Professional Documents
Culture Documents
The story is about the Holocaust. It was a genocide that killed 6 million of Jewish
people. Its the most brutal and painful things that ever happened to human. It took
place in Germany by Hitlers Nazi Germany. There are three main characters who
are Magda, Rosa and Stella. Rosa is a Jewish who having a child which is come
from the rapping of Nazi man. Her child name Magda. Magda is a fifteen months old
girl. She learn that she need to be quiet in order to survive in the holocaust and she
used the shawl to conceal her from Nazi. Stella is a Rosas fourteen-years-old niece
who is very thin. She jealous Magda because Rosa always gives foods to Magda
even though Stella is very hungry. The writer want to uses these three characters to
show the level of suffering during the Holocaust, the determination needed to survive
In the Holocaust, there are only a Jewish that can survive because Nazi see
any Jewish they will send to the concentration camp and most of them will died from
that camp. There are many situations that show the suffering and brutality.
cleverness and also luckiness. Rosa, Magda and Stella are very suffering from this
camp. For instance, Rosas dried-up breast, from which the infant Magda cannot
suck milk. This indicates a kind of suffering that Rosa is very thin even Magda cant
suck her breast. For another example, the writer used the metaphor for Stellas knee
to be a tumors of sticks which indicates how thin is her knees. Magda also cant
speak out even she still a baby. She needed stay in the shawl to hide from the Nazi
in order to survive. In the story, it can be easy to see that Stella is not a child of Rosa
because even Stella is more starving than Magda but, she still give foods Magda that
is smaller. This make Stella jealous to Magda and turn in to a conflict that make
Magda to dies. Magda used to stay inside a shawl to hide from the Nazi and Stella
knows that so, Stella take off the shawl and Nazi Germans see it. Suddenly, she get
killed. This indicates the brutality which is not only from Nazi but also from Stella too.
It can be said that the most suffering and determined person in this story is
Rosa. The reasons are she get raped by Nazis German which is a very brutal and
hard to forget and she also needed to take care another two kids even she feel very
exhausted. However, she still has a determination and doesnt give up to fight for
surviving.
Cynthia Ozick uses Magda, Stella and Rosa to indicate the level of sufferings,
brutality and the determination that needed to have in order to survive in Holocaust.
Every person who face the difficulties and brutal situations like holocaust would
normally show their real behavior such as, Stella that jealous Magda and want to kill