Professional Documents
Culture Documents
CHAN,
Complainant,
- versus -
- - - - ~- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
-)(
D 0 C,&liil T Ii D
Date: ,~.t;~~
..~.,~~!5
~:'
_-V.Ll. .................-
DECISION
Prefatory Statement
Electricity is properly the enjoyment of which the
provider, such as [a distribution utility], may extend or
deny to others.' However, electricity is. not just any
properly, and [a distribution utility] is not just any properly
owner. Electricity is a basic necessity the generation and
distribution of which is imbued with public interest, and its
provider is a public utility subject to strict regulation by the
State in the exercise of police power. Failure to comply
with these regulations will give rise to the presumption of
bad faith or abuse of right. 1
Samar II Electric Cooperative, Incorporated (SAMELCO II) and Dacula vs. Quijano,
G.R. No. 144474, April 27, 2007 citing United States vs. Carlos, 21 Phil. 553, 560
(1911), Article 429 of the Civil Code of the Philippines, Republic vs. Manila
EI.ectric Company, 440 Phil. 389, 397 (2002), and Manila Electric Company vs.
Hon. Lorna Navarro-Domingo, G.R. No. 161893, June 27, 2006, 493 SCRA /
363,371.
/1
1.
2.
Manila Electric Company (MERALCO) VS. Sps. Edito and Felicidad Chua, and
Josefina Paqueo, G.R. No. 160422, July 5, 201~
'1
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
541,877.85
Paid on October 23, 1998, Full Pa ment
548,656.05
Paid on October 30, 1998, Full Pa ment
389,559.73
Paid on Janua
101,202.55
Paid on Ma 26, 1999, Full Pa ment
103,881.85
Paid on Ma 26, 1999, Full Pa ment
Total
2,086,479.45
Note: * MERALCO's billing adjustment for the period September 11, 1998 to December 11, 1998
based on daily average energy consumption from August 11, 1998 to September 11, 1998 and
from November 26, 1998 to December 11, 1998 at 4,792 kWh/da
10.
11.
x xx.
Customer Liability:
In the event of loss of, or damage to
property of the Company through misuse or
negligence on the part of the Customer or his
employees or household members, the cost of
the necessary repairs or replacement thereof
shall be paid to the Company by the
Customer.
Customers will be held responsible for
tampering, interfering with, or breaking of
seals of meters or other equipment of the
Company
installed
on the
Customer's
premises, and shall be held liable for the
same in accordance with law. The Customer
agrees that no one except employees of the
Company showing proper identification card
shall be allowed to make any internal or
external adjustments of any meter or any
other piece of apparatus owned and belonging
to the Company.
The employees and/or representatives
of the Company are hereby given permission
by the Customer to enter its premises without
being liable to trespass to dwelling for the
purpose of inspecting, installing, reading,
removing, testing, replacing, or otherwise
disposing of its apparatus and properly and/or
removing the Company's entire property in the
event of the termination of the contract of any
cause.
xxx~
13.
14.
98,229
335,549.80
335,549.80
(Paid under Pay to
Cash Check No.
47530)
Adjusted Bills
Amount
kWh
(PhP)
(none)
(none)
164,240
541,877.85
Total
Payment
(PhP)
541,877.85
148,552
498,078.10
548,565.05
498,078.10
(50,486.95)
143,760
490,762.65
490,762.65
389,559.73
101,202.92
(Paid on May 26,
1999, OR No.
251560)
127,080
439,431.65
439,431.65
335,549.80
103,881.85
(Paid on May 26,
1999, OR No.
251560)
2,020,637.20
PhP1,970,150.25
PhP2,020,637.20
PhP50,486.95
Total
1,815,552.43
1,970,150.25
Total Amount Of Bills To Be Paid By The Customer
Total Amount Paid By The Customer
Difference (Still bein~ verified with payments if already credited to the customer)
4,
2001,
MERALCO
filed
its
"Answer
with
'l
his "Formal
Offer of
;:;
and
for
to Motionfor ReconSideratio~
"Vigore s
to
DISCUSSION
With the admission that MERALCO consistently billed Mr. Chan
with a monthly energy consumption of 165,240 kWh for the periods
August 11, 1998 to September 11,1998, September 11, 1998 to
October 12, 1998, and October 12, 1998 to November 11, 19983
without actual meter reading, and MERALCO's new kWh meter was
defectively installed and its meter reading was used for the period
November 20 to 26, 19984, and the determination that Mr. Chan fully
and excessively paid under protest his electricity bills for the disputed
periods, the primordial issue that has to be resolved is whether Mr.
Chan is entitled to a total refund of PhP2, 086,479. 45.
Undeniably, Mr. Chan consumed electricity when he operated
his ice plant during those periods~ sans actual meter reading.
However, the Commission is convinced that Mr. Chan must not be
made liable to pay for electricity which he did not actually consume
since the operation of an ice plant is seasonal, particularly, during the
months of the disputed billing periods wherein the production of ice is
low.
Thus, every person who through an act of performance by
another, or any other means, acquires or comes into possession of
something at the expense of the latter without just or legal ground,
shall return the same to him5.
It bears stressing that the metering facility of the ice plant
(Industrial Customers) involves two (2) kiloWatt-hour (kWh) meters.
The said installation is the most technically accepted design before
the advent of electronic multi-functional kWh meter.
4'
.~
3
4
Formula 1
Qr = (2 x qr) - Pr
-----
~3
(~)]
Where:
Qr is the total reactive energy or the total kVARh consumption
Pr is the total active energy or the total kWh consumption which
was based on the difference of the present reading from the
previous reading of the kV\fh1 meter
on assumedreading~
Period
August 11, 1998
September 11, 1998
October 12, 1998
October 12, 1998
November 11, 1998
November 11, 1998
to
to
to
to
to
to
Total
Estimated
Consumption
(kWh)
165,240.00
165,240.00
165,240.00
127,080.00
622,800.00
Amount
(PhP)
541,877.85
548,656.05
389,559.73
101,202.55
335,549.80
103,881.85
2,020,727.83
No.
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
Reading
Date
01/10/97
02/11/97
03/11/97
04/11/97
05/12/97
06/11/97
07111/97
08/12/97
09/11/97
10/13/97
11/12/97
12/11/97
01/12/98
02/11/98
03/12/98
04/13/98
05/11/98
06/11/98
07/10/98
08/11/98
09/11/98
10/12/98
11/11/98
* 11/20/98
** 11/25/98
12/11/98
Readings
(kWh)
1140
1909
2564
3363
4422
5530
6556
7696
8695
9914
10377
10916
11661
12391
13260
14249
15222
16350
17454
18826
20203
769
655
799
1,059
1,108
1,026
1,140
999
1,219
463
539
745
730
869
989
973
1,128
1,104
1,372
1,377
5
95
578
Note
.
90
483
2.26
2.12
2.12
2.16
2.00
2.07
2.11
1.99
1.99
1.99
1.96
2.16
2.15
2.14
2.12
2.07
2.12
2.13
2.23
2.20
2.20
9643
10120
10541
11033
11633
12415
13112
13976
14858
15943
16345
16851
17449
18059
18813
19686
20542
21532
22496
23702
24920
2.00
25662
25692
26056
.
-
477
421
492
600
782
697
864
882
1,085
402
506
598
610
754
873
856
990
964
1,206
1,218
30
364
Difference
11661
12391
13260
14249
15222
16350
17454
18826
20203
21580
22957
5
95
578
Readings
.
.
730
869
989
973
1,128
1,104
1,372
1,377
1,377
1,377
90
483
Difference
17449
18059
18813
19686
20542
21532
22496
23702
24920
26138
27356
25664
25692
26056
.
610
754
873
856
990
964
1,206
1,218
1,218
1,218
(1,692)
28
364
Energy (kWh)
time (hour/month)
Load Factor (%)
Demand
80,003.64 kWh
720 hours
84.13%
I Maximum Demand
Maximum
Maximum
Demand
. 132.08
kW
2,020,727.83
1,069,411.87
951,315.96
_______
7
writing.Furthermore'd
{/
3.
2,020,727.83
1,069,411.87
951,315.96
913,263.32
of
11,864,579.28
PhP1,864,579.28,
the
+rt)
Where:
A
P
r
t
=
=
=
=
And Where:
r
t
=
=
PhP951,315.96
6% per annum
16 years
Thus:
A
A
remiss
provide
line or
by the
Metropolitan Cebu Water District VS. Mactan Rock Industries, Inc., G.R. No.
172438, July 4,2012
11 MERALCO VS. Ramoy et aI., G.R. No. 158911, March 4, 20~
10
12
JOSE
V;;E'NTE
B~SZZ~
Chairman
ALF~ioN
G~~Iit.
Commissioner
commiSSione~
JOSEFINA PAT I
A. MAGPALE-ASIRIT
Co missioner
13
:ERC--~-F-' \\
Office afthe
'..
Chairman
Lc2015-004-02030 '_'
. __ .
No. of Violation
YAP-TARUC
:J
Basic Amount
of Penalty
PhP100,OOO.OO
c~
ANNEXA
SUMMARY OF DATA AND DISPUTED ENERGY CONSUMPTION COMPUTATION
No Data Integrity
I
1 12-Jan-1998
Actual Meter
Readings
C
onsump Ion
1 Meter 1 IActive
Energy (KWh) 1
1 Meter 2 Iq-reading
(RKVAh)
12-Mar-1998
1 11-Feb-1998
13-Apr-1998
Notes:
1 ll-Sep-1998
14249
15222
16350
17454
188261
202031
174491
18059
18813
19686
20542
21532
22496
237021
249201
989.00 1
973.00 1
873.00 1
856.00 1
with mulitplier
of 120 (x120)
1
1
730.00 1
869.00
610.00 1
754.00
I
I
87,600.00
104,280.00
118,680.00
116,760.00
73,200.00
90,480.00
104,760.00
102,720.00
1,104.00
1,372.00
1,377.00
990.00 1
964.00
1,206.00
1,218.00
1,128.00
135,360.00
with mulitplier
1
(RKVAh)
ll-Au!l-1998
13260
Energy (KWh) 1
Meter 2 Iq-reading
10-Jul-1998
12391
Energy (KWh) 1
.
I Meter 2 Iq-readmg (RKVAh)
I
Actual
Consumption
ll-Jun-1998
116611
1 Meter 1 IActive
Meter 1 IActive
l1-May-1998
132,480.00
ll-Dec-1998
1 15-Mar-1999
1
260561
28041
I
1,136.00
direct
164,640.00
165,240.00
419,392.00
144,720.00
146,160.00
136,320.00
1,985.00
reading
of 120 (x120)
118,800.00
115,680.00
238,200.00
1) New meter was installed replacing the missing Meter 1 on Nov. 20, 1998 however, said new meter was found defective on Nov. 26, 1998, thus, integrity of KWh data during said period is in question;
2) The new meter replacing Meter 1 is direct reading or it does not require any multiplier;
3) Meter 2 was continuosly
4) - consumotion
used and data was recorded even after replacing Meter 1; and
based on MERALCO's
etimates.
1 12-Jan-1998
Reactive
Energy
1
Power Factor I pf (%)1
Computation
for
Power Factor
1 11-Feb-1998
1
33,948.20
12-Mar-1998
44,271.22
93.24%1
92.05%1
1 13-Apr-1998
1 11-May-1998
52,446.50
91.47%1
(KWh) for the period of Jan 12, 1998 to Aug 11, 1998
(KVARh) for the period of Jan 12, 1998 to Aug 11, 1998
51,199.42
91.58%
1 l1-Jun-1998
59,028.29
859,800.00
370,035.33
1:
ILowest Power Factor for the period of Jan 12, 1998 to Aug 11, 1998
91.47%1
2:
IAvraae. Power Factor for the period of Jan 12, 1998 to Aua 11, 1998
91.85%1
~ctual
a-readina
(RKVAh)
~ctual
q-reading
wi
ll-Aug-1998
23,702
2,844,240.00
I 11-5ep-1998
72,053.31
73,369.67
91.61%1
26,056
3,126,720.00
282,480.00
91.47%
320,014.57
80,003.64
4
KWh consumption
of the disputed
period using the
average power
factor of the entire
year
~ctual
11-Aug-1998
23,702
2,844,240.00
15-Mar-1999
I
~ctual
ll-Dec-1998
91.40%1
SIMULATION 2:
11-Dec-1998
57,088.39
I l1-Au!l-1998
91.84%1
Simulation
10-Jul-1998
91.66%1
Simulation
SIMULATION 1:
KWh consumption
of the disputed
period using the
lowest power
factor of the entire
year
11-Dec-1998
26,056
3,126,720.00
282,480.00
91.85%
323,679.71
80,919.93
Page 12 of 13
ANNEX 8
SUMMARY OF THE APPROVED CHARGES
Simulation 1
~
I
W
-...
...
...Co
Gl
rn
..
0
...
...
til
::::I
Basic Charges
Energy (KWh)
Demand (KW)
Power Factor Adjustment
Power Factor
Currency Adjustment
PPA
...
...0
..
0
...
...
...Co
Gl
Basic Charges
Energy (KWh)
Demand (KW)
Power Factor Adjustment
Power Factor
Currency Adjustment
PPA
rn
...
...
:>
..
0
...
...0
Basic Charaes
Energy (KWh)
Demand (KW)
Power Factor Adjustment
Power Factor
Currency Adjustment
PPA
...
...
U
Gl
..
...
...
0
:>
0
I
Basic Charges
Energy (KWh)
Demand (KW)
Power Factor Adjustment
Power Factor
Currency Adjustment
PPA
91.47%1
W
,....-
...
...
Amount
153,606.99
29,056.89
(3,507.15)
...Co
Gl
rn
.....
0
4.24%
0.957
...
7,596.25
76,563.49
I
263,316.46
Amount
153,606.99
29,056.89
(3,507.15)
Rates
1.92
220.00
-1.92%
4.60%
0.990
266,601.55
...0
..
...
...
0
...Co
Gl
...
...
:>
..
8,205.38
83,043.78
269,087.97
1,069,411.871
...0
U
Gl
.....
0
...
:>
0
I IConsumotion
I I
80,919.93 x
133.59 x
184,755.93 x
91.85%
181,208.62 x
80,919.93 x
I
Basic Charges
Energy (KWh)
Demand (KW)
Power Factor Adjustment
Power Factor
Currency Adjustment
PPA
Basic CharQes
Energy (KWh)
Demand (KW)
Power Factor Adjustment
Power Factor
Currency Adjustment
PPA
IIConsumotion
I I
80,919.93 x
133.59 x
184,755.93 x
91.85%
181,208.62 x
80,919.93 x
I
Basic Charges
Energy (KWh)
Demand (KW)
Power Factor Adiustment
Power Factor
Currency Adjustment
PPA
II
133.591
II
91.85%1
Amount
155,366.26
29,389.67
(3,547.31)
7,683.25
77,440.37
Rates
1.92
220.00
-1.92%
8,335.60
80,110.73
Rates
1.92
220.00
-1.92%
8,299.35
83,994.88
Rates
1.92
220.00
-3.12%
269,654.94
Amount
155,366.26
29,389.67
(3,547.31)
4.58%
1.038
Sub-total Amount
266,332.23
Amount
155,366.26
29,389.67
(3,547.31)
4.60%
0.990
Sub.total Amount
IIConsumption
I I
80,919.93 x
133.59 x
184,755.93 x
91.85%
178,991.55 x
80,919.93 x
84.13%1
4.24%
0.957
Sub.total Amount
80,919.931
II
Rates
1.92
220.00
-1.92%
Sub-total Amount
IIConsumption
I I
80,919.93 x
133.59 x
184755.93 x
91.85%
181,208.62 x
80,919.93 x
Basic Charaes
Energy (KWh)
Demand (KW)
Power Factor Adjustment
Power Factor
Currency Adjustment
PPA
...
...
6,919.32
85,203.88
3.91%
1.065
270,405.89
Amount
153,606.99
29,056.89
(5,699.11)
Rates
1.92
220.00
-3.12%
Sub-total Amount
...
ILoad Factor
I
.
MaXimumDemand
rn
4.58%
1.038
II
<{
...
Amount
153,606.99
29,056.89
(3,507.15)
Rates
1.92
220.00
-1.92%
til
::::I
8,241.21
79,203.61
Sub.total Amount
IIConsumotion
I I
80,003.64 x
132.08 x
182,663.88 x
91.47%
176,964.77 x
80,003.64 x
II
132.081
Simulation 2
84.13%1
Rates
1.92
220.00
-1.92%
Sub-total Amount
IIConsumotion
I I
80,003.64 x
132.08 x
182,663.88 x
91.47%
179,156.73 x
80,003.64 x
80,003.64
II
II
Sub-total Amount
IIConsumption
I I
80,003.64 x
132.08 X
182,663.88 x
91.47%
179,156.73 x
80,003.64 X
I
,....-
IIConsumption
I I
80,003.64 X
132.08 X
182,663.88 x
91.47%
179,156.73 x
80,003.64 x
<{
ILoad Factor
I
.
MaXimum Demand
II
273,502.86
Amount
155,366.26
29,389.67
(5,764.39)
3.91%
1.065
6,998.57
86,179.72
272,169.84
1,081,659.87
Page 13 of 13