Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Acta Tropica
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/actatropica
a r t i c l e
i n f o
Article history:
Received 16 June 2015
Received in revised form
21 September 2015
Accepted 27 September 2015
Available online 22 October 2015
Keywords:
Phlebotomus perniciosus
TOSV
Ecology
Garlaban
a b s t r a c t
This paper reports on an entomological survey performed over the period 20092011 in endemic focus of
peri-urban TOSV in South of France located from 24 km east of Marseille. Sand ies were captured using
CDC light traps set in sand y resting places overnight, and temperature, relative humidity and wind
were recorded to establish possible relations between meteorological factors and vector densities. The
most common species, of 5,432 specimens collected and identied, was Phlebotomus perniciosus (74%),
followed by Sergentomyia minuta (6%) and Phlebotomus ariasi (1%). Male ies were highly predominant
for all Larroussius species instead of S. minuta which counted (85%) of females. The results shed light
on the wide populations dynamic of P. perniciosus in France showing a diphasic seasonal trend with
two abundance peaks at the beginning of July and late August, when a mean temperature is from 23.3
to 25.7 C. Interestingly, these two peaks are corresponding to the peaks of occurrence of human TOSV
cases. Among the 1724 females collected, 549 (32%) were blood-fed. Based on the results of blood meal
analyses, P. perniciosus fed on large animals diversity (man, chicken, rabbit, others mammalians, etc.),
including bats that are the only species found naturally infected by TOSV. Results indicate that host
choice was probably related to its availability than specic attractiveness. Data presented conrm that
sand ies easily adapted to the periurban sites like, P. perniciosus may represent a public health concern
for pathogen transmission in similar Mediterranean environments.
2015 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
1. Introduction
Phlebotomine sand ies (Diptera: Phlebotominae) are vectors
of Leishmania, Bartonella and phleboviruses affecting humans and
other vertebrates in warmers parts of the world. There populations were controlled particularly in leishmaniasis survey, and
recently for ARBOviroses (TOSV). In France, seven species have
been described: Phlebotomus perniciosus [Newstead, 1911], Phlebotomus ariasi [Tonnoir, 1921], Phlebotomus mascittii [Grassi, 1908],
Phlebotomus sergenti [Parrot, 1917], Phlebotomus papatasi [Scopoli,
1786], Sergentomyia minuta [Rondani, 1843] (Raynal, 1954) and
Phlebotomus perliewi [Parrot, 1930] (Izri et al., 1994). P. perniciosus, main vector of Leishmania infantum and phleboviruses in
southeast of France, was found in 1920 for the rst time in Bouchesdu-Rhnes by Pringault (Raynal, 1954).
We report here a detailed study of sand ies from South of France
to further understand aspects of their ecology, and implication on
epidemiological risk.
2. Materials and methods
2.1. Study area
The studied site is located from 24 km east of Marseille (SN: 43,3396; SE: 5,5844), with a population density of
361 habitant/km2 . This peri-urban territory belongs to Garlabans massif, a calcareous formation with a maximum altitude of
731 m. Its vegetation is divided into forest (Pinus halepensis, Pinus
sylvestris, Quercus ilex and Quercus pubescens) and scrubland with
bushes and low plants. Our study area consists more precisely
65
66
Table 1
Spearman analyses on correlation between Phlebotomus perniciosus collected during
each year.
P. perniciosus 2009
P. perniciosus 2010
P. perniciosus 2010
P. perniciosus 2011
Spearman
P-value
Spearman
P-value
0.5
0.450
0.6
0.484
0.35
0.0748
3. Results
3.1. Sandies fauna composition and dynamic
Collecting site was positive for sand ies. During the 3 years
of study, 5432 sand ies were caught (68% of males) belonging to
the genera Phlebotomus and Sergentomyia. Among the members of
the subgenus Larroussius, P. perniciosus (74%) was the most represented, and then we nd S. minuta (6%) and P. ariasi (1%). The
study did not show a markedly different sand ies density and
composition between 20102011, with respectively 2251 (72% of
P. perniciosus) and 2657 (80% of P. perniciosus) captured specimens.
Results of 2009 did not be exploited on this part because of monthly
capture instead of weekly collection on 2010 2011, induced gap
on information. The rst positive collection of P. perniciosus was
recorded in mid-May and the last in early October (Fig. 2). The
adults were active during 6 months (MayOctober) showing a typical diphasic distribution in France, which normally is described
with a single peak from July to August on Cvennes (Rioux et al.,
1969).
As regards S. minuta, the rst specimen was collected in the end
of June and the last in mid-September (data not showed) of the
333 specimens collected (85%) were females. Lastly, P. ariasi were
collected occasionally on July, August and September on this site.
Additionally, we make correlation analyse between annual populations (Table 1), and between meteorological data recorded
during study and P. perniciosus population (Table 2). Dynamic of P.
perniciosus populations between each year do not have correlation
and were not affected by relative humidity and wind variations.
Weekly mean temperatures were positively correlated with P. perniciosus distribution. Indeed, the populations uctuation of P.
perniciosus follows the temperatures curb (Fig. 3). Two genders follow the same kind of diphasic dynamic during season. But, contrary
to laboratory data, which establish that sex ratio is 1 on emergence
(Dolmatova and Delina, 1966), our study in the eld found a sex
ratio of 2,4 (71% males).
3.2. Blood meal analysis
Blood-meal sources were successfully identied by DNA
sequencing from (47%) of female P. perniciosus. Among the 220
positive results, 68 (31%) contained avian blood and 149 (68%) contained mammalian blood (Table 3). More than (43%) of the sand
y specimens collected inside the rabbit and chicken house were
found to have fed on the animals occupying these respective shelters.
4. Discussion
Light trap captures allowed the identication of 5432 sand ies
belonging to 3 species, from 2 genera, conrming the large density
of phlebotomines fauna at the Garlaban, and that great difference
exists between collected species. The presence of P. perniciosus, P.
ariasi and S. minuta conrms previous data on sand ies population
in France under 200 m a.s.l. (Rioux and Golvan, 1969), and more particularly around Marseille (Bron M, 1994). S. minuta sand ies were
not continuously caught throughout the collecting period. Data are
conformed to Maroli and Bettini, 1975 observations on Italy in 1975.
Among the identied species, two (75%) presented a health public
concern; P. ariasi and P. perniciosus but only P. perniciosus was sufciently abundant to be of health concern. The low density of P.
ariasi could be explained by the peri-urban localisation of study, as
P. ariasi is a rural species (Rioux and Golvan, 1969).
P. perniciosus is considered as the most abundant species in the
Mediterranean-type vegetation where it is thought to be the principal vector involved in the transmission of pathogens. The range
of activity of P. perniciosus in this part of South France is clearly
bimodal. Indeed, this kind of evolution of P. perniciosus population
with a highest rate at the beginning and at the end of the warm
season is more current in Maghreb (Dedet et al., 1984), or in Italy
(Maroli and Bettini, 1977). The rst peak appears from end June to
the beginning of July during the two years study. It could result from
a massive emergence of larva in diapause during winter. The second
peak, more important, appears at the end of August and can spread
out September. It seems to represent a second generation lead during summer. These ndings, two peaks, corresponding with two
successive generations, separated from 6 to 7 weeks, is conformed
with the biological cycle of sand y in laboratory condition, 3545
days for complete development (Dolmatova. and Delina, 1966). In
2009, the repartition of TOSV cases in the PACA region was also
clearly bimodal with a rst peak of cases from May to July and
another one from the end of August to the end of September. (Six
et al., 2014). We can hypothesis that the rst peak of transmission
could be due to the emergence of transovarian infected females
during the rst peak of emergence.
Our results conrm that on peri-urban focus the dominant
sand y is P. perniciosus (Rioux et al., 1982), but diphasic seasonal
distribution is a particular data for France, because it was only
mentioned on studies around Marseille (Bron, 1994; Gillet, 1981).
This difference could be explain by specic warming climate which
increase summer season and allows two successive emergence
events. Environmentalmeteorological factors like mean daily temperatures, affect the density and distribution of sand ies. Beyond
these data, Brons study in 1994, suggested that bimodal tendency
of P. perniciosus would be explained by competition phenomenon
with other sand ies species like S. minuta. This hypothesis does
not be veried in our study because population peaks of these two
species are simultaneous (data not showed). On the other hand, as
show with results from 2009, the difference on trend population
67
Fig. 2. Seasonal trends in Phlebotomus perniciosus density during three years of study ( 2009, 2010 and 2011).
Table 2
Spearman analyses on correlation between Phlebotomus perniciosus collected and meteorologicals data (weekly mean temperature, relative humidity and wind).
Weekly mean temperatures
P. perniciosus 2009
P. perniciosus 2010
P. perniciosus 2011
Relative humidity
Wind
Spearman
P-value
Spearman
P-value
Spearman
P-value
0
0.769
0.874
1
0.000308
0.0000002
0.4
0.212
0.0107
0.517
0.441
0.960
0.1
0.382
0.460
0.950
0.154
0.0310
Fig. 3. Density of male () and female () Phlebotomus perniciosus collected during the third year (2011) and variations in weekly temperature ().
organically rich moist soils (Feliciangeli, 2004). Indeed, the developmental stages were associated with a relatively stable, cool and
humid environment protected from sunshine and rain, rich in clay
and organic matter and particularly chicken or rabbit faeces (Pozio
et al., 1985; Bettini et al., 1986, 1991; Bettini and Melis, 1988;
Dougherty et al., 1993). Our results suggest this focus associates
characteristics of sand ies breeding site.
68
Table 3
Results of blood meal identication of sand ies female collected in 20102011.
Rabbit pens
Engorged females number
%
Chicken house
Number
%
Total
Engorged females number
%
Rabbit
Chicken
Human
Shrew
Bat
Cat
Cow
Amphibian
Other rodents
Other birds
43
28.5%
12
7.9%
20
13.2%
47
31.1%
12
7.9%
1
0.7%
1
0.7%
3
2.0%
11
7.3%
1
0.7%
2
2.9%
53
76.8%
6
8.7%
3
4.3%
1
1.4%
0
0.0%
0
0.0%
0
0.0%
2
2.9%
2
2.9%
45
20.5%
65
29.5%
26
11.8%
50
22.7%
13
5.9%
1
0.5%
1
0.5%
3
1.4%
13
5.9%
3
1.4%
69
Helal, H., Ben-Ismail, R., Bach-Hamba, D., Sidhom, M., Bettini, S., Ben Rachid, M.S.,
1987. Enqute entomologique dans le foyer de leishmanioses cutane
zoonotique (Leishmania major) de Sidi Bouzid (Tunisie) en 1985. Bull. Soc. Path
Ex. 80 (3), 349356.
Izri, M.A., Marty, P., Rahal, A., Lelivre, A., Ozon, C., Baldelli, G., et al., 1992.
Phlebotomus perniciosus newstead, 1911 naturellement infest par des
promastigotes dans la rgion de Nice (France). Bull. Soc. Path Ex. 85 (5),
385387.
Izri, M.A., Marty, P., Fauran, P., Le Fichoux, Y., Rousset, J.J., 1994. Phlebotomus
perliewi parrot, 1930 (Diptera, Psychodidae) from the southeast of France.
Parasite 1 (3), 286.
Lane, R.P., 1986. Chicken house reservoirs of sandies. Parasitol. Today 2 (9),
248249.
Lewis, D.J., 1982. A taxonomic review of the genus Phlebotomus (Diptera,
Psychodidae). Bull. Br. Mus. Nat. Hist. Entomol. 45 (2), 121209.
Maroli, M., Bettini, S., 1977. Leishmaniasis in Tuscany (Italy): an investigation on
phlebotomine sandies in Grosseto Province. Trans. R. Soc. Trop. Med. Hyg. 71
(4), 315321.
Pozio, E., Maroli, M., Gradoni, L., Gramiccia, M., 1985. Laboratory transmission of
Leishmania infantum to Rattus rattus by the bite of experimentally infected
Phlebotomus perniciosus. Trans. R. Soc. Trop. Med. Hyg. 79 (4), 524526.
Raynal, J.H., 1954. Les phlbotomes en France et leur distribution rgionale. Ann.
Parasitol. Hum. Comp. 29 (3), 297323.
Rioux, J.A., Golvan, Y.J., Croset, H., Houin, R., 1969. Leishmanioses in the
Mediterranean Midi: results of an ecologic survey. Bull. Soc. Path Exo. 62 (2),
332333.
Rioux, J.A., Perieres, J., Killick-Kendrick, R., Lanotte, G., Bailly, M., 1982. Ecology of
leishmaniasis in South France. 17. Sampling of Phlebotomus by the method of
adhesive traps comparison with the technic of capture on human bait. Ann.
Parasitol. Hum. Comp. 57 (6), 631635.
Rossi, E., Bongiorno, G., Ciolli, E., Di Muccio, T., Scalone, A., Gramiccia, M., et al.,
2008. Seasonal phenology, host-blood feeding preferences and natural
Leishmania infection of Phlebotomus perniciosus (Diptera, Psychodidae) in a
high-endemic focus of canine leishmaniasis in Rome province, Italy. Acta Trop.
105 (2), 158165.
Six, C., Tong, C., Deniau, J., Armengaud, A., Rousseau, C., Leparc-Goffart, I., et al.,
2014. Bilan de la surveillance des virus West Nile et Toscana mise en uvre du
1er juin au 31 octobre 2013 en rgions Languedoc-Roussillon. Paca et Corse
BVS PACA-Corse 11, 1416.
Verani, P., Ciufolini, M.G., Caciolli, S., Renzi, A., Nicoletti, L., Sabatinelli, G., et al.,
1988. Ecology of viruses isolated from sand ies in Italy and characterized of a
new Phlebovirus (Arabia virus). Am. J. Trop. Med. Hyg. 38 (2), 4334399.