Professional Documents
Culture Documents
TEXT 22
se mangalacarana haya tri-vidha prakara
vastu-nirdesa, asirvada, namaskara
The invocation involves three processes: defining the
We have seen that without a fixed goal, without knowing the internal mood of
our Gurudev and all disciplic sucession, it is impossible to start the practice of
bhakti-yoga. Thats why we see so many aspirants going away from the path of
bhakti. It was told by many disciples of Prabhupad Saraswati Thakur that He first
wanted his disciples to learn the right tattva siddhanta and to be detached from
material enjoyment. Without it, there is no question to do progressive sadhanabhajan. In this regard, Srila Gour Govinda Goswami Maharaj said (Book- Sri
Guru-pad-padma, page 311): Iam stressing on tattva, in all my lectures I stress
on it- tattva-vichar. Do you know real tattva? You are all after this apparent
consideration- not tattva-vichar, that mistake is there. You do not know who you
are, who is Krsna, who is Guru, who is sadhu, what is the relationship, like thistattvas- you do not know.
Our Rasacharya Srila Rupa Goswami expressed what is the supreme speciality
of the prema that Sriman Mahaprabhu came to give:
anarpita-carim cirat karunayavatirnah kalau
samarpayitum unnatojjvala-rasam sva-bhakti-sriyam
harih purata-sundara-dyuti-kadamba-sandipitah
sada hrdaya-kandare sphuratu vah saci-nandanah
May the Supreme Lord who is known as the son of Srimati Saci-devi be
transcendentally situated in the innermost chambers of your heart. Resplendent
with the radiance of molten gold, He has appeared in the Age of Kali by His
causeless mercy to bestow what no incarnation has ever offered before: the most
sublime and radiant mellow of devotional service, the mellow of conjugal love.
(Sri Caitanya-caritamrta Adi 1.4)]
So, taking a deep consideration of all these statements and taking the dust of
my Gurudevs lotus feet upon my head, let us analyze the tattva-vichar or
absolute consideration of our Guru Parampara line as stated in the scriptures and
by previous bona fide Gaudiya Acharyas. Let us understand how they have
traced the Gaudiya Guru Parampara, how they use the term Rupanuga in the
real sense of the word, and what is the internal mood- rasa, of the Acharyas under
anugatya of Srila Rupa Goswami- who is chief comander of Chaitanya
Mahaprabhus army.
And from Srila Gurudev, (Audio below) From 8:20 Only a Guru in
madhurya rasa can help all.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=R_7J55HYT0o
All these evidences from Srila Gurudev and Srila Sridhar Goswami gives no
room for speculative and imaginary ideas regarding the mood of all Acharyas in
our line and their Supreme form of knowledge and devotional intensity.
In the listen given in Gurudevs book (Prabandha Pancakam) there are about
28 names. We see that in the song "Parampara" by Prabhupad, he included only
those in madhurya rasa and excluded all others wich mostly are in sakhya rasa
like Rasikananda, Gauri das etc... Its another evidence that only those who are
manjaris in their nitya-swarupa can really be called Rupanuga in true sense. He
says "Mahaprabhu ie. Radha Krsna" is the life and soul of Rupanugas, then he
start with the chief Rupa Goswami, then he writes all those who follow Him
internally...like Sanatan,Narottama,Viswanath, Baladev, Jagganath etc... he did
not include all 16 -17 Acharyas that are in sakhya rasa even though they also
came from Madhavendra Puri.
Lets see all the names given by Prabhupad and their respective forms in Sri Sri
Radha-Krsna lila: (See the photo of the same on the book written by Param
Pujyapad Srila Bhakti Ballabh Tirtha Goswami Maharaj, footnote #2)
Rupa Goswami- Rupa Manjari
Sanatan Goswami- Rati or Lavanga Manjari
Jiva Goswami- Vilas Manjari
Raghunath Das Goswami- Rasa or Rati Manjari, Bhanumati
Krsna Das Kaviraj Goswami- Kasturi Manjari, Ratnarekha
Narottama Thakur- Champak Manjari
Viswanath Chakravarti Thakur- Vinode Manjari
Baladev Vidyabhusan- Ratnavali Devi
Jagannath Das Babaji Maharaj- Rasika Manjari
Bhaktivinod Thakur- Kamala Manjari
Gaur Kshor Das Babaji Maharaj- Guna Manjari
Prabhupad Saraswati Thakur- Nayanamani Manjari
So, here we have another evidence of the bona fide line of Gaudiya Bhagavat
Parampara from the Jagad Guru Srila Bhaktissidhanta Saraswati Goswami
Thakur Prabhupad, wich is the supreme authority in all Gaudiya Maths and his
branches in whole world.
One may argue that Nityananda Prabhu is Akhanda Guru-tattva and that he is
Balaram in Krsna-lila and it contradict the role of Guru-tattva in Bhagavat
Parampara. For this Srila B.R.Sridhar-dev Goswami Maharaj says in his Sri
Guru and His Grace, page 59:
(2) Nitya-sakhis and (3) Prana-sakhis: these are the only two kinds of
sakhis who are in the category of tat-tad-bhvecchtmik. It is their service that
r Caitanya Mahprabhu ultimately came to bestow upon the jivas. These
sakhs serve both Sri Sri Rdh and Krsna, with a propensity to favor Rdhik
and render service to Her. If Krsna calls them, they do not come to Him; they
obey only Her.The prana-sakhis, like Rpa Manjari and Rati Manjari, being even
more intimately connected with Her are naturally the leaders of the nityasakhis.
Thus its confirmed that Baladev Vidyabhusana serves Sri Sri Radha Krsna in
the mood of manjaris- prana-sakhi.
it. The jivas of this world can not even imagine how many personalties can enter
in a single Nitya-siddha bhakta what to say about declaring opposite or new
opiniom of their stayibhav? Are they supposing that they are all in the same level
of Bhaktivinod Thakur and others like Him to venture unto these transcendental
subjects? Any other opiniom about Srila Baladev Vidyabhusans eternal position
and swarupa is just another absurd speculation from an unauthorized source.
the camp of Srimati Radharani, and that can never be compared with any
attainment hitherto known even in the eternal factor of time and space.
In the book Sri Guru and His Grace, by Srila B.R.Sridhar Goswami, Page
221, he says:
When Radha and Govinda are in secrecy, in a private place, the sakhis, who
are well-versed in the art of that kind of play, because they are a little grown-up,
do not like to approach there to disturb their confidential mixing. If the more
grown-up sakhis, enter there, both Radha and Govinda will feel shy. So, their
presence may create some disturbance. But the younger girls can enter there, and
then Radha and Govinda have no hesitation in free mixing. So, in that highest
stage of the mixing of Radha Govinda, the free play of Radha-Govinda,
these manjaris, the younger girls, can have admission. But the grown-up
sakhis cannot have admission there. New recruits may come up to the
manjari class. And the manjaris have that sort of special advantage under the
leadership of Sri Rupa Manjari. So, they get the best advantage there, the most
sacred type of pure service, which is not open even to the sakhis, is open to the
manjaris.That is found in Radharani's camp. So, the position of the
rupanugas, the followers of Sri Rupa, is the most profitable position. That
has been given out by Sri Caitanya Mahaprabhu. That has been shown by
Him, and that is fixed as the highest limit of our fortune in Krsna's concern.
This is unexpectable, undesignable and beyond hope, but our prospect lies there
in that subtle camp of Sri Rupa Manjari, Rupa Goswami. So, the camp, the
sampradaya of Sri Caitanya Mahaprabhu is known as the rupanuga
sampradaya. There our fate and our fortune is located. Now we have to conduct
ourself in such a way that naturally we can connect with that highest, purest
spiritual conception, from here. We must not allow ourselves to be satisfied
with anything less than this highest ideal. That should be the highest goal of
our life. And we must adjust our approach from our present position.
So here we have different Acharyas- Srila Gurudev and Srila Sridhar Maharaj
giving the same conception of the term Rupanuga. Those who really honor them
will just accept without any further and futile attempt to contradict or to jump
over their pure conclusions.
In Jaiva Dharma, page 620, chapter 29, while speaking about Sakhya rasa,
Goswami explain to Vrajanath about the 4 types of sakhya rasa bhaktas:
There are four types of sakhas in Vraj; 1- suhrt, 2-sakha, 3- priya sakha e 4priya narma sakha.
Next page its said: The special prerogative of the priya narma sakhas is to
assist in Krishnas madhurya lila. Like Dasas, they decorate Krsna with forest
flowers and render service such as fanning Him
So, we see that the priya narma sakhas are described as being in sakhya rasa by
Bhaktivinod Thakur and also Rupa Goswamipad. We also see, even when related
to madhurya lila, the priya narma sakhas are said to assist Krishna and render
service to Him- like dasas (and only to some extent). To hear directly from
Gurudev, please hear link below (from min.6:25):
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XQu2iEoMnvM
Lets see what sastra tell us about the position of the stayibhav and if it can be
changed when mixed with another bhavas. In Jaiva Dharma, chapter 30"Those who relish a particular rasa are eternally sheltered in that one specific
rasa, which for them remains radiant as angi-rasa. Other rasas, even though they
may be mukhya, function in the capacity of angas of this prevailing angi-rasa.
By this statement from Jaiva Dharma we have evidence that even though priya
narma sakhas may do some seva in madhurya-lila related to Krishna and only to
some extent, still they can never loose their sthaibhav wich is sakhya bhav. Its not
possible as we see also from Rupa Goswmaipad:
Our dear Nemi Maharaj have refuted all their misconceptions in his page in FB,
please kindly read in the link below
https://www.facebook.com/bvnemi/posts/10154322579558782:4
bhava, focus on Gopi-janavallabha, and the other two words, krsnaya and
govindaya, will be adjectives of gopi-janavallabhaya.
[Pujyapada Madhava Maharaja:] Baladeva Prabhu is also an example of this.
He has vatsalya (parental mood), sakhya (the mood of a cowherd friend), dasya
(the mood of a servant), and even madhurya (the mood of a gopi) in the form of
Ananga Manjari.
[Srila Narayan Gosvami Maharaja:] But others - like Nanda Baba and Yasoda,
Vasudeva and Devaki, Uddhava, and Akrura - cannot add other rasas to their
already eternally existing rasa.
If one has a sthayi-bhava (the foundational ecstasy of a particular relationship
with Krsna) in only one mood, he will always be in that one mood.
One can have two spiritual forms - in the pastimes of Sri Caitanya Mahaprabhu
and in the pastimes of Sri Krsna - and this is from the beginning of one's
devotional practices.
[Dhruva dasa:] Gurudeva, does the soul somehow separate to be in two forms in
two pastimes?
[Srila Narayan Gosvami Maharaja:] Krsna is akhanda-tattva. Akhanda means
undivided, or whole. So how can He manifest in millions of forms? We cannot
imagine anything inconceivable, even in this world. How have the trees come?
Seeds come from trees, and trees again come from seeds. Flowers come and
leaves come. How? We cannot imagine this. So, everything about Sri Krsna is
inconceivable.
[Dhruva dasa:] Consciousness is always expanding and Krsna is always
expanding. So do Krsna's devotees also expand, even in their perfect spiritual
forms?
[Srila Narayan Gosvami Maharaja:] Yes. For example, Mother Yasoda has
unlimited forms. Wherever Krsna is, she is. This is true for Nanda Baba also, and
for Madhu-mangala and all of Krsna's other associates as well. But their rasa
(their particular relationship with Krsna) will be the same.
By this statement Gurudev very clearly is saying that such topics like nitya
swarupa, can never be understood by human mind-intelect and any attempt to do
They also quote some slokas wich says that Priya narma sakhas assist Krishna
in madhurya lila and that they have some madhurya or sakhi-bhav. But none of
these statements can change their sthayibhav as being in sakhya-rasa, thus not
allowing them to enter the kunjas to serve Radha Govinda togueter in their
intimate madhurya-lila. Mostly they serve only Krsna even when related to
madhurya lila. The most confidential nitya seva of Radha Govinda lila is
performed only by the manjaris, even asta sakhis who have much more higher
bhavas than priya narma sakhas can not, what to say the gopas? This conception
is also according to Srila Sridhar Maharaj, book Loving search for the lost
servaint, page 102:
And serving those who can serve Radharani is the way to approach Her
vicinity. By serving the servants of the servants, we are assured of success in
getting the grace of Krsna. If somehow one can be counted in the group of
Srimati Radharani's servitors, one's future is assured.
Within the group of Radharani's servitors, we aspire to be rupanugas, followers
of Sri Rupa. And the followers of Sri Rupa will have great earnestness to look
after the order of Sri Rupa, as he does towards Lalita. In this way, through Rupa
Goswami, our devotional service is going to the highest plane. And our highest
gain is only there. Not even our connection with Radharani or Lalitadevi is
the highest goal of life, but our highest aspiration is to serve in the
Rupanuga-sampradaya; that means that our highest attainment is in Sri
Rupa's connection.
Radha-dasyam has been said to be the highest attainment. Why? The quality and
quantity of rasa that Radharani can draw from Krsna can never be found
anywhere else. So if you are situated just behind Radharani, you'll be allowed to
taste not only the quantity, but the highest quality of rasa.
No other person can draw such high rasa from Krsna. The fullest, highest type of
quality is drawn from Krsna: He gives Himself fully and wholly and deeply. So if
you are in Sri Rupa's group, then you can have a taste of that sort of rasa.
In Radharani's camp, when Krsna and Radha are enjoying very solitary pastimes
in a secluded place, the grownup sakhis can't venture to enter the room and assist
Them. The young girls, the manjaris, are sent there. The leader of that young
group can enter where both Radha and Govinda are very closely connected, when
even the sakhis do not venture to go for fear of causing some interruption. But
Rupa and the manjaris can enter there at that time due to their young age. That
sort of rasa that cannot be had even through the sakhis can be had only through
the manjaris.
Bhaktivinoda Thakura prays to gain admission there. He has such a high quality
of aspiration. He says rupanuga hoite sei doy. He runs to be enlisted in the group
of Rupa, who can grant us that sort of prospect. And Prabhodananda Saraswati
has described the prerequisite for understanding all these things:
yatha yatha gaura padaravinde
vindeta bhaktim krta punya-rasih
tatha tathotsarpati hrdy akasmat
radha padambhoja sudhambhurasih
"As much as you surrender to the lotus feet of Sri Gaurahga, you'll find yourself
safely situated in the service of Radha-Govinda. Don't try to approach RadhaGovinda directly; if you do, there may be some difficulty. But the lotus feet of Sri
Gauranga will take you there safely."
Here Srila Sridhar Goswami very clearly says that we should submit ro Radhika
through the manjaris only. If priya narma sakhas are also in madhurya rasa why
Acharyas would say "Only through the manjaris?". If we read the kirtans written
by Bhaktivinod Thakur and Narottama Thakur we never see them praying to
Subala or Ujjwal, if they can give madhurya rasa why they never prayed to them?
But in other hand we see in all the songs like in Jugal arati: "Priya narma sakhi
yata camara dulay". Tulsi arati: "Koro nija dasi". "Ei baro koruna koro Lalita
Vishaka". "Sri Rupa Manjari pada" and many others. They have never prayed to
priya narma sakhas in their song. Thus our goal and the process to attain it was
very clearly stated by our bonafide Acharyas.
All Gaudiya Acharyas have fixed the same supreme goal and
devotion
Same book- Revealed Truth, page 405, Srila Govinda Maharaj, Sucessor
Acharya appointed directly by Srila Sridhar Maharaj, writes:
If you want entrance into Kr rs rn ra-lls special chamber of paramour love then
you must go to the sakhs, Rdhrn rs associates. All rights are reserved by the
sakhs in those Pastimes. You must go to the sakhs, surrender to them, and
get a visa from them to enter those Pastimes. If the sakhs do not give you a
visa then no oneneither Kr s n a, nor Lord iva, nor anyonecan give you
entrance into the Pastimes of paramour love. Laks rm Dev Herself was denied
a visa. All rights are reserved by the sakhs. In r Chaitanya-charitmr rta it is
written, sakh vin ei ll pus rt ra nhi haya, sakh ll vistriy, sakh svdaya
(r Chaitanya-charitmr rta: Madhya-ll, 8.203The sakhs provide all the
nourishment necessary for r r Rdh-Kr rs rn ras Pastimes of paramour love.
The sakhs personally taste these Pastimes, and only they have the power to
distribute them. No one else has the right to taste them, and without the sakhs
consent no one gets entrance into them.Rdhrn r is the leader of all the groups
of sakhs. She has eight principle sakhs: Lalit, Vikh, Chitra,
Champakalatik, Tuga Vidy, Indulekh, Sudev, and Raga Devik. They are
the group leaders of all the servitors of Rdh-Kr rs rn ra. The majars, the younger
sakhs, serve under the eight primary sakhs. The majars are led by Rpa
Majar and her associates: Lavaga Majar, Anaga Majar, Rati Majar,
Gun ra Majar, and so on. Rdhrn r serves Kr rs rn ra directly while all of Her
associates assist Her under the guidance of Lalit Dev and Rpa Majar.
Rdhrn r also sometimes sends Kr rs rn ra to satisfy the sakhs. The sakhs do not
expect they will associate with Kr rs rn ra alone, but Rdhrn r makes many tactful
arrangements for them. Rdhrn r wants to satisfy Kr rs rn ra and side by side all of
Kr rs rn ras servitors.
In this way the Pastimes of Rdh-Kr s n a go on, and service-entrance into
those Pastimes is only available by surrendering to the sakhs. Without their
mercy no one can expect to serve Rdhrn or Kr s n a. The service of
Rdhrn is very rare to get, and without the mercy of the sakhs no one
will get it. The sakhs give power to the majars, so if anyone can receive
the mercy of Rpa Majar, the leader of the majars, then they will get full
entrance into the service world of Goloka Vr ndvan. If we proceed properly
we must get the association and mercy of the Divine Couples associates, the
sakhs, one day. That is our lifes goal. But before that it is necessary for us to
understand the identities of Kr rs rn ra, Rdhrn r, and Their associates, as well as
our own identity and necessity. We need realisation of these things, and we need
to approach that highest plane through the proper channel. If we can approach
properly then we reach our lifes goal.
First, some are of the opiniom that Srila Swami Maharaj (Prabhupad) is in
sakhya rasa and they quote the Jaladutta prayer. There sometime He used to call
Krsna as friend etc But we see, same poem, in the main part- the refrain, lets
see what he wrote:
(refrain)
kr rs rn rataba pun rya habe bhi
e-pun rya koribe jabe rdhrn r khus habe
dhruva ati boli tom ti
I emphatically say to you, O brothers, you will obtain your good fortune from
the Supreme Lord Kr rs rn raonly when rmat Rdhrn becomes pleased with
you.
So, in the same poem wich is the one of very few evidences they have to try
to prove that He is a sakha in Golok, even there he says that Only when
Radharani becomes pleased with you. It clearly indicates that He is a Rupanuga
Acarya, because only the Rupanugas are inclinated to Radhika and serves
Krishna only because of His conection with Radhika, and never alone.
We must also remember that its not because Jiva Goswamipad have written
something about favoring swakiya bhav that he is established on that mood and
also it is not because Sanatana Goswami have written about Gopa Kumara and
sakhya rasa in his Brhad Bhagavatamrta, that he is also gopa in Krishnas lila.
We all know that they both are manjaris in Radha-Krsna lila, there is no doubt
about it. Thus one should be carefull before dare to declare about any nitya
siddha swarupa. Only another nitya siddha can declare it being also situated in
transcendental platform.
Now, they also say that Srila Sridhar Maharaj sometimes told Srila Swami
Maharaj is inclinated to sakhya rasa. We also know that most of Swami Maharaj
disciples used to believe that he was a gopa and to not cause any disharmony its
true sometimes Sridhar Goswami told it, but even so lets see what he told some
other times about same subject:
Devotee: Maharaj, it has been clear now, in a way, that Prabhupada (Srila
Bhaktivedanta Swami Maharaj) was in the sakhya rasa?
Srila Sridhar Maharaj: At least temporarily he has showed like that. What he
has expressed there in that journey there, it is almost clear that he liked that sort
of lila best, but it may be, it might have been suppressed purposely; it also
cannot be denied, maybe. That is one thing. There may be such a possibility,
and he has given, he has said that Radharani was his Gurudeva. His
Gurudeva was Radharani, but he himself was thinking that perhaps
madhurya rasa should not be distributed in the first instalment. That might
have been his view.
So, here we see that what our Gurudev told is also expressed by Sridhar
Goswami. Imagine the situation if Swami Maharaj would speak at that time that
he was a gopi serving in the most confidential Radha-Krsnas lila. What that boys
and girls would think? How they would digest such high truths?
Now, lets see Srila Gurudev words on this topic. Book Gaura vani Pracarine,
page 110:
He (Srila Swami Maharaj) used to sing daily, Jaya Radha Madhava Kunja
Bihari Gopi jana vallabha jaya giri vara dhari. He has so much transcendental
greed to serve Kunja-bihari. A cowerd boy does not have these sentiments and
exalted conceptions. He saw that there were only a few in this world who were
qualified for this; the number could be counted in ones fingers. Thus in order
to gradually bring his audiences to a levelbof understanding, he preached
about Jagannath-dev and established Deities of Sita-Rama and Sri KrsnaBalaram.
By this, we have two exalted Acharyas who have told same thing, but Gurudev
was always very emphatically to declare that Swami Maharaj is in madhurya
rasa, gopi bhav. And its not so extraordinary because it was Swami Maharaj
himself who appointed Gurudev to do his last sacred ceremony, even though
there were many of his god brothers like Srila Krsna Das Babaji Maharaj (who is
the only Prabhupads disciple knowed to be in sakhya rasa), Srila Bhakti Hrday
Bon Goswami and others. So, naturally it was Gurudev who openly told who
Swami Maharaj really is in his nitya swarupa. Some take this lila very cheaply
but who knows vedic traditions well, know the high importance of this virahamahotsava. (Gurudev wrote the gopi mantra on His forehead to give Him
udipana for his entrance unto Radha-Krsna lila). To hear Gurudev directly, here is
the linkhttp://sbnmcd.org/all_mp3/1982-1995/19921120_21BOMBAY%20SB
%2010_31_8%20CONT%20NOV%2020%20EKADASI%20TALK%20IN
%20SRILA%20PRABHUPADAS%20ROOM%20P1.mp3
FROM 1:19:00, Link above Gurudev intimate seva and revelation about SP:
"His Aradhyadev was Radhika" ... "I did same as i did for my Gurudev (Srila
Keshav Maharaj)" .... "I gave him some udipana for that Radhikas seva, manjariseva" ... "Your mood should be changed, that he is in madurya and not only in
saklhya rasa" .. "It may take many many births for you to realize this truth" ...
"He is engaged in nikunja yuno .. but i know it will take time to you to realize all
these things. Only those who received the actual mercy from Sri Guru, will see
all these things".
Also, in His book Loving search for the loving servaint Srila B.R.Sridhar
Goswami says, page 98:
Thus Sridhar Goswami many times indicated that Swami Maharaj is really a
gopi, always inclinated to Radhika. He always considered Swami Maharaj a true
Acharya in Rupanuga line, and as he told in the audio given before: They are all
in madhurya rasa.
From -http://www.purebhakti.com/teachers/bhakti-discourses-mainmenu61/21-discourses-2002/222-guru-in-full-a-manifestation-of-radhika.html- we
read:
We see in our guru-gayatri, krsnanandaya dhimahi. This refers to both Krsna
and Krsnaa. [Spelled in Sanskrit, k-r-s-n-a with a long 'a' at the end.] A male can
serve Krsna, but no male can serve Krsnaa. Krsnaa is Radhika. Therefore, in his
service to Radhika, for rati-keli-siddhyai, the perfection of Radha-Krsna conjugal
love, a guru cannot serve in his male form. Parama-pujyapada Srila
Bhaktivedanta Svami Maharaja and my Gurudeva are both serving there in their
female forms as gopis. In that realm my Gurudeva is Vinoda Manjari, Srila
Prabhupada Bhaktisiddanta Sarasvati Thakura is Nayana Manjari, Srila
Bhaktivinoda Thakura is Kamala Manjari, Srila Jiva Gosvami is Vilasa Manjari,
Srila Rupa Gosvami is Rupa Manjari, and Srila Raghunatha dasa Gosvami is Rati
Manjari. These manjaris can serve Sri Sri Radha-Krsna.
Srila Narayana Maharaja: "If you fully surrender, by body, mind, words and
ego, then I may tell you. Otherwise, I will not. I know who he is, but you do not
know. None of the ISKCON leaders know. Your Prabhupada has cheated them
all, in the sense that he has not revealed himself to them at all.''
From the above quotes from Srila Gurudev and Srila Puri Goswami, we have
examples on how sometimes the Acharya do not preach thet same internal mood
that he himself have to others, but give instructions according to the quality of
disciples. What more clear evidence we may have other the Great Rasika
Acharya, the Speaker of Srimad Bhagavat-Sukadeva Goswami who is well
known to be The Parrot of Radhika but considering the qualification of his
audience (Rsis, MahaRsis) did not spoke a single one name of Radha directly?
We have seem also in Parampujyapad Srila Bhakti Ballabh Tirtha Goswami
Maharaj also, he used to preach so much about the biographys of Dhruv and
Prahlad, but we know very well that he is also a manjari in Radha-Krishna lila
and he also revealed his nitya seva to the Divine Couple. He revealed it himself
some years ago to his intimate disciples and I myself have heard everything
about it from their mouth.
Many times if we conclude the internal mood of Sri Guru and Vaishnava
according to his preaching only, then we may be cheated as also we see in the
case of Jiva Goswami and also Sanatana Goswami (who wrote about sakhya-rasa
in his Brhad Bhagavatamrta). So, one should always be carefull while judging
the swarupa of Guru-vaisnava. Its better that we go to Bhagavat Parampara and
see what are their mood of devotion as we see in our Gaudiya parampara all have
same mood- madhurya rasa, manjari bhav.
The hidden matters can only be known by the special mercy of Sri Krishna
and not otherwise. They are not to be divulged to all persons indiscriminately.
This explanation offered by the Goswamis is not opposed to the open treatment
of the same subject by Sri Jayadeva and others writers. In spite of the Gita
Govinda and its companion works, the subject of the relationship of Sri Radhika
I end this compilation with these words from Srila Gurudev (The hidden path of
devotion, page 60):
We shall always try to be in anugatya of our Gurudev, Param-Gurudev, Srila
Bhaktissidhanta Saraswati Thakur- who is Nayana Manjari; ParatparaParamgurudev Srila Bhaktivinod Thakur who is Kamala Manjari, Narottama
Thakur who is Vilasa Manjari, Rupa Manjari, Ananga Manjari, Lavanga Manjari
and so on. This is the Line of Anugatya-dharma, wich we never disobey.
Footnote #1
Footnote # 2