Professional Documents
Culture Documents
September,
I957
of BIOLOGY
QUANTITATIVE LAWS IN METABOLISM AND GROWTH
BYLUDWIGVON BERTALANFFY
Los Angeles
Mt. Sinai Hospital,and University
BiologicalResearch,
ofSouthern
California,
INTRODUCTION
aimed at establishingconnectionsbeaspectsofliving
tweentwofundamental
and growth.
their
metabolism
organisms,
What we call growthof even a simple
complexphenomenon
organismis a tremendously
fromthe biochemical,physiological,cytological,
viewpoints.Thereare,however,
and morphological
certainaspects that are amenableto quantitative
analysis,and such an approach appears to lead
to some insight into the connectionsbetween
metabolismand growth,and to some answer to
the seeminglytrivial,but in fact hardlyexplored
question, "Why does an organismgrow at all,
and why, after a certain time, does its growth
come to a stop?"
QUANTITATIVE RELATIONS BETWEEN BODY
SIZE AND METABOLIC RATE
it may be
In orderto begin this investigation,
emphasizedthat,in manyphysiologicalactivities,
the absolutesize of the body is a mostimportant
the rate of processes.Whether
factordetermining
we take total metabolism,heart or respiratory
rate, the chemicalcompositionof the organism,
excretion,or the enzymecontentof the cells-we
vary
always will findthat theycharacteristically
with body size, this being true even thoughthe
the organismscomparedin such respectsshow a
tremendous
diversityin theiranatomy,physiological mechanisms,adaptations to certainenvironments,and so forth(cf. Adolph, 1949). To give
217
218
1000
~~~~80O
IL
ctS0O
OVS~~~~~~~MQMTO-'
P
co
DD
ED6Eh'0G
4W"
!50Q ioOs
RABBIT
-A
SS
-~~~~~~~~~~~~~_T
EUOSELjEP
509
gI
kg SW
I
tk!g
50k(s l0kg
200O kg
500kq
IOQOV9
BODY WEIGHT
FIG. 1. ALLomETRic DZEPENDENCE OF PULS5E FEREQuENcY ONBODY WEIGHTIN MAMMLS
It
rate,
pulse
basal
may be assumed that the volume of blood transported per minute is proportional to the basal metabolic
as the oxygen consumed must be transported by the blood. This volume is equal to stroke volume (S) X
frequency (F). In a rough first approximation, S may be taken as proportional to body weight (W). The
metabolic rate follows interspecifically, in the series of mammals, the W! rule. Hence:
3.1
6.5
11.0
17.7
19.2
23.7
30.4
Cal.per
production
Cal.m.
production
per
kg.
sq.
bodysurface
85.8
61.2
57.3
45.3
44.6
40.2
34.8
1909
1073
1191
1047
1141
1082
984
(1)
219
TABLE 2
CO2production
pallasii
ofArmadillidium
(Temperature
21?C.)
AfterMUller (1943b).
15 33 50 100 160
Weightin mg.
3.0 5.2 7.2 11.2 15.2
Cmm.C02/hr.
200 174 144 112 94
Perg./hr.
Perunitsurface
(WI)/ 48.5 54.2 53.0 49.8 51.6
hr.
220
30-3558-6290-100140 190-200
2.3
3.9
5.4
69 65 56
Perg./hr.
Per unit surface 22.9 25.1 26.1
(WI)/hr.
7.3
9.5
52
48
27.0 28.2
OF METABOLISM
TABLE 5
Relationbetween
metabolicrateand bodysize
Species
PLATYHELMINTHES
Dugesia gonocephala
NEMATHELMINTHES
Ascaris lumbricoides
ANNELIDA
Lumbricussp.
Eisenia foetida
MOLLUSCA
Lamellibranchiata
Anodontacygnaea
Dreissensiapolymorpha
Prosobranchia
Lithoglyphus,Paludina fasciata and
P. vivipara
Pulmonata
Lymnaeastagnalis
Lymnaeastagnalis
Lymnaeaacuricularia
Planorbissp.
Planorbiscorneus
Planorbiscorneus
Isidora proteus
Pulmonata and Operculata,15 species
intra-andinterspecific
Helicidae
Helix, Chilotrema,and Cepaea (interspecific)
Cepaea vindobonensis
CRUSTACEA
Branchiopoda
Daphnia pulex
Artemiasalina
Isopoda
Asellus aquaticus
Asellus aquaticus
Armadillidiumpallasi
Porcellioscaber
Oniscusasellus
Ligia oceanica
Decapoda
Astacus astacus
Potamobiustorrentiuin
Pugettiaproducta
Homarusvulgaris
INSECTA
Hemimetabola
Dixippus morosus
Holometabola
Various species,intra-and interspecific
Tenebriomolitor
PISCES
Lebistesreticulatus
Various species (Scorpaena,Abramis,
Cyprinus,etc.)
REPTILIA
Lacerta
Reference
to
Respirationproportional
W2'8(surface),W (weight)
or intermediate
Intermediate
Kruger,1940
Surface
Muller, 1943b
Kruger,1952
Weight
Surface?
Weinland,1919
Ludwig and Krywienczyk,1950
Surface
Surface
Krywienczyk,1952a
Surface
Intermediate
Intermediate
Weight?
Intermediate
Intermediate
Intermediate
Intermediate
Surface (high tenperature[30?C.]?)
Liebsch, 1929
Weight
Weight
1948
Jan6aroik,
and Krywienczyk,1953
Bertalanffy
Surface
Surface
Muller, 1943b
Will, 1952
Muller, 1943b
Will, 1952
Will, 1952
Ellenby, 1951
Surface
Surface
Surface
Intermediate
Surface
Probably surface
Kalmus, 1930
Wolsky,1934
Weymouthet al., 1944
Thomas, 1954
Surface?
Weight?
Intermediate
Surface
Muller, 1943a
Weight
Kittel, 1941
Weight
Weight
Surface
Surface
Kramer,1934
Surface
221
222
QUANTITATIVE
LAWS IN METABOLISM
AND GROWTH
223
15
7.~~~~~~~~~~~~~~z
6 t--Y?US
4
31
1o
20
30
40
50
60
eo
MO
l_
no
300
400
BODY WEi6rT IN G.
FIG. 2. TIssuE RESPIRATIONor VARious ORGANSOF TIE WHITE RAT IN RELATIONTO BODY WEIGHT
Qo2 =
.dl02/mg.drywt./hr.
Only regressionlines are shown; for individual data and statisticalevaluation cf. the originalpaper. After
and Pirozynski(1953).
Bertalanffy
224
QUANTITATIVE
LAWS IN METABOLISM
AND GROWTH
225
200
__
_
curves with the followingmain characteristics.
First, growthrates are decreasingand growth
eventuallyattains a steady state. Secondly,the
a)
-0
curves for weightgrowthand linear growthare
4o 0~
The curve of weight
characteristically
different.
growthis sigmoid,with a point of inflexionat
- ---40 ---about one-thirdof the finalweight.The curveof
-e00
30
lineargrowthis a decayingexponentialwithouta
- 20
60 80 100
200 300 500 800
30 40
turningpoint. This is what we actually find
Weight In mg.
experimentally.
This is themostcommonformofgrowthcurves,
foundin fish,in a numberof invertebrateclasses
and also, with certainrestrictions,
in mammals.
160
40
-The validityof these growthequations has been
shown in many examples (Putter, 1920; Berta_
140
5
3
lanffy,1934, 1951a), and theyhave been adopted
120
6-30
in applied biology.
It appears that the "Bertalanffy
growthequaE
E
00
b) 125----_It
tion" is widelyappliedin international
fisheries.
has been foundto fitthe commercially
exploited
fishspeciesstudiedby the FisheriesLaboratoryof
80
4~~~~the Ministryof Agriculture,
Fisheriesand Food at
-0
?' 2 I 0
Lowestoft(England), withthe possible exception
ofthehake (Wimpenny,
pers.commun.).A comprehensivetheoreticalmodel of the dynamicsof exploitedfishpopulationshas beendeveloped,where-0
0
in growthof the speciesconcernedis represented
12
10
6
0
4
2
8
by equation 7 (Beverton, 1954; Beverton and
Time in weeks
Holt, 1957). Discussionof this populationmodel FIG. 3. IHE FIRST METABOLIC AND GROWTH TYPE
(which,apartfromfisheries,
maywellbe adaptable
curves(b) in the
Metabolicrate (a) and growtlh
to otherpopulations)is beyondthe scope of the
Growthcurvesfor,d:
Guppy(Lebistesreticutatus).
presentreview.It shouldbe mentioned,however,
lengthgrowth;- - - - weightgrowth;calculated
to equation(7). AfterBertalanffy
and Millthat examinationof the variousgrowthfunctions according
proposed led to the conclusionthat "von Ber- ler (1943).
talanify'sgrowthequationis the mostsatisfactory
ofanythathave hithertobeen developed"(Bever- weightis continuallyshiftedin disfavorof the
ton and Holt, l.c.). Ampledata as well as descrip- surface.Consequently,so long as the animal is
tionof mathematicalanalysiscan be foundin this small, surface-proportional
anabolism prevails
work.
over weight-proportional
catabolism, and the
A relationsimilarto that stated by Bertalanffy animal grows.The largerit grows,the more the
et al. for the surfacedependenceof respiration surplus remaining for growth decreases, and
was found by Yoshida (1956) in food intake. eventuallya steady state will be reached where
The quantityofplanktonconsumedby thesardine anabolism and catabolism balance each other,
is proportionalto the square of body length,and and growthcomesto an end.
the same appears to be true for assimilating Now we come to the second type. We have
and the gut.
organs,such as the gill-rakers
said that in certain animals, for example, in
This characteristiccourse of growthis easily insects, respirationdoes not follow the surface
understood.If a body,withnot too muchchange rule but ratheris proportionalto weightitself.
of shape, increasesin size, its surfacesincrease Let us see whathappensin thiscase (Fig. 4). The
approximatelywith the second power of the log-logplot of metabolicrate againstbody weight
length,but its volume and mass with the third will give a line witha slope of 45?. On the other
power. Hence, the ratio between surface and hand, we have to insert1 for the exponentm in
C',j
--
226
a)~~
0-0
-j
-A
10
5--20
60 80 100
30 40
WeightIn mg.
(Tenebrio)
200 300
1:
.43
>
-?-
20
b)
2--f
a)
0 8jII7
6
30 40
20
40
60
80
60 80 100
200 300
Weight in mg.
500 700
Timqe in hours
(Drosophila)
METABOLICAND GROWnTYasPE
FIG. 4. THE SECOND
E8
'-
--V4
{>
QUANTITATIVE
LAWS IN METABOLISM
AND GROWTH
227
TABLE 6
Metabolictypesand growth
types
Metabolictype
Growthtype
Examples
228
curveis different
fromall others.Since our growth
formulas
to a large number of species,
apply
1000 _
the shapes of theirgrowthcurves are the same,
800 _
and the same curve can be used to representthe
600
growthof various species, simplyby takingdifE 400
Wt1nYmuS
*th
r g.
ferentscales fortimeand body size. Fig. 8 shows
the growthcurves of a fish and a mouse. The
latter, similar to that of the rat, also shows a
300
growthcycle in detailedanalysis,whichdoes not
CP 100
much alter the picture.If, however,the growth
curve of man is entered,it appears to be unique.
8e0
ib.
verQor2 n0
The second part of the curve, beginningwith
is
t
fn
5
50
puberty,
follows the general pattern. The first
4
40
In infancyand
part, however,is very different.
I
I I
11II
1II1II1
30
400~
10 15 20 30 40 60
100
200
childhood,the curve is enormouslyprotracted.
Body weighti'n g.
A new growthcycle is added, as it were,to the
or RELATivE GRowTHI
typicalpatternof growth.Althoughthis change
FIG. 6. DISCONTINUITIES
IN THlE ALBiNo RAT
is heraldedin thegrowthcyclesoflowermammals,
!FAIIdiscontinuities
appearat a bodyweightof ap- onlyin man does it lead to a singularshape of the
100g.,i.e.,beforepuberty.
A correspond-growthcurve.This growthcurveofman,abnormal
proximately
of theentire
is foundin thegrowth
ingdiscontinuity
animal(see Fig. 7). Onlyregression
linesareshownin as it were,is of courseconnectedwithchangesin
data and statisticalanalysisare the hormonalbalance. This is demonstratedby
individual
thefigure;
and pathological cases, such as pubertaspraecox in
givenin the originalpapers.AfterBertalanffy
Piozynski(1952,1953)and Racine(1953).
pituitarydysfunction,
when pubertytakes place
an
at
in othermammalsand
early
age,
as
it
does
number of physiologicalcharacteristics,at the
in
still
apes.
The
singular
growth
curveofman is a
same age and body size: in the allometricgrowth
of the liver, the involutionof the thymus,the quantitative expression of the retardation of
ofliverand thymus,
and certainly human developmentwhich, according to Bolk
tissuerespiration
(1926), is one of the basic factorsin the evolution
thereare others(Fig. 6). There is small wonder
of
man. At the same time, it is an important
that these breaks and shiftsare found,as the
factor
forhis uniquenessin nature.Animalsrun
cominginto play of the sex hormonesentails a
theirdevelopmentalperiodspeedily,and
through
deep-reachingchange in the entire metabolic
pattern.
_
_
_
__ ___300
300
On the other hand, the growthcurve of the
rat was analyzed long before the physiological E
__E
studiesjust mentioned(Bertalanify,1938, 1951a; c200
-200
_
_
_ _- _
a discussionof recentliteratureon rat growthis
given in Bertalanffy,1957). The result was
foundthat the growthof the rat followsthe first
too
R100
_______
growthtype, with a characteristicchange,however,in the values of the constants,again at the
criticalpoint of around 100 g. body weight.If
these growthcycles are taken into account, an
200
300
400
0
100
Time in days
excellentfit of the empiricalgrowthcurves by
FIG. 7. GROWTH OF THE ALBINO RAT
meansof our formulascan be obtained(Fig. 7).
So it wouldappear thatmammalsbelongto the
Donaldson'sdata (d1). Length growth
calculated according to equafirsttype, with the qualification,however,that weight growth----,
(7). The calculation
showstwogrowth
cycles,with
two growth cycles must be distinguished,the ation
breakat approximately
100g. bodyweight.
Donaldtransitionfromthefirstto thesecondcycletaking son'sdataaretodaynotconsidered
tobe optimal,
since
dietshave increasedthegrowth
in
place at the timeof sexual maturation.This is to modernlaboratory
the rat.The figure
shows,however,
the excellentnube consideredno morethan a firstapproximation. mericalfitthat
can be obtainedwiththe theoretical
However,thereis one organismwhose growth formulas.
AfterBertalanffy
(1941b).
1500
\P
QUANTITATIVE
LAWS IN METABOLISM
80~~~~~~~~~~
-
-______
3: (;0
_
_
40
20
20
o0
Mouse x
lo
years
lO weeks
Abramis bramao
5
~~0
0
5
~~
0-
7V
o0
37
SUMMARY
Man*
<
40
z-
________x
229
and the
searchCouncil,theNationalCancerInstitute,
ResearchCouncilof Canada.A surveyof
Humanities
the problemof animalgrowthin generalis givenin
1951a,and 1957.
Bertalanffy,
100
_80
AND GROWTH
_____
years______
Time in days
FIG.8. CO1PARISON
O0FTHE GROWTH CURVES
OF A FISH,MOUSE,AND MAN
AfterBertalanffy
(1951a).
soon they reach puberty and the adult stage.
Man, on the otherhand,is givena longperiodof
youth,and is thusenabled to learnand to collect
experience.Thus the characteristic
humangrowth
curve is a prerequisitefor that mental development and civilizationwhich so sharply distinguishesman fromall otherbeings.
ACKNOWLEDGMENT
Thisessayis baseduponworkcarriedthrough
in the
author'slaboratories
at theUniversity
ofViennaand
theUniversity
ofOttawa(Canada).Partofthiswork
was aided by researchgrantsfromthe NationalRe-
between
connections
Workaimedat establishing
metabolismand growthis reviewed.In thevarious
animal classes, three "metabolic types," i.e.,
formsof dependenceof metabolicrate on body
size can be distinguished:proportionalityof
metabolicrate to surfacearea, or to weight,or
one intermediatebetween surface and weight
proportionality.The various theoriesregarding
the size dependenceof metabolismare discussed,
with particularconsiderationof the relation of
to
tissue respirationto body size. Corresponding
the "metabolic types" mentioned, there are
growth
by different
"growthtypes" distinguished
curvesof the speciesconcerned.A generaltheory
ofanimalgrowth,advancedby theauthor,permits
explanationof the connectionbetweenmetabolic
typesand growthtypes.The theoryis illustrated
by examplestaken frominvertebrateand vertebrate classes. Mammalian and human growth,
whilegenerallyfollowingthe "firstgrowthtype,"
show breaksin the growthcurve connectedwith
puberty.The data and conceptspresentedherald
a new chapter of physiology,the comparative
physiologyofgrowth.
LIST OF LITERATURE
E. F. 1949. Quantitative relationsin the
physiologicalconstitutionsof mammals. Science,
109: 579-585.
1953. The
BERTALANFFY, F. D., and C. P. LEBLOND.
continuousrenewal of the two types of alveolar
cells in the lung of the rat. Anat. Rec., 115: 515541.
uber
BERTALANEBY, L. VON. 1934. Untersuchungen
die Gesetzlichkeitdes Wachstums. I. Allgemeine
Grundlagen der Theorie: Mathematische und
physiologische
Gesetzlichkeiten
des Wachstumsbei
Wassertieren. Arch. EntwickMech. Org., 131:
613-653.
-.
1938. Untersuchungen
uber die Gesetzlichkeit
des Wachstums. II. A quantitative theory of
organicgrowth. Hum. Biol., 10: 181-213.
tiberdie Gesetzlichkeit
. 1940. Untersuchungen
des Wachstums. III. QuantitativeBeziehungen
zwischen Darmoberflacheund KBrpergrossebei
Planaria maculata. Arch. EntwickMeck. Org.,
140: 81-89.
ADOLPH,
. 1941a. Untersuchungenuber die Gesetzlichkeit des Wachstums. IV. Probleme einer dynamischenMorphologie. Biol. gen., 15: 1-22.
. 1941b. Untersuchungeniiber die Gesetzlichkeit des Wachstums. VII. Stoffwechseltypen
und Wachstumstypen. Biol. Zbl., 61: 510-532.
uber die Gesetzlichkeit
. 1942. Untersuchungen
des Wachstums. V. Wachstumsgradientenund
metabolische Gradienten bei Planarien. Biol.
Gen., 15: 295-311.
. 1942, 1951a. TheoretischeBiologie. Bd. IL
Stoffwechsel,Wachstum. 1. Aufl. Borntraeger,
Berlin. 2. Aufl. Francke,Bern.
. 1948. Das organische Wachstum und seine
Gesetzmassigkeiten. Experientia, 4: 255-269.
. 1949. Problems of organic growth. Nature,
Lond., 163: 156-158.
. 1951b. Metabolic types and growth types.
Amer.Nat., 85: 111-117.
. 1953. Biophysikdes Fliessgleichgewiclsts.Ubers.von W. H. Westphal. Vieweg,Braunschweig.
230
BERTALANFFY, L.
VON. 1957. Wackstum. Kuiken- ELLENBY,C. 1951. Body size in relationto oxygen
thal's Handbuch der Zoologie. Vol. VIII 4 (6).
consumptionand pleopod beat in Ligia oceanicaL.
de Gruyter,Berlin.
J. exp. Biol. 28: 492-507.
, and R. R. ESTWICK. 1953. Tissue respiration
of FRIED, G. H., and S. R. TIPTON. 1953. Comparison
musculaturein relation to body size. Amer. J.
of respiratory
enzymelevels in tissuesof mammals
Physiol.,173: 58-60.
of different
sizes. Proc. Soc. exp. Biol., 82: 531532.
. 1954. Tissue respirationin experimentaland
congenitalpituitarydeficiency. Amer.J. Physiol., FRSSER, H., and F. KRUGER. 1951. Vergleichende
177: 16-18.
Versuche zur Atmungsphysiologie
von Planorbis
,
0. HOFFMANN-OSTENIOF, and 0. SCIRvEIER.
corneusund Limnaea stagnalis (Gastropoda Pul1946. A quantitativestudyof the toxicaction of
monata). Z. vergl.Physiol.,33: 14-52.
quinones on Planaria gonocephala. Nature,Lond. GREGORY,P. W., and H. Goss. 1933. Glutathion
158: 948-951.
concentrationand hereditarybody size. J. exp.
Zool., 66: 155-173.
, and J. KRYWIENCZYK. 1953. The surfacerule
HARMS, J. 1955. Biologie des Wachstums. In
in crustaceans. Amer.Nat., 87: 107-110.
Handbuchder AllgemeinenPatkologie,ed. by F.
, and A. MACFADYEN. 1954. Table 137: Correlation of oxygenconsumptionwithbody size: InverBuechner,E. Letterer,and F. Roulet, 6(I), 139179. Springer,Berlin,Gottingen,and Heidelberg.
tebrates. In Standard values in nutritionand
metabolism,ed. by E. C. Albritton. Saunders, HOMMA, K. 1953. Effectsof age on the metabolism
of testes. (Japan.) Nihon Chikusan Gakkai, 24:
Philadelphia and London.
49.
-, and I. MPLLER.
1943. Untersuchungentiber
die Gesetzlichkeitdes Wachstums. VIII. Die
HUXLEY, J. 1932. Problems of relative growtk.
Abhangigkeitdes Stoffwechsels
von der Kh5rperMethuen,London.
A. 1948. Contributionto the knowledge
gr6sse und der Zusammenhangvon Stoffwechsel- JAN?6AkfK,
typen und Wachstumstypen. Riv. Biol., 35: 48ofbreathingof CladoceraDaphnia pulex. (Czech,
95.
English summary). Publ. Fac. Sci. Univ.
and W. J. PIROZYNSKI. 1951. Tissue respira--,
Masaryk,Ser. M 1, No. 305.
tion and body size. Science, 113: 599-600.
JOST, H. 1928. VergleichendePhysiologiedes Stoff. 1952. Ontogeneticand evolutionary
, and
wechsels. In Handb. norm. pathol. Physiol., 5:
377-466.
allometry. Evolution,6: 387-392.
and
--,
- . 1953. Tissue respiration,growth KALMuS,H. 1930. Untersuchungen
uiberdie Atmung
and basal metabolism. Biol. Bull., 105: 240-256.
des Flusskrebses Potamobius astacus. Z. vergl.
Physiol.,12: 725-759.
BEVERTON, R. J. H. 1954. Notes on theuse of theoreticalmodelsin the studyof the dynamicsof ex- KIENLE, M.-L., and W. LuDWIG.
1956. Die Beziehung zwischen Korpergrosseund Sauerstoffkonploitedfish populations.Misc. Contrib. 2, U. S.
FisheryLaboratory,Beaufort,N. C.
sum bei Landpulmonaten. Z. vergl. Pltysiol.,
39: 102-118.
and S. J. HOLT. 1957. On thedynamicsof ex--,
Ser. KITTEL, A. 1941. K6rpergr6sse,Kt5rperzeitenund
ploitedfishpopulations.FisheryInvestigations,
Energiebilanz II. Der Sauerstoffverbrauch
II, vol. XIX. Her Majesty's Stationery Office,
der
London.
Insekten in Abhangigkeitvon der K6rpergr6sse.
Z. vergl.Physiol.,28: 533-562.
BOLK, L. 1926. Das Problem der Menschwerdung.
KLEIBER, M. 1941. Body size and metabolism of
Fischer,Jena.
liver slices in vitro. Proc. Soc. exp. Biol., 48:
BRAND, TH. VON, M. 0. NOLAN, and E. R. MANN.
1948. Observationson the respirationof Austral419-422.
1947. Body size and metabolicrate. Physiol.
-.
orbis glabratusand some other aquatic snails.
Biol. Bull., 95: 199-213.
Rev.,27: 511-541.
BRODY, S. 1945. Bioenergeticsand growth. Rein- KRAMER, G. 1934. Der Ruheumsatz von Eidechsen
und seine quantitativeBeziehungzur Individuenhold, New York.
CRANDALL, R. R., and A. H. SMITH. 1952. Tissue
gr6sse. Z. vergl.Physiol.,20: 600-616.
metabolism in growing birds. Proc. Soc. exp. KREBS,A. H. 1950. Body size and tissuerespiration.
Biochim. biophys.Acta, 4: 249-269.
Biol., 79: 345-346.
DONALDSON, H. H. 1924. The rat. Mem. Wistar KRU&GER,F. 1940. Die Beziehungdes SauerstoffverInst. Anat., 6, 2nd ed. Philadelphia.
brauches zur K6rperoberflbchebeim SchweineDUSPIVA,F. 1955. Biochemie des Wachstums und
spulwurm(Ascaris lumbricoides).Z. wiss. Zool.,
der Differenzierung.In HandbuchderAllgemeinen
152: 547-570.
. 1952. tjber die Beziehung des SauerstoffverPathologie,ed. by F. Buechner,E. Letterer,and
F. Roulet, 6(I), 307-382. Springer, Berlin,
brauches zum Gewicht bei Eisenia foetida (Sav.)
(AnnelidaOligochaeta). Z. vergl.Physiol.,34: 1-5.
Goettingen,and Heidelberg.
QUANTITATIVE
LAWS IN METABOLISM
AND GROWTH
231
1943. The
KRYWIENCZYK,J. 1952a. K6rpergrosse, K6rper- ROSENTHAL, O., and D. L. DRABKIN.
zeiten und Energiebilanz. IV. Korpergrosse,
contentofnormaland neoplasticmamcytochrome
bei Prosomalian epithelium,and its correlationwith body
02-Konsumund Kriechgeschwindigkeit
branchiern. Z. vergl.Physiol.,34: 6-13.
mass. J. biol. Chem.,150: 131-141.
brauchs
und RUBNER, M. 1902. Die Gesetzedes Energiever
. 1952b. Korpergr6sse, 02-Konsum
Kriechgeschwindigkeitbei Wasserpulmonaten.
bei der Ernahrung. Springer,Berlin and Wien.
1956. Die Grosse der Tracheen-InnenZ. vergl.Physiol.,34: 14-19.
SATTEL, M.
uber die Entin Abhangigkeit
KUMMER, B. 1953. Untersuchungen
flachenvon Seidenspinnerraupen
wick'ung der Schadelform des Menschen und
von der Korpergr6sse. Z. vergl. Physiol., 39:
einigerAnthropoiden. Abh. exakt.Biol., 3.
89-101.
H. O., and J. E. CAMTBELL, JR. 1952. SCIMIDT-NIELSEN,
KUNKEL,
K., L. VON BERTALANFFY, and W. J.
1951. Tissue respirationand body
Tissue cytochromeoxidase activity and body
PIROZYNSKI.
weight. J. biol. Chem.,198: 229-236.
size. Science, 114: 306-307.
1948. The
C. P., and C. E. STEVENS.
LEBLOND,
R. 1947. The Dynamic State of
SCHOENHEIMER,
constantrenewalofthe intestinalepitheliumofthe
Body Constituents.2nd ed. OxfordUniv. Press,
albino rat. Anat. Rec., 100: 357-377.
Oxford.
LEBLOND, C. P., and B. E. WALKER. 1956. Renewal
1949. Rate
SPRINSON, D. B., and D. RITTENBERG.
of cell populations. Physiol.Rev.,36: 255-276.
of interactingof the amino acids of the diet with
LIEBSCH, W. 1929. Uber die AtmungeinigerHelicithe protein synthesis. J. biol. Chem., 180: 715den. Zool. Jb., Abt. 3, 46: 161-208.
726.
A. J. 1955. Quantitative Biologie und STOREY, W. F., and C. P. LEBLOND.
LINZBACH,
1951. MeasureHyperMorphologiedes Wachstumseinschliesslich
of epidermisand assomentof rate ofproliferation
trophieund Riesenzellen. In HandbuclzderA,lgeciatedstructures. Ann. N. Y. Acad. Sci., 53: 537meinen Pathologie, edited by F. Buechner, E.
545.
Letterer,und F. Roulet, 6(I), 180-306. Springer, THOMAS, H. J. 1954. The oxygen uptake of the
Berlin, Gottingen,and Heidelberg.
lobster (Homarus vulgarisEdw.). J. exp. Biol.,
W. 1956. Betrachtung uber den EnerLUDWIG,
31: 228-251.
giekonsumvon Tieren mit Atmungsorganenvon VERNBERG, I. J., and I. E. GRAY. 1953. A comparazweierleiTyp. Z. vergl.Physiol.,39: 84-88.
metabolismof excised
tive studyof the respiratory
1950. KorperLUDWIG, W., and J. KRYWIENCZYK.
brain tissue of marine teleosts. Biol. Bull., 104:
grosse, Korperzeiten und Energiebilanz. III.
445-449.
Der Sauerstoffverbrauch
von Muschelnin Abhang1919. Beobachtungenilber den GasWEINLAND, E.
igkeit von der K6rpergr6sse. Z. vergl.Physiol.,
wechselvon Anodontacygnaea. Z. Biol., 69: 1-86.
32: 464-467.
F. W., J. FIELD, II, and M. KLEIBER.
WEYMOUTH,
MARTIN,A. WV.,and F. A. FUHRMAN. 1955. The re1942. Relationship between body size and melationship between summated tissue respiration
tabolism. Proc. Soc. exp.Biol., N.Y., 49: 367-370.
and metabolicratein the mouseand dog. Physiol.
, J. M. CRISMON, V. E. HALL, H. S. BELDING, and
Zool., 28: 18-34.
J. FIELD, II. 1944. Total and tissue respiration
1943a. Untersuchungenzur GesetzlichMULLER, I.
in relationto body weight. A comparisonof the
keit des Wachstums. IX. Die Abhangigkeitder
crab with other crustaceansand with mamkelp
Atmungvon der Korpergrossebei Dixippus moromals. Physiol. Zool., 17: 50-71.
sus and ihre Beziehungzum Wachstum. Z. vergl.
A. 1952. K6rpergr6sse, K6rperzeiten und
WILL,
Physiol.,30: 139-144.
Energiebilanz. VI. K6rpergrosseund 02-Kon1943b. X. Weitereszur Frage der Abhangigsum bei Schaben und Asseln(Isopoden). Z. vergl.
keit der Atmung von der K6rpergrosse. Biol.
Physiol., 34: 20-25.
Zbl.,63: 446453.
A., and J. JEHL. 1952. Influence
WOLLENBERGER,
PATRUSEV, V. J. 1937. On the inheritanceof bioofage on rateofrespirationofslicedcardiacmuscle.
chemical charactersby animals and its relation
Amer.J. Physiol., 170: 126-130.
to their growth. II. Glutathion concentration
und Korperin the blood and differences
in size in breeds of WOLSKY, A. 1934. Sauerstoffverbrauch
gewicht beim SteinkrebsPotamobius torrentium.
farmanimals. C. R. Acad. Sci. U.S.S.R., N. S.,
Arb. ung.biol. Forsch.Inst., 7.
14: 573-577.
A. 1920. Studien Uber physiologische YOSHIDA, Y. 1956. Relationbetweenthe sardineand
PUTTER,
the food plankton. III. On the growthcurve of
Pftig.
Ahnlichkeit.VI. Wachstumsahnlichkeiten.
Sardinopsmelanosticta. Bull. Jap. Soc. sci. Fish.,
Arch. ges. Physiol. 180: 298-340.
21: 1007-1012.
RACINE, G. E. 1953. A statistical analysis of the
size-dependenceof metabolismunder basal and ZEUTHEN, E. 1955. Comparative physiology (respiration). Ann. Rev. Physiol.,17: 459-482.
non-basal conditions. Thesis Univ. Ottawa.