Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Veena Das
possible
well
given
or
Beyond
Boundaries
Bioethics
these
the baby was
and Amoxycillin
diarrhea, Ampicillin for
medicines, probably
doctor. In
remedies made by
a medicine
what kind
doctor, I
he prescribed for his patients. In addition to the plant
he said,
paracetamol
antibiotics
they
name of three antibiotics for
were more effective. He knew
fever: Septron, Ampicillin,
Amoxycillin.
diarrhea he pre
scribed
Getamycin or Metrogyl.
there does not
much
between the medicines
by
doctor who runs a private
in the
The first
In an
U<'-I..H,-,H"_"
was gIven on
was given
for a
when they thought that
resistance to
she was
microbial
one ear,
was taken
was correctly
parents could
meanwhile)
six years. A
hospital, which were
the disease had developed
because
the fact that
was not aware
recelvmg
It would be
cases as simply the results of
inadequate
Delhi
Association has been demanding
legislature should
pass the Quackery Bill, which would make the
of
124
VeenaDas
III
broadly
Discussion in anthropology on
how to reorient
in relation to new objects of inquiry, since
the
distinction between so-called
and
societies has collapsed, cannot be oblivious to the profound
in the definition of what constitutes hu
manity and what constitutes nature. Bioethics is faced with a
should it
as a branch of the
of bio
in the West, which gives it coherence and allows it to
function in the shadow of the law within
such
their meaning, or
as
disclosure, and truth-telling
should it address
larger
to the tensions
and the symbiosis between health as a public
and health
as a private
a recent
Gisli Palsson and Paul Rabinow see the
problem
anthropology as that
itself in
prevI
face
a nature very
from that
ous generations. "For one
" they
"biotechnology
revolutionized the capacity
altering DNA material, raising
new and fundamental 'anthropological' questions. Although
argued for a
the human
body and nature are inextricably
... it is a cliche today
to
that a new
to modify them is with us
they
are increasingly commodified and subject to market exchange. "65
They locate this tension
the ethics
politics of representa
especially through
discussion of controversies sur
rounding the project to map
of the Icelandic people
by DeCode
a biotechnology company. A powerful
of this work
in the idea
to
I-'HUUHF.,
Issues
is another
in which nature is being modified: through
kind of biomedical practices that are leading to the
antimicrobial resistance.
modifications are not
eled on social norms, nor are they well understood. They are
of human actions and uncon
the unintended
trolled exchanges of
occurring in nature.
too hold the ominous potential of
the
new and unpredictable ways. In light of this,
fieldwork must
up to
the
126
VeenaDas