You are on page 1of 56

Shell

LubeAnalyst

Oil and equipment


condemnation limits
Strictly private and confidential
For internal use only

Shell Lubricants

Index
Page Number
3
Introduction
3-4
Setting oil Analysis Alarms
5-6
Oil Analysis: General Information
7
Rejection standards
8
Off-Highway: Diesel Engines
9
Diesel and Gasoline Engines (Passenger Cars)
10
On-Highway: HD Diesel Engines ACEA E2 / API CG-4 10,000 km
11
On-Highway: HD Diesel Engines ACEA E5 / API CH-4 40,000 km
12
On-Highway: HD Diesel Engines ACEA E7 / API CI-4 60,000 km
13
On-Highway: HD Diesel Engines ACEA E4 / API CI-4 100.000 km
14
Aviation Piston Engines
15
Aviation Diesel Engines
16
Medium Speed Diesel Engines Burning Heavy Fuel Oil
17
Medium Speed Diesel Engines Burning Light Fuel Oil, Marine Diesel or Automotive Diesel
18
Gas Engines
19
On-Highway Heavy Duty Automatic Transmissions
20
On-Highway: Manual and Automated Manual Gearboxes
21
On-Highway: Axles and Differential Gears
22
Off-Highway Power Shift Transmissions
23
Off-Highway Non-Shiftable Gears, with / without Wet Brakes
24
Agri: Tractor Transmissions and Tractor Hydraulic Systems
25
Off-Highway Axles, Final Drives, Reduction Gears and Slew-Drives
26
Mobile Hydraulic Systems, Detergent Type of Oils
27
Mobile Hydraulic Systems, Non-Detergent Type of Oils
28
Mobile Hydraulic Systems, Biodegradable Oils
29
Industrial Gears
30
Steam Turbines
31
Steam Turbines Fire Resistant Control Fluids
32
Gas Turbines, Industrial
33
Gas Turbines, Aero-Derivatives - Land Based
34
Hydraulic: Mineral Oils
35
Hydraulic: Biodegradable Oils
36
Hydraulic: Synthetic Food Grade
37
Hydraulic: Type HFC
38
Hydraulic: Type HFDU
39
Bearing Lubrication - Wire Rod Mill (Morlina T)
40
Bearing Lubrication - Morgoil Bearing ( Morlina / Morlina SD / Vitrea M )
41
Heat Transfer Oils Thermal Oils
42
Electrical Oils: Transformer Oils
43
Piston Gas Compressors
44
Piston Air Compressors
45
Centrifugal Air and Gas Compressors
46
Vane and Screw Compressors - Air and Gas
47
Refrigerating Compressors Refrigerant: CFC, HCFC, HC, CO2
48
Refrigerating Compressors Refrigerant: NH3
49
Refrigerating Compressors Refrigerant: HFC
50
Diesel Fuel
50
Unleaded Gasoline 95
50
Domestic Fuel
51
Coolants for Engines
52
Electro-Erosion Fluids
53
Metal Working Fluids
54
Circulating Oils
55
Seal Oils
56
Table of Changes
-2
This document is strictly confidential & for Internal Shell Use only. It is the basis of the agreement with our Laboratories
for the diagnosis of oil samples.

Introduction
First of all welcome to the new issue of the Shell Lube Analyst Limits Guide, the intension of this book is to provide
you with additional technical information on the limits currently used for Shell Lube Analyst in Europe. These are
formally agreed with our supplier SGS and are used to aid the diagnosis process.
The limits contained within this guidebook are owned and maintained by nominated product category experts within
the relevant Shell line of business, if you require updates or changes to these limits they must be submitted to the
Limits Owner for agreement. This is vital as this document form part of the contracted service agreement between
Shell and our supplier. Changing limits without very careful consideration can have a significant impact for
customers so please contact the owners, the names can be found at the bottom of each page of the book.

Setting Oil Analysis Alarms


1. Absolute alarms
These are alarms based on manufacturers recommendations and/or lubricant supplier technical bulletins. These
alarms generally define working ranges or condemnation limits and are most applicable to lubricant and
contamination condition. Absolute alarm limits matter greatly when warranties on new equipment are at issue.
Failure to comply with the recommendations is often viewed as justification for not honouring warranties. In many
critical applications OEM limits are used in the Lube Analyst Limits Guide

2. Statistical alarms
Manufacturers guidelines for alarm limits or general standards are disadvantaged in that they are based on average
operational and performance situations, which may not accurately reflect the actual conditions of a specific machine.
This is particularly applicable to machine condition. Statistical alarms limits are based on gathering a small sampling
of data from equipment, analysing the distribution of that data, and using this statistical characterization to set
specific alarm limits. Statistical trend analysis allows the identification of the equipment in greatest need of attention,
thus allocating maintenance in an efficient way.

3. Combining absolute and statistical alarms


Effective oil analysis exception management relies on the combination of both types of alarms. The following
illustration is an example of the alarm combination. The condemnation limit is the absolute alarm. Statistical
trending, taking into account variability based on the sampling, contamination, make-up oil etc. will develop the
standard deviations. Departure from this normal variability signals genuine problems occurring. This is the earliest
possible time to take action and head off problems. Failing this, as the trend approaches its warning limit, action
such as changing or cleaning the oil, or inspection of the unit is required.

fig 1: The idealized graph shown is an example of how absolute and trend line alarms are used together. The test
used could be iron content, viscosity or other parameter. The normal result variability range takes into account minor
-3
This document is strictly confidential & for Internal Shell Use only. It is the basis of the agreement with our Laboratories
for the diagnosis of oil samples.

variations caused by analytical accuracy, sample homogeneity, etc. as the trend approaches the warning limit, some
action must be taken, either cleaning the oil or inspecting the equipment.

Establishing statistical alarms, which provide the earliest possible warning without false alarms is a difficult task.
Factors such as adding or changing oil, filter changes, sampling technique can distort results. However, if the
following foundation steps are employed, a very good oil analysis and lubrication management program will be the
result.

-4
This document is strictly confidential & for Internal Shell Use only. It is the basis of the agreement with our Laboratories
for the diagnosis of oil samples.

Oil Analysis: General Information


1. Know your equipment.
Many engineers and technicians do not know their equipment from a lubrication viewpoint. Information such as oil
wetted component metallurgy, equipment loading conditions and environment are very important, and contribute a
great deal in solving problems shown up by oil analysis. Equipment maintenance manuals are sometimes useful
sources of information and may even contain the commissioning engineers Oil Analysis Reports for some
equipment.

2. Check equipment specifications


Many manufacturers of equipment have published specifications for lubricants and their maintenance. All
manufacturers of turbine systems and diesel engines have recommended guidelines with absolute limits for
degradation, wear metals and contamination, Caterpillar is a good example their manual contain limits. Many
manufacturers of compressors, turbines and hydraulics have similar notes. These specific limits can be a key input
when registering new equipment in our.

3. Assess your Lubricant


Shell Lube Analyst frequently finds incorrect lubricant types and/or grades in equipment. A common problem
recently is the use of synthetic lubricants, with different baseline properties or top up with incorrect grades. Often
these changes are not notified and can cause alarms or comments on the reports.

4. Fresh oil tests


We have now established a process for new product introductions and fresh oil baseline testing. Jane Paules is the
owner of this process so please notify her of new product introductions or if you see gaps in the fresh oil test data
book. You can send the lab samples of all your new oil, so that a baseline analysis can be performed. This must be
done via Jane and the results will then be added to the Fresh Oil Test Data book and used to enhance the quality of
diagnosis and limit setting in the future. This is part of our agreed contract with SGS and is part of the contracted
service so no addition costs are incurred for us.

5. Sample carefully
Poor sampling can cause distortion of several hundred percent in sample data. Follow established guidelines for
sampling, and sample from the same point each time. Air, oil and filter changes and conditions can result in distorted
alarms. Similarly, not recording or reporting topping up and/or bleed and feed operations have the effect of artificially
changing wear, contamination and additive levels without any real change in equipment or lubricant condition. These
events must be recorded so as to take account of variations to trend lines.

6. Operation time
Statistical trending programs are not always technically valid without including operation time. For example a
standard trend alarm for wear metals and contaminants is to signal an alert when an increase of 10 ppm over a 10
hour period is found in any of the spectrochemical analysis readings. Engine users often do track running
hours/kilometres or miles etc, in order to determine drain intervals, and schedule overhauls. Oil trend data for diesel
engines is generally highly developed, with manufacturers specifying absolute limits and trend alarms. Rotating
machinery users generally do not have tachometers fitted to equipment, and in cases of turbines, hydraulics and
large gearboxes, the oil is present since installation, and the units are running continuously. Time based sampling
the most common and effective method in these cases, especially when performed at regular intervals. Avoid
random sampling, as their predictive value can be suspect. In all cases, record the date when sampling.

7. Establish baseline trends


Taking one sample from a piece of equipment that has had no previous history will not give you information about
the wear trend of the machine, and it is difficult to set alarms at this point. A monthly analysis for three consecutive
months will establish a good wear trend. At this stage, a decision may be made on the sampling frequency of that
equipment (with criticality factored in) based on the data received. This is an example of how the program manages
both the equipment and itself by exception, thereby reducing the effort needed to maintain it by busy personnel.

-5
This document is strictly confidential & for Internal Shell Use only. It is the basis of the agreement with our Laboratories
for the diagnosis of oil samples.

8. The use of these limits


The diagnose of oil samples requires extensive experience and these limits are by no means intended to replace or
reduce the knowledge that our laboratories diagnosticians apply when providing their diagnosis and
recommendations. Limits are never considered as single line items, which cause a red or amber flag to be made,
they are looked at holistically and in combination with all the results before the final diagnosis is made.

9. Useful conversions and abbreviations


Conversion percentage ICP values to PPM;
100% = 1,000,000 ppm
10% =100,000ppm
1% = 10,000ppm
0.1% = 1,000ppm and so on
Blotter spot info;
IC = Contamination Index (the concentration of combustion residues expressed in %)
MD = Merit of Dispersancy (is the dispersant residual ability of the oil)
M.D. = 100 the dispersion is excellent. The distribution of combustion contaminants on the filter paper is
homogeneous.
M.D. = 0 the dispersion is poor. The combustion contaminants are concentrated in the centre of the spot.
DP = Demerit Points (is the following calculation [D.P. = (100 - M.D.) x I.C.].)
D.P. = 0 (or close) shows very low contamination and excellent dispersancy.
D.P. tending towards 100 or more shows heavy contamination and poor dispersancy.

-6
This document is strictly confidential & for Internal Shell Use only. It is the basis of the agreement with our Laboratories
for the diagnosis of oil samples.

Rejection Standards

-7
This document is strictly confidential & for Internal Shell Use only. It is the basis of the agreement with our Laboratories
for the diagnosis of oil samples.

Off-Highway: Diesel Engines


Lower limits

Upper limits

Red

Amber

Amber

Red

12.5

13.7

Analysis

Method

Units

Viscosity at 100C
(ASTM D445)

SAE 30

cSt

8.4

9.3

SAE 40

cSt

11.2

12.5

16.3

18.0

Water Content

ASTM D6304

ppm

2000

5000

Flash Point (Pensky


Maertens)

ASTM D93

160

180

TBN (Base Number)

ASTM D2896

Spectrometry

ASTM D5185-05

mg
40% of fresh oil 60% of fresh oil
KOH/g

Aluminum (Al)

ppm

12

24

Iron (Fe)

ppm

60

100

Chromium (Cr)

ppm

10

Copper (Cu)

ppm

20

40

Lead (Pb)

ppm

20

40

Tin (Sn)

ppm

10

20

Sodium (Na)

ppm

20

50

Silicon (Si)

ppm

15

25

30% of fresh oil

Calcium (Ca)

20% of fresh oil 30% of fresh oil

Diesel Fuel Dilution

ASTM D3524

4.0

6.0

Glycol Content

ASTM D2982

0.10

0.30

2.00

3.00

65

85

Index of Contamination
(IC)
Blotter Spot Test (In
House Method) Merit of Dispersancy
(MD)

Remarks

Remarks:
These limits apply to the following products:
RIMULA X, -SUPER, R3, R4, R5 after 300 to 500 hrs

Page owner: Hans Wildeboer/Paul Evers


Last update: 18/03/2008

-8
This document is strictly confidential & for Internal Shell Use only. It is the basis of the agreement with our Laboratories
for the diagnosis of oil samples.

Diesel and Gasoline Engines (Road Transport)


Passenger Cars
Lower limits
Analysis

Viscosity at 100C
(ASTM D445)

Upper limits

Red

Amber

Amber

Red

Remarks
8.3~HTHS- that's already below
minimum!

Method

Units

SAE 30

cSt

8.3

9.3

12.5

14.2

SAE 40

cSt

10.1

12.5

16.3

18.7

SAE 50

cSt

13.4

16.3

21.9

24.8

Flash Point (Pensky


Maertens)

ASTM D93

150

180

Water Content

ASTM D6304

ppm

2000

5000

TBN (Base Number)

ASTM D2896

To accommodate low SAPS oils


BUT: The effects of long term
low TBN driving are unknown.
(Limited experience)

Index of Contamination
(IC)

mg
30% of fresh oil 50% of fresh oil
KOH/g

Diesel Engine:
2.0%

Test does not


work >3%

Test does not work for Gasoline


engines

Blotter Spot Test (In Merit of Dispersancy


House Method)
(MD)

80

Diesel Engine

Merit of Dispersancy
(MD)

80

Gasoline Engine

Spectrometry

Not useful as to many engine


types exist to enable limits to be
set. Diagnostician's experience
required.

ASTM D5185-05

Aluminum (Al)

ppm

Iron (Fe)

ppm

Chromium (Cr)

ppm

Copper (Cu)

ppm

Lead (Pb)

ppm

Molybdenum (Mo)

ppm

Tin (Sn)

ppm

Sodium (Na)

ppm

Silicon (Si)

ppm

Example: 60ppm Fe is end of


ODI for gasoline, 250 ppm is
normal for modern diesel.

Diesel Fuel Dilution

ASTM D3524

7.0

RME use is the problem

Gasoline Fuel
Dilution

ASTM D322

7.0

10.0

Glycol Content

ASTM D2982

0.05

0.10

Up to 20% during winter in short


trip driving is possible

Remarks:

Page owner: Hans Wildeboer/Paul Evers


Last update: 08/07/2005

-9
This document is strictly confidential & for Internal Shell Use only. It is the basis of the agreement with our Laboratories
for the diagnosis of oil samples.

On-Highway: HD Diesel Engines ACEA E2 / API CG-4 10,000 km


Lower limits
Units

Upper limits

Red

Amber

Amber

Red

Remarks

Analysis

Method

Viscosity at 100C
(ASTM D445)

SAE 30

cSt

9.5

10.5

11.5

12.5

Red Limits: Outside SAE

SAE 40

cSt

12.5

13.5

15.3

16.3

Amber Limits: +/-2

Water Content

ASTM D6304

ppm

2000

5000

Flash Point (Pensky


Maertens)

ASTM D93

160

180

TBN (Total Base


Number)

ASTM D2896

Spectrometry

ASTM D5185-05

mg
40% of fresh oil 60% of fresh oil
KOH/g

Aluminum (Al)

ppm

Iron (Fe)

ppm

20

40

Chromium (Cr)

ppm

Copper (Cu)

ppm

10

Lead (Pb)

ppm

Molybdenum (Mo)

ppm

Tin (Sn)

ppm

Sodium (Na)

ppm

20

50

Silicon (Si)

ppm

15

25

Diesel Fuel Dilution

ASTM D3524

2.0

4.0

Glycol Content

ASTM D2982

0.10

0.30

1.00

2.00

75

85

Index of Contamination
(IC)
Blotter Spot Test (In
House Method) Merit of Dispersancy
(MD)

Remarks:
1. The figures given for wear metals are very approximate and based on an oil usage time of 10,000 km.
2. Heavy Duty diesel engines ACEA E2 / API E2
3. ACEA E2 ~ API CF-4
These limits apply to the following products:
Rimula R3 Turbo, Rimula R2 Extra, Rimula D Extra

Page owner: Paul Evers/ Hans Wildeboer


Last update: 18/03/2008

- 10
This document is strictly confidential & for Internal Shell Use only. It is the basis of the agreement with our Laboratories
for the diagnosis of oil samples.

On-Highway: HD Diesel Engines ACEA E5 / API CH-4 40,000 km


Lower limits

Upper limits

Red

Amber

Amber

Red

Remarks

11.5

12.5

Red Limits: Outside SAE


Amber Limits: +/-2

Analysis

Method

Units

Viscosity at 100C
(ASTM D445)

SAE 30

cSt

9.5

10.5

SAE 40

cSt

12.5

13.5

15.3

16.3

Water Content

ASTM D6304

ppm

2000

5000

Flash Point (Pensky


Maertens)

ASTM D93

160

180

TBN (Total Base


Number)

ASTM D2896

Spectrometry

ASTM D5185-05

mg
40% of fresh oil 60% of fresh oil
KOH/g

Aluminum (Al)

ppm

14

Iron (Fe)

ppm

30

60

Chromium (Cr)

ppm

Copper (Cu)

ppm

14

24

Lead (Pb)

ppm

10

20

Molybdenum (Mo)

ppm

Tin (Sn)

ppm

Sodium (Na)

ppm

20

50

Silicon (Si)

ppm

15

25

Diesel Fuel Dilution

ASTM D3524

3.0

5.0

Glycol Content

ASTM D2982

0.10

0.30

1.50

3.00

75

85

Index of Contamination
(IC)
Blotter Spot Test (In
House Method) Merit of Dispersancy
(MD)

Remarks:
1. The figures given for wear metals are very approximate and based on an oil usage time of 40,000 km.
2. Heavy Duty diesel engines ACEA E5 ~ API CH-4
3. ACEA E5 ~ API CH-4
These limits apply to the following products:
Rimula R3 X, Rimula X

Page owner: Paul Evers/ Hans Wildeboer


Last update: 18/03/2008

- 11
This document is strictly confidential & for Internal Shell Use only. It is the basis of the agreement with our Laboratories
for the diagnosis of oil samples.

On-Highway: HD Diesel Engines ACEA E7 / API CI-4 60,000 km


Lower limits

Upper limits

Red

Amber

Amber

Red

Remarks

11.5

12.5

Red Limits: Outside SAE


Amber Limits: +/-2

Analysis

Method

Units

Viscosity at 100C
(ASTM D445)

SAE 30

cSt

9.5

10.5

SAE 40

cSt

12.5

13.5

15.3

16.3

Water Content

ASTM D6304

ppm

2000

5000

Flash Point (Pensky


Maertens)

ASTM D93

160

180

TBN (Total Base


Number)

ASTM D2896

Spectrometry

ASTM D5185-05

mg
40% of fresh oil 60% of fresh oil
KOH/g

Aluminum (Al)

ppm

12

24

Iron (Fe)

ppm

60

100

Chromium (Cr)

ppm

10

Copper (Cu)

ppm

20

36

Lead (Pb)

ppm

18

30

Molybdenum (Mo)

ppm

10

Tin (Sn)

ppm

10

Sodium (Na)

ppm

20

50

Silicon (Si)

ppm

15

25

Diesel Fuel Dilution

ASTM D3524

4.0

6.0

Glycol Content

ASTM D2982

0.10

0.30

2.00

3.00

75

85

Index of Contamination
(IC)
Blotter Spot Test (In
House Method) Merit of Dispersancy
(MD)

Remarks:
1. The figures given for wear metals are very approximate and based on an oil usage time of 60,000 km.
2. Heavy Duty diesel engines ACEA E7 / API CI-4
3. ACEA E7 ~ API CI-4
These limits apply to the following products:
Rimula R4 L, Rimula R4, Rimula R5 E, Rimula Super, Rimula Super FE

Page owner: Paul Evers/ Hans Wildeboer


Last update: 18/03/2008
- 12
This document is strictly confidential & for Internal Shell Use only. It is the basis of the agreement with our Laboratories
for the diagnosis of oil samples.

On-Highway: HD Diesel Engines ACEA E4 / API CI-4 100,000 km


Lower limits

Upper limits

Red

Amber

Amber

Red

Remarks

11.5

12.5

Red Limits: Outside SAE


Amber Limits: +/-2

Analysis

Method

Units

Viscosity at 100C
(ASTM D445)

SAE 30

cSt

9.5

10.5

SAE 40

cSt

12.5

13.5

15.3

16.3

Water Content

ASTM D6304

ppm

2000

5000

Flash Point (Pensky


Maertens)

ASTM D93

160

180

TBN (Total Base


Number)

ASTM D2896

Spectrometry

ASTM D5185-05

mg
40% of fresh oil 60% of fresh oil
KOH/g

Aluminum (Al)

ppm

16

32

Iron (Fe)

ppm

80

160

Chromium (Cr)

ppm

16

Copper (Cu)

ppm

30

50

Lead (Pb)

ppm

25

40

Molybdenum (Mo)

ppm

16

Tin (Sn)

ppm

14

Sodium (Na)

ppm

20

50

Silicon (Si)

ppm

15

25

Diesel Fuel Dilution

ASTM D3524

5.0

7.0

Glycol Content

ASTM D2982

0.10

0.30

2.00

3.00

75

85

Index of Contamination
(IC)
Blotter Spot Test (In
House Method) Merit of Dispersancy
(MD)

Remarks:
1. The figures given for wear metals are very approximate and based on an oil usage time of 100,000 km.
2. Heavy Duty diesel engines ACEA E4 / API CI-4
3. ACEA E4 and E6 are typical European specs for synthetic / long drain oils. Many of them meet API CI-4.
These limits apply to the following products:
Rimula R6 M, Rimula R6 LM, Rimula R5 M, Rimula Ultra, Rimula Signia

Page owner: Paul Evers/ Hans Wildeboer


Last update: 18/03/2008
- 13
This document is strictly confidential & for Internal Shell Use only. It is the basis of the agreement with our Laboratories
for the diagnosis of oil samples.

Aviation Piston Engines


Lower limits
Analysis
Viscosity at 100C
(ASTM D445)

Red

Upper limits

Amber

Amber

Red

Method

Units

SAE 30

cSt

8.3

9.3

12.5

14.2

SAE 40

cSt

10.1

12.5

16.3

18.7

SAE 50

cSt

13.4

16.3

21.9

24.8

Water Content

ASTM D6304

ppm

1000

2000

Spectrometry

ASTM D5185-05

Magnesium (Mg)

ppm

10

20

Aluminum (Al)

ppm

25

45

Iron (Fe)

ppm

90

120

Chromium (Cr)

ppm

20

45

Copper (Cu)

ppm

25

50

Lead (Pb)

ppm

3500

5000

Tin (Sn)

ppm

30

60

Silicon (Si)

ppm

15

50

Sodium (Na)

ppm

20

50

Nickel (Ni)

ppm

15

30

Silver (Ag)

ppm

30

60

Potassium (K)

ppm

20

50

3.0

10.0

Gasoline Fuel
Dilution

ASTM D 322

Remarks

Remarks:
These limits apply to the following products:

Page Owner: Mark Wakem


Last update: 14/02/2008

- 14
This document is strictly confidential & for Internal Shell Use only. It is the basis of the agreement with our Laboratories
for the diagnosis of oil samples.

Aviation Diesel Engines


Lower limits
Analysis

Viscosity at 100C
(ASTM D445)

Upper limits

Red

Amber

Amber

Red

Remarks
8.3~HTHS- that's already below
minimum

Method

Units

SAE 30

cSt

8.3

9.3

12.5

14.2

SAE 40

cSt

10.1

12.5

16.3

18.7

SAE 50

cSt

13.4

16.3

21.9

24.8

Flash Point (Pensky


Maertens)

ASTM D93

150

180

Water Content

ASTM D6304

ppm

2000

5000

TBN (Total Base


Number)

ASTM D2896

To accommodate low SAPS oils


BUT: The effects of long term
low TBN driving are unknown.
(Limited experience)

Index of Contamination
(IC)
Blotter Spot Test (In
House Method) Merit of Dispersancy
(MD)
Spectrometry

mg 30% of fresh oil 50% of fresh oil


value
value
KOH/g

3.00

Test does not


work >3.0

Diesel Engine

80

Diesel Engine

ASTM D5185-05

Aluminum (Al)

ppm

Iron (Fe)

ppm

Chromium (Cr)

ppm

Copper (Cu)

ppm

Lead (Pb)

ppm

Tin (Sn)

ppm

Silicon (Si)

ppm

Sodium (Na)

ppm

Silver (Ag)

ppm

Potassium (K)

ppm

Example 60ppm Fe is end of


ODI for gasoline, 250 ppm is
normal for modern diesel.

Diesel Fuel Dilution

ASTM D3524

7.0

RME use is the problem

Gasoline Fuel
Dilution

ASTM D322

7.0

10.0

Glycol Content

ASTM D2982

0.05

0.10

Remarks:

Page owner: Mark Wakem


Last update: 14/02/2008

- 15
This document is strictly confidential & for Internal Shell Use only. It is the basis of the agreement with our Laboratories
for the diagnosis of oil samples.

Medium Speed Diesel Engines Burning Heavy Fuel Oil


Lower limits

Upper limits

Red

Amber

Amber

Red

110

120

200

220

Analysis

Method

Units

Viscosity at 40C

ASTM D445

cSt

Viscosity at 100C
(ASTM D445)

SAE 30

cSt

9.1

9.7

14.0

14.6

SAE 40

cSt

11.0

11.6

16.8

17.5

Flash Point (Pensky


Maertens)

ASTM D93

170

190

Water Content

ASTM D6304

ppm

2000

3000

Argina XX, XL, X

mg
KOH/g

20

24

Argina T

mg
KOH/g

18

20

BN (Base Number)
(ASTM D2896)

Spectrometry

ASTM D5185-05

Aluminum (Al)

ppm

20

25

Argina XX

ppm

42

54

Argina XL

ppm

42

54

Argina X

ppm

28

36

Argina T

ppm

20

25

ppm

10

Copper (Cu)

ppm

10

Lead (Pb)

ppm

10

Tin (Sn)

ppm

10

Sodium (Na)

ppm

Boron (B)

ppm

10

Silicon (Si)

ppm

25

30

Vanadium (V)

ppm

Nickel (Ni)

ppm

Iron (Fe)

Remarks

Chromium (Cr)

40-80 ppm possible

300 to 400 ppm possible


120 to160 ppm possible

Glycol Content

ASTM D2982

0.03

0.05

Insolubles Npentane

ASTM D893B

1.30

2.00

Insolubles Nheptane

IP316

1.30

2.00

1.30

2.00

Index of Contamination
(IC)
Blotter Spot Test (In
House Method) Merit of Dispersancy
(MD)

D893B = with coagulant

Remarks:
These limits apply to the following products: Argina T, Argina X, Argina XL, Argina XX
They apply to samples taken after filter (i.e. clean oil at engine inlet)

Page owner: Thijs Schasfoort


Last update: 11/02/2008

- 16
This document is strictly confidential & for Internal Shell Use only. It is the basis of the agreement with our Laboratories
for the diagnosis of oil samples.

Medium Speed Diesel Engines Burning Light Fuel Oil, Marine Diesel or
Automotive Diesel
Lower limits

Upper limits

Red

Amber

Amber

Red

Remarks
SAE 40

Analysis

Method

Units

Viscosity at 40C

ASTM D445

cSt

110

120

200

220

Viscosity at 100C

ASTM D445

cSt

-20%

-15%

+20%

+25%

Flash Point (Pensky


Maertens)

ASTM D93

170

190

Water Content

ASTM D6304

ppm

2000

3000

BN (Base Number)

ASTM D2896

Spectrometry

ASTM D5185-05

mg
50% of fresh oil 60% of fresh oil
KOH/g

Aluminum (Al)

ppm

10

20

Iron (Fe)

ppm

20

25

Chromium (Cr)

ppm

10

Copper (Cu)

ppm

10

Lead (Pb)

ppm

10

Tin (Sn)

ppm

10

Sodium (Na)

ppm

25

35

Boron (B)

ppm

10

ppm

20

25

Glycol Content

Silicon (Si)
ASTM D2982

0.03

0.05

Insolubles Npentane

ASTM D893B

1.30

2.00

Insolubles Nheptane

IP316

1.30

2.00

1.30

2.00

Index of Contamination
(IC)
Blotter Spot Test (In
House Method) Merit of Dispersancy
(MD)

D893B = with coagulant

Remarks:
These limits apply to the following products: Gadinia, Gadinia AL, Sirius, Sirius X, Argina S
They apply to samples taken after filter (i.e. clean oil at engine inlet)

Page owner: Thijs Schasfoort


Last update: 11/02/2008
- 17
This document is strictly confidential & for Internal Shell Use only. It is the basis of the agreement with our Laboratories
for the diagnosis of oil samples.

Gas Engines
Lower limits

Upper limits

Red

Amber

Amber

Red

Analysis

Method

Units

Viscosity at 100C
(ASTM D445)

SAE 30

cSt

9.0

9.3

12.5

14.5

SAE 40

cSt

12.0

12.5

16.3

17.5

Water Content

ASTM D6304

ppm

1000

2000

BN (Base Number)

ASTM D2896

mg
40% of fresh oil 50% of fresh oil
KOH/g

TAN (Total Acid


Number)

ASTM D664

mg
KOH/g

Oxidation

+2.5

+3.0

ASTM E2412-04

20

25

Nitration

ASTM E2412-04

20

25

Spectrometry

ASTM D5185-05
ppm

10

20

Aluminum (Al)
Iron (Fe)

ppm

20

30

Chromium (Cr)

ppm

10

Copper (Cu)

ppm

15

25

Lead (Pb)

ppm

20

30

Tin (Sn)

ppm

10

Sodium (Na)

ppm

15

20

Boron (B)

Remarks

Amber = SAE grade limits

Trend to be monitored!

ppm

10

Natural Gas, Biogas

ppm

15

20

Natural Gas, Biogas

Silicon (Si) Sewage Gas, Landfill


Gas

ppm

150

200

Sewage Gas, Landfill Gas

0.03

0.05

< 4.0

< 5.0

Glycol Content

ASTM D2982

Options
IpH Jenbacher

Jenbacher

Insolubles Npentane

ASTM D893

0.5

1.0

Insolubles Nheptane

ASTM D6560

0.5

1.0

0.5

1.0

170

190

X
+30%

Index of Contamination
(IC)
Blotter Spot Test (In
House Method) Merit of Dispersancy
(MD)
Flash Point (Pensky
Maertens)

ASTM D93

Viscosity at 40C

ASTM D445

cSt

-20%

-15%

+25%

Chlorine Content

DIN 51 408/2

ppm

1000

D893B = with coagulant

Remarks:
These limits apply to the following products: Mysella LA, Mysella MA, Mysella XL

Page owner: Thijs Schasfoort


Last update: 11/02/2008

- 18
This document is strictly confidential & for Internal Shell Use only. It is the basis of the agreement with our Laboratories
for the diagnosis of oil samples.

On-Highway Heavy Duty Automatic Transmissions


Lower limits
Analysis

Method

Units

Upper limits

Red

Amber

Amber

Red

Viscosity at 100C

ASTM D445

cSt

-30%

-20%

+20%

+30%

Water Content

ASTM D6304

ppm

500

2000

TAN (Total Acid


Number)

ASTM D664

mg
KOH/g

3.00

3.50

Spectrometry

ASTM D5185-05

Aluminum (Al)

ppm

15

50

Iron (Fe)

ppm

40

100

Chromium (Cr)

ppm

10

20

Copper (Cu)

ppm

25

50

Lead (Pb)

ppm

10

25

Tin (Sn)

ppm

Sodium (Na)

ppm

10

20

Silicon (Si)

ppm

15

20

30% of fresh oil

Calcium (Ca)

Remarks

No limit on Donax TZ

20% of fresh oil 30% of fresh oil

Remarks:
1. In applications using Donax TZ pay particular attention to the silicon concentration. The baseline Donax TZ
silicon 25 30 level is ppm, which exceeds the current amber upper limit. The main application for Donax
TZ is in ZF transmissions.
These limits apply to the following products:
Donax TA / TG / TX / TV / TZ

Page owner: Hans Wildeboer/Paul Evers


Last update: 18/03/2008

- 19
This document is strictly confidential & for Internal Shell Use only. It is the basis of the agreement with our Laboratories
for the diagnosis of oil samples.

On-Highway: Manual and Automated Manual Gearboxes


Lower limits
Analysis

Method

Units

Red

Upper limits

Amber

Amber

Red

Viscosity at 100C

ASTM D445

cSt

-20%

+20%

+30%

Water Content

ASTM D6304

ppm

2000

5000

TAN (Total Acid


Number)

ASTM D664

mg
KOH/g

2.50

3.50

Spectrometry

ASTM D5185-05

30%

20%

30%

Aluminum (Al)

ppm

Iron (Fe)

ppm

Chromium (Cr)

ppm

Copper (Cu)

ppm

Lead (Pb)

ppm

Molybdenum (Mo)

ppm

Tin (Sn)

ppm

Sodium (Na)

ppm

Silicon (Si)

ppm

Phosphorus (P)

Remarks

Remarks:
In practice it is hard (if not impossible) to take representative samples from any automotive (manual) transmission
component due to lack of dispersants in these types of oil and the presence of magnets in many transmissioncomponents. Therefore diagnoses based on wear-particles are not feasible: The particles, present in the lubesample, have no relation with the actual wear-rate in the transmission-component.
These limits apply to the following products:
Spirax G / GX / GSX / MA, Transmission MA / ZFLD

Page owner: Hans Wildeboer/Paul Evers


Last update: 18/03/2008

- 20
This document is strictly confidential & for Internal Shell Use only. It is the basis of the agreement with our Laboratories
for the diagnosis of oil samples.

On-Highway: Axles and Differential Gears


Lower limits

Upper limits

Red

Amber

Amber

Red

Analysis

Method

Units

Viscosity at 100C

ASTM D445

cSt

-30%

-20%

+20%

+30%

Water Content

ASTM D6304

0.5

2.0

TAN (Total Acid


Number)

ASTM D664

mg
KOH/g

3.00

3.50

Spectrometry

ASTM D5185-05

30%

20%

30%

Aluminum (Al)

ppm

Iron (Fe)

ppm

Chromium (Cr)

ppm

Copper (Cu)

ppm

Lead (Pb)

ppm

Molybdenum (Mo)

ppm

Tin (Sn)

ppm

Sodium (Na)

ppm

Silicon (Si)

ppm

Phosphorus (P)

Remarks

Remarks:
In practice it is hard (if not impossible) to take representative samples from any automotive (manual) transmission
component due to lack of dispersants in these types of oil and the presence of magnets in many transmissioncomponents. Therefore diagnoses based on wear-particles are not feasible: The particles, present in the lubesample, have no relation with the actual wear-rate in the transmission-component.
These limits apply to the following products:
Spirax A / AX / ASX / MB, Transmission MB

Page owner: Hans Wildeboer/Paul Evers


Last update: 18/03/2008
- 21
This document is strictly confidential & for Internal Shell Use only. It is the basis of the agreement with our Laboratories
for the diagnosis of oil samples.

Off-Highway Power Shift Transmissions


Lower limits
Analysis

Method

Units

Upper limits

Red

Amber

Amber

Red

Viscosity at 100C

ASTM D445

cSt

-30%

-20%

+20%

+30%

Water Content

ASTM D6304

ppm

500

2000

TAN (Total Acid


Number)

ASTM D664

mg
KOH/g

3.00

3.50

Spectrometry

ASTM D5185-05
ppm

15

50

Aluminum (Al)
Iron (Fe)

ppm

40

100

Chromium (Cr)

ppm

10

20

Copper (Cu)

ppm

25

50

Lead (Pb)

ppm

10

25

Tin (Sn)

ppm

Sodium (Na)

ppm

10

20

Silicon (Si)

ppm

15

20

30% of fresh oil

Calcium (Ca)

Remarks

20% of fresh oil 30% of fresh oil

Remarks:

These limits apply to the following products:


Donax TC / TCS, Rimula X / Super (Multi)

Page owner: Hans Wildeboer/Paul Evers


Last update: 18/03/2008

- 22
This document is strictly confidential & for Internal Shell Use only. It is the basis of the agreement with our Laboratories
for the diagnosis of oil samples.

Off-Highway Non-Shiftable Gears, with / without Wet Brakes


Lower limits

Upper limits

Red

Amber

Amber

Red

Analysis

Method

Units

Viscosity at 100C

ASTM D445

cSt

-30%

-20%

+20%

+30%

Water Content

ASTM D6304

0.5

2.0

TAN (Total Acid


Number)

ASTM D664

mg
KOH/g

3.00

3.50

Spectrometry

ASTM D5185-05

Aluminum (Al)

ppm

50

100

Iron (Fe)

ppm

500

2000

Chromium (Cr)

ppm

Copper (Cu)

ppm

50

100

Lead (Pb)

ppm

30

50

Tin (Sn)

ppm

Sodium (Na)

ppm

Silicon (Si)

ppm

25% of fresh oil

Calcium (Ca)

15% of fresh oil 25% of fresh oil

Remarks

Sometimes very small final


drives with only 2 - 2.5 liter of oil

Semi-open vents
Lower: dilution with other oils;
upper: evaporation losses

Remarks:

These limits apply to the following products:


Donax TC / TCS / DCF, Donax TD, Rimula X (single grade)

Page owner: Hans Wildeboer/Paul Evers


Last update: 18/03/2008
- 23
This document is strictly confidential & for Internal Shell Use only. It is the basis of the agreement with our Laboratories
for the diagnosis of oil samples.

Agri: Tractor Transmissions and Tractor Hydraulic Systems


Lower limits
Analysis

Upper limits

Red

Amber

Amber

Red

Method

Units

Viscosity at 100C

ASTM D445

cSt

-25%

-15%

+10%

+20%

Water Content

ASTM D6304

0.4

1.0

TAN (Total Acid


Number)

ASTM D664

mg
KOH/g

2.50

3.50

Spectrometry

ASTM D5185-05

Aluminum (Al)

ppm

25

50

Iron (Fe)

ppm

40

100

Chromium (Cr)

ppm

10

20

Copper (Cu)

ppm

25

50

Lead (Pb)

ppm

10

25

Tin (Sn)

ppm

Sodium (Na)

ppm

10

20

Silicon (Si)

ppm

30

40

25% of fresh oil

Calcium (Ca)

Remarks

15% of fresh oil 25% of fresh oil

Remarks:

These limits apply to the following products:


Donax T / TD / TDS / TDQ, Harvella T / TX

Page owner: Hans Wildeboer/Paul Evers


Last update: 18/03/2008

- 24
This document is strictly confidential & for Internal Shell Use only. It is the basis of the agreement with our Laboratories
for the diagnosis of oil samples.

Off-Highway Axles, Final Drives, Reduction Gears and Slew-Drives


Lower limits
Analysis

Red

Amber

Amber

Red

cSt

-30%

-20%

+20%

+30%

0.5

2.0

mg
KOH/g

3.00

3.50

30%

20%

30%

Method

Units

Viscosity at 100C

ASTM D445

Water Content

ASTM D6304

TAN (Total Acid


Number)

ASTM D664

Spectrometry

ASTM D5185-05

Aluminum (Al)

Remarks

ppm

Iron (Fe)

ppm

Chromium (Cr)

ppm

Copper (Cu)

ppm

Lead (Pb)

ppm

Molybdenum (Mo)

ppm

Tin (Sn)

ppm

Sodium (Na)

ppm

Silicon (Si)

ppm

Phosphorus (P)

Upper limits

Remarks:
In practice it is hard (if not impossible) to take representative samples from any automotive (manual) transmission
component due to lack of dispersants in these types of oil and the presence of magnets in many transmissioncomponents. Therefore diagnoses based on wear-particles are not feasible: The particles, present in the lubesample, have no relation with the actual wear-rate in the transmission-component.
These limits apply to the following products:
Spirax A / AX / ASX, Omala, Omala RL / HD

Page owner: Hans Wildeboer/Paul Evers


Last update: 18/03/2008
- 25
This document is strictly confidential & for Internal Shell Use only. It is the basis of the agreement with our Laboratories
for the diagnosis of oil samples.

Mobile Hydraulic Systems, Detergent Type of Oils


Lower limits
Analysis

Method

Units

Upper limits

Red

Amber

Amber

Red

Viscosity at 100C

ASTM D445

cSt

-15%

-10%

+10%

+15%

Viscosity at 40C

ASTM D445

cSt

-20%

-15%

+10%

+15%

Water Content

ASTM D6304

ppm

500

3000

TAN (Total Acid


Number)

ASTM D664

mg
KOH/g

0.70

1.20

Spectrometry

ASTM D5185-05
ppm

25

50

Aluminum (Al)
Iron (Fe)

ppm

50

100

Chromium (Cr)

ppm

25

50

Copper (Cu)

ppm

25

50

Lead (Pb)

ppm

25

50

Tin (Sn)

ppm

25

50

Sodium (Na)

ppm

Silicon (Si)

ppm

15

30

Remarks

Remarks:

These limits apply to the following products:


Tellus DO / TD, Donax TC / TCS, Rimula X (Single)

Page owner: Hans Wildeboer/Paul Evers


Last update: 18/03/2008
- 26
This document is strictly confidential & for Internal Shell Use only. It is the basis of the agreement with our Laboratories
for the diagnosis of oil samples.

Mobile Hydraulic Systems, Non-Detergent Type of Oils


Lower limits

Upper limits

Red

Amber

Amber

Red

Analysis

Method

Units

Viscosity at 100C

ASTM D445

cSt

-15%

-10%

+10%

+15%

Viscosity at 40C

ASTM D445

cSt

-20%

-15%

+10%

+15%

Water Content

ASTM D6304

ppm

500

3000

TAN (Total Acid


Number)

ASTM D664

mg
KOH/g

0.70

1.20

Spectrometry

ASTM D5185-05
ppm

Aluminum (Al)
Iron (Fe)

ppm

Chromium (Cr)

ppm

Copper (Cu)

ppm

Lead (Pb)

ppm

Tin (Sn)

ppm

Sodium (Na)

ppm

Silicon (Si)

ppm

Calcium (Ca)

Remarks

Remarks:
In practice it is hard (if not impossible) to take representative samples from a mobile hydraulic system in which a
non-detergent oil is used and / or where magnets are present. Therefore diagnoses based on wear-particles are not
feasible: The particles, present in the lube-sample, have no relation with the actual wear-rate in the hydraulic
system.
These limits apply to the following products:
Tellus, Tellus T / TX

Page owner: Hans Wildeboer/Paul Evers


Last update: 18/03/2008
- 27
This document is strictly confidential & for Internal Shell Use only. It is the basis of the agreement with our Laboratories
for the diagnosis of oil samples.

Mobile Hydraulic Systems, Biodegradable Oils


Lower limits

Upper limits

Red

Amber

Amber

Red

Analysis

Method

Units

Viscosity at 40C

ASTM D445

cSt

-15%

-10%

+10%

+15%

Water Content

ASTM D6304

ppm

1000

5000

TAN (Total Acid


Number)

ASTM D664

mg
KOH/g

3.50

5.00

Spectrometry

ASTM D5185-05

Aluminum (Al)

ppm

25

50

Iron (Fe)

ppm

50

100

Chromium (Cr)

ppm

25

50

Copper (Cu)

ppm

25

50

Lead (Pb)

ppm

25

50

Tin (Sn)

ppm

25

50

Sodium (Na)

ppm

Silicon (Si)

ppm

15

30

Remarks

Remarks:
These limits apply to the following products:
Naturelle HF-X / HF-E

Page owner: Hans Wildeboer/Paul Evers


Last update: 18/03/2008

- 28
This document is strictly confidential & for Internal Shell Use only. It is the basis of the agreement with our Laboratories
for the diagnosis of oil samples.

Industrial Gears
Lower limits
Analysis

Method

Units

Viscosity at 40C

ASTM D445

cSt

Appearance

Visual

Water Content
(ASTM D6304)

TAN (Total Acid


Number) ASTM D664

Spectrometry

Upper limits

Red

Amber

Amber

Red

-20%

-15%

10%

20%

Mineral and PAO:

0.20

2.00

Ester Based Oils:

0.10

0.50

Poly-glycol:

2.00

5.00

Cassida GLE

1.00

2.00

Omala, Omala HD:

mg
KOH/g

1.4

2.2

Tivela, Tivela SD,


mg
Cassida GL/GLE/WG KOH/g

2.0

3.0

Remarks

Should be free of solid particles,


sludge or emulsion, bright and
clear

ASTM D5185-05

Aluminum (Al)

ppm

25

50

Iron (Fe)

ppm

200

250

Chromium (Cr)

ppm

15

75

Copper (Cu)

ppm

25

75

Lead (Pb)

ppm

25

75

Tin (Sn)

ppm

20

40

Silicon (Si)

ppm

50

150

Sodium (Na)

ppm

25

100

Boron (B)

ppm

15

75

Potassium (K)

ppm

15

75

mg/L

100

200

Depending on the aspect of the


sediments on the membrane
Trend analysis

Millipore Solids (5.0


m membrane)

In House

ISU (Wear Severity


Index)

In House

5000

20000

WPI (Wear Particle


Index)

PQ

100

500

Remarks:
These limits apply to the following products:

Page owner: Joe OConnor


Last update:08/02/2008

- 29
This document is strictly confidential & for Internal Shell Use only. It is the basis of the agreement with our Laboratories
for the diagnosis of oil samples.

Steam Turbines
Lower limits

Upper limits

Red

Amber

Amber

Red

Remarks

Analysis

Method

Units

Viscosity at 40C

ASTM D445

cSt

-10%

-5%

5%

10%

Flash Point (Pensky


Maertens)

ASTM D93

160

190

Water Content

ASTM D6304

ppm

500

1000

Appearance

Visual

Should be free of solid particles,


sludge or emulsion, bright and
clear

TAN (Total Acid


Number)

ASTM D664

mg
KOH/g

+ 0.2 increase
over fresh oil
value

+ 0.5 increase
over fresh oil
value

Tan increase of 0.15 within a


year should give AMBER

Spectrometry

ASTM D5185-05
ppm

10

20

Aluminum (Al)
Iron (Fe)

ppm

10

25

Chromium (Cr)

ppm

10

15

Copper (Cu)

ppm

10

20

Lead (Pb)

ppm

10

Tin (Sn)

ppm

10

Silicon (Si)

ppm

10

15

Sodium (Na)

ppm

15

25
Look for rapid colour changes,
some oil types darken more
quickly

Colour

ASTM D1500

4.0

6.0

ISU (Wear Severity


Index)

In House

100

200

Particle Count

ISO 4406 or SAE AS


4059

ISO 19/17/14

ISO 20/18/15

For control circuits included in


the lube system, read 18/16/13
resp. 19/17/14 or as
recommended by OEM

Millipore Solids (0.8


m membrane)

ISO 4405

30

50

For CC and GT interpretation


should go together with Colour

RPVOT

ASTM D2272

mg/L

25% of fresh oil 35% of fresh oil


or 250 minutes, or 350 minutes,
min
whichever is the whichever is
lowest.
the lowest.

RPVOT values on fresh


products:
X

Turbo T/J : > 950 mins


Turbo GT: > 1000 mins
TURBO CC: > 1200 mins

Demulsibility

ASTM D1401

Steam Separation

IP19

Air Release (IP313)


Foaming (ASTM
D892)
Infrared Differential

40/37/3 after 25
minutes

> 3ml after 30


minutes

600

1200

Grade ISO 32 & 46

min

Grade ISO 68 & 100

min

10

Foam Stability

mL

>5

450

Foam Tendency

See Comment #2

Remarks:
1. When a sample is cloudy, it is necessary to make a remark in the diagnosis.
2. When infrared reports (simple spectrum or infrared differential) have to be attached to the report (ferrography,
Infrared differential), the standard comment IRDO should be added at the end of the diagnosis comment.
3. Attention: machines containing a very large volume of oil. In case of degradation of the oil or machine, it is
preferable to advise the customer to contact Shell Technical Services or a Shell representative instead of
recommending an oil change.
These limits apply to the following products: Turbo T/Turbo J/Turbo CC
Page owner: Ronald Bakker
Last update: 18/02/08
- 30
This document is strictly confidential & for Internal Shell Use only. It is the basis of the agreement with our Laboratories
for the diagnosis of oil samples.

Steam Turbines: Fire Resistant Control Fluids


Lower limits
Analysis

Method

Upper limits

Units

Red

Amber

Amber

Red

Viscosity at 40C

ASTM D445

cSt

-15%

-10%

10%

15%

Water Content

ASTM D6304

ppm

1000

1500

Appearance

Visual

TAN (Total Acid


Number)

ASTM D664

mg
KOH/g

0.3

0.5

Spectrometry

ASTM D5185-05

Aluminum (Al)

ppm

10

25

Iron (Fe)

ppm

15

30

Chromium (Cr)

ppm

10

15

Copper (Cu)

ppm

15

30

Lead (Pb)

ppm

10

Tin (Sn)

ppm

10

Silicon (Si)

ppm

15

30

Sodium (Na)

ppm

15

25

Boron (B)

ppm

20

40

Potassium (K)

ppm

20

40

Calcium (Ca)

ppm

10

30

Magnesium (Mg)

ppm

10

30

Remarks

Should be free of solid particles,


sludge or emulsion, bright and
clear

Look for rapid colour changes,


some oil types darken more
quickly

Colour

ASTM D1500

4.0

5.0

ISU (Wear Severity


Index)

In House

100

200

Particle Count

ISO 4406 or SAE AS


4059

ISO 18/16/13

ISO 19/17/14

Or as recommended by OEM

Millipore Solids (0.8


m membrane)

In House

mg/L

30

50

Interpretation should go together


with Colour, ester fluids have a
high natural dirt solvability,
Millipore levels can rise easily

Air Release

IP313

min

10

Chlorine Content

DIN 51 408/2

ppm

50

100

Mineral Oil Content

IR or TLC

0.5

1.0

These limits apply to the following products:


Turbo Fluid DR
Page owner: Ronald Bakker
Last update: 13/03/08
- 31
This document is strictly confidential & for Internal Shell Use only. It is the basis of the agreement with our Laboratories
for the diagnosis of oil samples.

Gas Turbines, Industrial


Lower limits

Upper limits

Red

Amber

Amber

Red

Remarks

Analysis

Method

Units

Viscosity at 40C

ASTM D445

cSt

-10%

-5%

5%

10%

Flash Point (Pensky


Maertens)

ASTM D93

160

190

Water Content

ASTM D6304

ppm

250

500

Appearance

Visual

Should be free of solid particles,


sludge or emulsion, bright and
clear

TAN (Total Acid


Number)

ASTM D664

mg
KOH/g

+ 0.2 increase
over fresh oil
value

+ 0.5 increase
over fresh oil
value

Tan increase of 0.15 within a


year should give AMBER

Spectrometry

ASTM D5185-05

Aluminum (Al)

ppm

10

20

Iron (Fe)

ppm

10

25

Chromium (Cr)

ppm

10

15

Copper (Cu)

ppm

10

20

Lead (Pb)

ppm

10

Tin (Sn)

ppm

10

Silicon (Si)

ppm

10

15

Sodium (Na)

ppm

15

25
Look for rapid colour changes,
some oil types darken more
quickly

Colour

ASTM D1500

4.0

8.0

ISU (Wear Severity


Index)

In House

100

200

Particle Count

ISO 4406 or SAE AS


4059

ISO 19/17/14

ISO 20/18/15

For control circuits included in


the lube system, read 18/16/13
resp. 19/17/14 or as
recommended by OEM

Millipore Solids (0.8


m membrane)

In House

30

60

For CC and GT interpretation


should go together with Colour

mg/L

RPVOT values
products:
RPVOT

ASTM D2272

min 25% of fresh oil 35% of fresh oil

on

Turbo T/J : > 950 mins


Turbo GT: > 1000 mins
TURBO CC: > 1200 mins

Demulsibility

ASTM D1401

Steam Separation

IP19

Air Release (IP313)


Foaming (ASTM
D892)

40/37/3 after 25 > 3ml after 30


minutes
minutes

600

1200

Grade ISO 32 & 46

min

Grade ISO 68 & 100

min

10

Foam Stability

mL

>5

450

Foam Tendency

Infrared Differential

See Comment #2

Remarks:
1. When a sample is cloudy, it is necessary to make a remark in the diagnosis.
2. When infrared reports (simple spectrum or infrared differential) have to be attached to the report (ferrography,
Infrared differential), the standard comment IRDO should be added at the end of the diagnosis comment.
3. Attention: machines containing a very large volume of oil. In case of degradation of the oil or machine, it is
preferable to advise the customer to contact Shell Technical Services or a Shell representative instead of
recommending an oil change (second sentence of the standard comment TOP).
These limits apply to the following products: Turbo T/Turbo J/Turbo CC/Turbo GT
Page owner: Ronald Bakker
Last update: 13/03/08
- 32
This document is strictly confidential & for Internal Shell Use only. It is the basis of the agreement with our Laboratories
for the diagnosis of oil samples.

fresh

Gas Turbines, Aero-Derivatives - Land Based


Lower limits
Analysis

Method

Units

Upper limits

Red

Amber

Amber

Red

Remarks

Viscosity at 40C

ASTM D445

cSt

-25%

-10%

10%

25%

Flash Point (Pensky


Maertens)

ASTM D93

160

190

Water Content

ASTM D6304

ppm

200

400

Appearance

Visual

Should be free of solid particles,


sludge or emulsion, bright and
clear

TAN (Total Acid


Number)

ASTM D664

mg
KOH/g

+0.8

+1.15

Interpret in combination with


water level

Spectrometry

ASTM D5185-05

Aluminum (Al)

ppm

10

20

Iron (Fe)

ppm

10

25

Chromium (Cr)

ppm

10

15

Copper (Cu)

ppm

10

20

Lead (Pb)

ppm

Tin (Sn)

ppm

Silicon (Si)

ppm

10

15

Sodium (Na)

ppm

15

25

Phosphorus (P)

ppm

600

500

Colour

ASTM D1500

5.0

8.0

Particle Count

ISO 4406 or SAE AS


4059

ISO 19/17/14

ISO 20/18/15

Millipore Solids (0.8


m membrane)

In House

mg/L

50

100

Air Release

IP313

min

Foaming (ASTM
D892)

Foam Stability

mL

>5

450

Foam Tendency

Asto 500 fresh oil has 1100 ppm


& Asto 560 fresh oil has 1900
ppm

These limits apply to the following products: ASTO 500 and 560, if used in land based installations only.

Page owner: Ronald Bakker


Last update: 13/03/08

- 33
This document is strictly confidential & for Internal Shell Use only. It is the basis of the agreement with our Laboratories
for the diagnosis of oil samples.

Hydraulic: Mineral Oils


Lower limits

Upper limits

Red

Amber

Amber

Red

Analysis

Method

Units

Viscosity at 40C
(ASTM D445)

HM Type Fluid

cSt

-15%

-10%

+10%

+15%

HV Type Fluid

cSt

-25%

-15%

+15%

+25%

Appearance

Visual

Water Content

ASTM D6304

ppm

500

2000

TAN (Total Acid


Number)

ASTM D664

mg
KOH/g

+0.5

+1.0

Spectrometry

ASTM D5185-05

Aluminum (Al)

ppm

10

20

Iron (Fe)

ppm

15

30

Chromium (Cr)

ppm

10

Copper (Cu)

ppm

15

30

Lead (Pb)

ppm

10

20
20

Tin (Sn)

ppm

10

Nickel (Ni)

ppm

Silicon (Si)

ppm

15

30

Sodium (Na)

ppm

20

40

Boron (B)

ppm

20

40

Potassium (K)
Millipore Solids (0.8
m membrane)

ppm

20

40

Other Systems

mg/L

100

200

Systems with Servo


and Prop Valves

mg/L

50

100

ISU (Wear Severity


Index)

In House

100

200

Colour

ASTM D1500

5.0

7.0

Particle Count

ISO 4406 or SAE


AS4059

NAS 9 or ISO
17/13

NAS 12 or ISO
21/17

Remarks

Should be free of solid particles,


sludge or emulsion, bright and
clear

Remarks:
1. When a sample is cloudy, it is necessary to make a remark in the diagnosis.
These limits apply to the following products:

Page owner: Ahmet Guvem & Dennis Woodley


Last update: 11/03/08
- 34
This document is strictly confidential & for Internal Shell Use only. It is the basis of the agreement with our Laboratories
for the diagnosis of oil samples.

Hydraulic: Biodegradable Oils


Lower limits

Upper limits

Red

Amber

Amber

Red

-15%

-10%

+10%

+15%

ppm

800

1500

mg
KOH/g

+2.5

+3.0

Aluminum (Al)

ppm

10

20

Iron (Fe)

ppm

15

30

Chromium (Cr)

ppm

10

Copper (Cu)

ppm

15

30

Lead (Pb)

ppm

10

20
20

Analysis

Method

Units

Viscosity at 40C

ASTM D445

cSt

Appearance

Visual

Water Content

ASTM D6304

TAN (Total Acid


Number)

ASTM D664

Spectrometry

ASTM D5185-05

Tin (Sn)

ppm

10

Nickel (Ni)

ppm

Silicon (Si)

ppm

15

30

Sodium (Na)

ppm

20

40

Boron (B)

ppm

20

40

Potassium (K)
Millipore Solids (0.8
m membrane)

ppm

20

40

Other Systems

mg/L

50

80

Systems with Servo


and Prop Valves

mg/L

25

50

ISU (Wear Severity


Index)

In House

100

200

Colour

ASTM D1500

5.0

7.0

Particle Count

ISO 4406 or SAE


AS4059

NAS 9 or ISO
17/13

NAS 12 or ISO
21/17

Remarks

Should be free of solid particles,


sludge or emulsion, bright and
clear

Remarks:
1. When a sample is cloudy, it is necessary to make a remark in the diagnosis.
These limits apply to the following products:

Page owner: Ahmet Guvem & Dennis Woodley


Last update: 11/03/08

- 35
This document is strictly confidential & for Internal Shell Use only. It is the basis of the agreement with our Laboratories
for the diagnosis of oil samples.

Hydraulic: Synthetic Food Grade


Lower limits

Upper limits

Red

Amber

Amber

Red

Analysis

Method

Units

Viscosity at 40C
(ASTM D445)

HM Type Fluid

cSt

-15%

-10%

+10%

+15%

HV Type Fluid

cSt

-25%

-15%

+15%

+25%

Appearance

Visual

Water Content

ASTM D6304

ppm

500

2000

TAN (Total Acid


Number)

ASTM D664

mg
KOH/g

+2.0

+3.0

Spectrometry

ASTM D5185-05
ppm

10

20

Aluminum (Al)
Iron (Fe)

ppm

15

30

Chromium (Cr)

ppm

10

Copper (Cu)

ppm

15

30

Lead (Pb)

ppm

10

20

Tin (Sn)

ppm

10

20

Nickel (Ni)

ppm

Silicon (Si)

ppm

15

30

Sodium (Na)

ppm

20

40

Boron (B)

ppm

20

40

Potassium (K)

ppm

20

40

Other Systems

mg/L

100

200

Systems with Servo


and Prop Valves

mg/L

50

100

In House

100

200

Colour

ASTM D1500

5.0

7.0

Particle Count

ISO 4406 or SAE


AS4059

NAS 9 or ISO
17/13

NAS 12 or ISO
21/17

Millipore Solids (0.8


m membrane)
ISU (Wear Severity
Index)

Remarks

Should be free of solid particles,


sludge or emulsion, bright and
clear

Remarks:
1. When a sample is cloudy, it is necessary to make a remark in the diagnosis.
These limits apply to the following products: Cassida HF

Page owner: Steve Slack


Last update: 22/02/08
- 36
This document is strictly confidential & for Internal Shell Use only. It is the basis of the agreement with our Laboratories
for the diagnosis of oil samples.

Hydraulic: HFC Type


Lower limits
Analysis

Method

Units

Viscosity at 40C

ASTM D445

cSt

Upper limits

Red

Amber

Amber

Red

-15%

-10%

+10%

+15%

5.0

7.0

40

43

35

45

pH
Appearance

Visual

Water Content
(ASTM D6304)

France

Other Countries

TAN (Total Acid


Number)

ASTM D664

mg
KOH/g

+2.0

Spectrometry

ASTM D5185-05

Aluminum (Al)

ppm

10

20

Iron (Fe)

ppm

15

30

Chromium (Cr)

ppm

10

Copper (Cu)

ppm

15

30

Lead (Pb)

ppm

10

20

Tin (Sn)

ppm

10

20

Nickel (Ni)

ppm

Silicon (Si)

ppm

15

30

Sodium (Na)

ppm

20

40

Boron (B)

ppm

20

40

Potassium (K)

ppm

20

40

Other Systems

mg/L

200

400

Systems with Servo


and Prop Valves

mg/L

50

100

Millipore Solids (0.8


m membrane)

Remarks

Should be free of solid particles,


sludge or emulsion, bright and
clear

Remarks:
1. When a sample is cloudy, it is necessary to make a remark in the diagnosis.
These limits apply to the following products:

Page owner: Ahmet Guvem & Dennis Woodley


Last update: 11/03/08

- 37
This document is strictly confidential & for Internal Shell Use only. It is the basis of the agreement with our Laboratories
for the diagnosis of oil samples.

Hydraulic: HFDU Type


Lower limits

Upper limits

Red

Amber

Amber

Red

cSt

-15%

-10%

+10%

+15%

140

160

210

240

ppm

800

1500

mg
KOH/g

+2.5

+3.0

Aluminum (Al)

ppm

10

20

Iron (Fe)

ppm

15

30

Chromium (Cr)

ppm

10

Copper (Cu)

ppm

15

30

Lead (Pb)

ppm

10

20

Tin (Sn)

ppm

10

20

Nickel (Ni)

ppm

Analysis

Method

Units

Viscosity at 40C

ASTM D445

Flash Point

ASTM D3828

Flash Point (COC)

ASTM D92

Appearance

Visual

Water Content

ASTM D6304

TAN (Total Acid


Number)

ASTM D664

Spectrometry

ASTM D5185-05

Silicon (Si)

ppm

15

30

Sodium (Na)

ppm

20

40

Boron (B)

ppm

20

40

Potassium (K)
Millipore Solids (0.8
m membrane)

ppm

20

40

Other Systems

mg/L

200

400

Systems with Servo


and Prop Valves

mg/L

50

100

ISU (Wear Severity


Index)

In House

100

200

Particle Count

ISO 4406 or SAE


AS4059

NAS 9 or ISO
17/13

NAS 12 or ISO
21/17

Remarks

Should be free of solid particles,


sludge or emulsion, bright and
clear

Remarks:
1. When a sample is cloudy, it is necessary to make a remark in the diagnosis.
These limits apply to the following products:

Page owner: Ahmet Guvem and Dennis Woodley


Last update: 11/03/08
- 38
This document is strictly confidential & for Internal Shell Use only. It is the basis of the agreement with our Laboratories
for the diagnosis of oil samples.

Bearing Lubrication - Wire Rod Mill (Morlina T)


Lower limits
Red
Amber

Upper limits
Amber
Red

-15%
X

-10%
170
X

+10%
X
2000

+15%
X
5000

mg
KOH/g

+0.5 increase
over fresh oil
value

+1.0 increase
over fresh oil
value

ppm
ppm
ppm
ppm
ppm
ppm
ppm
ppm
ppm

X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X

X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X

10
50
10
30
10
20
15
15
10

30
200
30
50
30
30
50
30
20

-50% of fresh
oil value

10
NAS 7

20
NAS 11

Analysis

Method

Units

Viscosity at 40C
Flash Point (COC)
Water Content

ASTM D445
ASTM D92
ASTM D6304

cSt
C
ppm

Appearance

Visual

TAN (Total Acid


Number)

ASTM D664

Spectrometry
Aluminum (Al)
Iron (Fe)
Chromium (Cr)
Copper (Cu)
Lead (Pb)
Tin (Sn)
Silicon (Si)
Sodium (Na)
Calcium (Ca)

Demulsibility (ASTM
D1401)

Should be free of solid particles,


sludge or emulsion, bright and
clear

ASTM D5185-05

Phosphorus (P)
Zinc (Zn)
Particle Count

Remarks

NAS 1638

ppm

X
X

X
X

VG ISO 100-220

40/37/3 (<25
min)

VG ISO 320-460

40/37/3 (<40
min)

VG ISO 680

40/37/3 (<50
min)

Use the cooling water from the


local steel mill to perform this
test.

Remarks:
1. When a sample is cloudy, it is necessary to make a remark in the diagnosis.
2. Use the cooling water from the local steel mill to perform the demulsibility test.
3. Basic analysis includes: Appearance / Viscosity @40C / Water Content / TAN / Demulsibility
* Advanced analysis includes: Appearance/ Viscosity@40C/ Water Content/ TAN/ Demulsibility / Particle Count
* For trouble shooting (viscosity drop) - check Flash Point (COC) to clarify Overheating or light oil contamination;
Flash Point (COC) need > 170C
* If it has foaming complaint, please check Foaming Tendency / Foaming Stability in Sq I / II/ III (ASTM D892)
These limits apply to the following products: Morlina T

Page owner: Jason Cao


Last update: 29/02/08

- 39
This document is strictly confidential & for Internal Shell Use only. It is the basis of the agreement with our Laboratories
for the diagnosis of oil samples.

Bearing Lubrication - Morgoil Bearing ( Morlina / Morlina SD / Vitrea M )


Lower limits
Red
Amber

Upper limits
Amber
Red

-20%
X

-15%
170
X

+15%
X
5000

+20%
X
20000

mg
KOH/g

+0.5 increase
over fresh oil
value

+1.0 increase
over fresh oil
value

ppm
ppm
ppm
ppm
ppm
ppm
ppm
ppm
ppm

X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X

X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X

15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
10

30
30
30
30
30
30
30
30
15

-50% of fresh
oil value

10

Analysis

Method

Units

Viscosity at 40C
Flash Point (COC)
Water Content

ASTM D445
ASTM D92
ASTM D6304

cSt
C
ppm

Appearance

Visual

TAN (Total Acid


Number)

ASTM D664

Spectrometry
Aluminum (Al)
Iron (Fe)
Chromium (Cr)
Copper (Cu)
Lead (Pb)
Tin (Sn)
Silicon (Si)
Sodium (Na)
Calcium (Ca)

Should be free of solid particles,


sludge or emulsion, bright and
clear

ASTM D5185-05

Phosphorus (P)

Zinc (Zn)

Demulsibility (ASTM
D1401)

Remarks

ppm

20

VG ISO 100-220

40/37/3 (<20
min)

VG ISO 320-460

40/37/3 (<40
min)

VG ISO 680

40/37/3 (<50
min)

Use the cooling water from the


local steel mill to perform this
test.

Remarks:
1. When a sample is cloudy, it is necessary to make a remark in the diagnosis.
2. Use the cooling water from the local steel mill to perform the demulsibility test.
3. Basic analysis includes: Appearance / Viscosity @40C / Water Content / TAN / Demulsibility
* For trouble shooting (viscosity drop) - check Flash Point (COC) to clarify overheating or light oil contamination;
Flash Point (COC) need > 170C
These limits apply to the following products: Morlina / Morlina SD / Vitrea M

Page owner: Jason Cao


Last update: 19/06/08

- 40
This document is strictly confidential & for Internal Shell Use only. It is the basis of the agreement with our Laboratories
for the diagnosis of oil samples.

Heat Transfer Oils Thermal Oils


Lower limits
Analysis

Viscosity at 40C

Flash Point (Pensky


Maertens)

Method

ASTM D445

DIN 51758

Units

cSt

Red

-50%

80

Upper limits

Amber

-25%

100

Amber

+25%

Red

Remarks

+50%

Viscosity can decrease because


of the presence of low boiling
substance and or mixing with
other oil. Viscosity can increase
because of the presence of high
boiling substance and or mixing
with other oil

The system would be subject to


the pressure vessel code for a
flash point below 55C. By the
way, it seems that the vessel
code isn't actual any more by
the end of 2007 for heat transfer
oil. The FP limits would be
100C today.

150

300

Water is dangerous because of


vapour formation,
corrosion/oxidation and
cavitation in the pump

Should be free of solid particles,


sludge or emulsion, bright and
clear

mg
KOH/g

+0.5 increase
over fresh oil
value

In House

mg/L

60

150

Depending on the appearance


of the sediments on the
membrane

Asphaltene Content

DIN 51588

%m

0.25

0.50

The risk of deposits in the


system will be increased up to
0.25%

Conradson Carbon
Residue

DIN 51551

%m

0.50

1.00

Gives information about the risk


of deposits of carbon and
distillation residues

Unsoluble
Bituminous
Residues Content

DIN 51588

%m

0.35

0.70

The risk of deposits in the


system will be increased up to
0.35%

DIN 51592
low boiling

%m
%

X
X

X
X

0.5
1.5

1.0
3.0

Water Content

ASTM D6304

Appearance

Visual

TAN (Total Acid


Number)

ASTM D664

Millipore Solids (5.0


m membrane)

Solids Residue

Distillation (ASTM
D2887)

ppm

low boiling

high boiling

A rapid TAN increase indicates


+1.0 increase
the presence of air in the
over fresh oil
system. Normal increases is an
value
indication of oxidation.

>5% of fresh oil >10% of fresh


IBP
oil IBP
>15% of fresh
oil DP

>30% of fresh
oil DP

Mineral Oil (3% max at 325C)


Alkylbenzol base fluids (Shell
Thermal S)
Alkylbenzol base fluids (Shell
Thermal S)

Remarks:
1. The boiling point limits are higher for the Di-alkylbenzol based products because of the better solubility of the
high boiling substances,
These limits apply to the following products:
Page owner: Daniel Heche
Last update: 29/02/08
- 41
This document is strictly confidential & for Internal Shell Use only. It is the basis of the agreement with our Laboratories
for the diagnosis of oil samples.

Electrical Oils: Transformer Oils


Lower limits
Analysis

Method

Appearance

Visual

Viscosity at 40 C
Water Content
TAN (Total Acid
Number)

Units

Red

Amber

Upper limits
Amber

Red

Remarks

Bright, clear, Bright, clear,


and free of and free of
solid
solid
particles
particles

Rank

xxx

ISO 3104

mm/s

-10%

-5%

IEC 60814

mg/Kg

0.1/0.3

0.1/0.30

-15%

-10%

IEC 62021-1, mgKOH/g


2

Flash Point (Closed


ASTM D3828
Cup)

5%

10%

0.001/0.0025 0.001/0.0025

xxx
See comment 3

xxx

Colour

ISO 2049

1.5

2.0

xxx

Dielectric Strength

IEC 60247

KV

30/50

40/50

xxx

PCB Content

IEC 61619

ppm

local limits

local limits

0.03/0.5

0.03/0.5

xxx

mN/m

<22

<28

xx

17/14

>18/15

Power Factor

IEC 60156

Interfacial Tension

ASTM D971

Particle Count

IEC 60970

Pour Point

ISO 3016

+9

+15

Inhibitor Content

IEC 60666

40

60

xxx

Density

ISO 3675

Kg/m

+10%

+5%

-5%

-10%

Corrosive Sulphur

DIN 51535 +
IEC 62535

Visual

positive

positive

x
x =least important
xxx =most important

Remarks:
1. As regards the PCB content, Please refer to the legal requirements for each country (can usually easily be found
on the internet).
Samples not inline with the standards given in the relevant IEC specifications 60422 should be rejected.
2. Tests on dissolved gases should be agreed with customers, interpretation should be agreed with customers
3. Any sampling shall be made by using air tight glass bottles. If not in place air tight metal cans can be used
instead. Only virgin containers shall be used.
These limits apply to the following products:
Diala A/AX/D/DX/G/GX/S/B/BX/M/MX

Page owner: Bernd Lohmeyer


Last update: 14/02/08

- 42
This document is strictly confidential & for Internal Shell Use only. It is the basis of the agreement with our Laboratories
for the diagnosis of oil samples.

Piston Gas Compressors


Lower limits

Upper limits

Red

Amber

Amber

Red

Remarks

Analysis

Method

Units

Viscosity at 40C

ASTM D445

cSt

-15%

-10%

10%

20%

mg
KOH/g

+0.7

+1.0

mg
KOH/g

+0.4

>0.00

0.30

Dependent on the oil, gas and


type of compressor

TAN (Total Acid


Number) (ASTM
D664)

SAN (Strong Acid


Number)

ASTM D664

mg
KOH/g

TBN (Total Base


Number)

ASTM D2896

mg
KOH/g

Appearance

Visual

Water Content

Spectrometry
Aluminum (Al)
Iron (Fe)
Chromium (Cr)
Molybdenum (Mo)
Copper (Cu)
Lead (Pb)
Tin (Sn)
Silicon (Si)
Sodium (Na)
Potassium (K)

Shell Vitrea

Should be free of solid particles,


sludge or emulsion, bright and
clear

ppm

1000

1500

Excludes PAG based products

ppm

3000

4000

PAG based products such as


Madrela T and GP

500

Dependent on the gas. 50ppm


for sour gases. When the gas is
sensible to hydrolysis (Freon,
HCl). Then the max. water
content is set up at 500 ppm (or
0.05%).

ASTM D6304
ppm

ppm
ppm
ppm
ppm
ppm
ppm
ppm
ppm
ppm
ppm

X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X

X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X

10
100
10
15
20
20
10
15
20
20

15
150
15
20
30
50
20
20
40
40

ASTM D5185-05

Insolubles nheptane

ASTM D 893 A (rev)

0.10

0.20

Millipore Solids (0.8


m membrane)

In House

mg/L

50

100

ISU (Wear Severity


Index)

In House

900

1500

Conductivity

ASTM D6560

50

75

ps/m

Remarks:
1. Typical water content for fresh PAG based products such as Madrela T and GP can be 2000 ppm..
2. When a sample is cloudy, it is necessary to make a remark in the diagnosis.
These limits apply to the following products:
Vitrea/Morlina//Corena P/Corena AP
Page owner: Ronald Bakker
Last update: 19/01/09

- 43
This document is strictly confidential & for Internal Shell Use only. It is the basis of the agreement with our Laboratories
for the diagnosis of oil samples.

Piston Air Compressors


Lower limits

Upper limits

Red

Amber

Amber

Red

cSt

-20%

-10%

10%

20%

ASTM D664

mg
KOH/g

+0.6

+1.0

TBN (Total Base


Number)

ASTM D2896

mg
25% of fresh oil 50% of fresh oil
KOH/g

Appearance

Visual

Analysis

Method

Units

Viscosity at 40C

ASTM D445

TAN (Total Acid


Number)

Water Content
Spectrometry
Aluminum (Al)
Iron (Fe)
Chromium (Cr)
Molybdenum (Mo)
Copper (Cu)
Lead (Pb)
Tin (Sn)
Silicon (Si)
Sodium (Na)
Potassium (K)

ASTM D6304
ASTM D5185-05

ppm

500

1000

ppm
ppm
ppm
ppm
ppm
ppm
ppm
ppm
ppm
ppm

X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X

X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X

10
50
10
10
20
10
10
15
20
20

15
100
15
20
40
30
20
20
40
40

0.10

0.20

900

1500

50

100

Insolubles nheptane

ASTM D 893 A (rev)

ISU (Wear Severity


Index)

In House

Millipore Solids (0.8


m membrane)

In House

mg/L

Oxidation by FTIR

ASTM E 2412

A/0.1mm

Remarks

Should be free of solid particles,


sludge or emulsion, bright and
clear

Remarks:
1. When a sample is cloudy, it is necessary to make a remark in the diagnosis.
These limits apply to the following products:
Vitrea/Corena P/Corena AP

Page owner: Ronald Bakker


Last update: 25/02/08

- 44
This document is strictly confidential & for Internal Shell Use only. It is the basis of the agreement with our Laboratories
for the diagnosis of oil samples.

Centrifugal Air and Gas Compressors


Lower limits

Upper limits

Red

Amber

Amber

Red

Analysis

Method

Units

Viscosity at 40 C

ASTM D445

cSt

-15%

-10%

5%

10%

TAN (Total Acid


Number)

ASTM D664

mg
KOH/g

0.30 above
lowest value

0.50 above
lowest value

TBN (Total Base


Number)

ASTM D2896

mg
25% of fresh oil 50% of fresh oil
KOH/g

Appearance

Visual

ppm

500

1000

Aluminum (Al)

ppm

10

15

Iron (Fe)

ppm

10

15

Chromium (Cr)

ppm

10

15

Copper (Cu)

ppm

10

15

Lead (Pb)

ppm

10

15

Water Content

ASTM D6304

Spectrometry

ASTM D5185-05

Remarks

Tin (Sn)

ppm

10

15

Silicon (Si)

ppm

10

15

Sodium (Na)

ppm

20

40

Potassium (K)

ppm

20

40

100

250

ISU (Wear Severity


Index)

In House

Millipore Solids (0.8


m membrane)

In House

mg/L

250

500

Conductivity

ASTM D6560

ps/m

50

75

Chlorine Content

DIN 51 408/2

ppm

300

600

Should be free of solid particles,


sludge or emulsion, bright and
clear

Remarks:
1. When a sample is cloudy, it is necessary to make a remark in the diagnosis.
These limits apply to the following products:
Turbo T/ Turbo GT

Page owner: Ronald Bakker


Last update: 25/02/08

- 45
This document is strictly confidential & for Internal Shell Use only. It is the basis of the agreement with our Laboratories
for the diagnosis of oil samples.

Vane and Screw Compressors for Air and Gas


Lower limits

Upper limits

Red

Amber

Amber

Red

Analysis

Method

Units

Viscosity at 40C

ASTM D445

cSt

-20%

-10%

+10%

+25%

TAN (Total Acid


Number)

ASTM D664

mg
KOH/g

+0.6

+1.2

TBN (Total Base


Number)

ASTM D2896

mg
25% of fresh oil 50% of fresh oil
KOH/g

Appearance

Visual

Water Content

ASTM D6304

Spectrometry

ASTM D5185-05

Remarks

Should be free of solid particles,


sludge or emulsion, bright and
clear

ppm

500

1000

Excludes PAG based products

ppm

3000

4000

PAG based products such as


Madrela GS

Aluminum (Al)

ppm

10

25

Iron (Fe)

ppm

20

35

Chromium (Cr)

ppm

10

15

Molybdenum (Mo)

ppm

15

20

Copper (Cu)

ppm

20

35

Lead (Pb)

ppm

10

20

Tin (Sn)

ppm

10

20

Silicon (Si)

ppm

15

20

Sodium (Na)

ppm

20

40

Potassium (K)

ppm

20

40

0.10

0.20

100

250

50

100

Insolubles nheptane

ASTM D 893 A (rev)

ISU (Wear Severity


Index)

In House

Millipore Solids (0.8


m membrane)

In House

mg/L

Remarks:
1. Typical water content for fresh PAG based products such as Madrela GS can be 2000 ppm.
2. When a sample is cloudy, it is necessary to make a remark in the diagnosis.
These limits apply to the following products:
Corena D/Corena S/Corena AS

Page owner: Ronald Bakker


Last update: 19/01/09

- 46
This document is strictly confidential & for Internal Shell Use only. It is the basis of the agreement with our Laboratories
for the diagnosis of oil samples.

Refrigerating Compressors: Refrigerant: CFC, HCFC, HC, CO2


Lower limits

Upper limits

Red

Amber

Amber

Red

Analysis

Method

Units

Viscosity at 40C
after degassing

ASTM D445

cSt

-20%

-10%

+20%

+60%

mg
KOH/g

0.10

0.20

mg
KOH/g

>0.00

0.30

ppm

20

50

Aluminum (Al)

ppm

10

20

Iron (Fe)

ppm

30

60

Chromium (Cr)

ppm

10

20

Copper (Cu)

ppm

10

20

Lead (Pb)

ppm

10

20

TAN (Total Acid


Number) ASTM D664
SAN (Strong Acid
Number) after
degassing

ASTM D664

Appearance

Visual

Water Content

ASTM D6304

Spectrometry

ASTM D5185-05

Tin (Sn)

ppm

10

20

Silicon (Si)

ppm

25

50

Sodium (Na)

ppm

20

50

ppm

20

50

Colour

Potassium (K)
ASTM D1500

4.0

6.0

ISU (Wear Severity


Index)

Screw Compressor

100

250

Piston Compressor

900

1500

Millipore Solids (0.8


m membrane)

In House

mg/L

50

100

Chlorine Content

DIN 51 408/2

ppm

300

600

Remarks

Should be free of solid particles,


sludge or emulsion, bright and
clear

Remarks:
1. When a sample is cloudy, it is necessary to make a remark in the diagnosis.
2. The indicated chlorine content can be adapted, depending on the water content. If water is present, the limit of
acceptance for the chlorine content will be lower, because of the risk of reaction with the copper.
3. Freon is very soluble in mineral oils. This causes a significant drop in viscosity, which can be severe in certain
cases.
These limits apply to the following products:
Clavus, Clavus G, Clavus AB, Clavus SD, Clavus SP

Page owner: Peter Smith


Last update: 07/03/08

- 47
This document is strictly confidential & for Internal Shell Use only. It is the basis of the agreement with our Laboratories
for the diagnosis of oil samples.

Refrigerating Compressors: Refrigerant: NH3


Lower limits

Upper limits

Red

Amber

Amber

Red

cSt

-20%

-10%

+20%

+60%

NH3 (Clavus SG)

mg
KOH/g

0.10

0.25

NH3 (Clavus SG)

NH3

mg
KOH/g

0.10

0.20

NH3

TBN (Total Base


Number) after
degassing

ASTM D2896

mg
KOH/g

0.15

0.30

SAN (Strong Acid


Number) after
degassing

ASTM D664

mg
KOH/g

>0.00

0.30

Appearance

Visual

Should be free of solid particles,


sludge or emulsion, bright and
clear

Water Content
(ASTM D6304)

NH3

ppm

200

400

NH3

NH3 (Clavus SG)

ppm

500

1000

NH3 (Clavus SG)

Spectrometry

ASTM D5185-05
ppm

10

20

NH3

ppm

30

60

NH3

NH3 (Clavus SG)

ppm

20

40

NH3 (Clavus SG)

ppm

10

20

Copper (Cu)

ppm

10

20

Lead (Pb)

ppm

10

20

Tin (Sn)

ppm

10

20

Analysis

Method

Units

Viscosity at 40C
after degassing

ASTM D445

TAN (Total Acid


Number) ASTM D664

Aluminum (Al)
Iron (Fe)
Chromium (Cr)

Silicon (Si)

ppm

25

50

Sodium (Na)

ppm

20

50

Potassium (K)

ppm

20

50

Colour

ASTM D1500

6.0

8.0

ISU (Wear Severity


Index)

Screw Compressor

100

250

Piston Compressor

900

1500

mg/L

50

100

ppm

10

40

Millipore Solids (0.8


m membrane)

In House

NH3 Content

Remarks

Remarks:
1. When a sample is cloudy, it is necessary to make a remark in the diagnosis.
2. NH3 being very soluble in water, it reacts with the copper and some of the oil additives. Therefore it is preferable
to use mineral oils.
3. The indicated chlorine content can be adapted, depending on the water content. If water is present, the limit of
acceptance for the chlorine content will be lower, because of the risk of reaction with the copper.
.
These limits apply to the following products:
Clavus SG, Clavus, Clavus AB, Clavus SP
Page owner: Peter Smith
Last update: 07/03/08

- 48
This document is strictly confidential & for Internal Shell Use only. It is the basis of the agreement with our Laboratories
for the diagnosis of oil samples.

Refrigerating compressors: Refrigerant: HFC


Lower limits

Upper limits

Red

Amber

Amber

Red

Analysis

Method

Units

Viscosity at 40C
after degassing

ASTM D445

cSt

-20%

-10%

+20%

+60%

TAN (Total Acid


Number)

ASTM D664

mg
KOH/g

0.10

0.20

TBN (Total Base


Number)

ASTM D2896

mg
KOH/g

0.06

0.15

SAN (Strong Acid


Number) after
degassing

ASTM D664

mg
KOH/g

>0.00

0.30

Appearance

Visual

50

100

All Others

ppm

Carrier

ppm

Aluminum (Al)

ppm

10

20

Iron (Fe)

ppm

20

40

Chromium (Cr)

ppm

10

20

Copper (Cu)

ppm

10

20

Lead (Pb)

ppm

10

20

Water Content
(ASTM D6304)
Spectrometry

300

Should be free of solid particles,


sludge or emulsion, bright and
clear
Note: Carrier allows max 300
ppm

ASTM D5185-05

Tin (Sn)

ppm

10

20

Silicon (Si)

ppm

25

50

Sodium (Na)

ppm

20

50

ppm

20

50

Colour

Potassium (K)
ASTM D1500

2.0

3.0

ISU (Wear Severity


Index)

Screw Compressor

100

250

Piston Compressor

900

1500

50

100

Millipore Solids (0.8


m membrane)

Remarks

In House

mg/L

Remarks:
1. NH3 being very soluble in water, it reacts with the copper and some of the oil additives. Therefore it is preferable
to use mineral oils.
2. The indicated chlorine content can be adapted, depending on the water content. If water is present, the limit of
acceptance for the chlorine content will be lower, because of the risk of reaction with the copper.
3. Freon is very soluble in mineral oils. This causes a significant drop in viscosity, which can be severe in certain
cases.
4. When a sample is cloudy, it is necessary to make a remark in the diagnosis.
5. In case of high water level (red) one may consider a remark to change the filter drier first
These limits apply to the following products:
Clavus R
Page owner: Peter Smith
Last update: 07/03/08
- 49
This document is strictly confidential & for Internal Shell Use only. It is the basis of the agreement with our Laboratories
for the diagnosis of oil samples.

Diesel Fuel
Lower limits
Units

Red

Upper limits

Amber

Amber

Red

Analysis

Method

Viscosity at 40C

ASTM D445

cSt

2.0

4.5

Density @ 15C

IP 189/190

kg/m

820

860

Water Content

ASTM D6304

ppm

200

Cetane Index
(Measured)

ASTM D613

51

Cetane Index
(Calculated)

ASTM D976

46

Millipore Solids (0.45


m membrane)

In House

mg/L

24

Sulfur Content

ASTM D 5185

ppm

50

460 m at 60C

Lubricating Property

Remarks

Remarks:
As regards the distillation of diesel oil, the initial point should be around 160-170 C and the final point should be
around 375 C. Distillation can be used to determine if the diesel oil is contaminated with another product.

Unleaded Gasoline 95
Lower limits
Analysis

Method

Units

Density @ 15C

IP 189/190

kg/m

Octane Index
(Research)

ASTM D2699

Lead (Pb)

ASTM D5185-05

ppm

Upper limits

Red

Amber

Amber

Red

720

775

95

Remarks

Remarks:
As regards the distillation of a gasoline sample, the initial point should be around 30C and the final point should be
around 175 C.

Domestic Fuel
Lower limits
Analysis

Method

Units

Density @ 15C

IP 189/190

kg/m

Cetane Index
Sulfur Content

ASTM D 5185

ppm

Upper limits

Red

Amber

Amber

Red

830

870

40

2000

Remarks

Depending on grade: 350, 50 or


10 ppm

Remarks:
1. Domestic fuel contains two tracers: furfural and diphenylamine.
2. Domestic fuel has a red colour.

Page owner: Hans Wildeboer/Paul Evers


Last update: 08/07/05
- 50
This document is strictly confidential & for Internal Shell Use only. It is the basis of the agreement with our Laboratories
for the diagnosis of oil samples.

Coolants for Engines


Lower limits
Analysis

Method

Units

pH

Upper limits

Red

Amber

7.5

Amber

Red

Remarks

pH: approx. 7.8 with 50 % of


water pH: approx. 8.5 with 66 %
of water

Water Content

40

50

75

Remaining Alkalinity

35

50

Density @ 15C

kg/m

1049

1085

Remarks:

Page owner: Hans Wildeboer/Paul Evers


Last update: 08/07/05
- 51
This document is strictly confidential & for Internal Shell Use only. It is the basis of the agreement with our Laboratories
for the diagnosis of oil samples.

Electro-Erosion Fluids
Lower limits
Analysis

Method

Units

Viscosity at 40C

ASTM D445

cSt

Upper limits

Red

Amber

Amber

Red

-2

-1

+2

+3

Fresh oil: 2.4 to 3.7 cSt


Should be free of solid particles,
sludge or emulsion, bright and
clear

mg
KOH/g

0.08

0.25

0.40

ASTM D93

-15%

-10%

In House

mg/L

100

200

Appearance

Visual

TAN (Total Acid


Number)

ASTM D664

Flash Point (Pensky


Maertens)
Millipore Solids (0.8
m membrane)

Remarks

Remarks:
These limits apply to the following products:
Macron EDM 110/Macron EDM 130

Page owner: David Sleep


Last update: 11/08//05

- 52
This document is strictly confidential & for Internal Shell Use only. It is the basis of the agreement with our Laboratories
for the diagnosis of oil samples.

Metal Working Fluids


Lower limits
Analysis

Method

Units

Upper limits

Red

Amber

Amber

Red

Viscosity at 40C

ASTM D445

cSt

-15%

-10%

+10%

+15%

Water Content

ASTM D6304

ppm

2000

10000

TAN (Total Acid


Number)

ASTM D664

mg
KOH/g

0.50

1.00

Appearance

Visual

Millipore Solids (0.8


m membrane)

In House

100

200

mg/L

Remarks

Should be free of solid particles,


sludge or emulsion, bright and
clear

Remarks:
These limits apply to the following products:

Page owner: Diego Curti


Last update: 08/07/05

- 53
This document is strictly confidential & for Internal Shell Use only. It is the basis of the agreement with our Laboratories
for the diagnosis of oil samples.

Circulating Oils
Lower limits
Red
Amber

Upper limits
Amber
Red

-20%
X

-15%
X

+15%
500

+20%
2000

mg
KOH/g

+0.5 increase
over fresh oil
value

+1.0 increase
over fresh oil
value

ppm
ppm
ppm
ppm
ppm
ppm
ppm
ppm
ppm

X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X

X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X

15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
10

30
30
30
30
30
30
30
30
20

Analysis

Method

Units

Viscosity at 40C
Water Content

ASTM D445
ASTM D6304

cSt
ppm

Appearance

Visual

TAN (Total Acid


Number)

ASTM D664

Spectrometry
Aluminum (Al)
Iron (Fe)
Chromium (Cr)
Copper (Cu)
Lead (Pb)
Tin (Sn)
Silicon (Si)
Sodium (Na)
Calcium (Ca)

Remarks

Should be free of solid particles,


sludge or emulsion, bright and
clear

ASTM D5185-05

Phosphorus (P)

-50% of fresh
oil value

Zinc (Zn)

-50% of fresh
oil value

Delima

Zinc (Zn)

ppm

10

20

Delima S / Morlina / Vitrea Zinc


free product

Remarks:
1. When a sample is cloudy, it is necessary to make a remark in the diagnosis.
2. As for Delima S / Morlina / Vitrea Zn- free product, Zn (Amber 10 ppm, Red - 20 ppm)
3. Vitrea is pure base oil.
Basic Test : Appearance / Viscosity @40C / Water Content /

These limits apply to the following products:


Delima / Delima S / Morlina / Vitrea

Page owner: Jason Cao


Last update: 29/02/08

- 54
This document is strictly confidential & for Internal Shell Use only. It is the basis of the agreement with our Laboratories
for the diagnosis of oil samples.

Seal Oils
Lower limits
Analysis

Method

Units

Upper limits

Red

Amber

Amber

Red

Viscosity at 100C

ASTM D445

cSt

-20%

-10%

+10%

+20%

Viscosity at 40C

ASTM D445

cSt

-20%

-10%

+10%

+20%

Flash Point

ASTM D3828

160

190

Water Content

ASTM D6304

ppm

30

75

TAN (Total Acid


Number)

ASTM D664

mg
KOH/g

0.40

0.60

Appearance

Visual

Colour

ASTM D1500

5.0

7.0

Spectrometry

ASTM D5185-05
ppm

10

Aluminum (Al)
Iron (Fe)

ppm

10

30

Chromium (Cr)

ppm

10

30

Copper (Cu)

ppm

10

30

Lead (Pb)

ppm

10

30

Tin (Sn)

ppm

10

30

Silicon (Si)

ppm

10

30

Sodium (Na)

ppm

10

30

Boron (B)

ppm

10

30

Potassium (K)

ppm

10

30

mg/L

200

500

200

500

Millipore Solids (0.8


m membrane)

In House

ISU (Wear Severity


Index)

In House

Remarks

Should be free of solid particles,


sludge or emulsion, bright and
clear

Remarks:
1. When a sample is cloudy, it is necessary to make a remark in the diagnosis.
These limits apply to the following products:
Shell R 3360/R 3327

Page owner: Joe OConnor


Last update: 08/02/2008

- 55
This document is strictly confidential & for Internal Shell Use only. It is the basis of the agreement with our Laboratories
for the diagnosis of oil samples.

Date

Person
Making
Change

Person
Recommending
Change

Item Changed / Reason for Change

16/11/07

Jane Paules

Hans Wildeboer

07/04/08

Jane Paules

Multiple

19/6/08

Jane Paules

11/11/08

Jane Paules

Dennis
Woodley/Jason Cao
Hans Wildeboer

19/1109

Jane Paules

Ronald Bakker

Automotive Transmission (Automatic) remark 1 added for Donax TZ baseline silicon


level of 25 30 ppm.
Major review of all profiles. See separate Excel spreadsheet for details of all
changes.
Change water level for Morgoil Bearings from an upper red of 1% to 2% as per the
Morgan OEM recommendation.
Added amber iron and copper limits to manual On-Highway Manual Gearboxes, OnHighway Axles and Differentials, and Off-Highway Axles Final Drives Reduction
Gears Slew Drives
Piston Gas Compressors and Vane and Screw Compressors- water limits of upper
amber 3000 ppm & upper red 4000 ppm added for PAG based products such as
Madrela T, GP, GS.

- 56
This document is strictly confidential & for Internal Shell Use only. It is the basis of the agreement with our Laboratories
for the diagnosis of oil samples.

You might also like