Professional Documents
Culture Documents
org -
1. Prologue
2. Q1. Sangam Literature
1. Part#1: doesnt help in Political history because:
2. Part#2: Social conditions in Sangam Age
3. Part#3: Economic conditions in Sangam Age
3. Q2. Chola Temples
4. Q3. Tandav Dance
5. Analysis/Rambling/Commentary/Observations:
1. Marks per question
2. Difficulty level & BackbreakingTM
3. Causal revision = #Epicfail
4. Focus on Dramatic part = also #EPICFAIL
5. Studyplan for Mains-2014 Culture section
6. Working professionals dont waste salary
7. No point in crying over the spilled milk
Prologue
The syllabus is new, pattern is new, BackbreakingTM techniques are new:
hence any analysis is hollow and shallow, without solving the questions first.
So, Lets start with the
Culture Questions in GSM-I-2013
Following questions were asked:
marks words
10
200
100
100
20
400
SchoolTextbook
CompetitiveExam
Academic
NCERTs
hardly
hardly
didnt
find
NIOS Culture
hardly
few
lines
one line
Tamilnadu Class 11
yes
yes
ICSE Class 9
yes
yes
yes
yes
hardly
yes
yes
yes
Krishna Reddy
yes
yes
didnt
find
didnt
find.
didnt
find.
just 1
line
didnt
find.
didnt
find.
didnt
use
didnt
use
yes
Few
lines.
Yes= means at least 60% of the answer content was available. Yes
doesnt mean 100% content for the said question is given verbatim in the
said book.
Didnt find= either the answer was not given there OR I didnt read
carefully.
Didnt use=because same content given in standard reference books for
free/ cheap price.
Now time for the answers:
USEFUL
1. 2/3rd of the answer (Society + Economy) can
be directly finished from ICSE Class 9 History
textbook alone. But doesnt talk about first
part (Why Sangam literature doesnt help
understanding pol.history of S.India?)
2. ^same as above with TMH General Studies
Manual.
3. Old NCERT Class 11 = Indias Ancient past RS
Sharma (under Oxford Publication). Matter
Covered under chapter 3 and 22.
4. Tamilnadu State Board History Textbook Class 11,
Chapter 8
VALUES
VARNAS
Women
social
Interaction
DEATH
OVERALL
Economy
Occupation
FOREIGN
TRADE
WOMEN in
Economy
Keypoints- Sangam
Q. Though not very useful from the point of view of a connected political history of
South India, the Sangam literature portrays the social and economic conditions of
its time with remarkable vividness. Comment. (10m | 200words)
Key points:
1. Sagam Litt. fails to give political history because:
1. While three Sangams were held, only the last gathering provides
1. Material
2. Walls &
Passages
have neatly detailed frescoes, sculptures and paintingsincluding birds, dancing figures, pictorial stories from
Puranas
3. Portraits
6. Shikhara
7. .Vs Pallavas
walls.
Chola temple pillars were constructed with greater
refinement than Pallavas.
8. Nataraja
9. Mandap
10. Gopuram
11. TrendSetters
~110 words.
Analysis/Rambling/Commentary/Observations:
before reading further, make sure youve read above culture question-answers
first, and also tried solving them at home from whatever books/material youve
at home.
=Total Marks
60
60
60
60
In 2012s General Studies Mains paper, some of the Questions were even
asked for 1 mark each! E.g PV Sindhu, Mario Miranda.
So, it was natural for the players to expect that lot of questions will be of
1m, 2m, 5m each.
Even in IFoS-2013 Mains exam, UPSC had asked all questions in 6-8
marks range. so the expectation even more bolstered.
Hence the study approach of most candidates= focused on gathering
maximum number of terms with 20-50 words for each. Especially for
culture, sci-tech, even for world-history to some extent.
UPSC did follow that expected line: questions were indeed small, only in
terms of marks (5 marks and 10 marks each) but not in terms of length
(100 words and 200 words each).
PREVIOUSLY
1. on Sangam
literature giving
picture of South
Indias society and
Economy
2. Chola temples
3. Tandav Dance
Two out three topics were not new, the only challenge was to bring 200
and 100 words worth content respectively- especially for students
without history optional.
For both questions- sufficient matter available in standard reference
books, as we saw while solving the answers.
But then a player wouldnt have prepared such topics in that detailbecause the previous trend of UPSC forced him to do Gadhaa majoori of
mugging up 50 dozen folk dances, painters, authors etc. for 20-30 words
each with hope that lot of 2 markers will be asked.
The GS1 paper started with culture question- hence most players would
have panicked and it indirectly affected their performance even in
remaining questions from history-post-independence India and
geography where they did have sufficient answer points inside their head.
Besides, even if the answer is verbatim given in a standard reference
book- hiding in the plain sight, doesnt mean the aspirant can recall all the
points during the actual exam. The stress, anxiety and fatigue doesnt let
the mind perform @100% efficiency.
Even if he can recall entire content, still it is humanly impossible to finish
25 questions in 5000 words with high quality points within three hours.
Thus, once again, the innocent bystanders are massacred while UPSC deploys
BackbreakingTM move against coaching classes, rot learners (and senior
players*).
THEORY
#1
THEORY
#2
In CSAT, CAPF and CDS 2013 exams, UPSC has shown its
prem for Buddism and Jainism MCQs. Prior to that, two
markers related to folk dances and festivals.
So Coaching walla (and senior players*) would have
assumed that similar Buddism-Jainism-cave-folk-festival
type stuff will come in Mains.
Therefore, asking about South Indian culture was the most
logical step according to UPSCs BackbreakingTM rulebook
for Mains-2013.
And hence, the most logical thing to do for Mains-2014=
ignore south Indian culture!
*it is a widely believed conspiracy theory that UPSC chairman prefers first
timers over senior players. All this so called exam
reform/gimmicks/tomfoolery is meant to prevent any senior player from
gaining advantage by his repeated experience.
And as usual, my sympathies and respect goes for these hard working senior
players for theyre the victims of circumstances- everyone wants to crack
exam in first trial, but Cinderella story doesnt happen with everyone- so what
can they do? Try again and again until age, attempt, money or willpower runs
out.
Back to the culture topic:
(new) NCERT
NIOS
comment
Quite good for geography and
science theory based MCQs.
But their history textbooks have
dumbed down entire India history
to secular case studies to prevent
any new PILs and controversies.
As a result, New NCERT are not
helping much in this
history/culture related
MCQs/Descriptive. Even Buddism,
Jainism related basic GK-MCQs is
not covered properly.
Had UPSC asked same questions in
2m/20 words, then NIOS alone would
have sufficed. But unfortunately, it did
not.
Almost useless
for history.
Cursory reading.
Tamil Nadu
Textbooks
(TNT)
ICSE textbook
Useful
Old NCERT
GS Manual
Spectrums
Culture book
Useful
Not much
useful.
AL Basham
Cost: benefit is
bad.
Krishna Reddy
websites
coaching/postal
material
Random surfing,
Net Ph.D
=useless.
Even Xeroxing
them is a waste
money and
paper.
So ^these are some of the books / sources for Indian culture. Design your own
studyplan/ kung-fu style according to your requirements for Culture section in
Mains 2014.
The focus should be on memorizing points that can help you assemble a 100150 words content in the exam.
(-)
So, Now its the time to move on- prepare for the interviews, prepare your
location-graduation related questions, prepare opinion based current
affairs, prepare your hobbies and so on.
And simultaneously, do work on whatever career backup/Post
graduation/other competitive exams you have.