Professional Documents
Culture Documents
IntroductiontothePropagatingWaveonaSingleConductor
GlennElmore
CorridorSystemsInc.
www.corridor.biz
Abstract
AnoverlookedsolutiontotheMaxwellHeavisideequationssupportstheexistenceofa
propagatingTMsurfacewaveoncoaxialcableaswellasonacompletelyunshielded
singleconductor.Thisnonradiatingsurfacewavemodeexhibitsattenuationmuchlower
thancoaxandarelativepropagationvelocityofunity.Itisverybroadbandandhas
practicalapplicationsfromRFthroughmicrowavefrequenciesandbeyond.Thisarticle
introducesthismode,measurementsanddescribesapplications.Inparticular,this
articledescribestheuseofthenewmodewithconventionaloverheadpowerlinesasa3rd
pipeandsolutiontothelastmileproblem.
Background&History
ConventionalModelofCoaxialLine
CoaxialcableisperhapsthemostcommonlyusedtransmissionlinetypeforRF&
microwavemeasurementsandapplications.In1894Heaviside,Teslaandothersreceived
patentsforcoaxiallineandrelatedstructures.Adevelopmentofcoax(coaxialline)theory
1
isoftenprovidedaspartofbasicphysicsandengineeringeducation ,evenpriortofull
developmentanduseoftheMaxwellHeavisideequations,whicharegenerallyusedfor
transmissionlineandmacroscopicelectromagneticanalysis.Accordingly,theanalysis,
measurementandapplicationofcoaxisusuallyconsideredtobequitematureand
complete.
07/27/09
IntroductiontothePropagatingWaveonaSingleConductor
Perfect
Conductor
b
a
Vacuum
dielectric
Illustration1:Coaxialtransmissionlineusedto
deliversourcepowertoaload.
IntroductorydescriptionsofcoaxoftenproceedalongthelinesofIllustration1.Here
losslesscylindricalcentralandoutershieldingconductorsareseparatedbyavolumeof
emptyspace.Thisstructureisexaminedasameansforconveyingpowerbetweentwo
points.Oneendisconsideredaninputportanddrivenwithasinusoidalvoltagesource
(1)
V s= Asin t
ofmagnitude A atfrequency .
Thissourceisappliedtothelinethroughaknownimpedance, Z S .Theotherendofthe
lineisterminatedbyaloadofimpedance Z L .
Illustration2:Schematicmodelofatransmission
linefromtheTelegraphers'Equation
07/27/09
IntroductiontothePropagatingWaveonaSingleConductor
Heaviside'stelegraphers'equationprovidesalumpedcircuitequivalentofan
infinitesimallengthoftransmissionline,showninIllustration2.Forthelosslesscase
where R=G=0 Ampere'slawcanbeusedtofindtheinductanceperunitlength
b
ln
2
a
andGauss'slawtofindthecapacitanceperunitlength
Ll =
q
2
=
Vl
b
ln
a
2
thisdescribesalinewithanentirelyrealcharacteristicimpedance of
Cl =
Z=
Ll
ohms
Cl
(2)
(3)
(4)
b
whichisdependentonlyonthegeometryoftheconductors .
a
Maximumtransferofpowerbetweensourceandloadoccurswhenalloftheseimpedances
areequaland
(5)
Z =Z S =Z L
Currententeringthelinecentralconductorproducesarealcurrentdensity, J .By
Ampre'scircuitallaw,thiscurrentdensityproducesanorthogonalmagneticfluxdensity
B field(invectorform)
B= J
(6)
intheregionofemptyspaceinsidetheouterconductor.Anequalmagnitudebutopposite
sensecurrentdensity, J returningfromtheoutershieldalsocontributestomagnetic
fluxwithinthisregion.Beyondthisregionthemagneticeffectsexactlycancelandno
fieldsduetothecurrentsarepresent.Thiscancellationprovidestheshieldingnatureof
coax.
Betweentheconductorsthevarying B fieldproducesanelectricfield
E=
B
t
(7)
Electricfieldlinesextendbetweentheconductorsandarenormaltotheirsurfaces.These
electricandmagneticfieldsproduceatransverseelectricmagneticwavetravelingalong
thelineinthespacebetweenthetwoconductors.Inidealcoaxthiswavetravelsinthe
vacuumdielectricwithoutattenuationandwithvelocitythesameasthatoflightina
vacuum.
07/27/09
IntroductiontothePropagatingWaveonaSingleConductor
Wavespropagatingontransmissionlinescanbedescribedintermsoftheaxesofthe
electricandmagneticfieldsandamodenumber.Oneorbothoftheelectricandmagnetic
fieldsmustbetransversetothedirectionofpropagation.Thecorrespondingmodesare
TE,fortransverseelectricfield,TMfortransversemagneticfieldandTEMwhenboth
fieldtypesaretransverse.Apairofmodenumbers,nandm,canbeassociatedwiththese
whichrepresenttheorderofthemodeinthetransverseandlongitudinaldirections,
respectively.Valuesofzeroforeachofthesedescribeaprincipalmodeinthe
correspondingdirection.
Foracoaxlineofinfinitelengthandforwavelengthslargecomparedtotheinner
circumferenceoftheouterconductor
2 b
(8)
thereisradialsymmetryandthecoaxiallineexhibitsaprinciple TEM 00 propagation
mode.Theimpedancepresentedtothesourcebythelinecanbewrittenas,
ZT E M =
1
b
b
ln 60 ln
2
a
a
(9)
where
4 x 107 Henry/meter 1.2566 H/meter,permeabilityofavacuum
1
= 2 Farad/meter8.8542pFpermeter,permittivityofavacuum
c
Forthematchedconditiondescribedthevoltageproducedbythewaveataposition
separatedfromthesourcebydistance, l ,alongthelinecanbedescribedas
A
sin t el
2
where
(10)
V=
= j
(11)
whichforthelosslesscaseispurelyimaginaryandthesameasthatoftheenclosed
3
medium .
Practicalcablesrequiredielectricsupportsanduseimperfectconductorswhich
07/27/09
IntroductiontothePropagatingWaveonaSingleConductor
complicatethemodelbutmorethanacenturyofusehasvalidatedthisbasic
understandingofcoaxiallineanditsapplicationtothesolutionofrealworldproblems.
FormostapplicationsfromRFthroughuppermicrowaves,convenientlydimensioned
coaxialcablehasproventobeanexcellentdevicefortransferringelectromagneticenergy
betweendifferentlocationswithoutsignificantradiation;effectivelyshieldingthe
internalwavefromexternalcomponentsandcircuitry.
ThePropagatingTMWaveinCoax
Ahomogeneousplanewaveinanisotropicmediumhasanintrinsicimpedance
i
infreespacewhere
Z=
(12)
=0
thisreducesto
Z =c =
120 ohms
(13)
(14)
However,energymaynotpropagatefasterthanthespeedoflightinavacuum.
c=
1
Z
=
(15)
Justasforaplanarwaveinfreespace,energypropagatingthroughalosslesscoaxial
transmissionlinehavingvacuumdielectricandnomagneticmaterialsissubjecttothis
constraint.Theimpedanceassociatedwiththepropagatingenergyinatransmissionline
isboundedbythepermeabilityandpermittivityofspace.Energymaypropagate
simultaneouslybywayofahybridofmultiplemodesbutthecombinedimpedancesand
thecombinedadmittancesofthepropagatingmodesareboundedsuchthatforthetotal
propagatingwave
Z total =
1
Y total
07/27/09
(16)
IntroductiontothePropagatingWaveonaSingleConductor
Foralinewithdimensionmeeting(8),duetosymmetry,onlymodeswithatransverse
magneticcomponent,eitherTEMorTM,arepossiblesinceanyasymmetricmodesthat
5
wouldproducealongitudinalmagneticcomponentwillbeimmediatelydampedout .Only
TEM 0m or TM 0m modescanpropagate.Additionally,forperfectconductorsonlythe
6
principalmodesaresupported .Thereforeonly TEM 00 or TM 00 arepossible.Incoaxof
thistypethecombinedadmittancesofthesemustbeboundedsuchthat
Y TEM =
00
b
ln
a
ispositive,finiteandcontinuousovertherange
00
Z TEM
(17)
(18)
00
b
1
a
Soatleastforthecasewhere
(19)
b
ln 2
a
Apropagating TM 00 modemustalsoexistandprovideafiniteadmittance
Y TM
(20)
00
AllpropagatingmodesaresolutionstothewaveequationwhichresultsfromMaxwell's
equationsandsatisfytherequirementsforcontinuityoffieldsattheconductorvacuum
boundary.CombinationsofBesselfunctionsareusedtodescribethefieldsand
impedancesassociatedwiththesesolutions.Thesefunctionsandtheirfirstderivatives
havesingularitiesonlyatzeroandinfinityandarecontinuousinbetween.Therefore,the
fieldsandwavestheydescribealsoarewithoutdiscontinuitiesovertheintermediate
region.
Asaresult,contrarytolongstandingbelieftothecontrary,incoaxthereexist
simultaneouspropagating TEM 00 and TM 00 modesovertheentirerangeofgeometries
b
1
a
07/27/09
(21)
IntroductiontothePropagatingWaveonaSingleConductor
ThePropagatingTMWaveasaSurfaceWaveonaSingleConductor
TheTMwaveonasingleconductorembeddedinadielectricmedium,canbeviewedasa
surfacewavealongtheinnerconductorofacoaxlinehavinginfinitegeometry.Inthis
view,forfinite V s ,realcurrentdensityvanishes:
b
J r 0 as
a
(22)
HoweverfromtheMaxwellHeavisideequations,thetotalmagneticfieldisduetoboth
realcurrent J r involvingmovingchargesandtodisplacementcurrentduetothetime
E
rateofchangeoftheelectricfield
,
t
B= J r
D
E
= J r
t
t
(23)
Asthegeometryofcoaxincreaseswithoutbound,thecomponentofthemagneticfielddue
tothelongitudinalcomponentofthedisplacementcurrentincreasesatthesametime
thatthecomponentduetorealcurrentdecreases.
b
,Y TEM 0
a
and
Y total Y TM =
(24)
Inthelimit,theamountofrealcurrentintheouterconductorfallstozeroandthetotal
admittanceisdueentirelytodisplacementcurrentwhichproducesasingleprincipal
TM 00 modewiththesameimpedanceasawaveinfreespace.
Forintermediategeometries,thetotaladmittanceisduetocontributionsfromeach
mode.Theouterconductorprovidesapathforrealreturncurrentwhichincreasesthe
totaladmittance.Thisincreaseinadmittancereducesthepotentialonthelineand
causesanassociatedreductionoflongitudinaldisplacementcurrentandacorresponding
decreaseintheportionofthetotalpowerpropagatedviatheTMmode.
Thus,conventionalcoaxcablealwayspropagatespowerbyahybridofaprincipalTEM
modeandaprincipalTMmodeovertheentirerangeofcoaxgeometries.Bothofthese
07/27/09
IntroductiontothePropagatingWaveonaSingleConductor
modeshavethesamepropagationvelocitywhichisdeterminedbytherelative
permittivityoftheencloseddielectric.Forthecaseofperfectconductivityandvacuum
dielectricbothwavestravelwithoutattenuationatthespeedoflight.
History
Theexistence,practicalityandimpactofthesurfacewaveTMmodeseemstohavebeen
generallyoverlooked.Thisisperhapsnotsosurprisinginviewofthesmalleffectithason
propagationincoaxofconvenientgeometryandcommonimpedance,aspreviously
7
8
described.Sommerfeldinvestigatedsurfacewaves asdidZenneck ,particularlyinvolving
lossyconductorsaspartofbetterunderstandingbeyondthehorizonradiopropagation
duringtheearly1900's.Solutionsforthewavearoundaperfectlyconductingcenter
cylinderembeddedinadielectricwerepresentedbyStrattonin1941.Thereitwasfound
thatonlyasinglemodallowattenuationsolutiondescribinga TM 00 wavehavingthe
9
samepropagationconstantasthatoftheenclosingdielectricexists .Solutionsforcoax
werealsoinvestigatedbutonlythesingleprinciple TEM 00 modewasdescribedasbeing
10
consequentialforlinedimensionsthatarecommonincommunicationspractice .Inthe
coaxialsolutionsnlyasingleprinciple TEM 00 modewasconsidered.
Morerecentcharacterizationofprecisioncoaxiallinestandardsinslightlylossylinefor
useinvectornetworkanalysiswithareferenceimpedanceof50ohmsalsofoundthe
effectofthe TM 00 modetobesmall.However,incalculatingit'seffectonlineimpedance,
theHFieldandwaveadmittanceassociatedonlywiththeradialcomponentofthe
11
electricfieldwereincluded .Apparentlythiswasduetoanaprioriassumptionthatno
propagatingTMmode,oratleastnosignificantmode,existsincoaxandanylongitudinal
componentoftheEfieldwouldbeonlyevanescentorsosmallthatitcouldbeneglected.
Perhapsmostsurprisingisthatduringthe1950'stheinitialpracticalapplicationof
surfacewavetransmissioninvolvingonlyasingleconductorandapplicationsofthatsame
worksincehavenotuncoveredtheexistenceandusefulnessofthisTMmode.Theseminal
applicationofsurfacewavepropagationoverasingleconductorwaspresentedby
12
Goubau .Thisapplication,calledGLine,providedmethodstobuildapractical
transmissionsystembyusingspecialconductorsurfaceconditioningorasurrounding
dielectricmaterialalongwithspeciallauncherstoconvertfromcoaxorwaveguidemodes
toasurfacewavemodeontheline.InspiteofthepriorworkbySommerfeldand
13
Stratton,aspartofpatenting thissystemGoubaupositedthatareductionofthewave
velocityontheconductorwasrequired,bothtopreventradiationandtoallowalauncher
14
ofconvenientsize.Adaptationsofhiswork,includingrecentvariations ,havecontinued
alongthesesamelinesofthoughtandthisopinionseemstohavepersisteduntilthe
presentday.
07/27/09
IntroductiontothePropagatingWaveonaSingleConductor
ImplementationofPracticalSingleConductorLines
SingleConductorApplicationoftheTMWave
SincethisarticleisintendedasanintroductiontotheusefulnessoftheTMmoderather
thanasacompletesolutiontothegeneralcaseofhybridpropagationoftheTEMandTM
modeswithlossyconductorsandimperfectdielectricsincoax,itwillnowturntoward
providingsomeinsightintopracticalnoncoaxialapplicationoftheTMmodeinreal
worldsituations.
Asitisnecessarytocoupletoandfromthemodeinordertoaccessitandtakeadvantage
ofitinconjunctionwithothertraditionaltransmissionlinessuchascoaxandwaveguide,
developingavisualizationoftheassociatedelectricfieldatthispointseemsuseful.
Efielddirection
ThesolutiontothewaveequationforthepropagatingTMmodeproducesanonzero
longitudinalcomponentoftheEfield.ThisisincontrasttothesolutionfortheTEM
modeincoaxwhichproducesonlyatransverseEfield.
WhereastheTEMmodeisexcitedbyrealcurrent,theTMwaveisexcitedbythe
displacementcurrent.Thepotentialonthecentralconductorincreasesaslineimpedance
increases.Astheseincrease,themagnitudeoftheEfieldincreasesaswell.However,a
nearbyconductorotherthanthelineitselfmayprovideaterminationpointandthereby
reduceenergycoupledintotheTMwave.Thisisthecasewiththeshieldofconventional
coaxialcableofcommongeometry.TheproximityofashieldreducestheTEMimpedance,
providesareturnpathforEfieldlines,increasesrealcurrent,reducesdisplacement
currentandcorrespondinglyreducesthepowercoupledintotheTMwave.Theresultis
thatasthegeometryisreduced,propagationincoaxialcablerapidlybecomesdominated
bytheTEMmodetotheexclusionoftheTMmode.Whenthegeometryhasreached50
b
ohmsinidealcoax, 2.3 (Illustration1)theTMmodehasbeenalmostentirely
a
suppressed.Toexaminethemodeitisnecessarytoconsideracentralconductorapart
fromnearbyshieldingorconductorswhichcansuppressit.
07/27/09
IntroductiontothePropagatingWaveonaSingleConductor
Illustration3:Efielddirectionsinvicinityofaperfectconductorandaplanarlauncher
Illustration3showsaplotofelectricfieldgeneratedfromanumericsolutionofMaxwell's
equationsperformedbya3DEMsolver(HFSS).Themodelisofathin,perfectly
conductingcirculardisk,ontheleft,havingacentralholethroughwhichpassesa
perfectlyconductingwirethatextendscontinuouslyfromlefttoright.Theshortregion
insidethisholeisequivalenttoasectionofidealcoaxandexcitationofthisportis
configuredtobecoaxialatthislocation.Therestoftheregionintheillustrationis
vacuumwhereintheshortlinesindicatethedirectionoftheEfieldthatresultwhenthe
portisdrivenbyasinusoidalsignalthroughaportimpedanceequivalenttothatofthe
TEMmodeatthecoaxialinputattheplaneofthedisk.
ItisimportanttorecognizethatbecausetheTMmodehasnotpreviouslybeenknownto
existent,computeranalysistoolsmaymakeassumptionsabouttheconditionsattheport
ofamodel.Eventhoughintheanalysisitself,afullnumericalsolutionofMaxwell's
equationsmaybeperformed,theportexcitationforthemodeldoesnotnecessarily
includethis.Forthemodelandplotshownabove,theanalysiswasperformedwiththe
assumptionthatconditionstotheleftofthelauncherport,thatregioninsidethe
modeler,isaTEMextensionoftheport.NolongitudinalEfieldcomponentispresent
thereandassuchitonlymodelsexcitationfromaTEMsource.BecauseaTMwave
actuallydoesexistthiscausessomeerror.However,inthisexampletheportgeometry
hasbeenchosentoprovidearelativelylowimpedance,inthevicinityof50ohms,andthe
TMcontributiontothepropagatingwaveissosmallthattheerrorisnegligible.
Thissameproblemexistswithconventionalscalarandvectornetworkmeasurementand
analysisofcoaxialsystemsingeneral.Allcommercialsystemsofwhichtheauthoris
awarepresentlymaketheimplicitassumptionthatincoaxonlyaTEMwaveexists.For
fiftyohmsystemsthisassumptionhasbeen,andcontinuestobe,almostentirely
07/27/09
10
IntroductiontothePropagatingWaveonaSingleConductor
adequatewiththepossibleexceptionofcharacterizationofprecisioncoaxialcalibration
standardsforvectornetworkanalysis,aspreviouslycited.TheTMmodeissowell
suppressedthatforalmostallpracticalmeasurementsandapplicationstheerrorsdueto
thisassumptionareofnoconsequence.
Theconductiveplanardiskwiththecoaxialport,ontheleftinIllustration3,iscalleda
launcherandservestocoupleenergyfromthecoaxialstimulusintotheTMwave
propagatingalongthecentralconductor.
Fromtheplotitcanbeseenthatclosetotheexcitationport,theEfieldsextendfromthe
centralconductortothelauncherandarenormaltothesurfacesofeachconductor
immediatelyadjacenttotheconductor.Perfectconductivityforcestangentialcomponents
oftheelectricfieldtobezeroandonlyafieldcomponentatrightangletotheconductor
surfaceispossible.Inthisregionneartheport,realcurrentflowsintheplaneand
returnsbywayoftheouterconductoroftheinputcoaxport.Furthertotheright,away
fromthelauncher,closeexaminationoftheillustrationwillrevealthatEfieldlines
terminatealongtheconductor.Herealsotheyleavetheconductornormaltoit'ssurface
butcurveintheenclosing(vacuum)dielectricandreturnatadifferentlocationalongthe
sameconductor,uptoonehalfwavelengthaway.InthisregiontheresultingwaveisTM.
Inessence,thelauncherservesasatransitionbetweenthepredominantlyTEMmodein
thecoaxandthepredominantlyTMmodeontheconductorintheregionfarfromthe
launcher.
Thefieldsolutiontothewaveequationforcoaxshowsthatthepeakmagnitudeforthe
longitudinalEfieldisdisplacedfromthepeakmagnitudefortheradialfieldbyone
quarterwavelength.Thepeaklongitudinalfieldsoccuratthelocationsofvoltageminima
onthecentralconductor.ThephaseoftheexcitationinIllustration3hasplacedthe
voltagemaximumatorneartheinputport.Carefulexaminationofthefieldlineswill
showthatthefirstclearlydiscerniblemaximumofthelongitudinalEfieldsoccurs
slightlytotheleftofthecenterofthecentralconductorandapproximatelythreequarter
wavelengthsawayfromthemaximumoccurringneartheexcitationport.Thefirst
longitudinalmaximumoccursonequarterwavelengthfromtheportbutisdifficultto
discernbecauseoftheotherfieldlinesreturningtothelauncher.
07/27/09
11
IntroductiontothePropagatingWaveonaSingleConductor
Efieldmagnitude
Illustration4:ContoursofconstantEfieldmagnitude
AlthoughIllustration3givesinsightintoEfielddirection,itgivesalmostnoinformation
aboutEfieldamplitudeorevenrelativemagnitude.Tohelpprovidethis,contoursof
constantEfieldmagnitudeforadifferentmodeledtwoportsystemareshownin
Illustration4.TheselinesarecontoursofconstantmagnitudesoIllustrations3and4
mustbetakentogetherinordertovisualizethecompleteEFieldvectors,whichcontain
bothamplitudeanddirectioninformation.Thelaunchersinthisillustrationare100mm
squareratherthanroundandthecentralconductoris400mmlong,alsosquarebut
taperedfrom4mmateachendto.04mmatthecenter.Thestimulusfrequencyis1875
MHzwherethestructureis2.5wavelengthslong.
ItisnoteworthythattheradialextentoftheEfieldisdependentonlyonlineimpedance
andnotonconductordiameterorwavelength.Becausedisplacementcurrentisconstant,
conductordiameteraffectstheEfieldmagnitudeatthesurfaceoftheconductorbutnot
thecontouritfollowsinthesurroundingdielectricmedium.
ContrarytopreviousbeliefinregardtosurfacewavesonGLine,alauncherneednotbe
large.BecausemostoftheEfieldisquiteclosetotheconductor,bothintheTEMregion
andintheTMregion,themajorityoftheterminatingfieldlinesandcurrentalsooccur
quiteclosetotheconductorsurface.Thefieldsolutionsshowthatthemagnitudeofthe
1
radialcomponentfollowsa
curveandthatthemajorityofthepropagatedenergyis
r
withinafewconductordiametersofthecenteraxis.
LongitudinallytheEfieldisdependentonwavelengthsinceeachfieldlinemusthavea
terminationpoint,whichcanbeuptoonehalfwavelengthaway.Thereforetheconductor
mustbeatleastahalfwavelengthlonginordertosupporttheTMmode.
07/27/09
12
IntroductiontothePropagatingWaveonaSingleConductor
Thelineimpedanceinthevicinityofthelauncherislowerthanthatofthethelineinfree
space.Thisisbecausefieldlinesproducingrealcurrentinthecoaxial(TEM)regionare
presentalongwiththelinesterminatingontheconductorintheTMmode.
Illustration5:Timedomainmeasurementofimpedanceof680mmlengthofTMline
stretchedbetweentwo68mmdiameterplanarlaunchers.
Illustration5showsaVNAtimedomainmeasurementofasimplesystemconstructed
withapairofcircularbrassplanarlaunchers68mmindiameterandspaced680mm.
Theconductoriscylindrical,madeof.5mmdiameterbarecopperconductor(burnished
#24copperwire)andconnectedbetweenthecenterpinsofSMAconnectorseachmounted
atthecenterofoneofthelaunchers.TheleftYaxishaslabelsfortheequivalentline
impedance,ascalculatedfromtherealpartofthereflectioncoefficientplottedovera
rangefrom0to1whenthesystemreferenceimpedanceisfiftyohms.
Withinapproximatelythefirstcentimeterfromtheexcitationport,approximately20wire
diameters,theimpedancerisesveryrapidlyfromtheinitial50ohmvalueattheSMA
connector.Beyondthatitrisesmuchmoreslowlyandasymptoticallyapproachesthefree
spacevalueof377ohms.Thevalueofthereflectioncoefficientatthemarkercorresponds
toalineimpedanceofabout366ohms.Thediscontinuityat4.5nsisatthelocationofthe
secondSMAconnector.
PracticalLaunchers
Apracticallaunchershouldprovidethetransitionfrom TEM 00 to TM 00 wavesas
07/27/09
13
IntroductiontothePropagatingWaveonaSingleConductor
effectivelyaspossible.Generallythistransitionisbetweendifferentimpedancesaswell
asbetweendifferentmodes.
Anylauncherrepresentsadiscontinuitytothepropagatingwaves.Thisdiscontinuity
mayproduceradiationawayfromtheregion.IntheTMportionofasystemsuchasis
showninIllustrations4and5,thereiscompletesymmetryofEfield;everyfieldlineis
oneofapairoflinesofequalmagnitudebutoppositesign.Thissymmetryispresentboth
axiallyandlongitudinally.Thereforeatdistancesofmorethanafewwavelengths,these
fieldsaddtozeroandnonetfieldandnoradiationresults.However,fortheregionneara
launcher,thereisnolongerlongitudinalsymmetryandincompletecancellationoffields
mayresultatlargedistances.Thisproducesradiationawayfromthelauncherwiththe
radiatedwavelinearlypolarizedparalleltotheconductor.
Illustration6:MeasuredS21andGAmaxforthetwoportTMsystemofIllustration5
Illustration6showsafrequencydomainmeasurementofthesamesystemwithplanar
launchersthatwasmeasuredinIllustration5.Thelowertraceisof S 21 whichdisplays
therippleorbeatbetweenthediscontinuitiesproducedbythelaunchersateachendof
theline.Inadditiontotheripplethereisalargeamountofmismatchlossbetweenthe50
ohmimpedanceoftheVNAandtheimpedancepresentedbytheTMsystemateachport.
15
Theuppertraceisacalculationof GA max whicheffectivelyremovestheextra
attenuationduetoportmismatchandallowsjusttheohmicandradiationlossestobe
evaluated.Inadditiontoattenuationduetoohmiclossesinthecopperconductor,
approximately2dBlossisapparentnear1GHz.Thisisalmostentirelyradiationloss
duetothediscontinuitiesatthelaunchersandoccursovertheentiremeasurement
range.Becauseofthelargestandingwavespresentonthelineduetomismatch,the
radiationlossisgreaterthanitwouldbeforthesituationofaperfectlyimpedance
matchedlauncher.
07/27/09
14
IntroductiontothePropagatingWaveonaSingleConductor
Whileaplanarlauncherofthetypeshownintheseillustrationisusefulforanalysis,even
withimpedancematchingaddedattheports,itisnotgenerallythebestdesignfor
minimumsystemattenuation.Themodaldiscontinuitiesofthistypeoflauncher
generallyproducesbothunwantedradiationandreflection.
07/27/09
15
IntroductiontothePropagatingWaveonaSingleConductor
Illustration8:140MHz20GHzmeasurementof3.4meterlengthsof.085"Teflon
dielectricsemirigidcoax(TEM)and#24barecopper(TM)modeline.
Illustration8showsameasurementofGAmaxforthesametypeofcompensatedlauncher
butthelinelengthhasbeenincreasedto3.4meters.Additionallyameasurementofan
equallengthof.085Teflondielectricsemirigidcoaxhasbeenincluded.Thecoaxcenter
conductorisofaboutthesamediameterastheconductoroftheTMlinebutissilver
plated.Inspiteofthebetterconductivityofthecoaxandtheradiationduetothe
launchers,thelowerattenuationoftheTMwavesystemisobvious.Abetterlauncher
designcanprovideevenmorecontrastbetweentheattenuationsoftheTEMandTM
modes.Evenwithonlycrudetechniques,itisnotdifficultoreducetotallossforasingle
launchertolessthan.25dB.Theseandotherlauncherpossibilitiesanddesignshave
16
beendescribedelsewhere .BecausethedisplacementcurrentinTMlineismuchless
thantherealcurrentinconventionalcoax,impedanceishigherandtheohmiclossesin
TMlinearedramaticallylessthanforcoax.ThesmallerslopeoftheTMattenuation
versusfrequencygivesanindicationofthissuperiorTMperformance.
07/27/09
16
IntroductiontothePropagatingWaveonaSingleConductor
Broadband
Thebroadbandnatureofthistransmissionsystemisobviousfromthesemeasurements.
Withevenrelativelysimplelaunchersitispossibletoachievethreeormoredecadesof
lowattenuationperformance.Thelowerfrequencylimitisprimarilydeterminedbythe
diameterofthelauncherandbytheabilitytoeffectivelymatchtothelineimpedance.
Thelauncheractsasasortofcapacitortospaceinthatitprovidesareturnpathfor
displacementcurrent.Asthelaunchergetsverysmall,thereactanceofthiscapacitor
increasesandgetslargecomparedtoloadpresentedbythelinepluslauncher.This
higherQmakesbroadbandimpedancematchingmoredifficult.Howevera60cm
diameterplanarlauncherhasprovenquiteusabletobelow20MHz.
Theupperfrequencylimitisaffectedmainlybythedetailofthetransitionfromthecoax
connectortothelineitself.Thesame60cmdiameterplanarlauncherdescribedabove
easilyprovidesgoodperformancefrom20MHzto20GHz,whichistheupperlimitofthe
HP8720VNAusedforthismeasurement.Itisveryprobablethatperformancewas
excellentwellbeyondthis.
Asthelinediameterbecomeslargecomparedtoawavelengthmorecareneedstobe
takentoassurethatunwanteddiscontinuitiesandresultantradiationdonotoccur.
HoweveritispossibletosupporttheTMmodeonlinesthatarelargecomparedtoa
wavelength.Workbetween30GHzand500GHzindicatesthatthemodeisusefulatleast
17
thathigh usingconductorshavingcircumferenceswhicharelargecomparedtoa
wavelength.
07/27/09
17
IntroductiontothePropagatingWaveonaSingleConductor
PracticalApplications
OverheadPowerLines
Anobviousandverypromisingclassofapplicationsofthistransmissionmodeisinuseof
existingoverheadelectricpowerlinesforlastmileinformationservices.Thelow
attenuationandbroadbandnatureofthemodeoperatingonpreexistinginfrastructure
canprovideabasisforverylowcostinformationtransmissioninmuchofthepopulated
world.Becausetheunderlyinghardware,rightsofway,supportandmaintenancefor
powergridsarealreadyinplace,theadditionofhighcapacityinformationtransportcan
bequiteinexpensive,particularlywhencomparedtoothercandidatetransmission
methodssuchasDSL,CATV,fixedormobilewirelesssystemsorfiberopticcable.
ThepreviouspracticalexamplesandmeasurementsofTMstructuresusedrelatively
smallconductordiameters.Commonpowerdistributionandtransmissionlineconductors
rangeindiameterfromabout4mmupto25mmoreven50mm.Modernpower
conductorsareoftenconstructedbywindingmultiplebarealuminumorcopperwires
aroundacentralsteelcarrierwirewhichproducesamultistrandcablewithextra
strengthandresistancetostretching.Twoormoreofthesecablesarethenplacedunder
tensionandsupportedbyseparateinsulatorsmountedonperiodicsupportsinorderto
formmultispansegmentsofoverheadpowerline.Inmuchoftheworldthesesupports
arewoodenpowerpolesandmaybe1020mtallandspaced30100m.It'snot
uncommonforasinglesystemofpolestoprovidesupportformultiplesetsoflines,with
highervoltagedistributionlinenearthetopsofthepoles,possiblyinconjunctionwitha
stepdowntransformer,andasecondsetofsupportslowerdownforlowervoltagelines
thatprovidedeliverytoresidentialorbusinessendusesiteslocatedadjacenttotheline.
Theselinesareprevalentinmuchoftheinhabitedworld,arelocatedinareasassociated
withhumanactivity,havesystemsinplacetoensurethattheyarekeptoperatingand
maintained,andassuchtheyaregoodcandidatesforlastmileinformationdelivery
systems.Becauseofthecapabilityforverylargebandwidthandlowattenuationofthe
TMmodeit'susefultoexaminethecharacteristicsofpracticalTMmodepowerline
systems.RFandmicrowavetransmissionsystemsusingtheTMmodethatutilize
overheadpowertransmission,distributionordeliveryinfrastructurehavebeendubbed
ELine.
07/27/09
18
IntroductiontothePropagatingWaveonaSingleConductor
Illustration9:AslottedELinelaunchermountedtoanaluminum
powerlineconductor.
Anexampleofaspecialslottedlauncher adaptedtomountonanexistingpower
conductorisshowninIllustration9.Thislauncherhasaspecialtriaxialadaptersection
includedtoallowcouplingbetweencoaxiallineandthesurfacewavemodepropagating
alongthealuminumpowerconductor.Theslotteddesignallowstheentireassemblytobe
placedonthelinewithoutrequiringanymodificationofthelineconductor.Thecoaxial
portisconnectedtobidirectionalamplifiers,whicharesolarpoweredinthisexample,
locatedbehindthelauncheranddirectlyaboveamechanicalclampwhichattachesthe
entireassemblytothepowerlineconductor.Thelauncherinthisphotographdoesnot
includeanydielectriccompensationtoimprovetheimpedanceandmodematchbetween
thecoaxialandTMmodes.
18
07/27/09
19
IntroductiontothePropagatingWaveonaSingleConductor
07/27/09
20
IntroductiontothePropagatingWaveonaSingleConductor
ImpairmentType
LineAttenuation
SaddleInsulators
Splices
TapLine
5dB
6dB
Approx.1dBvariationdependingupontailonendoftie
.55dB 15dB
Fingertrapstyle,larger(step)diameterslightlyworse.Quiteflat
withfrequency
3dB
Functionofconnectionhardware,inparticularfirstwith1from
line.Quiteflatwithfrequency.
Rain
Toosmalltomeasureon1100'run.
Sag
Nomeasurablevariationforanypracticaltension
Bends
020dB
Birds
small
Table1:Impactofimpairmentscommontooverheadpowerlines
Table1listssomecommonimpairmentfactorsandtheircharacteristicsat2and5GHz.
InsulatorsnormallyaccountfornomorethanafewdBadditionalattenuation.Taplines
whichconnecttoaconductorandleaddirectlyawayfromtheline,suchasthoseatastep
downtransformer,interruptthefieldlinesinonlyoneplaneandusuallycauseabout3
dBofextraattenuation.Ingeneral,impairmentslocatedclosetothesurfaceofthe
conductortendtohavemoreinfluencethanthoseevenslightlyremoved.Thisistobe
expectedsincethisisthelocationofthelargestfields.Theeffectsoflinebendsgenerally
dependalotonthedetailoftheconductorandinsulatorclosetothebenditself.Asmall
radiusbendismoreinfluentialthanaslowerbendhavingalargerminimumradiusof
curvature.Normallinesaghasnomeasurableeffect.Mostoftheseimpairmentshavea
relativelyuniformeffectversusfrequencyandasaresultproduceratherlowgroupdelay
perturbationofthetransmittedwave.
Becausetheeffectsofimpairmentsaregenerallystableandwellbehaved,highQ
resonances,sharpfrequencydomainnotchesandsimilareffectsarerelativelyuncommon.
Asforothertypesoftransmissionlinesitispossibletoconfigurespecialstructuresina
waytocreatefrequencydependentfilteringfromsectionsofTMmodelinebutthese
kindsofresponsesaren'tcommonontypicaloverheadpowerlineinstallations.
TouseoverheadpowerlinesfortransportofRFandmicrowaveinformationbearing
signals,alinkbudgetanalysiscanbemadeinmuchthesamewayasforotherwiredor
wirelesssystems.ToexaminethecapabilitiesofELine,itisusefultocomparethe
underlyingabilitytotransportsignalswithothermethods,intermsofspectral
07/27/09
21
IntroductiontothePropagatingWaveonaSingleConductor
bandwidth,attenuationanddistance.
Illustration11:Maximuminformationcapacitieswithin100MHzbandwidthforELine
comparedwithotherlastmiletransportmethods.
07/27/09
22
IntroductiontothePropagatingWaveonaSingleConductor
Transmission SpectralBW,
Signal
Method
(Center
PowerdBm
Frequency)
(mW)
Noise
dBm
orNoise
Figure(dB)
Attenuation
Notes
CenterFrequency
limitsavailable
bandwidth
HFBPL
26MHz
(17MHz)
50dBm/Hz
(260)
xDSL
100MHz
(50MHz)
0
(1)
120
Suburban
Wireless
100MHz
(2GHz)
0
(1)
(3)
Freespace
Wireless
100MHz
(2GHz)
0
(1)
(3)
lossless
Antenna#2dipole,2m
elevation
CATV
100MHz
(1GHz)
0
(1)
(3)
Perdatasheet
TimesWireLMR600
Line+Insulator
Attenuation
TypicalInstallation,
linelosspluseffectsof
supportinginsulator
every100m
ELine
100MHz
(2GHz)
0
(1)
OPERA
(3)
19
.3dB/m@100
MHz
Crosstalklimited
COST231/Hata
Antenna#1 1 m2
propagationmodel aperture,20m
elevation
Table2:Conditionsandassumptionsusedtocalculatetheinformationcapacitiesin
Illustration11
Illustration11plotsthemaximumtheoreticalinformationcapacityasafunctionof
distanceforseveralexistinglastmiletransmissionmethodsalongwiththatforELine.
Thetypescomparedare
HFBPL,HFtransportusingtwopowerlineconductors
xDSL,twistedpaircoppertelephonelines,
Freespacewireless,radiowithcompletelylineofsightpropagation,
Suburbanwireless,radiowithinatypicalsuburbanenvironment,
CATV,lowlossdistributioncoax
ELine,TMpropagatingmodeonsingleconductoroverheadpowerlines.
Acomparisonofthissortisalmostimpossibletoperformfairlyorcompletelyaccurately.
Eachtransportmediumhasitsowncharacteristics,strengthsandweaknessesthatmake
anycommonbenchmarklessthanperfect.Assumptionsnecessaryforonemethodare
inappropriateorirrelevantforanother.Becauseofthesedifficulties,Illustration11
07/27/09
23
IntroductiontothePropagatingWaveonaSingleConductor
shouldbeconsideredonlyaqualitativecomparisonandisprovidedtogiveasenseof
relativeperformanceratherthananabsolutemeasure.
Thisapproachcalculatesinformationcapacityasafunctionofdistancebyuseof
Shannon'sequation
C=B log 2
S
1
N
(25)
where
C=maximumchannelinformationrateinbits/second
B=bandwidthinhertz
S=signalpower
N=noisepower
Foreachmethod,theassociatedspectrumwassubdividedinto100segmentsandthe
informationcapacityforeachsegmentwascalculatedbasedondistance,segmentcenter
frequency,signalpowerandnoisepower.Theinformationcapacitiesofallofthese
subsegmentswerethensummedtoproduceanassociatedmaximumcapacity.These
resultsdescribethemaximuminformationratepossibleifaperfectencodingandprotocol
isused.Noallowancesormarginsforvariationhavebeenincluded.Theseresultsare
thereforetheupperboundratherthanadescriptionofpracticalsystems.Unlessnoted,a
sourcepowerof0dBm(1milliwatt)andinformationbandwidthof100MHzhavebeen
used.OtherrelevantattributesareasshowninTable2.Limitingthebandwidthtoonly
100MHzconsiderablyunderstatesthecapabilityofELine.
Inadditiontotheplotsforeachofthemethodsthemaximuminformationcapacity
possiblein100MHzbandwidthwithC/Nratiolimitof30dBisshown.Thisisan
arbitrarylimitbutissimilartotheminimumrequiredC/Nforprotocolssuchas802.11a,
802.11g,WiMax,LTEandothercommoncommunicationsstandards.Ifgreaterspectrum
wereused,thepotentialinformationcapacityofELinewouldeasilyexceedthatofevery
technology,exceptopticalfiberandfreespacewirelessouttodistancesofseveralkm.
Inordertotransportinformationoververylargedistancesallofthesemethodsrequire
periodicamplificationinordertoovercomesignalloss,possiblyaccompaniedby
demodulationandremodulationofinformation.Illustration11revealsthemaximum
distanceallowablebetweensuchamplificationifaspecificinformationrateistobe
maintained.ForELineinstalledontypicaldistributionlineswithpolespacingsof100m,
amplificationeveryfewpolesisnecessarytomaintainthemajorityofthemaximum
possiblecapacityallowedbytheassumptions.Linepowerlevelslargerthan1milliwatt
canallowincreasedspacing.Practicalsystemshavebeenbuiltwithfivetotenamplifiers
permileoflinewhichhavesupportedmorethan2Gbpsinformationcapacityusingless
07/27/09
24
IntroductiontothePropagatingWaveonaSingleConductor
than100MHzinformationbandwidth.Aphotographofaprototypeofoneofthese
amplifyingnodesinstalledonanoperatingpowerlineisshowninIllustration12.The
launchersareconsiderablylargerthannecessaryformanyapplicationsbutallow
operationfromaslowas200MHztoabove20GHz.
Illustration12:Photographofoneamplifyingnodeinaprototypesysteminstalledonan
existingmediumvoltagepowerline
07/27/09
25
IntroductiontothePropagatingWaveonaSingleConductor
Illustration13:ELine(TMmode)systemprovidingsimultaneoustransportand
distributionofdifferentinformationservices.
Illustration13depictsanELinesystemcapableofprovidingbothhighcapacityendto
endinformationtransportaswellasinformationdistributionforendusersneartheline.
Simultaneoususageofpowerpolesassitesfornanocellstoprovideaccessforadjacent
userswhileenablingnearlineofsight(freespace)radiopathsallowsveryhighuserdata
ratesalongwithsmalluserantennaapertureandlowtransmitpower.AnELine
distributionsystemcaneasilyincludebothanantennaandactivecircuitryatselected
polesinordertotailoracoveragefootprintalongandinthevicinityofthepowerline
system.Inasituationwherethecommunicationssystemisalreadyfrequencydivision
duplex,suchasinamobiletelephonesystem,thiscanbedonewithsimplebidirectional
amplificationandfiltering.InthiswayasingleELineinstallationcanprovidebackhaul
(transport),fronthaul(distributedantennafeed)andaccess(distributedantennas)for
endusersat3Gand4Gspeeds,withanaggregateinformationcapacityofmanyGbps.
TherelativelylowattenuationofELineallowssimpleamplificationtosufficeateach
amplifyingnode,ratherthanrequiringdemodulation,remodulationandtheattendant
delays(latency)producedbytheseprocesses.Sinceallhardwarecanbelocatedonthe
lineconductoritselfandnopoleattachisrequiredthecostofthissystemisdramatically
07/27/09
26
IntroductiontothePropagatingWaveonaSingleConductor
lessthanisthecaseforalternatetechnologiesandmethods.TheresultisthatsimpleRF
andmicrowaveelectronics,periodicallyincludedwithpairsoflaunchersplacedalonga
powerline,cansimultaneouslyprovideandmaintainbothtransportanddistributionof
highrateinformationservicesandcontent.Sincethesystemfollowstheelectric
distributiongrid,itcanalsobeusedtosimultaneouslyprovideSmartGrid
communicationswithenduselocationsforrealtimepowermanagementandbilling.
FeedLineforHighAltitudeAntennas
Theextremesimplicityandrelativelysmalldimensionsofalowattenuationandhigh
bandwidthTMmodesystemmakeuseasanantennafeedlinebetweengroundlocated
communicationsequipmentandhighaltitudeantennasattractive.Formanypractical
terrestrialcommunicationssystems,coverageisseverelylimitedbythepresenceofhills,
buildings,foliageandothersimilarobstructionswhicharerelativelyclosetotheearth.
Theimpactoftheseimpairmentscanbeappreciatedbycomparingthefreespace
attenuationwiththatofthesuburbanenvironmentattenuationofradiosignalsshownin
Illustration11.FortytosixtydBofexcessattenuationiscommonplaceformanypractical
anddesirablepathlengths.However,bylocatingatleastoneantennawellabovethe
impairments,thetotalradiopathlossrapidlyfallsandallowsmuchhighercarrier/noise
ratios,performanceandcoverage.TMmodetransmissionlinecanbeusedtoconnect
heavygroundlocatedequipmentwithhighaltitudeantennas.
Toillustratethisapplication,alightweightbiconicalantennawasfabricatedand
integratedwithasmallforwardhorntypelauncher.Asmallheliumfilledballoonwas
usedtolifttheantennaandtheentireassemblywastetheredbymeansofsmallgauge
copperwirewhichdoubledasalightweightTMfeedlinefortheantenna.
07/27/09
27
IntroductiontothePropagatingWaveonaSingleConductor
Illustration14:"Featherweight"biconicalantenna,integratedTMmodelauncherand
supportingballoontetheredbyfeedline.
Illustration14isaphotographoftheantennawithintegratedTMlauncherand
supportingballoon.
Tomeasuretheimprovement,theballoonwasfirstallowedtosupporttheantennaat
about2metersabovegroundandareferencemeasurementofadistantcommercial100
MHzFMbroadcastsignalwasmade.Thetransmittingantennaforthissignalwas
approximately150kmawayandtherewasconsiderableinterveningobstruction.Asa
result,thesignalwasatornearFMthresholdandcouldnotbefullydemodulatedbya
standardFMstereoreceiver.Thecopperwiretetherwasthenallowedtoplayoutandthe
balloonrosetoapproximately60meters.Atthatelevation,theantennawaswellabove
localfoliageandclutter.Thereceivedsignalamplituderosebymorethan30dB.Asthe
feedlineandantennawerepassivestructures,Lorentzreciprocitytheoremappliesand
thisantennaandfeedlinesystemcouldbeexpectedtoprovidethesameimprovementat
thedistantlocationiftheballoonsupportedantennawereusedfortransmittingrather
thanforreceiving.
Althoughballoonandkiteliftedantennashavebeeninuseforaboutacentury,the
lightweightandlowcrosssectionalareaofsuitableTMlineconductorallowstheantenna
07/27/09
28
IntroductiontothePropagatingWaveonaSingleConductor
feedpointtobelocatedathighaltituderatherthanatgroundlevel,aswasthecasefor
previousaeriallysupportedantennaswhichweregenerallyendfed.Thus,existingheavy
communicationsequipmentcanremaingroundmountedbutbeeasilyusedwith
temporarylightweightantennaslocatedatveryconsiderableelevationandthe
communicationsrangeandqualityofcommoncommunicationssystemsgreatlyincreased.
Anapplicationofthissortmighthaveparticularvalueforemergencycommunicationsas
wellasinsituationswheretemporarywideareacommunicationsisrequired,suchasona
battlefield.Inaddition,becausetheattenuationofthe TM 00 modeisquitelow,RFor
microwaveenergycanbetransmitteduptotheelevatedassemblyandrectifiedtoprovide
DCpowerforactiveelectronics,signageorevenfortheliftingdeviceitself.Itshouldbe
possible,forexample,topoweranelectrichelicopterwhichsupportsthelineandantenna
whichissimultaneouslybeingusedforcommunicationspurposes.
Summary
Thisarticlehasdescribedapreviouslyunknownpropagating TM 00 surfacewavemode
whichexistsonasingleunshieldedconductor.Practicaltransmissionlinesutilizingthis
modewerenotpreviouslyknowntobepossible.Descriptionsoftheassociatedfieldsand
launchersusefulforconvertingbetweenthismodeandconventionaltransmissionlines
havebeenprovidedandthebroadbandandlowlossnatureofthismodehasbeen
illustratedthroughmeasurementsofsimple,practicalsystems.Someapplicationsofthis
mode,includingtheuseoftheexistingworldwidegridofoverheadpowerlinesforhigh
ratelastmileinformationtransporthavebeendetailed.
Inparticular,thisdiscoveryallowsveryinexpensiveimplementationofwidearea
informationservicesutilizingthepreexistingworldwidepowerdistributiongrid.Simple
andinexpensivehardwarecanbeinstalledonasingleconductoroftheseubiquitouslines
andusedtocreateahighcapacity3rdPipeforinformationdistribution.Thelocation
andrightsofwayoftheseexistingpowersystemsallowthemtobeusedsimultaneously
toprovide3Gand4Guseraccesswhiletheyalsoprovidesbackhaulandotherpointpoint
informationtransport.Ofparticularvalue,thissystemcaneasilybeappliedforusein
SmartGridenergysystems.Thereuseofexistinglines,rightsofwayandmaintenance
systemsallowalloftheseinformationservicestobedeployedandoperatedatasmall
fractionofthecostofanyothermethod.
07/27/09
29
[1]Halliday&Resnick,Physics,PartII,1962JohnWiley&Sons,ISBN0471345237
[2]Schelkunoff,BellSystemTech.J.,17,January1938
[3]JuliusAdamsStratton,ElectromagneticTheory,1941,reprintbyIEEEpressSerieson
ElectromagneticWaveTheory,JohnWiley&SonsInc.ISBN139780470131534
[4]Schelkunoff,op.cit.p.24
[5]JuliusAdamsStratton,op.cit.p.546
[6]JuliusAdamsStratton,op.cit.f.530
[7]JuliusAdamsStratton,op.cit.p.529
[8]Zenneck,Ann.Phys.23(1907),846(referencedfrom[13])
[9]JuliusAdamsStratton,op.cit.f.527
[10]JuliusAdamsStratton,op.cit.p.549
[11]WilliamC.Daywitt,FirstOrderSymmetricModesforaSlightlyLossyCoaxial
TransmissionLineIEEETransactionsonMicrowaveTheoryandTechniques,vol.38,
no.11.November1990
[12]G.Goubau,Surfacewavesandtheirapplicationstotransmissionlines,J.Appl.Phys.,
vol.21,p.1119,1950.
[13]G.Goubau,USPatent2685068,July271954
[14]M.FriedmanandRichardFernsler,LowLossRFTransportOverLongDistances,
IEEETransactiononMicrowaveTheoryandTechniques,Vol49,No.2,February2001
[15]AgilentTechnologies,SParameterDesign,ApplicationNoteAN154,
[16]GlennElmore,USPatent7567154,July282009
[17]KanglinWangandDanielM.Mittleman,DispersionofSurfacePlasmonPolaritons
onMetalWiresintheTeraHertzFrequencyRange,PhysicalReviewLetters,PRL96,
157401,21APRIL2006,TheAmericanPhysicalSociety
[18]Elmore,GlennE,Methodandapparatusforlaunchingasurfacewaveontoasingle
conductortransmissionlineusingaslohed[sic]flaredcone,USPatent7,009,471
[19]OpenPLCEuropeanResearchAlliance,DocumentOP_WP1_D5_v0.9.doc,