Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Prof. M. Hassanein
Finc 4301
Prof. M. Hassanein
Project M Project N
$28,500
$27,000
Initial Investment
Year
1
2
3
4
CF(M)
10,000
10,000
10,000
10,000
CF(N)
11,000
10,000
9,000
8,000
Finc 4301
Prof. M. Hassanein
Project N
CF 1 +
(1+WACC)
NPV = - I +
CF n
n=1
(1+WACC)n
CF2
(1+WACC)2
+.
CFn
(1+WACC)n
Finc 4301
Prof. M. Hassanein
7,690
6,075
4,736
$ 28,148
Finc 4301
Prof. M. Hassanein
IRRN = 16%
DCF
10,000 (.877) = 8,770
10,000 (.769) = 7,690
10,000 (.675) = 6,750
10,000 (.592) = 5,920
ACC.DCF
8,770
16,460
23,210
29,130
DCF
ACC.DCF
1
2
3
4
9,647
7,690
6,075
4,736
9,647
17,337
23,412
28,148
Finc 4301
Prof. M. Hassanein
M:
PI = 640 / 28,500
= 0.0224
= 2.24 %
Project
N:
PI = 1,148 / 27,000
= 0.0425
= 4.25 %
Decision rule: The higher the PI, the better is the project.
It means that a highest PI offers the highest NPV per dollar of initial investment.
Therefore, select project N, since PIN > PIM.
Capital Rationing:
Choosing capital investments when financial resources are limited.
The selection criteria is the Profitability Index
Example:
Suppose that a firm is limited to spending $10 million on investment projects. The firm has
three projects and it needs a method of selecting the package of projects that is within its
resources, yet gives the highest net present value.
The three projects are as follows:
Project
Initial investment
A
-10
B
-5
C
-5
Calculate PI for each project
Cash Flows
C1
C2
30
5
5
($ millions)
NPV at 10%
5
20
15
21
16
12
Project
Initial Investment
PI
Rank by PI
A
B
C
$ 10
5
5
2.1
3.2
2.4
Third
First
Second
Finc 4301
Prof. M. Hassanein
Cash flow
$ 11,000
Fv of cash flow at 16 %
11,000 (FVIF) 3, .16 = 11,000 (1.561) = 17,171
10,000
9,000
8,000
= 8,000
Finc 4301
Prof. M. Hassanein
Find the IRR under the second assumption i.e.: the firm does not have investment opportunities
to reinvest the generated cash flow at the IRR = 16 %, rather it can reinvest this cash flow at
the WACC, which is its opportunity cost i.e.: 14 %
Step one:
Repeat the same step one as before, but the rate at which the generated cash flow will be
compounded is the WACC = 14 %
Years
Cash flow
$ 11,000
10,000
9,000
8,000
= 8,000
Finc 4301
Prof. M. Hassanein
Example:
MIRR for project M.
(FVA) 4, .14 = 10000 (FVIFA) 4, .14
= 10,000(4.921)
= $49,210
28,500 = 49,210 (PVIF)4,?
By the financial calculator: MIRR= 14.63% and not IRR= 15.1%
Decision rule: Select the project with the highest Modified IRR.
Therefore select project N since MIRRN = 15 % which is greater than
MIRRM = 14.63 %
Preposition two: (The Multiple IRR Paradox)
If the expected cash flows of a project double the change of the negative sign then it is more
than likely that the solution for IRR will result in multiple of IRRs.
Example: Suppose that the cash flow of a Mining Project is as follows:
NCF ($)
0
-1,000
1
800
2
150
3
150
4
150
5
150
6
-150
= 765.8
Finc 4301
Prof. M. Hassanein
= $ 2,054.6
OR
FV of cash flow at 10%
2054.6
- 150.0
1904.6
PV = 1000
1000 = 1904.6 (PVIF) 6,?
MIRR= 11.34%
10