Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Volume 1, No 4, 2011
Copyright 2010 All rights reserved Integrated Publishing services
Research article
ABSTRACT
A review is presented based on experimental studies on the performance concrete when
exposed to higher temperature. The compiled test data revealed distinct difference in
mechanical properties of normal, high strength and self compacting concrete. Shape of
specimen (cube, cylinder, beam etc), size of specimen, magnitude of temperature load applied
on the specimen, time duration maintained for heating, reference on time-temperature curve,
rate of heating, rate of cooling, time taken for hot test after curing period, time taken for load
test after heating, heat test on stressed/unstressed member, type of cooling adopted on heated
specimen by natural cooling or cooling by spraying water etc are the parameters that
influence the test results. To understand the behavior of concrete under elevated temperature,
it is necessary that several factors be taken into account for each experiment. Strength of
concrete, type of cement, type of aggregate, water cement ratio, density of concrete,
percentage of reinforcement, cover to the reinforcement etc are some of the important factors
that affect the performance of concrete at elevated temperature.
Key words: High strength concrete, Self compacting concrete, Spalling, Coefficient of
thermal expansion, Metakaolin
1. Introduction and methods
A review of methods used by various investigators for testing concrete at elevated
temperature indicates that, the tests can be categorized into two types namely cold testing and
hot testing. In stressed tests, a preload (2040% of the compressive strength at 27C) is
applied to the specimen prior to heating and the load is sustained during the heating period.
Heat is applied at a constant rate until a target temperature is reached, and this temperature is
maintained for a time until a thermal steady state is achieved. Stress or strain is then
increased at a prescribed rate until the specimen fails. In the unstressed test, the specimen is
heated, without preload at a constant rate to the target temperature, which is maintained until
a thermal steady state is achieved. Stress or strain is then applied at a prescribed rate until
failure occurs. In unstressed residual strength test, the specimen is heated without preload at a
prescribed rate to the target temperature, which is maintained until a thermal steady state is
reached within the specimen. The specimen is then allowed to cool, following a prescribed
rate to room temperature. Load or strain is applied on the specimen at room temperature until
the specimen fails. Based on the review of literature, the experimental investigations on
strength of concrete at elevated temperature can be broadly classified into three categories as
shown in Figure 1.
928
Research article
Temperature
range
Beam
(1.8x0.12
x0.2)
650C
(furnace
temperature)
Time
duration
Timetemperature
curve
0,
30min,
60min,
120min
Furnace
temperature
curve
Rate of
heating
Rate of
cooling/
coolant
Time
duration
b/w hot
test &
load test
Sprayed
with water
immediately
Chan et al (1999) carried out an investigation on the fire resistance of normal strength and
high-strength concrete, with compressive strengths of 39, 76, and 94 MPa respectively. After
exposure to temperatures upto 1200C, compressive strength and tensile splitting strength
929
Research article
were determined. The pore structure in HSC and in NSC was also investigated. Results
indicated that HSC lost its mechanical strength in a manner similar to that of NSC. The range
between 400 and 800C was critical to the strength loss. High temperatures had a coarsening
effect on the microstructure of both HSC and NSC. On the whole HSC and NSC suffered
damage to almost the same degree, although HSC appeared to suffer a greater worsening of
the permeability-related durability. The salient features of the test are shown in Table 2.
Table 2: Salient Features of Test Carried out by Chan
Size of the
specimen
(m)
TimeTemperature
Time
temperature
range
duration
curve
Cube
(0.1x0.1
x0.1)
Up to
1200C
BS 4761987(Part
20)
Rate of
heating
Time
duration
b/w hot
test &
load test
Rate of
cooling/
coolant
Peak
Natural
temperature cooling to
maintained
room
for an hour temperature
TimeTemperature
Time
temperature
range
duration
curve
Cube
(0.1x0.1x0.1)
Up to 800C
Cylinder
(0.1x0.2)
Rate of
heating
Furnace
temperature 2.5C/min
curve
Rate of
cooling/
coolant
Time
duration
b/w hot test
& load test
Natural
cooling
Kumar A and Kumar V (2003) carried out an investigation to find the residual strength of
reinforced cement concrete beams exposed to higher temperature for long duration. Six RCC
beams were cast with same reinforcement, length, grade of concrete and clear cover. Four
beams were exposed to fire for durations of 1 h, 1.5 h, 2 h and 2.5 h. These beams were
exposed to fire for 2.5 h and tested at room temperature failed in serviceability criteria. The
reduction in stiffness was found to increase with the increase in the duration of fire exposure.
The following conclusions were drawn by the authors from the test carried out on RCC
beams. RCC beam of grade M20 with 25 mm clear cover was unable to resist a fire exposure
930
Research article
Beam(0.415x0.1x0.1)
Cube (0.1x0.1x0.1)
Cube
(0.15x0.15x0.15)
TimeTemperature
Time
Rate of
temperature
range
duration
heating
curve
200 to
1000C
Chinese
standard
(GB/T
9978-1999)
Rate of
cooling/
coolant
Cooled
naturally
Time
duration
b/w hot
test &
load
test
-
Persson (2004) made a comparison between the performance of vibrated concrete and SCC
under elevated temperature. Cylinders and columns were tested by Compressive loading with
high temperature. Polypropylene fibers were used to avoid the spalling of concrete.
Hydrocarbon and ISO 384 fire curves were used. Rate of heating was maintained at 240C
and 480C per hour. Specimens were heated in the temperature range of 20 to 800C and
specimens were slowly cooled upto room temperature and tested. It was observed from the
test results that explosive spalling took place for columns with SCC but not for columns with
vibrated concrete, even through the vibrated concrete columns were cured exactly as SCC
columns. It was found that fire spalling mainly depended on the stress in the concrete,
931
Research article
cement-powder ratio and w/c ratio. Lower elastic modulus at fire temperature was observed
in SCC than in vibrated concrete. The salient features of the test are shown in Table 6.
Table 6: Salient Features of Test Carried out by Persson
Size of the
specimen
(m)
Cylinder
(0.1x0.2)
Prestressed
column
(2x0.2x0.2)
Temperature
range
20 to 800C
Time
duration
Timetemperature
curve
2hr &
4hr
ISO 384
fire curve &
modified
hydro
carbon
curve
Rate of
heating
Rate of
cooling/
coolant
240C/hr &
480C/hr
60C/hr
Time
duration
b/w hot
test &
load test
Gai-Fei Peng et al (2006) carried out an investigation to explore the relationship between
occurrence of explosive spalling and residual mechanical properties of fiber toughened high
performance concrete exposed to high temperatures. The residual mechanical properties
measured includes compressive strength, tensile splitting strength, and fracture energy. A
series of concretes were prepared using ordinary Portland cement and crushed limestone.
Steel fiber, polypropylene fiber, and hybrid fiber (polypropylene fiber and steel fiber) were
added to enhance fracture energy of the concretes. After exposure to high temperatures
ranged from 200 to 800 C, the residual mechanical properties of fiber toughened highperformance concrete were investigated. For fiber concrete, although residual strength was
decreased by exposure to high temperatures over 400 C, residual fracture energy was
significantly higher than that before heating. Incorporating hybrid fiber seems to be a
promising way to enhance resistance of concrete to explosive spalling. The salient features of
the test are shown in Table 7.
Table 7: Salient Features of Test Carried out by Gai-Fei Peng et al
Size of the
specimen (m)
Cube
(0.1x0.1
x0.1)
Beam(0.3x0.
1x0.1)
Temperatur
e range
200 to
800C
Time
duratio
n
Timetemperatur
e curve
Rate of
heating
Rate of
cooling/
coolant
Time
duratio
n b/w
hot test
& load
test
Furnace
temperatur
e curve
10C/min
(Target
temperatur
e
maintained
for an
hour)
Natural
cooling to
room
temperatur
e
2 days
Metin husem (2006) examined the variation of compressive and flexural strengths of ordinary
and high-performance micro-concrete at high temperature. Compressive and flexural
strengths of ordinary and high-performance micro-concrete which were exposed to high
932
Research article
temperatures (200, 400, 600, 800 and 1000C) and cooled differently (in air and water) were
obtained. Compressive and flexural strengths of these concrete samples were compared with
each other and then compared with the samples which had not been heated. On the other hand,
strength loss curves of these concrete samples were compared with the strength loss curves
given in the codes. Experimental results indicate that concrete strength decreases with
increasing temperature, and the decrease in the strength of ordinary concrete is more than that
in high-performance concrete. The type of cooling affects the residual compressive and
flexural strength, the effect being more pronounced as the temperature increases. Strength
loss curves obtained from this study agree with strength loss curves given in the Finnish Code.
The salient features of the test are shown in Table 8.
Table 8: Salient Features of Test Carried out by Metin husem
Size of the
specimen
(m)
TimeTemperature
Time
temperature
range
duration
curve
Cylinder
(0.15X0.3)
Beam
(0.04x0.04
x0.16)
200 to
1000C
Rate of
heating
Furnace
temperature 5.5C/min
curve
Rate of
cooling/
coolant
Time
duration b/w
hot test &
load test
Air and
water
After
cooling by
air/water
Size of the
specimen (m)
Temperatur
e range
Time
duratio
n
Cylinder
(0.16x0.32)
Beam(0.4x0.1x0.
1)
600C
Timetemperatur
e curve
Rate of
heatin
g
Rate of
cooling/
coolant
Time
duration
b/w hot
test &
load test
ISO 834
curve
(Eurocode)
0.5C/
min
Simultan
eous
cooling
Stressed
hot test
Research article
regression analysis, the relationships of the mechanical properties with temperature were
proposed to fit the test results, including the residual compressive strength, peak strain and
elastic modulus. The equation proposed is applicable to unheated and heated concrete
specimens at different temperatures. In addition, the split cylinder tests of 54 specimens were
also found and a relationship between splitting tensile strength and temperature was
established. The salient features of the test are shown in Table 10.
Table 10: Salient Features of Test Carried out by Chang et al
Size of the
specimen
(m)
Temperature
range
Cylinder
(0.15x0.3)
100 to 800C
Time
duration
Timetemperature
curve
2hr &
4hr
Rate of
heating
Rate of
cooling/
coolant
Time
duration
b/w hot
test &
load test
1 to
4.5C/min
Natural
cooling
1 month
Temperature
range
300C @30
min
600C@70
min
Time
duration
Timetemperature
curve
Furnace
temperature
curve
Rate of
heating
Rate of
cooling/
coolant
Time
duration
b/w hot
test & load
test
10C
/min
24 hours
24 hours
Research article
repaired by applying paint. The beams exposed to temperature ranging between 600 and
1000C were repaired for spalling. In the second stage, all repaired specimens were again
heated. These test specimens were tested for flexural strength after bringing them to room
temperature. The variation of flexural strength of repaired RCC beams with increase in
temperature has been studied and the flexural strength of beams before and after the repair
was compared. The salient features of the test are shown in Table 12.
Table 12: Salient Features of Test Carried out by Udaya kumar et al
Size of the
specimen (m)
Beam
(1.2x0.112x0.24)
TimeTemperature
Time
Rate of
temperature
range
duration
heating
curve
100 to
1000C
3hr
ISO 834
fire curve
Rate of
cooling/
coolant
Time
duration
b/w hot
test & load
test
Cooled
naturally
Tayfun Uygunoglu and Ilker Bekir Topcu (2009) Studied the effects of aggregate type on the
coefficient of thermal expansion of self consolidating concrete produced with normal (SCC)
and lightweight aggregate (SCLC) at elevated temperature. Two types of aggregate namely
crushed limestone and pumice were used. Different combinations of water/powder ratio and
super plasticizer dosage levels were prepared for the SCC and SCLC mixtures. The total
powder content (cement and mineral additives) was constant in the experiments. Thermal test
was performed to accurately characterize the coefficient of thermal expansion (CTE) of SCC
and SCLC aged 28 days using the dilatometer. The CTEs of SCC and SCLC were defined by
measuring the linear change in length of concrete specimens subjected to a range of
temperatures. Test temperatures were varied from 20 to 1000C at a heating rate of 5C/min.
The results, in general, showed that SCC has higher CTE than normal weight concrete and
that lightweight aggregate reduced the CTE of SCC due to their porous structure. The
aggregate type has significant influence on the thermal expansion of SCC. The salient
features of the test are shown in Table 13.
Table 13: Salient Features of Test Carried out by Tayfun Uygunoglu and Ilker Bekir Topcu
Size of the
specimen (m)
Cube
(0.07x0.07x0.07)
Cylinder
(0.15x0.3)
TimeRate of
Temperature
Time
Rate of
temperature
cooling/
range
duration
heating
curve
coolant
20 to
1000C
Furnace
temperature
curve
5C
/min
Time
duration
b/w hot
test &
load test
-
Hanaa Fares et al (2009) carried out an experimental study on the performance of selfconsolidating concrete (SCC) subjected to high temperature. Two SCC mixtures and one
vibrated concrete were tested. Mechanical and micro structural properties were studied at
ambient temperature and after heating. Compressive strength, flexural strength, bulk modulus
of elasticity, porosity and permeability of these concrete were found. For each test, the
specimens were heated at a rate of 1 C/ min upto desired target temperatures (150, 300, 450
935
Research article
and 600C). In order to ensure a uniform temperature throughout the specimen, the
temperature was held constant at the target temperature for 1 h before cooling. In addition,
the specimen mass was measured before and after heating in order to determine the loss of
water during the test. The salient features of the test are shown in Table 14.
Table 14: Salient Features of Test Carried out by Hanaa Fares et al
Size of the
specimen
(m)
Temperature
range
Cylinder
(0.160.32)
150 to
600C
Time
duration
Time
TimeRate of
Rate of
duration b/w
temperature
cooling/
heating
hot test &
curve
coolant
load test
Peak
Furnace
temperature
temperature
maintained
curve
for an hour
1 C/
min
24hr
Jin Tao et al (2010) reported the results of laboratory investigations carried out to study the
effects of high temperatures ranging from room temperature to 800C on the compressive
strength of SCC and HSC. It was reported that the hot compressive strength of SCC
decreased with increase in temperature. It was found that grade of concrete had an effect on
the strength loss of concrete, especially in the temperature range below 400C.Higher grades
of SCC resulted in higher loss of strength. But this difference was found to be less in the
permanent strength loss stage. Compared with normal strength SCC, high strength SCC was
found to possess a larger compressive strength when exposed to high temperature. It was also
reported that addition of polypropylene fibers decreased the strength .However the addition
reduced the probability of explosive spalling. The salient features of the test are shown in
Table 15.
Table 15: Salient Features of Test Carried out by Jin Tao et al
Size of the
specimen
(m)
Cylinder
(0.15x0.3)
Temperature
range
200 to
800C
Time
duration
Timetemperature
curve
Furnace
temperature
curve
Rate of
heating
Rate of
cooling/
coolant
Time
duration
b/w hot
test & load
test
5C/min &
30C/min
above
500C
Hot test
Immediate
load
application
Sivaraja (2010) studied the effect of high temperature on mechanical strength properties of
five different self-compacting concrete mixes. Initially five different SCC mixes such as
normal concrete, SCC (Self Compacting Concrete) with Fly ash, SCC with silica fume, SCC
with rice husk ash and SCC with 20% quarry sand and were designed. The fresh concrete
properties such as filling ability and passing ability were ascertained. Specimens were
subjected to high temperature up to 500C and 1000C for 1 hour in hot furnace. Mechanical
properties such as compressive strength, split tensile strength and modulus of rupture were
obtained by conducting respective tests as per Indian Standards. Results of specimens
subjected to high temperature were compared with the conventional specimens. The salient
features of the test are shown in Table 16.
936
Research article
Temperature
range
Time
duration
Cube
(0.15x0.15
x0.15)
Cylinder
(0.15X0.3)
Beam
(0.5x0.1x0.1)
500 and
1000C
Peak
temperature
for hour
TimeRate of
Rate of
temperature
cooling/
heating
curve
coolant
Furnace
curve
5C
/min
Natural
cooling
Time
duration
b/w hot test
& load test
After
natural
cooling
2. Conclusions
From the literature review, concrete specimens subjected to fire load can be broadly classified
into three types namely Stressed, Unstressed, Unstressed residual strength tests. It is reported
in the literature that behaviour of Normal strength concrete, high strength concrete and self
compacting concrete were different when exposed to high temperature. Many parameters
influence the test results and affect the performance of concrete specimens exposed to high
temperature. Analytical modeling of concrete elements exposed to thermal loads was the
missing phenomenon in the review of literature. Since the test methods were costly and
difficult to carry out, it is necessary to develop analytical modeling. Special attention has to
be paid to the material properties for analysis and evaluation of the residual strength of
structural elements exposed to accidental fire loading. Further examinations are needed in
order to document material properties for design purposes and for the evaluation of residual
strength of structural elements exposed to fire. Literature reveals that researchers adopt
different procedures for the application of heat load as well as for testing the specimens.
Hence there is a need to carry out an extensive investigation to find out the effect of the
variations in the testing procedures.
3. References
1. El-Hawary. M.M., Ragab. A.M., Abd El-Azim. A and Elibiari. S., Effect of fire on
shear behaviour of R.C beams, Computers & Strucrures 65(2), pp. 281-287, 1997
2. Chan Y. N., Peng, G. F and Anson M., Residual strength and pore structure of highstrength concrete and normal strength concrete after exposure to high temperatures ,
Cement and Concrete Composites, pp 23-27, 1999.
3. Chi-Sun Poon, Salman Azhar, Mike Anson and Yuk-Lung Wong., Performance of
metakaolin concrete at elevated temperatures , Cement and Concrete Composites, pp
83-89, 2003.
4. Kumar.A and Kumar.V. Behaviour of RCC beams after exposure to elevated
temperatures, IE(I) Journal CV, 84, November 2003, pp 165-170
937
Research article
5. Min Li, Chun Xiang Qian and Wei Sun., Mechanical properties of high-strength
concrete after fire Cement and Concrete Research, pp 1001-1005, 2004.
6. Persson. B., Fire resistance of self-compacting concrete, SCC, Materials and
Structures, 37, November 2004, pp 575-584
7. Gai-Fei Peng, Wen-Wu Yang, Jie Zhao, Ye-Feng Liu, Song-Hua Bian and Li-Hong
Explosive spalling and residual mechanical properties of fiber-toughened highperformance concrete subjected to high temperatures , Cement and Concrete
Research, pp 723-727, 2006.
8. Metin husem., The effects of high temperature on compressive and flexural strengths
of ordinary and high-performance concrete, Fire safety journal, pp 155163, 2005.
9. Noumowe. A., Carre. H., Daoud. A and Toutanji. H., High-Strength Self-compacting
concrete exposed to fire Test, Journal of Materials in Civil Engineering
November/December 2006, pp 754-758
10. Chang Y.F., Chen Y.H., Sheu. M.S and Yao. G.C., Residual stressstrain
relationship for concrete after exposure to high temperatures, Cement and Concrete
Research, May 2006, pp 19992005.
11. Anagnostopoulos. N., Sideris. K.K and Georgiadis. A Mechanical characteristics of
self-compacting concretes with different filler materials exposed to elevated
temperatures, Materials and Structures, pp 13931405, 2009.
12. P. M. V. Udaya Kumar, M. Potha Raju and K. Srinivasa Rao Performance of
repaired fire affected RC beams, Current science, 96(3), 10 February 2009, pp 398402.
13. Tayfun Uygunog lu and Ilker Bekir Topcu Thermal expansion of self-consolidating
normal and lightweight aggregate concrete at elevated temperature, Construction and
Muilding Materials, pp 3063-3069, 2009.
14. Hanaa Fares, Albert Noumowe and Sbastien Remond., Self-consolidating concrete
subjected to high temperature Mechanical and physicochemical properties, Cement
and Concrete Research, pp 12301238, 2009.
15. Jin Tao., Yong Yuan and Luc Taerwe., Compressive Strength of Self-compacting
concrete during high temperature exposure, Journal of Materials in Civil
Engineering, October 2010, pp 1005-1011
16. Sivaraja.M., Self compacting concrete under elevated temperature, International J.
of Engg. Research & Indu. Appls. (IJERIA). ISSN 0974-1518, 3(II) (May 2010), pp
295-311
938