Professional Documents
Culture Documents
National Key Laboratory of Industrial Control Technology, Institute of Advanced Process Control, Zhejiang University, Hangzhou 310027, China
b
College of Chemical Engineering and Materials Science, Zhejiang University of Technology, Hangzhou 310032,
China
Abstract A new kinetic model for commercial unit of toluene disproportionation and C9-armatiocs transalkylation
is developed based on the reported reaction scheme. A time based catalyst deactivation function taking weight
hourly space velocity (WHSV) into account is incorporated into the model, which reasonably accounts for the loss
in activity because of coke deposition on the surface of catalyst during long-term operation. The kinetic parameters
are benchmarked with several sets of balanced plant data and estimated by the differential variable metric optimization method. Sets of plant data at different operating conditions are applied to make sure validation of the model
and the results show a good agreement between the model predictions and plant observations. The simulation
analysis of key variables such as temperature and WHSV affecting process performance is discussed in detail, giving the guidance to select suitable operating conditions.
Keywords toluene disproportionation and C9-armatiocs transalkylation, kinetic model, catalyst deactivation function, parameter estimation, simulation analysis
INTRODUCTION
As is well known, benzene (B) is a key raw material for many intermediates of petrochemicals , and
xylenes (X) are important starting materials for the
production of synthetic fibers, plasticizers, and resin.
The convenient ways to get more valuable benzene
and xylenes from surplus toluene (C7) and trimethylbenzenes (C9) consists in the processes such as toluene disproportionation[1], toluene alkylation with
methanol[2] or toluene disproportionation and transalkylation with trimethylbenzenes[3]. The rapidly growing demand for benzene and xylenes urges development of all mentioned processes above.
Reaction kinetics study has shown to be a crucial
research subject for process development which provides valuable data for reactor design, process optimization, process control, and cycle length prediction.
The advantage of utilizing rigorous kinetic models as
compared to empirical approaches is related to the fact
that the prediction accuracy of rigorous models can be
significantly superior over a wide operating range,
hence researchers are in pursuit of kinetic model of
process industries. As to toluene disproportionation
(TDP), many kinetic models have been proposed over
several zeolites[47], but few models appeared for
toluene disproportionation and transalkylation with
trimethylbenzenes[8,9] although their reaction scheme
and mechanism were investigated widely[3,10,11].
Catalysis by zeolites always accompanies coke deposition causing deactivation problem during long-term
operation[12], and two major mechanism of coke
deposition had been proposed for the catalyst fouling:
pore plugging and site coverage which reduced diffu-
sivity of reactants or available acid site number respectively[7]. As far as catalyst decay is concerned,
only a few works[8,1315] can be found in the reported literatures in spite of commercial use of zeolites as catalysts for TDP and aromatics transalkylation to produce benzene and xylenes.
Zeolite catalyst is inevitably deposited by coke
with extending operation period, and the coke formation in the reactions is responsible for the loss of catalyst activity and must be incorporated into kinetic
models. The purpose of this study is to develop a
practical kinetic model for industrial application taking catalyst deactivation into account under representative industrial operation regimes, namely at high
reaction pressure and wide conversion range. Sensitivity of process variables is analyzed based on the developed model. The kinetic scheme employed in this
modeling work is largely based on previously published studies.
2
Kinetic Model and Simulation Analysis for Toluene Disproportionation and C9-Aromatics Transalkylation
Main reactions:
(1)
(2)
2
a a
(10)
r2 = k2 aTol
B EB
K2
a a
r3 = k3 aTol aTMB X X
K3
(3)
a a
r4 = k4 aTol aTMB EB EB
K4
Dealkylation (irreversible):
r5 = k5 aMEB
(4)
Side reactions:
ble):
(5)
(6)
(13)
(17)
rPB = r6
(18)
rMEB = r5
(19)
rTMB = r3 + r4 + r7
(20)
(21)
rC10 A = 0.5r7
(12)
aX aC10 A
2
(15)
r7 = k7 aTMB
K7
Hence the net rate equations of the key compositions such as benzene (B), toluene (Tol), propylbenze
(PB), methylethylbenzene (MEB), trimethylbenzenes
(TMB), ethylbenzene (EB), xylenes (X), and C10A are
given by
rB = 0.5r1 + 0.5r2 + r6
(16)
(8)
(11)
r6 = k6 aPB
(14)
Trimethylebenzenes diproportionation (reversi-
rTol = r1 + r2 + r3 + r4 r5
(7)
327
(22)
(23)
328
of catalyst to characterize deactivation as van Trimpont et al.[18] did during naphtha reforming, and the
reactant converted decay model was successfully
used for xylene transformation in a riser simulator[19].
In this work, a time-based empirical catalyst deactivation function is proposed taking hydrogen partial
pressure and weight hourly space velocity into account
as follows:
= exp( t ) Ph WHSV
(24)
where is catalyst deactivation constant; t is on
stream time, d; Ph is hydrogen pressure, kPa; is
pressure exponent; WHSV is weight hourly space ve
locity, h 1; and is space velocity exponent.
As to hydrogen partial pressure, it can be obtained:
Ph =
(m
1 + (m
H 2 / HC
) P
)Y
t
whre mH 2
HC
1
(25)
dl
K 2 = K ep2
M B M EB
2
M Tol
(28)
M X2
M Tol M TMB
(29)
2
M EB
K 4 = K ep4
M Tol M TMB
(30)
K3 = K ep3
K 7 = K ep7
M X2 M C10 A
(31)
2
M TMB
where M denotes molecular weight, gmol 1; Kep denotes thermodynamic constant, and is determined by
G
K epi = exp i ,
(32)
( i = 14,7)
RT
aPX = yPX aX
(36)
aOX = yOX aX
(37)
aMX = yMX aX
(38)
(35)
then
H2
H 2 / HC
Rb2
da j
, a j (0) = a j 0
WHSV Vc L c dt
(39)
where Rb is radius of catalyst bed, m; l is dimensionless length of bed; L is length of catalyst bed, m;
Vc is catalyst volume, m3; is feedstock density,
(1 ) 2
(1 )
dP
G + 1.50103 3
G
= 1.75105 3
dz
g d p
g d p
(40)
where is bed void fraction; is viscosity of gas
passing through the bed, Pas; g is density of gaseous
gases, kgm 2s 1.
3 MODEL PARAMETERS ESTIMATION
3.1 Catalyst deactivation parameters estimation
In the commercial operation of catalytic reactors,
the effects of catalyst inactivation are often encountered by increasing the catalyst temperature with time
on stream in order to achieve a constant conversion of
reactant to products[21]. Hence the loss of catalyst
activity is compensated by the raised reaction temperature during long-term operation. In this case, Sz
pe and Levenspie[22] derived an important condition
for the extremal policy as follows:
d (k )
=0
(41)
dt
which means that the effective rate constant should be
kept unchanged during the entire process.
As mentioned earlier, rate constants obey Arrhenius law and Eq.(41) can be rewritten as
E
k0 exp a
RT
= C
(42)
Kinetic Model and Simulation Analysis for Toluene Disproportionation and C9-Aromatics Transalkylation
Table 1
H2 purity,
%
7.64
1.11
84.75
7.56
1.12
84.53
3.13
7.58
1.17
84.40
3.13
6.92
1.24
83.74
3.13
7.66
1.18
82.51
Date
Time on stream,
d
Reaction temperature,
Reaction pressure,
MPa
H2/HC,
molmol 1
20050401
69
347.56
3.12
20050404
72
348.56
3.12
20050412
80
349.67
20050418
88
351.61
20050430
98
352.07
Date
329
Tol
PB
MEB
TMB
EB
PX
MX
OX
C10A
Non-aromatics
20050401
0.01
58.28
1.98
12.78
22.77
0.03
0.06
0.15
0.92
2.65
0.37
20050404
0.00
58.71
2.18
13.33
21.87
0.01
0.01
0.03
0.33
3.12
0.41
20050412
0.03
58.80
2.05
13.33
22.45
0.00
0.01
0.01
0.20
2.58
0.54
20050418
0.01
59.64
1.90
12.73
22.57
0.00
0.01
0.01
0.26
2.49
0.38
20050430
0.00
60.12
1.84
12.87
22.35
0.01
0.01
0.02
0.25
2.50
0.03
The deactivation function is assumed to be invariable in a certain day. This is absolutely reasonable
because of the catalysts stable performance during
long-term operation. The function is supposed to be
1 at the conditions of t = 0 and T0 = 614.53K , then
E
(43)
k0 exp a = C
RT0
Substituting Eq.(24) into Eq.(42) and combining
Eq.(43), then rearranging, leads to the following
relationship
1 1
(44)
T0 T
Parameters can be estimated by the least square
method with large number of data from commercial
unit. In this case, the deactivation function becomes
t + ln Ph + ln WHSV =
Ea
R
(45)
= exp(0.0006t ) WHSV
3.2
1.3781
(46)
k0 and parts of them are shown in Table 1. The frequency factors are optimized by the differential variable metric optimization method and the estimated
results are listed in Table 2. The detail procedures
about parameter estimation can be found in Xu et al.[9].
Table 2
Reaction
ki, s1
k0i, s1
Eai, kJmol1
326.222
9.1061010
13
102
36.221
9.53410
554.664
5.7121010
150
22.799
6.0011013
150
227.994
6.1261010
101.8
381.221
3.2631010
95.8
5.369
3.213109
106
96.77
4 MODELING RESULTS
4.1 Model validation
In order to demonstrate the efficiency of the developed model, two important performance indexes
are introduced, namely deviation (E) and average absolute error (Eaae) as below
E = a j a j
(47)
11
Eaae = a j a j
(48)
j =1
where a j and a j denote the concentration of component j and corresponding model output respectively.
The model is confirmed by simulation at different
operating conditions with the estimated parameters, and
the predictions are consonant with plant observations
greatly. The deviations vary from 1.79% to 1.24%
(by mass), while those from the model[9] developed
previously vary from 1.09% to 2.51% (by mass),
which convinces the better fitness of the proposed
Chin. J. Ch. E. 15(3) 326 (2007)
330
Table 3. As shown in the plot, toluene disproportionation and C9-aromatics transalkylation result in decrease of feedstock, and at the same time lead to the
increase in products such as benzene and xylenes,
which agrees with the tendency observed in the commercial unit quite well.
Date
Time on stream,
d
Reaction temperature,
Reaction pressure,
MPa
H2/HC,
molmol1
WHSV,
h1
H2 purity,
%
20050122
341.38
3.11
7.90
1.04
88.66
20050701
159
353.80
3.13
8.05
1.15
83.29
20051004
252
357.79
3.14
7.10
1.29
81.56
Date
Tol
PB
MEB
TMB
EB
PX
MX
OX
C10A
Non-aromatics
20050122
0.00
65.81
1.57
11.64
19.02
0.00
0.01
0.01
0.28
1.64
0.01
20050701
0.00
59.76
1.89
12.71
22.10
0.01
0.01
0.02
0.24
3.20
0.03
20051004
0.00
59.74
1.82
12.28
22.23
0.02
0.02
0.01
0.28
3.55
0.04
Pressure
drop, MPa
1.87
Average
absolute
error, %
0.71
2.14
0.40
0.02
1.90
0.029
2.45
0.26
This
work
9.76 38.30 0.36 4.60 10.09 2.25 7.03 15.69 6.69 3.13
2.10
0.23
0.032
Obser.
9.36 38.38 0.02 4.52 10.72 2.12 7.20 16.00 6.75 3.00
Date
Tol
PB MEB TMB EB
PX
MX
OX C10A
Non-aromatics
1.92
0.029
2.38
0.52
This
work
9.40 38.13 0.46 5.37 10.86 2.13 6.70 14.96 6.38 3.50
2.11
0.60
0.037
Obser.
8.58 37.53 0.02 4.09 10.86 2.01 7.50 16.75 7.06 3.43
2.15
0.029
Figure 1
June, 2007
Kinetic Model and Simulation Analysis for Toluene Disproportionation and C9-Aromatics Transalkylation
4.2
Simulation analysis
The kinetic model is useful for simulation analysis of process variables, giving the guidance to select
suitable operating conditions. The effect of variables
such as on-stream time, reaction temperature, and
weight hourly space velocity on the process performance is investigated below.
The coke deposition on the catalyst surface is noticed during long time operation. Activity of the catalyst
is reduced because of coke formation and the reaction
temperature must be raised to compensate the loss in
activity in order to maintain conversion at a certain level.
As expected, more coke accumulates as time goes on.
Generally speaking, the higher temperature is
favorable to the main reactions for their endothermic
character. As indicated in Fig.2, the same trend of total
conversion and temperature appears, but the conversion goes no further in spite of increase in temperature
because of thermodynamic control reactions. Meanwhile, higher temperature causes more rapid catalyst
fouling; hence, balance between conversion and reaction temperature should be kept during operation.
Figure 2
CONCLUSIONS
A rigorous kinetic model taking deactivation
function into account is developed and simulation results show validation of the model that supports reactor design, process optimization and process control.
The simulation analysis of variables to process performance is studied in the paper and the results indicate the importance of maintaining the operating conditions that would achieve a proper balance between
severity and catalyst activity, which directs our selection.
NOMENCLATURE
a
a
dp
E
Ea
G
G
K
Kep
k
k0
L
l
mH 2 HC
mass fraction, %
model output mass fraction, %
diameter of catalyst particle, m
deviation
activation energy, kJmol1
superficial mass velocity of gases, kgm2s1
Ph
Pt
R
Rb
r
T
t
Vc
WHSV
w
w1
YH 2
c
g
mole fraction, %
catalyst deactivation constant, d1
pressure exponent
space velocity exponent
bed void fraction
viscosity of gas passing through the bed, Pas
feedstock density, kgm3
catalyst density in the bed, kgm3
density of gaseous mixture through the reactor, kgm3
catalyst deactivation function
REFERENCES
1
3
4
Figure 3 Relationship between temperature,
deactivation function and WHSV
331
332
5
6
7
10
11
12
13
Bhavikattl, S.S., Patwardhan, S.R., Toluene disproportionation over nickel-loaded aluminum-deficient mordenite (2) Kinetics, Ind. Eng. Chem. Res., 20(1), 106
109(1981).
Bhaskar, G.V., Do, D.D., Toluene disproportionantion reaction over HZSM-5 zeolites: Kinetics and mechanism,
Ind. Eng. Chem. Res., 29(3), 355361(1990).
Tsai, T.C., Chen, W.H., Lai, C.S., Liu, S.B., Wang, I., Ku,
C.S., Kinetics of toluene disproportionation over fresh
and coked H-mordenite, Catal. Today, 97, 297
302(2004).
Liu, H.X., Reaction characteristics and kinetic study for
toluene disproportionation and C9-araomatics transalkylation over zeolites, Master Thesis, East China University of Science & Technology, Shanghai(2001). (in
Chinese)
Xu, O.G., Su, H.Y., Jin, X.M., Chu, J., Kinetic model for
toluene disproportionation and transalkylation with
C9-Aromatics, Journal of Chemical Industry and Engineering (China), 58(3), 630637(2007). (in Chinese)
Das, J., Bhat, Y.S., Halgeri, A.B., Transalkylation and
disproportionation of toluene and C9 aromatics over zeolite beta, Catal. Lett., 23, 161168(1994).
Dumitriu, E., Guimon, C., Hulea, V., Lutic, D., Fechete,
I., Transalkylation of toluene with trimethylbenzenes
catalyzed by various AFI catalysts, Appl. Catal. A: Gen.,
237, 211221(2002).
Bibby, D.M., Howe, R.F., McLellan, G.D., Coke formation in high-silica zeolites, Appl. Catal. A: Gen., 93(1),
134(1992).
Meshram, N.R., Hegde, S.G., Kulkarmi, S.B., Ratnasamy,
June, 2007
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
P., Disproportionation of toluene over HZSM-5 zeolites, Appl. Catal. A: Gen., 8, 359367(1983).
Bharati, S.P., Bhatia, S., Deactivation kinetics of toluene
disproportionation over hydrogen mordenite catalyst,
Ind. Eng. Chem. Res., 26(9), 18541860(1987).
Uguina, M.A., Sotelo, J.L., Serrano, D.P., Valverde, J.L.,
Deactivation kinetics of para-selective toluene disproportionation over modified ZSM-5, Ind. Eng. Chem.
Res., 33(1), 2631(1994).
Jacob, S.M., Gross, B., Weekman, Jr. V.W., A lumping
and reaction scheme for catalytic cracking, AIChE J.,
22(4), 701713(1976).
Taskar. U., Riggs, J.B., Modeling and optimization of a
semiregenerative catalytic naphtha reformer, AIChE J.,
43(3), 740753(1997).
van Trimpont, P.A., Marin, G.B., Froment, G.F., Reforming of C7 hydrocarbons on sulfided commercial Pt/Al2O3
catalyst, Ind. Eng. Chem. Res., 27(1), 5157(1988).
Al-Khattaf, S., Tukur, N.M., Al-Amer, A., Modeling
xylene reactions over ZSM-5 zeolite in a riser simulator:
1,2-versus 1,2-Methyl Shift, Ind. Eng. Chem. Res.,
44(21), 79577968(2005).
Froment, G.F., Bischoff, K.B., Chemical Reactor Analysis and Design, 2nd edition., Prentice Hall, NJ (1992).
Krishnaswamy, S., Kittrell, J.R., Impact of diffusional
limitations on temperature-time profiles for deactivating
catalysts, Ind. Eng. Chem. Fundam., 21, 9597(1982).
Szpe, S., Levenspie, O., Optimal temperature policies
for reactors subject to catalyst deactivation () Batch
reactor, Chem. Eng. Sci., 23, 881894(1968).