Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Practical Notebook
on the possibilities for
the inclusion of women
related to small-scale coastal fishing
2016
2
Editorial Box:
BSP CONSULT BG
9700 Shumen
29 Vasil Levski str., bl.2, vh.G
e-mail: sp_consult@abv.bg
http://smallscalefishing.eu
2016
All rights reserved
3
Content
1. Introduction 5
In Europe 14
In Bulgaria 21
7. Encouraging activity in the work of associations and CS and the LIFE plat-
form 46
8. Conclusion 49
References 50
Application 51
4
ACRONYMS
EU European Union
1. Introduction
The present edition is the result of the This guide presents the development of
implementation of Pilot project: Meas- the role of women in small-scale coast-
ures to support small-scale fisheries, al fisheries in its development, present
EU Grant Agreement: MARE/2014/04 - condition and future prospects on global,
SI2.724176 and SP CONSULT BG. European and national scale. The pres-
entation addresses the issues of fisheries
The aim of this financial assistance is to policy in the new programming period
increase the public awareness about the 2014-2020 and the presence of women in
role of small-scale fisheries in future de- it, the general problem of the untapped
cisions on the relevant policies at national potential of women in the economy, and
and European level through implementa- tracks historically the traditional female
tion of good practices, applicable in the roles in the small-scale fishing commu-
Black Sea basin region. nities and the ongoing changes, which
The projects is primary intention is to open new opportunities for them. Spe-
establish a European Association of fish- cial attention is given to the promotion
ermen of the Black Sea, to do research of the active role of women in the sector
and analyses for the purpose of write through certain supporting functions they
manuals, articles and etc. that will assist could perform, such as accounting, re-
the researched sector. More than 130 rep- lated administrative activities, activities
resentatives of small-scale fisheries from related to participation in existing asso-
the Republics of Bulgaria and Romania ciations, councils and Internet platforms.
will be trained. Exchange of experiences Tips are included for setting a policy for
in Great Britain id envisaged as a country marketing of the production and securing
with strong traditions in this industry. entrepreneurial capital, using the catch
as a resource. The empowerment that
This edition is intended for representa- collective action can provide to women
tives of organizations of small-scale fish- in the fishing communities is elaborated
ermen and other stakeholders concerned in the review of the practice, experi-
in this sector. The manual reflects only ences, successes and obstacles to local,
the position of the author(s) and the Com- national and transnational associations
mission shall not be held responsible for and organizations.
the information included therein.
6
The guide helps people employed in the For further information, the Application
fishing sector to get orientated in the contains a list of links to studies of wom-
overall picture of the lifestyles of fish- en in the fisheries sector and their roles
ing communities round the world and in and achievements in the European Union
Europe and to better comprehend their and in individual Member States.
place in it. It highlights the develop-
ment of the situation and the forecasts
for future opportunities, and offers ad-
vice about ways in which women can be
more efficient, successful and influen-
tial in determining the rules in the sec-
tor and increasing the welfare of their
families and communities.
7
destructive fishing methods threaten the The small-scale fishermen and their sup-
functioning of the broader ecosystems in ply chain and service functions cover a
many coastal areas. The increasing global large number of people involved in fish
demand for fish by various users and the processing, marketing, production of
penetration of the global market chains boats and nets. They also form a part of
in nearly all corners of the world also the tourist industry.
create incentives for over-exploitation of
the waters. The climate changes are al- On the one hand, the deliveries of local
ready affecting the coastal habitats (such fresh fish and the specificity of the local
as coral reefs, which are under serious dishes are an essential part of the hospi-
threat of destruction). tality service that makes it attractive to
visitors; on the other, anglers themselves
In addition to the natural challenges, fish- with their traditional practices and even
ermen are confronted with economic dif- with their vision represent one of the at-
ficulties, including the cost of fuels and tractions of coastal zones.
food, changes in the market structures
that force them to respect the global en- Small-scale fishermen have many advan-
vironmental imperative of the contempo- tages over large industrial fishing vessels
rary society and the dynamic changes that in terms of their relatively low environ-
occur in local and national economies. Es- mental impact and high social dimen-
sentially, the support for the sector in the sions. They can and in many places they
current situation means a contribution to do provide substantial indirect employ-
keeping the population in the coastal are- ment in ancillary activities.
as and protecting the ecosystems. Since fishing entrepreneurs and farms
The small-scale coastal fishing is or- always adapt to specific marine ecosys-
ganized mainly in family enterprises of tems, their management needs are dif-
communities with rooted tradition, local ferent. For example, in the cold waters
knowledge and culture. The catch of fish small-scale fishermen usually fish for a
in the sea is clearly dominated by men, few species, while in tropical waters the
but women play a key role in the activ- variety of species is great. This means
ities in their entirety. They are the con- also a wide variety of fishing gear, part
nection between fishing activities at sea of which is not used most of the year. So
and shore-based support and distribu- the nature of the marine ecosystem that
tion of goods produced in the community is exploited is an important determinant
and in society. Small-scale fishermen are of many of the cultural characteristics of
mainly self-employed, independent own- the fishing communities.
ers and operators of boats, fishing crew Globally, the assets related to the ac-
and workers who often receive a share of tivities of coastal fishermen are basical-
the catch. ly four types: natural, physical, finan-
cial and human. The natural assets are
the marine ecosystems and the species
9
that inhabit them. Physical assets are the trophies become cultural symbols that
fishing vessels, the fishing gear and the form part of the identity of the fishermen
equipment used for the harvest process- and their skills and are often included in
ing and sale. Financial assets are required various rituals.
to maintain the operations, providing
physical assets and for provision of the Technological innovations can provide
other social and economic activities of significant improvements in small-scale
the fishermen. The human resources, in- fisheries. The abrupt replacement of the
cluding skills and information used in the traditional with new tools, however, can
fishery activities, and the broader accu- have disastrous consequences on com-
mulated knowledge about life in a fishing munities in the form of increased levels
community are considered a part of the of ecosystem degradation and resource
respective local cultural heritage. depletion. The growing dependence on
more expensive technologies increases
The sense of pride with their occupa- production rates and can sometimes leed
tion and the addiction to the lifestyle of fishermen to a bankruptcy.
a fisherman is typical among the coast-
al fishermen. Sea fishing requires greater Small-scale fishermen have valuable eco-
independence, self-confidence, autono- logical knowledge, which includes in-
my, risk-taking and combating the forc- formation on the time and conditions
es of nature. These are not only impor- under which certain species are availa-
tant characteristics of ones identity, but ble, how to fish and the accessories that
also a feeling of satisfaction that is not are the most effective for the harvest
measured only on an economic basis. For when such conditions are met during the
them, fishing is not just a means of pro- periods in question.
viding income, but also an activity that is Maintaining the catch over the years re-
experienced as rewarding as a meaningful quires that fishermen apply a conserva-
way of life. tive approach to fishing. Among the fac-
The dominant fishing techniques are of- tors that necessitate it are:
ten the result of considerable accumulat- inability to accurately forecast avail-
ed experience. They stem from adapting ability of passages and future harvest;
to the specific marine ecosystem, which
is exploited and the opportunities the inability to accurately predict the
fishermen actually have to procure the future market prices of fish;
needed fishing gear. These include not inability to accurately predict future
only fishing tackle, but also the knowl- climatic conditions;
edge of them - manufacture, use, main-
tenance - which is an important element uncertain access to health insurance
of the culture of the fishing community. and business insurance, as well as loans
Fishing nets, elements of the vessels and for operating activities.
10
Maintaining other income opportunities is The activities of women - paid and unpaid
an important tool to reduce the risk and - including all along the value chain and
uncertainty, associated with fishing as a activities before and after the catch: ed-
form of employment. Since the sea is less ible shellfish collection, fishing, knitting
predictable, most fishermen must have and repairing nets, sorting and processing
other sources to switch to during the the fish, production of fishery products
off-seasons. Most often the complemen- and sale and distribution. They have lo-
tary activities are also seasonal in nature, cal and traditional ecological knowledge,
but beyond the fishing season. which is a valuable contribution to the
sustainable use and conservation of ma-
The many roles that women play in these rine ecosystems.
communities emphasize their basic im-
portance in socio-economic terms and for Often women cannot protect their la-
their general well-being. They often pos- bor rights because their economic role is
sess independence and economic autono- not formally recognized. They have lim-
my. Moreover, they often form socio-eco- ited access to social insurece, funds and
nomic networks that help them in selling loans. They work very often in insecure
the harvest and in other activities. More and problematic hygienic conditions. Glo-
often women deal with the fish process- balization, privatization, pollution and
ing. Although the work is not as risky as climate change have led to decreasing
the one in the sea, it is also related to access to fish for processing and sale.
possible injuries and medical problems. The lack of access to funding for wom-
en means no resources to purchase the
Nowadays the economic contribution of necessary equipment for the storage of
women in the small-scale fishing com- fish, maintaining high quality and fresh-
munities still remains the processing and ness, which reduces their control over the
marketing of the fish, but with the rapid markets.
changes in the socially stablished practic-
es with regard to which roles and activi- In 2010, the International Collective in
ties are siutable for women, they are in- Support of Fishworkers (ICSF), an interna-
creasingly involved in fishing as well. With tional NGO that works for equality, gender
advanced age women tend to reduce balance, independence and sustainability
their participation - according to global in the fisheries sector, and in particular
statistics women over the age of 60 are in small-scale coastal fishing achieved
only 5%. This may be due to the fact that an international agreement called the
fishing activities require energy and wom- Common Agenda for sustainable living
en should be physically strong to handle and well-being of fishing communities
most of the tasks. and equal participation of women. The
agenda was adopted by a wide network
of women from fishing organizations,
11
academic communities, practitioners, so- The analysis of the gender roles in the fish-
cial activists and other civil society or- eries sector, which is being made in view
ganizations. This common agenda was of achieving a balance in the participa-
used for inclusion of gender issues in the tion in its economic dimension, describes
Voluntary guidelines for securing sus- the womens place in the global value
tainable small-scale fisheries in the con- chain. The framework of this analysis has
text of food security and poverty eradica- three sections - profile of the activities
tion, adopted by the Food and Agriculture (who does what), profile of the access and
Organization of the United Nations in control (wh has what) and analysis of the
2014 and Voluntary guidelines on the re- factors and trends (what is the socio-eco-
sponsible governance of tenure of land, nomic context). The profile of activities
fisheries and forests(2012). The guide- considers what work is performed by men
lines emphasize the key role of women and women, where and when. So far the
in small-scale fisheries and point out that analyses of this type show that the role
achieving gender equality is crucial for assigned to women is still strongly tied to
sustainable fishing. the local culture. In the developed coun-
tries, for example, the participation of
The implementation of the guidelines women is concentrated at the end of the
is essential in enabling women to ac- value chain and has greater social pres-
quire ownership rights, equal participa- tige, while in the developing countries it
tion in decision-making and protection is spred along the entire chain and has
from discrimination. the lowest status.
Overall, although the specific forms of The reasons why women are not visible
womens work in the fishing sector are in the fishing industry are rooted in the
different in the different cultures and re- fact that the activities they are perform
gions, and between rural and urban ar- generally overlooked not only by econo-
eas, it is rarely seen as productive. It mists and analysts, but very often by the
has low social value and is perceived as authorities (Hitomi, 2009). Therefore the
a continuation of the household. Realis- analysis of the gender value chain was in-
tically, however, by participating women troduced with the goal of maximizing rev-
strengthen the fishermens organizations enues for both men and women involved
and expand their business. Their merit at its various levels. This type of analysis
is the focus on the quality of life in the is important since it emphasizes the dif-
fishing communities, such as access to ferent positions and contribution of men
health, education, hygiene. and women along the chain and reveals
the economic and organizational relation-
ships between participants located in dif-
ferent parts of the value chain in fishing.
12
In Europe
As in other parts of the world, small-scale Small-scale fishing can also include:
coastal fishermen in Europe develop in
time and space from specific ecological Freshwater catches;
and changing socio-economic and cultur- Auxiliary activities (production of
al context, marked by variety rather than fishing gear, net repairing);
uniformity. Therefore, all discussions on
the issue should consider the fact that Processing and marketing;
there is a problem with their definition. Management of the fishery firms.
Definitions are not universally applicable
and what in one situation can be defined
as small-scale, in another will be medium
or large-scale.
Its defining criteria, used in the EU, are: native employment could be scarce and
therefore the price of this option is high.
Structural characteristics - size and Furthermore, the loss of activity of SSF is
/ or capacity of the vessel (length, accompanied by loss of skills, traditions,
tonnage or HP / Kw); used fishing knowledge and culture, which constitute
tackle; the social basis of the communities. It is
Territory / range: location of the therefore important that they are pro-
fishing zone - distance from shore, tected as a unique sector with important
time in the sea; contribution.
Sea fishing is the exclusive jurisdiction OPF - applies only to maritime fishermen.
of 7 EU institutions, where the main Freshwater fishing - estuaries, lagoons and
ones are: other areas or from the coast - are under
the jurisdiction of the Member States.
The Council of Ministers of the In addition, Member States have special
Member States rights over the 12-mile zone where most
legislative and executive functions of the activities of a SSF are concentrat-
focusing the greatest power; ed. For this and other reasons, it can be
The European Commission argued that SSF is a sub-sector, for which
delegated executive, legislative and the most appropriate level of government
quasi-judicial functions; co-decision; is the national as regards governance and
policy-making.
The European Parliament
certain legislative and executive The Voluntary guidelines are important
functions. because SSF have a different status com-
pared to large-scale fishermen. By join-
Other important EU institutions are: ing the EU, Member States confer com-
The European Court of Auditors petences for the fisheries management to
financial / budget / audit functions; the European Commission in the waters
within 200 miles (Community waters) and
European Court of Justice in terms of international waters and the
judicial functions. waters of third countries for vessels regis-
tered in the European countries.
In 2012 FAOUN issued Voluntary guide-
lines for governance of tenure of land, In Europe small-scale coastal fishing pro-
fisheries and forests in the context of na- vides a high level of employment and is
tional food security. Their purpose is to not only socially, but alsoenvironmental-
serve as a reference point for improving ly sustainable form of fishing. For most
the management, with the long-term goal coastal areas this is a way of life and a sig-
of progressive support of peoples right to nificant source of subsistence. Therefore
adequate food in the context of national it recognized at EU level that it should be
food security. They are intended to con- encouraged in order to survive and should
tribute to the global and national efforts be given an impetus for economic devel-
to eradicate hunger and poverty on the opment. As a new target of a common
basis of the principles of sustainable de- fishery policy, the EU has set ensuring
velopment. preferential access of SSF within 12-mile
maritime zone, i.e. in the most sensitive
To better understand how to apply the
part of the Community waters.
Voluntary Guidelines on SSF in Europe,
it is important to comprehend how they In the European Community a total of
apply at EU and at Member State level. 500,000 fishing vessels are registered and
Above all, the fishing policy of the EU - the small-scale fishing fleet consists of over
17
12 million. Both however each provide 30 In the European countries, women control
million tons of annual catch for the mar- 39% of the fishing industry and provide
ket. It is important to note that the fish- solid income for themselves and their
ing ships reach that amount, utilizing 37 families (Aquilar, 2002). The key role of
million tons of fuel, while the small-scale women in professions based on natural
fishermen - only 5 million tons. Yet an- resources such as fishing, has long been
other fact of key signifcance - large ships accepted, but has not been recognized
discard between 8 and 20 million tons of and appreciated the way the role of men
extra harvest in the sea annually, which is (Obetta et al., 2007). One of the main
is generally prohibited, while with the SSF factors that limit womens participation
this practice is extemely restricted. in economic activities such as fishing is
the lack of access to and control over
Meanwhile, these fishermen are faced the production process (Acharya, 2003).
with many problems, the most acute According to researchers, women in ru-
among them beiong the preservation ral areas participate more actively in the
of their fishing areas, conflicts with the traditional fishing sector.
trawls of large ships, the need for a spe-
cial status to be guaranteed by law, etc. Attention to womens participation in the
sector in Europe increased at the begin-
Ten years ago in Europe more than 100 ning of the century. One of the first stud-
000 women were statistically recorded as ies - Women in small-scale fishing, 2002
employed in the fishing sector, but meas- - showed that despite the cultural and
uring their contribution represents a con- economic diversity in the EU, with regard
siderable difficulty. Statistics for example to the fisheries sector the perception of
does not include women working full or women demonstrates a high level of sim-
part-time in family businesses without ilarity.
being legally recognized and without the
associated benefits. Women do not feel well accepted
in marine fishering, but they are re-
Women do not have a special place in the luctant to participate anyway. It is
framework of the reform of the Common therefore not surprising that their
Fisheries Policy. For the first time the number in it is very small. Women
new European Marine and Fisheries Fund play a very small role in the fishing
(EMFF) recognizes the role that women proper (3% in the EU), ranging be-
play in the fishing family business. From tween 0 and 7% across the states,
now on they will be able to benefit from and in general their inclusion is pe-
support and training, in particular for ac- ripheral.
quiring skills related to entrepreneurship
and business management. Women feel discriminated in aqua-
culture, but to a much lesser extent
and are more widely involved. In
this area there are some activities
18
gal status of the supportive wife in And last but not least, womens or-
the national legislation of the Mem- ganizations are encouraged to mobi-
ber States and at providing women lize support by the government and
with equal access to social benefits. apply for funding from the special-
The achievements in some of the ized funds for common female pro-
countries in this respect are greater jects such as collective sale of fish
than in others (France, Spain, Portu- and education and training programs.
gal).
Access of women from the fishing
communities to decision-making on
management issues in the sector.
This is the main theme of AKTEA
for encouraging organizations in the
network to participate in the Re-
gional Advisory Council for Fisheries
of the EU. It also encourages them to
engage in consultations on important
policy issues in the field of fisheries
in the EU on Member State level,
such as the process of drafting the
Green Paper of reform in the Com-
mon Fisheries Policy and the Europe-
an Fisheries Fund.
AKTEA takes care that organizations
that are its members participate in
initiatives for promotion of the local
economy and the local community,
such as organizing local fish mar-
kets, activities to build a good im-
age of the fishers and promotion of
their traditional culture, campaigns
on safety at sea and better working
conditions for the crews.
21
In Bulgaria
According to FAOUN the number of small- rostat and STECF data differ significantly
scale fisheries in Bulgaria is 2767, and in in absolute terms, but proportionately re-
Romania it is 673. In Bulgaria it represents flect the global trends of concentration of
nearly 94% of the total number of regis- women in processing, to a lesser degree
tered active boats as of end 2015, and in in aquaculture and their virtusl absence
Romania 94.4%. from the fishing activities.
There is no data on the gender distribu- According to the Bulgarian public register
tion of the workforce in fisheries in both of the active fleet, the active vessels un-
countries, since no such were submitted der 12 meters were 1790 at the end of
to Eurostat. For the aquaculture, howev- 2015. The large ships with length over 12
er, data are available, according to which meters are around 100. Romania does not
in Bulgaria (Scientific, Technical and Eco- support such a register.
nomic Committee for Fisheries (STECF),
the number of enterprises is 336, and the Association has not become an effective
distribution of the workforce is 930 men practice in the fisheries sector in Bulgaria
and 445 women, i.e. women are 32.4%; yet. According to publicly available data
in Romania, the number of enterprises is the registered associations are currently
315, and the distribution of the workforce ten, but not all of them are active. Half
is 2135 men and 554 women, i.e. women of them are in the Northern Black Sea
are 20.6%. coast: three in Varna (Trakata, Quar-
antine, Ada Bahcha) and two in the
In the processing sector in Bulgaria (ac- north of Varna (Kaliakra Kavarna and
cording to the STECF data) the number of Kariya - Shabla). Most of the small-scale
enterprises is 45, and the distribution of fishermen, however, prefer to work inde-
the workforce is 883 men and 1051 wom- pendently because of the fees they have
en, i.e. women are 54.3%; in Romania the to pay in organizations. In Romania there
number of enterprises is 13, and the dis- are 5 active associations, 3 of them in the
tribution of the workforce is 230 men and Danube Delta area.
342 women, i.e. women are 59.8%. Eu-
22
The fish in the sea is a public resource that they represent, they take care of
and is not only an important source of the sea using fishing gear that provides
protein and nutrients for billions of peo- high-quality fresh fish, but their voices
ple around the world, but also the source could not get to influence the policy - at the
of 60 million jobs in the sector, 90% of national and the EU level. As a result, the
which are in small-scale fishing and 15% fisheries policy is dominated by the large,
of them for women. The European fishing better organized and resourced sector of
fleet has over 83,700 vessels that employ the fleet, often to the detriment of the
more than 150 000 people and at least small-scale sector.
three times more workplaces on shore.
Four out of five (80%) of the fishing ves- The commercial fishing in European wa-
sels in the European fisheries are defined ters is managed through the Common
as small-scale (with lenght less than 12 Fisheries Policy. The regulation is re-
meters). formed every ten years, and despite the
good intentions for decades it neglects
Historicaly at the end of the last and at the described diminishing of fish and jobs
the beginning of this century the waters related to fishing.
from the Atlantic Ocean to the Black Sea,
and from the Baltic sea to the Mediterra- As a result of the latest reform, which be-
nean have been overfished, leading to a gan in 2009 and was completed in early
dramatic reduction not only of fish stocks, 2014 with the adoption of a new policy,
but also of fishermen relying on them. two basic changes occurred. First, the
This ecological disaster stirred public Lisbon Treaty introduced the co-deci-
condemnation and the fishermen who had sion. This means that MEPs had the op-
the aura of heroes in their communities portunity to influence the reform process
became pirates who do not think about and second, small-scale fishermen and
the future. their representatives, with the help of
a large number of environmental NGOs
Virtually without exception, overfish- participated in the process. The combi-
ing is not due to those 80% of fleet, nation of these two elements undoubted-
represented by small-scale fishermen. ly had a serious and very positive effect
Since they cannot move to new loca- on the results.
tions, small-scale fishermen are forced
to keep what they have. Thus, regard-
less of the percentage of the total fleet
23
The new CFP and its related regulation pact, but so far they had no effective rep-
concerns: resentation in Brussels, or even at Member
State level. Established as an organization
providing a fair standard of living in in May 2014, LIFE is, in the words of its
the fishing sector, including small- President, organization of organizations
scale farms; led by a fisherman for fishermen. It is
preferential access for small-scale, managed by a Management Board of an-
artisanal and coastal fishing vessels, glers from all over Europe, all members
an action plan for development, of the local small-scale fishery communi-
competitiveness and sustainability of ties. The platform has an Executive Di-
coastal fishing; rector, supported by a team in an office
in Brussels and regional coordinators who
incentives, including economic, to currently cover the North Sea, the Baltic
encourage more selective fishing with Sea and the Mediterranean area.
low impact on the marine ecosystem
and fishery resources. When Member The members of LIFE unite fishermen who
States define their fishing perime- are small-scale and have a low environ-
ters, they should use transparent and mental impact, but at the same time high
objective criteria, including environ- social and economic value to the commu-
mental, social and economic. nities that they support and that support
them. Typical of them is that most often
Streight after the introduction of the new they do daily sea fishing trips and have
CFP the question of the actual implemen- low GHG emissions per kilogram of har-
tation of the measures emerged. To this vest, i.e. sustainable type of catch. Their
end, small-scale fishermen who united importance is not limited to the catch or
and spoke in one voice during the reforms even to those men and women who work
formed the Basic Team that created the routinely in one of the most dangerous
LIFE platform (Low Impact Fisheries of environments to provide fish for our ta-
Europe). ble (fishing is characterized by more inju-
The main objective of the LIFE Platform ries and deaths than any other industrial
is to provide the clear and coherent opin- sector). It is much bigger, because these
ion of the majority of European fishermen people take care of the sea every day:
on EU level, who are small-scale and use they are often at the core of envi-
fishing tackle and methods with low im- ronmental programs and initiatives;
24
they keep 1,000 years-old cultures Here is an example of the change that
and traditions alive; can guarantee sustainable development
of the sector in Europe. Traditionally, ac-
they are the successor of countless cess to fish in the sea, or at least for most
generations of knowledge and skills European fishermen goes through the
and if lost, they could never allocation of fishing quotas, represent-
be restored; ing a share of those allocated to the re-
they are often the mainstay of the spective state based on historical harvest
vulnerable communities inhabiting data. The problem with this approach for
the coasts, because they support the small-scale fishermen is that they do
them, create jobs where sometimes not have adequate systems of register-
there is no other employment and ing their catch, while the operators of
are a source of fresh fish. the larger vessels have their log-books,
where they register in detail everything
Since its establishment in 2014, LIFE has they landed. In some cases they exagger-
already more then 7000 members, work- ate the indications to secure access to
ing on more than 4,000 boats in all of the future opportunities. The method obvi-
14 maritime Member States of the Union. ously rewards those who have the biggest
catch and leaves the small-scale fleet out
of the process. This in turn provides many
important resources and thus affects the
larger fishermen. The vicious circle of
lack of resources is closing, and as a re-
sult small-scale fishermen have no impact
on the fisheries policy and the quota is
consolidating in the hands of the larger
players.
25
In Britain, for example, although the small- ver, they generate workplaces elsewhere
scale sector represents 77% of the fleet in in the community in local trade, in man-
absolute number, it has an access to only ufacturing and in repair activities.
1.5% of the quota in tonnage. This situa-
tion is exacerbated because the quota is Naturally, such a large group cannot be
becoming a commodity for sale. The cur- homogeneous, which is a challenge in it-
rent trading, along with well-intentioned self. That is why the CFP embarked on re-
but dangerous initiatives to further pri- flecting the challenges. It introduced spe-
vatization of fish in our seas, means that cial rules to minimize the administrative
the small-scale sector is left standing on burden on small-scale fishermen and their
the pier without being able to catch the SMEs for example they are not expected
fish that goes by, while large and often to keep a log-book.
foreign fishing vessels utilize the national The EU is also striving to make the right
quota, which they purchased or acquired investments. Access to finance was fa-
based on previous harvest. cilitated in the new European Fund for
Article 17 of the CFP requires from the Maritime Affairs and Fisheries. For small
Member States to incorporate the crite- boats a higher percentage of funding is
ria of environmental, social and economic eligible - 75%. But things are not limited
considerations in the allocation of access to financing. A framework has been pro-
to fishing quotas. If governments take this vided for conservation of the activities of
approach seriously and not just in words, small-scale fisheries. This is not only done
it could revolutionize the industry very at EU level. Since the measures for pres-
quickly. It would reward any vessel or ervation and access are local in origin,
group of vessels that implement sustaina- small-scale fishermen should have greater
ble fishing and bring significant social and participation.
economic benefits, but until then the sys- The LIFE platform aims to influence the
tem will encourage those with the biggest development and implementation of the
catch, not with the most useful one. policy and to ensure that fishing in Europe
The potential of the small-scale fishing is done in a sustainable way, and that the
sector to ensure sustainable jobs and the destructive fishing practices are eradi-
livelihoods of the local communities in cated by the new CFP and the concerns
the long term, and to reduce the impact of small-scale fishermen get heard. With
on the ecosystem is enormous. Small ves- the help of changes in the overall policy,
sels provide over 40% of the total employ- financial support and the growing collec-
ment in the sector and provide European tive voice of the industry can become the
citizens with fresh, local seafood. Moreo- pulse of the future generations.
26
Women represent slightly over a half ignoring half the population means wast-
of the worlds population, but their ed potential of half the workforce.
contribution to the measured econom-
ic activity, growth and prosperity is far It is a known fact that change does not
below its potential and this has serious come easy and does not happen fast.
macroeconomic consequences. Despite Habits die hard. We have all grown up in
the significant progress made in the re- a society, dominated by men. Conscious-
cent decades, labor markets around the ly or not, we participate in maintaining
world remain gender-divided and pro- the power structures of society that dis-
gress towards equality seems to be at a criminate against women by inertia. The
standstill. The participation of women presentations in the leading media also
remains lower than that of men, women influence the way boys and girls per-
perform the majority of the unpaid work, ceive the world and their aspirations.
and when they are engaged in paid em- Securing visibility of strong women in
ployment, they are overrepresented in the media and highlighting their remark-
the informal sector and among the work- able success can inspire women to be
ing poors. Overall, remuneration of their more ambitious.
labor is lower than that of men. The pro- Viewed through the issue of fundamental
portion of women among entrepreneurs rights, gender equality shows that wom-
also remains low. Differences in produc- ens rights are a matter of immediate
tivity of businesses owned by men and concerns. In the economic sphere the
women according to research are mainly link between equality, economic growth
due to the access to resources (Blackden and institutional mechanisms should be
and Hallward-Driemeier 2013). recognized. According to the Index of
The Europe 2020 strategy for smart, sus- Gender Equality, which in employment
tainable and inclusive growth reflects measures the difference in participa-
the priorities of Europe and the way it tion on the labor market, in the duration
will approach the future economic chal- of working life, in sectoral segregation
lenges. One of the biggest among them models and the labour quality (such as
is unemployment. When innovative solu- flexible working hours, job training and
tions to economic challenges are sought, health and safety), women participate in
28
5. Women in SSF:
traditional roles and opportunities
In most fisheries men are the main pro- part of the their husbandss catch to sat-
ducers. This is especially valid with re- isfy the needs of the family and the rest
gard to fishing activities that occur off- to provide for other needs. In the fisher-
shore. These activities are reserved for ies communities they are the ones that
men who are physically fit to withstand obtain loans when needed, because they
the difficulties of working at sea. There are involved in more and more extensive
are good reasons for that the work re- social networks than their husbands.
quires physical strength and men are
generally larger and have more muscles The gender analysis is still poorly in-
than women, which generally makes volved in fisheries and mostly limited to
them more productive; fishing boats the roles that men and women perform.
have very limited space and supplies of The belief that men fish and women par-
food and water that should maintain the ticipate in post harvest activities and
maximum possible amount of productive sale remains the most prevalent among
energy. Also, sea fishing is a potentially cultural, social, political and economic
dangerous activity and women are im- environments. Averages of global statis-
portant to the community as guardians tics that support this perception mask
of the family reproduction. the real importance of women national-
ly.
This does not mean that women are not
represent on the boats during the catch Changes in the traditional roles of wom-
or should not do that. There are nota- en in modern societies are both naturally
ble exceptions to the rule, especially in occurring and deliberately caused. The
Asia, where whole families live and work natural evolution is the result of global
together on water. economic and social trends, changes in
lifestyle and the influence that women
However, there are many other ways in managed to achieve thanks to their unit-
which women participate in the fisheries ing for a common cause. Purposefully
sector, but traditionally they are expect- caused changes are the result of the fish-
ed to perform a dual role: managing the eries policy, which increasingly recogniz-
household and taking care of the chil- es their key role and is looking to expand
dren, and being the engine of fish pro- their capabilities, including by means of
cessing and marketing. So women use Blue growth.
30
31
The activities that will contribute to basic hand accounting to modern com-
ensuring the remuneration of wives / puterized systems. The management
daughters of fishermen within in the fish- function also involves assessment and
eries considered as promising and having analysis of accounting information. With
opportunities for development are: their help informed decisions can be tak-
en based on the actual situation or on
Accounting forecasts.
The effective management of the fish- The financial part is related to the mon-
ing enterprise requires accounting that ey and financial operations of the fishing
helps them fulfill their obligations to the enterprise. It includes sales of the har-
tax authorities and make informed deci- vest, operational costs, liabilities and
sions about their financial situation. De- receivables, assets, depreciation, loans
cisions that are not based on accurate and price information. The part concern-
accounting information can lead to re- ing the harvest refers to the quantity of
duced profits or losses. This is an impor- caught fish by species. When this infor-
tant intrinsic function that women could mation is maintained and categorized
perform. accurately, it is a useful source of busi-
The National Revenue Agency requires ness decision-making.
reporting of sales, expenses, deprecia- The choice of a system should be deter-
tion and information about participation mined by the expected use of the ac-
in programs, financed by national or EU counting information. There is no best
funds. Furthermore, the funding insti- system for all situations, but as a mini-
tutions demand detailed business and mum an accounting system should:
personal information about the fisher-
mens property and the status of their provide accurate and relevant in-
outstanding loans. formation;
Accounts-keeping includes the collec- fit in the organization of the fishing
tion, organization, categorization and enterprise;
maintaining of financial information re-
lated to the catch and its marketing. be in a form that helps
Different methods could be used - from decision-making.
32
The permit holder for commercial fishing the vessels length is over 10 meters, the
must inform the authority which grant- captain is obliged to reflect in the log-
ed the authorization of any changes in book the time, coordinates of the areas
the circumstances, related to the boat and places of fishing.
characteristics within seven days of their
occurrence. Failure to comply with the statutory re-
quirements and rules lead to sanctions,
The validity of the permit may be termi- most of which are financial or related
nated with an order, when for two con- to withdrawal of rights. Therefore, the
secutive years the holder has not been implementation of administrative activ-
issued a permit, the permit holder does ities is an important task that requires
not comply with the law or has declared investment of considerable time, includ-
zero catch. The fishing boats are subject ing familiarization with the provisions
to official deletion from the register and and monitoring of the changes in them,
the released capacity remains in favor and respecting the deadlines. This activ-
of the state. Commercial fishing is done ity also has the potential to give women
only with gear and vehicles that are a significant role in the fishing enterpris-
marked and entered in the certificate, es with a good status and good income
subject to marking within a specified pe- opportunity.
riod.
Moreover, according to studies it is pre-
Any person holding a premit for com- ferred by women and perceived much
mercial fishing in the waters of the Black better psychologically than participation
Sea is obliged to provide EAFA with gen- in activities, related directly, preceding
eral information and economic statistics or following the harvest.
about the fishing vessel, data on the
number of employees and the fishing ac-
tivities by the end of March.
When fishermen are engaged in commer-
cial fishing, they should keep a log-book
after the model issued by EAFA, which
consists of data on the harvest by spe-
cies and quantitative composition: for
turbot it is reported in units and by size
groups in kilograms, for sturgeon by spe-
cies, gender, weight and size of each
individual and for the rest fish and oth-
er aquatic species in quantities in kilo-
grams, including the allowable catch. If
35
tugal, Ireland, Sweden, UK and Italy). rederas, although they are members of
A transnational network was created to the cofradias-professional organizations
make room for participation in the RACF representing the small-scale fishermen.
for the North Sea. Thus, womens or- Studies have shown that local organi-
ganizations began playing a role in the zations do better thanks to the small
fisheries management politics. Some of amounts they receive from the local au-
them have earned their participation in thorities, while regional, national and
the executive committees (Portugal, Ita- European fight for their survival. The
ly and the UK), others in working groups. membership fee can hardly provide for
This participation has proved somewhat their activities.
problematic, mostly for financial rea-
sons, since membership in RACF is rel- Experience shows that organizations pro-
atively expensive and womens organ- tecting the interests and rights of pro-
izations generally depend on voluntary fessional women and managing resourc-
contributions. es succeed in maintaining their level of
activity. They also face problems, albeit
Among the truly active are the organi- of a different character; the most com-
zations from Galicia, Spain, balers for mon are the environmental problems
various types of shellfish (mariscadoras) and illegal practices.
and masters of nets (rederas), who strive
to convert their unregulated activities Nevertheless, Europe considers womens
into profession and have managed to organizations in the fisheries sector as a
convince regional authorities to provide valuable partner, which is a new voice in
them support. The professionalization of the policy process and which boosts their
collecting mussels will give them a sta- confidence in their own strengths.
tus first, and second it will provide them
with the opportunity to better manage
the supply of their products.
Organizations representing wives in the
fisheries sector act independently of
mens organizations on a voluntary ba-
sis. Independent organizations exist at
all levels - from local to European and
the network AKTEA functions as a union,
which represents all womens organiza-
tions in the sector at European Union
level. For all these associations a ma-
jor problem is the lack of funding. This
applies even to the mariscadoras and
37
Providing capital to start own business, tional activities in the field of fisheries
using catch as a raw material. are recognized according the program.
Provision of capital to start own busi- The total budget of the grant according
ness using catch as raw material can be to the procedure is 1.5 million levs. The
secured in two main ways - through the maximum co-financing rate is 50% -80%.
loans of financial institution and with the
help of funds targeting the sector. Measure 2.1 appropriate for technical
innovations in aquaculture, innovation
The Program for Maritime Affairs and promoting sustainable use of resources,
Fisheries (PMAF) aims to achieve a dy- introduction of new, sustainable produc-
namic, sustainable and competitive tion methods, etc.
fisheries and aquaculture in the period
2014-2020 and provides grants of 50% to Applicants under this measure could be:
100% of the business initiatives depend- Persons registered under the Com-
ing on the chosen procedure. mercial Law or the Law on Coopera-
Funds can be recieved through the fol- tives operating in Aquaculture
lowing measures: Scientific and technical organiza-
Measure 1.1: suitable for investments tions.
on board of the vessels, fishing tourism, This measure aims at introducing pro-
restaurants, environmental services re- cess innovation and will support the
lated to fisheries, etc. acquisition of scientific and technical
Applicants under this measure could be: knowledge, striving to develop and in-
troduce new and significantly improved
Persons registered under the Com- products, new aquaculture species with
mercial Law operating in the fisher- good market potential, new or improved
ies sector. processes, new or improved manage-
ment systems and organization.
Persons registered under the Law on
Cooperatives operating in the fish- Financial assistance under this meas-
eries sector. ure should contribute to strengthening
of the technological development and
Under this measure you can receive fi- knowledge transfer. It will enable scien-
nancing for investments, leading to im- tific research authorities / institutes to
proved competitiveness and viability of develop their knowledge in the field of
the enterprises in the fisheries sector, in- aquaculture in practice; will accelerate
cluding small-scale coastal fleet and im- the track of their results to the business-
proving safety and working conditions. es, and they will be able to benefit more
Expenses for investment on board of the easily from the achievements of science
vessels, fishing tourism, restaurants; en- and directly apply them in practice. Im-
vironmental services, fishing and educa- plementation of innovative approach-
39
es, processes, products will diversify under Art. 25 LFA, in cases when
production, it will increase revenues/ the supported entities are exist-
reduce costs and fully optimize the pro- ing operating farms;
duction processes, management and sale
of production. to be registered under Art. 137
of the Animal Health Law (AHL) -
To reduce the risk of failure of an inno- where the subject of support are
vative idea, it will finance the study of existing farms;
the technical and economic feasibility of
innovative products and processes. To qualify for micro, small or me-
dium enterprise according SMEA
Under this measure expenses for tech- and Annex I of Regulation (EU)
nical innovation in aquaculture aimed 651/2014 or to have a staff
at reducing environmental impact; in- of less than 750 employees or
novation to promote sustainable use of with turnover below 200 million.
resources, to facilitate the introduction Euros, if they are enterpriceses
of new, sustainable production meth- that do not fall within the defi-
ods, including of locally adapted tech- nitions of the above-mentioned
nologies for breeding of new promising laws and regulations.
species and developing technologies to
produce products with high biological Part of the activities provided for in the
value; studies of the technical and eco- measure Productive investments in aq-
nomic feasibility of innovative products uaculture, aimed at modernization of
and processes will be recognized. the facilities and diversification of the
income of aquaculture enterprises, in-
The total amount of the grant is 1 mil- cluding improving safety working condi-
lion lev. The maximum co-financing rate tions, in particularly small and medium
is 100% enterprises.
Measure 2.2: a suitable investment Eligible activities will include:
for diversification of activities and the
reared species, modernization of farms, 1. Productive investments in aquacul-
including the purchase of equipment for ture, including production of fry
protection of the property, etc. 2. Diversification of production of aq-
Applicants under this measure could be: uaculture and farmed species;
to be registered as producers of
fish and other aquatic organisms
40
Measure 5.4: suitable for farm modern- to be registered under Art. 137
ization including the purchase of equip- AHL - when supported objects
ment to protect farm, investments to are existing or new created com-
improve the quality or value added, re- panies that process their own
storing ponds used for aquaculture, etc. aquaculture.
Applicants under this measure could be:: The implementation of measure Pro-
cessing of fisheries and aquaculture prod-
Legal entities registered under the ucts should contribute to promoting
Commercial Law or the Law on Co- investments, adding value to the prod-
operatives, as candidates must suit ucts through subsequent treatment/pro-
the following requirements: cessing. EMFF (European Maritime and
to be registered under Art. 12 of Fisheries Fund) can support investments
the Food Law and to be entered in the processing of fishery and aquacul-
in the register of BAFS in sector ture products, when these investments:
Fish products - only for exist- Contribute to the realization of
ing enterpriceses; energy savings or reduce the im-
to be entered in the Commercial pact on the environment, including
Register to the Registry Agency; waste treatment;
to qualify for micro, small or me- Improve safety, hygiene, health and
dium enterprise according SMEA working conditions;
and Annex I of Regulation (EU) Are associated with the processing
651/2014; of by-products that result from the
to be registered as producers of main activities of processing;
fish and other aquatic organisms Are associated with the processing
under Art. 25 LFA - in cases when of products of organic aquaculture
supported objects are existing under Articles 6 and 7 of Regulation
or new companies that process (EC) 834/2007;
their own aquaculture;
43
The objective of the LIFE platform is ity of the deep-sea fishing fleet. Thus,
to announce a clear and strong opinion small-scale fishermen are marginalized
of the majority of the European small- and lose their business. At the same time
scale fishermen at EU level. It has al- large vessels use short-term contracts
ready achieved the recognition that it and unskilled labor and provide benefits
is of crucial significance that small-scale to local communities, while small-scale
fishermen have specific and focused rep- fishermen lose their jobs or are forced to
resentation to affirm their cause, ensure seek additional sources of income.
long-term sustainability and the survival
of their activities. The efficient and fo- The LIFE platform stands for:
cused presence at EU level is an impor- Fishing rights should be given to
tant part of this approach. those who use sustainable practic-
The LIFE platform not only speaks on es. They are convinced that access
behalf of its members in Brussels, but to fish must be linked to the per-
it also helps them in their direct com- formance of individual fishermen
munication at all levels. With its estab- based on environmental, social and
lishment, they send a petition to the EU economic criteria. They struggle for
decision-makers to preserve their com- the rewarding of fishermen whose
munities, their heritage and lifestyle. work has a sustainable effect with
The main message is that the Common minimal by-catch, high level of em-
Fisheries Policy must cease fishing, which ployment versus the volume of the
is not sustainable and place in the center harvest and weak dependance on
of Europes future the small-scale fisher- subsidies and fuel. Small-scale fish-
men with low environmental impact. ermen expect the policy to recog-
nize that the quota (fishing rights)
The small-scale fisheries platform wants is a public good, not private prop-
to overcome an injustice. Since the erty and to provide opportunities
adoption of the Common Fisheries Poli- in a way that promotes sustaina-
cy its framework is unbalanced and un- ble fishing methods. They object to
fair in its essence: a huge share of the the transferable fishing methods - a
fishing quotas and the EU subsidies go to system they believe effectively pri-
large-scale fishing operators throughout vatizes access and can consolidate
Europe and increase the fishing capac- marine resources in the hands of a
small number of powerful players.
46
8. Conclusion
A global consensus has been reached This guide is the first attempt to fill the
on the gender issues in the exercise of gaps and focus on the problems and op-
fundamental and labor rights. However, portunities of women in the fishing busi-
they have not been fully realized in the ness. It is primarily aimed at practicians,
fisheries sector yet. but it would also be useful for decision
makers because it draws on lessons
Fishing communities are gender divided learned from real situations and analyz-
and it is often up to the women to solve es elsewhere in Europe and worldwide,
the problem of changing access to fish and refers them to the specifics of the
resources. However, public recognition situation in Bulgaria and Romania. he
of the role of women in fisheries is at information that is placed in it is guid-
an early stage both in the world and in ed by the logic of the value chain in the
the EU. These policies do not sufficiently sector and by understanding of the chal-
take into account the non-economic and lenges and opportunities, arising from a
economic contribution of women to the more integrated approach.
welfare of fishing communities and fam-
ilies. As the sector is still dominated by
men, attention to the various roles that
women perform in it is not sufficient for
a real change to occur.
It is clear that there is no single or best
way of empowering women and achiev-
ing gender equality in fisheries. The re-
search literature on the subject is scarce
internationally and non-existent nation-
wide. This hampers the design of meas-
ures and management decisions based
on evidence, especially in terms of the
lack of statistical information and data
on women in the sector.
49
References
Application
Research at EU level
Counting Womens Participation in EU Aquaculture
Gender in Aquaculture and Fisheries post, May 2013. A new EU report on the Euro-
pean Union member countries aquaculture sector contains some basic gender-dis-
aggregated data on employment in the production segment of aquaculture.
Women in the EU Fish Processing Economy
Gender in Aquaculture and Fisheries post, May 2013
EU 2011 employment statistics show that women and men are almost evenly bal-
anced, in terms of numbers of fish processing jobs. Looking at different countries,
however, the figures differ. Estonia, Latvia, Lithuania and Poland have more than
60% women fish processing employees, whereas Malta and the UK have more than
60% of men employees. In Europe, fish processing employs about 150,000 people.
France, Poland, Spain and the United Kingdom supported the largest workforces,
with more than 10,000 each.
ICSF-AKTEA WIF 2010:Strengthening the voice of women of fishing communities in
Europe
Cornelie Quist, Katia Frangoudes, Brian ORiordan, Mai 2010, 55 p.
This report contains a summary of the workshop of 13/02/2010 about Recasting
the net: defining a gender agenda for sustaining life and livelihoods in fisheries and
aquaculture and the synthesis reports by countries: Azores (Portugal), France,
Greece, Italy, Netherlands, Northern Ireland (UK), Portugal, Spain. French version
of the workshops summary.
Women in fisheries: a European perspective
Katia Frangoudes, Policy Department B: Strucutral and Cohesion Policies, Fisheries,
Note, 2013, 44 p.
This note gives an overview of the current situation faced by women in the fisheries
and aquaculture sector in Europe and the prerequisites for improved gender main-
streaming. It presents and discusses the available data on female employment in
the sector, the problems faced by womens fisheries organisations and their future
prospects. The note also proposes that the impact of the EFF on the promotion of
gender equality should be evaluated, and outlines the expectations vested in the
EMFF.
51
France
Maritime sectors: more women joining the ranks
Fisheries and Aquaculture in Europe, n 51, May 2011, p. 10-11.
In the collective imagination, maritime occupations have always been a male
stronghold. Yet womens role and status in maritime activities have evolved con-
siderably over the last 20 years, whether in terms of legal status, access to jobs or
visibility. Since 2009, the FEMMAR project at the University of Nantes has teamed
up researchers from different disciplines to study the sociological, legal, economic
and geographical processes related to these developments and to understand the
paradoxes that sometimes result.
Women in Artisanal Fisheries in Brittany, France
Katia Frangoudes and Enora Keromnes, Development, n 51, 2008, p. 265-270.
French fishers wives play an important role within fisheries enterprises by realizing
different tasks such as administration, repairing fishing gear and selling fish. This
informal contribution became legally recognized with the creation of collaborative
spouse status (CSS) in 1998. Katia Frangoudes and Enora Keromnes discuss the di-
verse contributions of women to Brittany fisheries and the reasons that push wom-
en to opt or not opt for legal status.
Ireland
Women as agents of wellbeing in Northern Irelands fishing households
Easkey Britton, Maritime Studies 2012, 22
This paper focuses on the gender dimensions of wellbeing in fishing households in
Northern Ireland. The impact of change in the fishing industry on womens wellbe-
ing is outlined and linkages are made between changing access to fish and changing
roles of women in fishing households. The paper explores what this change means
for how women perceive and pursue their wellbeing needs and aspirations and how
they negotiate their needs with the needs of the household. In an occupation as
gender biased as fishing it is argued that in order for fisheries management and
policy to be successful, a profile of what really matters to people is important. In
particular, the paper highlights how such priorities link to the complex and dynamic
role of women in fishing households.
53
United Kingdom
Women as visible and invisible workers in fisheries: A case study of Northern England
Minghu Zhao, Marilyn Tyzack, Rodney Anderson, Estera Onoakpovike, Marine Policy,
vol. 37, January 2013, p. 69-76.
This paper is based on an externally-funded research project on womens roles
and contributions in fisheries conducted in Northern England in 2010. The paper
analyses some of the major roles played by women and their contribution in four
selected sectors: capture fishing, families and communities, trading, processing
and management/administration.
Women in fisheries final report, 30 April 2010
IRIS & Greenwich Maritime Institute, [59] p.
Women play a wide range of roles in the fisheries industry making significant con-
tributions across sectors. However, there is a significant gap in knowledge about
women in English fisheries today, as identified in our literature review conducted at
the early stage of this study. This study aims to help close this knowledge gap and
to inform policy making with evidence-based information collected and analysed by
the Women in Fisheries (WIF) Team from Greenwich Maritime Institute, The Univer-
sity of Greenwich and IRIS Consulting between January and April, 2010.
Presenting the leading organization
SP CONSULT BG is a consultancy company that successfully operates in all sectors
and planning regions in Bulgaria since 2009, strengthening its position nationally with
honest partnership.
The company specializes in providing technical assistance services in the field of infra-
structure development, transport, environment, socio-economic development, urban
planning, local and regional development and rural development, and the implemen-
tation of reforms in the public sector.
SP CONSULT BG is certified with the Management System Standard - ISO 9001: 2008.