You are on page 1of 7

Pr-Fono Revista de Atualizao Cientfica. 2008 out-dez;20(4).

Habilidade de ateno compartilhada em sujeitos com


transtornos do espectro autstico***

Joint attention ability in children with autistic spectrum disorders

Camila Gioconda de Lima e Menezes*


Jacy Perissinoto**

*Fonoaudiloga. Especializao em Abstract


Desenvolvimento de Linguagem e suas Background: joint attention in children with autistic spectrum disorders. Aim: to evaluate joint attention
Alteraes pela Universidade de So
Paulo. Mestre em Cincias pelo
ability in subjects with autistic spectrum disorders in different contexts and with different interlocutors.
Programa de Ps-Graduao em Method: twenty subjects with ages between four and twelve years, diagnosed with autism or asperger
Distrbios da Comunicao Humana do syndrome (DSM-IV-TR, 2002) by a multidisciplinary team, with no associated disorders, and who were
Departamento de Fonoaudiologia da enrolled in language therapy for at least six months were assessed. The Symbolic Maturity Assessment
Universidade Federal de So Paulo. Test was used to evaluate joint attention behaviors. An adaptation that included the Semi-Structured Play
Endereo: Rua Botucatu, 802 - So
Paulo - SP - CEP 04023-900 situations was carried out for this research. For all of the studied situations (free play; semi-structured play
(cagimenezes@yahoo.com.br). with speech and language therapist and the caregiver; imitation) the following joint attention behaviors
were observed: alternate, point, show (by childs initiative or in response to adults action) and look at
**Fonoaudiloga. Doutora do adults action (response behavior). The last included the differentiation of the ways by which the adult
Programa de Ps-Graduao em
Distrbios da Comunicao Humana do
drew the childs attention (talking; gesturing; or both). Results: the different situations changed the way
Departamento de Fonoaudiologia da these subjects shared attention. The adults intervention proved to be effective in triggering an increase
Universidade Federal de So Paulo. in the occurrence of joint attention behaviors, mainly in response to the adult. No differences were found
Ps-Doutorado - Paris (Sorbone). between interlocutors (speech therapist and mother) in semi-structured situations, probably because both
interlocutors synchronized their behaviors with the children. Conclusion: the evaluation of joint attention
***Trabalho Realizado na
Universidade Federal de So Paulo.
behaviors in play contexts was effective and the interference of a known adult was reflected in the
increase of the occurrence of these behaviors in semi-structured and imitation situations.
Key Words: Autism; Asperger Syndrome; Autism Spectrum Disorders; Attention; Language.

Resumo
Artigo Original de Pesquisa
Tema: ateno compartilhada em sujeitos do espectro autstico. Objetivo: avaliar a habilidade de ateno
Artigo Submetido a Avaliao por Pares compartilhada em sujeitos com transtornos do espectro autstico em diferentes contextos e com diferentes
interlocutores. Mtodo: foram avaliados vinte sujeitos com idades entre quatro e doze anos, com autismo
Conflito de Interesse: no infantil ou sndrome de asperger (DSM-IV-TR, 2002) sem outros transtornos, diagnosticados por equipe
multidisciplinar, que estavam em terapia fonoaudiolgica h pelo menos seis meses. Para avaliao dos
comportamentos de ateno compartilhada foram utilizados os materiais e procedimentos da Avaliao
da Maturidade Simblica, alm de uma adaptao feita para esta pesquisa que incluiu as situaes Semi-
Dirigidas com interlocutores familiares. Para as situaes estudadas (brincadeira livre; semi-dirigidas com
terapeuta e cuidador; imitao), foram observados os comportamentos de ateno compartilhada alternar,
Recebido em 23.11.2007.
Revisado em 30.03.2008; 30.06.2008;
apontar, mostrar (por iniciativa ou resposta da criana) e olhar para a ao do adulto (sempre por
29.07.2008. resposta da criana). Este ltimo incluiu a diferenciao do meio utilizado pelo adulto para chamar a
Aceito para Publicao em 21.10.2008. ateno da criana (fala; gestos; ou, ambos). Resultados: as diferentes situaes modificaram a forma
como estes sujeitos compartilharam a ateno. A interveno de um adulto aumentou a ocorrncia dos
comportamentos de ateno compartilhada principalmente em Resposta. No foram observadas diferenas
na interveno dos diferentes interlocutores (fonoaudilogo e me) nas situaes semi-dirigidas,
provavelmente porque ambos sincronizaram seus comportamentos com as crianas. Concluso: a avaliao
da ateno compartilhada em contexto de brincadeira foi eficaz e a interveno do adulto refletiu no
aumento destes comportamentos nas situaes semi-dirigidas e de imitao.
Palavras-Chave: Autismo Infantil; Sndrome de Asperger; Transtornos do Espectro Autstico; Ateno;
Linguagem.

Referenciar este material como:


Menezes CGL, Perissinoto Jacy. Joint attention ability in children with autistic spectrum disorders (original title: Habilidade de ateno compartilhada em sujeitos
com transtornos do espectro autstico). Pr-Fono Revista de Atualizao Cientfica. 2008 out-dez;20(4):273-8.

Habilidade de ateno compartilhada em sujeitos com transtornos do espectro autstico. 273


Pr-Fono Revista de Atualizao Cientfica. 2008 out-dez;20(4).

Introduction and considered as exclusion criteria any alterations,


presence of birth malformations and/or associated
The manifestations of the autistic spectrum are genetic syndromes, neurological disorders,
very heterogeneous, varying in severity, but physical disabilities, hearing or visual impairment.
maintaining in common alterations on social Only one child was not included in any educational
aspects, communication and behavior and interests program. The procedures began after approval by
1, 2. the Research Ethics Committee and after the
The difficulties of the autistic spectrum are parents had signed the Term of Free and Informed
related to verbal and non-verbal aspects. These Consent (CEP / UNIFESP number 807/05).
difficulties have been considered important - The participants were children from the Speech-
especially the shared attention - for early Language Pathology Laboratory of Research in
identification and social and language development Language of Global Developmental Disorders and
of autistic spectrum children 3, 4. from the Reference Center for Children and
In typical development, shared attention Adolescents, Department of Speech-Language
appears at the end of the first year of life and Pathology and Psychiatry, UNIFESP.
involves directing the attention of a communicative
partner with the intention of sharing a situation 5. Material
The early relationship of the child-adult dyad
determines the success in their social and language The Evaluation of Symbolic Maturity 16,17 ,
development. Adults will take advantage of their which goal is to evaluate the cognitive performance
tips to introduce references about the world, of children with developmental disorders of
providing to the child the understanding of the language through more and less representative
communicative intention which will facilitate toys. In this study, the material was used in order
attention sharing 6. to verify the ability of shared attention.
The shared attention has been regarded as a The objects of Free Play are presented to
marker for the early identification and intervention children in a box: a toy phone, a big ball, dolls and
of cases of autistic spectrum, since it is the animals made of fabric or plastic, some small cars,
precursor to the development of language7-9. The kitchen utensils, baby bottle, a blanket and a small
behaviors of shared attention can be classified pillow, a long necklace, blocks and serial glasses,
based on its occurrence, by the initiative of the abacus and two winding mechanical toys.
child or in response to the action of the adult. The The Imitation toys were presented to the child
latter occurrence is more frequent in these cases according to actions: glass, tooth brush, spoon,
giving the difficulties that these subjects have in doll, soap, flower, frog, airplane, hat, car, banana,
the use and understanding of communicative crib, bathtub, napkin, blanket, towel and book.
intention 10-13.
Considering the deficits of these individuals in Procedure
this skill, it is hypothesized that the deficit is
influenced by situational and interactional context. Originally, the Symbolic Maturity Assessment
Thus, the objectives of this study were to verify suggests situations of Free Play and Imitation 16,17.
the ability of shared attention in situations of Free For this study, the procedure has been adapted by
Play, Semi-Directed and Imitation in children with including an interactive filming with the Therapist/
autistic spectrum disorders, from the involvement Speech-Language Pathologist and another one
with different partners. with the caregiver/mother, named Semi-Directed
situations, for observation of possible changes in
Methods the Shared Attention by the intervention of a
different interlocutor.
Participants The evaluation was divided into two sessions,
with duration of approximately 45-minutes and
Twenty children were evaluated -- 4 girls and 16 interval between them of at least 15 days to reduce
boys with an average age of 9.4 years, and with possible influences of the initial session on next
multidisciplinary diagnosis of Infantile Autism or contact with the same material.
Asperger Syndrome 14,15. It was considered as an The sessions were filmed individually, with the
inclusion criteria that all children were receiving presence of a familiar adult (Speech-Language
Speech-Language Therapy for at least six months, Pathologist and/ or mother), to avoid that

274 Menezes e Perissinoto.


Pr-Fono Revista de Atualizao Cientfica. 2008 out-dez;20(4).

interaction with an unknown person would interfere . to alternate: number of times that the child
in performance. alternated the gaze among a mechanical or non
mechanical object, one that was in their hands or
First Session out of reach, and the face of the adult;
. to point: number of times that the child pointed to
Situation 1 - Free Play an object nearby or non nearby of himself/herself
or to part of the room;
A box of toys was presented to the child with . to show: number of times that the child extended
the instruction: "You can play with these toys the the object on the face of the evaluator or drew his/
way you want to". The adult interacted only when her attention to something that was in their hands;
the child initiated contact or in order to draw the . to look to the action of the adult': number of times
attention if the child was expending a lot of time that the child turned his head and eyes in any
exploring a single object, without suggesting any direction that the adult had pointed to, had shown
activity. or had drawn his/her attention.

Situation 2- Semi-Directed with Speech-Language When the combination of behaviors occurred,


Pathologist both behaviors were scored for analysis. The
responses were recorded on the protocol,
The same materials from the Free Play were considering the number of times that each behavior
used, but, at this moment, the Speech-Language was observed in each situation.
Pathologist could suggest games during the The behaviors 'to alternate', 'to point' and 'to
interaction. show' were also classified when occurring as
Initiative of the Child (IC-child spontaneously used
Second Session these behaviors associated or not to the speech,
aiming to share the attention) or whether they were
Situation 3- Semi-Directed with Caregiver (mother) in response to the Adult Action (RA - Adult drew
the attention of the child with a purpose, using
The same materials from the Free Play were speech, gesture, or both, and this fact triggered a
used, but, at this moment, the mother was guided response by the analyzed behaviors).
by the Speech-Language Pathologist to play with The behavior 'to look to the action of the adult'
her child the way she wanted to, naturally. was only considered as responses of the child
through actions/comments of the adults. It was
Situation 4 -Imitation verified that the child answered (YES) or stopped
responding (NOT) when the adult drew their
It included two steps: Imitation of Simple attention by using the Verbal (V), Sign (G) or Verbal
Gesture Schemes and Sequence in Family Routines. and Sign (V + G) mode 12,19.
The adult presented an action and spoke at the A random selection of 50% of the subjects in
same time, for the child then imitate it. each situation for analysis by two Speech-Language
The situations of Free Play and Semi-Directed Pathologists with clinical experience in the autistic
lasted 20 minutes (analysis of the final 15 minutes), spectrum disorders and who were familiar with the
the situation of Imitation duration was variable material, but unknown the identification data and
(about 10 minutes). diagnosis of cases was conducted. No statistically
The tasks started on the floor, with adult and significant differences were found between the two
child positioned face to face, and the box of toys/ observers (Wilcoxon test), which indicated
objects between them. The order of conducting the compatibility on data analysis.
activities was from less to more directed, to highlight
the spontaneous behavior of the child and prevent Results
that the interference of adult would influence on
posterior performance. The obtained data were scored for each task
The analysis of the ability of Shared Attention and analyzed statistically (Wilcoxon and Friedman
was performed for each situation (behavior Tests) with significance level of 0.05.
adaptation proposed by Mundy et al.)18. Table 1 provides a comparison of 'to alternate',
'to point' and 'to show' behaviors in four situations.

Habilidade de ateno compartilhada em sujeitos com transtornos do espectro autstico. 275


Pr-Fono Revista de Atualizao Cientfica. 2008 out-dez;20(4).

The 'to alternate' behavior prevailed in a statistically In the 'to show' situation, no statistically
significant manner when compared to the 'to point' significant difference was found among the four
and 'to show' in the four situations (p <0001 *). In situations in IC. In RA, it was significantly more
IC, statistically significant differences were not frequent in the situation Semi-Directed with
found in this behavior in any situation. In RA, the Therapist than in Free Play and Imitation. The Semi-
'to alternate' was significantly less frequent in Free Directed situation with caregiver did not statistically
Play, than in Semi-Directed situations with differentiated from other situations.
Therapist/Caregiver and Imitation, which did not As for the behavior of 'to look at the action of
differ among themselves. the adult' (Table 2), no statistically significant
As for 'to point', statistically significant difference was found in use by the adult on V or G
difference was not found in IC on the four situations. modes in the four situations. The V + G mode was
In RA, this behavior was significantly less frequent statistically significant in Imitation in relation to
in Imitation when compared to Semi-Directed Semi-Directed situations Therapist/caregiver. The
situations with Therapist/caregiver. The Free Play Free Play did not statistically differ from other
did not statistically differ from other situations. situations.

TABLE 1. Comparison among the four situations for the to alternate, to point and to show behavior

Behavior P

to alternate Initiative of the child 0,346

to alternate Response to the action of the adult < 0,001 *

to point - Initiative of the child 0,520

to point Response to the action of the adult 0,006 *

to show Initiative of the child 0,065

to show Response to the action of the adult 0,013 *

Subtitle: *p-value: 0,05%

TABLE 2: Comparison among the four situations for the behavior to look to the action of the adult

Behavior P

to look to the action of the adult Verbal


0,748
(Yes / Total)

to look to the action of the adult Gesture


0,652
(Yes / Total)

to look to the action of the adult Verbal + Gesture 0,005 * imitation > (semi-directed with therapist = semi-

(Yes / Total) directed with caregiver)

Subtitle: *p-value: 0,05%

276 Menezes e Perissinoto.


Pr-Fono Revista de Atualizao Cientfica. 2008 out-dez;20(4).

Discussion attention as one of the most persistent deficits in


autism 9,13,22.
In this study, the occurrence of shared attention In the behavior 'to look to the action of the adult',
such on the request form (to draw the attention of statistically significant difference was found only in
other to achieve something desired), as on the response to the V + G mode in Imitation in relation to
declarative form (to target the attention of other to situations with Semi-Directed Therapist/Caregiver,
some other object or situation) was considered 10, due to the actual activity context.
12-13. Some authors verified that the combination of
Following, it will be discussed the comparison tips facilitated the attention sharing12-19. Bruner 6
among the four proposed situations, first of the 'to has emphasized that the adult, when associating the
alternate', 'to point' and 'to show' behaviors, and then direction of the gaze to speech, provides the most
'to look to the action of the adult'. effective mechanism for the occurrence of shared
At first, the adult directs his/her action according attention, which is an essential skill for social and
to the interests of the child, in order to promote language development and allows children to share
moments of sharing of attention. As the child experiences and emotions.
develops, he/she start to draw the attention of the In this study, mother and Speech-Language
other to start the events of shared attention by gaze, Therapist interacted with the children, who were
gestures and speech 5-6, 20-21. receiving therapy for at least six months and their
Thus, the initially shared attention occurs more families were receiving periodic guidelines for the
in RA than by IC. In the autistic spectrum, early deficits various aspects of social and language development
in these two aspects are present and the IC is even - including shared attention. These aspects are
more committed 12, 30. important for the expansion of acquisitions obtained
The behavior 'to alternate' predominated over the by other contexts and people 4,8,10-11,23-24.
'to point' and 'to show' on the four situations; it did There were no statistically significant differences
not differentiate in IC, but in RA it was less frequent found in the performance of the group in Semi-directed
in Free Play when compared to other situations. In situations with the Speech-Language Therapist and
this task, the adult interfered as little as possible in the mother. Probably, both were influenced by the
the activity, responding primarily in response to IC. spontaneous behavior of children and sought to take
The behavior 'to point' occurred less frequently advantage of situations of sharing attention to
in Imitation giving the very characteristic of the task, establish synchrony and to meet their expectations,
since the child had to play the actions from the model within the limitations of each case. This synchrony
of the adult (rarely included in his/her spontaneous was reported by Collis, Schaffer 25 through mother/
use or request). baby interaction, and referred in studies with
The 'to show' behavior was more frequent in RA individuals with autistic spectrum disorder as
in the Semi-Directed situation with Therapist, when essential to social and language development 26-27.
compared to Free Play (spontaneous behavior of the The use of the material and adaptation of the
child) and Imitation (reproduction of actions which procedure of the Evaluation of Symbolic Maturity
did not include 'to show'). for evaluating the initiative and response to shared
This context facilitated the use of this gesture by attention in individuals of the autistic spectrum has
the child and reflected the longest attention sharing. been effective and will assist in early identification,
The 'to alternate' behavior involves the exchange differential diagnosis and prognosis. This is because
of gazes among the child, an object/situation and the the shared attention appears early in the typical
adult. This behavior arises from 9-11 months and development, so it is possible to precociously observe
works as a pre-requisite for regulation with the if there is any change in the manifestations of these
gestures of 'to point' and 'to show' from 11 months behaviors. Furthermore, the deficits on shared
5,21. attention are described as precocious and persistent
Thus, the general predominance of the 'to alternate' in these cases 3-4,28. Some authors observed
reflected a more original share of attention due to the differences in the performance of individuals of the
deficit presented to individuals in the autistic autistic spectrum in relation to other pathologies such
spectrum, because no changes occurred in IC in the as mental disorder 18 and language development
different situations. disorders 23, in which individuals of the autistic
In contrast, most children improved the behaviors spectrum presented the worst performance. Finally,
in RA in more interactive situations (Semi-Directed some studies indicated that among cases in the
and Imitation). Studies showed the IC to share the autistic spectrum, there are differences in the

Habilidade de ateno compartilhada em sujeitos com transtornos do espectro autstico. 277


Pr-Fono Revista de Atualizao Cientfica. 2008 out-dez;20(4).

manifestation of the behavior of shared attention, standardized equipment. The Imitation test should
that in long-term influences on language development not be considered as an isolated analysis parameter.
10,18,24. The findings of this study reinforce the
The play promotes pleasant moments of attention observations of other studies, because although the
sharing and allows the spontaneous observation of shared attention is severely compromised and serve
as an early marker in individuals of autistic spectrum,
the child and the effects of the intervention of the the shared attention is not totally absent. This ability
adult, through contextualized and interesting is extremely important for diagnosis and early and
situations for the individual of the autistic spectrum specific intervention based on this specific aspect
9,12,29-31. 9,13,18,26.
In clinical practice, the priority would be the
comparison between the situations of Free Play (more Conclusions
spontaneous observations) and Semi-Directed with
a familiar adult (observation of the changes generated From the proposed interaction situations, it was
by an interlocutor prepared to meet the expectations possible to verify that the individual of the autistic
of the child), which promotes natural moments of spectrum presented the ability to share the attention
interaction and allows the observation of the and to modify their behavior positively from the
initiatives and interests of the child with the use of interference of an interlocutor.

References

1. Wing L. Asperger`s syndrome: a clinical account. Psychol 11. Kasari C, Freeman S, Paparella T. Joint attetion and
Med. 1981;21:115-29. symbolic play in young children with autism: a randomized
controlled intervention study. J Child Psychol
2. Perissinoto J. Diagnstico de linguagem em crianas
Psychiatry.2006:47(6):611-20.
com transtornos do espectro autstico. In: Ferreira L P,
Befi-Lopes D M, Limongi S C O. Tratado de Fonoaudiologia. 12. Leekam SR, Ramsden CA. Dyadic orienting and joint
So Paulo: Roca, 2004. p. 933-40. attention in preschool children with autism. J Autism Dev
Disord. 2006;36(2):185-97.
3. Kanner L. Autistic disturbances of affective contact.
Nervous Child. 1943;12:57-69. 13. Warreyn P, Roeyers H, Van Wetswinkel U, De Groote
I. Temporal coordination of joint attention behavior in
4. Perissinoto J. Processo de Evoluo da Criana com
preschoolers with autism spectrum disorder. J Autism Dev
Autismo. In: Perissinoto J. Conhecimentos Essenciais para
Disord. 2007;37:501-12.
Atender bem a Criana com Autismo. So Paulo: Pulso,
2003. p. 23-27. 14. American Psychiatric Association. Manual Diagnstico
e Estatstico de Transtornos Mentais - DSM IV-TR. Porto
5. Carpenter M, Nagell K, Tomasello M. Social cognition,
Alegre: Artes Mdicas; 2002.
joint attention, and communicative competence from 9 to
15 months of age. Monogr Soc Res Child Dev.1998;63(4):1- 15. Organizao Mundial da Sade. Classificao estatstica
143. internacional de doenas e problemas relacionados sade:
CID 10. 10 ed. So Paulo: Edusp; 1993.
6. Bruner J. Child's talk: learning to use language. London:
Norton & Company - New York, 1983. cap. 2,4. 16. Befi-Lopes DM, Takiuchi N, Arajo K. Avaliao da
maturidade simblica nas alteraes do desenvolvimento
7. Mundy P, Crowson M. Joint attention and early social
da linguagem. J Bras Fonoaudiol. 2000;1(3):6-15.
communication: implications for research on intervention
with autism. J Autism Dev Disord. 1997; 27(1):653-76. 17. Takiuchi N. Relaes entre Maturidade Simblica e
Desenvolvimento Lingstico em crianas com Distrbios
8. American Speech-Language-Hearing Association.
Especficos de Desenvolvimento da Linguagem [tese]. So
Guidelines for Speech-Language Pathologists in Diagnosis,
Paulo: Universidade de So Paulo; 2006.
Assessment, and Treatment of Autism Spectrum Disorders
Across Life Span. 2006. Available from: http:// 18. Mundy P, Sigman M, Kasari C. A Longitudinal Study of
www.asha.org/members/deskref journal/deskref/default. Joint Attention and Language Development in Autistic
Children. J Autism Dev Disord.1990;20(1):115-27.
9. Sullivan M, Finelli J, Marvin A, Garrett-Mayer E, Bauman
M, Landa, R. Response to joint attention in toddlers at risk 19. Leekam SR, Hunnisett E, Moore C. Targets and cues:
for autism spectrum disorder: a prospective study. J Autism gaze-following in children with autism. Child Psychol
Dev Disord. 2007:37:37-48. Psychiatry Allied Discipl. 1998;39(7):951-62.
10. Whalen C, Schreibman L. Joint attention training for 20. Iverson J, Capirci O, Longobardi E, Caselli MC.
children with autism using behavior modification procedures. Gesturing in mother-child interactions. Cognitive
J Child Psychol Psychiat. 2003;44(3):456-68. Development. 1999;14:57-75.

278 Menezes e Perissinoto.


Pr-Fono Revista de Atualizao Cientfica. 2008 out-dez;20(4).

21. Capone NC, McGregor KK. Gesture development: a 27. Miilher LP, Fernandes FDM. Anlise das funes
review for clinical and research practices. J Speech Lang comunicativas expressas por terapeutas e pacientes do
Hear Res. 2004;47:173-86. espectro autstico. Pr-Fono Rev. Atual. Cient.
2006;18(3):239-48.
22. Cardoso C, Fernandes FDM. Relao entre os aspectos
scio cognitivos e perfil funcional da comunicao em um 28. Bosa C. Ateno compartilhada e identificao precoce
grupo de adolescentes do espectro autstico. Pr-Fono no autismo. Psicol Reflex e Crit. 2002;15(1):77-88.
Rev. Atual. Cient. 2006;18(1):89-98.
29. Tamanaha AC. Interveno na Linguagem da Criana
23. McArthur D, Adamson LB. Joint Attention in Preverbal com Autismo. In: Perissinoto J. Conhecimentos Essenciais
Children: Autism and Developmental Language Disorder. J para Atender bem a Criana com Autismo. So Paulo: Pulso,
Autism Dev Disord. 1996;26(5):481-95. 2003. p. 55-60.
24. Koegel LK. Interventions to facilitate communication 30. Warreyn P, Roevers H, De Groote I. Early social
in Autism. J Autism Dev Disord. 2000;30(5):383-91. communicative behaviours of preschoolers with autism
spectrum disorder during interaction with their mothers.
25. Collis GM, Schaffer HR. Synchronization of visual Autism. 2005;9(4):342-61.
attention in mother-infant pairs. J Child Psycho.
Psychiatry. 1975;16(4):315-20. 31. Stanley GC, Konstantareas MM. Symbolic play in
children with autism spectrum disorder. J Autism Dev Disord.
26. Siller M, Sigman M. The behaviors of parents of children 2007;37(7):1215-23.
with autism predict the subsequent development of their
children's communication. J Autism Dev Disord.
2002;32(2):77-89.

Habilidade de ateno compartilhada em sujeitos com transtornos do espectro autstico. 279

You might also like