1997;314:7759. (Level II-3)
878
37. van den Berg C, Braat AP, van Opstal D, Halley DJ,
Kleijer WJ, den Hollander NS, et al. Amniocentesis or
chorionic villus sampling in multiple gestations?
Experience with 500 cases. Prenat Diagn 1999;19:
23444. (Level II-2)
22. Haas JS, Berman S, Goldberg AB, Lee LW, Cook EF.
Prenatal hospitalization and compliance with guidelines
for prenatal care. Am J Public Health 1996;86:8159.
(Level II-2)
23. Luke B, Bigger HR, Leurgans S, Sietsema D. The cost of
prematurity: a case-control study of twins vs singletons.
Am J Public Health 1996;86:80914. (Level II-2)
24. Albrecht JL, Tomich PG. The maternal and neonatal outcome of triplet gestations. Am J Obstet Gynecol
1996;174:15516. (Level III)
25. Newman RB, Hamer C, Miller MC. Outpatient triplet
management: a contemporary review. Am J Obstet
Gynecol 1989;161:54753; discussion 5535. (Level III)
26. Gardner MO, Goldenberg RL, Cliver SP, Tucker JM,
Nelson KG, Copper RL. The origin and outcome of
preterm twin pregnancies. Obstet Gynecol 1995;85:
5537. (Level II-2)
27. Seoud MA, Toner JP, Kruithoff C, Muasher SJ. Outcome
of twin, triplet, and quadruplet in vitro fertilization pregnancies: the Norfolk experience. Fertil Steril 1992;57:
82534. (Level II-2)
28. Elliott JP, Radin TG. Quadruplet pregnancy: contemporary management and outcome. Obstet Gynecol 1992;80:
4214. (Level III)
29. Ettner SL, Christiansen CL, Callahan TL, Hall JE. How
low birthweight and gestational age contribute to
increased inpatient costs for multiple births. Inquiry
199798;34:32539. (Level II-2)
30. Contribution of assisted reproductive technology and
ovulation-inducing drugs to triplet and higher-order multiple birthsUnited States, 19801997. MMWR Morb
Mortal Wkly Rep 2000;49:5358. (Level II-3)
31. Wenstrom KD, Syrop CH, Hammitt DG, van Voorhis BJ.
Increased risk of monochorionic twinning associated
with assisted reproduction. Fertil Steril 1993;60:510 4.
(Level III)
879
880
881
105. Perry KG Jr, Morrison JC, Rust OA, Sullivan CA, Martin
RW, Naef RW 3rd. Incidence of adverse cardiopulmonary effects with low-dose continuous terbutaline
infusion. Am J Obstet Gynecol 1995;173:12737.
(Level II-3)
106. Katz M, Robertson PA, Creasy RK. Cardiovascular complications associated with terbutaline treatment for
preterm labor. Am J Obstet Gynecol 1981;139:6058.
(Level II-3)
107. Effect of corticosteroids for fetal maturation on perinatal outcomes. NIH Consens Statement 1994;12:124.
(Level III)
108. Feldman DM, Borgida AF, Trymbulak WP, Barsoom MJ,
Sanders MM, Rodis JF. Clinical implications of velamentous cord insertion in triplet gestations. Am J Obstet
Gynecol 2002;186:80911. (Level III)
109. Kaufman GE, Malone FD, Harvey-Wilkes KB, Chelmau
D, Penzias AS, DAlton MD. Neonatal morbidity and
mortality associated with triplet pregnancy. Obstet
Gynecol 1998;91:3428. (Level II-2)
110. Talbot GT, Goldstein RF, Nesbitt T, Johnson JL, Kay HH.
Is size discordancy an indication for delivery of preterm twins? Am J Obstet Gynecol 1997;177:10504.
(Level II-2)
111. Warner BB, Kiely JL, Donovan EF. Multiple births and
outcome. Clin Perinatal 2000;27:34761, ix. (Level III)
112. Hsieh TT, Chang TC, Chiu TH, Hsu JJ, Chao A. Growth
discordancy, birth weight and neonatal adverse events in
third trimester twin gestations. Gynecol Obstet Invest
1994;38:3640. (Level III)
113. Petersen IR, Nyholm HC. Multiple pregnancies with single intrauterine demise. Description of twenty-eight
pregnancies. Acta Obstet Gynecol Scand 1999;78:2026.
(Level III)
114. DAlton ME, Newton ER, Cetrulo CL. Intrauterine fetal
demise in multiple gestation. Acta Genet Med Gemellol
(Roma) 1984;33:439. (Level III)
115. Robertson EG, Neer KJ. Placental injection studies in
twin gestation. Am J Obstet Gynecol 1983;147:1704.
(Level III)
116. Langer B, Boudier E, Gasser B, Christmann D, Messer J,
Schlaeder G. Antenatal diagnosis of brain damage in the
survivor after the second trimester death of a monochorionic monoamniotic co-twin: case report and literature
review. Fetal Diagn Ther 1997;12:28691. (Level III)
117. Sairam S, Costeloe K, Thilaganathan B. Prospective risk
of stillbirth in multiple-gestation pregnancies: a population-based analysis. Obstet Gynecol 2002;100:63841.
(Level III)
132. Fusi L, Gordon H. Twin pregnancy complicated by single intrauterine death. Problems and outcome with conservative management. Br J Obstet Gynaecol 1990;
97:5116. (Level III)
882
883