Ballot

Ballot 16
Ballot 17
Ballot 18
Ballot 19
Ballot 20

Start Date End Date

28-May
11-Jun
11-Jun
25-Jun
25-Jun
9-Jul
9-Jul
23-Jul
23-Jul
6-Aug

Issue 2582: class EnumerationLiteral issue

Issue 3391: UML 1.4 RTF Issue: Multiple languages for uninterpreted strings
Issue 4448: Does visibility apply to creating an destroying links?
Issue 5273: Initial state for composite states - OCL example and missing constraint
Issue 6186: UML 2 Super/Metamodel::Constructs/inconsistency with Kernel
Issue 6187: UML 2 Super/Metamodel::Super/missing merge
Issue 6188: UML 2 Super/Metamodel/merging of non-redefinable model elements
Issue 6189: UML 2 Super/Metamodel/package merge and visibility
Issue 6190: UML 2 Infra/Section 5.9/missing merge rules
Issue 6191: UML 2 Super/Package Merge/redefinition rules and standard OO languages
Issue 6194: UML 2 Super/Package merge/redefinitions issue - lost association ends
Issue 6196: UML 2 Super/Metamodel::Compliance::L3/Missing merges
Issue 6197: UML 2 Super/Metamodel::Kernel/missing merges
Issue 6198: UML 2 Super/Package Merge/missing rule for operations
Issue 6216: UML 2 Super/pg.75/kinds of changeability
Issue 6246: fig 141 p205 and 7.13.2 p101 / just what sort of relationship is <
Issue 6248: UML super/Section 2/Compliance points
Issue 6253: What does redefines mean in package extensibility?
Issue 6279: PackageMerge (from Kernel)
Issue 6404: UML 2 Super / Package Templates / StringExpression inconsistency
Issue 6430: UML2 super/ad-03-04-01/Derived attributes and associations
Issue 6447: Corrections and improvements to glossary definitions
Issue 6448: Inconsistent use of terms "implement" and "realize"
Issue 6452: UML 2 Super / Missing OCL constraints
Issue 6456: Use 'represent' for the relationship of a model
Issue 6471: Section 7.13.2 Package Merge
Issue 6517: Package Extensibility <> - UML2 Superstructure issue
Issue 6642: Error in definition of PackageMergeKind
Issue 6870: UML 2 Super / state machines / non-existent property reference
Issue 6872: UML 2 Super / state machines / misplaced operation definition
Issue 6876: Appendix B/Standard Stereotypes too heavyweight and incompletely defined
Issue 6877: UML2 super/notation/Keywords
Issue 6902: UML 2 Super / General / Idenitfy sections specifying run-time semantics
Issue 6918: Inconsistencies between Figure 3 and the detailled description of package
Issue 6958: UML 2 Super / General / specialization labeling convention
Issue 7045: Define containingStateMachine() for Vertex
Issue 7056: Super and Infra / Kernel-Classifiers / incorrect hasVisibilityOf definition
Issue 7068: UML 2 Super / Classes / makesVisible () operation incorrect
Issue 7124: Figure 95
Issue 7135: adopt a single notation to specify text strings used in the notation
Issue 7157: UML 2 Super / General / consistent formatting conventions
Issue 7159: UML 2 Super / General / Classes chapter organization
Issue 7256: transition is simply never enabled
Issue 7277: UML 2 Super / Templates / invalid multiplicity
Issue 7331: Page: 589
Issue 7336: UML 2 Super / missing owners of concepts
Issue 7362: Clarify example in figure 133
Issue 7365: UML2 Super / ordering of association ends
Issue 7366: UML2 Super / Classes / Operation constraints
Issue 7367: UML 2 Super / General / superclass pointers
Issue 7368: UML2 Super / Use cases / navigation from subject to use case
Issue 7374: Inappropriate to reference RFP documents
Issue 7377: empty sections in activities chapter
Issue 7396: Constraint 2 of AcceptEventAction - typo
Issue 7401: XMI schema
Issue 7402: XMI schema (02)
Issue 7407: The specification is fond of using 'typically.'

MOF/Infra
MOF/Infra
MOF/Infra
Super
MOF/Infra
Super
MOF/Infra
MOF/Infra
MOF/Infra
MOF/Infra
MOF/Infra
Super
Super
MOF/Infra
MOF/Infra
MOF/Infra
Super
MOF/Infra
MOF/Infra
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
MOF/Infra
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super

yes
yes
yes
no
yes
no
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
no
no
yes
yes
yes
no
yes
yes
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
yes
no
yes
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
yes

Classes
Classes
Classes
State machines
Classes
General
Classes
Classes
Classes
Classes
Classes
General
General
Classes
Classes
Classes
General
Classes
Classes
Auxiliary
All
Auxiliary
General
General
General
Classes
State machines
Classes
State machines
State machines
General
General
General
Classes
General
State machines
Classes
Classes
Classes
General
General
General
State machines
Auxiliary
Auxiliary
General
Comp.&Depl.
General
Classes
General
Use cases
Activities
Activities
Actions
General
General
General

Bran S.
Bran S.
Bran S.
Bran S.
Bran S.
Bran S.
Bran S.
Bran S.
Bran S.
Bran S.
Bran S.
Bran S.
Bran S.
Bran S.
Bran S.
Bran S.
Bran S.
Bran S.
Bran S.
Bran S.
Bran S.
Bran S.
Bran S.
Bran S.
Bran S.
Bran S.
Bran S.
Bran S.
Bran S.
Bran S.
Bran S.
Bran S.
Bran S.
Bran S.
Bran S.
Bran S.
Bran S.
Bran S.
Bran S.
Bran S.
Bran S.
Bran S.
Bran S.
Bran S.
Bran S.
Bran S.
Bran S.
Bran S.
Bran S.
Bran S.
Bran S.
Bran S.
Bran S.
Bran S.
Bran S.
Bran S.
Bran S.

the new model is quite close to the recommendation in here

Ballot 11
Ballot 15

Depends on compliance/merge resolution

Ballot 15
Ballot 15

Depends on compliance/merge resolution

Depends on compliance/merge resolution

Ballot 13

Depends on compliance/merge resolution

Ballot 11
Ballot 16
Ballot 11
Ballot 14
Ballot 17/defer
Ballot 17/defer
Ballot 13
Ballot 12
Ballot 12
Ballot 15
Ballot 15
Ballot 16
Ballot 14
Ballot 16
Ballot 11
Ballot 12
Ballot 14

Depends on compliance/merge resolution

Related to 6876

related to 7158
Duplicate
resolve with package merge set

Ballot 12
Ballot 16
Ballot 11

Issue 4932: Starting state machine

Issue 6091: Outgoing edges from input pins
Issue 6098: ActivityFinalNode
Issue 6114: State extension
Issue 6134: ExpansionRegion
Issue 6136: Pins on structured nodes 2
Issue 6142: Update actions for isUnique
Issue 6143: actions on properties that are association ends
Issue 6145: Action packaging
Issue 6179: UML 2 Super/Metamodel::IntermediateActivities/redundant merge error
Issue 6180: UML 2 Super/Metamodel::Communications/redundant merge error
Issue 6193: UML 2 Super/Metamodel::BasicActivities/inGroup problem
Issue 6195: UML 2 Super/Metamodel::StructuredActivities/double redefinition
Issue 6236: UML 2.0 serious layout problems with activity diagrams
Issue 6243: Association not affecting ends
Issue 6247: Question about InterruptibleActivityRegion
Issue 6348: Control pins
Issue 6368: Join nodes that destroy tokens
Issue 6374: Initial nodes in structured actions
Issue 6375: Flows across SAN boundaries
Issue 6376: Terminating a SAN
Issue 6487: Conditions for parameter sets
Issue 6491: Outputting constants
Issue 6625: UML 2 Super/Actions/PrimitiveFunction missing properties
Issue 6628: UML 2 Super/Action/featuringClassifier misinterpreted
Issue 6677: UML 2 Super/Activities/invalid multiplicity 0
Issue 6914: The query 'hostElement' has some errors
Issue 6915: The section "Associations (BasicActivities)" is not complete
Issue 6917: /context : Classifier [0..1]
Issue 7182: LinkEndData - Inconsistency with Figure 146
Issue 7184: LinkEndData - Additional operation not correct
Issue 7186: ReadLinkAction - inconsistency with Figure 147
Issue 7187: ReadLinkAction - Constraints use deprecated UML elements
Issue 7189: Variable - Typo in Attributes
Issue 7190: VariableAction - undefined query
Issue 7191: AddVariableValueAction - OCL in constraint [1] not correct
Issue 7230: UML 1 activities
Issue 7236: ActivityPartition - inconsistencies
Issue 7290: AcceptEventAction - inconsistent multiplicities
Issue 7291: AcceptEventAction - inconsistency
Issue 7292: AcceptEventAction - inconsistencies in Semantics and typos
Issue 7293: AcceptCallEvent - inconsistent multiplicity " trigger
Issue 7294: ReplyAction - Inconsistency with Figure 150
Issue 7319: behavior packages (Interactions, Statemachines
Issue 7330: Section: 12.3.20
Issue 7333: There is no redefinitionContext established

Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
MOF/Infra
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super

noSt.mach/Com.Beh./Action
Conrad B.
no
Activities
Conrad B.
no
Activities
Conrad B.
no
Activities
Conrad B.
no
Activities
Conrad B.
no
Activities
Conrad B.
no
Actions
Conrad B.
no
Actions
Conrad B.
no
Actions
Conrad B.
no
Activities
Conrad B.
no
Activities
Conrad B.
no
Activities
Conrad B.
no
Activities
Conrad B.
no
Activities
Conrad B.
yes
Classes
Conrad B.
no
Activities
Conrad B.
no
Activities
Conrad B.
no
Activities
Conrad B.
no
Activities
Conrad B.
no
Activities
Conrad B.
no
Activities
Conrad B.
no
Activities
Conrad B.
no
Activities
Conrad B.
no
Actions
Conrad B.
no
Classes
Conrad B.
no
Activities
Conrad B.
no
Activities
Conrad B.
no
Activities
Conrad B.
no
Activities
Conrad B.
no
Actions
Conrad B.
no
Actions
Conrad B.
no
Actions
Conrad B.
no
Actions
Conrad B.
no
Activities
Conrad B.
no
Actions
Conrad B.
no
Actions
Conrad B.
no
Activities
Conrad B.
no
Activities
Conrad B.
no
Actions
Conrad B.
no
Actions
Conrad B.
no
Actions
Conrad B.
no
Actions
Conrad B.
no
Actions
Conrad B.
no
Actions
Conrad B.
no
Activities
Conrad B.
no
Activities
Conrad B.

Issue 5979: The description of DataType is plainly wrong in the specification

Issue 6067: Section 1.3, ElementImport semantics on page 10 of ad/2003-04-01
Issue 6168: 7.3.1 ElementImport
Issue 6176: UML 2 Super/Metamodel::Constructs/owningComment
Issue 6217: UML 2 Super/pg.95/attributes in data types clarification
Issue 6221: UML 2 Super/pg.130/incorrect stereotype name
Issue 6255: UML2 Super / Classes/ Incorrect reference to "access"
Issue 6362: Side effects of value specifications
Issue 6379: Visibility of a Package
Issue 6468: Section 7.3.1 ElementImport
Issue 6469: Section 7.3.5 PackageImport
Issue 6596: page 95 diagram

MOF/Infra
MOF/Infra
MOF/Infra
MOF/Infra
MOF/Infra
MOF/Infra
MOF/Infra
MOF/Infra
MOF/Infra
MOF/Infra
MOF/Infra
MOF/Infra

yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes

Classes
Classes
Classes
Classes
Classes
Classes
Classes
Classes
Classes
Classes
Classes
Classes

Doug T.
Doug T.
Doug T.
Doug T.
Doug T.
Doug T.
Doug T.
Doug T.
Doug T.
Doug T.
Doug T.
Doug T.

import
import

import
import, dup of 6221?
import
import
import

Issue 4110: Semantics of firing compound transitions still appears to be circular

Issue 4298: Issue: Conflicting WFRs on Transition
Issue 4746: Composite relationship between Event and StateMachine
Issue 4936: StartStateMachine clarification
Issue 5107: Starting a state machine
Issue 5886: behaviour of the shallow history state and deep history state
Issue 6075: UML2 super/pg.470/entry and exit points for composite states
Issue 6228: UML 2 Super/pg.471/unclear terminate state semantics
Issue 6256: UML2 Super / association end naming convention
Issue 6381: Figure 395 requires a lot more explanation
Issue 6395: UML 2 Super / State machines / Transition triggers cannot be redefined
Issue 6489: Ports in Protocol State Machines
Issue 6608: Notation when guards are used in conjunction with triggers in transitions
Issue 6626: section 9 (State Machines) of 3rd revision
Issue 6868: UML 2 Super/State machines/pseudostate name consistency
Issue 6871: UML 2 Super / state machines / incorrect property redefinition
Issue 6873: UML 2 Super / state machines / non-existent return type
Issue 6990: manage simultaneity of events
Issue 6991: transtion
Issue 7049: ownedStateMachine not described correctly
Issue 7052: Figure 355 - ownedStateMachine should subset ownedBehavior
Issue 7053: Figure 355 - mulitplicities of redefinitionContext should be 0..1
Issue 7055: Region - Additional structural constraints necessary
Issue 7254: completion transitions
Issue 7255: Priority of the joint transition
Issue 7320: notation for statemachine transitions omitted from spec
Issue 7323: UML 2 Super / state machines / state should be a namespace
Issue 7335: behaviors
Issue 7372: surface notation for state machines

Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super

no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no

State machines
State machines
St. mach/Com. Beh.
St.mach./Actions
St.mach/Actions
State machines
State machines
State machines
State machines
State machines
State machines
State machines
State machines
State machines
State machines
State machines
State machines
State machines
State machines
State machines
State machines
State machines
State machines
State machines
State machines
State machines
State machines
State machines
State machines

Eran G.
Eran G.
Eran G.
Eran G.
Eran G.
Eran G.
Eran G.
Eran G.
Eran G.
Eran G.
Eran G.
Eran G.
Eran G.
Eran G.
Eran G.
Eran G.
Eran G.
Eran G.
Eran G.
Eran G.
Eran G.
Eran G.
Eran G.
Eran G.
Eran G.
Eran G.
Eran G.
Eran G.
Eran G.

Ballot 14
Ballot 14
Ballot 14
Ballot 14
Ballot 14
Ballot 14
Ballot 11
Ballot 12

Ballot 12
Ballot 12
Ballot 12
Ballot 12
Defer
Defer
Ballot 12
Ballot 12
Ballot 12
Ballot 12

related to 4932, 5107

related to 4932, 4936

Issue 6315: UML 2 Super/Components & Deployment chapters missing OCL constraints
Issue 6433: 03-04-01 Chap 2 p. 112/Components: Different ways to wire components
Issue 6440: Excessive syntactic and semantic overlap between structured Classifiers
Issue 6475: Section 8.3.1 Component
Issue 6513: Components and artifacts: Dependency problem - UML2 Superstructure
Issue 6875: Components / provided and required interfaces -- derived or subsets
Issue 7152: Deployment - keyword <> not introduced
Issue 7153: DeploymentTarget - Missing OCL expression
Issue 7155: Manifestation - visual representation should be dashed arrow
Issue 7178: Component - problem with provided interfaces (see also Issue 6875, 6338)
Issue 7227: UML2 Super/Deployment/inheritance
Issue 7228: UML2 super/Deployments/CommunicationPath
Issue 7229: UML2 Super/Deployments/Manifestation
Issue 7245: Figure 77

Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super

no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no

Comp.&Depl.
Comp.&Depl.
Comp.&Depl.
Comp.&Depl.
Comp.&Depl.
Comp.&Depl.
Comp.&Depl.
Comp.&Depl.
Comp.&Depl.
Comp.&Depl.
Comp.&Depl.
Comp.&Depl.
Comp.&Depl.
Comp.&Depl.

Guus R.
Guus R.
Guus R.
Guus R.
Guus R.
Guus R.
Guus R.
Guus R.
Guus R.
Guus R.
Guus R.
Guus R.
Guus R.
Guus R.

Ballot 14
Ballot 13
Ballot 13
Ballot 12
Ballot 12
Ballot 12
Ballot 12
Ballot 14
Ballot 12

Issue 5980: Description of GeneralizationSet

Issue 6520: GeneralizationSet Description clarification - UML2 Superstructure
Issue 7070: GeneralizationSet - outdated description

Super
Super
Super

no
no
no

Classes
Classes
Classes

Jim O.
Jim O.
Jim O.

Issue 4816: Suggest that alternate syntax used in section 6.5.5 be adopted thoughout
Issue 5924: representation of arrays of values in an action language
Issue 5951: UML 2.0 Superstructure: Operation vs. Attribute notation
Issue 6156: Kernel::Classifier missing "attribute"
Issue 6157: Property string undefined
Issue 6158: Notation for attributes
Issue 6159: Instantiates stereotype
Issue 6167: No notation defined for suppressing attributes or operations
Issue 6169: 7.4.1 Multiplicity
Issue 6171: 7.10.1 Operation
Issue 6173: 7.14.1 Abstraction
Issue 6183: UML 2 Super/Metamodel::Kernel::DataTypes/missing renames
Issue 6184: UML 2 Super/Metamodel::Kernel::Packages/missing redefinition
Issue 6200: UML 2 Super/Metamodel/redefinition and substitutability
Issue 6207: UML 2 Super/Metamodel/missing namespaces for metaclasses
Issue 6212: UML 2 Super/pg.78/operation redefinition
Issue 6213: UML 2 Super/pg.78/missing return types syntax
Issue 6214: UML 2 Super/pg.79/underlined operation syntax missing
Issue 6215: UML 2 Super/pg.64/Classifier redefinition notation
Issue 6232: UML 2 Super/pg.81/semantics of subsetting-specialization-redefinition
Issue 6252: Defenition of redefines?????
Issue 6398: UML 2 Super / Kernel features / cannot exclude superclass properties
Issue 6399: UML 2 Super / Interfaces / Cannot nest classes in interfaces
Issue 6401: UML 2 Super / Interface / missing owner of operation
Issue 6405: UML 2 super / Dependencies / improper subsetting?
Issue 6437: targetScope on StructuralFeature and AssociationEnd
Issue 6451: UML 2 Super / Dependency / ownership of dependencies
Issue 6514: Operation without - UML2 Superstructure
Issue 6616: UML Superstructure FTF : isRoot property disappeared
Issue 6630: UML 2 Super / Classes / dependencies should be unidirectional
Issue 6691: Consistent Naming
Issue 6897: importedMember property
Issue 6974: Ambiguous semantics of isStatic
Issue 6997: Additional Operations specification of NamedElement::allNamespaces()
Issue 7040: AssociationClass Constraint [1] should be reformulated
Issue 7219: Operations and derived attributes
Issue 7322: "Implementation" is ommitted
Issue 7355: Q re Parameter
Issue 7379: Question about Enumeration and EnumerationLiteral
Issue 7400: AssociationClass
Issue 7404: property strings on association ends

MOF/Infra
Super
MOF/Infra
Super
MOF/Infra
Super
Super
Super
MOF/Infra
MOF/Infra
Super
Super
Super
MOF/Infra
Super
MOF/Infra
MOF/Infra
MOF/Infra
MOF/Infra
MOF/Infra
MOF/Infra
MOF/Infra
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
MOF/Infra
MOF/Infra
Super
MOF/Infra

yes
no
yes
no
yes
no
no
no
yes
yes
no
no
no
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
yes
no
yes
yes
no
yes

Classes
Classes
Classes
Classes
Classes
Classes
Classes
Classes
Classes
Classes
Classes
Classes
Classes
Classes
Classes
Classes
Classes
Classes
Classes
Classes
Classes
Classes
Classes
Classes
Classes
Classes
Classes
Classes
Classes
Classes
Classes
Classes
Classes
Classes
Classes
Classes
Classes
Classes
Classes
Classes
Classes

Karl F.
Karl F.
Karl F.
Karl F.
Karl F.
Karl F.
Karl F.
Karl F.
Karl F.
Karl F.
Karl F.
Karl F.
Karl F.
Karl F.
Karl F.
Karl F.
Karl F.
Karl F.
Karl F.
Karl F.
Karl F.
Karl F.
Karl F.
Karl F.
Karl F.
Karl F.
Karl F.
Karl F.
Karl F.
Karl F.
Karl F.
Karl F.
Karl F.
Karl F.
Karl F.
Karl F.
Karl F.
Karl F.
Karl F.
Karl F.
Karl F.

Ballot 14
Ballot 14

NB: 'attribute' should be derived

Ballot 14
Ballot 14
Ballot 15

notation seems like it really belongs to Super?

error in text "instance of" phrase is incorrect
notation seems like it really belongs to Super?

Ballot 13
Ballot 13
Ballot 15

notation seems like it really belongs to Super?

rename 'ownedLiteral' to 'literal'
should be 'ownedClassifier'? (why derived?)

Ballot 15

Others as well -- also a Rose model change

Needs resolution of notation ownership (Super or Infra)

Ballot 15
Ballot 16
Ballot 14
Ballot 13
Ballot 15
Ballot 15
Ballot 15
Ballot 15
Ballot 15
Ballot 15
Ballot 14
Ballot 14
Ballot 14

fig. 56 (same for Property?, make navigable?)

yes
closed, no change Feature has isStatic
needs an explicit
check shared issues related to 'property string'
supplier should not have to know its clients
do the change
importMembers vs importedMembers?
needs an explanation (same for all children)

The spec is inconsistent in this way; both approaches are used

Issue 5433: How to properly designate exception returned from message sent to Java obje
Issue 6077: Message notation. Incorrect notation in Figure 333 p.414
Issue 6080: EventOccurrence, multiplicities incorrect in metamodel diagram
Issue 6082: Suspension Region
Issue 6083: More examples
Issue 6086: More explanation needed on Figure 339
Issue 6088: Parameterization of lifelines
Issue 6153: Interactions view of state machines/activities
Issue 6226: UML 2 Super/pg.427/missing notation description for lifelines
Issue 6264: Recommendation for InteractionOccurrences
Issue 6409: UML 2 Super/Interactions/missing OCL constraints
Issue 6463: UML 2 Issue: Message notation
Issue 6927: UML 2 Super / Interactions / Ambiguous diagram tags
Issue 6972: self-activation notation in Sequence diagrams missing
Issue 6975: missing illustrations of graphical paths for create and destroy messages
Issue 6978: graphic nodes for state invariant and continuation are not always distingui
Issue 6979: Ambiguous sentence and typo in description of EventOccurence
Issue 6980: UML 2 Super/Interactions/incorrect spelling of EventOccurence
Issue 6981: UML 2 Super/Interactions/incorrect grammar for
Issue 6988: Ambiguous example of a local action on a Lifeline in Figures 334, 335
Issue 7069: UML 2 Super / Interactions / Invalid subsetting for enclosingOperand
Issue 7160: UML 2 Super/Interactions/Alternative with all false guards
Issue 7161: UML 2 Super/Interactions/Need constraints that cover multiple Lifelines

Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super

no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no

Interactions
Interactions
Interactions
Interactions
Interactions
Interactions
Interactions
Interactions
Interactions
Interactions
Interactions
Interactions
Interactions
Interactions
Interactions
Interactions
Interactions
Interactions
Interactions
Interactions
Interactions
Interactions
Interactions

Nick M.
Nick M.
Nick M.
Nick M.
Nick M.
Nick M.
Nick M.
Nick M.
Nick M.
Nick M.
Nick M.
Nick M.
Nick M.
Nick M.
Nick M.
Nick M.
Nick M.
Nick M.
Nick M.
Nick M.
Nick M.
Nick M.
Nick M.

Ballot 18/defer
Ballot 11
Ballot 14
Ballot 13
Ballot 13
Ballot 13
Ballot 16
Ballot 17/defer
Ballot 12
Ballot 17/defer
Ballot 18/defer
Ballot 11
Ballot 12

Ballot 14
Ballot 14

Issue 3898: Specify XMI parameters for the UML / XMI interchange format
Issue 4504: Optimize Instance data values
Issue 5976: UML's use of the word "unique" for multiplicity is ambiguous
Issue 5977: saying {nonunique} on one end of a binary association is meaningless
Issue 6155: Replace "initial value" with "default value".
Issue 6219: UML 2 Super/pg.99/misnamed "packageMerge" attribute
Issue 6317: UML2 Super/Instances
Issue 6455: instantiations of Classifiers
Issue 6457: Abandon the OMGS4LMMA
Issue 6470: Section 7.11.2 Association
Issue 6515: Inconsistency concerning VisibilityKind - UML2 Superstructure
Issue 6624: freeing namespace
Issue 6645: UML 2.0 Superstructure Kernal/Packages
Issue 6681: UML2 Super/Kernel Classes
Issue 6929: UML 2 Super / Classes / Properties owned by properties
Issue 7039: Association - endType should be of type Classifier
Issue 7223: Questions about DataTypes and generalization
Issue 7338: metaattribute isReadOnly
Issue 7339: Property defines an association "datatype" which is redundant
Issue 7344: formal parameter or a return result

MOF/Infra
MOF/Infra
MOF/Infra
MOF/Infra
MOF/Infra
MOF/Infra
MOF/Infra
MOF/Infra
MOF/Infra
MOF/Infra
MOF/Infra
MOF/Infra
MOF/Infra
MOF/Infra
MOF/Infra
MOF/Infra
MOF/Infra
MOF/Infra
MOF/Infra
MOF/Infra

yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes

XMI
Classes/XMI
Classes
Classes
Classes
Classes
Classes
Classes
Classes
Classes
Classes
Classes
Classes
Classes
Classes
Classes
Classes
Classes
Classes
Classes

Pete R.
Pete R.
Pete R.
Pete R.
Pete R.
Pete R.
Pete R.
Pete R.
Pete R.
Pete R.
Pete R.
Pete R.
Pete R.
Pete R.
Pete R.
Pete R.
Pete R.
Pete R.
Pete R.
Pete R.

Ballot 14

out of scope? (Pete's resolution to Abstractions might resolve this)

constrained to isComposite=false?

Issue 6242: Confusion regarding XMI for use of stereotypes

Super

no

Profiles

Philippe D.

Ballot 18

Issue 4456: Event => Event Specification

Issue 6149: Activity attributes on Behavior
Issue 6373: Parameters in Features and Common Behavior
Issue 6682: See CommonBehavior for a description of Event specifications
Issue 7122: Connector - Constraint [2] is inprecise
Issue 7123: Connector - Constraint [3] not necessary ?
Issue 7231: UML2 Super/Composite Structure
Issue 7240: Connector - typo and inconsistency
Issue 7241: Connector - inconsistency
Issue 7243: ConnectorEnd - multipliciy of role
Issue 7303: simple time model" in CommonBehavior
Issue 7304: Notation sections for TimeObservation and DurationObservation
Issue 7321: UML 2 Super/Connector
Issue 7342: association "context"
Issue 7369: UML2 Super / Common Behavior / Trigger should be a named element
Issue 7370: Section 9.3.1
Issue 7371: Section 9.3.5. (ConnectableElement)
Issue 7380: UML 2 issue, Common Behaviors
Issue 7398: Provide exception handling for all behaviors.
Issue 7403: change trigger
Issue 7406: TimeObservationAction and DurationObservationAction

Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super
Super

no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no

Com. behav.
Com. behav.
Com.behav.
Com.behav.
Comp. struct.
Comp. struct.
Comp. struct.
Comp. struct.
Comp. struct.
Comp. struct.
Com.behav.
Com.behav.
Comp. struct.
Com.behav.
Com.behav.
Comp. struct.
Comp. struct.
Com. behav.
Com. behav.
Com. behav.
Com. behav.

Thomas W.
Thomas W.
Thomas W.
Thomas W.
Thomas W.
Thomas W.
Thomas W.
Thomas W.
Thomas W.
Thomas W.
Thomas W.
Thomas W.
Thomas W.
Thomas W.
Thomas W.
Thomas W.
Thomas W.
Thomas W.
Thomas W.
Thomas W.
Thomas W.