You are on page 1of 72

END USES OF NATURAL GAS

20444_a_A_ppt_07 - END USES OF NATURAL GAS

Contents


The gas chain

General presentation of the gas chain


Gas sources
Gas markets
Gas end uses

Transport routes

Chemical conversion routes

Positioning and processing requirements for each monetization


route

20444_a_A_ppt_07 - END USES OF NATURAL GAS

2013 - IFP Training

The Gas Chain


PRODUCTION

CONDITIONING/TRANSPORT

PROCESSING

MARKETS

LNG

ENERGY
GAS

CNG

-Residential
-Industrial
-Transport (NGV)

LIQUEFACTION

COMPRESSION
PIPE

Others (e.g. hydrates transport)

Raw gas

GTL / FT

PROCESSING

LIQUIDS

CHEMICAL
CONVERSION

DME
METHANOL

- Fuel oils and lubricants


- Methanol
- Olefins

Olefins/PP/PE

COMPRESSION

Reinjection
(EOR)
LPG CONDENSATES

CO2 Hg

N2

O2

H2O

To market /
Discharged into natural environment
or stored
20444_a_A_ppt_07 - END USES OF NATURAL GAS

2013 - IFP Training

H2S

Source: Total
3

Gas sources: natural gas fields


Liquids
Gas Field

Non-Associated Gas

Gas
Water
Associated Gas
Petroleum

Non-saturated oil field

Petroleum
Water

Dome gas
Associated Gas
Petroleum
Gas
Saturated oil field

20444_a_A_ppt_07 - END USES OF NATURAL GAS

Petroleum
Water

2013 - IFP Training

Liquids

Gas sources: natural gas fields


Comments on the previous slide
Types of field
Pure gas field containing dry gas, probably associated with water, CO2, nitrogen,
H2S, helium, mercury
Non-saturated oil field: containing petroleum with associated gas, and methane
molecules that will need to be extracted during wellhead processing.
Saturated oil field: containing gas associated with petroleum and gas in solution.
The heaviest dissolved gaseous elements have the same applications as pure gas
fields - for LPG, propane, butane


20444_a_A_ppt_07 - END USES OF NATURAL GAS

2013 - IFP Training

When we find gas or petroleum, the information collected during exploratory


drilling undergoes comprehensive evaluation. How much gas is there? What is
its quality? Is it easy to extract? How much will it cost to develop the field? And
finally, the big question: to what extent will the operation be profitable? If the
information seems favourable to investors and customers, drilling starts and
the gas is extracted.

Gas sources: composition of natural gas

LPG
Liquefied
Petroleum Gas

METHANE

C1

ETHANE

C2

PROPANE
BUTANE

C3
C4

PENTANES & HEAVY FRACTIONS:


Pentanes plus
Natural petrol
Condensates
Water

Nitrogen

C5+

NGL
Natural Gas
Liquids

Helium

Impurities
CO2

H2S

Mercury

...

Gas quality has a major economic impact.

The presence of impurities entails higher processing costs, thereby reducing


the profitability of a gas project.
20444_a_A_ppt_07 - END USES OF NATURAL GAS

2013 - IFP Training

The presence of heavy components (LPG, condensate) improves the


profitability of a gas project.

Gas sources: composition of natural gas


Comments on the previous slide


Why the gas is processed: the natural gas emerging from the ground is not the
clean gas delivered to consumers. Oil fields contain dissolved gas or gas in
the form of a pocket separate from the liquid. Gas deposits generally contain
hydrocarbons heavier than methane, and those that are liquid at ambient
temperature are known as natural gas liquids.

To be eligible for consumption, and partly for transport purposes, the gas must
have certain essential characteristics:
it must be DRY: containing no WATER or HYDROCARBONS in liquid state
its acidic components and toxic bodies must be eliminated
it must have constant heating value and specific gravity, Wobbe index
2013 - IFP Training

20444_a_A_ppt_07 - END USES OF NATURAL GAS

Gas sources: composition of natural gas




Natural gas quality: some semantics

Lean (Dry) Gas


Rich (Wet) Gas
Sour Gas
Highly (Very) Sour Gas
Acid Gas

Sweet Gas
Low Cal Gas

Low NGL content


High NGL content
Presence of CO2 and/or H2S
High CO2 and/or H2S content
Acidic gases separated from natural gas
(H2S+CO2)
Gas scrubbed clean of acidic constituents
High CO2 / N2 content

Comments
Gases with high NGL content are generally gases associated with a liquid hydrocarbon deposit.
Raw gas from a natural or associated gas deposit may contain acidic impurities: H2S and/or CO2, in greater or lesser quantities.

If the treated gas still contains large quantities of CO2 or nitrogen, it has a low heating value.

20444_a_A_ppt_07 - END USES OF NATURAL GAS

2013 - IFP Training

Sweetening these sour raw gases produces a treated or sweet gas and separated acid gases (H2S and CO2 present in the raw gas). This separated
acid gas is generally sent to a sulphur production unit (Claus unit) but can also be reinjected.

Gas markets: energy gas

Gas as an energy source


Fuel:
Residential and commercial
Industrial: heating, steam production, gas turbines

Raw material for electricity production


Thermal power stations

Fuel for transport


NGV: Natural Gas for Vehicles (but limited impact: 60 MMscfd for
500,000 vehicles)

20444_a_A_ppt_07- END USES OF NATURAL GAS

2013 - IFP Training

When the consumer market is a long way away,


costly transport is required

Gas markets: energy gas


Comments on the previous slide


Gas is mainly used as a fuel:


for residential and commercial use (heating)
for industrial use (heating, steam production, feeding gas turbines to power rotating
machines)

It is also used in thermal power stations for electricity production

Natural gas can also be used as a fuel in vehicles internal combustion engines. This
requires a suitable infrastructure (network of service stations with gas compression),
and vehicles equipped with compressed gas tanks.

The gas consumer markets are industrialised countries. Natural gas deposits are
generally located a long way from these markets, which means that the gas must be
transported. Gas is more expensive to transport than oil: where petroleum can be
transported at atmospheric pressure in liquid state, gas must be at high pressure or low
temperature to have sufficient specific gravity to make the transport economic.
2013 - IFP Training

20444_a_A_ppt_07 - END USES OF NATURAL GAS

10

Gas production, consumption and flows in 2012

COMMENTS

2013 - IFP Training

Source : BP Stat Review 2013

Another way to look at the international gas trade, presently donimated by the import to Europe for pipeline gas, and by Japan/Korea for LNG.
EP - 20500_b_A_ppt_06 - FUNDAMENTALS OF LIQUEFIED NATURAL GAS (LNG)

11

Gas markets: fuel oils, lubricants and chemicals




Converting the gas into liquid products opens up access to new


markets:
The fuel oils and lubricants market
GTL-FT conversion:
Diesel
Naphtha
Lubricants

Conversion to Dimethyl-Ether (DME)


The DME market is developing in several emerging countries

The chemicals and petrochemicals markets


Conversion to Methanol
Conversion to Olefins

20444_a_A_ppt_07 - END USES OF NATURAL GAS

2013 - IFP Training

Converting gas to liquid products facilitates market access


by reducing transport costs, but this involves high
investment

12

Gas markets: fuel oils, lubricants and chemicals


Comments on the previous slide
Chemical conversion of gas into liquid products, with higher molar mass, facilitates its
transport.

Gas can be converted into liquid hydrocarbons, gas oil or lubricants, via Fischer-Tropsch
conversion.

It can also be converted into DimethylEther. DME is used as a fuel for vehicles, instead
of LPG. This requires a suitable infrastructure, which certain emerging countries are
putting in place.

Gas can also be chemically converted into methanol, and then possibly into olefins.

Liquid hydrocarbons generally fetch a higher price than natural gas. So the FischerTropsch conversion can also ensure greater profitability of the gas.

On the other hand, chemical conversion facilities are very large and expensive. They are
also highly energy-consuming.

20444_a_A_ppt_07 - END USES OF NATURAL GAS

2013 - IFP Training

13

Gas markets: use in hydrocarbon production

Gas is used for enhanced liquid hydrocarbon recovery


EOR (Enhanced Oil Recovery)

Gas is also used to satisfy the internal consumption needs of


hydrocarbon production and processing centres
Steam generation
Electricity generation
Powering rotating machines
2013 - IFP Training

20444_a_A_ppt_07 - END USES OF NATURAL GAS

14

Gas markets: monetization routes

Domestic gas
CONVERSION

TRANSPORT
Gas pipeline

GTL/FT

Fuel oils /
Lubricants
&
Chemicals /
Petrochemicals
markets

DME

Natural
or associated gas

LNG

Onshore
Offshore

CNG

Energy gas
market

NGH
METHANOL
GTW

20444_a_A_ppt_07 - END USES OF NATURAL GAS

2013 - IFP Training

Used by the
hydrocarbons producer

15

Gas markets: monetization routes


Comments on the previous slide


Gas is a low concentration energy (a volume of gas under ambient conditions has approximately
1000 times less energy than the same volume of petroleum), and commercial exploitation of gas
resources when there is no nearby domestic market is always confronted with the problem of
transporting or converting the gas for sale for end use on a distant market.

The choice of technology to be adopted must be examined on an individual basis, but the main
means for transport remain: gas pipeline, LNG (including mini-LNG), GTW (Gas to Wire) i.e.
converting the gas into electricity, CNG (Compressed Natural Gas) and NGH (Natural Gas Hydrates).
The target end markets are the gas and/or electricity markets.

As regards conversion, with petrochemicals and fuels as the end markets, the currently feasible
means are: methanol and GTL, and DME (DiMethyl Ether).

Historically, the first target market was gas and energy, via pipelines and LNG, but the attraction of
the liquid markets - bigger, more flexible and with higher added value has driven the
development of these new technologies.
2013 - IFP Training

20444_a_A_ppt_07 - END USES OF NATURAL GAS

16

Contents


The gas chain

Transport routes

Gas pipeline
Liquefied gas (LNG)
Compressed gas (CNG)
Transport in the form of hydrates (NGH)
Gas to wire (GTW)

Chemical conversion routes

Positioning and processing requirements for each monetization


route

20444_a_A_ppt_07 - END USES OF NATURAL GAS

2013 - IFP Training

17

Gas pipeline: principle

The mostly used transport


route

A gas pipeline comprises:


a transport pipe
compression stations

Gas pipelines

2013 - IFP Training

Recompression
stations
Collection

Processing
Terminal - storage

20444_a_A_ppt_07 - END USES OF NATURAL GAS

18

Gas pipeline: principle


Comments on the previous slide


Gas pipelines were the first equipment used for transporting gas over long distances from the
production site to the consumption site. A gas pipeline essentially comprises a gas transport line
and compression stations designed to compensate for pressure losses due to gas friction as it
flows.

A gas pipeline chain comprises the following stages:

This mature and simple technology poses the following drawbacks: incompressible investment,
geopolitical risks associated with the countries crossed, difficulty in installing new pipelines in
highly urbanised areas and technical feasibilities (trenches, seismic hazard zones)

20444_a_A_ppt_07 - END USES OF NATURAL GAS

2013 - IFP Training

collection of effluent from the various wells


processing of the gas produced to bring it up to the transport specifications: separation of the heaviest
hydrocarbons and dehydration to prevent risks of condensation, hydrate formation and corrosion; this
treatment may be supplemented by sweetening
gas compression if the wellhead pressure is insufficient (especially in the deposit depletion phase)
transport through the pipeline
recompression during transport, for long distances, to prevent an excessive pressure drop
any additional processing to bring the gas up to the distribution specifications
storage and transfer to the distribution network
distribution of the gas.

19

Gas pipeline: sizing

Flowrate (MSm3/h)

SIZING OF MAIN GAS PIPELINE

Service pressure: 90 bar  50 bar before recompression


20444_a_A_ppt_07 - END USES OF NATURAL GAS

2013 - IFP Training

Length without recompression (km)

20

Gas pipeline: sizing


Comments on the previous slide


This graph suffices to determine an initial sizing estimate for transporting gas via
pipelines.

Based on the chart on the right and the pre-determined hypotheses, for lengths without
recompression between 100 and 1000 km, and pipe diameters of between 24 and 56,
a gas pipeline can transport up to 6-7 MSm3/h, i.e. approximately 5500 MMscfd.

Note that beyond 48, pipelines must adhere to local legislation. Currently, only Russia
permits pipeline diameters of 56.

Similarly, the maximum pressure in an onshore pipeline is limited by the countrys


legislation. Generally, the maximum value is 80 bar. Exemptions have been granted up
to 100 bar, following negotiations with the authorities.

2013 - IFP Training

20444_a_A_ppt_07 - END USES OF NATURAL GAS

21

Gas pipeline: selection criteria

Advantages

Important orders of magnitude:

Consumption of 1 % per 1000 km


Mature
1.5 to 2 kT CO2/MMBoe
Relatively simple
Efficient, and low CO2 emissions
No restrictive specifications
Economical for short distances
Applicable to all types of reserves in principle

Drawbacks
Location constraints highly case dependent
Long-term fixed transport installation
Sensitivity to geopolitical risk
Not economical over long distances

20444_a_A_ppt_07 - END USES OF NATURAL GAS

2013 - IFP Training

22

LNG: the LNG chain




Liquefaction, transport and regasification


Train capacities: from 1 to 8 MTPA
Transport: atmospheric pressure and T=-160
C
1 m3 of LNG = 580 Sm3 of natural gas

2013 - IFP Training

20444_a_A_ppt_07 - END USES OF NATURAL GAS

23

LNG: the LNG chain


Comments on the previous slide


Liquefaction is a technology used for condensing natural gas, with a high volume reduction factor:
580 m3 of natural gas per m3 of LNG. The gas is transported in liquid form at atmospheric pressure
and at a temperature close to - 160
C. The quantities used by an LNG project are always large (> 3
3
MTPA, i.e. 4.5 billion m /year), and generally supply regasification terminals serving national
distribution networks, except for Japan, where certain terminals only supply power stations.

An LNG transport chain comprises the following main stages:

This mature technology has the following advantages: greater flexibility than pipelines, high
efficiency. On the drawbacks side, it is highly capital-intensive, and requires long-term contracts.

20444_a_A_ppt_07 - END USES OF NATURAL GAS

2013 - IFP Training

processing and transport by gas pipeline to the coast


processing of produced gas to bring it up to the requisite specifications for liquefaction (deep sweetening,
dehydration, removal of heavy metals)
liquefaction of gas, possibly accompanied by recovery of Liquefied Petroleum Gases (LPG) for separate end
use
storage and loading (shipping terminal)
transport by methane tankers
receival and storage
regasification.

24

LNG: liquefaction

20444_a_A_ppt_07 - END USES OF NATURAL GAS

2013 - IFP Training

With 8 production trains, the plant has reached a capacity of


22.25 MT/year of LNG + 1 Mt/year of LPG + 10 Million b/year of condensates

25

LNG: comparative transport costs


5

$/MMBtu

High-cost
gas pipeline
4

Low-cost
gas pipeline
3

LNG

Oil tankers

Oil
pipeline
km

Heavy investment: ($/mmbtu)

20444_a_A_ppt_07 - END USES OF NATURAL GAS

160
0

320
0

400
0

Production: 0. 2.5
Processing: 0.1 0.25 * 3 offshore
Transport: 0.5 4.5
Distribution: 1.2 2.8
TOTAL: 2.1 10.5

640
0

800
0

2013 - IFP Training

80
0
Comments

26

LNG: selection criteria

Advantages

Mature, except for offshore LNG (FLNG)


Efficient for transport
Economical over long distances
Storage
Flexible for downstream

Important orders of magnitude:


CO2 spec of feed gas: CO2 < 50 ppm
Liquefaction cons.: 10-15 %
Transport cons.: 0.4 %/1000 km
Regasification cons.: 0.5-1.5 %
Liquefaction
emissions:
35-45
CO2/MMboe
NG reserves : large

kT

Drawbacks
High investment required
Tough location and installation constraints
CO2 specifications
High internal consumption and CO2 emissions
Uneconomical over short distances
Economical for large gas reserves

20444_a_A_ppt_07 - END USES OF NATURAL GAS

2013 - IFP Training

27

CNG: principle

Pressure (bar.a)

m3 gas/m3 transported

Vapour

Liquid
2013 - IFP Training

Temperature (C)
20444_a_A_ppt_07 - END USES OF NATURAL GAS

28

CNG: principle
Comments on the previous slide


This graph positions the various CNG technologies in pressure and temperature terms in relation to
one another and to LNG. As a reminder, LNG - Liquefied Natural Gas - is a gas condensed at a
temperature of 160C and at ambient pressure.

8 different CNG technologies - of varying maturity , as we will see later - are currently available on
the market. They function in two fairly distinct pressure and temperature ranges. The first,
qualified as High Pressure, is associated with ambient temperature, which gives operating
pressures for CNG cylinders of approximately 200 to 250 b. The second is a medium pressure
region (around 120/130 b) associated with a lower temperature of around 30C.

The efficiency gain obtained by cooling the gas operates on 2 levels:


The volume occupied by the gas is reduced as a function of the temperatures ratio (PV/T = cste)

At low temperatures, the behaviour of the gas increasingly diverges from the ideal gas law, the
compressibility factor expressed in the formula (PV = nZRT) drops steeply, which results in a steep increase
in the compression ratios. Conversely, employing low temperatures makes the whole export chain more
complex

These combinations can achieve ratios of gas volume under standard conditions to volume transported of
230 to 290 m3/m3. This is to be compared with the ratio of 580/600 obtained for LNG.

20444_a_A_ppt_07 - END USES OF NATURAL GAS

2013 - IFP Training

29

CNG: principle

Gas transported in dense state:


either at ambient temperature and P = 250 bar
or T = 30
C and P = 120 bar
CNG downstream
process

CNG upstream process

CNG fleet

CNG export method

20444_a_A_ppt_07 - END USES OF NATURAL GAS

Unloading system

2013 - IFP Training

Loading system

30

CNG: principle
Comments on the previous slide


The principle of gas transport as CNG is based on obtaining a gas in dense phase state through
compression at ambient temperature or low temperature (approx. 30
C). The fluid obtained
3
reaches densities of around 150 to 250 kg/m , as compared with 500 kg/m3 for LNG.

The gas is processed upstream in order to achieve the transport and, where relevant, commercial
specifications and is then transported (by ship or truck) to the downstream processing site, where
it will be transferred to a local market.

This technology seems to be a valid alternative to LNG and pipelines for certain cases (small
quantities of gas and short distances) but, as at 2012, there are not yet any operational references
for sea transport, although there are land transport references by truck in Argentina, for example.

2013 - IFP Training

20444_a_A_ppt_07 - END USES OF NATURAL GAS

31

CNG: selection criteria




Advantages
No very restrictive
specifications
Makes short distances
economical
Offshore production

Important orders of magnitude


Km 0 consumption: 12%
Transport consumption: 1%/1000 km
Total emissions over 2000 km:
30 kT CO2/MMboe
NG reserves : low, average

Drawbacks
No commercial application with
transport by ship in 2012
Inefficient for transport
High costs
2013 - IFP Training

20444_a_A_ppt_07 - END USES OF NATURAL GAS

32

Transport in the form of hydrates (NGH): principle

After CNG, now lets look at methane hydrates as a gas transport solution. With CNG, the gas is compressed to concentrate it; with liquefaction
we turn it into a liquid through condensation; and with hydrates we turn it into a solid by trapping gas molecules in crystalline water structures.
The diagram positions the hydrate formation region in pressure regions of around 40/50 bar and at positive temperatures. Then the hydrates
are cooled and the pressure returned practically to ambient pressure. A metastability phenomenon revealed by the Norwegians enables
hydrates to be kept stable for transportation.
20444_a_A_ppt_07 - END USES OF NATURAL GAS

2013 - IFP Training

Comments

33

Transport in the form of hydrates (NGH): principle




Gas transport in solid form:


at atmospheric pressure and T = 20
C

20444_a_A_ppt_07 - END USES OF NATURAL GAS

2013 - IFP Training

Major drawback: transport of 85% water (by mass)

34

Transport in the form of hydrates (NGH): principle


Comments on the previous slide


Natural gas hydrates offer a means of storing large quantities of gas with a volume reduction
factor of around 180 (less advantageous than LNG 600 - and CNG 300 on average). They are
also stable under normal conditions. NGH consists in using gas hydrates to transport the gas in
solid form at atmospheric pressure and at a temperature of approximately 20
C. It is defined by
the following stages:

Production: the gas from a field is injected into a reactor at a temperature of approx. 10
C and a pressure
of 60 bar where, in contact with water, it will be trapped in the form of hydrates.

Transport: the hydrates are transferred to a ship and transported from the production site to the
distribution site.

Regasification: close to the distribution market, the hydrates are dissociated and the gas is distributed.

NGH is immature and does not seem to have great potential, in the short term at least.

2013 - IFP Training

20444_a_A_ppt_07- END USES OF NATURAL GAS

35

Transport in the form of hydrates (NGH): selection criteria

Advantages
Transport
pressure

at

atmospheric

Drawbacks

Important orders of magnitude


Km 0 cons.: 4-5 %
Transport cons.: 3 %/1000 km
Total emissions over 3000 km: 50 kT
CO2/MMBoe
NG reserves : very small

Immature, industrial feasibility


not proven. 2015-2020
deadline?
Transports 85% water (by
mass)
Inefficient
High costs
Very low gas reserves
2013 - IFP Training

20444_a_A_ppt_07 - END USES OF NATURAL GAS

36

Gas to wire (GTW): principle

2013 - IFP Training

20444_a_A_ppt_07 - END USES OF NATURAL GAS

37

Gas to wire (GTW): principle


Comments on the previous slide


One of the solutions for transferring medium quantities of gas to the markets is to convert it into
electricity. This technology, dubbed GTW (Gas to Wire), has numerous advantages:

electricity is the energy source most easily usable by the consumer and also offers significant growth
prospects

deregulation of the electricity market in many countries offers the opportunity to become a producer

using gas as a fuel makes GTW an ecologically clean sector

the cycles used are efficient compared to other means of electricity production.

GTW also has drawbacks:


given the large quantities of electricity produced, you need a market able to provide outlets for it. In many
potentially GTW candidate countries, the local market can only absorb a small proportion of the electricity
produced. The rest must be transported over distances of thousands of km, which is costly, involves
substantial losses and exposes the installations to sabotage.

a power station requires a stable supply chain over a period of at least 20 years. A gas production profile
associated with oil production often peaks before rapidly falling. So GTW will be more suitable for natural
gas deposits.

20444_a_A_ppt_07 - END USES OF NATURAL GAS

2013 - IFP Training

38

GTW: combined cycle power station

2013 - IFP Training

20444_a_A_ppt_07 - END USES OF NATURAL GAS

39

GTW: combined cycle power station


Comments on the previous slide


The combined cycle uses the heat from the gas turbine exhaust gases to generate steam, which
expands in a turbine until it condenses. Hence the power of the gas turbine is increased by one
third and the net overall ISO efficiency may reach 58%. The main parts in a combined cycle are the
gas turbine, the recovery boiler, the steam turbine, the condenser and electricity generator.

The condenser uses ambient air or water to condense the steam; the choice of condenser type
depends on the local water resource, and directly influences the combined cycle performance.

A combined cycle brings numerous advantages:

20444_a_A_ppt_07 - END USES OF NATURAL GAS

2013 - IFP Training

high efficiency, i.e. electricity production at minimum costs


partial-load operation can be optimised by adjusting the power station configuration (3*33 % or 2*50 %)
high availability (92% on average over a year) if the maintenance program, concentrated within the offpeak period, is observed
flexibility of use, especially with the Single-shaft configuration
small workforce (54 people for a 1260-MW power station)
investment cost lower than for a steam power station
short construction time (25 months for a standard module)
lower atmospheric emissions

40

Gas to wire (GTW): efficiency

2013 - IFP Training

20444_a_A_ppt_07 - END USES OF NATURAL GAS

41

Gas to wire (GTW): efficiency


Comments on the previous slide
Continuous transport of electrical energy


DC (direct current) transport has numerous advantages over AC (alternating current) transport:

lower line installation cost


smaller line losses
possible interconnection of networks operating at different frequencies
continuity of service in case of failure
highly flexible operation

Conversely, the major drawback of DC transport is the obligation to install at each line-end an
AC/DC conversion station, which is expensive (approx. $175 million (in 2000) for 1000 MW in +/500 kV). However, beyond a certain transport distance, the savings generated by the lower
installation cost of a DC line compensate for the expense of building conversion stations.
2013 - IFP Training

20444_a_A_ppt_07 - END USES OF NATURAL GAS

42

GTW: combined cycle organisation


BangBo - ABB/Alsthom technology

Cooling tower
Water treatment
Discharge water
Heat recovery steam generator
Gas compressor

Gas inlet
Fuel storage
Clean water tank
HV zone
Turbine buildings

2013 - IFP Training

20444_a_A_ppt_07 - END USES OF NATURAL GAS

43

Gas to wire (GTW): selection criteria

Advantages
Mature technology
Attractive thermal efficiency and costs
Open electricity market
Rapid implementation (construction 2
years)
Operating flexibility
No special constraints

Important orders of magnitude


1 MSm3/d gas = 250 MWe (combined
cycle)
Electricity
generation
efficiency
(combined cycle): ~ 50 %
NG reserves : small

Drawbacks

20444_a_A_ppt_07 - END USES OF NATURAL GAS

2013 - IFP Training

Economical for capacities


< 1000 MW
Not economical over long
distances (> 1500-2000 km)
Very high surface area
of AC/DC and DC/AC conversion
stations

44

Contents


Gas chain

Transport routes

Chemical conversion routes


Fischer-Tropsch (GTL/FT)
DiMethyl-Ether (DME)
Methanol and other chemical sectors

Positioning and processing requirements for each monetization


route

20444_a_A_ppt_07 - END USES OF NATURAL GAS

2013 - IFP Training

45

Chemical conversions

2013 - IFP Training

20444_a_A_ppt_07 - END USES OF NATURAL GAS

46

Chemical conversions
Comments on the previous slide


Another way of commercialising natural gas is to chemically convert it into liquid products, more
easily transportable under ambient conditions. There are various methods, but the first stage
common to every case is conversion of natural gas into synthesis gas with catalysts (SMR, ATR,
catalytic POx) or without catalysts (gas POx), a mixture of carbon monoxide (CO) and hydrogen
(H2). The H2/CO ratio of the synthesis gas produced must differ according to the target end product.

The products examined in this study are:

the Fischer-Tropsch process, producing Diesel and naphtha


methanol
DME: only the direct process is examined here, as it maximises energy efficiency

These differ widely in terms of target markets and their size. The technical constraints (process,
location, etc.) vary.

For information, the optimum stoichiometric ratios at the synthesis gas production outlet are as
follows:
GTL/FT: H2/CO = 1.7 for iron-based catalysts and H2/CO = 2 for cobalt-based catalysts
Direct DME: H2/CO = 1
Methanol H2-CO2 / CO + CO2 = 2

20444_a_A_ppt_07 - END USES OF NATURAL GAS

2013 - IFP Training

47

GTL/FT: brief history

1920

1940
1924

German discovery
Conversion of CO & H2
into hydrocarbon

F.Fischer & H.Tropsch

1935

WWII

1960
1955

1980
1980-82

2000
1990-2000

2006 2007

1993
1st Industrial FT
Atmospheric fixed bed
reactor - Rhurchemie

SASOL I
Iron Medium Pressure
Synthesis commercialized by
Rhurchemie and Lurgi
(8,000 BPD)

9 FT Plants
built in Germany
Support German petroleum
independency during WWII
(~16,000BPD)

SASOL II & III


150,000 BPD plant in South
Africa, Fe catalyst and
Circulating Fluidized Bed
Reactor

ORYX (QP+SASOLChevron)
34,000 BPD plant in Qatar Co Cat. Slurry Reactors.

Synthol CFB Reactors

WWII German Low


Pressure Reactors

ARGE
Fixed Bed Reactor

SHELL BINTULU
12,500 BPD plant in
Malaysia, Co catalyst Fixed
Bed Reactor

PEARL
(QP+SHELL)
2x70,000 BPD plant in Qatar
- Co Cat. Fixed bed Reactors.

2013 - IFP Training

Patent granted to Fischer


& Tropsch

SASOL
Dev. of Advanced Synthol
Process
SASOL II & III Reactors
Replacement

Source: Total
20444_a_A_ppt_07 - END USES OF NATURAL GAS

48

GTL/FT: principle


Production of liquid hydrocarbons from natural gas in 3 stages:


Synthesis gas generation - highly endothermic
Fischer-Tropsch synthesis - highly exothermic
upgrading
Light HC (used as fuel
H2O and/or O2

Fields

Pretreatment

Synthesis gas
generation

Steam

FischerTropsch
synthesis

gas or syngas load)

Waxes and

Hydro-treatment
condensates Hydro-cracking

Water

(+ lube bases)

20444_a_A_ppt_07 - END USES OF NATURAL GAS

Local or
transport

2013 - IFP Training

Diesel
+
Paraffin naphtha

MARKETS:
Local or
transport
Petrochemicals

49

GTL/FT: principle
Comments on the previous slide


Chemical conversion of natural gas via Fischer Tropsch synthesis, often known as GTL/FT, produces
liquid hydrocarbons such as gas oil or kerosene. It follows the three main stages below:

conversion into synthesis gas (syngas), a mix of carbon monoxide and hydrogen

Fischer Tropsch synthesis: primarily paraffin-like, very long carbon chain compounds, known as waxes

upgrading into lighter hydrocarbons by means of hydro-treatment units, to obtain primarily diesel (75%)
and naphtha (25 %).

A successful GTL chain necessarily means integrating the three units, and this demands highly
specialised know-how.

This highly capital-intensive technology has few operational references, low efficiency and high
CO2 emissions, but it opens up access to the huge fuels market.

2013 - IFP Training

20444_a_A_ppt_07 - END USES OF NATURAL GAS

50

GTL/FT: synthesis gas generation

1.

SMR

Boiler zone

S/C > 2.5


T: 850-900C
P ~ 20 bar
H2/CO ~ 4.8
flue gas

Prerefor
mer

Radiant zone
(naked flames /
tubes filled with catalyst)

steam
Desulphurised
natural gas
(ppbs S)

20444_a_A_ppt_07 - END USES OF NATURAL GAS

2013 - IFP Training

air

synthesis gas
to process

fuel gas
51

GTL/FT: synthesis gas generation

2.

POX

S/C < 0.2


T ~ 1350C
P ~ 60 bar
H2/CO <1.9
Advantages:

Constraints:

High conversion
High CO/CO2 selectivity
H2/CO ratio close to optimum for F-T
Need for additional SMR
High outlet T
Air separation plant

2013 - IFP Training

20444_a_A_ppt_07 - END USES OF NATURAL GAS

52

GTL/FT: synthesis gas generation

3.

ATR
S/C ~ 1.2
T ~ 1050C
P ~ 20-50 bar
H2/CO ~2.6

Combining POX and catalytic reforming

Constraints:

CO2 recycling, F-T purge


Air separation plant

20444_a_A_ppt_07 - END USES OF NATURAL GAS

2013 - IFP Training

N.B. there is air ATR, with constraints


downstream due to high nitrogen load

53

GTL/FT: the Fischer-Tropsch stage


Main reaction

n CO + 2n H2  -(CH2)n- + nH2O + n x 165 kJ

 primarily: mix of paraffins C1->C200


 olefins
 alcohols, acids, oxygenated solvents
 volume water ~ volume HC
 no sulphur or aromatics

 Catalyst: iron based or cobalt based


 Reactor: multi-tube fixed bed or slurry
20444_a_A_ppt_07 - END USES OF NATURAL GAS

2013 - IFP Training

Technological options

54

GTL/FT: selection criteria

Advantages
Usable over a wide range of
capacities
Efficient to transport
No market constraint

Important orders of magnitude

H2S < 0.1 ppm


Energy efficiency: 42-52%
Emissions: 150 kT CO2/Mmboe
NG reserves : average to large

Drawbacks

Oryx Sasol /QP: 34,000 bpd


20444_a_A_ppt_07 - END USES OF NATURAL GAS

2013 - IFP Training

H2S specifications
High energy consumption and
high CO2 emissions
High
technical
cost
(compared to other types of
conversion)
Complexity due to various
types of product

55

DME: principle


Two processes:

Pilot Plant in JFE Tsurumi Factory

direct conversion or via methanol




Two different markets:


chemicals (
 olefins) and energy (fuel
for vehicles)

2013 - IFP Training

20444_a_A_ppt_07 - END USES OF NATURAL GAS

56

DME: principle
Comments on the previous slide


Todays global DiMethylEther (DME) market represents 150,000 tonnes per year, and encompasses
aerosol applications, particularly in the field of cosmetics. Since this application is already mature
and the market very small, DME could be used as diesel fuel in appropriate engines (clean gas fuel),
as fuel in energy production turbines or in domestic applications. With the chemical formula CH3O-CH3, DME is gaseous under normal conditions and its physical characteristics are very similar to
those of LPG.

There are two types of process for synthesising DME, either directly, or via methanol as the
intermediary.

The direct process optimises energy efficiency: the potential maximum efficiency (65-70%) appears
to be the best of the conversion processes.

There are a host of technology licensors for the indirect process: TOPSOE, LURGI, TEC and MGC. At
present, only JFE fully masters the direct process.
2013 - IFP Training

20444_a_A_ppt_07 - END USES OF NATURAL GAS

57

DME: selection criteria

Advantages
Lower CO2 emissions than
GTL/FT
Single product
Possibility of mixing with LPG

Important orders of magnitude

H2S < 0.1 ppm


Energy efficiency: 60%
Emissions: 75 kT CO2/MMboe
NG reserves : small

DME is supplied from 100t/d Demonstration Plant at Kushiro

Drawbacks

20444_a_A_ppt_07 - END USES OF NATURAL GAS

2013 - IFP Training

H2S specifications
Immature: no commercial
installation in 2011 (one in
project)
Markets to be developed

58

Methanol: principle


3 stages:
Synthesis gas generation
Methanol synthesis
Distillation

2013 - IFP Training

20444_a_A_ppt_07 - END USES OF NATURAL GAS

59

Methanol: principle
Comments on the previous slide


Methanol is the simplest alcohol, with chemical composition CH3-OH, and is used primarily as a
base compound in the chemicals industry. Methanol fuel is very little used at present. The main
outlet today (approx. of worldwide production) is in the manufacture of chemicals, primarily
formaldehyde. Then comes manufacture of MTBE (approx. 1/4 of the market), an additive added
to petrol to increase its octane rating. It is synthesised in three stages, as in the case of Fischer
Tropsch synthesis:

synthesis gas production


methanol synthesis
purification of end product

For the moment the methanol route is essentially limited by the market size.

The first cases of a methanol production rate exceeding 1000 t/d date back to the 1980s. The
plants are located chiefly in gas-producing countries.
2013 - IFP Training

20444_a_A_ppt_07 - END USES OF NATURAL GAS

60

From gas to plastics: principle




4 stages:

synthesis gas generation


methanol or DME synthesis
conversion into olefins (MTO / DTO)
polymerisation
Integrated MTO - PE-PP

Natural gas
Coal

Methanol
Plant
MTO

Syngas
Plant

indirect

direct

DME
Plant

+ OCP
Plant

Polyethylene
Plant
Polypropylene
Plant

Source: Total Petrochemicals

20444_a_A_ppt_07 - END USES OF NATURAL GAS

2013 - IFP Training

MTO: Methanol to Olefins


DTO: Dimethylether to Olefins
OCP: Olefin Cracking Process

61

Methanol: selection criteria




Advantages

Mature
More efficient and lower CO2
emissions than GTL/FT
The cheapest of the conversion
routes
Single product


Important orders of magnitude

H2S < 0.1 ppm


Energy efficiency: 65%
Emissions: 75 kT CO2/Mmboe
NG reserves : small

Drawbacks

20444_a_A_ppt_07 - END USES OF NATURAL GAS

2013 - IFP Training

H2S specifications
Market constraint: economy
of scale required, but
difficult due to the tight
market

62

Contents


The gas chain

Transport

Chemical conversion

Positioning and processing requirements for each monetization


route
2013 - IFP Training

20444_a_A_ppt_07 - END USES OF NATURAL GAS

63

Positioning for each monetization route


Reserves

10 TCF

5 TCF

GAS PIPELINE
LNG
CNG
DME
MeOH
Distances to 500
market

GTL
1000

10 000 km

GAS PIPELINE
LNG
CNG
GTL / MeOH / DME: distance to market: no real impact
Energy Eff.

50 %

60 %

70 %

90 %

80 %
LNG
CNG

GTL
20444_a_A_ppt_07 - END USES OF NATURAL GAS

MeOH

DME

2013 - IFP Training

GAS PIPELINE

64

Positioning for each monetization route


Comments on the previous slide


Gas pipelines transport medium-to-high volumes of gas over distances of thousands of km. They
remain a rigid solution, sensitive to geopolitical risks. They are also limited by geographical
constraints (e.g. ocean trenches).

To transport gas over very long distances, LNG is the most economical solution but as it is
expensive, the economy requires high volumes of gas.

CNG is more suitable for small volumes of gas and short distances (up to 1,000 km).

The conversion processes all have lower energy efficiencies than the transport alternatives. The
market for the Fischer-Tropsch method products is not limited, unlike the DME and methanol
method markets which are very limited.

2013 - IFP Training

20444_a_A_ppt_07 - END USES OF NATURAL GAS

65

Commercial specifications of gas





Interchangeability: measured by Wobbe index


3 categories of countries for gases:
Specific gravity of
methane = 0.555

IW =

PCS
dgaz
dair

Asian
Countries
RICH GASES

Specific gravity for


black flue gas = 0.7

20444_a_A_ppt_07 - END USES OF NATURAL GAS

United States and


United Kingdom:
LEAN GASES

European
countries: future
EASEE-gas standard

2013 - IFP Training

Nitrogen

66

Commercial specifications of gas


Comments on the previous slide


There are several kinds of commercial specifications:

toxicity and corrosion (max. content of oxygen and sulphur-based compounds)


formation of hydrates and liquid (water and hydrocarbons dew point)
interchangeability

Interchangeability characterises the composition thresholds and properties of the gases, to ensure
satisfactory operation of devices running on gas, and is measured by the Wobbe index. It is
important this should remain as constant as possible. We therefore give an upper and lower
threshold value for this index, and combustion emissions can be controlled, burner efficiency is
improved and the operating conditions of this equipment are secured.

This positioning enables us to determine the type of composition possible for an H type gas (high
heating value): so lean gases will contain little C3+ and may have relatively large proportions of
nitrogen. Gases for Japan, on the other hand, must be low in N2 and rich in ethane and propane.

Certain gases, known as L gases (low heating value), contain more inert gas and have Wobbe index
values below 47 MJ/Nm3, and so are not interchangeable with any current specifications. This is
the case for certain fields in Thailand and the Groningen gas reserves in the Netherlands, for
example. So with very little or no pre-treatment, these gases must be distributed in a different
network.

20444_a_A_ppt_07 - END USES OF NATURAL GAS

2013 - IFP Training

67

Technological specifications


3 families of routes for the H2S/CO2 grid


4
3

2
H2S, total S or
H2S+COS
specifications

EASEE-gas: European Association for Streamlining of Energy Exchange - gas


20444_a_A_ppt_07 - END USES OF NATURAL GAS

2013 - IFP Training

EASEE-gas: H2S+COS < 3 ppm and total sulphur < 19 ppm


L gas: CO2 spec at 25% mol for the Thai network for example

68

Technological specifications
Comments on the previous slide


It is important to stress that the EASEE-gas H2S specification is more precisely a specification
limiting H2S + COS to 3 ppm.

Gas monetization routes fall into three categories:

LNG, for which the constraints are both technological (CO2 which must be removed to prevent it from
crystallising and clogging the equipment in cryogenic zones) and commercial

the conversion routes, where there is no reason for commercial gas specifications, leaving only H2S content,
which is highly restrictive (H2S is poisonous to the catalysts used, even at low concentration)

gas pipelines, CNG and methane hydrates: only commercial specifications (H2S, CO2) are genuinely
restrictive.

2013 - IFP Training

20444_a_A_ppt_07 - END USES OF NATURAL GAS

69

Quiz
True
The gas chain includes a gas treatment stage, followed by transport to the consumer markets.

False

...

It also includes a gas conditioning stage (compression, liquefaction) for transport to the energy gas markets, or a chemical conversion
stage for conversion before the transport stage.

All technologies involving chemical conversion of the gas start with a synthesis gas generation stage

Yes. The synthesis gas is then converted into liquid hydrocarbons (GTL-FT), methanol or DME.
...

LNG is more economic than gas pipeline transport over distances of more than 3,000 km.

True, insofar as it is possible to transport the gas by sea; otherwise land transport of large quantities of LNG is impossible.
...

All gas liquefaction plants are located on the coast

..
...
Liquefied
gas is effectively transported over long distances in methane tankers. If the gas deposit is far from the coast, it is preferable

to transport gas in a pipeline as far as the coast, and liquefy it at the methane tanker loading site.

Conversion of gas into DME has good energy efficiency, better than GTL-FT and equivalent to that of LNG

.....

DME is more energy-efficient than GTL-FT (70% vs. 60%), but less efficient than LNG (80-85% efficiency)

CNG can be used to exploit very large gas reserves (more than 5 Tcf), but over relatively short distances
(< 1000 km)

..

CNG is denser than LNG

...
False. The specific gravity of LNG is 580 times denser than gas under standard conditions; the specific gravity of CNG is between 295
..and

320 times that of gas under standard conditions, depending on the CNG process used.

20444_a_A_ppt_07 - END USES OF NATURAL GAS

2013 - IFP Training

No, CNG is suitable for medium-sized gas reserves (less than 2 Tcf), over relatively short distances.
...

70

Key points to remember


The gas chain comprises several stages: production and processing, conditioning
or chemical conversion, and transport to the consumer markets.

The gas markets are generally a long distance away from the production sites.

Gas may be transported by means of a gas pipeline (gaseous at ambient


temperature and at high pressure), by methane tankers (liquid at 160C and
atmospheric pressure) or under intermediate conditions (CNG).

Chemical conversion enables us to reach the fuel oils and lubricants markets
(GTL/FT, DME) or the chemicals market, while facilitating transport but at the
cost of major investment.

The monetization route must be selected on an individual basis, according to the


markets available and the economy of each route (dependent on the size of the
reserves, the product value and the transport cost).

Gas processing must be suited to the monetization route, so as to satisfy the


commercial specifications of the finished product, but also the technological
specifications specific to each route.

20444_a_A_ppt_07 - END USES OF NATURAL GAS

2013 - IFP Training

71

Approximate conversion factors

Chaleur
/ Energie
Heat / Energy
Million Btu (MMBtu)

GJ
1

Mcal
250

kWh
300

Flow rate
Dbit

Volume
cubic meter (cm)

Heating
Value
Valeur
Calorifique
Btu/cf
1000

cubic feet (cf)


35

Mcal/m3
9

Million cubic feet per day


(MMcfd)
100

Btu/m3
35 000

Mj/m3
35

Billion cubic
meter per year
(Bcm/y)
1

kWh/m3
10

Equivalences
1 bep
1 t1charbon
t coal

t (LNG)
t (GNL)

20444_a_A_ppt_07 - END USES OF NATURAL GAS

m3m3
(LNG)
(GNL)
2,5

m3 (gas)
m3
(gaz)
1500

MMBtu
53

kWh
15 000

m3
m3(gas)
gaz
180
750
2013 - IFP Training

Gaz
naturel
liqufi
Liquefied
natural
gas

MMBtu gaz
6
25

72

You might also like