Professional Documents
Culture Documents
To cite this article: Klaus Holschemacher (2004): Hardened material properties of selfcompacting concrete, Journal of
Civil Engineering and Management, 10:4, 261-266
This article may be used for research, teaching and private study purposes. Any substantial or systematic
reproduction, re-distribution, re-selling, loan, sub-licensing, systematic supply or distribution in any form to
anyone is expressly forbidden.
The publisher does not give any warranty express or implied or make any representation that the contents
will be complete or accurate or up to date. The accuracy of any instructions, formulae and drug doses should
be independently verified with primary sources. The publisher shall not be liable for any loss, actions, claims,
proceedings, demand or costs or damages whatsoever or howsoever caused arising directly or indirectly in
connection with or arising out of the use of this material.
261
ISSN 13923730
JOURNAL OF CIVIL ENGINEERING AND MANAGEMENT
http:/www.jcem.vgtu.lt
Klaus Holschemacher
Leipzig University of Applied Sciences (HTWK Leipzig), Dept of Civil Engineering.
Karl-Liebknecht-Strasse 132, D-04329 Leipzig, Germany. E-mail: holschem@fbb.htwk-leipzig.de
Received 24 Aug 2004; accepted 30 Nov 2004
Abstract. Self-compacting concrete (SCC) is an innovative construction material with a favourable rheological behaviour,
which is caused by its modified concrete composition. Based on this fact SCC offers improved fresh concrete but also
Downloaded by [University of Malaya] at 23:29 21 September 2011
hardened material properties and therefore many advantages regarding the productivity and the design potential com-
pared with normal vibrated concrete. Consequently, the amount of SCC, used for structural purposes has strongly
increased worldwide in the last years. In this context it is necessary to know, if it is possible to apply the current design
rules, eg Model Code 90 and Eurocode 2, that are based on years of experience on normal vibrated concrete, to
structural members made of SCC as well. This paper represents the analysis of own and internationally published test
results of the compressive strength, tensile strength, modulus of elasticity, bond behaviour and the time-dependent
deformations of SCC in comparison with conventional concrete, in order to give a general statement regarding the
agreements and differences between the hardened material properties of these concretes.
Keywords: self-compacting concrete, hardened concrete properties, tensile strength, modulus of elasticity, creep and
shrinkage, bond behaviour.
261
262 K. Holschemacher / JOURNAL OF CIVIL ENGINEERING AND MANAGEMENT 2004, Vol X, No 4, 261266
and stabiliser is used, if required. Fig1 shows a typical 2.2. Aim of the investigation
mix composition of SCC compared with normal vibrated
concrete in principle [7, 8]. The aim of the performed investigations was to com-
On the basis of the stated differences between the pare the hardened material properties of SCC with those
mix composition of SCC and conventional concrete it is of normal vibrated concrete, ultimately to give a general
necessary to analyse the effects of these modifications estimation regarding the application of the current de-
on the hardened concrete properties. So, referring to this, sign codes or calculation methods respectively in case
the applicability of the currently existing design rules of the usage of SCC.
based on years of experience on normal vibrated con- Thereupon a database with results of own experi-
crete has to be examined carefully. mental investigations and a large number of internation-
Reasons for possible differences between the hard- ally published data of design relevant to hardened mate-
ened properties of SCC and conventional concrete may rial properties of several self-compacting concretes was
be the modified mix composition as mentioned before, created [911]. The data of properties such as compres-
the better microstructure and homogeneity of SCC and sive strength, tensile strength, modulus of elasticity, bond
the absence of vibration. strength and the time-dependent deformations were docu-
The higher content of ultrafine materials and the mented and analysed particularly with regard to the given
accordingly lower content of coarse aggregates change values and limits of the European design code CEB-
the granular skeleton. This could influence the strength FIB Model Code [12]. This strategy seemed to be ex-
pedient because the [12] is the basis of the future uni-
Downloaded by [University of Malaya] at 23:29 21 September 2011
262
K. Holschemacher / JOURNAL OF CIVIL ENGINEERING AND MANAGEMENT 2004, Vol X, No 4, 261266 263
differences in the concrete composition and the positive filler content at the same time cause an increase in con-
changes in the microstructure, as mentioned before, have crete strength. For young SCC (aged up to 7 days) the
an effect on the short and long term load-bearing relative compressive strength spreads to a greater extent
behaviour. Moreover, clarification is still necessary to as given in the Model Code90, whereas higher values
determine whether the hardening process and the ulti- as well as lower values are reached. Especially when
mate strengths of SCC and conventional concrete differ. limestone powder is used, higher compressive strengths
Corresponding to the characteristic compressive are noticeable at the beginning of the hardening process.
strength fck of cylinders and cubes, concrete is classi- At higher concrete ages SCC often exceeds the valid
fied in concrete grades. As is known, there exists a cer- range according to the given limits by Model Code90.
tain dependence on the specimen geometry with conven- Using fly ash or silica fume this will be caused by the
tional concrete [9]: pozzolanic effect of these fillers.
f c, cyl (150 / 300)
= 0,8 ... 0,85. 3.2. Tensile strength
f c, cube (150)
However, my own tests carried out in Leipzig have All parameters, which influence the characteristics
shown that this well-known relation between cylinders of the microstructure of the cement matrix and of the
and cubes could not be confirmed with SCC in the ex- ITZ, are of decisive importance in regard to the tensile
pected magnitude. A clearly lower dependency was as- load bearing behaviour. Fig3 shows the arranged data
Downloaded by [University of Malaya] at 23:29 21 September 2011
1.8
rel. com pressive strength
1.0
13 7 21 28 56 90
C oncrete age [days]
Fig 2. Development of compressive strength of SCC with time in comparison with the regulations of ModelCode90 [12]
263
264 K. Holschemacher / JOURNAL OF CIVIL ENGINEERING AND MANAGEMENT 2004, Vol X, No 4, 261266
3.3. Modulus of elasticity and content of ultrafines seems to influence the shrink-
age deformations. Thus such deformations of SCC can
As it is known, the modulus of elasticity of con- increase due to a lower content of coarse aggregate and
crete depends on the proportion of the Youngs modules the minimum paste volume, which must be present for
of the individual components and their percentage by ensuring the optimal self-compaction of SCC without seg-
volume. Thus, the modulus of elasticity of concrete in- regation. As a result, the conclusion could be drawn that
creases with higher contents of aggregates of high rigid- the shrinkage deformations of SCC can achieve clearly
ity, whereas it decreases with increasing hardened ce- higher values than the ones of comparable normal vi-
ment paste content and increasing porosity. For this rea- brated concretes. However, a denser microstructure of
son lower values of modulus of elasticity can be expected, the cement paste can be achieved by addition of fillers
because of the higher content of ultrafines and additives with a fineness larger than that of cement, whereby the
as dominating factors and the accordingly lower content shrinkage can be affected positively. So, it is possible to
of coarse, stiff aggregates with SCC. The evaluation of modify the SCC mix in such a way that smaller shrink-
the data really shows the fact that the modulus of elas- age deformations appear, similar to those of normal vi-
ticity of SCC is within the lower half of the scattering brated concrete.
range according to the ModelCode90. More exactly, the Fig5 shows the relationship between shrinkage and
average value valid for conventional concrete represents concrete age. The identified areas mark the limits for
the upper limit for SCC, whereas all values were always shrinkage deformations of C20 up to C80 with a relative
referred to the mean compressive strength (Fig4).
Downloaded by [University of Malaya] at 23:29 21 September 2011
10
splitting tensile strength [M P a]
9 used fillers:
fly ash , silica fum e
lim eston e p ow de r, qua rtzite filler
8
blast furnace slag
fly ash + q ua rtzite filler
7 unknow n
6
3
range of sp litting tensile stre ngth
2 a cc. to C E B -F IB M o d e l C od e 9 0
1
0
15 25 35 45 55 65 75 85
m ean com pressive strength [M P a]
Fig 3. Data base of the splitting strength of SCC with reference to the corresponding compressive
strength in comparison with the regulations of Model Code 90 [12]
264
K. Holschemacher / JOURNAL OF CIVIL ENGINEERING AND MANAGEMENT 2004, Vol X, No 4, 261266 265
50
40
rang e of m od ulus of elasticity
acc. to C E B -F IB M odel C o de 90
30
20
used fillers:
10 fly a sh, silica fum e fly a sh + quartzite filler or
lim e stone po w der, q uartzite filler silica fum e + lim estone pow de r
blast furnace slag blast furnace slag + silica fum e
w ith out fille r unkn ow n
0
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90
m ea n co m p ressive stren g th [M P a]
Fig 4. Data base of the modulus of elasticity of SCC with reference to the corresponding
compressive strength in comparison with the regulations of Model Code 90 [12]
0 7 14 21 28 35 56 63 91 112 168 18 2
0
ra n g e o f sh rin ka g e fo r C 8 0
a cc. to C E B -F IB M o d e l C o d e 9 0
-200
ra n g e o f sh rin ka g e fo r C 2 0
a cc. to C E B -F IB M o d e l C o d e 9 0
-400
-600
u se d fille rs:
fly a sh , silica fu m e
-800 lim e sto n e p o w d e r,
shrinkage [m m /m ]
q u a rtzite fille r
b la st fu rn a ce sla g
silica fu m e
-1000 + qu a rtzite fille r
b la st fu rn a ce sla g
+ fly a sh
w ith o u t fille r
-1200
Fig5. Data base of the shrinking deformations of SCC at different concrete ages in
comparison with the regulations of ModelCode90 [12]
and the surrounding matrix on the other hand the bond vibrated concrete does not exist. The results of the inter-
behaviour of SCC is different from that one of conven- pretation of the data base can be summarised as follows:
tional concrete. In our own tests an improvement of the The concrete strength of SCC and conventional con-
bond stiffness in the serviceability limit state and a very crete is similar under comparable conditions,
ductile bond behaviour after reaching the maximum load whereas the tendency is obvious that SCC shows
was ascertained for SCC [1620]. However, the maxi- higher strengths with same water-cement ratios. The
mum bond strength of SCC is lower than that of a nor- definite relation, however, is still to be clarified.
mal vibrated concrete of comparable strength. The development of concrete strength with time is
A positive effect of the high segregation resistance similar. Deviations are to be recognised depending
of SCC is the better homogeneity. Hence, the concrete on the type of filler.
strength could be more evenly distributed referring to The dependence of the compressive strength on the
the overall member. Indeed, in some investigations it was specimen geometry of SCC is only inarticulately
found that the concrete strength measured at different pronounced compared with the well-known relation
locations of a construction member spreads less than in of conventional concrete. However, this fact is sub-
members of conventional concrete [21]. ject to review.
The splitting tensile strength achieves clearly higher
4. Conclusions values, partly up to 40% higher than in the current
standard. Thus, there is a need for action regarding
The described investigations show that an exact iden- the minimum amount of reinforcement.
tity between the mechanical properties of SCC and normal The modulus of elasticity of SCC is slightly lower
265
266 K. Holschemacher / JOURNAL OF CIVIL ENGINEERING AND MANAGEMENT 2004, Vol X, No 4, 261266
but within the upper half of the standardised limits. 9. Holschemacher, K. and Klug, Y. A Data Base for the Evalu-
The shrinking deformations of SCC are up to 50% ation of Hardened Properties of SCC. In: Leipzig Annual
higher, especially at concretes aged up to 28 days. Civil Engineering Report No7. University of Leipzig,
Regarding the creep deformations there are only Leipzig, 2002, p. 123134.
insufficient test results known, thus it is necessary 10. Klug, Y. and Holschemacher, K. Material Properties of
to carry out further investigations. Hardened Self-Compacting Concrete. In: Proceedings of
The bond behaviour of reinforcement in SCC is the International Conference on Performance of Construc-
partly better than in comparable vibrated concrete. tion Materials in the New Millennium a New Era of
Based on these facts, it can be concluded that extra Building, Cairo, Egypt, 1820 Feb 2003. Ed by A.S.El-
design rules for SCC may not be necessary. However, it Dieb, M. M. Reda Taha and S. L. Lissel, Elmaarefa Print-
seems to be useful to add regulations regarding the mini- ing House, 2003.
mum reinforcement and the time-dependent deformations 11. Klug, Y. and Holschemacher, K. Comparison of the Hard-
to the current standards. ened Properties of Self-Compacting and Normal Vibrated
In this regard further research projects are required Concrete. In: Proceedings of the 3rd International RILEM
to interpret the dependencies of the hardened material Symposium on Self-Compacting Concrete. Reykjavik, Ice-
properties of SCC more precisely. Referring to this the land, 1720 Aug 2003. Ed by O. Wallevik and I. Nielsson,
influence of any parameter, eg type of cement and filler RILEM Publication, Bagneux, France, 2003.
as well as their portion, water-binder/ -cement ratio, pro- 12. CEB-FIB Model Code 1990. Design Code. Lausanne,
portion of fine and coarse aggregates and fineness have Switzerland: Thomas Telford Services Ltd, 1991. 637 p.
Downloaded by [University of Malaya] at 23:29 21 September 2011
to be investigated specifically. 13. Eurocode 2: Design of Concrete Structures. Draft July 2002.
To benefit from the advantages of SCC not only 14. RILEM Publications Pro 7: Proceedings of the 1st RILEM
the fresh concrete properties but also the design relevant International Symposium, Stockholm, Sweden, 1314 Sept,
hardened material properties have to be known accurately. 1999. Ed by . Skarendahl and .Petersson, RILEM
Only in this way SCC can be used conveniently and a Publications, France, 1999. 804 p.
realistic calculation of structural members made of this 15. RILEM Publications Pro 33: Self-Compacting Concrete.
innovative material is possible. Proceedings of the 3rd International RILEM Symposium,
Reykjavik, Iceland, 1720 Aug, 2003, Ed by O. Wallevik
References and I. Nielsson, RILEM Publications, Bagneux, France,
2003. 1048 p.
1. Okamura, H. Expectation to the New Concreting Material.
Cement and Concrete Journal, No 475. Cement Associa- 16. Holschemacher, K.; Klug, Y.; Weie, D.; Knig, G. and
tion of Japan, 1986 (in Japanese). Dehn, F. Bond Behaviour of Reinforcement in Self-Com-
pacting Concrete (SCC). In: Proceedings of the 2nd Inter-
2. Okamura, H. and Ozawa, K. Mix Design for Self Com- national Structural Engineering and Construction Confer-
pacting Concrete. Concrete Library International, No25. ence (ISEC02), Roma, Italy, 2326 Sept 2003.
Japan Society of Civil Engineers, June 1995, p.107120.
17. Knig, G.; Holschemacher, K.; Dehn, F. and Weie, D.
3. Skarendahl, A. The Presnt the Future. In: Proceedings Bond of Reinforcement in Self-Compacting Concrete un-
of the 3rd International RILEM Symposium on Self-Com- der Monotonic and Cyclic Loading. In: Proceedings of the
pacting Concrete. Reykjavik, Iceland, 17-20 Aug 2003. Ed 3rd International RILEM Symposium on Self-Compacting
by O. Wallevik and I. Nielsson, RILEM Publication s.a.r.1, Concrete. Reykjavik, Iceland, 17-20 Aug 2003. Ed by O.
Bagneux, France, 2003, p. 614. Wallevik and I.Nielsson, RILEM Publication, Bagneux,
4. Walraven, J. Structural Aspects of Self-Compacting Con- France, 2003, p. 1522.
crete. In: Proceedings of the 3rd International RILEM 18. Knig, G.; Holschemacher, K.; Dehn, F. and Weie, D.
Symposium on Self-Compacting Concrete. Reykjavik, Ice- Self-Compacting Concrete - Time Development of Mate-
land, 1720 Aug 2003. Ed by O. Wallevik and I.Nielsson, rial Properties and Bond Behaviour. In: Proceedings of the
RILEM Publication, Bagneux, France, 2003, p. 1522. 2nd International Symposium on Self-Compacting Con-
5. Wallevik, O. Rheologa a Scientific Approach to Develop crete, Tokyo. Oct, 2325, 2001, p. 507516.
Self-Compacting Concrete. In: Proceedings of the 3rd In- 19. Knig, G.; Holschemacher, K.; Dehn, F. and Weie, D.
ternational RILEM Symposium on Self-Compacting Con- Determination of the Bond Creep Coefficient for Self-Com-
crete. Reykjavik, Iceland, 1720 Aug 2003. Ed by pacting Concrete. In: Proceedings of the 3rd International
O.Wallevik and I. Nielsson, RILEM Publication, Bagneux, Symposium on Bond in Concrete - From Research to Stan-
France, 2003, p. 2331. dards. Budapest, Hungary, Nov. 2022, 2002. Ed by G. L.
6. Skarendahl, A. and Petersson, (eds). Proceedings of the Balasz, P. J. M. Bartos, J. Cairns and A. Borosnyoi, 2002.
1st International RILEM Symposium on Self-Compacting 20. Holschemacher, K. and Weie, D. Self-Compacting Con-
Concrete. Stockholm, Sweden, Sept 13-14, 1999. Cachan, crete Made with Sand-Rich Particle Fractions. In: IABSE
France: RILEM Publications, 1999. 786 p. Symposium Towards a Better Built Environment Inno-
7. Holschemacher, K. and Weie, D. Self-Compacting Con- vation, Sustainability, Information Technology, Melbourne,
crete in Practice. Concrete Plant International, No 1, 2002, Australia, 813 Sept, 2002.
p. 7481. 21. Khayat, K. H.; Manai, K. and Trudel, A. In Situ Mechani-
8. Holschemacher, K. and Weie, D. Structural Aspects of cal Properties of Wall Elements Cast Using Self-Consoli-
Self-Compacting Concrete. New Building Materials and dating Concrete. ACI Materials Journal, Vol 96, Issue 6,
Construction World, July 2002, p. 812. 1997, p. 491500.
266