3, 1, 2005. .

2752

. .

1990 .

. , 
exit voice . . , 

, 
, ( state capture). 
, 
,  ,
 .


. 


. , 1990 .
.
(
, . .).
,

, 
,
.


, 21 2004 . 
().

, 20022003 .
() .
. . , . , . . , . . , . ,
. . , . . , . . , . . , 
.
. . , 2005
28 . .

1990 .2
 .
, 
1,  ,
 .3
, , 
 ,
 , 
.


, . ,
.  ,
, , .

 , 
19902000 . exit voice
 . [Hirschman, 1970].4
 ,
, . exit , (
, , 
 ),
 , 
, ( ). 
, 
1990 ., .

, 
20002003 . 
. , 
 ,
,  .
2
 .: [Aslund, 1996; Hellman, 1998; Shleifer,
 Treisman, 2000] .
3
. 


: 40
, 
(.: [ 
1990 . ..., 1994]).
.
(rentseeking)  [Yakovlev, 1993].
 1990 .
[, 1998].
4
, 

1
,  [Cook, Gimpelson, 1995]

. , .
 29


, ;
 
. .
, voice  
,
, 

. . ,
.
( loyalty)
 . 1980 . 
, , , 
.  .


, ,
, ,
exit, , 
voice,  . 

, 
.5 
, 

. 

 
.  . ,
 , ,


 
 .6
. 

"
"
. ,
 ,


6
, ,
, : .: [Kryshtanovskaya, White, 1996; Lane,
Ross, 1998; Kryshtanovskaya, 1999; 
 , 2002; Pleines, 2003] . 


5
.: [Hirschman, 1970, p. 34]. [, 2003].
30 . .

.  ) . . 
 
 .
 ( ,
, 
7, )
.
.8
 
 
  
,
1990 .
. . ,

9 
1990x . .
, 
, " 
. , , .
 
, 
( , 
,  
,  . 
,  (
, ,
, 
), , 
( ,  ).
 

7
 
,  (
, ).
, 
[, 1990]. 

, , 
(
) 
. . [, 1997], 
.
[, 2001]. 
8
, ,  

9
state capture.
.
. 2000 . [Hellman,
[Woodruff, 2003]. Jones, Kaufman, 2000].
 31

.  . 
 
 1990 .
,
.  ,
 

. 
 .
, 
 , , 
. , 

.  
 , 
 , 
 . .

. .


, 
.
. 
,
, 
1990 . 
 .
.10 ,  , 
,
.  1990 .,
 

. (. 1). 
, ,  
 ,
, 
 . ,
, ,
(),  
 .
,
10
 
19901991 .  
,


. ,
(.: [, 1992]). ,
32 . .

1

1990 .

-,

/

- -
( , - ,
, - (
, . .) ) -

, - ( -
, - ( -
- ),
( ) ,


)


(
)

1980- . 1990- .


(. 2).  

, .
1980 .  , 

11
 .
. , , 
 
,  .

11
1980 .: [ 
, 2002] .
 33

,  

, .
.
,
.


,
1990 . 


 .
.12 ,  , ,
:
  

;

 
,
 .
1998 .
, , ,


 
,  
 . 
.13 1980 . 

, 
. , 
,  () . . 
 , , 
 ,
.
1990 . .
14, : 

12
.: [Hellman et al., 2000; Frye, 2002] . , 
13
.: [, 2002; 2002]. .
14
 1992 .,
, 
[,
,
, , 1997], 
[,  28%
, 1998]. 40%
34 . .

. , 
 , 
.  , "
.
 
,
, 
19921993 .  .
. , 
 , 
 
, 1992 . . , ,

, 
 . 
.
, ,  ,
 ,
,  
,  
. , ,
,
.16

, ,
 , 
.15 ,
,  ,
,
 .
1990 .
.  
,  ,


. 
, , , 16
,
,  McKinsey 
, 

. , 
, , 
,

15
, 
,  [New Horizons..., 2003]).
, . 
[Yakovlev, 2001]. [ , 1995].
 35

. 

  . 
 
, ,
 1990 . 

.  
 .

,  
.  ,
 . . 
, .18
, 
, 
. 2003 .,
, , 
,  1990 . 

. 
, 
,
.17 ,
 . 
 
, 19, 

( ) 1990 .
, 
 
,
. 
,  18
., .: [, 1998] . 
 

, , ( ,


).
. 
. 
,  , 
, , , 
.
19
, , , 

17

[,
2002]. .
36 . .

, 
. "
 
 , 
, .
 1990 .
 
. , ,

 

20 
,  .
, ,  

,
.
.
,
,  
 

 , 
. 
, 
 
21, . 
 , , 
.  ,
, 

, 
. 
 .
 
 ,

.
20 . . ,

. 

. . ,   .22

22
. .: [, 1998, c. 5]
21 ,
, 
19981999 . 
, . . . 
[, 2000]. .
 37

, ,  (,
 1997 .

1000 . ) . .
. ,  , 
,
 
1998 .

1998 ., 


( 19992004 .
). 
 1990 .
,  
1990 ., 

,
, 
. , 1999 .
 .
,  
1996 
1997 . , 
 ,
 
23, 
(  . .
, , 
. 
. .) 
. 

1997 . 
23

.  19992003 .
 1,5 , 
86%.


, 20022003 .,

(  ,

() , 
. 
. . ), 

,  
. . .
38 . .

 (
( 1990 .). ,
. . . .  . .).
, 20002002 .,
,  , 
. 

,
 .

.  ,

, 
 1990 .

(  . 
) 
 , 
. 
20002002 . 26, 
.
,

. .  
.24
 ,


 
 . 
.25 ,  
, 

, , 

24
2000 . 2003 .  
6 . . . 
.
25
 . 3, 
, 


( 
. . , 
. . . .),  .
,  1990 . 
, 

,

26
. ., .: [, 2000; , 2001].
 39

1 2
1.

2. ,

( (
1990- . )
34 )

 
2. , ,  

 . 
 , ,
. .
,  
,  , 
, 
,
, 
.  .
, 
, 
1990 . ,

 , 
.27 ,
1997 2001 .,
27
, 

2004 .
,
, 
,
(,  (.: [, 2002]).
), ,
2004 . 
. 
 
 .
40 . .

28, . 
. . (
) 
 
(enforce 
ment),
. state capture  .


,
. [Frye, 2002]. 
,
500 , 
2000 ., 
 . 
 
. 
, , , 
 (
, ,
. 
 ). 
 ,
.  . 
, , 
. 
. , 
 .
 

. ,
. 
 . . ()
,  (, )
,  . 
. 
1990 2000 . 

2003 . 
 . ,
,
 . .
 
29, 

28
: [, 2003]. 
29
[
 , 2004].
 41

 .
( ) ,
 ,
. . , , 500 . 
 , , 
. 
. , , 
,
  ,
. .
, . 
,   
. , .
, , , 
, ,
, , . , 
1990 ., 
, ,

. .30
 ,
 , 
.  2003 .
 , 
(  
2003 .) ( , 
2004 .) ,  
 ,
, .
. . ,
. ,

, ,  ,
,  

. .
1990 . , , 

,  ,

, 30
1990 .
. . . 
, , , . . . 19961997 . 
.  
,
,
1990 . , 
" (.: [, 1998,
" . 137, 241242]).
42 . .

"
,  31 ,
, 
, 

 .
 , 1996 . 
. 
, 
, , 2004 .
,
1990 ., 
 . 
. . . .  
 
, .

 . 

. . , 
, ,
1990 .
 57 ,
. . . , 
, 

 ,  ,
. . .

, 

, 
.  , 
 . ,
,  1990 ., 
,  ( 
,
31
 
PR.




,  .
. 
. . .  [, , 2004]. 

,
. , 
 .
 43

 . 
,  
, ),  ,
 
. , .
, 


. 


,
.

 
 ,
, 
32, 
1990 . . ,
 2003 . 
.  , 
2004 ., 
, , 
8,5
1990 .,  ., ,
.  ,
,  14 17
.33
, , , 
,  
voice 
, 
.  .
, 
 ,

:
exit 
;
. , 
: 32
., , . .
2004 . ,
 . . 
? , 
2004 . . .
 33
.: [, 2004],
2004 ., 
 . . 05.08.2004.
44 . .


 
 ,
.
, .
 


exit
,  
1990 . , , . , 
(
,  , 
1990 .), , 
" 
.  
. . .35
, 
 "
" .
.34 , ,
.
1990 . 
. , ,
, 
, 


, ,
,  (),
, ,  .36
 1990 . 
.
 
, 
,  
,
 ,

" " 35

.  , , 
 .
 
34

 [Gereffi, 1999] 
.  .
36
: [, , 2004;  
, 2004] . .: [Yakovlev, 2004].
 45

.
, , 

. , 
. 
,

 
,  
IPO  
. ,
.
 
,  


 
 . 
.

.

 , , 
.  , , :

( ,  38
, ;
),  
.37 ;
 
, .
 , 
, . . , ,

.
38
 
 . .
,

, 
,
.
, .
37

. . ,
, 2005 . . 

,  
.
, .: [, , 2005]. .: [, 2003].
46 . .

 , 
, , , 
. ,
 .
 
 , 

 . 20002003 .,
. ,  , ,
,  ,

voice. , ,

, . ,
,
, 
, "
 ,
 
. 

 . , ,

2004 .  
, 
. ,
2000 . ,
 ,
,
, , ,
. .,  . 
. 
19992000 . (.: [ 
..., 1999] .), , 

, 
 
  . .
20012004 ., , 
. , 
, 20002004 ., 
 , 

, .

.  
,  , , ,
 47


, ,  ,
, ,  
 ()
. ,  
 
, , , .
, ,
,  
,
. . 

 ,
,
exit, , ,
, .
voice ( , 
) 

. 
, .

, 
 ( )
 , , 
,
. .  . . 
20072008 . 
, 2005 .  ,


( 150 .
., , 
). 


. .
 , 
 
. 


, , . ,
,  , 
 , 
 , . 
1995 . ,
48 . .

,
,
, .
 90% ,
.
2004 .
.

. . 
[, 2004].
. ,
 , 
, 1990 . , 
,  
.  
. ,
. 
 , 
,  ,
, .
. 

, , ,
 
20072008 .,  , ,
, 
.  .
, , 
. 
,  

,

 .
,
, 2002
2003 . 
. . . 
.
 2004 . 
 . . 
, 
1990 . ,
, , 
 
.
 . (
.
 49

 , 
 exit voice
 . [Hirschman, 1970].
, , .) , 
 
, ,  
 1990 .,
. ,
 
, 
. 
,  


20002004 .  ( ) 
.
, 
 , 
,
,
. 
. ,
, 

exit .  1980 . 
. ,   
voice . 
, 
,  ,
 (
, , ,
. .).

. , 


. 

1990 . ,
, 
,
, 
, ,
,
 
.  (
1998 .). 

50 . .

,  , 

.39  

 ,
1990 . 

. 
 , 
40 ,
 , ,
,  
. .
 , 2004 .
 
 .

,
, 


. . 

, 
39

, 

, , 
, ,
,
.: [, 2004, . 42].
40
.: [, 2002]. , .

., . 2005.  . 1995. .
. . .: Catal
. " laxy.
(11 ). ., . 2004. "
: 40 . 1994. . .: .
.: . . . 2001. 
. . 2002. " ? ( 
. .: . ). Pro et Contra 6 (4): 171198.
. 2004. " . . 2003. . : 
" . "
" (2):
. http://www.worldbank.org.ru 6783.
., . 2004. ., . 1998. 
. (39): : 
2026. . (5): 103120.
 51

( . . 2004. 
). 1999. : 
(12): 433. . Pro et Contra 8 (3): 3655.
. 2003.  . . 1992. 
. .:
" .
" : "
. : "
, (, 2021 1992 .).
148. .: ; .: ; 114118.
:  . . 2000. 
; 340358. ?
. 1990. . .: . (11): 134152.
. 1998. . " . . 2001. 
(19 ).
. . 2002.  .
: . " 5 (1): 4156.
XI (4): 360. . . 2003.
. 1998.  
: .
. " XII (4): 4488.
(10): 143154. . . 1997. "
. 2000.  "
:  . .: .

,  Aslund A. 1996. Reform vs. 'Rentseeking' in
? IX (1): 322. Russia's economic transformation. Transi"
. 2004. . tion 2 (2): 1217.
(45): 2432. Cook L. J., Gimpelson V. E. 1995. Exit and
., ., . voice in Russian managers privatization
1997. . " strategies. Communist Economies & Eco"
nomic Transformation 7 (4): 465483.
. Economisti Asso Frye T. 2002. Capture or exchange? Business
ciati. lobbying in Russia. Europe"Asia Studies
. 2004. . 54 (7): 10171036.
(6 ). Gereffi G. 1999. International trade and in
. . 2002. dustrial upgrading in the apparel commod
:  ity chain. Journal of International Eco"
 nomics 48 (1): 3771.
. Hellman J. S. 1998. Winners take all: The
(1): 2946. politics of partial reform in postcommu
. . 2002. nist transitions. World Politics 50 (2):
:  203234.
,  Hellman J. S., Jones G., Kaufman D. 2000.
. (2): Seize the State, Seize the Day: An Empir"
8397. ical Analysis of State Capture and Corrup"
. . 1998. " tion in Transition. Paper Prepared for the
: " ABCDE 2000 Conference, April 1820,
, " Washington, D.C.
. .: . Hellman J. S., Jones G., Kaufman D., Schan
. 2004.  kerman M. 2000. Measuring Governance,
. (29 ). Corruption, and State Capture. How Firms
52
and Bureaucrats Shape the Business Envi"
ronment in Transition Economies. World
Bank Policy Research Paper 2312 (April).
Hirschman A. O. 1970. Exit, Voice and Loyal"
ty. Harvard University Press: Cambridge,
MA.
Kryshtanovskaya O. 1999. Die Transformation
der alten NomenklaturKader in die neue
russische Elite. In: Steiner H., Jadow W. A.
(eds.). Russland wohin? Trafo Verlag:
Berlin.
Kryshtanovskaya O., White S. 1996. From So
viet nomenklatura to Russian elite. Eu"
rope"Asia Studies 48 (5): 1133.
Lane D., Ross C. 1998. The Russian political
elites: Recruitment and renewal. In: Hig
ley J., Pakulski J., Weselowski W. (eds.).
Postcommunist Elites and Democracy in
Eastern Europe. Macmillan Press: Lon
don; 3466.
New Horizons: Multinational Company In"
vestment in Developing Economies. 2003.
McKinsey Global Institute: San Francisco.
. .
Pleines H. 2003. Wirtschaftseliten und poli
tik im Russland der Jelzinra (199499).
Osteuropa: Geschichte, Wirtschaft, Politik.
Band 33. LIT Verlag: MnsterHamburg
London.
Shleifer A., Treisman D. 2000. Without a Map:
Political Tactics and Economic Reform in
Russia. MIT Press: Cambridge.
Woodruff D. M. 2003. Property Rights in Con"
text: Privatizations Legacy for Corporate
Legality in Poland and Russia. Mimeo,
MIT.
Yakovlev A. 1993. Commodity exchanges and
the Russian government. RFE/RL Research
Report (45): 2428.
Yakovlev A. 2001. Black cash tax evasion
in Russia: Its forms, incentives and conse
quences at firm level. Europe"Asia Studies
53 (1): 3355.
Yakovlev A. 2004. Evolution of corporate
governance in Russia: Governmental policy
vs. real incentives of economic agents. Post"
Communist Economies 16 (4): 387403.
17 2005 .