Professional Documents
Culture Documents
325
Introduction
Muscle contraction increases free radical formation [12, 24],
which has been implicated in muscle fatigue [38] and exercise
induced myocellular injury in humans [8, 27, 32]. The rise in
oxidative stress during physical activity has been partially attributed to increased mitochondrial respiration [43], which
has been estimated to rise up to 200 fold in active muscle fibres [28]. Exercise such as running can elevate markers of oxidative damage, such as malondialdehyde [12, 32] and produces damage to muscle membranes [37, 45]. These events
are often associated with the release of myocellular proteins
[17] and compromised membrane function [12,17]. Antioxidant defences include enzymes such as superoxide dismutase
and glutathione peroxidase, and non-enzymatic compounds
such as vitamins and reduced glutathione. Some aspects of antioxidant protection can be increased by training [26, 41, 45] ,
especially the enzymes of glutathione synthesis [30, 41].
available on endurance events such as marathon and halfmarathon running [47]. Houmard et al. [22] reported improved running performance during a 5 km time trial, which
was attributed to a 6 % decrease in submaximal oxygen consumption (i.e. improved running economy). As this is an important contributor to middle and long, distance running performance [3, 35], it has been proposed that reduced training
volumes might result in even greater performance benefits
for endurance events [23]. At present however, there are no
empirical data to support this view [16].
Little is known about the mechanisms by which a training taper can improve exercise performance. Most studies have focused on changes in glycogen availability and/or muscle oxidative capacity to explain the positive effects of reduced training
[23, 33, 42]. However, beneficial effects could also arise by
mechanisms unrelated to these factors. Distance running disrupts the muscle ultrastructure [20, 29] and the frequency of
such injuries appears to increase with training distance [29].
Muscle damage may be a limiting factor to long distance running performance [22, 29] and performing a training taper provides several potential mechanisms to reduce exercise induced
myocellular injury.
Child RB et al
Table 1 Profiles of subjects in normal and training taper groups, prior
to the first half-marathon
Parameter
Taper group
n=7
Normal group
n=7
Age (years)
31 2
30 1
15 1
14 1
Mass (kg)
72.4 2.1
71.2 1.6
Height (m)
1.77 0.02
1.76 0.02
63.2 1.7
61.8 1.4
50 7
45 7
215 33
202 28
14.8 0.5
14.6 0.4
258 18
270 19
456 29
503 39
1.43 0.17
1.49 0.16
90 32
115 24
Urate (mol l
The objectives of this study were to reproduce the taper regimen of Houmard et al. [22] to test the hypotheses that a controlled training taper could enhance half-marathon running
performance by improving serum antioxidant protection and
attenuating indices of lipid peroxidation and exercise induced
muscle damage.
Methods
Experimental protocol
Subjects refrained from exercise for 36 hours before each laboratory testing session and performed only light training in
the 2 days prior to each half-marathon.
Reducing training volume decreases myocellular oxygen utilisation, which in turn decreases the oxidative load on the muscle. This could result in a more reductive myocellular redox environment and experiments in mice have shown this can improve exercise performance and increase resistance to free
radical mediated muscle injury [45].
326
327
Biochemical analysis
The whole blood lactate concentration of capillary blood samples was determined immediately following collection. This
was performed using an automated analyser (Model 2300 Stat
plus, Yellow Springs Inc., Ohio, USA).
In venous blood, haemoglobin concentrations were determined by the cyanmethaemoglobin method using a diagnostic
kit (No. 124 729, Boehringer Mannheim, Mannheim, Germany). Haematocrit was determined in triplicate following microcentrifugation (Hawksley and Sons Ltd, Lancing, UK). The
remaining venous blood was split between potassium EDTA
tubes, to be centrifuged immediately at 2500 g for 10 minutes
and plain tubes (to be centrifuged using the same protocol
after clotting at room temperature for 1 hour). Plasma and serum were removed, and stored at 20 8C until analysis. Postexercise measurements in venous blood were corrected for
plasma volume changes using procedures described by Dill
and Costill [13].
Serum total antioxidant capacity (TAC) was determined by the
method of Whitehead et al. [46], relative to 6-hydroxy-2,5,7,8tetramethylchroman-2-carboxylic acid (Trolox), a soluble vitamin E analogue. Each analysis was performed in duplicate and
was expressed as Trolox Equivalents per litre (Trolox Eq l1).
MDA was measured following the method of Young and Trimble [49], with slight modifications described by Child et al. [9].
The assay uses HPLC and fluorescence to distinguish the MDA
adduct from contaminating compounds.
Serum creatine kinase activity (CK) was measured using a diagnostic kit (Sigma No. 47-10, Sigma Chemicals, Poole, UK). At
least duplicate analyses were performed on each sample, and
creatine kinase activities were calculated as a mean of two values that differed by no more than 10 % of the lower value. The
serum urate concentration (UA) was measured using a diagnostic kit (Sigma No. 686), based on the uricase-peroxidase
system.
Statistics
All data are presented as arithmetic means SEM. To illustrate
relative changes prior to running the first half-marathon biochemical measurements are presented as a percentage of each
subjects baseline measurements. Physiological and biochemical data were analysed using repeated measures analysis of
variance (ANOVA). Where significant differences were observed using the ANOVA, post-hoc paired t-tests (with Bonferroni correction), were used to evaluate exercise induced
changes within groups. Where significant differences were ob-
Child RB et al
Oxygen uptake during each half-marathon in normal and training taper groups
Group
Halfmarathon
Minute 5
@ 50 %
peak VO2
Minute 5
@ 70 %
peak VO2
Normal
Run 1
Run 2
2.23 0.06
2.18 0.04
2.95 0.05
2.96 0.03
2.99 0.08
2.93 0.05
3.34 0.05
3.26 0.06
Taper
Run 1
Run 2
2.35 0.07
2.31 0.07
3.13 0.11
3.08 0.15
3.13 0.11
3.11 0.14
3.44 0.09
3.40 0.22
Results
Baseline physiological and biochemical measurements suggested that the groups were well matched (Table 1). Performance times for the first and second half-marathons were
86.75 2.65 min and 87.67 2.87 min for the normal training
group and 85.62 2.81 min and 85.39 3.52 min for the training taper group. Differences in performance both between and
within groups were non-significant. Completion of the halfmarathon represented 52 7 % of weekly training volume in
the normal training group and 48 8 % weekly training volume
in the taper group. The first half-marathon was performed at
an intensity of 111 6 % average training speed in the normal
training group, and 108 2 % average training speed in the taper group. At the start of each half-marathon there were no
differences either within or between groups in oxygen consumption, at running speeds which elicited either 50 % or 70 %
VO2max (Table 2).
During the self paced run average exercise intensity for the
normal training group was 77.5 0.4% peak VO2 during run 1
and 75.1 0.7% peak VO2 during run 2. For the training taper
group average exercise intensity was 77.0 0.8 % peak VO2 during run 1 and 76.4 1.0 % peak VO2 during run 2. Oxygen uptake measurements made during exercise are reported in
Table 2.
Plasma volume decreased immediately after exercise, by
6.9 1.2 % after run 1 and 8.3 1.1 % after run 2 in the normal
training group, and 8.5 1.6 % and 7.1 1.2 % after run 1 and 2
respectively in the training taper group. Serum urate was
elevated over time in both groups (P < 0.001, ANOVA), although
there was no difference in this response between groups. Serum TAC also was elevated over time in both normal training
and taper groups (P < 0.001, ANOVA), but there was no difference in this response over time between groups. When MDA
data for each group were pooled, such that the t-test was applied to 14 paired data sets, the rise in plasma MDA was significant (P < 0.05). However, when the same statistical procedures were applied to MDA data for each group of seven subjects, the rise in MDA was found to be non-significant. These
findings suggest that the small size of each group resulted in
insufficient statistical power, to determine if the exercise induced rise in MDA was significant. Changes in MDA over time
did not differ either between or within groups (P > 0.05, ANOVA). Serum CK was elevated over time in both normal training
12 km
16 km
20 km
3.43 0.06
3.29 0.06
3.38 0.05
3.25 0.08
3.39 0.07
3.25 0.04
3.45 0.10
3.41 0.08
3.42 1.2
3.38 0.20
3.50 0.12
3.51 0.11
3.59 1.0
3.53 0.17
3.60 0.12
3.63 0.40
and taper groups (P < 0.01, ANOVA), however there was a greater rise in serum CK in the normal training group than the training taper group (P < 0.05, ANOVA). Resting CK was elevated in
the normal training group, rising from 90 32 IU l1 at baseline to 106 23 IU l1 immediately prior to the second halfmarathon (P = 0.2037). In the training taper group baseline CK
was 115 24 IU l1 and decreased to 108 24 IU l1 prior to
the second half marathon. In the normal training group CK
was higher than in the taper group over the time course of
the study and at the end of the second half-marathon (Fig. 5).
This reflected both a higher resting CK prior to the second halfmarathon (P = 0.2240) and a greater relative rise during exercise (P = 0.2144). When expressed relative to CK activity immediately before exercise CK rose by 80 24 IU l1 in the normal
training group and only 53 19 IU l1. The greater relative rise
in CK in the normal training group (74 20 %) relative to the
taper group, where CK rose by 49 11 % was not significant
(P = 0.2141). These changes in CK suggest that the higher activity observed in the normal training, group reflected both the
higher resting CK prior to the second half-marathon and the
greater relative rise during exercise.
Discussion
There is accumulating evidence that a training taper can improve performance in a variety of sports [22, 23, 33], but the
biochemical mechanisms which produce this effect have received little attention. Free radical and mechanically induced
skeletal muscle damage occurs during distance running
[2, 29], which may impair muscle performance [6, 8,10]. A
training taper could improve skeletal muscle function by allowing training induced myocellular injuries and antioxidant
deficits to recover, prior to exercise. Such a transient reduction
in training volume is unlikely to compromise the activities of
enzymes important for glutathione metabolism in locomotory
muscles [41]. Despite the potential benefits of reducing training loads, the effects of this intervention on indices of muscle
damage, lipid peroxidation and antioxidant protection have
not been investigated.
In the present investigation treadmill time trials were chosen
to assess distance running performance, as in previous training
taper studies [22, 42]. This exercise model has the advantage of
closely simulating a competitive race situation by allowing self
pacing through the given distance, yet minimises variability in
environmental and psychological factors which may confound
measurements made during actual competition. The halfmarathon runs were performed at a pace which exceeded the
average running speed during training, furthermore for most
subjects, completion of each half-marathon involved perform-
328
Fig. 4 MDA in normal and training taper groups. A (baseline, immediately before run 1); B (immediately after run 1); C (immediately before run 2); D (immediately after run 2).
Fig. 3 Serum TAC in normal and training taper groups. A (baseline, immediately before run 1); B (immediately after run 1); C (immediately before run 2); D (immediately after run 2). * P < 0.025
relative to pre-exercise.
329
Child RB et al
7
Acknowledgements
The authors gratefully acknowledge the support of the runners
who participated in this project and critical input from Mr. J.D.
Chance.
References
1
Byrnes WC, Clarkson PM, White JS, Hsieh SS, Frykman PN,
Maughan RJ. Delayed onset muscle soreness following repeated
bouts of downhill running. J Appl Physiol 1985; 59: 710 715
8
Child RB, Brown SJ, Day SH, Donnelly AE. Functional and biochemical changes in indices of muscle damage, lipid peroxidation
and lysosomal enzyme release, following eccentric exercise in
humans. J Physiol 1998; 509.P: 46P 47P
9
Child RB, Brown SJ, Day SH, Donnelly AE, Roper H, Saxton JM.
Changes in indices of antioxidant status, lipid peroxidation and
inflammation in human skeletal muscle after eccentric muscle
actions. Clin Sci 1999; 96: 105 115
10
Child RB, Brown SJ, Day SH, Saxton JM, Donnelly AE. Manipulation of knee extensor force using percutaneous electrical myostimulation during eccentric actions: Effects on indices of muscle
damage in humans. Int J Sports Med 1998; 19: 468 473
11
Corbucci GG, Montanari G, Cooper MB, Jones DA, Edwards RHT.
The effect of exertion on mitochondrial oxidative capacity and
on some antioxidant mechanisms in muscle from marathon runners. Int J Sports Med 1984; 5: 135
12
Davies KJA, Quintanilha AT, Brooks GA, Packer L. Free radicals and
tissue damage produced by exercise. Biochem Biophys Res Com
1982; 107: 1198 1205
13
Dill DB, Costill DL. Calculation of percentage changes in volumes
of blood, plasma and red cells in dehydration. J Appl Physiol 1974;
37: 247 248
14
Duthie GG, Robertson JD, Maughan RJ, Morrice PC. Blood antioxidant status and erythrocyte lipid peroxidation following distance
running. Arch Biochem Biophys 1990; 282: 73 83
15
Faulkner JA, Brooks S, Opiteck J. Injury to skeletal muscle fibers
during contractions: Conditions of occurrence and prevention.
Physical Therapy 1993; 73: 911 921
16
Fry RW, Morton AR, Keast D. Periodisation of training stress: A review. Can J Spt Sci 1992; 17: 234 240
17
Gauduel Y, Menasche P, Duvelleroy M. Enzyme release and mitochondrial activity in reoxygenated cardiac muscle. Relationship
with oxygen induced lipid peroxidation. Gen Physiol Biophys
1989; 8: 327 340
18
Gleeson M, Robertson JD, Maughan RJ. Influence of exercise on
ascorbic acid status in man. Clin Sci 1987; 73: 501 505
19
Gohil K, Rothfuss L, Lang J, Packer L. Effect of exercise training on
tissue vitamin E and ubiquinone content. J Appl Physiol 1987; 63:
1638 1641
20
Hikida RS, Staron RS, Hagerman FC, Sherman WM, Costill DL.
Muscle fiber necrosis associated with human marathon runners.
J Neurol Sci 1983; 59: 185 203
21
Hooper SL, Makinnon LT. Monitoring overtraining in athletes.
Sports Med 1995; 20: 321 327
22
Houmard JA, Scott BK, Justice CL, Chenier TC. The effects of taper
on performance in distance runners. Med Sci Sports Exerc 1994;
26: 624 631
23
Houmard JA. Impact of reduced training on performance in endurance athletes. Sports Med 1991; 12: 380 393
24
Jackson MJ, Edwards RHT, Symons MCR. Electron spin resonance
studies of intact mammalian skeletal muscle. Biochem Biophys
Acta 1985; 847: 185 190
25
Ji L. Gatorade Sports Science Exchange. Roundtable. Exercise nutrition and free radicals: Whats the connection? 1994; 15: Vol 5:
380 393
26
Ji LL. Exercise and oxidative stress: Role of cellular antioxidant
systems 1995. Exerc Sport Sci Rev 1995; 23: 135 166
27
Kanter MM, Lesmes GR, Kaminsky LA, La Ham-Saeger J, Nequin
ND. Serum creatine kinase and lactate dehydrogenase changes
following an eighty kilometer race. Eur J Appl Physiol 1988; 57:
60 63
330
331
Corresponding Author:
Robert B. Child, Ph.D.
Exercise Physiology Research Group
University College Chichester
College Lane
Chichester
West Sussex, PO19 4PE
UK
Phone:
Fax:
E-mail:
+ 44 (1243) 816-387
+ 44 (1243) 816-080
rchild@chihe.ac.uk
28