Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Edublogger Review
Under the rule change, colleges can still change strategies, and
A "mash-up" of postings from nine engaging educational they can still sell themselves to for-profits. The only change
and e-learning bloggers. is that sale to a new owner will trigger a new review of the
accreditation. If they pass the new review, they’re good to
go. Nobody is blocked from making changes; they just don’t
Taxi Medallions and get a rubber stamp saying they’re still the same institution
Midwestern Zombies afterwards.
By Dean Dad on July 5th, 2010
Of course, having to prove that the new college is worthy of
Credit where credit is due: this story suggests that the Higher accreditation would take time and money, and would therefore
Learning Commission of the North Central Association -- the reduce the economic appeal of struggling colleges to investors.
regional accreditor of record for much of the middle of the But that strikes me as reasonable. Their economic appeal now
country -- is finally righting a longstanding wrong. is based on what amounts to fraud.
As this story from IHE notes, several for-profit companies Will some colleges die on the vine? Yes. Frankly, there’s no way
have built a wildly lucrative business model on treating around that. If anything, I think there’s a perfectly reasonable
regional accreditation as a taxi medallion. I don’t know if the argument for letting some die, rather than letting them walk
taxi system still works this way, but for a long time New York among us as bloated, hollow, undead shells of their former
City rationed the number of taxis, requiring a medallion issued selves, wielding unearned stamps of approval as talismans
by the City as a condition of operation. Medallions could be against sunlight. I say kill the zombies, and make room for the
openly traded, and often went for six figures. The City didn’t new kids.
especially care who had them; it only cared about the overall
number. In that setting, the system made a degree of sense. Bravo, North Central. I hope the other regional accreditors do
(One could always argue about the morality of limiting the the same thing.
overall number, but that’s a separate issue.)
1
July 5th, 2010 Published by: philosophyandrew
Representative of Guide Peer in learning. highlight a sentence) and it's stored in your repository, and the
the establishment. paragraph meanwhile earns a +1 in some database somewhere
(and if read with that turned on, appears as slightly larger print
Responsible Knows what to Continuously than the rest). Tony Hirst , OUseful Info , July 2, 2010 7:49
for imparting teach, when & learn & unlearn. p.m.. [ Link ] [Tags: Learning Object Repositories ] [ Previous
approved how. ][ Next ]
knowledge. Comments
Omit & modify as Knowledgeable on Provocateur
Comment
necessary. a given subject. Connector
Collude with the Interpreter of You are not logged in. [Login]
establishment. information. Title
Workers - Your comment:
Learners –
Employees – Enter email to receive
Associates replies:
Powerless receiver Empowered to Critical Thinker.
Your comments always remain your property, but in posting
of knowledge. find knowledge. Democratization
them here you agree to license under the same terms as this
of knowledge.
site ( Creative Commons ). If your comment is offensive it will
Studies out of fear Closing of Decentralization be deleted.
of failure, reprisal, teacher-learner of authority.
or displacement. divide. Automated Spam-checking is in effect. If you are a registered
user you may submit links and other HTML. Anonymous users
Selfish motive Opportunities Seeker of truth. cannot post links and will have their content screened - certain
to learn – job, for self-directed Engaged words are prohibited and your comment will be analyzed to
money, fame, learners. professional- make sure it makes sense.
power, desire to amateur.
appear smart.
Bingo for Books
By Dean Dad on July 5th, 2010
France Considers Diversifying Last night TW and I took the kids to the local library for Bingo
Its Universities for Books. (It doubled as an excuse to return a pile of books we
all had finished, and to get some new piles.)
By StevenB on July 5th, 2010
France is embarking on a grand experiment — how to On the way into the library, we ran into a family whose younger
diversify the overwhelmingly white “grandes écoles,” the elite daughter is in TB’s class. When she saw TB, she immediately
universities that have produced French leaders in every walk hid behind her older sister. Her sister shoved her out in front,
of life — and Rizane el-Yazidi is one of the pioneers. Because and she smiled at TB. It was a classic embarrassed-to-see-my-
entrance to the best grandes écoles effectively guarantees top crush move. TW and I decided that his charm comes from
jobs for life, the government is prodding the schools to set a double recessive genes.
goal of increasing the percentage of scholarship students to 30
percent. The current system, critics say, is a self-perpetuating We got there early to comb through the stacks. The Boy
elite of the wealthy and white, who provide their own children found a series of adventure novels, and The Girl found a
the social skills, financial support and cultural knowledge to book about wild animals in Africa. (TW found several novels,
pass the entrance exams. Read more at: and I found a characteristically nerdy nonfiction piece about
http://www.nytimes.com/2010/07/01/world/ political economy.) Then we filed into the Community Activity
europe/01ecoles.html?_r=1 room for Bingo.
2
July 5th, 2010 Published by: philosophyandrew
Watching the kids with their friends was worth the time. TB a transformative set of circumstances in her life,
and the girl with the secret crush sat facing each other, making Connected exposes the importance of personal
faces and making each other laugh. They haven’t figured connectedness in relation to understanding global
out self-consciousness yet, so their interaction was sweetly conditions, ultimately showing how all of humanity is
unguarded. Crush Girl referred to her sister at one point as invested in today’s crucial issues.
“Butthead,” eliciting approving laughter from TB. Online Communities are Changing my World – by @edavidove
TG, meanwhile, sat across from Crush Girl’s younger brother. #1 – I was organizing a conference in London
As TW put it, the younger brother looked like he belonged in UK for a client. I researched the internet (blogs,
a creek, jeans rolled up, triumphantly holding up a giant frog discussion threads, social networks, etc.) and found
he had just caught. He was squirmy and silly and incredibly 2 very interesting speakers to participate. One was
animated; TG tolerated him, but proved mostly immune to his from Finland and one was from the USA. The first
wiggly charms. time we met in person was at the conference. We
continue to network and collaborate to this day. One
Every kid won something. TB picked My Side of the of the speakers connected me to an incredible career
Mountain , which struck me as an unusual choice, and TG opportunity.
picked a Cam Jansen mystery. Crush Girl picked The Other Birthing; midwives; knowledge management; organizations &
Side of the Mountain , the sequel, and told TB they’d have structures – by @johnt
to swap after they were done. He agreed, suspecting nothing.
I just smiled. What I got out of it is that midwives are facilitators in
uncertain situations.
In a cruel trick on the parents, the events concluded with a No two births are alike, and nearly all births don’t fall
panoply of sugary snacks. Sugar ‘em up and send ‘em home. on the planned date.
What could possibly go wrong?
Every “mother to be” is different and the midwives
both have to deal with people and their situation.
As we walked out to the car, Crush Girl’s younger brother
They don’t know what to expect as they have not
yelled “bye, TG!” with surprising poignancy; TB suggested that
seen the “mother to be” going through a birth, either
he was thinking “goodbye, my future wife!” TG let it slide.
has the “mother to be” if it’s their first (even if it
was the second or third baby, not every birth is the
It was a small evening in the scheme of things, but as a parent,
same anyway, so not even the “mother to be” knows
it was a real win. We’re such frequent customers at the library
how she will react to new circumstances, especially in
that the children’s librarians greet the kids by name. The kids
different environments).
already know their favorite shelves. They were excited to go,
and excited to start reading their latest acquisitions when they Performance Consulting: finding the best solution from the
got home. They enjoyed the activity, behaved well, and had training, informal learning, performance support mix – by
fun with their friends. They’re growing up, but they haven’t hit @c4lpt
the self-conscious “shut the parents out” stage yet. It’s all just When confronted with a learning or performance
there. It all just worked. problem, the normal and traditional response from
L&D is to create a training solution, probably in
I just wanted to capture that in writing before it fades. the form of an all-singing, all-dancing content-rich
e-learning course. For a long while I’ve compared
this approach with using a hammer to crack the
Connecting the dots proverbial nut!
By Harold Jarche on July 5th, 2010 Steve Denning: HBR: Rushing to the 20th Century – via
@RossDawson
Here are some of the things I learned via Twitter this past
week: Want to kill your firm quickly? Then study the
current issue of Harvard Business Review. Imbibe its
@Louisvancuijk – “Knowledge is only a rumour until it is in philosophy, its attitudes and its values. Implement
the muscles.” everything it says. In so doing, you will be well on the
Connected, a declaration of interdependence by way to turning your organization into a fully-fledged
@tiffanyshlain 20th Century organization, with a life expectancy of
around 5-10 years.
Combining powerful visuals, humor, animation,
irony, and serious messages, Connected explores Competition is overrated: Startups are primarly competing
the visible and invisible connections between the against indifference, lack of awareness, and lack of
major issues of our time — the environment, understanding — not other startups – via @sebpaquet
population growth, technology, human rights, and 1) Almost every good idea has already been built.
the global economy – demonstrating how they Sometimes new ideas are just ahead of their time.
are all interdependent. Following the filmmaker’s There were probably 50 companies that tried to do
exploration of her own place in the world during viral video sharing before YouTube. Before 2005,
3
July 5th, 2010 Published by: philosophyandrew
when YouTube was founded, relatively few users had Enter email to receive
broadband and video cameras. YouTube also took replies:
advantage of the latest version of Flash that could
play videos seamlessly.
Your comments always remain your property, but in posting
them here you agree to license under the same terms as this
Oklahoma State U Will Be site ( Creative Commons ). If your comment is offensive it will
be deleted.
Testing Out iPads This Fall
By StevenB on July 5th, 2010 Automated Spam-checking is in effect. If you are a registered
user you may submit links and other HTML. Anonymous users
The iPad is coming to a classroom near you this fall. OSU has
cannot post links and will have their content screened - certain
announced that it will be running a trial program with the
words are prohibited and your comment will be analyzed to
Apple-made tablet computers with about 125 students in five
make sure it makes sense.
classes during the fall semester. OSU President Burns Hargis
said he sees the iPad being a useful tool moving forward. “I
really think they’ll be the future,” Hargis said. The iPad also
had the potential to save students some money on textbooks.
Higher Ed's Caste System
According to the press release, students in one of the trial Makes Adjuncts The
classes offered this fall can save more than $100 on the
textbook for that class by purchasing the electronic version Untouchables
instead of the physical copy. Read more at: By StevenB on July 5th, 2010
http://www.ocolly.com/ipad-invades-osu-1.1495519 American universities and colleges are riddled with a caste
system that violates our societal sense of fairness, justice,
and decency. Adjunct or contingent faculty, who are neither
What HBR hasn't noticed: four tenured nor on a tenure track, comprise nearly 80% of all
reasons why management college teachers. The 540,000 adjuncts who work part-time
receive low wages, no benefits, no administrative support
needs radical change and no academic rights. Contingent teachers, as adjuncts are
July 5th, 2010 officially called, are the "untouchables" of our college system.
Read more at:
That sputtering and disguised cursing you hear is me reading
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/pablo-eisenberg/the-
Harvard Business Review. Every day I am finding stuff from
untouchables-of-ameri_b_629815.html
that site that to me is so far off base I don't even know where to
begin my criticisms. But this article is a good start. The author
argues that HBS writers simply haven't noticed that the world
has changed. That could be. In particular, HBS writers seem
What China Can Teach Writing
not to have noticed the following: Teachers
- workers are no longer semi-skilled and cannot simply be July 5th, 2010
supervised and cannot simply be told what to do
The key think the 'common core' people get wrong is that there
- you need a committed workforce; you cannot expect sullen
are other ways to see the world. This is drawn out evocatively
or resentful, morose or angry to do brain surgery or draw up
by Clay Burell as he describes some recent work in Chinese
legal documents
literary theory. He writes, "Nisbett's whole point in this book
- customers are no longer willing to accept just anything; they
of 'cultural psychology' is to show that modes of thought differ
expect quality products and customer service
from culture to culture, that Enlightenment universalism is
- you can't just think of the workplace as a system any more;
belied by the evidence, etc, etc. The point of the passage itself is
the 'parts' have feelings, the 'outputs' have social goods (or
to illustrate how unlike our abstract and essentialist Greek way
harms)
of thinking is the Chinese, which resists hard categories and
There's a lot more, in my book, but this is a good starting point.
prefers, as Nisbett puts it, 'expressive, metaphoric language.'"
Clay Burrell , Beyond School , July 2, 2010 7:19 p.m.. [ Link ]
Steve Denning , The Leader's Guide to Radical Management
[Tags: Books , Ontologies , China ] [ Previous ][ Next ]
, July 2, 2010 7:27 p.m.. [ Link ] [Tags: Quality ] [ Previous ]
[ Next ] Comments
Comments Comment
Comment You are not logged in. [Login]
You are not logged in. [Login] Title
Title Your comment:
Your comment: Enter email to receive
replies:
4
July 5th, 2010 Published by: philosophyandrew
Your comments always remain your property, but in posting Title
them here you agree to license under the same terms as this
site ( Creative Commons ). If your comment is offensive it will Your comment:
be deleted.
Enter email to receive
Automated Spam-checking is in effect. If you are a registered replies:
user you may submit links and other HTML. Anonymous users
cannot post links and will have their content screened - certain Your comments always remain your property, but in posting
words are prohibited and your comment will be analyzed to them here you agree to license under the same terms as this
make sure it makes sense. site ( Creative Commons ). If your comment is offensive it will
be deleted.
Federal officials are requiring colleges that use Kindles and College Presidents Need To
other electronic book readers in the classroom to make Rethink Corporate Board
sure the gadgets have accommodations for blind and vision-
impaired students. The U.S. Departments of Justice and Participation
Education sent a letter to college and university presidents By StevenB on July 5th, 2010
Tuesday instructing them to find alternatives for blind As much as higher education and corporate America
students if the devices are required in the classroom. Not doing would like to be engaged, college presidents are struggling
so would be a violation of federal law. Read more at: to reconcile the demands and values of academia with
http://www.boston.com/news/education/higher/ shareholder skepticism about their boardroom commitments.
articles/2010/06/29/ Companies recruit college presidents to add independent
feds_colleges_must_have_blind_friendly_gadgets/ voices on boards dominated by corporate officers.
Shareholders question the college leaders’ availability for
Sakai Conference: Kamenetz board tasks. Campus critics say chancellors, provosts and
presidents should be focusing on budget cuts and shrunken
Keynote endowments, and are tainted by the behavior of companies
July 5th, 2010 they serve. Read more at:
http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2010-06-30/bp-to-
I haven't watched this yet, but Anya Kamenetz's keynote at goldman-boards-becoming-hot-seats-for-conflicted-college-
the Sakai conference is an odd enough mix to be intriguing. presidents.html
Michael Feldstein gives the talk (which starts about 23 minutes
into the video) a polite, almost enthusiastic, write-up. "The
keynote," he writes, "provides a significantly evolved and It's every bastard for himself,
refined version of her argument." In order to grow DIY U
("which I'm increasingly inclined to think of as simply a the last century hasn't ended
trendier and more provocative name for open education," he
writes) we need to pay attention to content, socialization,
yet
July 5th, 2010
and accreditation. Or, as George Siemens has said more
clearly, we are creating open learning in three phases: open It's not simply because my photo is on page 9 that I think
content, open classes, open assessment. Feldstein finishes this issue of Today's Campus is worth a look. Because though
with what I would consider the starting point of the personal the issue is set from the premise of edupunk, as Groom
learning environment project: "it's worth asking ourselves how notes, "I marvel at how quickly the narrative of change in
technology can help scaffold learning experiences to foster a higher education is sucked into the seemingly irrefutable and
sense of autonomy, increasing mastery, and greater purpose." naturalized logic of business innovation." Agreed. Maybe they
Michael Feldstein , e-Literate , July 2, 2010 7:15 p.m.. [ weren't there, but the magazine authors - and Anya Kamanetz
Link ] [Tags: Assessment , Connectivism , Open Content , - fail to see is that edupunk is about counter-culture, not selling
Experience , Project Based Learning ] [ Previous ][ Next ] out. There are good reasons for that. As Tony Hirst says, "The
disaster that happens when democracy is for sale is nothing
Comments
when compared to what will happen when learning is for sale."
Comment Jim Groom , bavatuesdays , July 2, 2010 7:03 p.m.. [ Link ]
[Tags: Edupunk ] [ Previous ][ Next ]
You are not logged in. [Login]
5
July 5th, 2010 Published by: philosophyandrew
6
July 5th, 2010 Published by: philosophyandrew
words are prohibited and your comment will be analyzed to
Why For-Profits Are Facing make sure it makes sense.
Tougher Federal Regulation
By StevenB on July 5th, 2010
Bringing Back The Bell Tower
Congress last instituted reforms in the for-profit education
sector two decades ago, but federal aid to students at for- Tradition
profit schools has rapidly increased, approaching $24 billion By StevenB on July 5th, 2010
last year. Senator Tom Harkin found that up to 90% of for- Each day, as University of Florida students wander their
profit schools' revenue comes from Washington and that for- Gainesville campus, texting away on cellphones and pondering
profit students are graduating with more debt than students their collective futures, the afternoons are punctuated by the
at public or private nonprofit universities. With 96% of echoing sounds of a relic from the past. From the 11th floor
proprietary students taking out loans, and nearly half of of UF's Century Tower, the 500-year-old art of playing the
them defaulting, taxpayers foot the bill. The refrain is usually carillon endures. What does all that bell-ringing have to do
the same: after being lured by aggressive recruitment and with higher education? Increasingly, a lot, as schools across
advertising strategies, low-income students leave proprietary Florida and the country are turning to bell towers -- or
schools unemployed and trapped in debt. cheaper electronic imitations -- as a way of fostering tradition,
Read more at: http://www.time.com/time/business/ reflection, and perhaps even little bit of promptness among the
article/0,8599,2000160,00.html#ixzz0sKgG6B9m perpetually late student body. Read more
http://www.miamiherald.com/2010/06/29/1705565/
tradition-rings-on-across-campuses.html#ixzz0sKhUT1De
The educational significance
of social media – a critical Stephen Downes – The Role of
perspective Open Educational Resources
July 5th, 2010
Title
Your comment: