Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Abstract
In dealing with heterogeneous thick formations, objectivity of
well-to-well correlation is often hard to maintain and this is
the case for a volcanic formation, the Minami-Nagaoka gas
field. To overcome this difficulty, the refractive index is
utilized to identify the different types of plagioclase, with
which the well-to-well correlation is established in an
objective manner and the formation is divided into six
volcanic bodies.
One of the identified bodies corresponds to the productive
zone encountered in the southern region of the field. This
volcanic body is glassy rhyolite and extensively distributed
throughout the field, even toward the northern region, where
the productivity is poor. To explain the regional difference in
productivity, various types of alterations are examined,
including devitrification, montmorillonitization, chloritization,
illitization, and albit ization.
Identifying the primary volcanic bodies and examining the
secondary alterations enables us to construct a geological
model of the subject volcanic formation. Integrated geological
interpretation yields a clear view of the formation and a
reasonable explanation to the productivity aspects.
Introduction
The Minami-Nagaoka gas field, 3 miles (north-south) by 1
mile (east-west), is located in the northern central region of
Japan (Fig. 1). There are 17 wells completed in the main
reservoir, occurring at a depth of 12,500 ft with the initial
pressure of 8,100 psi and the temperature of 350F. Deepseated volcanic rocks (rhyolite) of the Middle Miocene age
form this gas reservoir and are referred to as green tuff
because of the characteristic greenish color. As a consequence
of repeated volcanisms, rhyolite eruptions were deposited one
after another forming a thick formation (over 2,600 ft) with a
drastic change of lithofacies, divided into lava, breccia, and
hyaloclastite.1
Core analyses show that the permeability of breccia facies
ranges from 0.1 to 10 md, while most of the hyaloclastite
facies yields low values of less than 0.1 md. The average
porosity is around 15% in both facies. Lava facies is
characterized by the average porosity value less than that of
hyaloclastite but the permeability value between the other two
facies. Since the volcanic rocks are naturally fractured, in-situ
values are supposed to be lower than the core measurements.
As for the productivity, most of the productive wells are
located in the southern region of the field and the northern
region does not yield economic gas production. Indeed, the
breccia facies, which is most favorable as a reservoir rock, is
found more frequently in the south than in the north. This
biased distribution of productive zones, however, has not been
well understood or explained.
In addition to the lithofacies change, intense alteration
made the reservoir much more heterogeneous. Due to the
severe heterogeneity, the discontinuous layers,2,3 and the large
formation thickness, well-to-well correlation is hard to
establish by using conventional means, such as log responses.
To keep objectivity in zoning the formation, additional
petrological tools must be utilized.
This paper attempts to construct a geological model in an
objective manner. The objectives are (1) to gain a clearer
view of the formation and (2) to give a reasonable explanation
to the regional difference in productivity. The key strategy is
to focus on the primary volcanic body and the secondary
alteration.
Petrological Methods
Petrological tools employed in this study are the refractive
index of plagioclase and the microscopic texture of the subject
T. KAWAMOTO, K. SATO
SPE 59407
Volcanic Bodies
In order to identify the primary volcanic bodies, plagioclase
types are first inspected. The well-to-well correlation and the
zoning of the volcanic reservoir are then established to define
the body boundaries.
Plagioclase Types. The refractive index of plagioclase is
measured by the thermal immersion method.6 Specimens are
taken from cores and cuttings, and up to 30 plagioclase
measurements are performed per specimen to offset inherent
measurement errors. From the core samples, we select the
specimens which have the plagioclase phenocrysts, identified
by the thin section observation. For the cutting samples, it is
difficult to select the porphyritic texture part. Cares must be
taken to distinguish the secondary albite or contamination with
the cuttings data.
Taking all the data into consideration, it is found that the
histograms of measured data can be classified into seven
types: Type-A to Type-G as shown in Fig. 3.
Type-A: Sanidine (K-Feldspar). Type-A is found only
from the cuttings taken at a southern well. This type
corresponds to sanidine (KAlSi3 O8 ), according to its range of
the minimum refractive index (1.519-1.523). Sanidine is one
of the K-feldspars that exist among the felsic rocks.
Type-B: Albite. Type-B consists of mainly albite and
partly little oligoclase. This type is widely found in the
southern and northern regions of the Minami-Nagaoka gas
field. In particular, most of the samples taken from the
southern region fall in this type. This type indicates the rock of
felsic magma origin.
Secondary albite by albitization is commonly found in this
field, and the measurement of cuttings samples may be
somewhat biased by this effect. However, from the
measurement of selected core samples, we can determine
whether the albite is primary or secondary.
Type-C: Albite-Oligoclase. Type-C includes more
oligoclase than does Type-B and the frequency peak is within
the oligoclase range. This type indicates the rock of felsic
magma origin and tends to be associated with Type-B.
Type-D: Oligoclase. Type-D consists of oligoclase. This
type indicates the rock of felsic magma origin, but closer to
the intermediate than Types-A, B, and C.
Type-E: Oligoclase-Andesine. Type-E consists of
oligoclase and andesine. This type indicates the rock of felsic
or intermediate magma origin and tends to be associated with
Type-D.
Type-F: Labradorite. Type-F consists of labradorite. In
general, this type indicates the rock of intermediate or mafic
magma origin. Because this type is found concurrently with
Type-G (mentioned below) in the Minami-Nagaoka reservoir,
Type-F rather indicates the mafic magma.
Type-G: Labradorite-Anorthite. Type-G consists of
labradorite and anorthite, which indicates the rock of mafic
magma origin. This type has the broad range and low
frequency pattern in the histogram.
SPE 59407
T. KAWAMOTO, K. SATO
SPE 59407
SPE 59407
T. KAWAMOTO, K. SATO
SPE 59407
SPE 59407
intermediate
basalt
andesite
Ca-rich plagioclase
felsic
dacite
rhyolite
intermediate plagioclase
feldspar
mafic
139
1.590
n1:minimum refractive index
n2:maximum refractive index
(001),(010):cleavage plane
1.580
NIIGATA
TOKYO
38
38
R fr ct ve In ex
1.570
1.580
n1(001)
1.575
a no rth it e
byto wn it e
n1(010)
1.565
1.560
n2(001)
la bradorite
1.554
n2(010)
1.550
a nde sine
1.544
1.540
oligo clase
1.532
1.530
NIIGATA CITY
1.520
albite
1.528
0
Ab
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
100
An
An(%)
Fig. 2
Relationship between the
composition and the refractive index.
300
Miles
Japan
Sea
plagioclase
chemical
Agano River
K-Feldspar
Shinano River
Albite-Oligoclase
(w/peak at Albite)
Oligoclase
NAGAOKA CITY
C
38
20'
KASHIWAZAKI
CITY
: O il & G as F ields
Albite-Oligoclase
(w/peak at Oligocl ase)
38
20 '
Minami-Nagaoka gas field
0
Miles
139
20
Oligocl ase-Andesine
Labradorite
Fig. 1
Index Map of the Minami-Nagaoka gas field.
Labradorite-Anorthite
Fig. 3
Histogram patterns of plagioclase and K-feldspar.
Fr equenc y
T. KAWAMOTO, K. SATO
SPE 59407
below MSL(feet)
11000
S
N
12000
well
4
5
13000
Zone 5
4
4
Zone 4
14000
6
4
Zon e 3
3
2
15000
Zon e 1
Zo ne 6
6
6
Zon e 3
Zone 3
3
3
Zone 1
0
16000
0.5
Mile
17000
Fig. 4
Geological profile correlated by the plagioclase types.
Zone 2 Basalt
1x10
: crest wells
1x10
: flank wells
1x10
Zone 3
-1
1x10- 2
glassy Rhyolite
-3
1x10
158000 157000
eruption of Zone 3
Ba s alt
Zo ne 5 dev itrificati on
sili cified part
6?
and es itic
Rh yo lite
Z one 4
152000 151000
Fig. 6
Regional trend of average permeability in Zone 3.
c ry s tall ine
R hy ol ite
Z one 6
devi trific ation
spheruli ti c part
13500
13500
Zone 3 top
Zone 3 top
14000
14000
14500
14500
15000
15000
top o f N an atani F m .
Zone 3 bottom
10 00 ft
1 m ile
V.E.=200%
Fig. 5
Geological Model of the volcanic rocks.
15500
0.1 0.2 0.3
0.01 0.1 1
10 100 0
Porosity
Permeability (md)
15500
0.1 0.2 0.3
0.01 0.1 1
10 100
Porosity
Permeability (md)
Fig. 7
Petrophysical profiles in Zone 3: (left) a northern well and
(right) a southern well.