Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Problem 1:
(i) For every a, b R, |ab| = |a||b|. Prove this identity by checking all the
possible cases for the signs of a and b.
(ii) For every a, b R, with b 6= 0, ab = |a|
|b| . Prove this identity.
Solution to Part (i).
Well directly check the 4 possible cases for the signs of a and b.
Case 1: a 0, b 0. In this case |a| = a, |b| = b, and, because ab 0,
|ab| = ab. Thus:
LHS = |ab| = ab = |a||b| = RHS.
Case 2: a 0, b 0. In this case |a| = a, |b| = b, and, because ab 0,
|ab| = ab. Thus:
LHS = |ab| = ab = (a) (b) = |a||b| = RHS.
Case 3: a 0, b 0. In this case |a| = a, |b| = b, and, because ab 0,
|ab| = ab. Thus:
LHS = |ab| = ab = (a) (b) = |a||b| = RHS.
Case 4: a 0, b 0. In this case |a| = a, |b| = b, and, because ab 0,
|ab| = ab. Thus:
LHS = |ab| = ab = (a) (b) = |a||b| = RHS.
Solution to Part (ii).
Using Part (i) we deduce:
a
= a
b
1
1
=
|a|
b
b
1
(?).
Next, well understand the quantity 1b . We can understand this via:
1
1
1 = |1| = b = |b| .
b
b
Thus:
1
=
b
Substituting this into equation (?), we
a
=
b
1
.
|b|
deduce:
|a|
.
|b|
Problem 2:
Now to explain the equation a2 = |a| well consider the two possible cases.
p
|ab| = (ab)2 = a2 b2 = a2 b2 = |a||b|.
2
Problem 3:
Prove that for every x R the following inequality is true:
|x| x |x|.
Solution
Well just check this for the two possible signs of x.
If x 0, then x = |x|, and the inequality that must be true is
|x| |x| |x|,
which is obviously true.
On the other hand, if x 0, then x = |x|, and the inequality that must
be true is
|x| |x| |x|.
Again, this is obviously true.
Problem 4:
If a > 0 then we have the following two facts:
(i) |x| = a if and only if x = a.
(ii) |x| < a if and only if a < x < a.
Explain these facts using a graph of the absolute value function. Then prove
them (probably by laboriously checking all the possible cases).
Solution
We can read these facts directly from a graph of the absolute value function.
Here is such a graph:
Fact (i) concerns the set of x with the property that |x| = a. Looking at
the graph of the function |x| we observe that there are exactly two such x,
namely a.
Fact (ii) concerns the set of x such that |x| < a. Thinking in terms of the
graph, we want the set of x with the property that the graph over those
points lies (strictly) under the line y = a. Looking at the graph we can just
read off that this is the set of x such that a < x < a.
Now lets think about how we would actually prove these facts formally.
Proof of (i). The clearest way, logically speaking, to prove a statement
like A if and only if B is to prove that A implies B, and separately prove
4
that B implies A. (Sometimes you can do both directions at the same time,
but you have to be very careful when you do this.) So we have two questions
to answer.
If |x| = a, why is x = a? Well, take some x such that |x| = a. If x 0,
then |x| = x, so x = |x| = a. On the other hand, if x 0, then |x| = x, so
x = |x| = a.
If x = a, why is |x| = a? We are assuming that a > 0, so this is obviously
true. (Details are: |a| = a, while | a| = (a) = a because a < 0.)
Proof of (ii). Again, well split this if and only if proof into two questions.
If |x| < a, then why is a < x < a? Well just check this for the two cases
that x 0 and x 0. If x 0, then one side of the required inequality is
obtained from the deduction x = |x| < a, and the other is obtained from
a < 0 x. On the other hand, if x 0 then one side of the required
inequality is obtained from the deduction x = |x| > a and the other is
obtained by x 0 < a.
If a < x < a, then why is |x| < a? If x 0 then |x| = x < a. And if x 0
then |x| = x < (a) = a.
Problem 5:
Let d > 0, and a R. Determine the following sets. (You can give your
answer using interval notation, e.g. (r, s).)
(i) {x R | |x a| < d}.
(ii) {x R | 0 < |x a| < d}.
Explain using a graph of the absolute value function, and also using your
answers to problem 3.
Solution to (i).
The answer is (a d, a + d). This can be read straight off the graph of the
x1
Looking at the graph, we observe that we can choose any such that 0 <
1. For such a delta, if 0 < |x 1| < , then 0 < x < 2 and we can
observe directly that every point of the graph above such an x lies between
the horizontal lines.
Solution to Part (iii).
In the case = 1.5 the graph looks like:
|(2x + 3) 5|
|2x 2|
2|x 1|
2
(By assumption (??).)
2 2
(By assumption (?).)
.
1
2x
+ 3 = 2.
Proof.
Let be an arbitrary positive real.
Set = 2 (?).
Let x be an arbitrary number such that 0 < |x (2)| < (??).
Then:
|f (x) L| = 21 x + 3 2
= 12 x + 1
= 12 |x (2)|
< 21
(By assumption (??).)
= 12 (2)
(By assumption (?).)
= .
Thus, when 0 < |x (2)| < 2, |f (x) 2| < , as required.
Problem 8:
Prove that limx4 (7 3x) = 5.
Proof
Let be an arbitrary positive real number.
Set = 3 . (?)
Let x be an arbitrary number such that 0 < |x 4| < . (??).
Then:
|f (x) L| =
=
=
=
<
=
=
Problem 9:
Prove that
x
3
= .
x3 5
5
lim
Proof
Let be an arbitrary positive real.
Set = 5. (?).
Let x be an arbitrary real number such that 0 < |x 3| < . (??).
Then:
x 3
= (x3)
5
5
5
= 15 |x 3|
< 15
(By assumption (??).)
1
= 5 (5 ) (By assumption (?).)
= .
Problem 10: (#1.8.25 from [Stewart])
Prove that
lim x2 = 0.
x0
Solution
Let be an arbitrary positive real.
Set = . (?).
Let x be an arbitrary real number such that 0 < |x 0| < .
Then:
|x2 0| = |x2 |
< 2
(By assumption (??).)
=
(By assumption (?).)
11
x0
Proof
Let be an arbitrary positive real number.
Set = . (?).
Let x be an arbitrary real number such that 0 < |x| < . (??).
Then:
|f (x) 0| = ||x| 0|
= |(|x|)|
= |x|
<
(By assumption (??).)
=
(By assumption (?).)
Problem 12? : (#1.8.29 from [Stewart])
Prove that
lim (x2 4x + 5) = 1.
x2
Solution Proof
Let be an arbitrary positive real number.
Set = . (?).
Let x be an arbitrary real number such that 0 < |x 2| < . (??).
Then:
|f (x) 1| = (x2 4x + 5)
1
= x2 4x + 4
= (x 2)2
= |x 2|2
< 2
= .
12
1 if x > 0
1 if x < 0
13