Professional Documents
Culture Documents
jiJJ
.
.2 Steel springs are more effective, but
Neoprene and Natural Rubber pads are
rJ also used to reduce vibration to entire struc-
tures or structural components such as indi-
':':::::",:~::~::::';::"":~:..~.".:;.'~:
vidual floors or a theater within a building,
to levels that are unnoticeable or totally
acceptable,
i =100 [1-{Li}.r-1]
= percentage vibrationreduction
= disturbingfrequency
= Natural or Resonantfrequency
of the isolated system
Since the disturbing frequency can be measured or from a
known source, the variable is the,pad frequency or resonance. Shape
This frequency is a fundion of deRection, the shape of the load Factor
- deflection curve and dynamic stiffness. Plates
Helical steel springs have straight line load deflection curves and Rubber Bearing Cross Section Type BBNR
the dynamic stiffness at is the same as the static stiffness (stiff-
ness when loaded slowly),
: ',~-, .', :..' ~~
If a steel spring were deflected 0.3" (7.6mm), the frequency
would be: Metric .
,"" , ",.'. .'b,,'"
. .' '.
~
:1
. -' :'.'
,'().~
0:
4.,<7'0' 4",
'1=3. 13 JTT.
. 't or ...=3,13}~25 4 = Hertz 1Hz)cycles
frequency in per sec-
'...
;:,. , -~". ~~~.:.
:'",".'
','
,.,,' :.'
. '..'--:", :_-" ~
ond
.. deflection in inches
.,
('=3,13) 01.3 or 3.13} 2';64 =,0... or mm
- - - ----
."- .
is accom- '; 1
In broad terms, dynamic stiffness is controlled by:
plished by tall bearings with \,1
, Natural Rubber has the lowest dYnam- , "I
extremely Iow horizontal or shear '1
ic stiffness of all the common materials. The synthetic frequencies. Vertical deflection is
j
material, Neoprene, comes next. There is virtually no kept to a minimum as most earth-
data on other polymers, because they are not used for quakes have high horizontal forces,
this purpose. and structures are more prone to -.
horizontal resonance and failure.
- Rubber materials are similar to concrete
in the sense that by varying the formula you can Bridge and overpass bearings work
in shear to accommodate expansion
produce different properties. When mixing concrete, and contraction. Frequency is not
the reinfarcing materials are sand and gravel. In
important and plays little or no role ~
mixing rubber, high quality compounds are rein. in the design. The rubber pad must
forced with carbon blacks. The inexpensive com- have a minimum thickness of twice
pounds with poor physical properties may use cheap the anticipated horizontal motion.
fillers like clay, talc and sometimes coal particles. In Movements are dependent on the ~
order to keep dynamic stiffness Iow, the black fillers are temperature extremes and the spac-
kept to a weight ratio that is never over half that of ing between pads.
the Natural Rubber. ~
This bulletin is primarily dedicated
Harder materials with larger proportion to or
of black Fillers will tend to have higher dynamic . The nouns "pads" and "bear-
stiffnesses. ings" are interchangeable. -.-
Most acousticians will specify a maximum dynamic stiff- Rubber is an engineering material
ness of 1.4 or lower. We are pleased to say that within and design is based on both chem-
our company, we have developed compounds as hard as ical and physical properties. Neoprene and Natural
Rubber formulations fill both requirements. Neaprene has
60 durometer with a dynamic stiffness that is still in the
the advantage of better aging documentation and chemi-
1.3 range. In working with our company, bearings can be cal resistance. Natural ruober is considerably less expen-
designed at lower cost by using 60 durometer rubber as sive and lower in dynamic stiffness. Natural Rubber aging
compared to competitors that might be limited to 50 documentation is not as formal, but with modern anti-oxi.
durometer or softer materials.
dant and anti-ozonant additives, aging is no longer of
If a rubber pad deflected 0.3" (7.6mm) and the dynamic major concern.
stiffness was 1.3, the effective deflection would be 0.3" load carrying capacity is based on:
divided by 1.3 or 0.23" (5.9mml. Solving the Frequency 1. Hardness
'.w
....
equation shows a frequency of 6.5Hz. A poorer com- 2. Area
pound with a dynamic stiffness of 1.7 would reduce the 3. Shape Factor
effective deflection to O.180" (4.6mm) with a corre- 4. Allowable Strain
sponding higher frequency. 5. Allowable Stress
A second correction , is the term for hardness as
depends on.the shape of the rubber load deflection curve. indicated by a Durometer number. The
This curve is not straight line and the measured deflection normal range for isolation is 40 to 60~5
must be reduced by the effect of the increased spring rate as limited by dynamic stiffness. It is mea-
at the design loading. sured by a clock like instrument called a
Durometer that has a spring loaded pin in the flat surface
is additional deflection or drift over time. It is on the bottom. Penetration shows as a direct reading by
not a percentage of the pad's thickness. Creep is a single hand that points to the hardness number. The
a percentage of the initial deflection and a function harder the rubber, the higher the durometer and the
of the rubber compound. A working number of 30% greater the load carrying copacity.
creep is reasonable. Were the initial deflection 0.3"
- . . - is the fully covered pad area at
(7.6mm), within 100 days the pad would creep
0.30 (0.3) or 0.09" (2.3mm) and for all ractical
purposes remain at a total deflection 0 0.39"
(9.9mm). This additional deflection does not reduce
r 90 to the supported load. In flat pads the shear area is
identical. Shear offers horizontal resistance to wind and
accidental impact from a derailed train or a large vehicle.
Shear stiffness and spring back restores centering and
the frequency. contributes to stability. Holes
When an isolation frequency of 5.5 Hz or higher will --: Rubber is similar to a fluid
solve the problem, rubber isolation pads are more eco- and volumetrically incompressible. When
nomical than steel springs. the flat surface is loaded and the rubber
squeezed, the rubber bulges. The bulge
Rubber noise and vibration pads are used in compression volume is equal to the pad deflection multi-
at a strain of (deflection) up to 10% of the rubber thick- plied by the loaded area. Shape Factor is defined as the
ness when supporting structures. Once the desired fre- loaded area divided by the bul!iJeor escape area. While \",;
quency and dynamic stiffness is known, it is a simele cal- this is usually perimeter area onty, holes or cutouts can be
culation to work back to the deflection. The deflection introduced to allow for inward bulging as well. Typically,
divided by the strain determines the thickness of the work- the holes or ribs in standard isolation pads, such as the
ing rubber in the bearing. "Super W", are there to reduce shape factor.
2
- --- -
~
450000 EffectiVe Deflection
- L~~,;~d 400000 0.12 DeRection (A)
3vlging-cscc;::e ) \'S"
' 350IlOO
, . 0.03 Correction (8)
300000 , 0.09 Usable Deflection
The Shape Factor for a 12" x 12" x 1" thick pad (300mm :g
:;. 25QOOO for Frequency Calculation
x 300mm x 25mm) would be: 'a
.. -'; Curvature -
.'-..' . 2 0 200000 uO --u
A = loaded Area= 12x12 = 144 In I "-< Correction
150000 , Tangent-
SF = E = Escape Area = 12x4xl = 48 in2=3 100000
,
,
,
If the pad were 2" (50mm) thick, the SF would drop to 1.5 50000
or should it be 0.75" (20mm) , it would increase to 4. :'81 A
0
0.00 0.05 0.10 0.15 0.20 D.25 0.30
The higher the SF the greater the capacity, as it is more Deflection (in)
4.0
--- 3.0
-.-
difficultfor the rubber to bulge. 1000
2.5
is the percentage reduction of the I
overall thickness. A 1" (25mm) thick pad compressed This is not 0 design manual 900
0.10" (2.5mm) has a strain of 0.10/1.00 (2.5/25) or but 0 general source of infor- 800
10% . Strain should be kept very Iow when there are motion as to bearing pod 2.0
large variations in loadings and large shear displace- design. If our results differ from 1 700
1.8
your experience, it is because tii
ments such as under bridges or trestles as this type of
cycling leads to fatigue. Most engineering references con-
of different references and 600 ~ i i
1.6 ~
sider strain more critical than stress. compounds. ~ 600
!
t)
1.4 {f.
: ..
Highway codes such as the British BS 6177 and Earlier in our discussion we 'I 1.2 i
the American AASHTO may limit pads to as little referenced a 12" x 12" ~ 400 .t::
1.0 I/)
as 6% strain. Building isolation is more passive, so (300mm x 300mm) pad in S 300
0.8
strain can be somewhat higher and subject to the thicknesses of 2" (50mm), 1" "
0.6
200
designer's experience. (25mm) and 3/4" (20mm)
.
with respective shape factors 100
We have overloaded high quality pads in our laboratory of 1.5, 3 and 4. let us see
to 60% strain (6-8 times rated load) and held them how these pods would act by 00 5 10 15 20
for a week. They recovered 80% to 90% of the original referring to the 60 durometer Compressive Strain, %
thickness immediately and 100% in a day. The recom- shape factor curves.
mended strain limit had been 15% for many, many years.
We do not know if the more conservative numbers are
." based on negative experience or arbitrarily increasing
.'
.--
".-
----
safety foctors. ---
is the loading per unit area. 12x12x2.0 1.5 144 170 0.16 24,480
Maximum published compressive stress values are as high 12xl2x1.0 3 144 450 0.08 64,800
as 3OOOpsi (20,680 kPa), but more commonly 2000psi
(13,790 kPa). A limit of 1500psi (10,340 kPa) in com- 12xl2x3/4 4 144 660 0.06 95,040
pression is recommend provided strain is in the 8-10%
range. Reductions in either number increase consistent When rubber bulges, it develops large shear forces at
performance over time. Much lower stresses are often the upper and lower contact surfaces. Ifpancaking occurs,
used to provide a practicol bearing size when support the shape factor curves become meaningless. Simple
areas are large and loadings Iow. rubber pads used at Iow stress between rough concrete
surfaces, do not spread in the contact area. As a rough
If a 10,000 Ib (4545 kg) bearing pad were to be
located under a 12 inch (300mm) beam Range or the guide based on our experience, 400psi (2757 kPa)
between concrete surfaces and 250psi (1723 kPa)
load were applied at the top of a 12 inch (300mm)
between dry steel surfaces are not a worry.
square column, we would use minimum 10"x 10"
(250mm x 250mm) pads both for appearance and
stability. Since there are 100 square inches, the stress
drops to l00psi (689 kPal, nowhere near maximum
design. Therefore, loadings may be controlled by
available space, stability, common sense or aesthetics
rather than maximum allowable stress.
Empirical Shape Factor curves help the designer. While
they are bosed on durometer, results can vary widely as
not only do Natural Rubber and Neoprene have different
- -------
The 12" x 12" x 3/4" (300mm x 300mm x 20mm)
pad at 660 psi (4550 kPa) with a shape factor of
4 does not fall into these categories. Therefore, steel Not all problems con be solved with rubber isolation pads.
On page 2 we hove indicated that the cut off point for rub-
plates must be bonded to each surface to prevent surface
ber bearings is about 5.5 Hz. This would mean that the
spreading. In most cases, these plates are 1/8" (3mm)
thick and covered with 1/8" (3mm) bonded rubber incoming frequency should not be lower than 16.5 Hz just
to maintain the traditional but often unsatisfactory 90%
top and bottom. There is a 1/4" (6mm) protective
thearetical efficiency. The efficiency equation is based on
,
layer around the edges. The deflection of the 1/8"
(3mm) cover is negli- the assumption that a structure is a lumped mass or a block
1/4" (6mm) 3/4"(19mm) l/S" (3mm) gible as the shope of concrete that has no flexibility and an infinite resonance
Side Cover ActivePad Steel factor jumps to 24, frequency. It is also assumed that this rigid mass loads
, J. but the overall pad each isolator in accordance with the weight distribution as
dimensions are now a lump mass at each location.
T 12-1/2" x 12-1/2" This assumption is false. Just as in the isolation of structur-
l/S* (3mm) 1-1/4"(32mm) x 1-1/4" (318mmx al floors from machinery, the selection of a practical
Cover OverallHeight 318mm x 32mm). deflection is dependent on the sensitivity or rigidity of the
structure and the various resonances of the structural ele-
Assuming the loading of 95,040 Ib (43,200 kg) is
correct, but the deflection of 0.06" (1.5mm) is too Iow ments. A lightly loaded structural floor might have a fre-
to meet a frequency requirement, we would increase quency as high os 7 Hz and fully loaded, 3 Hz. The fre-
the number of layers. quency of the steel columns resting on the isolators might
be very much higher. Concrete structures will transmit
To attain 1/2" (13mm) deflection, the bearing wauld structurally induced noise over very large distances from
have eight 3/4" (19mm) active layers. The overall the source with almost no attenuation.
configuration would be nine 1/8" (3mm) bonded steel
plates, 1/8" (3mm) We recently extended our own office building and some
top and bottom cover demolition was required. The construction workers were
7-3/8* and 1/4" (6mm) pro- using small chipping hammers about 150 feet from my
(t87mm
Overal /
tection on all sides.
The overall dimensions
office. There was no air-borne sound transmission, but the
structure-borne noise radiating from the ceiling made it
Height
~-~~--
~I. would increase to seem like they were directly overhead.
12-1/2" x 12-1/2" x In mechanical isolotion wor~ we have found that when iso-
7-3/8" (318mm x
lating vibration at frequencies as high as 250 Hz, we
318mm x 187mm).
have had to use air springs with a response of 3 Hz before
the isolation was effective as the vibration was in the audi-
ble noise range. -
Moving on to lower speed machinery at 30 Hz, we have
had to use isolators with a response os Iow os 2 Hz (0
frequency ratio of 15 to 1) before we could solve the
problem.
-- -- -
means the isalatian will only improve at greater occupan-
cy, However the mountings must have additional capacity
to accept maximum structuralloadings,
In designing spring isolators, travel can be limited
Embedded
Anchor Plate
While steel spring isolators do an excellent job of stop-
ping vibration, it is very important that high frequency
Combination
noise transmission is considered too. It is our suggestion
Adjustment Bolt
that all spring isolators have 10Hz base isolation pads and Downstop
2"(50mm) thick, manufactured to the same standards as
in the earlier part af this discussian.
. '.".0
"
. ,-.." ,0','.
/,
.'-.
"u
.. -' -.
0' " ----- - --
Downstop Clearance
2" (50mm)Thick
. #," 10Hz Acoustical Pad
Embedded
Anchor Plate
Removable
SteelSpacer
Each Side
Springsare
Horizontally Restrained -.....
Top and BoUam by Holders Hydraulic Jack
Load Retention
Bolts
Structural weight calculations ore broad. In terms of - Structural
foundation design, normal discrepancies are of no Steel Slides
consequence. However, when the structure is depen-
dent on springs releasing themselves, if the weight is not
close to the calculation, the springs will either release We use exactly the some system in supporting structures.
too early or not at 011.Hot wound spring capacity con The mountings con be built to any capacity, but the
vary plus or minus 19%. Assuming they do release requirement for on individual isolator rarely exceeds
exactly as planned, there is still additional travel equal 750,000 Ibs.(340,OOO kgs.) Rather than using steel sides
to 30% of the dead load deflection plus additional live to support the structure, temporary support is provided by
load. A 2"(50mm) spring deflectian example is easier concrete piers or individual steel stanchions.
to visualize. The mountings should release at 1.4"
(36mm), depending on whether the 2"(50mm) was Bolts, Steel Spacers Removable Hydraulic
specified at dead load or at dead load with some orWedgeJocks-- -- Jack to Load Springs
Support Structure
occupancy. They would have to travel on additional
0.6"(15mm) or more at full load. This is considerable
movement os it is not just the mountings that ore
moving, but the whole structure.
Should the totol weight be correct, but the distribution
erroneous, the mountings would release and continue
troveling at different times. Most important the structure
is at 0 fixed elevation only until 70% of the assigned
load is reached. Thereafter the level changes. The final
elevation can not be forecast os it is weight and exact
spring rote dependent.
Springs ore ~
Should there be 0 need to change springs, the only way Horizontally Restrained
to do so is to tighten the bolts so the springs cannot Top and BoUom by Holders
expand, jock up the building slightly and pull the mount-
ings out. Alternately, you mignt compress the springs
6
-
- - -- - -- - - - - - ----
Building load Resting on Building load Building load
Removable Spacers Transferred to Springs FullySupported by Spring
on Construction Using Hydraulic Jack AssemblY,Spacer Removed
Embedded Load I
I I I 1 I I I I I I
DistributionPlates
---- I
Removable
-~ Typical No Change
Steel Spocer in Building
Elevotion
Steel or
---- i 5" Unloaded -- :\ I
Concrete,
.. .- . . I (12lmm) / 0 -\ -.'
Conslruction
." :. -.: 0: : .00 0 0 0 . o. 0 . 0".
- - - -,;, . o' .- . 0 0 '. Typicol
Supports . '0. 0
Supports~ecome
.: .
00 '. 0 0 o. o. 0
.. 0" .0 : 0 . SafetyStopsAlterSpnng..
0
~.o
Mo 0
:
,00 41/4"(lOlmm)
00 AfterAdjustment
The buildingis held at fixed elevation by the stanchions position. If it is more expeditious to do so, the whole
plus the removable steel spacer on top until the building mounting is removed, serviced, placed back in position,
is completed. The building never moves during construc- the load restored and the spacer removed. This is a foo/-
tion. Hydraulic jacks are then introduced to compress the proof method.
springs uniformly, and the structural support bolts Earlier in the discussion we had mentioned that should you
advanced, mounting by mounting, until the spacers can wish to install rubber bearing pads and have them remov-
be removed. The elevation never changes. If the loads able, the same technique could be used. The difference is
are not exactly correct, adjustments vary until each mount that the rubber bearing would be load supporting rather
picks up the exact load at that location. than the springs.
Should the architect wish to minimize live chan.ges in ele- Building isolation systems should not be used in seismic
vation, spring adjustment could be held off until all zones without a thorough study of the revailing fre-
mechanical systems were installed, or everything except quencies, accelerations and amplitudes. AI building con- r
the people. Figurations must be studied for wind effects and there will
Should the springsneed servicing,the steel shimsare put be those occasions where viscous damping becomes
back in place, the springs relaxed by reversing the instal- important.
lation procedure until the mounting is completely free and Our professionol staff can offer designs and specifica-
'-" the load backon thestanchion.Dependingon location, tions. We would be pleased to work with your acoustical
the compression plate over the springs coulClbe removed consultant or to introduce you to consultant firms to help
and the springs serviced with the lower base plate in establish the frequency criteria.
........
- - - - - --- - - - - - - - --
The following pictures will 2) Completedmoldfor a
give you 0 better ideo of the 4" f1OOmm) bearing
pad 18" x 24" (457 x
process of manufacturing {)lOmm). The mold has
isolation bearings. a base plate with 4
he~ k~ sides. The
holes in tfie sides ore fur '--
air escape and rubber
Row os the uncured rub-
ber is compressed. The
closure plate is s~
ed temporarily. The
mold is on a feed table 3) The uncured rubber is in ~rs
to a huge rubber press separated by the bonded steel plates
with a 30" 762mm) that maintain the shape foetor. Starting
cylinder and oif eressure from the bottom, the lower rubber
of 3000psi (20,640 cover, steel plate, and the active load
kPa). Theclosing force is bearing layer:.The bearing consists of
over 2,000,000 lb. four plates, three load bearing layers
(909,090 kg.). and the top and bottom cover.
1) Our certified welder is
welding the steel mold shown 6) The molding
in phOtograph 2. The steel process is camp'lete,
components have already and the mold back
been saw or flame cut in on the table. The
other areas af the shop. excess rubber has
escal?6.dthroughthe
bleea holes.
4) Our skilled press-
man is placing the
uncured rubber and
sond-blasted steel
plates, covered with
0 bonding agent in 7) The top and
the mold. Twosides side plates are
were removed to removed to reveal
focilitate loading. the finished part.
5) The mold is in the press
during the slow, forceful
closing. The mold will
remain in the p'ress for 3
hours at 305DF (152 DC).
'-
8) Flash rubber is removed 9) A finished lot of bearings 10) Compl!terizedtesting in our 11) Test in ~ 10 determine
around the edges" as well being wheeled to the test 750 000 lb. (340,OOO kg.) in house test shear characteristics under full verti-
as the sprues tram the area. machine to determine vertical spri~ rate cal load. When independent testi!Jg
bleeder holes. and carrying capacily, superviSed by our is ~uired, it is always witnessed by
professional engineering staff. independentprofessionalengineers.
- -
':":=""="-"""""-"'MasaN --- .-- - Ifi@ a ~FOR' I~
,,~~:~~J ~~;~',,~~=.~!I
IIf r_n I - ... ---'
~~!I'fck~~~'~==
~
~
1
L LI7I!J8rf~_!t~l~~
~~~2:c2~ao ~~~--~~=--~~
J-MuimlnLoldato.1S'0!I~~~
a x8 20800412.
I
I
g
1
:3x 3 ~ Ox 12 384G1).S78OD
~
,
I, I 3:(~
.4.n'io
~!O
~ 10xlO'
1Ox12 ~~
~ 4x& ~ 12x12 'I92OO-1118QQ
n I 6 xS 'iacll>iaooG 151:15 . 'MCI:SN18375
.~ I 6s6
&2i:~2 1~1soao
~OO 18x18
24x24 243GC'S!15DO
482Q00.648000
B i- -, -~~ ,- "--""
1
ij I
'jP'-PadIa ~
-~~~~~~!!~~....
AI'I'~- to&d~
.. "* .
r PadsHatf':'8load
,
':.J; I TYPE'"
Y DIIIENSION$ANDWBG!ff$
L_-
r-, "'""""""""===-
e t.~.a~rr~~11QN ~TA
- -
~--=--~-="""~-== =-"'-""""",.,~
=--
=--===
=.~ =.""",..,
= ==
...::
,
--'
--
.
r:.r.-: t,~~Rf:~."" =~~-:-=-
-~--=--- - ..~J --i.
i~;O.~-=-=-~-'--- --=~.=
..i
~ ,Alllis.a-' ; - ~
~
-
**
.~,.,..".-
TOTAL PAGE.ee4 **
---~=
-
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-- -- ----
----