Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ISBN: 978-1-62618-930-0
2013 Nova Science Publishers, Inc.
Chapter 4
ABSTRACT
The Research Group Psychological Styles, Gender and Health
(EPSY) is working on topics such as differences between sexes in ailing
and dying and the consequences of these on health practice, quality of life
and degree of personal satisfaction, stress and psychological problems
suffered by women and men, all from the gender perspective.
In order to operationalize the gender, the group used femininity and
masculinity concepts. Mahalik et al. (2003, 2005) define femininity as the
degree of people's conformity (emotional, cognitive and/or behavioural)
with a series of gender norms that designate what is considered socially
appropriate for women, are transmitted by each culture and can be
identified as such by the members of every society. Therefore, we
consider that femininity/masculinity is a psychological dimension, which
can, moreover, be measured or assessed.
82
83
Lpez, 2004) and, on the other hand, while men have been considered the
references in these studies, they didnt take into account the risk factor related
to the masculinity in men (Courtenay, 2000a; Courtenay, 2000b).
When we speak about sex we mean the biological characteristics
(chromosomal, gonadal, hormonal, cerebral and genital dimorphism, etc).
Gender is the result of an evolutionary process, a social category, which
indicates the non-existence of traits or types of conduct that might intrinsically
a priori belong to one sex or the other, and through which social norms and
expectations are interiorised. The term also refers to the individuals
psychological feeling of being male or female, including the social and
psychological types of behaviour designed by society as masculine or feminine
(Barber & Martnez-Benlloch, 2004; Fernndez, 1996, 1998; Laqueur, 1990;
Maccoby, 1990). Therefore, gender as a social concept is sensitive to
variations and changes that may take place in any society.
On the other hand, gender is a variable that must be taken into
consideration from the moment of the assessment, in order to
provide an accurate diagnosis of the reality and not only when interpreting the
results. Therefore, in our studies we have chosen two questionnaires that
evaluate peoples conformity to a series of feminine/masculine gender norms:
the Conformity to Feminine Norms Inventory (Mahalik et al., 2005) and the
Conformity to Masculine Norms Inventory (Mahalik et al., 2003) in order to
study how gender relates to health. We chose these instruments because both
measurements offer a series of advantages regarding other instruments: they
are updated instruments, since they have been created quite recently and
incorporate a multidimensional perspective of gender. In this way they work
with the constructs of femininity and masculinity not as homogeneous
entities, but as multiples (there would be different femininities and
masculinities to which people would identify themselves in different
degrees).
Regarding the concept of (emotional, cognitive and/or behavioural)
conformity to the feminine/masculine gender norms, Mahalik et al. (2005,
2003) define it as the degree of satisfaction in social expectations, for what is
considered feminine/masculine in private or public life. The statements were
designed to measure various attitudes, beliefs, and behaviours associated to
feminine gender roles, both traditional and untraditional. From this
perspective, it comes before saying that, for example, in the case of women,
they receive many messages about how they should think, feel, or be. These
norms are more or less accepted, depending on each woman. Therefore, any
84
instrument that evaluates femininity should also assess the relevance of these
feminine norms for every woman.
When literature about health and gender is reviewed, many articles appear,
that take into account sex, but not gender. Although the first step in
introducing a gender perspective is to divide data by sex, results about sex
differences bring up an important phenomenon, but they explain little about
the processes that may be responsible for the observed differences (Mechanic,
1978) and ignore important within-group differences in men and women
(Addis & Mahalik, 2003).
85
86
member state to another. Hereby, in 2009, the largest difference between the
genders was found in Lithuania (11.2 years) and the smallest in Sweden (4.1
years) (Eurostat, 2011). For a long time, men's shorter life span was
considered natural and unavoidable. Besides the unquestionable biological
component, little was known on why adult men engage in less healthy
lifestyles and adopt fewer health-promoting beliefs and behaviors. This has
reached to the point that health risks associated to men's gender or masculinity
have remained largely unproblematic and taken for granted. It is well known
that men of all ages are more likely to engage in alcohol and tobacco use
(Hudd et al., 2000; WHO, 2002, 2004). Therefore, men engage in more health
risk behaviours, compared to women (Courtenay, 2000) as part of developing
a masculine identity (Courtenay, 2001; Harrison, Chin & Ficarrotto, 1992).
Research supports this connection, resulting that men who adopt traditional
constructions of masculinity are more likely to engage in risky health practices
(Mahalik, Burns & Syzdek, 2007), drug abuse (Liu & Iwamoto, 2007; Mahalik
et al., 2003), risky sexual behavior (Mahalik, Lagan & Morrison, 2006; Pleck,
Sonenstein & Ku, 1994) or use less frequently mental health services (Addis &
Mahalik, 2003). Other works based on individual differences in masculinity
ideology and gender-role conflict have examined the relationship between
these differences and the attitudes toward help seeking (Good et al., 1995;
Wisch, Mahalik, Hayes & Nutt, 1995). The results showed that many of the
tasks associated with seeking help from a health professional, such as relying
on others, admitting a need for help, or recognizing and labelling an emotional
problem, are perceived as conflicting in regard to the messages men receive
about the importance of self-reliance, physical toughness, and emotional
control (Good, Dell & Mintz, 1989; Levant & Pollack, 1995; Pleck, 1981;
Pollack, 1998; Real, 1997).
On the other hand, some studies suggest that reliance on traditionally
masculine characteristics, such as acting independently and being assertive and
decisive, has been found to enable men to cope with cancer (Gordon, 1995)
and chronic illness (Charmaz, 1995). These studies prove that while some
masculine gender norms may often be adaptive and healthy, others may be
associated with social stress factors.
87
achieve this aim we will analyze different research works realized by the
research group EPSY on gender and general health in women and men.
The analysis of different research works (some presented at international
conferences and other already published) is summarized in Table 1 and Table
2. At our studies, the participants are Spanish and Romanian. The Spanish
participants are college students and nurses. As for Romanian participants,
they are people who live in Romania, but also Romanian immigrants who live
in Spain.
Before starting to analyse these results, we have to mention that health
variables taken into account are not always the same, but differ from one
research to the other (in some researches, the same health indexes have been
used).
As Table 1 shows, the degree of conformity to gender norms in our studies
is related to some of the health indices contemplated. There is just one gender
norm which positively correlate to self-perceived health, and that is, in the
case of Romanian women living in Spain, Nice in Relationship. Those gender
norms that negatively correlate to self-perceived health are: Care for children,
Sexual Fidelity, Domestic, Modesty and Invest in appearance. This leads to the
conclusion that women who appreciate friendship and support feel that they
enjoy better state of health.
On the other hand, women who are interested in caring for children,
having sex within a committed relationship, women who are concerned about
home care and use resources to maintain and improve their physical
appearance have poorer self-perceived health.
Another health index used by EPSY was the one concerning the physical
complaints. Women who obtain higher scores on Nice in Relationships,
Thinness and Sexual Fidelity have more physical complaints (see Table 1).
Women who obtain lower scores on Nice in Relationship consume medication.
When it is about both alcohol and tobacco use, while Thinness, Romantic
Relationship and Invest in Appearance are positively related to these
behaviours, almost all the others norms are negatively related to the same
behaviours. At the same times, higher scores on Thinness, Modesty, Romantic
Relationship and Invest in Appearance are positively correlated to worst
mental health, whereas Care for Children is negatively correlated to worst
mental health. Women who obtain higher scores on Thinness report more
sleep problems.
Title
Journal or Congress
Participants n
Positive
relationship
Snchez-Lpez, M.
Masculinity and Femininity as
P., Rivas-Diez, R. &
Predictors of Tobacco and
Manuscript. (being
Cullar-Flores, I.
Alcohol Consumption in
evaluated)
(being evaluated)
Spanish University Students
Spanish
university
students
: 419
: 435
Snchez-Lpez,
Health and Conformity with
M.P., Saavedra, A.I. Traditional Gender Norms in
& Dresch, V. (2012) Men and Women Nurses
Alcohol use 3, 6, 8
Spanish nurses 3
:98
Psychological
: 98
health (GHQ12) - 2
Brabete, A. C.,
Snchez-Lpez, M. The Impact of Gender Norms
P. , Cullar-Flores, I. on Alcohol and Tobacco Use
& Rivas-Diez, R. ( at Romanians
2012)
Oral communication.
PSIWORLD Congress 2012
(International). (Romania)
Oral communication.
PSIWORLD Congress 2011
How does the Gender
(International). (Romania)
influence Peoples Health?
Data of a Sample of Romanian
people living in Spain
Manuscript. Procedia Social
and Behavioral Sciences.33,
pp. 148-152
Brabete, A. C. &
Snchez-Lpez, M.
P. (2011, 2012)
Snchez-Lpez, M.
The Impact of Gender Roles
P., Cullar-Flores, I.
on Health
& Dresch, V. (2011)
Romanian
people :489
:261
Negative
relationship
Tobacco
consumption 7, 6
Alcohol
consumption - 7
Tobacco use- 2, 9
Alcohol use 5
Self-perceived
health 5
Psychological
88ealth (GHQ-12)
6
Tobacco use- 2, 4,
5
Tobacco use-8
Alcohol use- 2, 4,
5, 6, 7
Self-perceived
health - 1
Romanian
N Physical
people living in
complaints - 3
Spain :48
Tobacco use-8
:70
Alcohol use 8
Spanish
N Physical
university
complaints - 4
students
Self-perceived
health - 2, 4, 7, 8
Medicine use - 1
Alcohol use - 2 , 4
Tobacco use-6, 7,
8, 9
Alcohol use - 6 , 7,
Authors/Year
Title
Journal or Congress
Participants n
: 226
: 234
Oral communication. 4th
Spanish
World Congress of Womens university
mental health (International). students
Madrid (Spain)
: 164
:164
Oral communication. VII
Congreso Iberoamericano de
Psicologa (International).
Oviedo (Spain)
Spanish
university
students
: 335
: 312
Positive
relationship
Negative
relationship
9
Psychological Psychological
health (GHQ- helath (GHQ-12) 12) - 2
6
Tobacco use- 4
N Physical
Alcohol use - 4, 6
complaints - 1 Self-perceived
health - 4
Spanish
university
students
: 200
Self-perceived
health - 8
Medicine
consumption - 1
Tobacco
consumption- 4, 6,
8, 9
Alcohol
consumption - 1,
4, 6, 9
Psychological
health (GHQ-12)
3, 5
Note.1 = Nice in relationships, 2 = Care for children, 3= Thiness, 4= Sexual fidelity, 5= Modesty, 6= Romantic relationship, 7=
Domestic, 8= Invest in appearance, 9= Total.
Positive relationship
Negative
relationship
Masculinity and
femininity as predictors of
Manuscript. (being
tobacco and alcohol
evaluated)
consumption in Spanish
university students
Oral communication. 20th
Annual Interdisciplinary
Limiana-Gras,R.M. Health and Gender in
Mens Studies Conference
Snchez-Lpez, M.P., Female Dominated
(International), Minneapolis
Saavedra, A.I. &
Occupations: The case of (USA)
Corbaln, F.J. (2012) male nurses
Manuscript. The Journal of
Mens Studies (being
evaluated)
Spanish
university
students
: 419
: 435
Tobacco use- 7
Alcohol use- 4, 7
Tobacco use - 10
Alcohol use - 2
Self-perceived health
Spanish nurses - 2
:98
Alcohol use - 4, 7,
: 98
11, 12
N Doctor visits - 3
N Physical
complaints -10
Medicine use - 4
N Doctor visits
2, 6
Work satisfaction
6, 11
Self-perceived health
Spanish nurses - 2
:98
Alcohol use - 4, 7,
: 98
11, 12
N Doctor visits - 3
N Physical
complaints -10
Medicine use - 4
N Doctor visits
2, 6
Work satisfaction
6, 11
Authors/Year
Title
Journal or Congress
Snchez-Lpez, M. P.,
Rivas-Diez, R. &
Cullar-Flores, I.
(being evaluated)
Brabete, A. C.,
Snchez-Lpez, M. P.
, Cullar-Flores, I. &
Rivas-Diez, R. ( 2012)
Brabete, A. C. &
Snchez-Lpez, M. P.
Oral communication.
PSIWORLD Congress 2012
(International). (Romania)
Oral communication.
PSIWORLD Congress 2011
Romanian
people :489
:261
Tobacco use-3, 4, 5,
6
Alcohol use- 3, 4, 7
Romanian
people living
N Physical
complaints- 4
Self-perceived
health - 4,5, 7
Authors/Year
Title
Journal or Congress
Participants n
Positive relationship
Negative
relationship
Medicine use - 6
Tobacco use 6,
9
Alcohol use -10
Tobacco use-10
Psychological
health (GHQ-12)
-9
Psychological
health (GHQ-12)
-2
Table 2. (Continued)
Authors/Year
Title
Journal or Congress
Oral communication. VII
Congreso Iberoamericano
de Psicologa
(International).
Oviedo (Spain)
Negative
relationship
Participants n
Positive relationship
Spanish
university
students
: 335
: 312
Tobacco use- 1, 7
Tobacco use-10
Alcohol use 1, 10
N Physical
Self-perceived health
complaints - 2
1, 3
Note. 1= Winning, 2 = Emotional Control, 3= Risk Taking, 4 = Violence 5 = Power over women, 6 = Dominant, 7 = Playboy, 8= SelfReliance, 9 = Primacy of work, 10 = Disdain for homosexuality, 11 = Pursuit of status, 12= Total.
93
CONCLUSION
These results confirm previous researches that analyzed the relationships
between gender norms and health (for example, Courtenay, 2000a; Mahalik et
al., 2003, Mahalik, Lagan & Morrison, 2006; Mahalik, Burns & Syzdek,
2007). They show that the roles assigned and assumed by men and women
have an important part in explaining their health, their behaviour and their use
of health services.
94
95
men. In our studies, we found that gender norms are related to Health, but this
relationship differs, depending on the participants (nurses, students,
Romanians, Romanian immigrants) although some gender norms are common
to all men as a group or to all women as a group.
These conclusions have important implications on action on health, since
they show how important feminine and masculine gender identity is, with
regard to health behaviour, the use of medicines and presence or recognition of
illnesses. This knowledge has a potentially practical use in health programmes
and in social health activities, and stresses the need to introduce the gender
perspective into research and action related to health. We consider that studies
on mens and womens health status and perception will need to bear in mind
the heterogeneity within each group, with the purpose of refining analyses,
detecting subgroups at risk and promoting more effective techniques for health
care.
In practice, it has been noted that the cognitive restructuring worked in the
case of the gender patterns (e.g. Barrowclough et al; Hensley et al., 2004). The
aim of these techniques is to change the gender patterns for men and women
(Mahalik, 1999; Mahalik & Morrison, 2006) that interfere with health
behaviours. This will work on the question of prevention in order to reduce
risk behaviours and increase health-promoting behaviours.
REFERENCES
Addis, M.E. & Mahalik, J.R. (2003). Men, masculinity, and the contexts of
help-seeking. American Psychologist, 58, 5-14.
Arias, E., Anderson, R.N., Kung, H.C., Murphy, S.L. & Kochanek, K.D.
(2003). Deaths: Final data for 2001. National Vital Statistics Reports, 53,
1-115.
Barber, E. & Martnez Benlloch, I. (cords.). (2004). Psicologa y gnero
[Psychology and gender]. Madrid: Pearson Prentice Hall.
Barrowclough, C., King, P., Colville, J., Russell, E., Burns, A. & Tarrier, N.
(2001). A randomised trial of the effectiveness of cognitive-behavioural
therapy and supportive counselling for anxiety symptoms in older adults.
Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 69, 756-762.
Bayne-Smith, M. (1996). Race, Gender, and Health. Sage Publications,
Thousand Oaks, CA.
Bernrdez, A. (2005). La publicidad como contrato comunicativo [Advertising
as communicative contract]. In B. Lpez Driga (coord.) La publicidad y
96
97
Courtenay, W.H. & Keeling, R.P. (2000). Men, Gender, and Health: Toward
and Interdisciplinary Approach. Journal of American College Health, 48,
243-246.
Cullar-Flores, I. & Snchez-Lpez, M.P. (2011). Masculinity: How can be
made operative and its use in health. In M.E. Harrison & P. W. Schnarrs
(Eds). The 17th Annual American Mens Studies Association Conference
Proceedings. Mens Studies Press, LLC.
Eurostat (2011). Mortality and life expectancy statistics. Available at
epp.eurostat.ec.europa.eu/statistics_explained/index.php/Mortality_and_lif
e_expectancy_statistics.
Evans, O., & Steptoe, A. (2002). The contribution of gender-role orientation,
work factor and home stressors to psychological well-being and sickness
absence in male and female dominated occupational groups. Social
Science and Medicine, 54, 481-492.
Fernndez, J. (1996). Varones y mujeres. Desarrollo de la doble realidad del
sexo y del gnero [Men and women. Development of the double reality of
sex and gender]. Madrid:Piramide.
Fernndez, J. (1998). Nuevas perspectivas en el desarrollo del sexo y el
gnero [A new outlook in the development of sex and gender]. Madrid:
Piramide.
Gijsbers van Wijk, C.M.T., van Vliet, K.P., Kolk, K.P. & Everaerd, W.T.
(1991). Symptom sensitivity and sex differences in physical morbidity: A
review of health surveys in the United States and the Netherlands. Women
and Health, 17, 91-124.
Gispert, R. & Gutirrez-Fisac, J.L. (1997). Esperanza de vida saludable:
pasado y presente de un indicador con futuro [Healthy life expectancy:
past and present of a future indicator]. Revisiones Salud Publica, 5, 7-32.
Gonzlez de Chvez, M.A. (1998). Feminidad y masculinidad: subjetividad y
orden simblico [Femininity and masculinity: subjectivity and symbolic
order]. Madrid: Biblioteca Nueva.
Gonzlez de Chvez, M.A. (1999). Hombres y mujeres: subjetividad, salud y
gnero [Men and women: subjectivity, health and gender]. Las Palmas de
Gran Canaria: Universidad.
Good, G.E., Dell, D.M., & Mintz, L.B. (1989). Male role and gender role
conflict: Relations to help seeking in men. Journal of Counseling
Psychology, 36, 295-300.
Good, G.E., Robertson, J.M., ONeil, J.M., Fitzgerald, L.F., Stevens, M.,
DeBord, K., Bartels, K. M., & Braverman, D. G. (1995). Male gender role
98
99
100
Mechanic, D. (1978). Sex, illness behavior, and the use of health services.
Social Science and Medicine, 12, 207214.
Mechanic, D., & Cleary, P.D., 1980. Factors associated with the maintenance
of positive health behaviour. Preventive Medicine, 9, 805-814.
Mokdad, A.H., Marks, J.S., Stroup, D.F., & Gerberding, J.L. (2004). Actual
causes of death in the United States, 2000. Journal of the American
Medical Association, 291, 1238-1245.
Neff, J.A., Prihoda, T.J., & Hoppe, S.K. (1991). Machismo, self-esteem,
education and high maximum drinking among Anglo, Black and MexicanAmerican male drinkers. Journal of Studies on Alcohol, 52, 458-463.
Perula, L.A., Martnez, D. L. I., Ruiz, R., & Fonseca, P.J. (1995). Variables
relacionadas con el estado de salud autopercibido: estudio
poblacional[Variables related to self-perceived health status: population
study]. Atencin Primaria, 16, 323-329.
Pleck, J. H. (1981). The myth of masculinity. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
Pleck, J. H., Sonenstein, F. L., & Ku, L. C. (1994). Problem behaviours and
masculinity ideology in adolescent males. In R. D. Ketterlinus & M. E.
Lamb (Eds.), Adolescent problem behaviours: Issues and research (pp.
165186). Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum.
Pollack, W. (1998). Real boys: Rescuing our sons from the myths of boyhood.
New York: Random House.
Real, T. (1997). I dont want to talk about it: Overcoming the legacy of male
depression. New York: Fireside.
Rodrguez-Sanz, M., Carrillo, P., & Borrell, C. (2005). Desigualdades sociales
en la salud, los estilos de vida y la utilizacin de servicios sanitarios en las
CC. AA. 1993-2003. [Social inequalities in Health, lifestyles and use of
health services in the Autonomous Communities]. Madrid: Observatorio
de Salud de la Mujer y del SNS, Ministerio de Sanidad y Consumo.
Rossi, J.S. (1992). March. Stages of change for 15 health risk behaviours in an
HMO population. Paper presented at the 13th annual scientific sessions of
the Society of Behavioural Medicine, New York.
Snchez-Lpez, M. P. (2003). Mujer y salud: familia, trabajo y sociedad
[Woman and health: Work, family and society]. Madrid: Daz de Santos.
Snchez-Lpez, M.P. (2004). Womens Health. In C. Spielberger (Ed.).
Encyclopedia of Applied Psychology. Volume 3. Elsevier Academic
Press.
101
102