Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Chris Liljenstolpe
CTO, IP Division, Alcatel APAC
Agenda
Page 2
Introduction
Carrier-grade Ethernet
Triple-play Service Delivery
Converge with Multi Service Edge
Conclusion
IP Transformation A Definition
Page 3
What?
Service providers evolve their people, process and technology to leverage
a single, converged network on IP.
Why?
Enable greater efficiencies, lower costs, and create new revenue streams
from profitable IP-based services.
How?
Network IP transformation
Multi-purpose converged IP infrastructure
Service IP Transformation
Connectivity-centric to service-centric
Organization IP Transformation
Internal changes in sync with network IP transformation
External partnerships for service IP transformation
Operator Challenge
Page 4
Triple
Triple Play
Play
Business
Business
VPN
VPN
Network
Network
Convergence
Convergence
2G
2G to
to 3G
3G
Evolution
Evolution
Agenda
Page 5
Introduction
Carrier Ethernet
Triple-play Service Delivery
Converge with Multi Service Edge
Conclusion
Ethernet as Access
Page 6
From a carriers point of view, Ethernet is not yet ready for the primetime
Alcatel IP Day, Hanoi, July 18, 2006
MPLS-based Ethernet
Page 8
Equipment vendors patch their products to introduce MPLSbased Ethernet service to achieve:
Better QoS based on MPLS forwarding classes
Expanded service portfolio (Layer 2 and Layer 3 VPNs)
Better scalability VLAN IDs should have only local significance
Better network resiliency MPLS Fast Reroute (FRR)
Better OAM capabilities LSP ping and traceroute
Better accounting connection-oriented packet counting
Alcatel
Cisco
Juniper
7750 SR-7
7750 SR-12
7450 ESS-1
7450 ESS-7
MTU/CLE for
Business Services
7250
SAS
2G
5G
10G
20 G
50 G
100 G
200 G
400 G
Capacity
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
VPLS
PE B
PE B
ATM Service
PE C
PE C
B
IP/MPLS
Network
PE A
Ethernet
Service
PE D
RR
Virtual Bridge
PE B
PE A
IP/MPLS
Network
PE D
Layer 3 IP-VPN
RFC-2547bis Routed Multipoint
RR
B
B
PE A
FR Service
RR
VPLS Service
B B
VPLS Service
draft-ietf-l2vpn-vpls-ldp-05.txt
PE C
VPRN
SERVICE 1
VPRN
SERVICE 1
IP/MPLS Network
RR
RR
PE D
RR
VRF
Characteristic
Martini
Tunnels
IP-VPN
(RFC-2547bis)
VPLS
End-User Protocol
Multiprotocol
IP only
Multiprotocol
Service Topology
Point-to-point
Switched service
Multipoint
Routed service
Multipoint
Bridged service
Customer:
End user controls
routing/security
Provider:
IP address coordination
needed
Customer:
End user controls
routing/security
Clean demarcation:
Customer routes/
Provider switches
Clean demarcation:
Customer routes/ Provider
switches
Low
High
Low
Routing Management
Network Demarcation
Scalability
Troubleshooting
Complexity
Conventional Bridged
Services
VPLS
Services
Scalability
Restricted to 4K VLANs
Reliability
QoS
No end-to-end QoS
Service
Activation
OA&M
Limited standardization
Complex management based on vendor
implementation
Leadership in Standardization
Active contributor to IETF, Metro Ethernet Forum and MPLS FR Alliance.
Chairman of Layer 2 VPN working group at IETF.
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
Service Variables
Port charges
Bandwidth
VC charges
Flat rate or Usage based
Distance fees yes or no
QoS premiums / granularity
Access Inclusions
Access included or not / granularity of bandwidth
CPE included or not
Access diversity included or not
Subscriber Isolation - prevents one user from taking too much shared
bandwidth
Bandwidth Efficiency - controls bursts to optimize use of buffers downstream
resulting in lower loss and better quality services
User differentiation - enforces each subscribers unique policy
Liquid Bandwidth fluidly sharing the bandwidth among applications
Network control VPN
NGN/Mobile transport VPN
Port
Business VPN A
Business VPN B
Sub 1
Sub n
Voice
Bank
of
Asia
Video
ERP
Internet
..
.
..
.
PIR=4Mb/s
CIR=4Mb/s
SAP
PIR=max
CIR=128kbps
Multicast
Broadcast
Unknown
PIR=max
CIR=0
PIR=0.3M
CIR=0
PIR=0.3M
CIR=0
Overall
BW = 8 Mb/s
PIR=2Mb/s
CIR=2Mb/s
PIR=0.3M
CIR=0
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
Milliseconds
00:00:00:0X
TO
RE
PA
I
M
EA
N
TI
M
Internet Access
Beginning
1. Protocol Reconvergence
Standard operation of routing networks. Route around the failed node.
00:0X:XX:XX Minutes
Alcatel IP products are the only ones in the industry to support NSR & NSS
Alcatel IP Day, Hanoi, July 18, 2006
Alcatel:
Non-Stop Routing & Services
No effect to the network
Alcatel
7750 SR with
Non-Stop Routing
Graceful Restart:
Whole network participation
Other
Vendor
RIB
RIB
RIB
Other Vendor
Alcatel 7750 SR with GR Helper
Newly inactive control plane
7750 SR
with GR Helper
Page 23
Fast Convergence
1M routes, 100 seconds
T640
2 orders of magnitude
10 times more routes
1 tenth the time
No bump in CPU load at
neighbor routers
DIRECT COMPARISON
Slow Convergence
150K routes, 950 seconds
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
Interface Tests
Tunnel Tests
Service Tests
VPLS Service
VPLS Service
VLL
VLL
IP-VPN
Edge
Core
Network
IP-VPN
Edge
Service
Mirroring
OAM Category
OAM Feature
Traditional
Routers/Ethernet
Switches
Alcatel 7750 SR
CALEA
Yes
Service MTU
Yes
MAC Ping
Yes
MAC Trace
Yes
MAC Populate
Yes
VPRN Ping
Yes
VPRN Trace
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
SDP Ping
Yes
LSP Traceroute
Yes
LSP Ping
Yes
Service Tests
Tunnel Tests
Router/Interface Tests
ICMP Ping
Yes
Yes
ICMP Traceroute
Yes
Yes
Innovative
and Profitable
Services
Personalized &
Interactive
User experience
Account usage
SUBSCRIBER
AND USAGE
CONTROL
Self-service
Portals
Service driven
QoS
Try-and-buy
weekend specials
Subscriber
Admission Control
Distributed
Policy
Enforcement
SERVICE
AND REVENUE
CONTROL
Prevent abuse
Subscriber
Service
Controller
NETWORK
INFRASTRUCTURE
CONTROL
Control usage
On-demand
Services
Flow-through
OSS integration
Centralized
Policy
Management
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
Service
Continuity
Simultaneously
support existing and
emerging services
Scalability across
multiple dimensions
Seamless migration to
emerging services with
Ethernet - FR - ATM
network and service
interworking
Service
Richness
Service-aware QoS to
meet demanding SLAs
H-QoS to deliver tiered
service bundles
Service-aware
accounting and billing for
innovative service models
Full suite of legacy and
emerging Layer 2 and
Layer 3 VPNs
Service
Assurance
Non-stop services
and non-stop routing
Service-aware OA&M
diagnostic tools
Policy-based Layer 2
and Layer 3
provisioning tools
Pre-integrated OSS
partners
Access
Metro
Service Edge
7250 SAS
Internet
VPLS
Ethernet Access
7450 ESS
VLL
7250 SAS
VLAN/SVLAN
7450 ESS
T5C-L3
7450 ESS
xDSL
DSLAM
FTTU
7750 Service
Router
MPLS
Switching
Business Services
Ethernet L2 VPNs
VLL (E-Line)
VPLS & H-VPLS (E-LAN)
Service Aware Ethernet
aggregation
DSLAM and E/GPON
aggregation
7750 Service
Router
7750 Service
Router
IP/MPLS Core
Service Network
Layer 3 Services
IP-VPNs (RFC-2547bis)
Internet Peering (BGP)
Service Router edge
FR/ATM Interworking
Agenda
Page 32
Introduction
Carrier Ethernet
Triple-play Service Delivery
Converge with Multi Service Edge
Conclusion
Always-on
Service Availability
Mass
Revenue
Millions of subs
Broadband access
Wire/wireless
multi-access
~100% uptake
Triple Play
Service
Delivery
Customization
Partnerships
Mass
Dynamics
ISAM Family
BSA
7450 ESS
Broadcast
Video
7750 SR
Video On
Demand
VPLS
Routed
Home
Gateway
BSAN
BSA
BSR
Internet
DHCP
Server
BSA
PSTN
Softswitch
Voice Gateway
High Availability
Per-path, per-link, per-node HA,
Policy scaling
Scale security, anti-spoofing,
Connectivity Model
Page 35
Access
Node
Modem
..
.
BSA
BSR
IP: 10.20.192/20
MAC: A
BTV
IGMP
Snoop
IGMP
Proxy
..
.
IP: 192.168.0/20
MAC: B
IP: 138.120.0/20
MAC: C
IP address
assigned per
service
All services on
untagged last
mile
L2 termination and IP
routing point. Upstream
and downstream forwarding
by IP routing. DHCP proxy
point. Separate service
interface for different
services. Programmed MAC
per service interface
simplifies service splitting at
BSA. Supports one edge or
multiple edge devices.
GE
VLAN
Per
Sub
Per-service priority/delay/loss
Content Differentiation in HSI
VoIP VLAN
VoIP
Video
HSI
BSR
Video VLAN
GOLD
Access Node
GE
BSA
BRONZE
ONON-NET
HSI
VLAN
Internet
Service
Preferred content
marked (DSCP) at
trusted ingress points
of IP network .
GE
VLAN
Per
Sub
Per-service priority/delay/loss
Content Differentiation in HSI
Realtime
VoIP VLAN
HSI
Video VLAN
GOLD
BSA
Access Node
HSI: Per-subscriber
queueing, with PIR/CIR
policing/shaping.
VoIP/Video: shared queueing
for prioritization of real-time
traffic over HSI. Upstream
Video traffic is neglible
Per-subscriber
QoS/Content
classification for
content differentiation
BRONZE
ONON-NET
HSI
VLAN
GE
IP
BSR
RG
Access Node
Add Option82
Circuit ID
Remote ID
BSA
BSR
5750 SSC
Provision the
Subscriber
Mangement
Install Subscriber
Allows DHCP
Allow authenticated users
Deny un-authenticated users
DHCP server
Check Authentication
CheckCircuit ID
Check Remote ID
(Subscr ID, Appl ID)
Allocate IP
address
IP address
assigned
Residential
Gateway
BASIC AUTHENTICATION
BTV
AN
7750 SR
7450 ESS
73xx
VPLS
BSA
1. DHCP Proxy
BSR
DHCP snooping
DHCP relay
Security:
Against Peer-to-peer, Theft of Service and DoS
Page 39
DHCP/AAA
Servers
Access
Node
Aggregation
Home
Gateway
VPLS
IP
BSR
BSA
802.1X port authentication (optional)
RG
Antispoof
Block User-user
DHCP ACK
(UserIP/MAC)
ARP Reply
ARP
Cache
Data
Per-customer filters
1000s of filters, filtering at wire-speed!
Per-customer service mirroring
All rights reserved 2006, Alcatel
Access
Node
Home
Gateway
BTV
..
.
BSA
DHCP
Snoop
QoS
Per-subscriber, per-service queuing and
scheduling
Wirespeed classification and marking
Security
Wirespeed filtering with auto-configuration of
antispoofing
Prevention of unauthorized user-to-user
bridging
BSA acts as trusted host for BSR ARP requests
(ARP reply agent)
BSA validates customer ARP requests to prevent
theft of service at BSR
BTV
IP: 10.21.0/20
MAC: A
IP: PUB.1.0/20
MAC: B
PPPoE
RADIUS
Server
BSR
DHCP
Relay
VPLS
IP
IP: PUB.2.0/20
MAC: C
DHCP
Server
PPPoE
BRAS
Accounting
Per-service, per-subscriber traffic counters and
records
DHCP
Relay and Snooping
Scalable and reliable traffic aggregation towards
multiple edges
Ethertype based tunnel selection
VPLS based aggregation
Multicast
IGMP proxy in BSA; PIM-SM/SSM, IGMP v2/v3 in
BSR
Reliable aggregation
Non-Stop Routing and Services
Persistency of DHCP session state
All rights reserved 2006, Alcatel
Applications
Integrated IP Television, ultra-high-speed,
user centric broadband services, IP voice
and wireless bundles
Agenda
Page 42
Introduction
Carrier Ethernet
Triple-play Service Delivery
Converge with Multi Service Edge
Conclusion
Internet
Leased lines
Mostly narrowband
High OPEX due to
management
Perceived as old
IP/MPLS
ATM
FR
Multi
Access
Ethernet VPNs
Poor scalability
Poor QoS
High OPEX due to VLAN
ID management
Perceived as cheap and
un-realiable
IP/VPN
Edge
Router
DSL
Access
Metro
Ethernet
Ethernet
Access
PNT
G-MIS
PNT
AR
AR
The Internet
MI
S
LSR
LSR
LSR
USUS-IPFR
EVPN3
MGX
IP
MGX
IP
Subnet 3
BPX
MGX
ATM
MGX
ATM
LSR
OpenNet
LSR
Common
Back Bone (CBB)
BPX
AR
AR
Legacy
OpenNet
AR
LSR
Global
Network
PER
G-EVPN3
G-FR/ATM
BT-RoW
G-IPFR
High Speed
Packet
Services
C500
C550
G-IA
PER
MGX
IP/AT
M
MGX
IP/AT
M
The Internet
BR
BPX
E2EE2E-FR
BPX
USFR/ATM
E2EE2E-ATM
C500
Americas
Frame
Network
C9000
CBB-bas
rvic eess
CBB-baseedd sseervic
HS
HSPS-bas
PS-baseedd sseervic
rviceess
AFN/GFN
AFN/GFN sservic
e rviceess
C500
C9000
Global
Frame
Network
C9000
Fast
PER PathPER
C9000
G-EVPN2
USUSMDNS
G-MDNS
Scalable services:
ATM/FR access to Internet
routing
ATM/FR access to IP/VPN
Continuation of legacy
ATM/FR services using single
IP/MPLS core
New services:
ATM
ATM/Ethernet/FR any-to-any
FR
Layer 2 inter-working
VPLS
ATM/FR access to VPLS
Multi
ATM, FR pseudo-wires over Access
MPLS
New Capabilities:
Terminating VPLS/VLL for
Internet routing
Terminating VPLS/VLL for
IP/VPN
Non-stop routing
Non-stop services
IP/VPN
MSE
DSL
Access
Metro
Ethernet
Ethernet
Access
Universal access to new VPN services demands new functionalities at the Edge
Alcatel IP Day, Hanoi, July 18, 2006
NMS
IDC
TG SoftSwitch BTV
VOD
MSC/MGW
Internet
RNC
IP/MPLS
IP-based MSE
IP/VPN
SGSN
ATM
FR
Metro
Ethernet
MSE
Multi
Access
Wireless
Access
Ethernet
Access
Primary Drivers
Minimise the cost/risk associated with rolling out new
services: avoid building a new network for each new
service
Generate new revenues from new wide area Ethernet
services (VLL/VPLS) and 2547 IP-VPN
Extend reach of existing Ethernet/FR/ATM services out-ofregion sites
Part of a wider IP convergence strategy - next generation
mobile backhaul and residential 3-play
Reduce CAPEX and OPEX
Alcatel IP Day, Hanoi, July 18, 2006
MSE Summary
Page 48
Agenda
Page 49
Introduction
Carrier Ethernet
Triple-play Service Delivery
Converge with Multi Service Edge
Conclusion
Conclusion
Network IP Transformation trends:
Triple Play
Business VPN
Convergence
Mobile IP Transformation
Page 50
Page 51
www.alcatel.com
Alcatel IP Day, Hanoi, July 18, 2006