You are on page 1of 7

4FTJO ** 0CJTQP Z UPQPHSBGB TVCVSCBOB

0DDJEFOUF
  $PNVOJDBDJPOFT

'SBODFTDB 3PNBOB 4

7&4$07* & 3*56"-* '6/&3"3*


26"%30 /03."5*70 & 3&"-5 "3$)&0-0(*$"

"GGSPOUBSF JM QSPCMFNB EFM SJUVBMF GVOFSBSJP  QFS JM QFSJPEP UBSEPBOUJDP FE BMUPNF
EJFWBMFDPNFQFSRVBMTJBTJBMUSBFQPDB TJHOJGJDBUFOUBSFEJDPNQSFOEFSFFEJEFDPEJGJDBSF
RVFM DPNQMFTTP EJ B[JPOJ  EFMMF RVBMJ OPJ BSDIFPMPHJ WFEJBNP J SJGMFTTJ NBUFSJBMJ  DIF DB
SBUUFSJ[[BOPVOPEFJSJUJEJQBTTBHHJPQJJNQPSUBOUJ-BNPSUFEJVOJOEJWJEVPEMVPHP
BEVOBTFSJFEJB[JPOJDIFIBOOPMPTDPQPEJTFHOBSFJMEJTUBDDPEFMEFGVOUPEBMMBDPNV
OJUEFJWJWJ EJQPSMPJOVOPTUBUVTEJiNBSHJOFw FEJSJBHHSFHBSMPBEVOBOVPWBDPNV
OJU  RVFMMB VMUSBUFSSFOB * SJUVBMJ DIF JM NPOEP UBSEPBOUJDP FSFEJUB EBMMB DVMUVSB SPNB
OB QSFWFEPOP USB MBMUSP MB OFDFTTJU EJ BDDFSUBSTJ EFM OPO SJUPSOP EFM EFGVOUP  EJ TDPO
HJVSBSF MB DPNNJTUJPOF USB NPOEP EFJ WJWJ F NPOEP EFJ NPSUJ  MB DVJ TFQBSB[JPOF WJFOF
DPOGFSNBUBEBMMFDFSJNPOJFGVOFCSJJOSJDPSSFO[FTQFDJGJDIF BOOJWFSTBSJFGFTUFJOPOPSF
EFJ NPSUJ 4F JOGBUUJ UBMJ DFSJNPOJF NBOUFOHPOP WJWB MB NFNPSJB EFM EFGVOUP  OF SJCB
EJTDPOP BM DPOUFNQP MBQQBSUFOFO[B BE VO NPOEP EJWFSTP  DPO VO DPNQMFTTP EJ TFHOJ
DIF OPO QPTTPOP FTTFSF NBJ DBTVBMJ  NB DIF TPOP WPMVUJ F DIF TQFTTP GBOOP QBSUF EFM
SJUP *O FU UBSEPBOUJDB  JO DPODPNJUBO[B DPO MB EJGGVTJPOF EFM $SJTUJBOFTJNP  D TUBUB
MBOFDFTTJUEJSJMFHHFSF SFJOUFSQSFUBSF BEFHVBSF SFJOWFOUBSFTFHOJFSJUJ-BMFUUVSBEFM
MF BUUFTUB[JPOJ NBUFSJBMJ EFJ SJUVBMJ GVOFSBSJ NPMUP EFWF  QFS JM NPOEP SPNBO[P  BE "O
OB .BSJB (JVOUFMMB  DIF B QBSUJSF EBMMP TDBWP EFMMB OFDSPQPMJ EJ $PSOVT IB FMBCPSBUP MF
QJPOFSJTUJDIF SJGMFTTJPOJ TVM DPOUSJCVUP EFMMBSDIFPMPHJB BMMB DPNQSFOTJPOF EFJ SJUJ F BMMB
MPSP JOUFSQSFUB[JPOF 0HHJ  MB SJDDB NFTTF EJ EBUJ B OPTUSB EJTQPTJ[JPOF  VOJUBNFOUF BMMB

-BSJDDIF[[BEFHMJTUVEJBDBSBUUFSFBOUSPQPMPHJDPTVRVFTUPBTQFUUPEFMQSPCMFNBGVOFSBSJPTUFSNJOBUB
4J DJUBOP  B TPMP UJUPMP EJ FTFNQJP  RVFJ UFTUJ SJUFOVUJ NBHHJPSNFOUF BGGJOJ BE VOB MFUUVSB BSDIFPMPHJDB EFM SJ
UVBMF GVOFSBSJP 3 )  1 .  $FMFCSBUJPOT PEG EFBUI 5IF BOUSPQPMPHZ PG NPSUVBSZ SJUVBM 
$BNCSJEHF  4 $  $ $  + - FE
 0O UIF NFBOJOH PG EFBUI  &TTBZT PO NPS
UVBSZ SJUVBMT BOE FTDIBUPMPHJDBM CFMJFGT  4UPDLIPMN  " '  3FTUJ EJ VNBOJU 7JUB TPDJBMF EFM DPSQP
EPQP MB NPSUF  3PNB#BSJ  4FQQVSF MPOUBOP QFS DSPOPMPHJB  TQVOUJ JOUFSFTTBOUJ TJ USPWBOP JO .5 -
%  +' 4 FE
 /DSPQPMFT FU QPVWPJS *EPMPHJFT  QSBUJRVFT FU JOUFSQSUBUJPO "DUFT EV $PMMPRVF
5IPSJFT EFM MB ODSPQPMF BOUJRVF  -ZPO   KBOWJFS   -ZPO  / - FE
 1FSGPSNJOH %FBUI
4PDJBM BOBMZTFT PG GVOFSBSZ USBEJUJPOT JO UIF BODJFOU /FBS FBTU BOE NFEJUFSSBOFBO  $IJDBHP  "MUSFUUBOUP
JOUFSFTTBOUF  QFS DPNQBSB[JPOJ JO BMUSP BNCJUP ) 8  %FBUI BOE .FNPSZ JO &BSMZ .FEJFWBM #SJUBJO 
$BNCSJEHF1FSVOBOBMJTJDPNQBSBUJWBGSBEJWFSTFSFMJHJPOJBOUJDIF+% %FBUI #VSJBMBOE3FCJSUI
JO UIF 3FMJPHJPOT PG "OUJRVJUZ  -POEPO/FX :PSL 
 .PMUP SFDFOUJ TPOP JM WPMVNF EJ 7 . )  %FBUI JO "ODJFOU 3PNF  -POEPO/FX :PSL  F MB UFTJ
EJ 1 4 $  "QQSPBDIJOH EFBUI JO UIF DMBTTJDBM USBEJUJPO QFS JM 1I% QSFTTP M6OJWFSTJUZ PG 4U "OESFXT 
JO 4DP[JB  EJTDVTTB OFM OPWFNCSF   DPO BNQJB CJCMJPHSBGJB
 4J SJNBOEB BJ DMBTTJDJ TUVEJ EJ 1 "  &TTBJT TVS MIJTUPJSF EF MB NPSU FO 0DDJEFOUF EV .PZFO HF 
OPT KPVST  1BSJT  *  -IPNNF EFWBOU MB NPSU  1BSJT 

 " . (  $PSOVT   -BSFB DJNJUFSJBMF PSJFOUBMF  0SJTUBOP  "E "OOB .BSJB (JVOUFMMB 
BMMB TVB EJEBUUJDB TVM DBNQP  BJ TFNJOBSJ iEFM MVOFEw OFMMB CJCMJPUFDB EJ "SDIFPMPHJB $SJTUJBOB QSJNB  QPJ BHMJ
JOOVNFSFWPMJTDBNCJEJJEFF EFWPJMNJPJOUFSFTTFWFSTPMBSDIFPMPHJBGVOFSBSJBJOUFTBDPNFDIJBWFEJDPNQSFO

Atti Toledo - 2a sessione

373

30-07-2013, 13:56

 

 

NBHHJPSF DPOTBQFWPMF[[B EJ RVBOUP JOUFOTF TJBOP MF JOUFSDPOOFTTJPOJ DVMUVSBMJ USB OVP
WJBGGJMJBUJBMDSJTUJBOFTJNPFNPOEPQSFDSJTUJBOP USBDSJTUJBOJEJEJWFSTFDPOGFTTJPOJOFM
NPNFOUPTUPSJDPEFMDPOTPMJEBNFOUPEFMMPSUPEPTTJB USBSPNBOJFQPQPMB[JPOJHFSNBOJ
DIF F  BMMJOUFSOP EJ RVFTUF VMUJNF  EJ SFUBHHJ EJWFSTJ  UVUUP RVFTUP OPO QV DIF TPMMFDJ
UBSDJ BE VOB SJGMFTTJPOF QJ BSUJDPMBUB F QFSUBOUP NBHHJPSNFOUF JOUFSEJTDJQMJOBSF -BOB
MJTJ EFM GFOPNFOP OFMMB MVOHB EVSBUB  GJOP BMMBMUP NFEJPFWP   JOGBUUJ JOEJTQFOTBCJMF QFS
DPNQSFOEFSF DPNF MF HFSBSDIJF FDDMFTJBTUJDIF TJ TJBOP QPTUF EJ GSPOUF BM SFUSPUFSSB DVM
UVSBMF EFJ OVPWJ DSJTUJBOJ[[BUJ  FMBCPSBOEP MJOFF EPUUSJOBMJ GFSNF F DPODPSEJ  NB DPO BQ
QMJDB[JPOJ QBTUPSBMJ EJWFSTJGJDBUF B TFDPOEB EFHMJ PSJ[[POUJ HFPHSBGJDJ F DSPOPMPHJDJ
/FM MBWPSP EJ DPOOFTTJPOF F EJ DPOGSPOUP USB GPOUJ BSDIFPMPHJDIF F GPOUJ MFUUFSBSJF 
HJ GFMJDFNFOUF BWWJBUP EB "OOB .BSJB (JVOUFMMB  WPSSFJ JO RVFTUB TFEF BOBMJ[[BSF BM
DVOJ EBUJ BMMB MVDF EFMMB MFUUVSB DPNQBSBUB EJ GPOUJ EPDVNFOUBSJF  TPQSBUUVUUP BUUJ DPODJ
MJBSJ  FE J EBUJ OPUJ EBMMBSDIFPMPHJB  BODIF JO DPOTJEFSB[JPOF EFM GBUUP DIF OPO UVUUF MF
B[JPOJ MBTDJBOP USBDDF NBUFSJBMJ F OPO UVUUJ J SJUJ QFS J RVBMJ TPOP FWJEFOUJ MF USBDDF BS
DIFPMPHJDIF IBOOP BEFHVBUP SJTDPOUSP OFMMF GPOUJ TDSJUUF -B SJDFSDB JO FTTFSF QSFOEF JO
FTBNF JM DPNQMFTTP EFMMB SJUVBMJU GVOFSBSJB  TDPSQPSBOEPOF J HFTUJ JO BOBMJTJ EJ EFUUB
HMJP  QFS MF RVBMJ NJ MJNJUFS B QSFTFOUBSF BMDVOF FTFNQMJGJDB[JPOJ
*M SJUP EFMMB TFQPMUVSB QSFWFEF JO QSJNP MVPHP MB QSFQBSB[JPOF EFM EFGVOUP  WBSJB
NFOUF BCCJHMJBUP -B EJTUJO[JPOF VTVBMF JO BNCJUP BSDIFPMPHJDP USB DPSSFEP QFSTPOBMF F
DPSSFEP SJUVBMF DJ TQJOHF TPMJUBNFOUF BE BUUSJCVJSF BM QSJNP HMJ BHHFUUJ SFMBUJWJ BMMBCCJ
HMJBNFOUPJOTFOTPBNQJP DPNQSFTFFWFOUVBMJBSNJPQQVSFPHHFUUJEJNFTUJFSF-BTUFT
TB SJDPTUSV[JPOF EFMMBCCJHMJBNFOUP WJFOF FGGFUUVBUB TQFTTP TVMMB CBTF EFMMB QPTJ[JPOF EFJ
NBOVGBUUJ TPQSBUUVUUPOFMMFTFQPMUVSFHFSNBOJDIF QJSJDDIFEJPHHFUUJ-BSFBMUFSBQSP
CBCJMNFOUF QJ TGBDDFUUBUB USBMBTDJBOEP BM NPNFOUP J DBTJ BDDFSUBUJ EFMMB EFQPTJ[JPOF EJ
HJPJFMMJ F EJ FMFNFOUJ MFHBUJ BM WFTUJBSJP DIJBSBNFOUF OPO BQQBSUFOFOUJ BM EFGVOUP  F EF
QPTUJ RVJOEJ DPO WBMFO[B SJUVBMF  DPNF TQFTTP OFM DBTP EFHMJ BEPMFTDFOUJ  RVBMDIF DPO
TJEFSB[JPOF QV FTTFSF BWBO[BUB JO NFSJUP BM WFTUJBSJP -B QSFTFO[B EJ EFGVOUJ BCCJHMJBUJ

TJPOF QFS JM NPOEP BOUJDP F QFS MF USBTGPSNB[JPOJ EFMMB NFOUBMJU -B WPMPOU EJ QSPTFHVJSF RVFTUP GJMPOF EJ
SJDFSDB  OBUP JO TFOP BMM6OJWFSTJU EJ 3PNB 4BQJFO[B  IB EFUFSNJOBUP JM DPJOWPMHJNFOUP OPO TPMP EJ OVPWJ
F QJ HJPWBOJ BEFQUJ  NB BODIF EJ DPMMFHIJ EJ BMUSF EJTDJQMJOF  EBMMF MFUUFSBUVSF BOUJDIF F NFEJFWBMJ BMMB TUPSJB
EFMMF DIJFTF F EFMMF SFMJHJPOJ
 " . (  4FQPMUVSF F SJUP DPOTVFUVEJOJ F JOOPWB[JPOJ  JO -F TFQPMUVSF JO 4BSEFHOB EBM *7 BM
7**TFDPMP"UUJEFM*7$POWFHOPTVMMBSDIFPMPHJBUBSEPSPNBNBFNFEJFWBMF $VHMJFSJ HJVHOP .FEJ
UFSSBOFP UBSEPBOUJDP F NFEJFWBMF 4DBWJ F SJDFSDIF  
 0SJTUBOP   QQ  " . (  -VTP
EFHMJ TQB[J TFQPMUVSF F SJUJ GVOFSBSJ  JO -B iDJWJUBT DISJTUJBOBw 6SCBOJTUJDB EFMMF DJUU JUBMJBOF GSB BOUJDIJU F
BMUPNFEJPFWP "TQFUUJ EJ BSDIFPMPHJB VSCBOB "UUJ EFM * 4FNJOBSJP EJ TUVEJP  5PSJOP  .FEJUFSSBOFP UBSEP
BOUJDPFNFEJFWBMF4DBWJFSJDFSDIF2VBEFSOJ 
5PSJOP QQ".( /PUFTVBMDVOJ
BTQFUUJ EFMMB SJUVBMJU GVOFSBSJB OFMMBMUP NFEJPFWP $POTVFUVEJOJ F JOOPWB[JPOJ  JO( $ 8  (
1 # FE
 4FQPMUVSF USB *7 F 7*** TFDPMP "UUJ EFM  4FNJOBSJP TVM UBSEP BOUJDP F TVMMBMUP NFEJPFWP
JO *UBMJB DFOUSP TFUUFOUSJPOBMF  (BSEPOF 3JWJFSB   PUUPCSF   .BOUPWB   QQ 
 /PO BGGSPOUFS JOWFDF JO RVFTUB PDDBTJPOF JM QSPCMFNB EFMMF TFQPMUVSF BMMJOUFSOP F BUUPSOP BMMF DIJFTF 
MB DVJ DPMMPDB[JPOF  OPO EJ SBEP SJUVBMF  QSPCMFNB GPSUFNFOUF TFOUJUP EBJ WFTDPWJ F SJCBEJUP DPO GPS[B OFJ
DBOPOJ DPODJMJBSJ  QFSDI PHHFUUP  JO TQFDJGJDP SJGFSJNFOUP BJ DPNQMFTTJ FQJTDPQBMJ  EFMMB UFTJ EJ EPUUPSBUP EJ
'BCSJ[JP 7BMMFMPOHB 4BQJFO[B 6OJWFSTJU EJ 3PNB  %PUUPSBUP JO "SDIFPMPHJB  DVSSJDVMVN EJ "SDIFPMPHJB F
BOUJDIJU QPTUDMBTTJDIF

 1FS VOB TJOUFTJ EFMMF QSBUJDIF MFHBUF BM USBUUBNFOUP EFJ DPSQJ TJ SJNBOEB EB VMUJNP B . .  *
SJUJ GVOFSBSJ  JO - & 1 FE
 $ISJTUJBOB -PDB $BUBMPHP EFMMB NPTUSB  3PNB   QQ 

 " RVFTUB EJTUJO[JPOF TJ  QSPWBUP BE BHHJVOHFSF RVFMMB EJ DPSSFEPBSSFEP  JO SJGFSJNFOUP BJ NBOVGBUUJ
EFQPTUJ TVMMB TFQPMUVSB P  TQFDJF OFJ DPOUFTUJ DBUBDPNCBMJ  BQQMJDBUJ OFMMB DIJVTVSB EFM MPDVMP " & '  .
1 % .  % /  &MFNFOUJ EJ iDPSSFEPBSSFEPw EFMMF UPNCF EFM DJNJUFSP EJ 4 *QQPMJUP TVMMB WJB 5JCVS
UJOB  JO 3"$S    
 QQ 

Atti Toledo - 2a sessione

374

30-07-2013, 13:56

   



 EPDVNFOUBUB OFJ DBTJ EJ TFQPMUVSF GSFUUPMPTF QFS FTFNQJP FQJEFNJF F NBMBUUJF DPOUB
HJPTF
 PQQVSF QFS QFSTPOBHHJ EJ BMUJTTJNP SBOHP  TQFTTP SFBMJ  QFSTPOBHHJ QFS J RVBMJ MF
WFTUJ JO TF TUFTTF FSBOP VO FMFNFOUP JOEJTQFOTBCJMF BMMB EFGJOJ[JPOF EFMMP TUBUVT TPDJBMF
*OBMUSJDBTJ MBQSFTFO[BEJFMFNFOUJDIFEPWFWBOPFTTFSFDVDJUJTVMMBTUPGGB EBJCSBUUFBUJ
BMMFDSPDFUUFBVSFF USBEJTDFMVTPEFMTVEBSJP DPOGFSNBUPBODIF JOBTTFO[BEJNBUFSJBMJ 
EBMMB QPTUVSB QBSUJDPMBSNFOUF DPOUFOVUB EFHMJ BSUJ EJ NPMUJTTJNJ JOVNBUJ -VTP EFM TV
EBSJP P DPNVORVF EJ UFTTVUJ QFS BWWPMHFSF JM EFGVOUP  DPOGFSNBUB BMMB GJOF EFM 7* TF
DPMP EB VO DBOPOF EFM DPODJMJP EJ "VYFSSF  JO CBTF BM RVBMF J EFGVOUJ OPO EFWPOP FT
TFSF BWWPMUJ OF WFMP WFM QBMMB F RVBMDIF EFDFOOJP QSJNB JM DPODJMJP EJ $MFSNPOU BWFWB
QSPJCJUP EJ BWWPMHFSF J DPSQJ OFJ QBMMJ DPOTBDSBUJ "MMVTBO[B SPNBOB EPWFWB GPSTF BH
HJVOHFSTJ  JO BNCJFOUF DSJTUJBOP  JM SJDPSEP EFM SJUVBMF GVOFSBSJP EJ $SJTUP  BWWPMUP BQ
QVOUP OFM TVEBSJP  DIF OFJ UFTUJ QBUSJTUJDJ WJFOF DPO GBDJMJU BTTJNJMBUP BMMB WFTUF CBUUFTJ
NBMF  TVEBSJP EFMMVPNP WFDDIJP FE JOTJFNF TJNCPMP EFMMVPNP OVPWP -B DPNQSFTFO
[B EJ TVEBSJ F EJ FMFNFOUJ EJ DPSSFEP EPWSFCCF TQJOHFSDJ BE VOB SJGMFTTJPOF QJ BQQSP
GPOEJUB TVMMB EPQQJB QSFTFO[B BCJUJTVEBSJP  PQQVSF TVMMB TPMB QSFTFO[B EFM TFDPOEP  TVM
RVBMFHMJPHHFUUJMFHBUJBMMBCCJHMJBNFOUPTBSFCCFSPTUBUJQPHHJBUJ DPOVOBWBMFO[BSJUVBMF
RVJOEJ CFO QJ BNQJB F QSFHOBOUF
/PO NJ TPGGFSNFS TVJ NBOVGBUUJ EFQPTUJ FOUSP MF TFQPMUVSF  TF OPO QFS SJDPSEBSF
DPNFMBQSBUJDBEJEFQPSWJBNVMFUJDPMMJNJDPOMBEJGGVTJPOFEJPHHFUUJDPOGVO[JPOFBQP
USPQBJDB DIFBEFTFNQJP$FTBSJPEJ"SMFTEFQMPSBDPOWJHPSF TPQSBUUVUUPRVBOEP JOWJ
UB  TJ TPTUJUVJTDPOP BMMB NFEJDJOB P BMMF QSFHIJFSF -B OFDFTTJU EJ QPTTFEFSF NBOVGBUUJ
DPOWBMFO[BQSPUFUUJWBTJNBUFSJBMJ[[BOFMMBEJGGVTJPOFEFMMFTUBVSPUFDIF DIFDPOUFOHPOP
SFMJRVJF  MF VOJDIF JO HSBEP EJ HBSBOUJSF VOFGGJDBDF QSPUF[JPOF  JO GPS[B EFMMF WJSU DSJ
TUJBOF EFM NBSUJSF -P TUFTTP (SFHPSJP .BHOP EPOB B 5FPEFMJOEB  JO PDDBTJPOF EFM CBU
UFTJNP EFM GJHMJP "EBPBMEP  VO QIZMBDUFSJVN  DPOTJTUFOUF QSPQSJP JO VOB TUBVSPUFDB
-FTUFSOPEFMMBUPNCBEPWFWBQSFTFOUBSTJWBSJBNFOUFBEEPCCBUP-BQSFTDSJ[JPOFEFM
DPODJMJPEJ&MWJSBEFMMJOJ[JPEFM*7TFDPMPSJHVBSEPMBSBDDPNBOEB[JPOFEJOPOBDDFOEF
SF DFSJ OF USBEJTDF JOEJSFUUBNFOUF MVTP  JOUFSFTTBOUF DPNF MB OPSNB DPODJMJBSF TJ SJ
GFSJTDB TQFDJGJDBUBNFOUF B DBOEFMF JO DFSB  F OPO B HFOFSJDIF GPOUJ EJ MVDF  DPT DIF USB
JNBUFSJBMJEFMMFOFDSPQPMJDPNQBJPOPMVDFSOF TJBQVSFJORVBOUJUOPOFDDFTTJWBFQSP

 "  $PODJMJP "VUJTTJPEPSFOTF "VYFSSF


 DBO 9** /F NPSUVJT FVDIBSJTUJB EFUVS OFD PTDVMVN FU
OF WFMP WFM QBMMB JOWPMWBOUVS /PO MJDFU NPSUVJT OFD FVDIBSJTUJBN OFD PTDVMVN USBEJ  OFD WFMP WFM QBMMJT DPSQPSB
FPSVN JOWPMWJ ) 5 #  $BOPOFT "QPTUPMPSVN FU $PODJMJPSVN TBFDVMPSVN *77**  #FSMJO       Q
 $  $  $PODJMJB (BMMJBF B B   5VSOIPMUJ   Q 

 "  $PODJMJP "SWFSOFOTF $MFSNPOU
   D  $BEBWFSB NPSUVPSVN OPO PCWPMWFOEB QBMMJJT TBDSBUJT
0CTFSWBOEVN OF QBMMJJT WFM NJOJTUFSJJT EJWJOJT EFGVODUPSVN DPSQPSB PCWPMWBOUVS ) 5 #  $BOPOFT "QP
TUPMPSVN FU $PODJMJPSVN TBFDVMPSVN *77**  #FSMJO       Q  $  $  $PODJMJB (BMMJBF B 
B   5VSOIPMUJ   Q 

$BFT"SFM 4FSN F  JO$PSQVT$ISJTUJBOPSVN4FSJFT-BUJOB1FSMBEJGGVTJPOFEFHMJBNV
MFUJOFMNPOEPDSJTUJBOPTJSJNBOEBB#%. ;VN"NVMFUUFOCSBVDIUVOJOGSINJUUFMBMUFSMJDIFO
'SBVFO  VOE ,JOEFSHSCFO  JO 'SBVFO JO 4QUBOUJLF VOE 'SINJUUFMBMUFS  4JHNBUJOHFO   QQ  F  JO
SFMB[JPOF DPO JM DPNQMFTTP EFMMBCCJHMJBNFOUP  B 3 .  "TQFUUJ EJ TUPSJB EFM DPTUVNF JO &VSPQB EBM
MFU HJVTUJOJBOFB BM 7** TFDPMP  JO "DUB 9** $POHSFTTVT *OUFSOBUJPOBMJT "SDIBFPMPHJBF $ISJTUJBOBF  4QMJU1PSF 
       $JUU EFM 7BUJDBOP4QMJU   QQ 
 (SFH .  &Q     JO 7 3 FE
 0QFSF EJ (SFHPSJP .BHOP    -FUUFSF 9*9*7  3PNB 
 "   $PODJMJP &MJCFSJUBOP &MWJSB
 D  /F DFSFJ JO DPFNFUFSJJT JODFOEBOUVS $FSFPT QFS EJFN
QMBDVJU JO DPFNFUFSJP OPO JODFOEJ  JORVJFUBOEJ FOJN TBODUPSVN TQJSJUVT OPO TVOU 2VJ IBFD OPO PCTFSWBWFSJOU
BSDFBOUVS BC FDDMFTJBF DPNNVOJPOF ) 5 #  $BOPOFT "QPTUPMPSVN FU $PODJMJPSVN TBFDVMPSVN *77** 
#FSMJO       Q  + 7 FE
 $PODJMJPT 7JTJHUJDPT F )JTQBOP3PNBOPT &TQBB DSJUJDB 
 #BSDFMPOB
.BESJE   Q 


Atti Toledo - 2a sessione

375

30-07-2013, 13:56

 

 

HSFTTJWBNFOUFQJCBTTBQBSSFCCFSPGBSFFDDF[JPOFJDPOUFTUJDBUBDPNCBMJ EPWFNBHHJP
SF  JM OVNFSP EFMMF MBNQBEF JO UFSSBDPUUB  GPSTF QSPQSJP B DPOGFSNB EFMMVTP EJ RVFTUJ
TUSVNFOUJ EJ JMMVNJOB[JPOF QJ JO GVO[JPOF EFMMB GSFRVFOUB[JPOF EFJ WJWJ DIF EFMMB QSF
TFO[B EFJ EFGVOUJ /PO  QPTTJCJMF WFSJGJDBSF MB QFSNBOFO[B EFMMVTP EJ DFSJ  DIF OPO
MBTDJBOP USBDDF NBUFSJBMJ  NB SJUFOHP TJHOJGJDBUJWB MB GSFRVFO[B EFJ SJGFSJNFOUJ JDPOPHSB
GJDJBDFSJFDBOEFMBCSJ MBDVJJNNBHJOF PMUSFBJTJHOJGJDBUJTJNCPMJDJCFOOPUJ QPUSFCCF
GPSTF BODIF  BMNFOP JO BMDVOJ DBTJ  BWFSF VOB WBMFO[B TPTUJUVUJWB EFM NBOVGBUUP  SBQQSF
TFOUBSF VO DFSP DIF OPO TJ DPOTVNB F OPO TJ TQFHOF 6OB BOBMPHB DPOTJEFSB[JPOF QV
FTTFSF GBUUB JO NFSJUP BJ EPOJ GMPSFBMJ  JO QSPTFHVP EVTP DPO MB USBEJ[JPOF SPNBOB DIF
QSFWFEFWB JO PDDBTJPOF EFMMF GFTUF EFJ NPSUJ MB EFQPTJ[JPOF EJ HIJSMBOEF EJ SPTF QSFTTP
MF TFQPMUVSF /PO FTDMVEFSFJ MB QPTTJCJMJU DIF RVFTUB VTBO[B QPTTB USPWBSF FDP OFMMF EF
DPSB[JPOJ GMPSFBMJ EJQJOUF DIF BSSJDDIJTDPOP HMJ BNCJFOUJ JQPHFJ F TQFTTP BODIF J UVNV
MJ EFM TPQSBUFSSB OPO B DBTP  BODIF QFS JM NPOEP SPNBOP  TUBUB PTTFSWBUB MB QSFTFO[B
EFDPSP BSDIJUFUUPOJDP B HIJSMBOEF TVM RVBMF TPOP SJNBTUJ DIJPEJ QFS BQQFOEFSF DPSPOF
EJ GJPSJ GSFTDIJ OFJ HJPSOJ EFJ QBSFOUBMJB
*MSJUPTVMRVBMFGPOUJTDSJUUFFEBSDIFPMPHJDIFTPOPQJFTQMJDJUFTJDVSBNFOUFRVFM
MP EFM SFGSJHFSJVN 4J USBUUB  DPNF  OPUP  EJ VO UFSNJOF NPMUP EJGGVTP OFM NPOEP SP
NBOP TJB JO SJGFSJNFOUP VOB DPOEJ[JPOF GJTJDB JM SFGSJHFSJP EBM DBMEP FTUJWP
  NB FTUF
TP BODIF BMMB TGFSB NPSBMF F QSFTFOUF JO BMDVOF JTDSJ[JPOJ GVOFSBSJF  JOUFSQSFUBUF DPO BM
MVTJPOF BM CBODIFUUP GVOFCSF *O BNCJUP DSJTUJBOP  PMUSF B RVFTUJ TJHOJGJDBUJ  CFO QSF
TUP  TPQSBUUVUUP B QBSUJSF EBHMJ TDSJUUJ EJ 5FSUVMMJBOP  JM UFSNJOF TJ EJMBUB TPUUP JM QSPGJ
MP TFNBOUJDP  DPO JOEVCCJF BDDF[JPOJ EJ DBSBUUFSF TQJSJUVBMF  CFO OPUF  NB BODIF JO SJ
GFSJNFOUP BJ QBTUJ -B QBSPMB USPWB BNQJP TQB[JP TFNBOUJDP JO SFMB[JPOF BMMBNCJUP GV
OFSBSJP  UBOUP EB FTTFSF TUBUB DPOTPMJEBUB OFM DBOPOF EFMMB $IJFTB SPNBOB OFM NFNFO
UP EFJ EFGVOUJ *M DPOTVNP EJ QBOF FE BDRVB EPQP MF PSB[JPOJ  BUUFTUBUP BE FTFNQJP
OFMMB QBTTJP EJ 1JPOJVT  JO PDDBTJPOF EFMMF DFMFCSB[JPOJ QFS JM EJFT OBUBMJT EJ 1PMJDBSQP
*O /PSE "GSJDB  MF DFMFCSB[JPOJ JO POPSF EFM NBSUJSF QJ OPUP  $JQSJBOP  EPWFWBOP FTTF
SF QBSUJDPMBSNFOUF DIJBTTPTF  DPO DBOUJ F EBO[F BUUPSOP BMMB UPNCB EFM NBSUJSF  DPT DIF
JM WFTDPWP "VSFMJP TJ USPW DPTUSFUUP BE JTUJUVJSF VO DPOUSPMMP QFS MJNJUBSF HMJ BCVTJ *O

 1FS MB MFUUVSB EFJ SFTUJ BSDIFPMPHJDJ EFMMF DBUBDPNCF SJDPOEVDJCJMJ F SJUJ GVOFSBSJ TJ SJNBOEB B - 4 
3JUJ GVOFSBSJ F iDVMUP EFJ NPSUJw OFMMB UBSEB BOUJDIJU VO RVBESP BSDIFPMPHJDP EBJ DJNJUFSJ QBMFPDSJTUJBOJ EJ
3PNB  JO "VHVTUJOJBOVN    
 QQ 
 . &  TW $BOEFMBCSP  JO ' # FE
 5FNJ EJ JDPOPHSBGJB QBMFPDSJTUJBOB  $JUU EFM 7BUJ
DBOP   QQ 
 $PT BE FTFNQJP OFMMB OFDSPQPMJ WBUJDBOB MVOHP MB WJB 5SJPOGBMF  B 3PNB 1 -  ( 4  -B
OFDSPQPMJ WBUJDBOB MVOHP MB WJB 5SJPOGBMF  3PNB   Q 

$JD $BUP .FWFSPEFMFDUBWJUQPDVMB TJDVUJO4ZNQPTJP9FOPQIPOUJT NJOVUBBURVFSPSBOUJB 
FU SFGSJHFSBUJP BFTUBUF  FU WJDJTTJN BVU TPM BVU JHOJT IJOFSOVT
 1FS VOB SBDDPMUB EFMMF GPOUJ DSJTUJBOF FE VOB QSJNB EJTDVTTJPOF EFJ TJHOJGJDBUJ EFM UFSNJOF TJ SJNBOEB
B ) -  TW 3FGSJHFSJVN  JO %JDUJPOOBJSF E"SDIPMPHJF $ISUJFOOF FU EF -JUVSHJF      1BSJT   DPMM
 
 1FS JM SJGFSJNFOUP BM SFGSJHFSJP GJTJDP TJ SJNBOEB  JO QSJNJT  BJ QBTTJ FWBOHFMJDJ MFHBUJ BMMB SJDIJFTUB EJ
BDRVB EB QBSUF EJ -B[[BSP  OFMMJOGFSOP -D    -B[[BSP DIJFEF BDRVB VU SFHSJHFSFU MJOHVBN NFBN
 F BM
MJODPOUSP EJ (FT DPO MB 4BNBSJUBOB BM QP[[P (W   

 5FSU  "QPM     JO SJGFSJNFOUP BJ QPWFSJ DIF QBSUFDJQBOP HSBUVJUBNFOUF BMMBHBQF 2VBOUJTDVNRVF
TVNQUJCVT DPOTUFU IBFD DFOB
 MVDSVN FTU  QJFUBUJT OPNJOF GBDFSF TVNQUVN  TJRVJEFN JOPQFT RVPTRVF SFHSJHFSJP
JTUP KVWBNVT

 *QTJVT%PNJOFFUPNOJCVTJO$ISJTUPRVJFTDFOUJCVTMPDVNSFGSJHFSJJ MVDJTFUQBDJTVUJOGVMHFBTEFQSFDBNVS

 1BTTJP 4 1JPOJJ   JO "DUB 4BODUPSVN  'FCS   Q  'BDUB JHJUVS PSBUJPOF TPMFNOJ  DVN EJF TBCCBUP
TBODUVN QBOFN FU BRVBM EFHVTUBTTFOU

 "VH  4FSN    &Q   

Atti Toledo - 2a sessione

376

30-07-2013, 13:56

   



WFTDPWJ BGSJDBOJ TJ USPWBOP OFMMB OFDFTTJU EB VOB QBSUF EJ MJNJUBSF HMJ BCVTJ  NB JO OFT
TVO NPEP TFNCSBOP DPOEBOOBSF MB QSBUJDB  DIF DPTUJUVJWB BODIF VOPDDBTJPOF EJ QSP
TFMJUJTNP  DPNF BNNFUUF MP TUFTTP "HPTUJOP *O VOBMUSB PDDBTJPOF  BMMB GPMMB EJ GFEFMJ
DIF JM  HFOOBJP DFMFCSBWB JM SFGSJHFSJVN  CFWFOEP WJOP F NBOHJBOEP DJCJ GSJUUJ  JM TFS
NPOF EFM WFTDPWP EJ *QQPOB SJDPSEB 0EFSVOU NBSUZSFT MBHFOBT WFTUSBT  PEFSVOU NBS
UZSFT TBSUBHFOBT WFTUSBT  PEFSVOU NBSUZSFT TPCSJFUBUFN WFTUSBN  JOTJTUFOEP RVJOEJ TVM
MB TPCSJFU  TFO[B BMDVOB DPOEBOOB QFS MB QSBUJDB EFM QBTUP SJUVBMF /PO UVUUF J WFTDP
WJ VUJMJ[[BSPOP MP TUFTTP DSJUFSJP TF JO "GSJDB DJ TJ MJNJUBWB B SBDDPNBOEBSF MB MJNJUB[JP
OF EFHMJ FDDFTTJ  B .JMBOP "NCSPHJP BWFWB QSPJCJUP EFM UVUUP MB QSBUJDB  HJVEJDBUB RVBTJ
QBSFOUBMJB  USPQQP TJNJMF BJ SJUJ GVOFCSJ QBHBOJ /F BWFWB GBUUP MF TQFTF MB TUFTTB .P
OJDB  DIF HJVOUB EBM /PSE "GSJDB TJ BQQSFTUBWB B WJTJUBSF MF NFNPSJF EFJ TBOUJ NJMBOF
TJ SFDBOEP JO VO DBOFTUSP QBOF  WJOP FE VOB GBSJOBUB  VOB WFSTJPOF FTUSFNBNFOUF SJ
EPUUB EFM QSBO[P GVOFCSF 4F HVBSEJBNP BMMB SFBMU BSDIFPMPHJDB  MF JOEVCCJF USBDDF EFM
DPOTVNP EJ DJCJ F CFWBOEF OFMMF BSFF GVOFSBSJF QSFTFOUBOP TUSVUUVSF EJ NPMUP SJEPUUF
CVPOB QBSUF EJ RVFMMF DIF EFGJOJBNP NFOTF TPOP JO SFBMU TFNQMJDJ QJBOJ EJ BQQPHHJP 
UBMWPMUBTFNQMJDFNFOUFJMCPSEPEFMUVNVMP1SPQSJPOFMSJUPEFMSFGSJHFSJPJMNPOEPDSJ
TUJBOP TJ EJGGFSFO[JB EB RVFMMP SPNBOP  QSPQPOFOEP VOB HFSBSDIJB EJ SVPMJ OFMMB NPSUF
" MJWFMMP BSDIFPMPHJDP  DSFEP WBEBOP UFOVUF EJTUJOUF MF TUSVUUVSF GVO[JPOBMJ BJ QBTUJ GV
OFCSJ JO POPSF EFJ NBSUJSJ  MB DVJ GVO[JPOF OPO  TPMP NFNPSJBMF  NB BODIF DFMFCSBUJ
WB EFM OVPWP SVPMP BTTVOUP EBM EFGVOUP F EFMMF QPUFO[JBMJU EJ BJVUP DIF OF EFSJWBOP BJ
WJWJ *M MVPHP EFMMB UPNCB EFM NBSUJSF OPO  TPMP RVFMMP EFMMB NFNPSJB  NB BODIF RVFM
MP EFMMB QSFHIJFSB  EFMMF SJDIJFTUF EJ JOUFSDFTTJPOF F EFMMBGGJTTJPOF EFHMJ FY WPUP DIF OF
BUUFTUBOPJMQPUFSFUBVNBUVSHJDP*MNBSUJSF BTTJNJMBUPB$SJTUPOFMTBDSJGJDJP MPBODIF
OFM SJDPSEP EFMMB DFOB FVDBSJTUJDB  MB DVJ NFNPSJB TJ GPOEF EFMMB QSBUJDB SJUVBMF EFM QB
TUP GVOFCSF  DIF RVBOEP EJWFOUB NFNPSJB OPO B DBTP QSFWFEF QBOF F WJOP  DPNF BUUF
TUB "HPTUJOP JO NFSJUP BM SJUP DFMFCSBUP EBMMB NBESF B .JMBOP
"MUSPTPOPMFBHBQJJOPOPSFEFJEFGVOUJ BDPNJODJBSFEBRVFMMBWPMVUBEB1BNNB
DIJP JO SJDPSEP EFMMB NPHMJF F DIF WJEF  QPWFSJ SJVOJUJ BUUPSOP BM EFTDP OFMMB CBTJMJDB
EJ41JFUSPB3PNB2VJQSFWBMFMFWFSHFUJTNP TFDPOEPVOBNPEBMJU TGBNBSFJQPWFSJ 
DIF SJTVMUB SJDPSSFOUF OFM .FEJPFWP F DIF IB CFO QPDP EJ SFMJHJPTP  TF OPO HMJ JOUFOUJ
EFM DPNNJUUFOUF $POUSP RVFTUJ QBTUJ  OPO B DBTP EFGJOJUJ TFNQSF OFMMF GPOUJ BHBQJ P
QSBOEJB  NBJ SFGSJHFSJB  TJ TDBHMJBOP TFWFSBNFOUF J WFTDPWJ  DIF WJ WFEPOP VOPDDBTJPOF
EJ MBTTJTNP DIF QPDP IB B DIF WFEFSF DPO J SJUVBMJ GVOFSBSJ "MMB NFU EFM 7* TFDPMP  JM
DPODJMJP EJ #SBHB UFOUB EJ SFHPMBNFOUBSF MF DFSJNPOJF DIF TJ TWPMHFWBOP TVMMF TFQPMUV
SF QSPJCFOEPDFMFCSB[JPOJFVDBSJTUJDIF QBTUJFTBDSJGJDJ%BMMBMFUUVSBDPNQBSBUBEFJDB
OPOJ  TFNCSFSFCCF DIF MJOUFOUP EFJ WFTDPWJ TJB TPQSBUUVUUP RVFMMP EJ FWJUBSF DIF J NP
OVNFOUB GVOFCSJ GPTTFSP MVPHIJ TPTUJUVUJWJ EFMMF TFEJ MJUVSHJDIF  SJQSJTUJOBOEP MF HJVTUF

 "VH  D 'BVTU    1T 0SJHFOF  *O +PC DPNNFOUBS 


 "VH  4FSN   D 
 "VH  $POG     RVJB JMMB RVBTJ QBSFOUBMJB TVQFSTUJUJPOJ HFOUJMVN FTTFOU TJNJMMJNF
 "VH  $POG    DBOJTUSVN DVN TPMFNOJCVT FQVMJT QSFHVTUBOEJT FURVF MBSHJFOEJT
 1FS VOB SBDDPMUB EJ GPOUJ FE VOB QSJNB EJTBNJOB TJ SJNBOEB B ) -  TW "HBQF  JO %JDUJPOOBJSF
E"SDIPMPHJF $ISUJFOOF FU EF -JUVSHJF      1BSJT   DPMM  
 D  %F FP RVPE OPO MJDFBU TVQFS NPOVNFOUB NPSUVPSVN NJTTB UFOFSF /PO PQPSUFU DMFSJDPT JHOBSPT FU
QSBFTVNQUPSFT TVQFS NPOVNFOUB JO DBNQP NJOJTUFSJB QPSUBSF BVU EJTUSJCVFSF TBDSBNFOUB  TFE BVU JO FDDMFTJB
BVU JO CBTJMJDBT VCJ NBSUZSVN SFMJRVJBF TVOU EFQPTJUBF JCJ QSP EFGVODUJT PCMBUJPOFN PGFSSF D  %F FP RVPE
OPO MJDFBU DISJTUJBOJT QSBOEJB BE NPOVNFOUB QPSUBSF /PO MJDFBU DISJTUJBOJT QSBOEJB BE EFGVODUPSVN TFQVMDSB
EFGFSSF FU TBDSJGJDJB SFEEFSF NPSUVPSVN %FP 7 FU BM   Q 




Atti Toledo - 2a sessione

377

30-07-2013, 13:56

 

 

HFSBSDIJFEFJMVPHIJSJUVBMJ4VRVFTUPBSHPNFOUP JWFTDPWJEPWFWBOPBWFSFVOBUUFHHJB
NFOUP FTUSFNBNFOUF QSBHNBUJDP  TF (SFHPSJP .BHOP SBDDPNBOEB BE "HPTUJOP  WFTDP
WP EFHMJ "OHMJ  EJ OPO EJTUSVHHFSF J UFNQMJ EFHMJ JEPMJ  NB EJ USBTGPSNBSMJ JO DIJFTF F EJ
DPODFEFSFBHMJ"OHMJEJNBOHJBSFMFDBSOJEFJCVPJ DIFFSBOPTPMJUJTBDSJGJDBSFBHMJJEPMJ 
OFM HJPSOP EFMMB EFEJDB[JPOF F EFJ TBOUJ NBSUJSJ  OFMMF DBQBOOF GBUUF DPO SBNJ EBMCFSP
F QPTUF BUUPSOP BMMF DIJFTF
"MUSP BODPSB  JOGJOF  TPOP J SJUJ GVOFCSJ DFMFCSBUJ JO GPSNB QSJWBUB  EJWFSTJ BODIF
QFSEFOPNJOB[JPOF JSFGSJHFSJB*SJUJQFSJTFNQMJDJEFGVOUJFSBOPGVO[JPOBMJTPQSBUUVUUP
BJ WJWJ  UFPSJ[[B EB "HPTUJOP JO VO BQQPTJUP USBUUBUP  JM %F DVSB QSP NPSUVJT HFSFOEB 
DPO VO DPNQMFUP DBQPWPMHJNFOUP EJ TJHOJGJDBUP OPO  JM EFGVOUP DIF WB TPTUFOVUP OFM
MB TVB WJUB VMUSBUFSSFOB  NB TPOP J WJWJ DIF IBOOP OFDFTTJU EJ DSFEFSWJ  DPNQSFOEFSF 
EBSF TFOTP BMMB QFSEJUB  FMBCPSBSF JM MVUUP OFMMB QSFHIJFSB *M WBMPSF EFMMB QSFHIJFSB QV 
TUBOEPBMMFGPOUJBHJPHSBGJDIF BEEJSJUUVSBJODJEFSFTVMMBDPOTJTUFO[BEFMMBTFQPMUVSB/FMMB
QSJNB NFU EFM *9 TFDPMP  MB TFQPMUVSB EJ SFMJHJPTB EFM NPOBTUFSP EJ #JTDIPGIFJN  PH
HFUUP EFM SJTFOUJNFOUP EFMMF DPOTPSFMMF QJ HJPWBOJ DIF BWFWBOP TVCJUP MF TVF BOHIFSJF
EJ DPOTFHVFO[B JM UVNVMP EFMMB TFQPMUVSB JOJ[J B EJNJOVJSF  QFS UPSOBSF EJ EJNFOTJPOJ
OPSNBMJ TPMP JO TFHVJUP BMMF QSFHIJFSF EFMMB CBEFTTB -JNQPSUBO[B EFMMB WJTJCJMJU EFM
MB TFQPMUVSB  EFM SFTUP  OPO FSB NBJ TUBUB NFTTB JO EJTDVTTJPOF F WJFOF SJCBEJUP FTQSFT
TBNFOUF EB (SFHPSJP EJ 5PVST
* WFTDPWJ TV RVFTUP QJBOP  RVFMMP EFJ SFGSJHFSJB  OPO TPOP NBJ JOUFSWFOVUJ DPO JO
UFOUJ DFOTPSJ  NB EBMMF PQFSF QBTUPSBMJ  TPQSBUUVUUP PNJMFUJDIF  BQQBSF DIJBSB MB WPMPOU
EJ WPMHFSF JO DIJBWF DSJTUJBOB QSBTTJ QSFDFEFOUJ  VTVBMJ OFMMB TPDJFU SPNBOB EFMMB RVBMF
QVSF HMJ TUFTTJ WFTDPWJ GBDFWBOP QBSUF F EFMMB RVBMF TQFTTP FSBOP MFTQSFTTJPOF DVMUVSBM
NFOUF QJ FMFWBUB * SFDJQJFOUJ DFSBNJDJ F WJUSFJ  DPOUFOJUPSJ EFJ DJCJ DIF OPO QPUFWBOP
UPSOBSFOFMNPOEPEFJWJWJ SBQQSFTFOUBOPMBUFTUJNPOJBO[BNBUFSJBMFEJRVFTUPSJUPDIF 
DSFEP BWFTTF WBMFO[B QSPHSFTTJWBNFOUF QJ TJNCPMJDB %FMMB SJEV[JPOF EFM QBTUP JO GPS
NFQJNPEFTUFOFGBOOPUFTUJNPOJBO[BMFTJHVJUEFMMFNFOTF TFNQMJDJQJBOJEJBQQPH

 (SFH .  &Q   


 "VH  $VS    + ; FE
 Q 
 DVSBUJP GVOFSJT  DPOEJUJP TFQVMUVSBF  QPNQB FYFRVJBSVN NBHJT
TVOU WJWPSVN TPMBUJB  RVBN TVCTJEJB NPSUVPSVN
 7JUB -FPCBF  D   QQ  -B SFMJHJPTB WFOOF TFQPMUB JO UFSSB F TVMMB UPNCB GV DSFBUP VO QJDDPMP
UVNVMP EJ UFSSB iTFQVMUVSBF USBEJUB  UVNVMVTRVF TVQFS TFQVMDISVN FJVT DPOHFTUP UFSSBF BHHFSF FY NPSF DPNQP
TJUVT FTUw %PQP MB TFQPMUVSB MF NPOBDIF QJ HJPWBOJ  DIF BWFWBOP TVCJUP MF BOHIFSJF EFMMB DPOTPSFMMB  TGPHB
SPOP JM MPSP SJTFOUJNFOUP TVMMB UPNCB EJ DPOTFHVFO[B JM UVNVMP EFMMB TFQPMUVSB JOJ[J B EJNJOVJSF DPNF SF
TQPOTP BMMF JOHJVTUJ[JF EFMMB SFMJHJPTB i2VPE DVN NBUFS DPOHSFHBUJPOJT WFOFSBCJMJT 5FUUB DPNQFSJTTFU  
 QFS
SFYJU BE UVNVMVN FU NJSVN JO NPEVN DPOTQFYJU UFSSBN RVBF EFTVQFS DPOHFTUB FSBU TVCTFEJTTF FU VTRVF BE
TFNJQFEJT TQBDJVN JOGSB TVNNJUBUFN TFQVMDISJ EFTDFOEJTTF 2VP WJTP  WFIFNFOUVS FYQBWJU  JOUFMMFYJU FOJN FY
EFGVDUVUFSSBFQPFOBNTFQVMUBFFUTFWFSJUBUFNJVTUJJVEJDJJ%FJQFSQFOEJUFYEFUSJNFOUPTFQVMDISJw-BCCBUFTTB
JOJ[J BMMPSB B QSFHBSF QFS MBTTPMV[JPOF EFJ QFDDBUJ EFMMB EFGVOUB F JM UVNVMP SJDPNJODJ B DSFTDFSF i$VNRVF
JO PSBUJPOF QFSTJTUFSFU  GPTTB TFQVMDISJ  RVBF QSJVT QFOF WBDVB WJEFCBUVS  IVNP FYDSFTDFOUF QBVMBUJN DPFQJU SF
QMFSJ  JUB VU VOP FPEFNRVF NPNFOUP FU JQTB BC PSBUJPOF SFTVSHFSFU  FU UFSSB TFQVMDISVN DPNQMBOFSFU 2VB FY
SFNBOJGFTUFPTUFOEJUVS RVPE DVNNPOVNFOUVNWJTJCJMJUFSBEQSJPSFNTUBUVNSFEJJU QFSPSBUJPOFTTBODUBFWJS
HJOJT EFGVODUBF BOJNBN WJSUVT EJWJOB JOWJTJCJMJUFS BCTPMWJUw
 &TFNQMBSF JM SBDDPOUP EJ (SFHPSJP EJ 5PVST DIF FTQSJNF DIJBSBNFOUF MJNQPSUBO[B EFMMB WJTJCJMJU EFM
MF TFQPMUVSF i%F TFQVMDSJT RVBF FMFWBOUVS 4VC UFSNJOP RVPRVF 7JDJ +VMJFOTJT TVO USFT QSFTCZUFSJ DPOTFQVMUJ  VU
GFSUVS QFS BOUJRVBN SFMBUJPOFN  OVMMJVT DPOTBOHVJOJUBUJT QSPQJORVJ WJODVMP OJTJ UBOUVN JO BNPSF %FJ TPDJJ  F
DPFMP GSBUSFT BGGFDUJ  RVJ VOJVT MPDJ TQBUJVN  TFQVMDSJT JVYUB QPTJUJT  BTTJEVJUBUF NJSBDPMPSVN JMMVTUSBOU 2VJ DVN
NVMUPSVNBOOPSVNDVSSJDVMBJOIJTVCJTFQVMUJTVOUMPDVMJTRVJFTDFSFOU TDJTTVNOVQFSQBWJNFOUVN RVPEDBMDF
BURVF DPNNJOVUB UFTUB RVBTJ TJMFY EVSJTTJNB GVTVN FSBU  VOJVT TFQVMDSJ DBDVNFO BQQBSVJU 2VP QBVMVMVN FMF
WBUP UFMMVTTDJTTBBQJDFNBMUFSJVTQBUFGFDJU*MMPRVFFNJDBOUF TFDVUVTFTUUFSUJVTUVNVMVT RVJOVODJVYUBJOJUJVN
PTUFOTJPOJT TVBF HSBEBUJN FMFWBOUVS TVQFS UFSSBNw (MPS DPOG   1BUSPMPHJB -BUJOB   DPMM 




Atti Toledo - 2a sessione

378

30-07-2013, 13:56

   



HJP  UBMWPMUB TFNQMJDFNFOUF JM CPSEP EFM UVNVMP MB TDBSTJTTJNB DPOTJTUFO[B EFJ GPDPMBSJ
MB QSBUJDB EFMMBTQFSTJPOF EFMMF TFQPMUVSF DIF QSPHSFTTJWBNFOUF TJ TPTUJUVJTDF BMMF MJCBHJP
OJ BMMJOUFSOP EFMMB UPNCB  MB DPOUFNQPSBOFB SJEV[JPOF EFM DPSSFEP JOUFSOP BMMB UPNCB
BJ TPMJ NBOVGBUUJ QPUPSJ WJUSFJ F DFSBNJDJ  BODIF RVFTUJ EB MFHHFSF DPNF VOB SJDPOWFS
TJPOF JO DIJBWF DSJTUJBOB EFJ DPSSFEJ QSFDFEFOUJ
4PMP RVBMDIF TQVOUP  GJO RVJ QSFTFOUBUP  EJ VOB SJDFSDB JO JUJOFSF  DIF DPOGJEP QPT
TB DPOUSJCVJSF B EFGJOJSF JM OPDDJPMP EFM DBNCJBNFOUP USB MFU SPNBOB F MB QSBTTJ NF
EJFWBMF OFMMF NPEBMJU EJ DSJTUJBOJ[[B[JPOF  OPO UBOUP OFJ UFSNJOJ EJ EJGGVTJPOF HFPHSBGJ
DB EFMMB OVPWB SFMJHJPOF  RVBOUP QJVUUPTUP OFJ NPEJ F OFJ UFNQJ EFMMB QFOFUSB[JPOF DVM
UVSBMF F EFMMB SFJOUFSQSFUB[JPOF EFHMJ PHHFUUJ F EFHMJ VTJ  VO GFOPNFOP EJ MVOHB EVSBUB
QBUSPDJOBUP F HJVTUJGJDBUP TVM QJBOP DVMUVSBMF QSPQSJP EBJ WFTDPWJ  VO GFOPNFOP DIF EF
UFSNJOB MB QFSNFBCJMJU EFM NPOEP SPNBO[P OFJ DPOGSPOUJ EFMMPSJ[[POUF HFSNBOJDP F
DIF  OFJ TVPJ NJMMF SJWPMJ  DSFEP WBEB BODPSB DPNQSFTP BQQJFOP

Atti Toledo - 2a sessione

379

30-07-2013, 13:56

You might also like