Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Positive impact:
[1] Today, science has a profound effect on the way we live, largely through
technologythe use of scientific knowledge for practical purposes. The first
automobile, dating from the 1880s, made use of many advances in physics and
engineering, including reliable ways of generating high-voltage sparks, while the
first computers emerged in the 1940s from simultaneous advances in electronics
and mathematics.
[2] Alongside these achievements, science has also brought about technology
that helps save human life. The kidney dialysis machine enables many people to
survive kidney diseases that would once have proved fatal, and artificial valves
allow sufferers of coronary heart disease to return to active living. Biochemical
research is responsible for the antibiotics and vaccinations that protect us from
infectious diseases, and for a wide range of other drugs used to combat specific
health problems. As a result, the majority of people on the planet now live longer
and healthier lives than ever before.
Negative impact:
[4] However, scientific discoveries can also have a negative impact in human
affairs. Over the last hundred years, some of the technological advances that
make life easier or more enjoyable have proved to have unwanted and often
unexpected long-term effects.
[5] Industrial and agricultural chemicals pollute the global environment, even in
places as remote as Antarctica, and city air is contaminated by toxic gases from
vehicle exhausts. The increasing pace of innovation means that products become
rapidly obsolete, adding to a rising tide of waste. Most significantly of all, the
burning of fossil fuels such as coal, oil, and natural gas releases into the
atmosphere carbon dioxide and greenhouse gases. These gases have altered the
composition of the entire atmosphere, producing global warming and the
prospect of major climate change in years to come.
[6] Science has also been used to develop technology that raises complex ethical
questions. This is particularly true in the fields of biology and medicine. Research
involving genetic engineering, cloning, and in vitro fertilization gives scientists
the unprecedented power to bring about new life, or to devise new forms of
living things. At the other extreme, science can also generate technology that is
deliberately designed to harm or to kill. The fruits of this research include
chemical and biological warfare, and also nuclear weapons, by far the most
destructive weapons that the world has ever known.
[7] Now, more than ever, technology a product of science has become an
important part of peoples lives. Not only does technology have a direct impact
on our physical lives but it also affects our social relationships and values.
Question:
(a)When the lines between home and work are blurred, what are the implications
on the employee?
The employee may be expected to be on call/ working 24 hours a day
regardless of where he may be.
Difficult to have work-life balance because there is no such distinction.
This may increase stress on the family, as the parent brings work-related stress
back home.
b. Effect on Relationships
i. Social Glue
Gone are the days of snail mail and expensive trunk calls. With Information
Communication Technology (ICT), communication between individuals within a
family, company, or country can be made with ease. When the Internet was first
introduced, it was used to disseminate information within a company and
between companies.
Background:
Prior to the global communications network we understand the internet to be
today, it is theorized that the internet started out with military computers in the
Pentagon called Arpanet in 1969. The Arpanet gave birth to the internet
protocols in the 1970s.
Today, the Internet has become a common form of communication capable of
disseminating information across time and space. Where a country has the skills
and access to ICT, society will be able to find, foster and develop relationships
through online social networks like Facebook, Twitter and MySpace.
The rapid adoption of such social network sites by members of a society reveal
how ICT has transformed from once a private space between
companies/organisations to a public space between members from various
societies.
In the past, it has been suggested that the Internet and e-mail could diminish
real relationships.
But the report, entitled The Strength of Internet Ties done by the US-based Pew
Internet think-tank, found that e-mail supplements rather than replaces offline
communications.
ICT has created a new basis for community. Instead of relying on a single
community for social support, individuals often actively seek out a variety of
appropriate people and resources across continents for different situations. This
has resulted in the rise of networked individualism where users of modern
technology are less tied to local groups and increasingly part of more
geographically scattered networks.
Adapted from Internet serves as social glue
(http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/technology/4644666.stm)
Question
(a) Does the emphasis on online communication necessarily lead to social
isolation?
c. Social problems and cyber crimes
i. Piracy
Music theft can take various forms: individuals who illegally upload or download
music online, online companies who build businesses based on theft and
encourage users to break the law, or criminals manufacturing mass numbers of
counterfeit CDs for sale on street corners, in flea markets or at retail stores.
Across the board, this theft has hurt the music community, with thousands of
layoffs, songwriters out of work and new artists having a harder time getting
signed and breaking into the business.
One credible analysis by the Institute for Policy Innovation concludes that global
music piracy causes $12.5 billion of economic losses every year, 71,060 U.S. jobs
lost, a loss of $2.7 billion in workers' earnings, and a loss of $422 million in tax
revenues, $291 million in personal income tax and $131 million in lost corporate
income and production taxes.
Taken from RIAA--Piracy (http://www.riaa.com/physicalpiracy.php)
However recently, after years of futile efforts to stop digital pirates from copying
its music, the music business has started to copy the pirates.
Online and mobile services offering listeners unlimited, "free" access to millions
of songs are proliferating.
Taken from the Intl Herald Tribune
(http://www.iht.com/articles/2009/01/18/technology/midem.4-410564.php)
ii. Private or Public Opinion
Online blogs or diaries, similar to online social networks, can be created to
provide a private space for individuals on the public spaces of the Internet. While
such blogs may function as a private diary, the readership is not limited to the
author.
Under Section 298 of the Penal Code, Chapter 224, anyone with deliberate
intention of wounding the religious or racial feelings of any person, causes any
matter however represented to be seen or heard by that person, can be jailed up
to three years, or fine, or both, if convicted.
Deputy Commander of Central Police Div HQ, Superintendent Lee Ping Yue, said
that the police take a serious view of irresponsible blog postings in a multi-racial
society like Singapore and 'will expend all efforts in tracking the perpetrators'.
Taken from ST Online (http://www.straitstimes.com/Latest
%2BNews/Singapore/STIStory_239545.html)
iii.Internet Addiction (Social Isolation)
Youth internet addiction has become a serious social problem. To curb and
alleviate this problem, the Chinese authorities have called for tighter
enforcement of the rules banning under-18s from internet cafes and for a rating
system for games.
Adapted from Chinas clinic for its Internet junkies
(http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/1545382/Chinas-clinic-for-itsinternet-junkies.html)
The potential to be absorbed by the wonders/capabilities of ICT is real and
continues to pervade societies. In extreme cases, individuals who do not exercise
discipline or control when dealing with ICT may become socially isolated from the
physical world, from reality.
iv. Predators
The goal of a predator is to get a child to consent to sexual activities. Predators
contact teens (online and offline) to start a conversation. Just as most teens
know to say no to strange men who approach them on the street, most know to
ignore strange men who approach them online. When teenagers receive
solicitations from adults on MySpace, most report deleting them without
question. The media often reference a Crimes Against Children Report
(http://www.unh.edu/ccrc/pdf/jvq/CV38.pdf) that states one in five children
receive a sexual solicitation online.
Although the media has covered the potential risk extensively, few actual cases
have emerged. While youth are at minimal risk, predators are regularly being
lured out by law enforcement patrolling the site. The fear of predators has
regularly been touted as a reason to restrict youth from both physical and digital
publics.
Taken from Danah Boyds Discussion Forum
(http://www.danah.org/papers/MySpaceDOPA.html)
v. Identity Theft
Having more than one e-mail address can be useful in the battle against online
fraud and spam. It is also a good way to keep personal and professional lives
separate.
Adapted from Web users keeping multiple emails
(http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/uk_news/northern_ireland/7374540.stm)
Identity theft is costing the UK economy over 1.7bn a year, according to figures
"calculated by the Home Office Identity Fraud Steering Committee (IFSC) in cooperation with both public and private sector organisations".
Adapted from Guardian
(http://www.guardian.co.uk/technology/blog/2006/feb/02/identityfraud)
Question
(a) What is your opinion on the blame placed on ICT in the creation of social
problems? Is it appropriate/fair?
d. Effect on Identity
i. Multiple Identities
Individuals can create a private space within the public space of the Internet. In
creating that private space, they may reveal their personalities and express their
opinions without any qualms (subjective to whether their private space remains
private or is open to public viewing).
According to Sally M. Cohen, author of Email, IM, And Social Network Strategists:
Help Teens Manage Multiple IDs While Preserving Privacy, multiple identities
allow teens to create boundaries in online social networks. However, are such
boundaries created to express themselves freely or free themselves from the
watchful eyes of parents?
ii. The Invisible Cloak
U.S. Supreme Court Justice Scalia said The very purpose of anonymity is to
facilitate wrong by eliminating accountability (quoted in [Framkin 1995]).
Under the cloak of an online identity, which is easily created, edited and deleted,
individuals may feel protected being anonymous. However there is an obvious
risk of misuse of anonymity. To eliminate such a risk, a United Nations agency is
quietly drafting technical standards, proposed by the Chinese government, to
define methods of tracing the original source of Internet communications and
potentially curbing the ability of users to remain anonymous. Adapted from CNET
News (http://news.cnet.com/8301-13578_3-10040152-38.html)
Question
(a) How different is having multiple personalities from having multiple online
identities?
e. Education
i. Accessibility of Information
With the help of new media, information is now easily available. The teacher no
longer holds absolute authority over knowledge. Both the teachers and students
can take part in knowledge acquisition and creation.
Question
(a)With increasing access to information, how has the role of teachers changed?
(b)Are teachers redundant?
(linked to how we define education? Also the need for a teacher to help teach
skills to process the abundant information)
In addition, new media has provided the platform for distance learning which has
transformed the global education landscape.
Technology "will allow you to control the information you want, and to get it
where you want it and when you want it" - Randy Bennett (responsible for
electronic-media initiatives at the Newspaper Association of America)
ii.Digital Divide
ICTs are expected to improve efficiency and increase access to knowledge and
expertise. Thus it would appear that an inclusive information society will
The potential to improve the human condition using this kind of technology is an
irresistible fruit. But with it comes the dark side of supertechnology: the
possibility of annihilation of life on this planet. Synthetic biology and creating
novel life forms by creating new DNA sequences could be used to create
organisms never before encountered on earth.
This kind of science will not and should not be stopped. The potential benefits
are too great. But with it, we require the most profound and overarching
programme of radical moral enhancement of human beings, using not just
traditional methods of education but looking at how we can alter our own biology
to ensure that we become the kinds of beings fit to develop and use
supertechnology.
Craig Venter:
J. Craig Venter is an American biologist and businessman. He founded the
Institute of Genome Research and was instrumental in mapping the human
genome.
Adapted from Changing the Building Blocks of Life: Playing God and Being gods
http://www.practicalethicsnews.com/practicalethics/2008/02/changing-thebu.html
Question
(a)What is your opinion on the use of science to alter our biology so as to make
us morally upright?
(b)Are there differences in our understanding of morality across cultures and
time? If so, who decides which morality to abide to?
ii. Producing Designer Children
Some people view the deliberate intervention in the natural process of
procreation as an unethical interference with the process of nature.
Preimplantation Genetic Diagnosis (PGD)
Preimplantation genetic testing is a technique used to identify genetic defects in
embryos created through in vitro fertilization (IVF) before pregnancy.
Preimplantation genetic diagnosis (PGD) refers specifically to when one or both
genetic parents have a known genetic abnormality and testing is performed on
an embryo to see if it also carries a genetic abnormality.
Because only unaffected embryos are transferred to the uterus for implantation,
preimplantation genetic testing provides an alternative to current postconception
"Low-income countries will bear significant burdens from climate change and
ozone depletion. But these environmental problems have been overwhelmingly
driven by emission of greenhouse gases and ozone-depleting chemicals by the
rest of the world," Srinivasan said.
The primary cost is loss of storm protection, which some say was a major factor
in the huge loss of life from 2005's tsunami in Southeast Asia.
Deforestation, on the other hand, can exacerbate flooding and soil erosion, affect
the water cycle and offshore fisheries and lead to the loss of recreation and of
non-timber products such as latex and food sources. Agricultural intensification
can lead to drinking water contamination by pesticides and fertilizers, pollution
of streams, salinization of croplands and biodiversity loss, among other impacts.
When all these impacts are added up, the portion of the footprint of high-income
nations that is falling on the low-income countries is greater than the financial
debt recognized for low income countries, which has a net present value of 1.8
trillion in 2005 international dollars, Srinivasan said. (International dollars are
U.S. dollars adjusted to account for the different purchasing power of different
currencies.) "The ecological debt could more than offset the financial debt of lowincome nations," she said.
Adapted from
http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2008/01/080121181408.htm
(2)Political Impact
i. A Surveillance Society
=> Cameras everywhere
=> Tracking on the use of the internet
This results in increased power/ authority by the state over its people and it can
potentially create fear and paranoia amongst the masses. We can draw parallels
with the panopticon.
The Panopticon is a type of prison building designed by English philosopher and
social theorist Jeremy Bentham in 1785. The concept of the design is to allow an
observer to observe prisoners without the prisoners being able to tell whether
they are being watched, thereby conveying what one architect has called the
"sentiment of an invisible omniscience."
Bentham himself described the Panopticon as "a new mode of obtaining power of
mind over mind, in a quantity hitherto without example."
Question:
(a)How does the use of technology for surveillance infringe on our privacy? Does
it matter?
ii. People Power
Technology has allowed the lateralization of communication systems, as
mentioned in Friedmans The World is Flat.
Governments seem powerless to stop the propagation of ideas: you can ban
someone from the country but you cant ban them from the internet. People are
empowered by the new media.
Blogosphere
E.g 1.
One of Ian M. Banks novels about a post-human Culture where enhanced humans
live alongside A.I.s in an anarchic, trans-galactic society, Look to Windward
explores the way humans can maintain their basic identities and ethical values
no matter how much they tamper with their genes or modify their morphology.
For Banks, synthetic biology is simply a logical way that humans extend their
capabilities, but it does not turn them into monsters or make them authoritarian
overlords.
E.g Michaelmas
A novel published by Algis Budrys in 1977 described a worldwide web of
telecommunications and computer data, not unlike what we see today.
More information about the novel:
The eponymous protagonist, Laurent Michaelmas, is an ex-hacker who had early
in the computer era left "back doors" in many key pieces of software which run
vital government and commercial computers. As a result, by the turn of the
millennium, he has become one of the most powerful men on earth, because of
his ability to spy and influence through the worldwide computer network.
By the time of the novel, Laurent Michaelmas has successfully used his power to
create and sustain a powerful version of the United Nations to ensure world
peace. He stays in the background, however, as a journalist, albeit a highly
influential and respected one whose words and opinions can still influence public
opinion. However, as the novel progresses, Michaelmas slowly learns that a
possible extraterrestrial presence may be interfering with the new world he has
worked so hard to create.
The novel is remarkable for its prescience, because it appeared less than a
decade into the Internet era, long before its current prominence and ubiquity.
accusatory
belligerent
bitter
disappointed
disgusted
furious
grouchy
incredulous
indignant
inflammatory
insulting
irritated
outraged
petulant
querulous
savage
Humor (Satire)
belittling
caustic
comical
cynical
facetious
flippant
haughty
insulting
ironic
irreverent
malicious
mock-heroic
mocking
obsequious
ribald
ridiculing
sarcastic
SADNESS/FEAR
TRANQUILITY
apprehensive
calm
concerned
hopeful
despairing
meditative
elegiac
nostalgic
foreboding
optimistic
gloomy
peaceful
hopeless
relaxed
melancholy
reminiscent
morose
sentimental
mournful
serene
pessimistic
soothing
regretful
spiritual
serious
staid
sober
solemn
somber
ROMANCE
affectionate
amorous
sullen
scornful
threatening
taunting
tragic
compassionate
erotic
wrathful
fanciful
ideal
HAPPINESS
ARROGANCE
NEUTRAL
amiable
authoritative
Apathetic
amused
boastful
Authoritative
cheery
bold
Candid
contented
condescending
Cautionary
ecstatic
contemptuous
Ceremonial
elated
critical
Clinical
enthusiastic
disdainful
Detached
exuberant
haughty
Didactic
hopeful
insolent
Distant
LOGIC
jovial
judgmental
Erudite
argumentative
joyful
mordant
Factual
didactic
jubilant
patronizing
Forman
doubtful
lighthearted
pompous
Forthright
explanatory
optimistic
pretentious
Informative
informative
positive
supercilious
Instructive
persuasive
Matter-of-fact
rational
Objective
thoughtful
sanguine
Restrained
intimate
loving
lustful
lyurical
reflective
sensual
tender
whimsical
POSITIVE
NEGATIVE
NEUTRAL
admiring/ laudatory
arrogant
aloof
amused
ambivalent
approving
cautionary
brusque
compassionate
concerned/ worried
callous
joyful
defensive
world-weary
judicious
detached
condescending
modest/ unassuming/
humble
confused/ befuddled
didactic
optimistic
critical
thoughtful
disparaging
disbelieving
dispassionate
ironic
philosophical/ reflective
cynical
joking
respectful
skeptical
nostalgic
earnest
pessimistic
pensive
sincere
disapproving
remorseful
factual
disdainful
evasive
disheartened
grudging
forgiving
dejected
indifferent
humorous
sarcastic
impassioned
informative
lamenting/ sorrowful
impartial
malicious
indignant
supportive
mocking
sentimental
tolerant
nave
nasty/ abusive
shocked
pessimistic
solemn/ dignified
resentful
sympathetic
sarcastic
unemotional
satirical
urgent
flippant
whimsical
hypocritical
insulting
intolerant
irrelevant
scorning/ biting/caustic
self-pitying
whining/ aggrieved/
complaining