Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Group-5
Outline
Introduction
to Metros in
India
Mumbai
Metro
Intro &
History
Mumbai
Metro Line-1
Mumbai
Metro Line-2
Key Lessons
Learnt
Government of India
100% by Ministry of
Railways, Government of
India
Kolkata Metro Railway North
and South corridor and other
metro projects in Kolkata
have been taken up by the
Ministry of Railways
State Government Projects
100% by the State
Government
For example, AhmedabadGandhinagar metro project
Private sector projects
100% Private sector
Eg. Rapid Metrorail Gurgaon,
Hyderabad Metro - L&T
Metro Rail Hyderabad Ltd
Construction
Operation
Need for
Metro
Project Approvals
Testing
Expansion
Increasing Urbanization
Limited road space
Road Safety issues
Road Traffic congestion
issues
Metro in India
Government initiatives
National Urban Transport Policy
Identifying innovative
financing methods to raise
resources
Incorporating urban
transportation as a key
parameter at the urban
planning stage
Encouraging integrated
land use and transport
planning to minimize travel
distance
Peak Hour
Direction
Traffic
(2021)
Populati
on
census
(2011)
in
million
Average
trip
length in
motor in
km
Metro
Rail
>=15000
for 5 km
>=2
>7-8
Light
Rail
Transit
<=10000
>1
>7-8
Monorail
<=10000
>2
5-6
Issues:
Project saw significant delays in commissioning, initial timeline of 2011
operational start got delayed until 2014.
Project also saw legal issues pertaining to fare hikes - finally being
settled in MMOPLs favour.
Delays in commissioning
Facts:
Questions Raised:
The state had the power to do so, because Mumbai Metro Area
was notified under the Indian Tramways Act, 1886
In late 2013, the Mumbai Metro got notified under the Metro
(Construction of Works) Act, 1978, which gave initial fare setting
power MMOPL.
MMOPL wanted a fare hike to new range of INR 10-40 for the
project as an initial setting.
MMOPL claimed it had the right to do so since the earlier fares set
by the government were now null and void under the new act
Even though MMRDA went to court over this hike, the Bombay
High Court, and later the Supreme Court ruled in MMOPLs favour.
Questions Raised:
Why did the FFC suggest a hike to maximum fare of INR 110?
Success Story
Question Raised:
Despite only one bidder submitting the bid, no revisions
were made in restructuring to allow more bids
Questions Raised:
While selecting land locations for such critical areas,
are inter-agency factors taken into account?
Aftermath
Mumbai Metro Line-2:
Subsequent development of Line-2 would be done under Public-Public-Partnership
Mumbai Metro Rail Corporation (MMRC) incorporated for subsequent lines of Mumbai Metro
Charkop - Mankhurd route, originally constituted Line-2 of Mumbai metro, was extended to
Dahisar
Cost of Line-2 per km stretch under this MMRC model is expected to be 2.5 times under PPP
agreement
Still, tussle faced between State Home Ministry and MMRDA over the land for Metro Car-shed
in Mankhurd
Mumbai Metro Line-3:
Colaba-Bandra-SEEPZ corridor
First corridor to have a section of it to be constructed underground
Line-3 will be implemented by MMRC. Will be implemented under EPC
The project will be financed by primarily State and Central Government,
and the Japanese International Cooperation Agency (JICA).
Further, the construction of 3 metro stations in proximity to International
airport will receive contribution from Mumbai International Airport Limited.
Bidding Process
Assessment
Public Support
Asset transfer
Specification