Professional Documents
Culture Documents
www.elsevier.com/locate/apcata
Abstract
The addition of propylene oxide with methanol was carried out over solid bases and a detailed mechanism of the reaction over MgO was
investigated by using FT-IR method. It was found that 1-methoxy-2-propanol could be selectively synthesized on MgO, which had base sites
of moderate strength, while CaO and Al2O3 showed either low activity or selectivity toward the production of 1-methoxy-2-propanol. In situ
FT-IR revealed that methanol dissociation into methoxide and proton took place readily on MgO, and that propylene oxide adsorbed on MgO
could generate propylene-like species via carbanion intermediates. As a result, methanol dissociated into adsorbed methoxide and reacted
with the propylene-like specie in anti-Markownikov fashion, which led to the high selectivity to 1-methoxy-2-propanol on MgO.
# 2005 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
1. Introduction
0926-860X/$ see front matter # 2005 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.apcata.2005.07.005
W. Zhang et al. / Applied Catalysis A: General 294 (2005) 188196 189
[9], had good activity but lower selectivity to 1-alkoxy-2- syringe at 323 K, and the effluents were detected by a
propanol. BALZQ-mass spectrometer.
Solid basic catalysts, including anionic double hydroxide
clays [10], magnesiumaluminum oxide [11] and basic 2.4. FT-IR of adsorbed methanol and propylene oxide
zeolites [12], have attracted much attention due to their high
selectivity of 1-alkoxy-2-propanol. Unfortunately, few FT-IR spectra were recorded on a Nicolet Magna 550II
studies have reported the reaction mechanism on the Fourier-transform infrared spectrometer in the region 4000
methanol addition to propylene oxide over solid base 1000 cm 1; 128 scans with a resolution of 4 cm 1 were
catalysts. There are many differences between homogenous collected. A magnesium oxide disc, pressed at 2.4
reactions and heterogeneous ones. First, a heterogeneous 108 Nm 2 and weighing 1520 mg, was thermally pre-
reaction proceeds on the surface of solid catalyst, and only treated by heating at 673 K in vacuo. The build-up of
those propylene oxides that are close to the surface have the methanol and propylene oxide species on the surface was
chance to take part in the reaction. Second, the hetero- performed by adding their vapors, which had been degassed
geneous basic catalysis is more complex than the homo- by freezing and pumping several times, to the cell for 15 min
genous type in most circumstances. Thus, it is possible that a (propylene oxide for 10 s) at a desired temperature. After was
different reaction mechanism may exist over solid base removed by evacuation, FT-IR spectra of surface species were
catalysis. The present work focused on the understanding of obtained.
propylene glycol ether synthesis from methanol and
propylene oxide over solid bases. Considering the high 2.5. Catalytic performance
performance of alkaline earth metal oxides in a variety of
organic reactions involving formation of carbanion inter- The reaction was carried out in a 75 ml batch reactor, with
mediates [1317], we chose MgO as model catalysts, and the mole ratio of methanol and propylene oxide being 5:1.
both CaO and Al2O3 were studied for comparison as well. After running at 393 K for 5 h under magnetic stirring, the
reactor was cooled down to room temperature. The products
were analyzed by a gas chromatograph with a flame ionization
2. Experimental detector after centrifugal separation from the catalyst.
and CO2 uptake at the moderate basic sites decreased due to the formation of methoxide species. Tench et al. [18]
with the rise of calcination temperature. As a result, the reported that the introduction of methanol onto MgO led to
conversion of propylene oxide and the CO2 uptake at the appearance of two strong bands at 1114 and 1060 cm 1,
moderate basic site could be lineally correlated, as shown in the latter being largely removed by pumping at RT. They were
Fig. 4, i.e. the basic sites with moderate strength appeared to assigned to an undissociated methanol species and a meth-
be the active sites for the formation of 1-methoxy-2- oxide species, respectively. Our results were similar with their
propanol. The lower selectivity to 1-methoxy-2-propanol of work, but the band at 1055 cm 1 could not be removed by
Al2O3 would be ascribed to its acidity (not shown here). pumping at RT or even at 323 K. As the temperature was
increased from RT to 423 K, the band intensity at 2800 and
3.2. Methanol adsorption and desorption on MgO 1097 cm 1 (1106 cm 1 323 K) increased while it decreased
at 1055 cm 1. This was reasonable if the bands at 1106 and
The adsorption of methanol on MgO at various 1055 cm 1 were due to two kinds of methoxide species. The
temperatures was investigated by FT-IR (see Fig. 5). An new OH group that formed from the dissociative adsorption
intense band at 1450 cm 1 was observed over MgO pre- gave rise to broad bands near 3600 cm 1. When the
treated at 673 K in vacuum; this band could be assigned to adsorption temperature reached 393 K, new bands appeared
the MgCO3 stretching vibration. When methanol was at 1599 and 1394 cm 1, these could be ascribed to the
adsorbed onto the MgO surface, the bands were observed transformation of methoxide species into formate ions
at 2915, 2861, and 2800 cm 1 and at 1097 and 1055 cm 1, [19,20]. However, for methanol adsorbed on CaO (see
corresponding to the CH and the CO stretching vibrations Fig. 6), the bands around 2800 cm 1 and 12001000 cm 1
Fig. 2. Comparison of catalytic properties of MgO, CaO and Al2O3. Fig. 3. The effect of calcination temperature on MgO activity.
W. Zhang et al. / Applied Catalysis A: General 294 (2005) 188196 191
Table 1
BET surface area and CO2 uptake of MgO calcined at various temperatures
Calcination temperature (K) BET surface area (m2/g) CO2 uptake (mmol/g)
373 K 503 and 573 K 923 K
4 2
673 198.73 6.20 10 2.58 10
4 2
773 150.49 8.31 10 1.89 10
3 2 4
873 105.92 1.63 10 1.24 10 6.26 10
3 2 4
973 96.92 2.11 10 1.18 10 6.99 10
were not clearly observed, and only trace adsorption took both undissociated and dissociated forms, in agreement with
place. At the same time, the broad bands due to hydroxyl the FT-IR results. Undissociated methanol could be removed
groups were not easily observed near 3600 cm 1. by pumping at RT and was not observed by FT-IR, because it
The TPD of methanol over MgO indicated that methanol coordinated to the catalyst surface in a weakly absorbed
desorbed with the maximum at 432 K (see Fig. 7), and CO2 molecular state, corresponding to the methanol desorption at
and CO desorption peaks were observed at the high low temperature. Dissociated methanol produced methoxide
temperature region. Thus, methanol adsorbed onto MgO in species and desorbed into CO2 and CO at high temperature.
However, only methanol desorption was observed with the increased simultaneously with the rise of adsorption
maximum in TPD patterns at 609 K on CaO (see Fig. 8). temperature (see Fig. 9 line 25), suggesting that the epoxide
Unlike MgO, CO2 and CO were not observed in the high ring opened and formed propylene-like species. In addition,
temperature region, and these results suggested that no the bands at 2964, 2852, 2782 and 2653 cm 1 were assigned
methanol dissociation took place on CaO (trace dissociation to CH asymmetrical and symmetrical vibrations of the methyl
might be possible). Although CaO had the strong basic group. The bands around 3600 cm 1 were characteristic of
strength and high basicity, methanol was hard to dissociate to stretching vibrations of the hydroxyl group in the various
form methoxide species on CaO surface. Because of the environments. The increase of those broad bands with the rise
strong basic strength of the oxygen anion, methanol in of adsorption temperature suggested that the proton abstrac-
molecular state would be coordinated to the CaO surface in a tion from propylene oxide took place in the process of
stronger manner than that of MgO, leading to the desorption at formation of propylene-like species.
higher temperature. Fig. 10 shows the stability of the propylene-like specie on
MgO. In order to quantify the stability of propylene-like
3.3. Adsorption and desorption of propylene species, we analyzed the area of band at 3080 cm 1 evacuated
oxide on MgO at various temperatures using curve-resolving techniques
with a Gaussian method. The band area varied a little untill
The rapid adsorption of propylene oxide vapor (Pe = the evacuation temperature reached 393 K. Afterwards, the
10 Torr) at various temperatures was investigated by FT-IR band area decreased drastically, and when the evacuation
(see Fig. 9). Compared with the spectrum of pre-treated
MgO (Fig. 9, line 1), four groups of bands were clearly
visible in the regions near 3600, 30802653, 1644 and
1164 cm 1. However, the characteristic bands of propylene
oxide at 3050 cm 1 (CH stretching in epoxide ring) and
1260 cm 1 (epoxide ring breathing) were not observed
when 10 Torr propylene oxide vapor was introduced at room
temperature (see Fig. 9 line 2). The band at 1164 cm 1 could
be associated with the CO stretching vibration. The epoxide
ring probably opened and the CO bond was formed by the
interaction of propylene oxide with the MgO surface, and
then the intensity grew with the rise of adsorption
temperature (see Fig. 9 line 25).
In the CH stretching region, bands appeared at 3080, 2964,
2852, 2782 and 2653 cm 1. Therein, the band at 3080 cm 1
should be most interesting. As is well known, alkenes species
showed the CH stretching vibration at high wave numbers.
Furthermore, the characteristic stretching band of C C at Fig. 10. The stability of absorbed species on MgO with the rising evacua-
1644 cm 1 was also observed in our work. These two bands tion temperature.
W. Zhang et al. / Applied Catalysis A: General 294 (2005) 188196 193
Fig. 11. PO pulse reaction over MgO at 323 K: (m/e = 28 and, 43 corre-
sponding to the strongest mass spectra signal of propylene oxide and Fig. 12. IR spectra of MeOH and PO co-adsorption on MgO: (1, MgO; 2,
acetone, respectively). MeOH adsorbed on MgO at RT; 3, PO introduced at RT; 4, PO introduced at
373 K).
temperature reached 453 K, only a little propylene-like room temperature, the bands at 3080 and 1644 cm 1 were
species were present on the surface. These illustrated that the clearly observed (see Fig. 13 line 1). However, with the
propylene-like species were stable to some extent, although introduction of methanol, no clear presence of propylene-
they would be desorbed or decomposed at higher temperature. like specie could be detected, because the bands at 3080 and
Fig. 11 shows the results of propylene oxide pulse 1644 cm 1 were hardly visible (see Fig. 13 line 2). At the
reaction. As soon as the propylene oxide was injected to the same time, the band at 1097 cm 1 was strong and sharp,
pulse reactor in which MgO was loaded, propylene oxide (m/ which indicated the formation of 1-methoxy-2-propanol, as
e = 28) and acetone (m/e = 43) were detected. Molnar et al. mentioned above. The bands at 1106 and 1055 cm 1, which
[21] have also found the same results. Compared with the correspond to the methoxide formation, were not observed
FT-IR results, the propylene-like species are similar to in this process. When methanol was introduced at 373 K, the
enolate that readily changes to acetone. band at 1097 cm 1 became stronger and sharper (see Fig. 13
line 3). Thus, the propylene-like species were involved in the
3.4. Co-adsorption of methanol and propylene formation of 1-methoxy-2-propanol in this experiment.
oxide on MgO At last, propylene oxide and methanol were introduced at
the same time (see Fig. 14). Once the propylene oxide and
In order to understand the interaction between the methanol were introduced at room temperature, the weak
methoxide and propylene-like species on MgO, we carried
out two co-adsorption experiments with the different intro-
ductions of methanol and propylene oxide. In the first
experiment, methanol was introduced first onto activated
MgO pellets, followed by propylene oxide, and then the
system was evacuated at room temperature (see Fig. 12).
Obviously, the intensity of the bands at 1106 and 1055 cm 1,
which were the symbol of methoxide, was weakened when the
propylene oxide was introduced at room temperature (see
Fig. 12 line 3). However, the adsorption of propylene oxide on
MgO, which led to the particular bands at 3080 and
1644 cm 1 (see Fig. 9), was not observed in this process.
It was interesting that if the propylene oxide was introduced
at 373 K as shown in line 4, the band at 1055 cm 1 disappea-
red and the spectrum presented a new band at 1097 cm 1,
which might be assigned to CO stretching vibration of 1-
methoxy-2-propanol. This suggested that methoxide takes
part in the formation of 1-methoxy-2-propanol. Fig. 13. IR spectra of PO and MeOH co-adsorption on MgO: (1, PO
The reverse process was carried out in the second adsorbed on MgO at RT; 2, MeOH introduced at RT; 3, MeOH introduced
experiment. Once the propylene oxide was introduced at at 373 K).
194 W. Zhang et al. / Applied Catalysis A: General 294 (2005) 188196
partly compensated by the electron donation of methyl C (3). Thus, the addition reaction took place in anti-
group). Such a ring opening led to the formation of the Markownikov fashion.
more stable carbanion. The proposed reaction steps took A similar anionic mechanism was proposed in cya-
place as follows (see Scheme 1): the propylene oxide was noethylation of alcohol to 3-alkoxypropanenitrile [25] and
adsorbed on the active centers, and oxygen in the epoxide addition of methanol to allyl alcohol [26]. It seemed
ring interacted with the surface cation (Mgn+). As a result, reasonable if high activity and selectivity were due to the
a carbanion was formed by OC (3) bond breaking induced ability of both methoxide ion generation and propylene
by Mgn+ in the second step, and then the rearrangement oxide activation on MgO. The types of basic sites on the
reaction took place via the abstraction of proton with basic MgO surface included surface hydroxyl group, Lewis-acid
site (oxygen anion), where the propylene-like speices was Bronsted-base pairs (Mgn+O2 pair site) and isolated
formed. surface O2 ions [27,28]. The basic strength of surface
hydroxyls was considered to be very low [27], which might
4.3. Mechanism of formation of 1-methoxy-2-propanol correspond to the desorption peak at 373 K (see Fig. 1). This
on MgO type of basic sites might be not strong enough to dissociate
methanol and abstract a proton from propylene oxide. The
Methanol and propylene oxide adsorbed on MgO moderate basic sites of Lewis-acidBronsted-base pairs and
combined to form methoxide and propylene-like species. isolated surface O2 ions were appropriate to dissociate
The addition of methanol to alkenes species might occur in a methanol to methoxide and had the ability to abstract a
Markownikov fashion and resulted in the formation of 2- proton from propylene oxide. CaO with only strong basic
methoxy-1-propanol. However, such an addition mainly sites seemed unfavorable because of strong adsorption of
yielded 1-methoxy-2-propanol over MgO in the present methanol (see Fig. 8). Thus, moderate basic sites should be
work (see Fig. 2). Apparently, the addition of methanol the active sites for the present reaction.
followed an anti-Markownikov fashion. One plausible
mechanism could be illustrated in Scheme 2. A proton
was abstracted from methanol to form a methoxide ion, and 5. Conclusion
then adsorbed on the MgO surface. At the same time,
propylene-like species were formed by the adsorption of MgO was an efficient catalyst for the synthesis of 1-
propylene oxide as described in Scheme 1. Afterwards, the methoxy-2-propanol from methanol and propylene oxide.
addition of methoxide to propylene-like species took place Such a reaction required appropriate base strength to obtain
in an anti-Markownikov fashion and produced 1-methoxy-2- high activity and selectivity. The basic sites with moderate
propanol anion, followed by capturing a surface proton to strength were predominant on MgO surface, i.e. oxygen in
form 1-methoxy-2-propanol, which was adsorbed on surface MgO pairs and isolated O2 anions, and they preferentially
or desorbed into gas phase. In this process, the presence of catalyzed the reaction by liable formation of methoxide and
the methyl substitution on C (2) gave rise to steric hindrance carbanion intermediates. The addition of methoxide to
against attack on this carbon, and a difference in polarization propylene-like species took place in anti-Markownikov
between C (2) and C (3) induced by the electron-releasing fashion and then selectively produced 1-methoxy-2-
methyl group might also contribute to the favored attack on propanol.
196 W. Zhang et al. / Applied Catalysis A: General 294 (2005) 188196
References [16] A. Coma, S. Iborra, J. Primoo, F. Rey, Appl. Catal. 114 (1994)
215.
[1] European Chemical Industry Ecology and Toxicological Center [17] M. Xu, M.J.L. Gines, A.-M. Hilmen, B.L. Stephens, E. Iglesia, J.
Catal. 171 (1997) 130.
Report, No. 4, 1982.
[2] H.C. Chitwood, J. Am. Chem. Soc 68 (1946) 680. [18] A.J. Tench, D. Giles, J.F.J. Kibblewhite, Trans. Faraday Soc. 67 (1971)
[3] J.F Knifton, US Patent No. 4390734, 1983. 854.
[4] J. Umezawa, K. Furuhashi, JP Patent No. 63316749, 1988. [19] R.O. Kagel, R.G. Greenler, J. Chem. Phys. 49 (1968) 1638.
[20] Z.H. Qian, C.X. Guo, S. Naito, K. Tamaru, Chemical Journal of
[5] R.E. Parker, N.S. Isaacs, Chem. Rev. 59 (1959) 737.
[6] G. Woods, The ICI Polyurethanes Book, 2nd ed., John Wiley and Chinese Universities (Gao deng Xue Xiao Hua Xue Xue Bao) 13
Sons Inc., 1990. (1992) 246.
[7] ECETOC, Technical Report No. 64, 1995. [21] A. Molar, I. Bucsi, M. Bartok, J. Catal. 129 (1991) 303.
[22] W.C. Choi, J.S. Kim, T.H. Lee, S.I. Woo, Catal. Today 63 (2000)
[8] W.Y. Dong, T.N. Gao, CN Patent No. 1033742C, 1993.
[9] R. Gregory, D.J. Westlake, US Patent No. 4440958, 1984. 229.
[10] P.A. Martin, T. William, C. Malama, US Patent No. 5110992, 1992. [23] H. Knozinger, P. Ratnasamy, Catal. Rev. -Sci. Eng. 17 (1978) 31.
[24] A. Dinger, C. Lutterloh, J. Biener, J. Kuppers, Surf. Sci. 449 (2000) 1.
[11] W.J. Smith, F.C. Malherbe, US Patent No. 6291720B1, 2001.
[12] Z.S. Jin, X.M. Jiang, L. Zhang, CN Patent No. 1087651C, 1998. [25] H. Kabashima, H. Hattori, Catal. Today 44 (1998) 277.
[13] H. Hattori, in: Proceedings of the Third International Symposium on [26] T. Yamakawa, M. Takizawa, T. Ohnishi, H. Koyama, S. Shinoda,
Heterogeneous Catalysis and Fine Chemicals, Poitiers, 1993, p. L19. Catal. Commun. 2 (2001) 191.
[27] V.K. Dez, C.R. Apestegua, J.I. Di Cosimo, Catal. Today 63 (2000)
[14] G. Zhang, H. Hattori, K. Tanabe, Appl. Catal. 36 (1988) 98.
[15] J.I. Di Cosimo, V.K. Dez, C.R. Apestegua, Appl. Catal. 137 (1996) 53.
149. [28] R. Philipp, K. Fujimoto, J. Phys. Chem. 96 (1992) 9035.