Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Facts:
Issue:
Held:
The police power of the state is a very broad and expanding power. The
police power may encompass every law for the restraint and punishment of
crimes, for the preservation of the public peace, health, and morals. But
that power cannot grow faster than the fundamental law of the state, nor
transcend or violate the express inhibition of the constitution. The Police
Power is subject to and is controlled by the paramount authority of the
constitution of the state, and will not be permitted to violate rights secured
or guaranteed by the latter.
Facts:
Issue:
Whether or Not this Court should revisit its ruling in Santiago declaring RA
6735 incomplete, inadequate or wanting in essential terms and conditions
to implement the initiative clause on proposals to amend the Constitution.
Held:
According to the SC the Lambino group failed to comply with the basic
requirements for conducting a peoples initiative. The Court held that the
COMELEC did not grave abuse of discretion on dismissing the Lambino
petition.
1. The Initiative Petition Does Not Comply with Section 2, Article XVII of the
Constitution on Direct Proposal by the PeopleThe petitioners failed to show
the court that the initiative signer must be informed at the time of the
signing of the nature and effect, failure to do so is deceptive and
misleading which renders the initiative void.