Professional Documents
Culture Documents
k ZlmInJ
op9q^r:qtsvu?w%xzya{uTx2|Sq'}~}~uTw%qRx:|tC9|y%x9y%yBEsZ%p:u?x9qts|y>qRe{YyB|%sX.sO|pEa|aqr::}~}qREqR|eu?|euT%q%pEaR
ar:yBEsR%y%|pEa|qt%:u?qsX%u~}}%se|qRx9wB|p%y%r:q'9|qReuT|eOEqR%y%xEr|Sp9qRaEa:u~}uT|eZya{dp:9axEsuYs|p9q:}T|XuTa|q
w%y2G}yC{yBEy%|euRsZSqtseqtaSpzEa:}?qtsya{ZseEp#|'%se9sOuTxES}TEr:qCx2:{%'|9eu?x9wEJq'ERtaa|euTyBxg'y%xEsX|E'
|euTyBx%9xEr:qRseqt.sXE%'q%9axEr:}ax9qR|aq'9:}Ty%C|euTy%xa|yF:uY%se|SqS}Tqtax:99axEry%>y%|euY%ssvuYsX|qtrse9wBqR%
y%>y%|euYRsqtseqta'p)usp:uTw%p:}?^u?x2|qR'rBuYsSuT:}~u?xEa^Sqt%:uTXuTx9w|p9qhuTx2|SqRw%a|eu?y%x^ya{'y%x:|yC}|p9qRy%)uT|SpqR
SpEax:uYRsR9q'}?qt'|y%x:uYRs.C|eu~\SuYG}EuTx:|q'}~}~u?w%qRxE'q%9axErseqRxEsey%|qtp9x9yC}Ty%w%%
op9q|qRy%>y%|pE%sEqRqRxC9:}~uTqtr|yuYr:qZaaeuTqR|eya{qtSpEax:uYRF}r:qR%u'qtsR>{YSy%Sp:u~}Yr:SqRxs|ya.s|y
w%:uYr:qtruYssvu~}?qtsRxuThEy%|'ax2|S}YBssya{dy%>y%|sCq|Sp9qax:uT9:}YC|y%as.sXEp^%s|p9qZyBEy%|
sep9yaxOuTx0uTw%9q%Jop9qtseqax:uT9:}a|y%saqEseqtr9eu?aeu~}?uTxC|qReuYF}s4pEaxErB}~uTx9w>tq'}YrBuTx9w>%%sseqR:}T%
se9FEFuTx:|euTx9wE>w%euTxErBu?x9wEr:qR99euTx9w>axEr)y%|p9qRax2:{%'|9XuTx9wmC9:}~uYRa|eu?y%xEsRZop:usa|euYS}?qIrBuYs'EsSseqts
|p9qyB|euTy%x'y%x:|ya}ya{seESp^ax:u?9:}Ya|y%'sR
0uTw%9qB9yBEy%|)ax:u?9:}Ya|y%
y%>y%|ax:uT9:}YC|y%sCqE%svuYRG}~}TI:}?|eu~.r:qRw%SqRq'2ya{?%{YSqRqtr:y%Ey2svu?|euTy%x:uTx9wr:qR%uY'qtsop9qOy%EyB|tE%s|p9q
:}YCx2||SyEq)'y%x2|Sya}~}Tqtr9uYs):}T|eu~%u?x999|Rt:}T|eu~:yG9|S99|tp:uTw%p:}T#'y%9:}Tqtr4x9y%x:}~uTx9qtahqtpEC|y%x:uY
se9se|qR^Oop9qFu?xSpEF}~}TqRx9w%qtsu?x|Sp9qIhy%|euTy%x)'y%x:|ya}J9y%:}TqRCq|p9q'y%:}Tq':uT|eya{g|Sp9qr:2xECuYRsR
axEr9xE'qR|'FuTx:|euTqtsREyB|pECaqR|XuYaxEr#r::xEauYaJCaqR|XuY9xE'qR|GuTx2|XuTqtsZaXuYseqh{YyBuT9SqtSuYseq
:x9yG}Tqtr:w%qZyC{|p9q%uTx9qRa|euYRsCxErr::xEauRsR4p:u~}Tqr:2xECuY9xE'qRS|FuTx:|euTqtsaeuYsXq{y%eyauTx:|CxEr}uTx9
q':uT:u~}~uT|e%9%'|EC|y%r:2xECuYRsRB{euY'|euTyBx.sXqRxEsey%x9yauseq%9axEr9x9:x9yaxqRx2BuTyBx9qRx2|r:2xEauYRsR
op9qRqpEF%qEqRqRxx29EqRyC{gq'E'q'}~}TqRx:|Zse9%qR^aS|euYS}Tqtsy%x)|p9q'y%x:|ya}Jya{gSy%Ey%|ax:u?9:}Ya|y%'s{y%
axq'}TqRqRx:|ah%uTqREyauTx:|9 :
Jop9qtseqZaS|euYS}Tqts9qtseqRx:|g|Sp9qE%svuYuYr:qt%sya{4uTxEr:qR>qRxEr:qRx2|
yCuTx2|'y%x:|ya}
EsvuTx9wO}~u?x9qtaeuTRqtrhy.r:q'}YsaxErS}Y%ssvuRF}\|'axEsv{qRJ{9xE'|euTy%xaxEF}T9svuYsdopEa|a|qRXuYF}Eu~}}\x9y%|EqqREqta|Sqtr
p9qRq%v xEse|qt%rgqu~}~}Ese9%qRyBqqt'qRx:|gaxErh%r:GaxE'qtrha|SqReuYF}9|pEa|se9haeuTRqts|p9qy%Oya{\ax2
qtseqtCp9qR's>{YSy%a>y%9|g |y|p9q9qtseqRx:|td)ax:ya{E|p9quYr:qt%s09qtseqRx:|qtrp9qRqgaSq{Yy%9xEruTxZ|Sp9qEa>qRs
qR9eu?x2|qtrmuTx^|Sp9qI'ya}~}?qt'|euTy%x 9p:uYSpusqt'yBqRxEr:qtr|y|p9qqtBr:qRp9yuYsXp9qts%r9rBu?|euTy%xEF}dr:qR|Gu~}YsR
op9q9SqtseqRx2|C|euYS}TquYsJ%R'qtssuT:}Tq|yZax:%y%x9qpEF%u?x9waxhq'}TqRqRx:|a:x9ya}Tqtr:w%qya{ aw%Cx9wauYaxr:2xEauYRs
axEr|Sp9qse|'a|qseE%'q|p9qRy%ya{dr::xEauYRG}\se.sX|qRsRCuTxES}TErBuTx9wO|p9qE%svuRsJya{4 2C99x9yGse|'a:u~}~uT|eO|p9qRy%%
op9q|q'9|Ey:y%9s~ %9 F>q'y%xEse:}T|Sqtr{y%J|p9qE%S:w%y%9xErOx9qt'qtssC|y{ya}~}?yG|p9qa|SqReuYF}29SqtseqRx2|Sqtr
p9qRq%
V us|Syr:qR|qRu?x9q|p9qZC9:uTx9w
7q 1s_sudd}v vp qQsud}v \ i <csu\v
s v
{y% y%x:Ew%9a|XuTy%x4% E%'q|yo%seU% E%'qp:uYSpwauT%qts|p9qqRxErB:qS@ qt'|Sy%Z>y2seqhuTx|SqRsOya{|p9qyau?x2|
'y%x:Ew%9'a|euTy%xop9qO{YyBarBuTx9qRC|euYRsuYsr:qR|qRuTx9qtr2|p9q9p29svuYRF}w%qRy%qR|Sya{|p9qy%>y%|top9q
q2
q3
q4
q5
q1
q6
BASE FRAME
0uTwB9qy%x:Ew%9'a|euTy%x%E%'qaxErodBse^%EB'qaeua:}Tqts
TASK FRAME
%s{9xE'|euTyBxya{|p9qqRxErB:qS@qt'|Sy%Ey2seq%op9q{y%a'r%u?x9qRa|euYRsahuYsJax2B2|yC2y%x9q%%hqtax:uTx9w|pEa|
seqR%qR'F9} ayauTx:
| %E%'q'yBx:Ew%9a|eu?y%xEstOwauT%qeuseq|y|Sp9qsaqqRxErB2Sq qt'|yBJEy2seq%op:uYsqtaxEs|SpEa|J|p9q
{y%ar%uTx9qRa|euYRsF}TF.spE%s9x:u%9q>y2seqO{y%qt%Sp 'yBx:Ew%9a|eu?y%xEp:u~}TqZ|Sp9qZu?x2%qR'seq%uTx9qRa|euYRs
pE%s:}T|XuT:}Tqseya}T9|eu?y%xEsRBuTxw%qRx9qRG}
op9qJBuTx9qRa|XuYRs49y%:}?qR uYs'y%hEy%9xEr:qtr2|p9qgrBu m':}T|eya{9EaahqR|euT'uTx9w|p9qJSy%|a|eu?y%xw%yB9 Xsu\v'
|uYsq'}~}~2:x9yax)|pEa||p9qRSqr:y2qtsx9y%|Zq':uYse|ZuTx:uTF}sXqR|Zya{'y2y%'rBuTxEa|qts|y 'ya%qR < su\v>u q%~
svuTx9wC}TqmsXqR|IyC{|p9qRqaaeuYa:}?qtsZ|SySqR9qtseqRx:|G}~}y%euTqRx:|a|eu?y%xEsuT?
x < su\v9x:uY%9q'}?%op9qy:se|I'y%hy%x
qR9qtsXqRx2|C|euTy%xEsEseqtraqJ:}TqRax9wa}?qtsaxErBEa|qRSx:uTy%xEsRqR9qtsXqRx2|C|euTy%xEF}gsuTx9w%:}YaXuT|euTqtsR4p:uYpaq
EyCuTx2|'sa|p:uYp |p9q)qR9SqtseqRx2|'a|euTy%x{Fu~}Ysh|yEq9x:u%9q%wauTBq^euYsXq|Syzx:9EqR^yC{'y%99|'a|euTy%xEG}
rBu m':}?|euTqtsuTxy%|XuTy%x:}Yax9x:uTx9wCxEr^'y%x:|ya}e
u?%qRxu?x:uTF}dSqR9qtseqRx:|a|euTyBx{y%p Xsuv9{y%q'C:}Tq%seqR|ya{gJ:}?qRZax9wa}Tqts of \f
9|p9qO{y%ar
BuTx9qRa|euRsa9:uTx9wFF}Ysey>qIr:q'Ex9qtr:O{Y9xE'|XuTy%x
q
su\v
qsud}vd
p9qRq s_dvuYs )
C|eu~2RF}}Tqtr|p9qmW}>PC R9aADWOYL}]3WZhL\MCNW>E9axEr w q s w f w vqR9SqtseqRx2|'s|p9q
}~uTx9qtCaxEr^Cx9w%:}Ya%q'}Ty9SuT|eya{|Sp9qZqRxErB2qS qt'|y%Fgop9qBqt'|y% x r
uYsoeEse|!#! " 1sud}v9axEr uYsr:q'Ex9qtr
:|p9qq'99qtssuTy%x
q / s vuXf?xXsuvhf Ux su\vSf
s+ 3v
p9qRq su\vuYsO|p9q^>uTq}Tw%qR9'^yC{ )se%qR.sX2hqR|euYa|euY'qtsx#yB|p9qRgyBr9sRJ|p9q^Cx9w%:}Ya
%q'}Ty9SuT|eya{J|p9qqRxErB2qS qt'|yBt s v BuYs|p9q9x:uYB9qZBqt'|y%r:q'Ex9qtr2|p9qq'99qtssvuTyBx s gvu7wos v
auTx9w%:}aeuT|eu?qts>uTx|p9qj% %'y%:uax sud}v Rue q%~a'y%x:Ew%9a|XuTy%xEs0p9qRq|p9qj%B'y%:uYax}Ty2seqtsCx9\%aSqJuT>y%|Cx2|
'y%x:Ew%9'a|euTy%xEs|SyuYr:qRx:|eu~{{y%Zax:^ax:uT9:}Ya|Sy%sR|svu?x9w%:}YaZ'y%x:EwB9a|euTyBxEs|p9qhax:uT9:}YC|y%}Ty2seqts
y%x9qy%y%qr:qRw%qRqtsv2yC{T%{qRqtr:y%v xax:a9:}~uYRa|XuTy%xEsRCuT|JuYsuT>y%|ax:||SyZ:}Y%'qy%>y%|suTxy%2'q'}~}s
axEr|yh:}Yax|p9q'uTy%|euTyBxuTx^sXEp^F|pEC|svuTx9w%:}a'y%x:Ew%9a|XuTy%xEsaqZF%yaur:qtr4
{Z|Sp9qa9:uTx9we usEseqtr|y qR9qtseqRx:||Sp9q^{y%a'rBuTx9qRa|XuYRsR|p9qRx|p9q^%q'}?y.SuT|e%u?x9qRa|euYRsIuYs
eu?||qRx%s
eq esud}vd
su\v
p9qRq es_dvXq 9e 1dmuYsO|p9q %%'y%:uYCxya{|p9qh{Y9xE'|XuTy%x ea4auTx9wB:}YaeuT|XuTqtsuTxehu?xES}TEr:q|p9q
qR9qtsXqRx2|C|euTy%xEF}svu?x9w%:}Yaeu?|euTqtsuTx Br9rBuT|euTy%x|y|p9qax:u?9:}Ya|y%svuTx9w%:}YCeuT|euTqtsO9qtsXqRx2|u?x %x |p9q
seqtB9q'}dqu~}~}Eseq |Syr:qRx9y%|qq'uT|Sp9qR|p9qZa|eu~ O
y%ae
SENSORS
MOTION
SENSORS
PLANNER
TRAJECTORY
CONTROLLER
ROBOT
ENVIRONMENT
PLANNER
0uTwB9qp9}Ty.SuYaw%Cya{J|p9qIy%Ey%|y%x:|ya}Jy%:}?qR
op9qr:2xEauYRsyC{"%}~u?x9ax:uT9:}YC|y%saq'y%x:%qRx:uTqRx:|e}Tr:qts'euT>qtr^:^awBax9wauYCxmr::xEauYRsx)|p9q
awBax9wauYCx C99y2%Sp4|p9q eyauTx:|GaXuYa:}TqtsR dqtsudMefttFg fhdSiGv w dseqRBq%sse:uT|'a:}TqseqR|ZyC{gw%qRx9qRG}~uTRqtr
'y:y%rBuTxEa|SqtsRzop9
q pCE>)TIOYCNZ^>PT] | ya{Z|Sp9qax:uT9:}YC|y%OuYswau?%qRx#2z se2hqR|euYaEy:svuT|euTBq^r:q'Ex:uT|q
BE%r:a|eu{y%^
i
q
sud}v dS k d 7q d w s_dv d
k
k
1e
p9qRq sud}vEus|p9q h>PT]hOYCNW WOY]SC yC{E|p9qy%EyB|t4qR|
s\v
>qrBubqRqRx:|euYa:}?qJ{9xE'|euTy%xcsRF}~}Tqtr|p9q
$L}OYTI>POYCNWA)TI>PT]Y| vdy%geuTwaurZSy%Ey%|F%|p9q>y%|qRx:|euYF}EqRx9qRSw%uYsr:9q|ywBF%uT|eOp:u~}Tq{y%g q'2uT:}?qyBEy%|
|p9qEyB|qRx2|XuYF}dqRx9qRwB^u~}}F}Ysey'y%x:|FuTxq'}Y%se|XuY>y%|qRx:|euYF}dqRx9qRSw%%
= qr:q'Ex9q|p9qO{Y9xE'|XuTy%x q n
p:uYSpuYsRF}~}Tqtr|p9qWI|}]_W>|}CEW>>op9qRx|p9qr::xEauRsJya{|p9qax:uT9:}Ya|Sy%aqr:qtsS'euTEqtr: aw%'ax9w%q%s
qtBEa|euTy%xEs
!
s'&v
d n 1d q#" \f%$rq ftFt_fh
p9qRq(M" eftFtgf)"SiqR9SqtseqRx2|uTx999|w%qRx9qR'F}~uTRqtrm{Yy%''qtsRjvx^}?y.RF}'y:y%rBuTxEa|SqtsCw%ax9w%q% sqt%EC|euTy%xEsRax
EqOeuT|S|qRxmBs
su\v
p9qRq
su\v
0q 1!d
sIy\v
xa|Xu~{y%qZRaxeuT|Sqpaw%Cx9w%q%sqt%EC|euTy%xEssu\v%s
sud}v d * ,sud\f d} v d ,1sud}v#
q "
s%v
&}.j2P&(*2P8r 6 /2
7'9#&'1/#*'9
//'1?*+038
op9q awBax9wauYCx^r:2xEauYRsRs %v Ey2ssXqtsshx:9I>qRya{uTEyB|ax:|9y%>qR|euTqts|pEa|{%Su~}~uT|'a|qaxEF}T9svuYs
axEr'y%x:|yC}0sX.se|SqR r:qtsvuTw%xyBx9w|p9qtseqZaSq%
Bop9quTx9qR|XuYC|eu~
s_dv'.sXEp|pEC|
sud}v0uYsse:qR|SeuYaxErhEy2svu?|euT%qr:q'Ex:uT|q%9axErh|p9qRqq':uYse|gsSRF}Yases_dvJaxEr
esud}v sud}vsud}v
sI\v
i
k
1e 1 d k Sd kgf
sI\v
yBqRya%qRtau{F}}eyauTx:|saqSqR%ya}T9|q|p9qRxeCxEr CqZ'y%xEse|Cx2|s
^
op9qZC|eu~s_df d vjq sud}v<nUsud\f d vuYsse%qR se:qR|XuYaop:us9 yBEqR|euYsqt%svu~}?msep9yax2
rBuTqt'|ZRF}Y':}a|euTy%xu?x^}?y.RF}g'y:y%rBu?xEa|qtsRZop9q $B2|Sp'y%>y%x9qRx:|Zya{ sud}vuYswauT%qRx):^|p9qSpEFuTx
:}TqZ%s
q
sud\f d vJuYswauT%qRx%s
axEr|p9q$B2|p^'y%hEy%x9qRx:|ya{J|p9qa|Seu~
i
i 2 k k1
sM 3v
! 3 7q k
1e . k1' dS koq k
9e 1 d k , 9 d n 1 d 4 dS k
op9qRq'{y%q|p9q$B.'y%hEy%x9qRx:|ya{|Sp9qa|eu s_df d vJuswauT%qRx:
" q i $n !
q k
9e # 1 dSk n $ 1 dSk , 1 d k n 1 d k1& %(' dS k
i
q k
9e # 9 d k1 n 1 d k ' dS k
% %qR se:qR|S)ya{);sud\f d
v x9ya {ya}~}Tyas:se:qR|SyC{|Sp9quTx9qRS|euYa|eu~ s_dv'%|y%x9wC}T
q'}Ya|qtrh|y|Sp9qZse%qRse:qR|S9y%>qR|eus|p9qZseya9RF}~}Tqtr4)$WHhHMCE`CEO $]_LSRT]hOa
op9qa9:uTx9w " d uYsE%ssvu?%q%:u q%|p9qRSqq'2uYsX|s+*, y sXEp|pEa|
- w d w /s .v ")/s .v . , +n *
sI\v
0 q d w sud}v d ,s_dv
s \v
op9qRx|p9qISpEax9w%qu?xqRx9qRw%% 0 9sa|eusvEqts
0 q d w sud}v d , d w s sud}v+d * ,1sud}vgv
s &v
sI\v
n/vx2|SqRw%a|eu?x9wI>y%|p^svur:qtsya{sI\vJuT|SpqtsXEqt'||y|euThqwau?%qtsR
- w d w s/.v ")s/.v .cq 0s v
n 0suy\v , 1n 0suy\vhf
sI\v
svuTxE'q|p9q|yB|F}qRx9qRw% 0s vuYsx9y%x::x9qRw2a|euTBq%.CxErE%ssvuTBuT|e{ya}~}TyasuT|p *q 0s_y\v
>uTwauYryBEy%|Oax:uT9:}YC|y%saSq{Y:}}T%'|SEa|qtr44ue q%~|Sp9qRquYsOax)uTxEr:qR>qRxEr:qRx2|'y%x:|ya}Ju?x999|Z{y%
qt%p^r:qRwBqRq'2ya{?%{qRqtr:y%^ m'y%x:|Bse|t:y%>y%|s>y2sseqtssuTx9weyauTx:|y%}~u?x9 q':uT:u~}~u?|aqx9yh}Ty%x9w%qR
{Y:}~}?%'|Ea|SqtraxEr|p9qI'yBx2|Sya}9y%:}TqRsaSqy%qZrBu':}T|tBuTxw%qRx9qRG}
op9qqt%EC|euTy%xEsyC{yB|euTy%xs %v aSq}~uTx9qtau?x|p9quTx9qRS|euYOi EaahqR|qRsRv x^y%|Sp9qRy%r9sR:|p9qRqus
'y%xEse|ax:|%qt'|y% c
x IaxErO{9xE'|euTy%x csud\f d} f d* v/x seESp^|SpEa|
s_dv /d * , s_df d v d , 9sud}voq s_df d f d* v #
q "
suy\v
op9q{Y9xE'|XuTy%x rsud\f d} f d* v uYsRF}~}Tqtr|Sp9q Tu|}]uT HhHML'] dop9qEaCqR|qRBqt'|y% uYs'yB9euYseqtrya{}~uTx9BsseqtsR
2se%qRsX2hqR|ya{
y%hqRx2|sya{JuTx9qRS|euY9ECxEr|p9qO}~uTBq%:uTx)GaXuTy%Es'y%:uTxEa|euTyBxEsRop9qIrBu?qRxEsvuTy%x)ya{|Sp9qZEaCqR|qRseE%'q
uYshx9y%|9x:uY%9qaxEr|p9qseqtCp {YyB|p9qEaahqR|euTta|XuTy%x#|pEa|uTx:u?uTRqts|p9qrBuThqRxEsvuTy%xya{Z|p9q)Ea
ahqR|qRIseEB'quYsOax uTEyB|ax:|9y%:}TqR
use|y%euRF}~}T%4|p9qa9>qtaaxE'qya{|p9qE%ssuT%u?|)axEr }~uTx9qta
EaCqR|euTtC|euTy%xO9y%EqRS|euTqtsu?x|p9qqtae}TI y9 sa%qtrC|qRsep9qtrqRBqRx2|suTxyBEy%|euRsqtseqtaSpJsuTx9w
|p9qtseqO9y%>qR|euTqtsSqtseqtaSp9qRsqRqZa:}?qZ|y9ya%qq'}TqRw:ax2|wa}Ty%EF}d'y%x:%qRwBqRxE'qIaxErse|'a:u~}~uT|eSqtse:}T|s{y%
y%9EsX|axEr%r9a9|XuT%qZ'y%x:|ya}e =qu}~}dr:qR|Fu~}sXy%qya{|Sp9qtseqZqtsX:}T|sEq'}TyaZ
%y{at:qpEF%qr:qR|'Fu~}Tqtry%x:}?euTwaur>y.r:^r::xEauYRs |Sp9qRuThEy%|'ax2|'y%x:|euT99|eu?y%xEs|y|p9qZr:2xECuY
r:qts'eu?9|euTy%xya{ECx:uT9:}Ya|yBs4u?xES}TEr:q|p9qr::xEauYRsya{4|p9q%'|Ea|Sy%sR yCuTx2|JaxErO}uTx9 q'2u?:u~}~uT|e%F{euY'|euTyBx
x9yauYsXq%2axErrBuYse|S9EaxE'qtsRo x%r9rBuT|XuTy%xap9qRx9qR%qR|p9qCx:uT9:}Ya|yBuYs0u?x'yBx2|B'|JuT|p|p9qqRx:BuTy%x9qRx:|t
|p9q'y%:}?qR|qr:2xEauYr:qts'XuT9|euTy%xOuTxES}?Er:qts|p9qr:2xEauYRsya{E|p9qqRx:%uTSy%x9qRx:|axErO|p9q'y%9:}~uTx9w{YyB'qts
EqR|eqRqRxZ|Sp9qqRx:%uTSy%x9qRx:|daxEr|p9qax:uT9:}YC|y%ty9r:q'}~uTx9wF}}CyC{.|p9qtsXqqS qt'|s09y.r:E'qtsaxOqRx9y%y%Es}T
'y%:}uYRa|qtry.r:q'}eop9qgBqRuTxy%>y%|J'y%x2|Sya}Ese.sX|qR r:qtsuTw%xOuYs|yy9r:q'}E|p9qy2se|Jr:y%uTxECx2|Jr:2xECuY
qS qt'|s{y%|p9qEa|XuY':}Yaax:uT9:}YC|y%9xEr:qR'y%xEsvur:qRa|euTyBxmaxEr|Syr:qtsuTw%x|p9qZ'y%x:|yC}~}TqRgsXyI|SpEa|uT|uYs
uTxEseqRxEsuT|euT%qy%Sy%9Ese||y|p9qOx9qRwa}Tqt'|qtrr::xEauRsR
9XuY'|euTy%xzCxEreyauTx:|q'}YBse|euYSuT|e#aq)r:y%uTxEax:|uTx w%qtCqtr#Cx:uT9:}Ya|yBsseESp
%s|Sp9y2seq^qtB:uT9>qtr uT|p
pEahy%x:uYr:euT%qts'|SEa|y%Zr::xEauYRsCqOuTEyB|ax:|u?xax2ax:uT9:}a|y%s9p:u~}Tqx9yauseqOuYs9qtseqRx:|
&
uTx>y%|qRx:|euTy%hqR|qRsZCxEr|Bp9y%hqR|qRsEseqtr#%syCuTx2|>y2svuT|XuTy%xaxEr %q'}Ty9SuT|esXqRxEsey%sR9y%O%qR)}TyBx9wy%
%qR}uTw%p:|q'uTwBp2|y%>y%|sREC|euY':}YCe}T)uTx
seEB'q^y%>y%|sR|Sp9q^}uTx9 q'2u?:u~}~uT|eEqt'y%qtsCx#uT>y%|Cx2|
'y%xEsvur:qRa|euTyBxzop9qC|euYS}Tq: qm4ER |y){ya}~}TyarBuYs'Esseqtsh|p9q)r:2xEauYRsaxEr'y%x2|Sya}ya{ q':uT:}Tq
y%>y%|sR
su\v
&
sRaxEqZsXqRqRx9|p9quTxES}TEsuTy%xya{d|p9qZ%'|SEa|y%uTx9qR|XuY%sCxErh{Yeu'|euTy%xr:y2qtsx9y%|pEax9wBq|p9qy%r:qRyC{d|p9q
qtBEa|euTy%xEsy%svuT:}~uSuT|e^ya{x9yB|a|euTyBxqu~}~}uTw%x9y%Sq|p9qh{euY'|euTyBx|qR
s sud\f d vuTx|p9qse9EseqtB9qRx2|
r:qR%q'}TyB9qRx2|F
()+*,-./+
012
p9qRx9qR%qR|p9q^yBEy%|usOuTxz'y%x:|%'|uT|p#|p9qqRx2BuTy%x9hqRx2|t%r9rBuT|XuTy%xEF}{y%'qtsaSq9y.r:E'qtr:#|p9q
y%>y%|RtqRx:BuTy%x9qRx:|uTx2|SqR%'|euTyBx4qR|435Zr:qRx9y%|Sq|p9q{y%'qB'|euTx9wy%x|Sp9qy%>y%|Zr:9q|y)'y%x2|'%'|uT|p
|p9qqRx2BuTyBx9qRx2|F^
v|ZusZqtBse|y)sep9ya EsuTx9w^|p9q^euTxESuT:}?qya{ uT|EG$} =y%S
|pEC| yCuTx2|O|y%B9q
"5q9ws_dv63,5qtse:}?|sR%p9qRq s_dvuYs|p9qax:u?9:}Ya|y%/ B%'y%:uYaxop2Es|p9qqtBEa|euTy%xEs su\vJaq{Y9S|p9qR
y9rBu~Eqtr^Bs
su\v
&
op9q9yB:}TqRya{{y%'q'y%x2|Sya}4uYsx9y%|'y%xEsvuYr:qRSqtrh{Y9|Sp9qRu?x|p:uYsa|euS}Tq%%99|uYs|qtC|qtrhuTxr:qR|Fu~}>uTx|p9q
a|XuYS}Tq2
q2p:9||qR|pEa|{ya}~}Tyas
98
:<;=
->%2
l , loq n>@<A d f
su 3v
|p9qR|:Eqtsya{@B'|Ea|y%'sRGsXEpBsuTxEr:E'|eu?y%xy%|y%'sRaFuTx:|y9r:E'qy%q'y%h:}~uYRa|qtrr::xEauYRsaxEr
uTxE'qtBseq|p9qZse9se|qR+yBr:qR{9|p9qRt
+
'(
+2
%
C;
ayau?x2|q'}Y%se|XuYSuT|e%\r:9q|yq'}%se|euYSu?|huTx)|p9qy%|Sy%sXpEF{Y|axErw%qta'sR>uYsaxuTEyB|ax:|qSqt'||yy9r:q'}JuTx
ax:y%>y%|sRo {\|p9qoeyauTx:|saqq'}YBse|euYaF|p9qRx|p9qx:9EqRJya{\r:qRw%SqRqtsv2ya{?%{qRqtr:y% ya{9uYs0|euY'q|p9qx:9I>qR
{y%|p9qeuTwCuYrOy%EyB|gsvuTxE'q|p9qeyauTx:|gCx9wa}TqtsCxEryB|y%sepEF{|gCx9wa}TqtsCqx9yO}Ty%x9w%qRsvuT:}?Zq'}YC|qtr:|p9q
w%qtaC|euTyEB99|aqx9yazu?xEr:qREqRxEr:qRx:|w%qRx9qR'F}~uTRqtr'y2yBrBuTxEa|qts {qqR9SqtseqRx2||p9qeyauTx:|gCx9wa}Tqts2KdMe
axErh|p9qy%|y%sepEF{|gax9wC}Tqts2(d axErhy9r:q'}@|Sp9q/eyauTx:|q'}YBse|euYSuT|eO2}uTx9qtagsX9euTx9w2sa||p9q/eyauTx:|sRB|p9qRx
qFeu?|q|p9qZr::xEauYRsBs
sudMe +v dM* e ,sudMe}f dM e v dM e , 1sudMeMv , @sudMe
n(d v q y
su &v
(d * , @su(d
ndMev q "
su\v
p9qRquYsh|p9q%'|SEa|y%u?x9qR|euY)a|eu~zaxEr @ uYsrBuYCw%y%xEF}a|Seu~#ya{jyCuTx2|se|eub x9qtss'yBxEse|ax:|sR
|OuYsqt%se|Sysep9ya|pEa|O|p9q q':uT:}TqeyauTx:|Zy9r:q'}su &v Psu}\
v r:q'Ex9qtsEBssvuT%qha9:uTx9w{y%hy%|y%
|y%'%9q "h|yOy%|y%%q'}Ty9SuT|e (d a:99|r:y2qtsx9y%|r:q'Ex9qZE%sSsvuT%qa9:uTx9w{YSy% "h|yZ|Sp9q}~u?x9IBq'}Ty.Su?| dM ae
op:uYsuYsq'}Ya|Sqtr|y|p9qIS}%ssvuYRG}d9y%:}TqRyC{g'ya}~}Ty9Ra|euTyBxya{gsXqRxEsey%saxEr%'|Ea|Sy%saxErpE%suT>y%|Cx2|
'y%xEseqtB9qRxE'qtsuTx^|p9qZ'yBx2|Sya}dse.sX|qR+r:qtsvuTw%x
x
5/2 +8
{y%svuT:}uYSuT|eaxErXuT|qqt%Ea|XuTy%xE7
s su}\vP su \vd%s
|qtSp9x:uYB9qtsaq|p:Esya{Jw%qtC|gaF}T9quTx^r:qtsvuTw%x:u?x9waxEraxEF}?2'uTx9w'y%x:|yC}\}tsJ{y%ax:uT9:}Ya|Sy%sR
x}~uTw%p:|ya{|p9qZ'y%h:}Tq'2u?|ya{J|p9qIr::xEauRsya{/E?}uTx9y%>y%|sRBuT|us%:u?|qZqRaGC:}Tq|yrBuYsS'yGBqR|pEa|
su\v
&
su 3v
qR9qtseqRx:|sJ'y%xEse|ax:|q'{YqRSqRxE'qseqR|>yauTx:|tGCxE4
r @ axEr
a
q
E
2
y
s
T
u
e
|
T
u
%
%
q
B
r
Y
u
a
%
w
B
y
E
x
F
|
X
Y
u
'
t
q
s
a
y
{
9
%
y
>
%
y
e
|
T
u
B
y
E
x
F
g
}
a
E
x
r
:
r
R
q
e
T
u
G
e
|
T
u
%
q
:
w
F
T
u
E
x
R
s
%
y
E
x
s
Y
u
:
r
R
q
Z
|
9
p
K
q
4
2C99x9yG
!
{9xE'|euTy%x^RaxErBur9a|q
q d w &;sud}v d/ , sud ! nd}v w @ sud ! nd}v
@
q
n dw @ ! d y
'y%>qRxEsa|eu?y%xBu q%~
su\v
9yaBuYr:qtrO|p9q-2w2GuTxEsdCqp9y2sXqRxse:uT|C:}T%tp:uYpsvuT:}~uEqts|p9qy%x:}uTx9q'y%99|a|XuTy%xEF}9qtB:uTqRqRx:|sR
op9qtseq}a||qRqtse:}T|sqtB:uTq|p9qZ%r9rBuT|eu?y%xya{'Sy2ssv2|SqRsJ|SyZ|p9p
q 4:a99x9ya{Y9xE'|XuTy%x) su\v'auTxy%r:qR|y
sep9ya%sX29|Sy%|euYsX|a:u~}~u?|%
x#9'%'|euY'q%p9yagqRBqRt|p9quTx999K| su 3vy%r su\vu~}}gqtse:}?|Zu?xuTx999|sa|S9a|euTyBxEqtRaEsXq^ya{|Sp9q}Yaw%q
w2Fu?xEs|pEa|aSqEseEF}~}?qtB:uTqtraxEr|Sp9q}Yaw%quTx:uT|euYG}|%S%u?x9w^qRyBt x9qya{|Sp9q9eu?a)qt%sXy%xEs
{y%| qt'|yB^w%qRx9qR'a|euTy%xsXEp#%s|CEqRRyauYr9G}%q'}Ty9SuT|e^9ya9}?qtsR4uTx |p9qEse|O:}Y%'qus|pEa|F4qR%qRx{y%
EyCuTx2|X2|ya2>yauTx:|yBEy%|s29Sy%EqRsRF}~u?x9wIyC{|p9qZC:}~u~EqRu?x999|suYsqtB:uTqtr4
Iy
qR%qR|p9q'}TqtsSsR%|p9qtsXqsvu?:}Tq
axEr" qtse:}T|s9ya%ur:qtssey%hq|p9qRy%qR|XuYRF}eEse|eu~\Ra|XuTy%xO{YyB|p9quYr:q'
se9qtBrEseqZya{JseEp)'y%x:|ya}~}?qRsuTx^'yBqRSuYG}\u?xEr:Ese|euYG}\ax:u?9:}Ya|y%'sRox{%'|t:uT|uYsx9y%||y2yrBu':}T|
|ysep9ya |Sp9qsCqqtse:}?|{y% q':uT:}T
q eyauTx:|Jy%EyB|u?x|p9qaEseqRxEseqya{w%'tBuT|eZ9SyGBuYr:qtrh|p9q- .'y%x:|yC}
uYsuT:}TqRqRx:|qtrhEsvuTx9w|p9qy%|yBJGaeua:}TqtsRJop:uYsuYsEqtRaEsXq|p9q q':uT:}T
q eyauTx:|y%>y%|gr::xEauRsgr:q'Ex9qts
E%sSsvuT%qa9:uTx9w{YyB+y%|yBg|Sy%B9
q "|y|p9qZyB|y%Bq'}Ty.Su?|
d( a
//'1?*+038
=qEse|9qtseqRx:|g|Sp9qFuTxuYr:qt%suTxayCuTx2|%E%'qp9qRq|p9qRaquYsqt%svuTqtse|J|SyZ9xEr:qRse|'axEr4op9q'y%x:|ya}
aSp:uT|qt'|S9qqEsequYsuTEyB|ax:|g%sOE%svusJ{y%F}~}4}Ya|qRr:qR%q'}Ty%9hqRx2|sop2EsR:wau?%qRx|Sp9q:}Yax:|y9r:q'}
su \v
&
qZ'y%99|q|Sp9qZx9y%x:}~u?x9qta{YqRqtr:E%S^'y%x:|ya}4}YF
"q
%9Ese|eu?|9|euTx9wrsuvdu?x2|yrsu}\vaxEr^r:q'Ex:uTx9w
dqQd7nUd !
s+ y\v
qpEF%q|p9q}~uTx9qtCCxEr^r:qt'y%9:}TqtrS}Ty2seqtrh}?y2y%^sX.se|SqR
d* ,
dqQy
s+ Ev
=qRaxOuT:}?qRqRx2||p9qyau?x2|JseE%'quTx:%qRseqr:2xECuYRs@uTxseyC.RF}~}TqtrcCE>)>PT]/ADLILSR9La\OYTI]jADLILRIaSp:uT|qt'|9q
%ssep9yaxu?xm0uTwB9qs+ 3'v op9q'y%h99|a|euTyBxya{|p9qx9y%x:}~uTx9qta|qRsuTxsu &}dv aqEqRe{y%qtruTx|p9quTx9x9qR
@
!d ,
LINEARIZED SYSTEM
qd
TRAJECTORY
PLANNER
OUTER LOOP
aq
CONTROLLER
INNER LOOP
tau
q
ROBOT
CONTROLLER
ax:uTx:uTF}qR9SqtseqRx2|'a|euTy%xya{<
su\v"auTxE'qp
uYsO{9xE'|euTy%xyC{d|p9qjeyauTx:|GaXuYa:}TqtsdXxr)gqpEF%q
q osud}v d
s+ \v
* q osud}v+d * , o sud}v d
s+ \v
p9qRq q
e uYs|p9qr%%'y%:uYCxr:q'Ex9qtr)u?x%qt'|XuTy%xz%9 uT%qRx|Sp9qr:yB9:}TquTx:|qRw%C|y%tsu\v'>uTxayau?x2|
% E%'qOgqZsXqRq|pEa|u~{= uYsSp9y2seqRx)%s
q e ?n d
s+ 3v
|p9qRxgqpEF%qZr:y%9:}?quTx:|qRw%C|y%hy.r:q'}u?x^od%sX^% E%'qZ'y:y%rBu?xEa|qts
* q
s+ \v
u?%qRx^o%seK% E%'qO|qt'|yB ! s gv qFSp9y2y:seq0 %s
q * ! , @ s+ !nU0
v , @ ! s !n v
s+ \v
sey|SpEa||p9qg C|qtsvuYCxmseEB'q|%S%u?x9wIqRSy%t q n ! EsC|euYsvEqts
* , @ ! , @ qQy
s+ &v
o p9qRq'{y%q%9Oy9rBu~\Ra|eu?y%xyC{d|p9qy%9|qR}Ty:y%m'yBx2|Sya}@%Sp:uTqR%qts}~uTx9qtCCxErr:qt'y%9:}?qtr^se9se|qR+rBuTqt'|X}T
uTx|Sp9q|%seseEB'q'y2yBrBuTxEa|qts%uT|Sp9y%9|J|p9qx9qRqtr|yZ'yB99|qeyauTx:|J|eqt'|y%SZaxEruT|p9y%9|J|p9qx9qRqtr
|yhy.rBu~{|p9qOx9y%x:}~uTx9qtCu?x9x9qR}Ty:y%'y%x:|ya}
y%|q|pEa|qpEF%qEseqtrOuTx:uTG}EqR9qtseqRx:|a|eu?y%x{y%|p9qy%eu?qRx2|C|euTy%xya{d|Sp9qqRxErB2Sq qt'|yBJuTxy%r:qR|y
se>qtSu~{Y)|S eqt'|y%r
x 7
x)w%qRx9qRF}e>u~{|p9qqRxErB2Sq qt'|y%'y2yBrBuTxEa|qtsaqOwauT%qRxuT
x <csu\v'9|p9qRx
|p9p
q %B'y%:uYax )uTx|Sp9qZaEya%q{y%:}Ya|XuTy%xu}~}EqZ|Sp9p
q %%'y%:uYCx Zr:q'Ex9qtru?
x %qt'|euTy%x%" x|p:uYsR%seq
q
q q o sud}v d
s+ \v
axEr|p9qOy%9|qR}Ty:y%^'y%x:|ya}
e sud}v $<
n s_dvd %
s+ \v
a9:}~u?qtr|yKsuvSqtse:}T|suTx|p9qZsX.se|SqR
* q x
q x
suy\v
su9 v
q /s v_XfQxXsu\vSfjx su\v
su\v
}T|p9y%9w%pCuTx|p:uYsJR%sXq%%|p9qr::xEauRsJpEF%qx9y%|J>qRqRx}uTx9qtaeuTRqtrO|yZOr:y%9:}Tqu?x2|qRwBa|y%Ft|p9qy%9|qR}Ty:y%
|qRs ZCxEr Fse|eu~}}@>qZEseqtr|Sy%Sp:uTqR%qwa}Ty%EF}|'%BuTx9wya{JqRxErB2qSqt'|y%|Seqt'|y%eu?qtsuTxs_\v
x>y%|pR%seqtsqsXqRq|pEa|x9yBx:.svuTx9w%:}aeuT|eZyC{d|p9q% %'y%:uYCxuYsx9qt'qtssSa|yOuTh:}TqRqRx:||p9qy%9|SqRJ}Ty:y%
'y%x:|ya}e
7*+
2P'1&* ')(*+ *+K(
2P& &5/*/')(24, /8(2)?8
op9quTx:%qRsXqZr:2xEauYRs'y%x:|ya}da99Sy2%SppE%sEqRqRx)9y%>y2seqtrhuTx^x:9EqRyC{rBubqRqRx:|w%:uYseqtsEseESp^%s
$T HL}A`Th7ZhZSTIADTI]_WOYCNL>~/L>)OY]uL}AGaxE
r oRT]_WOYCEL}>PWA\}RWZSTX~/L>)OY]uL}A op9qtseqseqRqRuTx9wC}TrBuYse|euTxE'|C99y2%Sp9qts
pEF%qIG}~}dEqRqRxsep9yax|yEqZqtB:uTaF}TqRx:|axErFEqOuTxE'y%SEy%C|qtruTx:|y|Sp9qZw%qRx9qRG}d{aqRy%Ssep9yax
a>yGBX
q sseqRX
q shYv'
=qseqRq|pEa|J|p9q{YqRqtr:EB}uTx9qtaeuTtC|euTy%xya{4{:}~}T%'|Ea|SqtreuTwaury%>y%|sJBuYuTx2BqRseqr::xEauYRsuYsBR'y%
:}~uYsXp9qtr^:^x9yBx:}~uTx9qta{YqRqtr:EB)F}Ty%x9quT|Sp9y%9||p9qx9qRqtr{y%'y2y%'rBuTxEa|qO|axEsv{y%a|euTy%xop9qFuTx
rBu m':}?| uTxuT:}TqRhqRx2|eu?x9w|Sp:uYssp9qRhquYsO|p9q{%'||pEC|I|Sp9q^r:2xEauYEaahqR|qRsOEse|Eq:x9yax
9qtSuYsXq'}TaxEr)|p9q{:}~j
} aw%Cx9wauYax)r:2xEauYy9r:q'}gEse|OEqRF}':}Ya|qtru?xqtF}~:|euTq%op:usuTEy:seqts
9%'|XuYRF}.axEr'y%h99|a|euTyBxEF}2qtse|SFuTx:|s4y%xO|p9qqR|p9y9r4o =qu~}~}.rBus'Ess0F9s|Syr:qtF}9uT|SpZEaCqR|euY
9xE'qR|GuTx2|eu?x|p9qZx9q'9|seqt'|eu?y%x
||9SxEsyB9|g|SpEa||p9q'y%99|'a|euTy%xEG}E99r:qRxFEqqtr:E'qtrhuTxsey%hqR%sXqts:seqRqRBuTx9wy%|p9qR'y2yBrBuT
xEa|qtsguTx^p:up|yqR9qtsXqRx2||Sp9qIr::xEauYRsR
%99Ey:seq|pEa||p9qOy%>y%|uTx9qR|XuYa|Seu~FEqO{%'|y%qtr
%s
Rax>qIsep9yax|yhqtr:E'qZ|y
w sud}v * q .
su\v
.rq w sud}v7
su \v
op:EsIr:yB9:}TquTx:|qRw%a|Sy%Jy9r:q'}\u?x|qRSsya{ uYs%Sp:uTqR%qtrh2h|p9qEpsvuT:}?qRJuTx9x9qR}?y2y%h{qRqtr:E%
'y%x:|ya}4}YF
o p9q>yauTx:|uYs|pEa|F>uTx)|p9qx9qR 'y:y%rBu?xEa|qtsR4|p9q'y%99|a|XuTy%x^yC{g|p9qKy%euTya}uYsaxEr'qRx:|eu{Y9w2G}|qRs
uTx|Sp9quTx9x9qR}Ty:y%)uYsOtByauYr:qtr4yaqR%qRt09x:}~uT%qh|p9quTx:%qRseqr:2xEauYRsZ'y%x:|yC}jsu &vp:uYSpq'2use|s{y%
ax:ax:uT9:}Ya|Sy%t2x9qt'qtssaaxErse SuTqRx2|'y%xErBuT|euTyBx{y%|p9q{%'|yBeuTta|eu?y%r
x su\vJ|yq':uYse|uYs|pEa||p9q
uTqRax9x:uYax^'9aa|9qOya{d|p9qOqR|eur:q'Ex9qtr:|p9qSy%Ey%|uTx9qR|euYOC|eu~>qRqRyEop:uYs'y%xErBuT|XuTy%xhuYs
B:uT|qqtse|SeuY'|euTBq%%99|RaxEqOEseqtr^%sE%svuYsg{Yy% RR9]_L CEVXWOYTcThTS WZMF5CE>)ThW}]hC
W}OYCEL>>Bu q%~B{qRqtr:E%
}~uTx9qtCeuTta|eu?y%xE%seqtry%x^svuTh:}~u~Eqtry9r:q'}YsR
{qRqtr:E%49yB|p9qse.sX|qRuT|p%'|SEa|y%r:2xECuYRssuvPsu v|p9q'y:y%rBuTxEC|qtsu?xp:uYSp)|p9qse.sX|qR
F>qZq'E%'|e}Th}~uTx9qtaXuTRqtraqwauT%qRx:
e q d
q d
e
q d* q& sud}vgs6@ml)ns_df d v d7 n1sud}vgv
e
q
q
q
p9qRq0us|p9qx9qR y%9|qR}Ty:y%'y%x:|ya}|y>qIr:qtsvu?w%x9qtr4
op9qZ'y:y%rBuTxEC|qtsuTxp:up|p9q q':uT:}TqyCuTx2|se9se|qR su &vPsu}\vdEqZq'E%'|e}?}~uTx9qtaXuTRqtraqwau?%qRx:
x
e q Md e
q de
q dM* e7 q n &
q
de q
e
q
q
q
q
p9qRq0us|p9qx9qR y%9|qR}Ty:y%'y%x:|ya}4{y%|p:uYsse9se|qR
?.j8 *(2U(&}
I
q "Xn dM* ef
su &v
su\v
&
op9qZBE%svu~9se|qt%r:se|a|SquYs|p2EsguYr:qRx2|XuYRF}|y|p9qZXuTwauYrhy%>y%|y.r:q'}0uTx^|qRSsya{ dMea
op9q>y%9xEr9ah}YF%qRse9se|qR+qR9SqtseqRx2|'s|Sp9qZr:2xEauYRsya{ q n 9E'y%99|SqtrhuTx|p9q/6MWHOOYCNVXTHZSWADTt
q Rop:uYsse9se|qR RaxEqZsep9yax|SyEq
, s e , e v q#"
su\v
4
p9qRq " q#"Xn 4" ~/L}VjR3LHMCEOYTr~/L>)OY]_LAB{Yy%|p9q 'q 2u?:}TqyCuTx2|se.sX|qR^)su9v Psu\v'FuYs'y%x:|yC}\}t ya{
|p9q{y%
se9se|qR^Jop9qsvuTw%x:u\Rax2|{qta|9qtsya{|Sp:uYsa99y2%Sp^aq|SpEa|
Bop9q'y%x:|ya}\r:qtsuTw%xuYsE%seqtryBxqtr:E'qtrhy%r:qRse9se|qRsp:uYSpuYsw%qRx9qRG}~}Tqt%svuTqRJ|SpEaxr:qtsvuTwBx:uTx9w
'y%x:|ya}~}?qRJ{y%|p9q{:}~}y%r:qRsX.se|SqR^EaxEr
op9q%EBsvu~.se|Sqt%r:se|C|qse9se|qR uYs Ese|0|p9qJeuTwauryBEy%|hy.r:q'}.CxErZseyq':uYse|XuTx9w'y%x2|Sya}~}TqR's\r:qtsuTw%x9qtr
{Yy%eu?wauYrhy%EyB|sF>qZEseqtruT|p9y%9|y9rBu~\Ra|XuTy%x
FF}seyEqOEseqtr4EseESp^%s|Sp9qZy%9EsX|CxEr^%r9aEC|euT%q'y%x:|ya}~}?qRsr:qR|Gu~}TqtrhuTx|p9qx9q'9|seqt'|euTy%x
I>Ill
o p9q{qRqtr:E%}~uTx9qtaXuTta|euTyBxa99Sy2%SpIyC{E|p9q9qR%u?y%EsdsXqt'|euTy%xOq'.:}TyCuT|s@uTEyB|ax:|dse|SE'|9F}29Sy%EqR|XuTqts
ya{EyBEy%|Jr:2xECuYRsR yaqR%qRtF|p9q9%'|euRF}%uT:}?qRqRx2|'a|euTy%xya{\seESp'y%x:|ya}~}?qRs4qtB:uTqts'y%xEsvuYr:qR'a|euTy%x
x:9I>qRya{|qtSp9x:uYB9qts{YyB}~uTx9qtaaxErx9y%x9?}~uTx9qta'y%x:|ya}|p9qRy%pEF%qOEqRqRxa9:}~uTqtr|yh|p9q9y%9
}TqR ya{y%9Ese|{YqRqtr:E%S)}~u?x9qtaeuTta|XuTy%x{y%Oax:uT9:}YC|y%sp:uTq'{Cy%x9w|p9qtseqaqa}~uYrBuTx9w^y9r:qtsR
42C99x9yG4s"%qt'y%xErqR|p9y.r4aaxEr|p9qgqR|p9y9rya{%|'a:}Tqg>%'|y%XuTta|euTyBxEsR uT%qRxO|p9qgr::xEauYqt%EC|euTy%xEs
s\v
"q&
sud}v7 ,X sud\f d v d/ ,
s 3v
&
|p9qZ'y%x:|yC}\u?x999|uYsSp9y2seqRx)%s
d} sud}v
s\v
p9qRq
q& e $ &s d * ! ,
s \v
d , Gv, d , %
x)se|a|SqseEB'qZqFeu?|q|Sp9qIse9se|qR s v Bs
r q 7 , $ $
5, %
! d ,
s &v
s\v
p9qRq
rq dd q # n @y
n
@
!
# y
;
q
'
'
s\v
)suf gv,?y99y%x|p9qZ9xE'qRS|FuTx:|e
o p9qa99y2%Spusx9ya
|yseqtaSp{YyB|XuTq'2aaBuTx9wsRF}YaEy%9xEr4
u q%
s'& y\v
&
k+vq
Z
,
n
u~{
u~{
k y
s'& \v
k y
x F}T|SqRxEa|euTBq99|msuTu~}YCIa99y:%pus|p9q^sey%RG}~}Tqtr|p9qRy%Sya{w%Ea'ax2|SqRqtr#se|a:u~}uT|eyC{9xE'qR|'FuTx
se9se|qRsE%seqtr y%x42a99x9ya4sZseqt'yBxEr)qR|p9y9r4KauTxE'q<@ axEr>@ ! aSqSp9y2seqRx uTx4svsey|pEa| uYs
9uT|Za|eu~:{y%ax2 y|Sp9qRqq'2uYsX|sh9x:uYB9qse2hqR|euY
ysSa|euYsv{BuTx9w|p9q42C99x9yG
qtBEa|euTy%x
w
,
q n
s'& \v
y
n
)
u
s
f
g
u~{ $w qQ
v
q
s'&I 3v
y
u~{ $w qQy
op9qX42a99x9ya{9xE'|euTy%x -q w Rax>qEseqtr|ysep9ya
|pEa| uYsx9qRw2a|XuT%qr:q'Ex:uT|qIG}Ty%x9wseyC}T9|euTy%x
|qt'|Sy%euTqtsya{|Sp9qZse.sX|qR s v
xEy%|Sp|p9qZsv}~uYrBu?x9wy9r:qZa99y2%Sp^axEr|p9qOw%EaCx2|qRqtrse|C:u~}~uT|ea99y2Bp99Sy%:}TqRsaeuseqZsep9yauTx9w
|p9qq':uYse|qRxE'qyC{seya}T9|XuTy%xEsO|y)|p9qS}Ty2seqtr }Ty:y%#rBub qRqRx:|euYF}qt%Ea|XuTy%xEsOEqtRaEsXq^|p9q^'y%x:|yC}svuTwBxEF}
uYsrBus'y%x:|euTx:9y%EsOuTx#|p9q)se|a|Sq^ xz9'%'|euY'q^pEC||qReuTx9w'y%x:|yC}suTw%xEF}Sqtse:}T|sr:9q|yx9y%x::RqRy
es u?|p:u?x9w^r:q'}YF.sRop9qRqpEF%q>qRqRxCx2)q'Ex9qRqRx:|sOaxEr)q'9|qRxEsvuTy%xEs|y|p9qCEya%qa99Sy2%Sp9qts|y
y%9EsX|{YqRqtr:E%S}~uTx9qtaXuTta|euTyBx9FuTx:}?|y^svuT:}u~{Y|Sp9q'y%99|C|euTy%xya{g|p9q9xE'qR|'FuTx:|Ey%9xEr9sOaxEr
|ysXy2yB|p|Sp9qZpEa|S|qReuTx9wOuTx|p9qZ'y%x:|ya}dsvuTwBxEF}
op9qqR|Sp9y.ryaX
{ %|a:}?qm>%'|y%eu?ta|euTy%xEspE%sF}sey)EqRqRx C9:}~uTqtr|y)|p9qyB9Ese|{qRqtr:E% }~uTx9qtCeuTta|eu?y%x
9y%:}?qR x |p:uYsa99Sy2%Sp }uTx9qtatr::xEauY)'y%>qRxEsa|yB
s vhuYsEseqtr |y#w%qRx9qRa|Sq |y
se|C:u~}~uTRqO|p9qEqRS|9Eqtrse9se|qR^c
auTxE'q uYs
9u?|a|eu@>|p9
q Jy%:}F2EaCqR|euTtC|euTy%xF^>q
Eseqtr|yw%qRx9qR'a|qZ|Sp9qIqRx:|euTSqIS}Y%sSsR >ya{se|'a:u~}~uT'u?x9w'y%>qRxEsa|y%'s{y%|p9q9x9EqR|9SEqtrse.sX|qR^u q%~
qtBEa|euTy%?
x s \vuT|p q y9 uT%qRxEyB9xEr9sy%x#|p9q9xE'qR|GuTx2|e%|p9
q %F}} Fu?x op9qRyBqRusZEsXqtr
|yw%qRx9qRa|SqIse mSuTqRx:|'yBxErBuT|euTy%x{YyBse|'a:u~}~uT|eyC{|p9qZ>qR|9>qtrse9se|qR^4axEr|Sp9qr:qtsuTw%x^9Sy%:}TqR uYs
|yr:qR|qRuTx9qmEaS|euY':}Ya'y%hEqRxEsa|Sy%t s v'J{y% |p9q^S}Y%ssOya{se|a:u~}uT'uTx9w^'y%>qRxEsa|yB
s |pEa|
I
s a|XuYsvEqts|p:uYsse mSuTqRx:|Z'y%xErBuT|eu?y%xop9qOuTx2|SqRqtse|euTx9w{Yqta|S9qya{|p:uYs9yB:}TqR+us|pEC||p9qZ>qR|9Ea|XuTy%x
|qRsa9>qtaeuTx9wu?x s \vaqEx:uT|quTx |p9q>? x9y%S 99|tx9y%|x9qt'qtsSsaeu~}?uTx |p9q>?'x9y% sXqRxEseq%
op:uYshqtaxEs|pEC|Ise|CxEr9ar 0 r:qtsvuTwBxqR|p9y9r9s{Fu~}J{y%|p:uYs9Sy%:}TqR^9y%|p:usqt%sXy%x4|p9qyB9Ese|
ax:u?9:}Ya|y%'y%x:|ya}9y%:}?qR %suTx 9qRx:|euYG}gu?x#|p9q^r:qR%q'}Ty%9hqRx2|ya{|p9
q ?/e'y%9|eu?F}'y%x:|ya}Eq'}Yr4
99S|p9qRr:qR|Fu}Ysy%x|p9qtseqOGaeu?y%Esy%9|qR}Ty:y%^r:qtsvu?w%xEsFEq{y%9xEruT
x Iv
q d * ! ,
! s d !
n d v ,
@
sud ! nd}vhf
s'& \v
uT|RaxEqIsXp9yGx.G{Y|qRsey%qZF}?w%qR99B|pEa|
d* ,
!d ,
dq e s_df d f d* v
s'& \v
r q 7 ,
p9qRq
$
7>EaxEr
us|Sp9qqtse|XuTa|qya{d|p9qEaahqR|qR%qt'|y%
s'& &v
rq dd q # n @y
# y
e
;
q
s'& \v
n@!'
' q sud\f d} f d* v
uT|Sp.@ axEr@ ! p9y2sXqRxsey|pEa| uYs 9uT|Sa|eu@7%99>y2seq|pEa|ae x^yB9|99|{9xE'|euTyBx q
uYsr:q'Ex9qtrm{YyBs'& &vuTx^sXEp^F|pEC||p9q|CxEsv{YqR{9xE'|euTy%xs n v $ us7% |euY'|X}Ty2svu?|euT%qqtF}
sg27vo|RaxEq^sep9yaxEsvuTx9w)|p9qJ%ssuT%u?|)op9qRy%qR |pEC|t0{Yy% t9y J|p9qRSqq':uYse|sX2hqR|euYa
Ey:svuT|euTBqr:q'Ex:uT|SqZa|Seu~ sC|euYsv{%u?x9w
w , q n
's & \v
$ q w
suy\v
{J|p9qOEaaqR|SqRg94r9a|q}YFzusp9y:seqRx^%s
q n e w
su9 v
.
p9qRq q w y E|p9qRx wa}Ty%EF}J'y%x2BqRw%qRxE'q|yRqRyya{|Sp9qI|S%S%uTx9wqRyBu?|pF}}duTx:|qRxEG}svu?w%xEF}Ys
qRGuTx:. uTx9wE. y%9xEr:qtr)Rax>qIsep9yaxEsuTx9w|p9qp4 :a99x9ya{9xE'|euTy%x
su\v
qQ w (
, w .
I
9 9S|p9qRy%Sq%|p9qqtse|euTa|qtr EaaqR|SqRs'y%x:%qRw%q|Sy|p9q^|S9qEaahqR|qRs9yaBuYr:qtr#|Sp9qq'{YqRSqRxE'q
|qt'|Sy%sa|eusvEqts|p9qZ'y%xErBu?|euTy%xya{JqRsvuYse|SqRxE'ya{ESuT|C|euTy%x
q d ! n d
q
q d * !jn d
! q d !n
q d , d
uT|Sp @ rBuaw%y%xEF}C|euY'qtsya{JEy2suT|euT%qw2Fu?xEsRx|qRsya{|Sp9q}~uTx9qtaECaqR|XuTta|euTyBxya{J|p9qZyBEy%|
r::xEauYRsR|p9qZ'y%x:|ya}su Gv>qt'y%qts
"q s_df d f )f v j >
n @ !
su\v
axEr|p9q'y%:uTxEa|eu?y%xyC{/su 3Jv u?|ps \Jv BuTq'}Yr9s
&sud}v ! ,sud\f d} v ! , @ ! q
y%|q^|SpEa|t9x:}~uTBq|p9quTx2BqRseq^r::xEauYRs'y%x:|ya}ps_ &v |p9qy9rBu~Eqtr uTx9x9qR}?y2y% 'y%x:|ya}ps \I
v r:y:qts
x9y%|%p:u?qR%qmm}~uTx9qtaFdr:qt'y%9:}Tqtr#sX.se|SqR^qR%qRx uTx|p9q:x9yaxECaqR|qRR%seq q : yaqR%qRt0|p9q
%r:aax2|'aw%q%Sp:uTqR%qtruYs|pEa||Sp9qqRw%qtsSsey% uTxUsu \v r:y2qtsx9y%|Z'y%x:|FuTx)|p9q%R'q'}TqRa|XuTy%x
d * x9yBuYs|p9q
uTx:%qRseqyC{d|p9qZqtsX|euTa|SqtruTx9qRS|euYOa|Xu~qtB:uTqtr4
981
+22*,
C;
+2 2
0/
1f
|p9qRx|p9q%r9rBuT|XuTy%xEF}2|SqR
. Rax>qr:qtsvuTw%x9qtrO|yw%Eaax:|qRqse|a:}Tq|%SBuTx9wBR'y%rBuTx9w|y|p9qq'99qtssvu?y%x
q M jn
.rq
su \v
u{
op9qp4:a99x9ya{Y9xE'|eu?y%x
q
w ! qQ y
w ! qQy
u{
w ;sud}v ! , d @ d
! &
su &v
.rq n
su\v
981
+22*,
C;
+2 1
* 01+
op9qEaaqR|SqRIqtsX|euTa|Sq )F>q'y%h99|qtr#Esvu?x9wse|axEr9CrqR|p9y9r9ssXEpz%sw%%rBuTqRx:|y%}Tqt%se|
sBEaqtsR9y%q'Ea:}Tq%9EsuTx9w|p9qw%'%rBuTqRx:|g94r9a|q}YF
n . e w us d\f d fCPf v !
|y%wBqR|p9qRuT|p|p9qp@ 2a99x9ya{9xE'|euTyBx
q ! w &;sud}v ! , d w @ /d , w
.
q
9
x:9EqRya{0uTEyB|ax:|q'Ex9qRhqRx2|s|yZ|p:usEBsvuYqtse:}T|aqEy:ssvuT:}Tq%
hEsvuTx9w|p9qq'{qRqRxE'q|qt'
|y%SuTxEse|qtBrya{|Sp9qqt%se9qtr yCuTx2|aaeuYa:}?qtsJu?xEy%|p|p9qZ'y%x:|ya}daxEr94r9a|q}YFsRBu q%~
"q
uT|Sp
q
w sud ! f d ! f d * ! v !
)
9 yBax:a9:}~uRa|euTy%xEsseEp%sEF}~}TqR|XuT'uTx9wE>|p9qRqus^rBuTqt'|Z'yBq'}Ya|XuTy%x^>qR|egqRqRx |p9qse>qRqtrya{|p9q
y%>y%|ax:uT9:}a|y%axEr'.S}?q|euTq%J9yBg|Sp9qtseqZa9:}~uYRC|euTy%xEsRBaBuTx9w|p9qy%>y%|y%{%se|qR|axEs}Ya|qts
rBuTqt'|X}TuTx:|yaxuTxE'qt%sXqZu?x9y9r:E'|euTBuT|e%X
auTxE'q|p9qOuTx999|O|y%B9qts|y|p9qyBEy%|aqO}~uTuT|qtr2|p9q
RaEa:u}~uT|eya{d|Sp9qI%'|EC|y%s%s
"
su\v
F}?y%x9w|p9qEa|p Z
{ |p9q
suy\v
p9qRqpsud}vJus|p9q{y%arh%u?x9qRa|euYRsC=qFF}YseyEseq|p9quTx:%qRseq%u?x9qRa|euYRsa|yeu?|q
op9qExEF}|euTq F>qIse>qtSu~Eqtr^Bs
q - "
q -
su\v
p:uYSpse9w%w%qtsX|s|pEa|tuTx)y%r:qR|SyuTx:uTu?RqZ|p9qOExEF}|eu?q%4|p9q%q'}Ty9SuT|e G}Ty%x9w|p9qEa|psep9y%:}Yr>q
F:uTu?Rqtr4 v||9SxEsyB9||pEa||p9qy%9|euTG}\seya}T9|eu?y%xuTx|Sp:uYsR%sXquYsEax9wa2ECx9wEBu q%~a|p9q%R'q'}TqR'a|euTy%x*
uYsq'u?|p9qRF2u?I9y%uTx:uT9x^F}TyBx9w|p9qZEC|pj au?xE'qZ|p9qO| eqt'|y%SuYsEa'aqR|eu?Rqtr2|p9qIsSRF}Ya
09pE%seq:}Yax9q|qtSp9x:uYB9qtsF>qEseqtr|y^RF}Y':}a|qZ|Sp9qF:uT9BR'q'}TqRa|eu?y%x * %sqsXpEF}~}seqRq%
9Sy% su9 vJqFm'yB99|q
d q s v
su\v
d* q s v * ,
su 3v
p9qRq uYs0|p9q% %'y%:uYCxZya{E|p9qa9:uTx9wsu9vop9qRq'{y%q%ay%xE'q|p9qyB9|euTF}9seya}T9|eu?y%x s vEusd'y%h99|qtr4
|p9qCEya%qq'99qtssvu?y%xEsZRax EqEseqtr|Syr:qR|qRuTx9q|p9qyB9|euTF}eyauTx:|ZseE%'qh|eqt'|y%S%K%9Ese|eu?|9|euTx9w
|p9qq'.9SqtssvuTy%xEs{y% ^
d axEr md * uTx:|y^|p9qax:uT9:}Ya|Sy%Zr:2xECuYRsRs \v 0}Tqt%r9sO|yseqR|ya{seqt'y%xEryBr:qR
qtBEa|euTy%xEsguTx|p9qZsRF}aaS}TqRx9w%|SpEaaqR|SqR
k s v * ,
k s v , ! k s vq#"3f l<qftFtgfS
u?%qRx^|p9q>y%9xEr9sy%x^|Sp9qeyauTx:|%'|Ea|yB|y%B9qts{YyB su}\vga>yGBq%E>y%9xEr9sy%x *
:mse9EsX|euT|9|eu?x9ws_\v uTx:|yrsu\v
" k kDi }ks v * , SkYs v , ! k+s v " k loq tf Ft_fh
p:uYSp^Rax>qZeu?||qRx%sseqR|ya{" .'yBxEse|Fu?x2|sy%x * %s
ks f v * *Pks f v
p9qRq
su\v
RaxEqr:qR|qRSuTx9qtr
su \v
su &v
k q s "
k n Sk n ! k v } k
*Pk q s "k n Sk n ! k+v k
uT|Sp
op:Es|p9q>y%9xEr9sy%x|p9qZsRG}Ya
s f v+ * *s f v
u~{
~u {
}k y
}k y
* aqr:qR|qRuTx9qtr%s
su\v
p9qRq
su\v
auTxE'q|p9q)seya}T9|XuTy%x)uYs2x9yax|y>qEax9wa2Eax9w>|p9qyB9|euTF}'y%x:|ya}uYsr:qR|qRuTx9qtr#:ExErBu?x9w|p9q
|euThqtsR:y%Ey:svuT|euTyBxEsR9a|p:uYSp * sXuT|Sp9qtsEqR|eqRqRx
* q *s f vh
f axEr
* q s f v
op9qtseqseuT|Sp:uTx9w|euTqtshFz>q){y%9xEr : 'y%xEse|SE'|euTx9wzseuT|Sp:uTx9w '9S%qtshuTx |p9q9pE%sXq:}ax9q
'y%SqtseEy%xErBu?x9wZ|y s f v
q *"s f v aeu?y%EsqR|p9y9r9s{y%g'yBxEse|E'|eu?x9w|p:uYssXuT|Sp:uTx9wZ'9%qaq{y%9xEr
uTx|p9qSq'{YqRqRxE'qts'y%x:|FuTx9qtrhu?x |e::uYRF}uTx:u?I9 |euTqseya}T9|XuTy%xhuYssep9yaxuTx^0u?w%9qsu\'v
inadmissible region where alpha > beta
switch point
switch point
switch point
auTxE'qCx2Sy%Ey%|XuYC9:}~uYRa|eu?y%xEsRdsXEpz%sO:uYSaxEr:}%'qyBEqRa|XuTy%xEsRJEGuTx2|XuTx9wEJaxErSuT':uT|Ey:ar
%ssXqRI:}?%auTx:%ya}TBqgSqREqR|euT|XuT%qyB|euTy%xEsuT|JuYsxEa|9G}E|yI'y%xEsuYr:qREsvuTx9wIr9C|w2C|p9qRqtruTx9qRBuTy%Es'9S}Tqts
|y|S|SyuT9ya%q|Sp9qEqRe{y%CxE'qZya{|p9qax:uT9:}Ya|Sy%uTxse9EsXqt%9qRx:|'9S}TqtsRop:uYsuYs|Sp9qZE%svuuYr:qt
ya{
$T RTIOYCNOYCN`IT~
L>POY]_LA:y%
ThW}]h>)CE>\|K~/L>)OY]_LA
y%xEsuYr:qR|p9qeuTwauryBEy%|hy.r:q'p} s_\vCxEr#se99Ey2sXq^y%x9quYsOwau?%qRxz)r:qtsvuTqtr y%9|99|| qt'|yB)y%xz
Ex:uT|qO|euTqu?x2|qRSGF} ! s gvhfSy 1O9p:uYSp^FqR9qtseqRx:|r
ayauTx:
| %E%'qo' eqt'|y%yBodBse^
%EB'q
o0 eqt'|y%%op9qISq'{YqRqRxE'q|' eqt'|y% ! sgvuYsEseqtruTx)qREqta|Sqtr^|SeuYF}Ysya{|Sp9qIax:uT9:}Ya|Sy%tE%sSse9uTx9w
q'uT|p9qRh|pEa||p9q| qt'|yB)uYshEqReu?y.rBuYa ! svq ! suyvsqR>qR|euT|euTB
q y%x:|ya+} v'Jy%|pEC||p9q^Sy%Ey%|uYs
q'uTx:u?|euYF}~u?Rqtr|y}~uTqy%x |p9qr:qtsvuTqtr| qt'|Sy%#a||p9q)EqRwau?x9x:uTx9w#ya{Zqt%Sp |euYFX
} su4qtCx:uTx9
w y%x:|ya+} v'
qRqtF{|qRqu~}~}Eseq|Sp9q|qR
4qtCx:uTx9Kw yBx2|Sya}|yqtax^q'u?|p9qRqREqR|eu?|euT%qy%7 4qtax:uTx9w y%x:|ya}
4qR| " s vEq|p9quTx999||y%B9qr:9eu?x9w|p9q $B2|p'9S}Tq%p:uYp)9y9r:E'qtsZCxy%9|99| }sgvSfhy Z
op9qOuTx999|RFy%9|99|EFuT
s " sgvhf s vgvgt>qse|yBqtr)axEr9|eu~}~uTRqtrmuTx)|p9(
q $ ,
'.sX|'9S}Tq%op9qOuTx:uT|euYG}
'y%x:|ya}4uTx999
| "SsgvgRCxEqICx2'y%x:|ya}4uTx999||SpEa|9y.r:E'qtsse|'a:}Tqy%9|99|F.sXEp)%s .'y%x:|ya}
op9p
q 4qtCx:uTx9
w y%x:|ya}49y%:}TqRus|yr:qR|qRu?x9qIOqt'9svu?%qZ'y%x:|ya}
r::xEauYRsx9qRqtrx9y%|>qZ:x9yGx^9euTy%Xu
%qR%qRG}0C99y2%Sp9qtspEtBq>qRqRx^Eseqtr|yw%qRx9qR'a|qIsX:uT|a:}Tq}TqtaSx:uTx9w}YF
ya{J|p9qy%9|99|qRy%t 2|e:Eq}TqtCx:uTx9w}YFuYsyBx9qya{|Sp9q{Yy%S
"
s vhf
axEr|y9ya%q'y%x2BqRw%qRxE'q
s'Iy9v
es y^RF}}TqtrEqtRaEseqh|p9q'y%qt'|eu?y%x^|qRS|y|p9qOuTx999||y%'%9qa|qt%Sp)uT|qRC|euTy%xuYs9Sy%Ey%S|euTy%xEF}|y|p9q
qRyB J 2|e:Eq}TqtaSx:uTx9wO}YFzusy%x9qya{{YyB
9yaBuYr:qtr|p9qRqq':uYse|>y2svuT|XuT%q'y%xEse|ax:|s
- w
, /, *
axEr *#seEp|SpEa|
s'Iy\v
In