Professional Documents
Culture Documents
BASIC CONCEPTS
What is culture?
the quality in a person or society that arises from a concern for what is regarded as
excellent in arts, letters, manners, scholarly pursuits, etc.
a particular form or stage of civilisation, as that of a certain nation or period: Greek
culture
the behaviours and beliefs characteristic of a particular social, ethnic or age group: the
youth culture; the drug culture (Random House Unabridged Dictionary 2006)
all the arts, beliefs, social institutions, etc. characteristic of a community, race
etc.
(Oxford Advanced Learners Dictionary of Current English 1974)
Macro-culture
Micro-culture
Intercultural communication
Negotiation
Negotiation techniques
Example
When people interact with others from other cultures, they may acquire intercultural
sensitivity (they can discriminate and experience relevant cultural differences), which allows
them to develop intercultural competence (=they can act in interculturally appropriate ways).
Deardorffs model of intercultural competence
source culture materials that draw on learners own culture and content
target culture materials that use the culture of a country where English is spoken as a
first language
international target culture materials that use a great variety of English and nonEnglish speaking countries
(Cortazzi and Jin 1999:204-5)
Textbooks can also be aimed at international target cultures English as a global language;
characters are from all over the world and they speak English; various elements, e.g. Picasso
(Spain), Bob Marley (Jamaica), Thomas Mann (Germany), Nelson Mandela (South Africa),
Brigitte Bardot (France), Mahatma Gandhi (India), Kofi Annan (Ghana) etc.
Views
Culture and language are inseparable, therefore, English cannot be taught without its
culture(s)
English should be taught independently of its cultural context. Instead, contexts familiar to the
students should be used
British or American English?
trainers: sneakers
pupil: student
primary/secondary school: elementary/high school
3
flat: apartment
film: movie
maths: math
chips: [French] fries, [potato] wedges
autumn: fall
cinema: movie theater
Graddol (1999): in the next 50 years the balance between native and non-native speakers will
shift significantly, with L2 speakers overtaking L1 speakers
The number of second-language speakers of English has already surpassed the number of
native speakers
EIL vs. culture
learners dont need to internalize cultural norms (YES/NO?)
international language is de-nationalized
learners should communicate their culture to others (Smith:1976)
ownership of English has become re-nationalized (Kachru 1985)
Chinglish (Chinese + English)
Hinglish (Hindi + English)
Scottish English/Scots
Irish English (Hiberno-English)
Jamaican English/Jamaican Patois
African American English
Australian English, etc.
Culture is ALWAYS present
SC: TC : IC can vary
Culture-neutral/international content
Are children already aware of TC?
Intercultural communicative competence: the ability to understand the language and behavior
of the target community and explain it to the members of the home community and vice
versa (practical definition important for teaching)
Knowledge of language and culture
Communicative competence
Hymes: Chomskys definition of language knowledge does not account for the knowledge and
skills that individuals need to understand and produce utterances appropriate to the particular
cultural contexts in which they occur criticism
Knowledge and ability that individuals need to understand and use linguistic resources in
ways that are structurally well- formed, socially and contextually feasible in cultural contexts
etc.
According to Hymes, communicative competence has four dimensions: systemic potential,
appropriateness, occurrence and feasibility
Systemic potential: knowledge and ability to use generative base of the language
Appropriateness: knowledge of language behavior, its contextual features and the
ability to use language appropriately
Occurrence: knowledge of whether and to what extent action is taken with language
and the ability to use language for that action
Feasibility: knowledge of whether and to what extent something is possible and the
ability to be practical and feasible
Canale and Swain used Hymess model in curriculum design. Their own model of
communicative competence contains four components: grammatical, sociolinguistic, strategic
and discourse competence
Grammatical: knowledge of lexical items, rules of phonology, morphology, syntax and
semantics
Sociolinguistic: knowledge of rules of language use
Strategic: strategies to compensate for breakdowns in communication
Discourse competence: knowledge one needs to participate in literacy activities
Which components to teach?
(Canale and Swain)
Each component should be addressed in terms of its probability of occurrence in authentic
texts
= it should be based on ana analysis of the linguistic, sociolinguistic, discourse and strategic
components which learners need
How to design language curricula and tests (based on communicative competence)?
Celce-Murcia et al. five interrelated areas of competence: discourse, linguistic,
actional/rhetorical, sociocultural and strategic.
Discourse competence: knowing how to use linguistic resources to create cohesion and
coherence, conversational rules
Linguistic competence: very similar to Chomskys definition, but more comprehensive
5
Aim: to develop learners voices in response to their local conditions and transform their lives
in socially meaningful ways
Learning is a socially situated, collaborative process of transformation in which Ts and Ss
build a common base of knowledge, system of meanings, values etc.
Ss acquire skills for full participation in larger social worlds
Teachers role is to create a safe environment in which Ss feel comfortable and validated as
they raise questions and consider alternatives
Activities raise awarness of social, cultural and political inequities
Focus on informed action
Language knowledge is about knowing how to take action and make a difference to ones
world
The multiteracies project
Developed by the New London Group (group of international scholars)
Learner-centered focus + knowledge-centered focus
To help learners acquire knowledge, skills and abilities they need to expand their
communicative horizons and move into other worlds
Major challenges to education: increasing cultural and linguistic diversity all over the world;
proliferation of means of communication (requires more knowledge)
Product of this project: pedagogy of multiliteracies
Pedagogy of multiliteracies
Situated practice its purpose is to socialize learners into those communicative
activities in which they are expected to become competent
Overt instruction its purpose is to provide opportunities for learners to focus on,
practice and take control of various linguistic and other conventions needed for
competent engagement in communicative activities
Critical framing: larners will understand historical, social, political cultural and
ideological contexts, i.e. they will see how linguistic resourses are used
Transformed practice based on critical framing; purpose: to use what has been
learned
Some practical considerations
4. STEREOTYPES IN ELT
Stereotypes are part of the common, background or world knowledge shared by a social
group, most frequently defined as accumulated wisdom of a community about an object,
being, or phenomenon
Nature of stereotypes:
a) often inherited from or socially transmitted by members of a cultural group
b) products of excessive generalization reduction to polar opposites, resulting from underrating differences within a category
c) rigid, treating everyone and everything in either /or terms, not allowing for any exceptions
d) they often carry an ideological position
Functions of stereotypes:
a) Cognitive function: an aid to humans to reduce excess information and in its subsequent
organization into a meaningful whole
7
b) to identify and clearly mark distance between two social or cultural groups
Prejudice: a mental state composed of usually negative attitudes towards social groups and
of matching stereotypical beliefs
National stereotypes
a) direct: achieved due to geographic proximity, by means of cultural influence and trade, or
are consequences of political alliances and hostilities, colonial domination, etc.
b) indirect - undertaken or imported from other cultures, civilizations and literature
National stereotypes can also be other-oriented or self-oriented: we/they are clever/stupid
etc.
Other stereotypes
Stereotypes refer to social categories and can refer to:
ethnic groups
national groups
gender groups
professions
different social classes, etc.
National stereotypes and ELT
To deal or not to deal with them?
Option 1: avoid them avoid controversial topics, books that contain stereotypes; problem
which stereotypes to avoid? (e.g. tea at 5 oclock)
Option 2: teach culture; problems does it impose cultural values? is the learner just an
observer?
Option 3: tackle them confront differences, barriers to communication and stereotypes
7. What is diglossia? Parallel use of two different varieties of the same language. A situation
in which there are two forms/varieties of the same language used in different contexts.
Meaningful learning
Examples
Questions based on rote learning:
4. Name the speech acts mentioned in Austin and Searles theory.
Questions based on meaningful learning:
12. Provide an example of pragmalinguistic failure of your own choice. Do not use examples
from the lecture or the book.
Learning styles (Kolb)
Converging: abstract conceptualization + active experimentation practical
application of ideas, learning by doing
Diverging: concrete experience + reflective observation viewing situations from
different perspectives
Assimilating: abstract conceptualization + reflective observation; watching, induction
Accomodating: learners tend to solve problems through experiments supported by data
and observations; using trial and error
Impact of culture on learning
Power distance S/T relationship: T as authority (HP) vs. T as facilitator (LP)
Individualism vs. collectivism: contradicting/not contradicting a fellow student
Uncertainty avoidance: precise learning objectives, unambiguous assessment,
structured learning etc. (high u.a.)
Long-term vs. short-term time orientation: LT learning helps you acquire skills for a
good job
Masculinity vs. femininity: (masc.): success is important, best students are
benchmarks, stressful climate
Bad teaching/learning practices roooted in Serbian culture (ELT)
The Present Simple is used to express the idea that an action is repeated or usual. It
shows the action to be a habit, a hobby, a scheduled event... especially with younger
children, poorly educated adults etc.
Reading and translating texts you are not coaching TV anchors or translators
Sticking to the book
Doing useless activities
Testing memory (in reading/listening tasks)
Not testing comprehension
They saw a palgish flester in the corridor
What did they see?
Where did they see the palgish flester?
They saw a palgish flester.
They saw the palgish flester in the corridor.
Anyone can answer the questions. What does palgish mean? Who/what is a flester?
9
Perlocutionary act the effect you achieve; the addressee is amused, persuaded etc.
Illocutionary act conditions for success
Preparatory conditions
Sincerity conditions
Essential conditions
Example: ordering (give me the book)
Both the speaker and hearer recognize speakers authority ( preparatory condition), the
speaker wants something to be done ( sincerity condition), the speaker indends the
utterance to get the hearer do something ( essential condition)
Illocutionary acts in learner language
A: You have a beautiful accent.
B: ......
A: You have a beautiful accent.
Its very old
A: You have a beautiful accent.
B: Thank you. It is good to hear that from a native speaker. Ive been learning English for
years and...
Sociopragmatic failure: a learner fails to perform the illocutionary act required by the
situation, e.g. not saying thank you, response to compliments etc.
Pragmalinguistic failure: a learner tries to perform the right speech act, but uses wrong
linguistic means, e.g. saying may God reward you instead of thanks.
Problems occur in requests, apologies, refusals, etc.
Examples - refusal
Examples - apologies
Examples other
Excuse me vs. sorry; I apologize...
Happy 8th March*; happy July 4th *; happy May 1st
I respectfully disagree I dont agree Nonsense
Please, be quiet Quiet Shut up
Ill take you to drink* Let me buy you a drink
Can I help you, love? [British English, informal]
How are you, duck? [British English, informal]
Impression management
How speakers achieve communicative effects by manipulating their linguistic and nonlinguistic resources
How speakers change the attitudes of other speakers; using contextualization cues
Conversations between L1 ind L2 speakers
British empoyer and foreign worker
11
Education:
Winston Nursery irrelevant and silly
Hartford Heights Elementary irrelevant and silly
Hobbies: hanging out with friends, skiing, hiking, reading, watching TV, playing games on
my computer irrelevant
Common mistakes
Achievements: Captain of the University Women's Hockey Team , winner of high school
math contest in 2002
Working experience: my 1st job was at an insurnace company & im still working for them.
Referees: John Smith [address]
------------------------------------------------------------------------------S potovanjem; roen sam u X kod Y, optina Z, kao najmlae dete u estolanoj porodici
(dva starija brata i jedna mlaa sestra, roditelji); osvojeno prvo mesto na optinskom
takmienju recitatora u VIII r. O.
Culture and learning: personal cognitive abilities determined by demands of our environment
Cultural ways of knowing: methods people employ to think
Cultural learning approaches
Influenced by learners preferred modalities (auditory, visual, kinesthetic), perceptions
Approach #1: Four bi-polar scales = continuums of learning preferences
- Field Independence vs. Field Sensitivity: whole concept versus parts
- Cooperation vs. Competition: collective versus individualistic cultures
- Trial and Error vs. Watch, then Do
- Tolerance vs. Intolerance for Ambiguity: low or high uncertainty cultures
Approach #2: Perception and judgment
- Mastery (Sensing-Thinking) Learners: realistic, results-oriented, active engagement)
- Understanding (Intuitive-Thinking) Learners: theoretical, knowledge-oriented
- Self-expression (Intuitive-Feeling) Learners: curious, insightful, imaginative
- Interpersonal (Sensing-Feeling) Learners: interpersonally-directed
Relational styles for learning (the manner in which people relate to one another carry over
into the classroom)
- Dependency/Independence: student reliance on support, help, opinions of teachers
- Participation/Passivity: engaging in versus observing the learning process
- Impulsivity/Reflectivity: rapid versus slow arrival at answers; risk to saving face
Cultural motivation style
Four styles that impact multicultural classroom:
- Intrinsic: internal drive to succeed, excellence reward in and of itself
- Extrinsic: stimulated by external rewards
- Learning on demand: set, scheduled curriculum; student interest not a factor
- Learning when interested: study of whats interesting, relevant to the learner
Language and identity
- Language helps individuals construct and maintain their ethnic identity
- Assimilation into English-speaking culture can become wedge between identity and social
system
Four sources of difficulty for ELLs:
dual concern with cognitive (content) and linguistic (new language expression)
academic insufficiency
higher grade level entries create heavier cognitive and linguistic loads
deductive instructional approach in U.S. in conflict with inductive-approach cultures
Teacher Multiculural Competence
Becoming multiculturally competent
- Develop competencies in multiple ways of perceiving, evaluating, believing, and doing
- Engage in practices that provide equitable outcomes for all learners
14
1) Understanding self
2) Understanding diversity
3) Classrooms for multicultural education
4) Multicultural competence and communication strategies
Non-U
looking-glass
mirror
wireless
radio
vegetables
greens
telegram
wire
lavatory-paper
toilet-paper
15
Examples:
I bought a/the book = Kupio sam knjigu.
*I bought book
Kupio sam/kupila sam... = I bought...
uncle = ujak, stric, tea
lend, borrow = pozajmiti
Loanword a word borrowed from another language
Examples (English): mayonnaise, caf (French), pizza, bravo (Italian), kindergarten
(German), sombrero (Spanish), democracy (Greek) etc.
Examples (Serbian): fudbal, kompjuter (English), makaroni (Italian), kroasan (French),
uprija (Turkish), farba, alter (German) etc.
Compare these words:
In English:
The Mexican was wearing a sombrero.
What is guerrilla warfare? (Spanish)
Some sections of the German Autobahn have speed limits.
My son is in the kindergarten. (German)
In Serbian:
Erl od Kardigana mogao bi da izgubi kuu koja je u vlasnitvu njegove porodice hiljadu
godina.
Naa kola dobila je nekoliko novih kompjutera.
Turski paa je odmah shvatio da e izgubiti bitku.
Jesi li ostavio baki taksisti?
Cultural markedness
A word is culturally marked if it is necessary to know some specificities of the culture it
comes from in order to understand it.
Every word which is culturally marked IS a loanword
Not all loanwords are culturally marked
Examples:
music/muzika, democracy/demokratija
sombrero, kimono marked
Degrees of cultural markedness
Strong: sombrero, kimono; baibozuk, arda strong association with the culture they come
from
Weak: vampire, pizza; dragstor, tost weak association with the culture they come from
Zero: music, democracy; fudbal, kompjuter common vocabulary
The degree of cultural markedness depends on the context,
e.g. kauboj:
stoar sa amerikog divljeg zapada strong
osoba koja se bahato ponaa (ponaati se kao kauboj)
Problems (Serbian words and phrases)
17
opanak, slava, kajmak, ajvar, evapii, prebranac, dizela (person), balvan-revolucija, jogurtrevolucija, petooktobarske promene, via kola, euro-krem, pusto tursko, ko te ljivi/ia?,
mator konj, bus-plus kartica, irilica (nationalist music), indeks (students booklet)
Euro-Cream???
The Yoghurt Revolution???
Bus Plus Card???
Open your indexes???
Possible solutions
slava = Slava (Oxford English Dictionary, 2nd Edition)
When is your Slava? (???)
slava family patron saints day (description)
opanak Serbian peasant shoe (description)
sarma cabbage rolls filled with mincemeat and rice (description)
kulen a kind of spicy sausage (description)
kulen = pepperoni (similar object, concept, etc.)
opanak = moccasin (similar object, concept, etc.)
prebranac = beans (general term)
kajmak = cheese (general term)
ljivovica = brandy (general term)
Problems in communication
Culturally marked words in ELT problems and solutions
Slava = family + patron + saint + day + feast
burek = pastry + cheese + pie
indeks = student + booklet + ID
= Expanding vocabulary, enhancing verbal skills
Teacher, teacher, may I...? you still have some time
Dear Sir,
Take my heartiest love and cordiality from my inner psychology. I hope, all of you are
keeping fine.
I would like to work for your company if you have a mercy upon me, it will bring a grand
success for my professional life. beyond repair
= Awareness raising
18