Professional Documents
Culture Documents
is obvious that T.S Eliot goes through several periods and stages in his
poetic career. As I pointed out in the previous chapters, critics claim
that Eliots career witnessed a poetic development and spiritual
progress from early poetry to Four Quartets. Indeed, in the early and
transitional poetry, Eliot had a considerable difficulty in defining his
role as a Christian poet and finding the proper place for religion in his
work. After this transitional period, Eliot tends to seem more comfortable in his
positions as Christian poets. Accordingly, in his later works, he reaches the
peak of his religious sensibility. In fact, a proper appreciation of Eliots
career as a whole depends upon the awareness of his later work Four
Quartets. In a seminal thesis entitled Wrestling with Angels: T. S. Eliot, W.
H. Auden, and the Idea of a Christian Poetics Pauline McAlonan states that in Four
Quartets Eliot's critical perspective was radically altered and his chief concern became
"the relation of poetry to the spiritual and social life of its time and other times" 1 In this
specific context, unlike early poems, such as The Waste Land and
The Love Song that address spiritual failure in a bankrupt universe,
the journey of the pilgrim in Four Quartets ends with redemption. In
fact, in order to understand Four Quartets, this chapter will be
devoted to the analysis of Eliots poem from a Dantean perspective.
Unlike the psychological trauma of the inhabitants of the Waste Land
1 Pauline McAllon, Wrestling with Angels:T. S. Eliot, W. H. Auden, and the Idea of a
Christian Poetics (Montreal: Department of English,2006) p.59
Dantes poem. Therefore, the first part examines the image of the
Beatrice and Her Eyes and how T.S Eliot in Four Quartets, unlike early
and transitional poetry, presents the eyes as a symbol of vision. The
second part discusses the theme of Incarnation and the image of God
in Eliots poem and its connection with the Divine Comedy. The last
part consists of Eliots spiritual fulfilment and his reconciliation with
earthly desires.
I.
The
Quartets
and
The
doctrine
of
Christianity:
Before starting to analyse the connectedness of both poets, we
should first present Eliots poem Four Quartets. Indeed, Eliots Four
Quartets is a set of four poems Burnt Norton, East Cocker, The Dry
Salvages and Little Gidding. The poems were originally published as
separated works, and only later combined in a series. Therefore, the
central focus of the Four Quartets is man's relationship with time, the
universe, and the divine. The poems present the reader to close
elements of the Doctrine of Christianity. Like Dantes protagonist who
journeys in Paradise under the light of the medieval context, Eliots
pilgrim journey in this real world under the light of the modern context.
Skilfully, Eliot transforms the medieval context of Dante and projects it
to modern England in the era after World War II. In fact, the secular nature
of modern society creates conditions for the writing of religious poetry. Therefore, T.S
3
In these lines, the poet states that the religious celebrations like the
Eucharist4 should be sustenance for living and that otherwise our
years are largely wasted. Besides, the fourth section of The Dry
Salvages contains a prayer to the Virgin Mary
Lady, whose shrine stands on the
promontory,
Pray for all those who are in ships,
those
Whose business has to do with fish(Eliot
211)
In this passage Eliot evokes the shrine of the Virgin Mary and asks
her to pray for suffering of people in the modern England. Moreover, in
the last quartet Little Gidding the poet recalls the trauma of early
3 T.S Eliot, Four Quartets , Collected poems 1909-1962 ( London: Faber
Paperbacks, 1963)P.202
4 The Holy Eucharist is a sacrament and a sacrifice. In the Holy Eucharist,
under the appearances of bread and wine, the Lord Christ is contained,
offered, and received.
4
In the lines that follow Eliot declares that the poet must endeavour To
purify the dialect of the tribe. By such a claim, Eliot shows that the
language of his poem should not only communicate with the audience,
but also purify their language.
From the above glance on the context of the quartets, we grasp
that Eliot, like Dante, very skilfully incorporates his religious beliefs into his poem in
order to redeem Twenty years largely wasted. Therefore, the link
between Four Quartets and Paradise becomes tenable. Indeed,
Eliots poem came under the influence of Dante who helped him to form his theological
philosophy. Like Dante in Paradiso, Eliots Quartets are a presentation
of spiritual achievement and the move from a carnal love to a divine
love.
5 Pauline McAllon, Wrestling with Angels:T. S. Eliot, W. H. Auden, and the
Idea of a Christian Poetics (Montreal: Department of English,2006) p.253
5
II.
In fact, in his later poem Four Quarets, Eliot places more emphasis on the doctrine of
the Incarnation. In this context, Pauline McAlonan claims that whereas the speakers in
Ash-Wednesday and the Ariels see the Incarnation primarily as a necessary but disruptive
event that causes great suffering, Four Quartets takes pains to emphasize that it is
motivated by love Therefore, in his treatment of the this doctrine Eliot emphasizes the
connection or the intersection between divinity and humanity, eternity and
temporality.
present and future are conventional times which are in movement, and
the last type of time is always present within the motion of
temporality. For Eliot if humans are submerged in time and movement,
they are unable to perceive the source of this movement. Therefore,
any redemption is possible outside the time of the always present.
8 Lille dEasum, T.S Eliot use of the philosophy of time in his poetry (British
Columbia: B.A., University of British Columbia, 1955)p.54
9
In this passage, the spatial and temporal locations are indefinable and
unfixed. Therefore At the still point of the turning world is a place
where time and space do and do not exist in a state that contains all
paradoxes9. In other words, the poet wants to say that the still point is
somewhere and nowhere i.e. a place that goes beyond this world. It is
neither arrest nor movement so we cant call it fixity, because we
9 Corey Latta, When the Eternal can Be Met: The Bergsonian Theology
of Time in the Works of C.S. Lewis, T.S Eliot, and W.H. Auden (Eugene:
Pickwick, 2014) p.145
10
can't stop the world around us from moving. Accordingly, Nidhi Tiwari
in her book Imagery and Symbolism in T. S. Eliot's Poetry says that Eliots
still point is still like the wheel with its spokes and pivotal point. Without this point no
movement is possible but, this central point does not move itself. 10Here, it is important
to mention the still point of the turning world, the centre, is thus outside
of movement but is also the core of the movement. In fact, T.S Eliot uses
this philosophical perspective of time to convey that redemption
cannot be reached without God the one from which all existence emanates11
Besides, in Four Quartets Eliot presents another recurrent image of
the still point through the presentation of the cycle of seasons that
conveys the circle of the turning world. Therefore, in the poem the
temporal and mutable world is defined by the turning of the seasons
within the circle of to time. Eliot associates the four parts of his poem
to the four seasons in order to portray the movement of turning
world around the still point. In the second part of Burnt Norton the
speaker refers to the cycle seasons
What is the late November doing
With the disturbance of the spring
And creatures of the summer heat,
the evening circle in the winter gaslight (Eliot
198)
In this passage, the poet presents the reader to the seasonal cycle
which turns within the circle of temporal world. The movement of this
cycle doesnt exist the time of the timelessness but in the temporal
time. The speaker presents the turning of seasons in time where late
November i.e. autumn the spring the summer and the winter
exist in the circle of temporality. So, none of the seasons is timeless
since each season exist in a determined ephemeral point. By the end
of the poem, Eliot emphasizes the temporality of seasons in this life
and the timelessness of the still point by referring to the
unimaginable season that may exist beyond the time
Where is the summer, the
unimaginable
Zero summer? (Eliot 214)
In
expression
zero
summer?
connotes
the
unimaginable season at the still point. Eliot puts the number zero
with summer to suggest that none of the seasons will last forever.
Therefore, the poet uses the expression Zero summer as a device
that transcends human imagination which is unimaginable neither
arrest nor movement. By this image Eliot reinforces his vision of the
temporality of carnal life, where the cycle of seasons occurs, and his
vision of the timelessness of the still point, where the unimaginable
zero summer takes place.
Hence, T.S Eliot, like Dante, compares God to both a circle and a
point. It is" the still point of the turning world" that suggests an
12
Incarnation
whether
spiritual
or
physical
"conquered,
and
reconciled."
3. The Intersection:
Moreover, in his poem Eliot represents the ultimate meeting of
two disparate qualities within a point of Intersection. In the second part
of Burnt Norton the poet uses the image of axle-tree which conflates
two parts in one point. Through this image, the poet implicitly wants to
convey the point to which two different times intersect. In the Dry
Salvages Eliot presents us to the central theme of Incarnation in Four
Quartets:
But to apprehend
The point of intersection of the timeless
With time, is an occupation for the
saint(Eliot 212)
In the passage above, the poet refers to way in which our eternal God
intersects with our temporal world. As Susan Fish claims in her book
entitled Let God Be God a wise person is not merely one who knows
the times, but is one who recognizes the hand of Gods sovereignty in
13
and brightness, but towards the end of the poem the poet refers to
the blind eye and the distraction of nature and music that prevent
the pilgrim to fulfil his end. Yet, in Four Quartets the absence of eyes is
changed to eyes of vision that address the pilgrim towards the divine. In
the first part Burnt Norton the poet introduces the episode of the
Rose Garden and refers to the eyebeam that had the look of
flowers:
And the bird called, in response to
The unheard music hidden in the shrubbery,
And the unseen eyebeam crossed, for the
roses
Had the look of flowers that are looked at.
There they were as our guests, accepted and
accepting.
So we moved, and they, in a formal pattern,
Along the empty alley, into the box circle,
(Eliot 190)
2. Elements of Nature:
Apart from the theme of vision, Eliots Four Quartets uncovers the ways in
which artistic and religious elements act upon one another. As I have mentioned
previously in the third chapter, Eliot repudiates Shelleys and Arnolds
attempt to substitute poetry for religion. He asserts that religion should
be part of a work of art. So, he condemns anyone who tries to make a religion out
of aesthetism. In this section I will accentuate the way T.S Eliot
accommodates Romanticism in his aesthetic philosophy in order to
17
The speaker compares people of his society with autumn, the time of
year when the leaves on the trees start to die. By this image, Eliot
conveys that the human spirit dies, just as the leaves die and fall from
the trees. In the next line the look of flowers suggests the allure of
the natural world to which people should be attracted and seduced.
The houses are all gone under the sea.
The dancers are all gone under the hill.
(Eliot 199)
eternity of the timeless and the temporality of this life since we are
all going to be gone and every trace of us will be wiped from the Earth
expect the always present.
Moreover, T.S Eliot employs the image of the rose, another
eloquent symbol from Dantes Paradise. In this context, many scholars
affirm that the rose which first appears in the second part of Burnt
Norton, originates from Dantes Garden of Eden. In this respect, Maria
Cristina Fumagall in a book entitled The Flight of the Vernacular
states that Eliots rose garden image melds the garden of Eden in
Dantes paradise, where Dante enjoys a vision of the Blessed in the
Empyrean of heaven in the form of a white rose.16
In fashion then as of a snow-white rose (Paradiso XXXI ) page 367
Unlike the fruitless Garden of the waste land, and the unfulfilled rose
garden of the Ash Wednesday, in Four Quartets Eliot considers the
garden as a point involved with past and future.
To be conscious is not to be in time
But only in time can the moment in
the rose garden
Be remembered; involved with past
and future(Eliot 192)
Within this specific context, Domenic Manganiello in his part suggests
that these lines tigers primal memories of both an earthly and supraterrestrial paradise of bliss.
16Fumagall Maria Christina, The Flight of the Vernacular (New York:
Rodopi, 2001)p.57
19
In this line, the poet associates the dance of the body with the still
point. Here the poet conveys that the dance comes from that stillness
or the divine where there is only the dance. In fact, the dance here
portrays a state of freedom from desire and compulsion. Eliot repeats
the image of dance in the poem in order to stress the spiritual
salvation of the self in one hand, and to refer to the purification of the
body on the other hand. Thus, it is the Incarnation which helps for the
restoration of the body in Four Quartets. In other words, within the
17 Pauline McAllon, Wrestling with Angels:T. S. Eliot, W. H. Auden, and the
Idea of a Christian Poetics (Montreal: Department of English,2006)p.180
20
The speaker in these lines recaptures the dance around the fire which
goes back to a way of celebration in old England. Eliot recalls this old
fashioned wedding celebration because he wants to throw off the
complications of his modern life and return to the simplicity of past
where people care only about their present. In this specific context,
Pauline McAllon says that Eliot's greater acceptance of the body and
sexuality in his later poem suggests that he is more willing to subscribe
to the idea that the body was redeemed when "the Word was made
flesh" and therefore need not be denied.18
In the passage in question, The Fire evokes both the pain and purity.
The Rose stands as a symbol of life, love and beauty or as Eliot
himself indicates it connotes at once the sensuous, the socio-political
and spiritual dimensions of life 19. By the association of the fire and
the rose, metaphorically T.S Eliot shows that he eventually accepts
the tormenting fire that leads him to catch the rose of redemption. In
fact, the imagery of the fire and the rose being one conveys that the
poet in Four Quartets, like Dante in Paradise, accepts all the
psychological
and
physical
suffering
that
leads
him
to
reach
redemption within one point of existence between the Fire and Rose.
In this context, Willis E.P. McNelly in his seminal thesis entitled T.S
Eliots
Four
Quartets
Study
in
explanation
give
another
perspective of these lines. He says that In that unity "all shall be well"
and the Divine Fire is changed from a fire of trial and purgation to a fire
of Eternal Peace.20 Similarly, Lowe Peter James in his thesis Christian
Romanticism: T. S. Eliot's response to Percy Bysshe Shelley confirms
that Eliot brings together the purgatorial fire and the divine rose,
19 T.S Eliot Qtd in Dominic Manganiello, T.S. Eliot & Dante, Eliots book of
memory, (London: The Macmillan Press LTD, 1989)p.122
20 Willis Everett McNelly, T.S Eliots Four Quartets: a Study in explanation
(Chicago: Loyola University, 1948)p.115
22
23
difference between the two poems lies in the different period of time
each work was written. Though the context is different, Eliot imitates
Dante and succeds to integrate much of his principles within his later
work Four Quartets. In this context, Bloom says that Apophrades is
the process by which the poem is held open to the precursor, where
once it was open, and the uncanny effect is that the new poem's
achievement makes it seem to us, not as though the precursor were
writing it, but as though the later poet himself had written the
precursor's characteristic work.22
To sum up, like Dante in Paradiso, T.S Eliot in Four Quartets is
definitely settled in his faith. Therefore, unlike the previous poems
where Eliot reaches an ironic effect in his borrowing from Dante, in this
poem the allusions to Dante are definitely not ironic. Because of his
religious maturity in his later poem, Eliots mission to redeem the
society becomes possible. Therefore, through the different trajectories
in his poetic career, Eliot as a modernist poet succeeds to transcend
the chaos in his society and to fulfil his mission of redemption. In fact,
throughout the analysis of the presence of Dante in Four Quartets,
the sincere and faithful imitation of Eliot from Dante becomes tenable.
The religious maturity and the spiritual growth of T.S Eliot are the
reason behind the absence of ironic elements in the later poetry.
22Bloom Harold, The Anxiety of Influence (New York: Oxford university
press, 1997)p.18
24