You are on page 1of 75

Reservoir Geomechanics

In situ stress and rock mechanics applied to reservoir processes!


"
"
"
Mark D. Zoback
"
Professor of Geophysics
"
"
"

Week 1 Lecture 1
Course Overview

Why is Geomechanics Important?


Drilling and Reservoir Engineering
Compaction, Compaction Drive, Subsidence, ProductionInduced Faulting Prediction
Optimizing Drainage of Fractured Reservoirs
Hydraulic Propagation in Vertical & Deviated Wells
Wellbore Stability During Drilling (mud weights, drilling
directions)
Completion Engineering (long-term wellbore stability, sand
production prediction)
Well Placement (Azimuth and Deviation, Sidetracks)
Underbalanced Drilling to Formation Damage

Why is Geomechanics Important?


Reservoir Geology and Geophysics
Optimizing Drainage of Fractured Reservoirs
Pore Pressure Prediction
Understanding Shear Velocity Anisotropy
Fault Seal Integrity
Hydrocarbon Migration
Reservoir Compartmentalization

Why is Geomechanics Important?


Exploitation of Shale Gas/Tight Gas/Tight Oil
Properties of Ultra-Low Permeability Formations
How Formation Properties Affect Production
Optimizing Well Placement
Multi-Stage Hydraulic Fracturing
Importance of Fractures and Faults on Well Productivity
Interpretation of Microseismic Data
Simulating Production from Ultra-Low Permeability
Formations

Text for Class

Part I Basic Principles


Chapters 1-5
Part II Measuring Stress
Orientation and Magnitude
Chapters 6-9
Part III Applications
Chapters 10-12

Course Syllabus Part I - Basic Principles


Week 1
Lecture 1 Introduction and Course Overview
Lecture 2 Ch. 1 - The Tectonic Stress Field
HW-1 Calculating SV from density logs
Week 2
Lecture 3 - Ch. 2 - Pore Pressure at Depth
HW-2 Estimating pore pressure from porosity logs
Lecture 4 - Ch. 3 - Basic Constitutive Laws
Week 3
Lecture 5 - Ch. 4 - Rock Strength
HW-3 Estimating rock strength from geophysical logs
Lecture 6 - Ch. 4 - Fault Friction and Crustal Strength
HW 4 Calculating limits on crustal stress
Week 4
Lecture 7 - Ch. 5 - Faults and Fractures
HW 5 Analysis of fractures in image logs
6

Course Syllabus Part II In Situ Stress


Week 4
Lecture 8 - Ch. 6 - Stress Concentrations Around Vertical Wells
Week 5
Lecture 9 - Ch. 7 - Hydraulic Fracturing, Measuring Shmin, Limiting Frac
Height and Constraining Shmax
HW 6 Analysis of stress induced wellbore failures
Lecture 10 - Ch. 8 - Failure of Deviated Wells
Week 6
Lecture 11 - Ch. 9 - State of Stress in Sedimentary Basins
HW 7 Identification of critically-stressed faults

Course Syllabus Part III - Applications


Week 6
Lecture 12 - Ch. 10 - Wellbore Stability -1
Week 7
Lecture 13 - Ch. 10 - Wellbore Stability 2
Lecture 14 - Ch. 11 - Critically-Stressed Faults and Flow
HW 8 Development of a geomechanical model
Week 8
Lecture 15 - Ch. 11 - Fault Seal and Dynamic Hydrocarbon Migration
Lecture 16 - Ch. 12 - Effects of Depletion, Reservoir Stress Paths
Week 9
Lecture 17 - Ch. 12 - Compaction of Weak Sands and Shales and Subsidence

Course Syllabus Additional Topics


Week 9
Lecture 18 Geomechanics and Shale Gas/Tight Oil Production - 1
Week 10
Lecture 19 Geomechanics and Shale Gas/Tight Oil Production - 2
Lecture 20 - Geomechanics and Triggered Seismicity

Geomechanics Through the Life of a Field

P
r
o
d
u
c
t
i
o
n

Exploration

Appraisal

Development

Harvest

Abandonment

Wellbore Stability
Pore Pressure Prediction
Fault Seal/Fracture Permeability
Sand Production Prediction
Compaction
Casing Shear
Subsidence
Coupled Reservoir Simulation
Fracture Stimulation/ Refrac
Depletion

Geomechanical Model
Time

Components of a Geomechanical Model


Principal Stresses at Depth
Sv Overburden
SHmax Maximum horizontal
principal stress
Shmin Minimum horizontal
principal stress

Sv

Additional Components of a
Geomechanical Model
UCS
Pp

Shmin

SHmax

Pp Pore Pressure
UCS Rock Strength (from logs)
Fractures and Faults (from Image
Logs, Seismic, etc.)
11

Course Syllabus Part I - Basic Principles


Week 1
Lecture 1 Introduction and Course Overview
Lecture 2 Ch. 1 - The Tectonic Stress Field
HW-1 Calculating SV from density logs
Week 2
Lecture 3 - Ch. 2 - Pore Pressure at Depth
HW-2 Estimating pore pressure from porosity logs
Lecture 4 - Ch. 3 - Basic Constitutive Laws
Week 3
Lecture 5 - Ch. 4 - Rock Strength
HW-3 Estimating rock strength from geophysical logs
Lecture 6 - Ch. 4 - Fault Friction and Crustal Strength
HW 4 Calculating limits on crustal stress
Week 4
Lecture 7 - Ch. 5 - Faults and Fractures
HW 5 Analysis of fractures in image logs
12

Anderson Classification of Relative Stress Magnitudes


Sv

Normal

Shmin
SHmax
a.

Strike-Slip

Sv > SHmax > Shmin


Sv

SHmax
Shmin
SHmax > Sv > Shmin
Sv
Reverse

b.

SHmax
Shmin
c.

SHmax > Shmin > Sv

Tectonic regimes are


defined in terms of the
relationship between
the vertical stress (Sv)
and two mutually
perpendicular
horizontal stresses
(SHmax and Shmin)

Range of Stress Magnitudes at Depth


Hydrostatic Pp

Figure 1.4 a,b,c pg.13

Course Syllabus Part I - Basic Principles


Week 1
Lecture 1 Introduction and Course Overview
Lecture 2 Ch. 1 - The Tectonic Stress Field
HW-1 Calculating SV from density logs
Week 2
Lecture 3 - Ch. 2 - Pore Pressure at Depth
HW-2 Estimating pore pressure from porosity logs
Lecture 4 - Ch. 3 - Basic Constitutive Laws
Week 3
Lecture 5 - Ch. 4 - Rock Strength
HW-3 Estimating rock strength from geophysical logs
Lecture 6 - Ch. 4 - Fault Friction and Crustal Strength
HW 4 Calculating limits on crustal stress
Week 4
Lecture 7 - Ch. 5 - Faults and Fractures
HW 5 Analysis of fractures in image logs
16

Variations in Pore Pressure Within Compartments,


Each With ~Hydrostatic Gradients

Figure 2.4 pg.32

Range of Stress Magnitudes at Depth


Overpressure at Depth

Figure 1.4 d,e,f pg.13

Course Syllabus Part I - Basic Principles


Week 1
Lecture 1 Introduction and Course Overview
Lecture 2 Ch. 1 - The Tectonic Stress Field
HW-1 Calculating SV from density logs
Week 2
Lecture 3 - Ch. 2 - Pore Pressure at Depth
HW-2 Estimating pore pressure from porosity logs
Lecture 4 - Ch. 3 - Basic Constitutive Laws
Week 3
Lecture 5 - Ch. 4 - Rock Strength
HW-3 Estimating rock strength from geophysical logs
Lecture 6 - Ch. 4 - Fault Friction and Crustal Strength
HW 4 Calculating limits on crustal stress
Week 4
Lecture 7 - Ch. 5 - Faults and Fractures
HW 5 Analysis of fractures in image logs
19

Stress (MPa)

Laboratory Testing

Figure 3.2 pg.58

Constitutive Laws

Figure 3.1 a,b pg.57

Constitutive Laws

Figure 3.1 c,d pg.57

Course Syllabus Part I - Basic Principles


Week 1
Lecture 1 Introduction and Course Overview
Lecture 2 Ch. 1 - The Tectonic Stress Field
HW-1 Calculating SV from density logs
Week 2
Lecture 3 - Ch. 2 - Pore Pressure at Depth
HW-2 Estimating pore pressure from porosity logs
Lecture 4 - Ch. 3 - Basic Constitutive Laws
Week 3
Lecture 5 - Ch. 4 - Rock Strength
HW-3 Estimating rock strength from geophysical logs
Lecture 6 - Ch. 4 - Fault Friction and Crustal Strength
HW 4 Calculating limits on crustal stress
Week 4
Lecture 7 - Ch. 5 - Faults and Fractures
HW 5 Analysis of fractures in image logs
23

Module 1
Compressive Strength
Strength Criterion
Strength Anisotropy
Module 2
Shear Enhanced Compaction
Strength from Logs, HW 3
Module 3
Tensile Strength
Hydraulic Fracture Propagation
Vertical Growth of Hydraulic
Fractures

Course Syllabus Part I - Basic Principles


Week 1
Lecture 1 Introduction and Course Overview
Lecture 2 Ch. 1 - The Tectonic Stress Field
HW-1 Calculating SV from density logs
Week 2
Lecture 3 - Ch. 2 - Pore Pressure at Depth
HW-2 Estimating pore pressure from porosity logs
Lecture 4 - Ch. 3 - Basic Constitutive Laws
Week 3
Lecture 5 - Ch. 4 - Rock Strength
HW-3 Estimating rock strength from geophysical logs
Lecture 6 - Ch. 4 - Fault Friction and Crustal Strength
HW 4 Calculating limits on crustal stress
Week 4
Lecture 7 - Ch. 5 - Faults and Fractures
HW 5 Analysis of fractures in image logs
25

Limits on Stress Magnitudes


Hydrostatic P
p

Critical S
Hmax

Critical S
hmin
Critical S
Hmax

S v Pp
= 3.1
Sh min Pp
Sh min =
Sh min

S v Pp

3.1
0.6S v

SHmax Pp

+ Pp

Sh min Pp

= 3.1

SHmax = 3.1 Sh min Pp + Pp

SHmax Pp
= 3.1
S v Pp

SHmax = 3.1 S v Pp + Pp

Course Syllabus Part I - Basic Principles


Week 1
Lecture 1 Introduction and Course Overview
Lecture 2 Ch. 1 - The Tectonic Stress Field
HW-1 Calculating SV from density logs
Week 2
Lecture 3 - Ch. 2 - Pore Pressure at Depth
HW-2 Estimating pore pressure from porosity logs
Lecture 4 - Ch. 3 - Basic Constitutive Laws
Week 3
Lecture 5 - Ch. 4 - Rock Strength
HW-3 Estimating rock strength from geophysical logs
Lecture 6 - Ch. 4 - Fault Friction and Crustal Strength
HW 4 Calculating limits on crustal stress
Week 4
Lecture 7 - Ch. 5 - Faults and Fractures
HW 5 Analysis of fractures in image logs
27

Stress Regimes and Active Fault Systems

Sv

Normal

SHmax

Shmin

Shmin

shmin

SHmax
a.

Strike-Slip

Sv > SHmax > Shmin


Sv

Normal

sv

SHmax

Shmin

SHmax
Shmin
Strike-slip

SHmax > Sv > Shmin


Sv
Reverse

b.

SHmax

Shmin

sHmax

SHmax
Shmin
c.

SHmax > Shmin > Sv

Reverse
Map View

sv
Cross-section

Stereonet

Course Syllabus Part II In Situ Stress


Week 4
Lecture 8 - Ch. 6 - Stress Concentrations Around Vertical Wells
Week 5
Lecture 9 - Ch. 7 - Hydraulic Fracturing, Measuring Shmin, Limiting Frac
Height and Constraining Shmax
HW 6 Analysis of stress induced wellbore failures
Lecture 10 - Ch. 8 - Failure of Deviated Wells
Week 6
Lecture 11 - Ch. 9 - State of Stress in Sedimentary Basins
HW 7 Identification of critically-stressed faults

29

Stress Concentration Around a Vertical Well

Compressional and Tensile Wellbore Failure

Well A

UBI Well A

FMI Well B

Course Syllabus Part II In Situ Stress


Week 4
Lecture 8 - Ch. 6 - Stress Concentrations Around Vertical Wells
Week 5
Lecture 9 - Ch. 7 - Hydraulic Fracturing, Measuring Shmin, Limiting Frac
Height and Constraining Shmax
HW 6 Analysis of stress induced wellbore failures
Lecture 10 - Ch. 8 - Failure of Deviated Wells
Week 6
Lecture 11 - Ch. 9 - State of Stress in Sedimentary Basins
HW 7 Identification of critically-stressed faults

32

Drilling Induced Tensile Wall Fractures

FMI

FMS

Visund Field Orientations

Regional Stress Field in the Timor Sea

Complex Stress Field in the Elk Hills Field

Horizontal Principal Stress Measurement Methods


Stress Orientation
Stress-induced wellbore breakouts (Ch. 6)
Stress-induced tensile wall fractures (Ch. 6)
Hydraulic fracture orientations (Ch. 6)
Earthquake focal plane mechanisms (Ch. 5)
Shear velocity anisotropy (Ch. 8)
Relative Stress Magnitude
Earthquake focal plane mechanisms (Ch. 5)
Absolute Stress Magnitude
Hydraulic fracturing/Leak-off tests (Ch. 7)
Modeling stress-induced wellbore breakouts (Ch. 7, 8)
Modeling stress-induced tensile wall fractures (Ch. 7, 8)
Modeling breakout rotations due to slip on faults (Ch. 7)

Horizontal Principal Stress Measurement Methods


Stress Orientation
Stress-induced wellbore breakouts (Ch. 6)
Stress-induced tensile wall fractures (Ch. 6)
Hydraulic fracture orientations (Ch. 6)
Earthquake focal plane mechanisms (Ch. 5)
Whyvelocity
do we
use these
Shear
anisotropy
(Ch. techniques?
8)

1. Model is developed using data from


Relativeformations
Stress Magnitude
of interest
Earthquake focal plane mechanisms (Ch. 5)
1. Every well that is drilled tests the model
Absolute2.
Stress
Magnitude
They
work!
Hydraulic fracturing/Leak-off tests (Ch. 7)
Modeling stress-induced wellbore breakouts (Ch. 7, 8)
Modeling stress-induced tensile wall fractures (Ch. 7, 8)
Modeling breakout rotations due to slip on faults (Ch. 7)

Obtaining a Comprehensive Geomechanical Model


Parameter

Data
z0

Vertical stress
Least principal
stress
Max. Horizontal
Stress

Sv (z0 ) = r g dz
0

Shmin ! LOT, XLOT, minifrac


SHmax magnitude ! modeling
wellbore failures

Stress
Orientation

Orientation of Wellbore failures

Pore pressure

Pp ! Measure, sonic, seismic

Rock Strength

Lab, Logs, Modeling well failure

Faults/Bedding
Planes

Wellbore Imaging

Course Syllabus Part II In Situ Stress


Week 4
Lecture 8 - Ch. 6 - Stress Concentrations Around Vertical Wells
Week 5
Lecture 9 - Ch. 7 - Hydraulic Fracturing, Measuring Shmin, Limiting Frac
Height and Constraining Shmax
HW 6 Analysis of stress induced wellbore failures
Lecture 10 - Ch. 8 - Failure of Deviated Wells
Week 6
Lecture 11 - Ch. 9 - State of Stress in Sedimentary Basins
HW 7 Identification of critically-stressed faults

40

Wellbore Wall Stresses for Arbitrary Trajectories

Course Syllabus Part II In Situ Stress


Week 4
Lecture 8 - Ch. 6 - Stress Concentrations Around Vertical Wells
Week 5
Lecture 9 - Ch. 7 - Hydraulic Fracturing, Measuring Shmin, Limiting Frac
Height and Constraining Shmax
HW 6 Analysis of stress induced wellbore failures
Lecture 10 - Ch. 8 - Failure of Deviated Wells
Week 6
Lecture 11 - Ch. 9 - State of Stress in Sedimentary Basins
HW 7 Identification of critically-stressed faults

42

Generalized World Stress Map


180

270

90

180

70

70

35

35

SHmax in
compressional
domain

-35

-35

SHmax and Shmin


in strike-slip
domain
Shmin in
extensional
domain

180

270

90

180
9-2

M.L. Zoback (1992) and subsequent papers

Course Syllabus Part III - Applications


Week 6
Lecture 12 - Ch. 10 - Wellbore Stability -1
Week 7
Lecture 13 - Ch. 10 - Wellbore Stability 2
Lecture 14 - Ch. 11 - Critically-Stressed Faults and Flow
HW 8 Development of a geomechanical model
Week 8
Lecture 15 - Ch. 11 - Fault Seal and Dynamic Hydrocarbon Migration
Lecture 16 - Ch. 12 - Effects of Depletion, Reservoir Stress Paths
Week 9
Lecture 17 - Ch. 12 - Compaction of Weak Sands and Shales and Subsidence

44

Exploration Success Targeting Critically-Stressed


Faults in Damage Zones

Hennings et al (2011)

Geomechanical Wellbore Characterization

Wellbores Intersecting Fault Damage Zones


j
d

j
a
k

h
a

Well

R2

Well Performance (bcf/d)

0.35

0.13

0.04

0.36

0.07

0.12

0.12

0.09

0.01

1.0

1.0

Well/Reservoir Contact Length, m

345

550

560

930

180

420

240

400

50

197

778

Critically-Stressed m=0.5

214

254

204

323

280

350

156

279

16

607

0.67

Critically-Stressed m=0.6

91

77

56

140

32

117

37

63

379

0.93

Critically-Stressed m=0.7

10

12

153

0.9

1.0

Well Performance, bcf/day


Maximum Open-Hole Flow

0.8

0.6
R2=0.93

0.4

0.2

g
b

e
i
0
0

c
100

200

300

Number of Critically-Stressed Faults

400

Course Syllabus Part III - Applications


Week 6
Lecture 12 - Ch. 10 - Wellbore Stability -1
Week 7
Lecture 13 - Ch. 10 - Wellbore Stability 2
Lecture 14 - Ch. 11 - Critically-Stressed Faults and Flow
HW 8 Development of a geomechanical model
Week 8
Lecture 15 - Ch. 11 - Fault Seal and Dynamic Hydrocarbon Migration
Lecture 16 - Ch. 12 - Effects of Depletion, Reservoir Stress Paths
Week 9
Lecture 17 - Ch. 12 - Compaction of Weak Sands and Shales and Subsidence

50

Depletion in Gulf of Mexico Field X

Depletion in Gulf of Mexico Field X

90
80
70
60

S3

Pp

Pp

40
30
20
10

Jan-04

Apr-01

Jul-98

Oct-95

Jan-93

May-90

Aug-87

Nov-84

0
Feb-82

Pp (psi)

S3

50

Compaction Drive
Elliptical reservoir at 16300 ft
depth with single well at centre
Reservoir dimensions 6300 x
3150 x 70 ft, grid 50 x 50 x 1
Average permeability 350
md, !init 30%
Oil flow, little/no water influx, no
injection
IP 10 MSTB/d, min. BHP 1000 psi, Econ. Limit 100
STB/d
Ran for maximum time of 8000
days

Compaction Drive
Simulation Result - Recovery

30

Compaction drive

Cum. Oil, MMSTB

25

20
Compaction drive with
permeability change

15

10

5
Elastic strain only
(Constant compressibility)

0
0

2000

4000

6000

days

8000

10000

National Geographic, October 2004

Oil and gas fields are pervasive


through the region of high rates
of land loss.

Land Loss 1932-2050


Land Gain 1932-2050

Geertsma Model
For a circular reservoir, surface displacements are:

u (r ,0) = 2C (1 )pHR e D J (R )J (r )d
m
1
0
0
z

ur (r ,0) = 2Cm (1 )pHR e D J1 (R )J1 (r )d


0

Assuming R>>H, total


reduction in reservoir
height:
H

H = Cm (z )p(z )dz
0

Study Area: LaFourche Parish

Leeville Subsidence

Course Syllabus Additional Topics


Week 9
Lecture 18 Geomechanics and Shale Gas/Tight Oil Production - 1
Week 10
Lecture 19 Geomechanics and Shale Gas/Tight Oil Production - 2
Lecture 20 - Geomechanics and Triggered Seismicity

62

Current Shale Gas/Tight Oil Research Projects

Eagle Ford Shale Pore Structure


Shale Permeability is a Million Times
Smaller Than Conventional Reservoir

50mm
10 mm

64

500 nm

Multi-Stage Hydraulic Fracturing


S

Hmax

Dan Moos et al.


SPE 145849

Horizontal Drilling and Multi-Stage


Slick-Water Hydraulic Fracturing
Induces Microearthquakes (M ~ -1 to M~ -3)
To Create a Permeable Fracture Network

We Need to Dramatically Improve Recovery Factors

Dry Gas ~25%


Petroleum Liquids ~ 5%

Course Syllabus Additional Topics


Week 9
Lecture 18 Geomechanics and Shale Gas/Tight Oil Production - 1
Week 10
Lecture 19 Geomechanics and Shale Gas/Tight Oil Production - 2
Lecture 20 - Geomechanics and Triggered Seismicity

67

Recent Publications
Physical properties of shale reservoir rocks
Sone, H and Zoback, M.D. (2013), Mechanical properties of shale-gas reservoir
rocksPart 1: Static and dynamic elastic properties and anisotropy, Geophysics,
v. 78, no. 5, D381-D392, 10.1190/GEO2013-0050.1
Sone, H and Zoback, M.D. (2013), Mechanical properties of shale-gas reservoir
rocksPart 2: Ductile creep, brittle strength, and their relation to the elastic
modulus, Geophysics, v. 78, no. 5, D393-D402, 10.1190/GEO2013-0051.1

Why slow slip occurs


Kohli, A. H. and M.D. Zoback (2013), Frictional properties of shale reservoir
rocks, Journal of Geophysical Research, Solid Earth, v. 118, 1-17, doi: 10.1002/
jgrb. 50346
Zoback, M.D., A. Kohli, I. Das and M. McClure, The importance of slow slip on
faults during hydraulic fracturing of a shale gas reservoirs, SPE 155476, SPE
Americas Unconventional Resources Conference held in Pittsburgh, PA, USA 5-7
June, 2012

Recent Publications
Fluid transport/adsorption in nanoscale pores
Heller, R., J. Vermylen and M.D. Zoback (2013), Experimental Investigation of
Matrix Permeability of Gas Shales, AAPG Bull., in press.
Heller, R. and Zoback, M.D. (2013), Adsorption of Methane and Carbon Dioxide
on Gas Shale and Pure Mineral Samples, The Jour. of Unconventional Oil and
Gas Res., in review.
Viscoplasticity in clay-rich reservoirs
Sone, H. and M.D. Zoback (2013), Viscoplastic Deformation of Shale Gas
Reservoir
Rocks and Its Long-Term Effects on the In-Situ State of Stress, Intl. Jour. Rock
Mech.,
in review.
Sone, H and M.D. Zoback (2013), Viscous Relaxation Model for Predicting Least
Principal Stress Magnitudes in Sedimentary Rocks, Jour. Petrol. Sci. Eng., in
review.

Recent Publications
.

Discrete Fracture Network Modeling in Unconventional Reservoirs


Johri, M. and M.D. Zoback, M.D. (2013), The Evolution of Stimulated Reservoir
Volume During Hydraulic Stimulation of Shale Gas Formations, URTec 1575434,
Unconventional Resources Technology Conference in Denver, CO, U.S.A., 12-14
August 2013
Case Studies
Yang, Y. and Zoback, M.D., The Role of Preexisting Fractures and Faults During
Multi-Stage Hydraulic Fracturing in the Bakken Formation, Interpretation, in press

Course Syllabus Additional Topics


Week 9
Lecture 18 Geomechanics and Shale Gas/Tight Oil Production - 1
Week 10
Lecture 19 Geomechanics and Shale Gas/Tight Oil Production - 2
Lecture 20 - Geomechanics and Triggered Seismicity

71

An Increase in Intraplate Seismicity

Prague, OK
3 M5+ Eqs
Prague,
Nov., 2011

OK*
Nov. 2011 M 5.7

Zoback (2012)
Ellsworth (2013)
About 150,000 Class II EPA Injection Wells Operating in the US
Why the Increase in Seismicity?

Managing Triggered
Seismicity

EARTH April, 2012

Earthquakes Spreading Out Along an Active Fault

Hurd and Zoback (2012)

Horton (2012)

Seismicity Triggered by Injection

Guy Arkansas
Earthquake Swarm

- Avoid Injection into Potentially Active Faults


- Limit Injection Rates (Pressure) Increases
- Monitor Seismicity (As Appropriate)
- Assess Risk
- Be Prepared to Abandon Some Injection Wells

You might also like