Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Ashleigh Larkin
Abstract
Student mental health issues and suicides are growing at an alarming rate. The research proves
that it is time for politicians and educational leaders to act in order to create policy that will work
towards solving the issue. Three main solutions are presented within this paper, including suicide
prevention training for school personnel, connecting schools to outside mental health agencies,
and implementing small group counseling techniques in schools. While all solutions are viable
options, the main solution advocated for is mandating mental health awareness trainings and
suicide prevention programs for all school personnel. These types of programs are most
cost-effective and provide the greatest impact. By establishing a mandate and hortatory policy
implementation approach, school leaders and politicians will ensure that the needs of students
suffering from mental health issues are met. Once a mandate is created, schools will follow the
mobilizing, adopting, and institutionalizing steps of policy implementation in order to meet the
needs of all students. Politicians and educational leaders can no longer sit idly watching students
struggle with these issues- it is time to act, and the time is now.
MENTAL HEALTH AWARENESS AND SUICIDE PREVENTION IN SCHOOLS 3
Introduction
Despite the fact that mental health issues have grown in recent years, the stigma that
surrounds these problems still remains. Mental health issues have been at the forefront of many
tragic events that have occurred in our recent history. In addition to the rise of mental health
problems, suicide rates in the United States have also increased. According to the American
Foundation for Suicide Prevention (2015), suicide is the 10th leading cause of death in the
United States and each year 44,193 individuals die by suicide (p. 1). This national problem has
trickled down into our nations schools and has recently been referred to as a silent epidemic
(Anderson & Cardoza, 2016). Teen mental health issues and suicide is a growing health concern.
The American Psychological Association (2017) states that suicide is the third-leading cause of
death for young people ages 15 to 24, surpassed only by homicide and accidents. Coupled with
the fact that mental illness is the leading risk factor for suicide, it is clear to see how the
connection between these two issues is prominent and is dramatically affecting our youth.
Despite the idea of the rise in student mental health issues being a silent epidemic, it is
no secret to many in education that student mental health issues and the number of teen suicides
due to these issues are growing. The CDC has reported that one in five children living in the
United States show signs or symptoms of mental health disorders in a given year (Anderson and
Cardoza, 2016). Many school social workers, psychologists, and counselors at the high school
level have reported an increase in student mental health issues in the last five years. Sommer
Yono, school social worker at West Bloomfield High School agrees by stating, student mental
MENTAL HEALTH AWARENESS AND SUICIDE PREVENTION IN SCHOOLS 4
health has become a problem and we need to address it. Many students are feeling overwhelmed,
hopeless and anxious due to the pressures that society has placed on them in regards to their
post-high school plans, social media and technology, as well as peer interactions (S. Yono,
Despite the fact that these issues are becoming well-known, approximately 80 percent of
these children will not get the help that they need. Anderson and Cardoza (2016), explain that
this is a role that schools are not prepared for (p.1). Many schools lack the resources necessary in
getting these students the help that they need and deserve. The reality is that the stigma
associated with mental health is wide, the idea that students can just get over it is present, our
teachers, counselors, and administrators have a great deal on their plates in relation to managing
the day to day operations within a school. With more research being done and the findings
clearly showing that student mental health problems and suicide are an increasing problem, it is
time for political leaders and leaders in education to step up and challenge the status quo.
Throughout the past ten years, the research on mental health issues and related suicides
has increased. This research has the ability to provide political leaders and educators with the
understanding of how prominent the issues have become. When looking at the research, it is
evident that the mental wellbeing of our students has been impacted by a variety of issues.
According to Schrobsdorff (2016), anxiety and depression in high school students have been on
the rise since 2012 after several years of stability. This is a phenomenon that cuts across all
demographics--suburban, urban and rural; those who are college bound and those who are not.
MENTAL HEALTH AWARENESS AND SUICIDE PREVENTION IN SCHOOLS 5
Teens in our present day have grown up in a world riddled with fear based on economic
recession, mass gun violence, and high stakes. In particular, research shows that student mental
1. 6.2 million teens have an anxiety disorder. These anxiety disorders and mental health
2. Many statistics that are currently available may not be accurate due to the fact that many
individuals do not report or seek help for mental health related issues.
3. The role of technology and social media has played a part in student mental health issues.
While students are now more connected than ever before, they must also keep up with the
4. School pressures play a large role in student mental health. With a difficult college
application process, high expectations, and competition between peers, students can
5. There is less time available for school personnel and less financial resources being
6. Bullying in schools has increased between peers. Bullying can cause mental health problems
and/or young people may experience bullying because of their mental health issues (Fekkes,
The research shows that our students are dealing with a variety of issues that impact their
mental wellbeing. Increased anxiety, low reporting, technology, school pressures, less time and
resources in schools, and bullying between peers have all contributed to the rise in mental health
disorders and student suicides. This problem can be directly related to the democratic values of
MENTAL HEALTH AWARENESS AND SUICIDE PREVENTION IN SCHOOLS 6
our nation. In particular it is related to the idea of common good, which is described as when we
are all "working together for the greater benefit of everyone in our community" (Alvaro &
Vredevoogd, 2001). In order to promote the common good, it is our job as educators to work
with politicians in order to provide our students with equal access to education and services that
will support their needs. This problem impacts a diverse population and it is up to our
government at the national, state, and local level to provide students with the best support
possible.
While it is evident that educators and politicians must work towards solving the mental
health crisis, there are many different professional opinions on how to tackle this issue and solve
the problem. There are three well known approaches to solving the problem, which include
professional development and suicide prevention program training for school personnel,
developing community relationships between outside mental health agencies and schools, and
establishing small group counseling resources for students. Each of these solutions offer a
strategic way to think about combating the silent epidemic in our schools.
One of the most prominent approaches to solving the mental health crisis is prevention
training for school personnel. This approach is promoted by several mental health organizations,
such as the American Foundation for Suicide Prevention and the National Association of School
Psychologists. School staff must be trained in recognizing mental health issues and intervening
when necessary. A system wide policy increases the chances that students will receive needed
support and assistance. Intervention and prevention training should be taught in schools
MENTAL HEALTH AWARENESS AND SUICIDE PREVENTION IN SCHOOLS 7
(LivingWorks Education, 2015). This approach to solving the problem is widely regarded as the
best solution by many professional organizations. In order to these types of trainings to occur,
each state should require mandatory professional development for all school personnel in regards
between mental health organizations and schools. Being able to build connections with these
organizations in order to provide schools with desperately needed resources is key. At this
present time, many schools have cut counselor and social work positions due to a decrease in
funding. In this case, partnering with community organizations to establish resources for students
is imperative to solving the issue. Schools should start by creating a referral list of licensed
professionals for students and invite members from community organizations to the buildings for
roundtable discussions. Ongoing collaboration will need to occur in order to sustain a program of
A final solution to be considered is small group counseling and methods used by school
counseling staff for students. In this solution, students would take charge of their own issues and
would be allowed to participate in small group therapy sessions with other individuals. The
Missouri Department of Education explains that Small group counseling provides students with
assistance to improve skills in the areas of personal/social, academic and career development.
Working with students in small groups is one strategy for helping students become more
successful (Missouri Center for Education, 2015). Small group counseling could provide a
Taking the approach of training school personnel in awareness and suicide prevention
MENTAL HEALTH AWARENESS AND SUICIDE PREVENTION IN SCHOOLS 8
programs, connecting schools to outside mental health agencies, and small group counseling
strategies for students are all positive approaches towards creating a solution in regards to the
student mental health crisis. There are several major actors and coalitions that have been
advocating for each of the different solutions. Each of these agents have the ability to positively
When looking at potential solutions for solving the student mental health and suicide
crisis, there are several major agents of change that are advocating for a variety of approaches.
Ninety percent of young people who die by suicide have a mental health condition at the time of
their deaths, although often these conditions are untreated, under-treated, or undiagnosed
(American Foundation for Suicide Prevention, 2016). One of the first steps in preventing suicide
The National Strategy for Suicide Prevention (NSSP) has created several goals to involve
individuals in suicide prevention. Specifically, Goal 7 of the revised NSSP is to Provide training
to community and clinical service providers on the prevention of suicide and related behaviors
(U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, 2012). The NSSP organization advocates for
the first solution of school personnel being trained on how to address suicidal thoughts and how
to respond to those that have been affected by suicide. The organization also believes that suicide
prevention should be integrated into the values, culture, leadership, and work of educational
institutions. Schools must be able to intervene and must also know how to deal with mental
The National Association of School Psychologists also play a key role in advocating for
MENTAL HEALTH AWARENESS AND SUICIDE PREVENTION IN SCHOOLS 9
student mental health and suicide awareness. Overall, the NASP takes on the second potential
solution that is advocated for in the form of connecting schools to outside mental health
organizations. NASP argues for more informed and effective decision making when dealing with
mental health issues. The NASP has made four recommendations for improvements for school
and community mental health services. The first solution is to offer a continuum of school and
community mental health supports (Brock & Brant, 2015). Schools need to provide multi-tiered
systems of support and should positively promote mental health and wellness. One of the
arguments of the NASP in particular is to offer mental health screenings to students. The second
recommendation is to broaden mental health supports beyond special education. Many students
who experience mental health issues do not meet the criteria for a 504 plan or IEP and in
accordance, schools must find ways to extend these supports to the general education population.
The third recommendation is to improve collaboration efforts by schools and community mental
health organizations. Brock and Brant state that, Steps toward building effective partnerships
professionals, conducting an assessment of needs and existing resources, clarifying roles and
problem-solving and evaluation. Finally, the NASP advocates for empowering families to
manage the decisions and resources they need to meet their students mental health issues.
Involving the parents and respecting their rights, while helping them advocate for their student is
A final organization that advocates for the third solution, small group counseling, is the
American Foundation for Suicide Prevention (AFSP). AFSP is the national leading nonprofit for
MENTAL HEALTH AWARENESS AND SUICIDE PREVENTION IN SCHOOLS 10
understanding and preventing suicide through research, advocacy, and to reaching out to people
with mental disorders and those impacted by suicide (American Foundation for Suicide
Prevention, 2011). One of the solutions that this organization advocates for is small group
counseling. The AFSP states, wherever possible, group meetings should follow a structured
outline, keep to a time limit, and provide each student with an opportunity to speak. The
meetings should focus on helping students identify and express their feelings and discuss
practical coping strategies. These group meetings could provide students with a safe place to
Finally, the Michigan Board of Education has also advocated for student mental health
issues by creating a policy on integrating mental health in schools. In 2003, the state board of
education adopted the Policy on Coordinated School Health Programs to Support Academic
Achievement and Healthy schools (Michigan Department of Education, 2016). This policy
creates a structure to improve classroom environments, school culture and climate, and address
student behavior, including behavior impacted by mental health. The Michigan Department of
Education has also created a mental health toolkit for schools and provides many
recommendations for dealing with mental health issues. While there have been no formal
legislation efforts beyond this in connection to student mental health and suicide in Michigan,
In addition to the major coalitions advocating for solutions, there have also been several
policies developed in different states across the country. According to the American Foundation
for Suicide Prevention there are currently ten states that mandate annual suicide prevention
training for school personnel (2016, p. 3). In eight of the ten states, this mandate is titled the
MENTAL HEALTH AWARENESS AND SUICIDE PREVENTION IN SCHOOLS 11
Jason Flatt Act. Michigan is not currently one of the ten states to mandate this training for school
employees. In addition, there are seventeen states that require mandated training, but do not
require it annually. Again, Michigan is not one of these states. Although it is not currently
mandatory in Michigan, the state does encourage suicide prevention training, meaning that it can
While each of these organizations and created policies have had an impact on student
mental health and wellbeing, the three solutions that are being advocated for have not fully been
implemented. Taking on one of the approaches would ensure that student needs are being
addressed.
It is clear that student mental health has become a growing concern in education. While
the statistics clearly show that mental health issues and student suicide prevention must be acted
upon, many school systems are still unsure of how to implement these changes to their
environments. The three solutions that have been popularly advocated for are suicide prevention
programs and professional development for school personnel, building connections with outside
community mental health agencies, and small group counseling efforts. Each of the solutions
have been advocated for through mental health organizations and policy adoptions. Although
each solution in itself is beneficial, a combination of these solutions would ensure that schools
are effectively tackling the mental health and suicide crisis within schools. Due to a lack of
funding for many of these programs and difficulty in getting different solutions off the ground,
the recommended course of action for solving this issue at the state and local level is to
MENTAL HEALTH AWARENESS AND SUICIDE PREVENTION IN SCHOOLS 12
implement mandatory suicide prevention programs and professional development training for
school personnel.
Creating mandatory prevention programs in schools is the most logical solution for
solving the mental health and suicide crisis that is currently plaguing our schools. Critics of
implementing these types of programs in schools suggest that suicide prevention programs may
be too costly. Leenaars and Wenckstern (2007) state that prevention was chosen because it is
generally agreed that this is the most cost-efficient and potentially constructive avenue (although
(p. 299). With school funding being a challenge for many school districts, prevention plans offer
the most feasible method to combat the problem. This is due to the fact that there are several free
prevention and training programs in existence and schools would be able to have a choice in
which programs they use. For example, Michigan currently has free resources for school
programs could be the most effective route for schools in terms of autonomy and ease of
implementation. Schools would be able to choose their preferred method of prevention programs
problem and to advocate for those affected. A number of suicidologists have outlined additional
2. building a working relationship between mental health experts and school personnel and
students
4. demonstrating that mental health experts are approachable, caring, and professional
The reason that prevention programs are the best choice for schools is due to the
all-encompassing nature, as described above. Mandating prevention programs for all schools
In establishing prevention programs, teachers and school personnel, must be at the front
lines of the fight. Hazel (1995) explains that schools should be cautious when implementing
suicide prevention programs due to the fact that there is research to suggest that some individuals
exposed to programs will show a deterioration in attitudes. Much of the research on this topic
describes implementing these types of training with students. Furthermore, there is no major
research to suggest that talking about suicide will increase the amount of suicides in schools
(suicide prevention policies, p. 10). In this case, the solution being advocated for is training for
all school personnel in the building. School personnel must be trained in suicide prevention
training, so that they are able to identify the issues before they occur. Lillian M. Range supports
this argument in Suicide Prevention: Guidelines for Schools (Range, 1993). Range (1993)
describes the importance of prevention programs for teachers and administrators and how to
effectively implement the programs. Suicide prevention programs will train school personnel to
identify students that are at risk, to ask those students pertinent questions in order to gain an
understanding of their mental state, as well as provide them with a course of action in next steps
MENTAL HEALTH AWARENESS AND SUICIDE PREVENTION IN SCHOOLS 14
these programs and the reduced financial burden should allow schools to build these programs
into their systems. Many suicide prevention programs already exist that can provide schools with
the necessary resources needed to combat the problem. One program in particular is the
Adolescent Suicide Awareness Program. The ASAP offers a curriculum based approach to
suicide prevention for schools. The key areas of information provided in the curriculum focus on
the following: the warning signs, the facts of adolescent suicide, what depression looks like in
teens, the causes of self-destructive behavior in adolescents, what educators can do the help, and
where professional help can be provided within the community (Ryerson, 1990, p. 375). In
addition to the curriculum, the ASAP training provides an educator's seminar, a student
Overall, schools should adopt yearly prevention program training for all school personnel
in regards to mental health issues and suicide. This training is the most cost-effective and
informative. It will allow staff members to recognize the warning signs and save the lives of
While many states are getting on board and implementing prevention programs of their
own, it is not mandated across the country. Currently, the Michigan Department of Education has
created the Integrating Mental Health in Schools Toolkit, a free resource that provides no-cost
techniques for schools. In addition the state board of education recommends that each Michigan
school develop socially and emotionally healthy schools by implementing universal prevention
MENTAL HEALTH AWARENESS AND SUICIDE PREVENTION IN SCHOOLS 15
programs (Michigan Department of Education, 2016, p. 3). Although it is promising that the
state board of education in Michigan recommends that schools implement these policies, it is not
mandated. Prevention programs must be mandated in Michigan schools as required programs for
school personnel in order to tackle student mental health issues and the increase in suicides that
currently exist.
Policy Instruments
McDonnell and Elmore (1987) argue that four alternative policy instruments, or
mechanisms [exist] that translate substantive policy goalsinto concrete actions (p. 134).
The first policy instrument that will be used to implement the suicide prevention programs in
schools and training for school personnel are mandates. Developing a mandate in this case would
develop language that would require schools to implement suicide prevention programs, as well
as a possible penalty for not doing so. The state boards of education, along with state politicians,
must draft legislation that would require school districts to implement annual prevention training.
the government that these goals and actions need to be considered a high priority. This approach
would appeal to the values to those in educational policy and would allow for individuals to
target the population that is most likely to act on the information (p. 398). In regards to student
mental health and suicide prevention programs, government officials must understand the dire
Combining a mandate and hortatory policy instrument provides the best approach for
policy implementation. Creating a mandate in which all schools in Michigan, and perhaps across
the nation, have to create mandatory suicide prevention training programs for school personnel
MENTAL HEALTH AWARENESS AND SUICIDE PREVENTION IN SCHOOLS 16
would be the first step in ensuring steps towards solving the problem. Appealing to the values of
those in educational policy and targeting the individuals most likely to act on this is also key.
Using the hortatory approach will communicate the dire need for policy implementation in
Implementation
The time to implement suicide prevention programs and school personnel professional
development is now. The current statistics on suicide in adolescents proves that educational
policy leaders cannot sit idly and must take a course of action in implementing mandatory
programs for schools. Prevention programs are the best possible solution because they are the
most cost-effective and will help school employees in identifying the warning signs of mental
health issues and suicides. There are three major steps to implementation that must occur in order
The mobilization step to policy implementation may be most critical. In this step, data
will be collected, necessary resources will be determined, and the planning will begin. A group
of individuals will develop a firm understanding of the motives behind the adoption of the new
policy, as well as the implications for the school district. Educational leaders and politicians will
ask critical questions, such as whether the mandated policy and selected training program will fit
the values of the community and whether the policy is consistent with the priorities and needs of
the school district (Fowler, 2013, p. 80). In this step, resources will also be gathered.
Following the mobilization stage, policies will be created and tested at the local level in
the adopting stage. This is the early stage of implementation in which the measure of success of
the program will be determined. In this stage, school districts will follow the mandate created by
MENTAL HEALTH AWARENESS AND SUICIDE PREVENTION IN SCHOOLS 17
local and state governments to implement suicide prevention programs. Each school district will
select the policy that they believe best fits their environment from a provided list of resources. It
is important for school leaders to provide a combination of pressure and support throughout this
stage in order to see the programs carried out at the local level.
innovation has been incorporated into the organization (Fowler, 2013). Policy advocates are
working to move the necessary components forward. Institutionalizing the policy will mean that
suicide prevention programs become a norm of school culture and are mandatory for positive
school culture. In the institutionalization phase of implementation, leaders will assess the degree
of policy implementation by making sure the policy is included in the school board manual, as
well as the master contract, and that necessary training is described in a handbook and budgetary
requirements of the program are included in the general budget (p. 293). Once the policy has
effectiveness. Educational leaders and politicians must work to implement annual suicide
prevention training programs for school personnel in all schools in order to aggressively address
Conclusion
Suicide prevention programs and professional development for school personnel are
necessary in order to combat the student mental health and suicide crisis currently plaguing our
schools. These programs are the most cost-effective, comprehensive, and easily implemented
solutions available. It is proven that establishing a system-wide policy will allow students to
receive the support that they need. While some may argue that suicide prevention programs have
MENTAL HEALTH AWARENESS AND SUICIDE PREVENTION IN SCHOOLS 18
their pitfalls, the absolute urgency in helping our students outweighs the cost. Educational policy
leaders and school officials must follow the mobilizing, adopting, and institutionalized steps to
policy implementation in order to create safe school environments for the youth of America.
References
MENTAL HEALTH AWARENESS AND SUICIDE PREVENTION IN SCHOOLS 19
Alvaro, J., & Vredevoogd, K. (2001). The Core Democratic Values. Retrieved from
http://www.macomb.k12.mi.us/cc/cdv/cdv.htm
American Foundation for Suicide Prevention. (2016, August) State Laws: Suicide Prevention in
American Foundation for Suicide Prevention and Suicide Prevention Resource Center. 2011.
After a Suicide: A Toolkit for Schools. Newton, MA: Education Development Center,
Inc.
Anderson, M., & Cardoza, K. (2016, August 31). Mental Health In Schools: A Hidden Crisis
Brock, S., & Brandt, T. (2015). Four Ways to Improve Student Mental Health Support.
Education Week.
Fowler, F. C. (2013). Policy studies for educational leaders: An introduction. Upper Saddle
Hazell, P., & King, R. (1996). Arguments for and against teaching suicide prevention in schools.
Fekkes, M., Pijpers, FI., & Verloove-Vanhorick, SP. (2005). Bullying: Who does what, when
and where? Involvement of children, teachers and parents in bullying behaviour. Health
Hamlet, H. & Redekop, F. (2010). Connecting schools with mental health resources. Counseling
https://ct.counseling.org/2010/03/connecting-schools-with-community-mental-
health-resources/
Leenaars, A., & Wenckstern, S. (1990). Suicide prevention in schools: An introduction. Death
McDonnell, L. M. & Elmore, R. F. (1987). Getting the Job Done: Alternative Policy Instruments.
Michigan Department of Education. (2016). Michigan state policy on integrating mental health
in schools.
Michigan State Board of Education Policy on Integrating Mental Health in Schools. 2016.
Retreived from
https://www.michigan.gov/documents/mde/MHPolicy-SBE_FINAL_310961_7.pdf
Missouri Department for Elementary and Secondary Education. Professional School Counselor
http://www.missouricareereducation.org/doc/
smallgroup/SmallGroupCounseling.pdf
Range, L. (1993). Suicide prevention: Guidelines for schools. Educational Psychology Review,
5(2), 135-154.
Ryerson, D. (1990). Suicide awareness education in schools: The development of a core program
14(4), 371-390.
Schrobsdorff, S. (2016, October 27). Teen Depression and Anxiety: Why the Kids Are Not
Alright. TIME.
Schrobsdorff, S. (2016, November 15). There's a Startling Increase in Major Depression Among
Whitney, Renner, Pate, & Jacobs. (2011). Principals' perceptions of benefits and barriers to
school-based suicide prevention programs. Children and Youth Services Review, 33(6),
869-877.
U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) Office of the Surgeon General and
National Action Alliance for Suicide Prevention. 2012 National Strategy for Suicide
Prevention: Goals and Objectives for Action. Washington, DC: HHS, September 2012.