You are on page 1of 7

ARTICLE IN PRESS

Phytomedicine 16 (2009) 683689


www.elsevier.de/phymed

Clinical observation of Danhong Injection (herbal TCM product from


Radix Salviae miltiorrhizae and Flos Carthami tinctorii) in the treatment
of traumatic intracranial hematoma
M. Suna, J.-J. Zhangb, J.-Z. Shana,, H. Zhangc, C.-Y. Jina, S. Xua, Y.-L. Wanga
a
Department of Traditional Chinese Medicine, Second Affiliated Hospital Zhejiang University College of Medicine, Hangzhou,
Zhejiang 310009, PR China
b
Chinese Journal of Integrative Medicine Press, Beijing 100091, PR China
c
Department of Neurosurgery, Second Affiliated Hospital Zhejiang University College of Medicine, Hangzhou,
Zhejiang 310009, PR China

Abstract
Danhong Injection (DHI), a Chinese Materia Medica standardized product extracted from Radix Salviae
Miltiorrhizae and Flos Carthami tinctorii, has the actions of promoting blood circulation and resolving stasis to
promote regeneration. The clinical therapeutic effects of DHI on traumatic intracranial hematoma (TICH) were
observed. Eighty patients with TICH were randomly assigned to trial group and a control group (40 patients per
group), and all were administered with routine medication. Additionally, DIH was administered intravenously to
patients in the trial group. Pre and post-treatment GCS was observed in the two groups, along with GOS after therapy.
The intracranial hematoma absorption, hemorheological changes, and changes in coagulation indexes pre- and post-
treatment were evaluated. The results indicated that GCS and GOS after therapy for the trial group were superior to
those for the control group (po0.05). There was a signicant post-treatment difference in the intracranial hematoma
absorption between the two groups (po0.01). Each hemorheological index in the trial group improved signicantly as
compared with that of the control group (po0.05 or po0.01). The plasma levels of brinogen and D-dimer in the trial
group were signicantly decreased after therapy (po0.01). These results suggest that DHI is conducive to the recovery
of patients with TICH.
r 2009 Elsevier GmbH. All rights reserved.

Keywords: Danhong injection (Salvia miltiorrhiza; Carthamus tinctorius); Traumatic intracranial hematoma; Clinical observation;
Hemorheology; Coagulation function

Introduction Its incidence has increased along with the increased use
of motor vehicles, along with higher fatality and
Traumatic intracranial hematoma (TICH) is a com- deformity rates (Holm et al. 2005). Brain tissue injury
mon severe encephalopathy secondary to brain injury. and intracranial hematoma after brain injury may
induce brain edema and increased intracranial pressure.
Corresponding author. Tel./fax: +86 571 51216168. Cerebral blood ow may decrease, resulting in the
E-mail addresses: shan6666@yahoo.cn, contraction of vessels all over the body, contraction of
shan6666@sina.com (J.-Z. Shan). local cerebral vessels and disorders of cerebral blood

0944-7113/$ - see front matter r 2009 Elsevier GmbH. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.phymed.2009.03.020
ARTICLE IN PRESS
684 M. Sun et al. / Phytomedicine 16 (2009) 683689

circulation, including cerebral capillary spasm, increased Materials and methods


vasopermeability, hemorheological changes (Daniel et al.
1997). These factors may further accelerate cerebral Subjects
ischemia and hypoxia, thus further aggravating the
edema of injured brain tissue. Cerebral edema is the Eighty patients with TICH at the Second Hospital
most signicant secondary pathological lesion after afliated to Zhejiang University from Dec 2005 to
brain injury. Therefore, reducing cerebral edema and Mar 2008 participated in the study. The causes for
improving cerebral microcirculation disturbance are TICH ranged from trafc accident injury to falling from
of great signicance for the treatment of brain injury higher places, to being hit. The patients were randomly
(Cao et al. 2002). assigned to the two groups upon admission to the
The diagnosis rate of TICH has improved greatly with hospital. The patients met the diagnostic criteria of mild
the use of computed tomography (CT) and Magnetic and moderate TICH (Wang 2005), as follows: those who
resonance imaging (MRI). These also provide reliable were admitted within 24 hours after a cerebral injury
scientic evidence for clinical tracing, observation, and conrmed by CT; with an intracranial hemorrhage
absorption judgment of small and moderate-sized hema- volume between 10 and 40 ml; with no continuously
tomas in nonsurgical treatment. Symptomatic treatments enlarged hematoma after consecutive head CT exam-
such as dehydration therapy to reduce cranial pressure, inations within 3 days, but not scheduled for surgery;
pain relief, and so on are often adopted in neurosurgery aged between 16 and 65 years; and all with Glasgow
for those having small and moderate-sized, non-life- coma score (GCS) greater than 8 (Teasdale and Jennett
threatening hematomas. The therapeutic course is rather 1974). Exclusion criteria were: severe cardio-/cerebral
longer, but the clinical results obtained are not satisfac- vascular diseases; liver or renal diseases; diabetes
tory (Li et al. 2003). However, TICH treated with mellitus; other severe organ injuries; coagulation dis-
additional Chinese materia medica in the early phase orders; obviously enlarged hematoma conrmed by
may result in satisfactory therapeutic effects with im- head CT and/or aggravated symptoms indicating a need
proved safety (Liu et al. 2007; Chen and Shao 2005). for surgery. Written informed consent was obtained
Danhong Injection (DHI), a Chinese materia medica from each subject after the nature, purpose and
standardized product extracted from the herbal Radix potential risks of the study had been explained.
Salviae Miltiorrhizae and Flos Carthami, promotes
blood circulation and resolves stasis, and removes stasis
to promote regeneration. Its main components include Preparation of Danhong Injection
tanshinone, tanshinol acid, safor yellow, etc. Pharma-
cological studies show that Radix Salviae miltiorrhizae DHI is manufactured by Shandong Buchang Phar-
extract dilates cerebral arteries, lowers vascular resis- macy Co. Ltd. The raw materials of danshen root and
tance and blood viscosity, and enhances erythrocyte safower were from a standard medicinal herbs resource
deformability; it also can clear oxygen free radicals, base established by Buchang Pharmacy. The two core
antagonize the inow of calcium ions, and improve the technologies adopted were ultra-high speed centrifugal
activities of adenosine triphosphatase. Meanwhile, it separation and membrane separation in the manufac-
may also improve the anti-hypoxia capacities of brain turing technology. Quantities of 750 g danshen root and
tissue and exhibit protection of brain tissue (Tai et al. 250 g safower were boiled twice with 1000 ml water
2005). The avanoid Safor yellow is one of the main added, for 1 h each time. The decoction was combined,
compounds in Flos Carthami, with pharmacological ltered, claried after cold storage, and then ltered. A
activities including vasodilation, antioxidation, protect- suitable amount of gelatin was added to the ltrate, and
ing cardiac muscle and brain from injury, decreasing the ltrate was cold stored and ltered. The ltrate was
blood pressure, and suppressing immune function. concentrated to the relative density of 1.10-1.20, and
Flos Carthami extract in vivo and in vitro clearly alcohol was added to the raise alcohol content to more
inhibits platelet aggregation, shows certain inhibition than 80%. The ltrate was then cold stored and ltered,
of the activation of the intrinsic coagulation system, with the pH value readjusted. Following cold storage,
and plays a role in increasing the blood ow of cerebral the alcohol was recovered from the ltrate till it had no
arteries and nourishing brain cells (Xin et al. 2004). alcohol taste, water was added to achieve a volume of
DHI has shown signicant therapeutic effect when 1000 ml, then the ltrate was cold stored. The ltrate
applied extensively to the treatment of TICH in the was ltered once more, with water added to the ruled
authors hospital. Therefore, the aim of this clinical volume, subpackaged and sterilized. Thus the DHI was
study was to observe the short- and long-term ther- obtained. HPLC ngerprint analysis (Fig. 1) shows that
apeutic effects of DHI in the treatment of acute TICH, the total amount of danshensu sodium and Protocate-
and to explore its possible mechanisms using hemor- chuic Aldehyde was 1.5 mg/ml, containing 11 mg/ml
heological indexes. safor yellow.
ARTICLE IN PRESS
M. Sun et al. / Phytomedicine 16 (2009) 683689 685

VWD1 A, Wavelength = 288 nm (DANHONG\04041205.D)

70

60

50

40 12
mAU

30 8 14
20 3
2 5 10
10 1 4 67 9 11 13
0

0 10 20 30 40 50
min

Fig. 1. HPLC-ngerprint analysis of Danhong injection provided by Shangdong Buchang Pharmacy Co. Ltd. (1) Protocatechuic
aldehyde, (2) protocatechuic acid, (S) danshensu sodium (Hydroxy-dihydro-caffeic acid), (4) safor yellow A, (6) salvianolic acid B,
(13) Quercetin.

Performance of HPLC-ngerprint analysis of intracranial hemorrhage volume between the two groups
Danhong Injection (Fig. 1) were not statistically signicant. Routine Western
medical therapies, including dehydration, cranial pres-
HPLC-analysis was performed using an LC-system sure lowering, infection prevention and treatment with
consisting of an HP Agilent 1100 series quaternary antibiotics, brain cell nourishment, stress ulcer preven-
pump with a degasser and photodiode array detector. tion and treatment were applied to both groups. Other
The samples were injected to an HP Agilent 1100 hemostasis and symptomatic therapies were also used if
Autosampler with thermostated column compartment necessary. DHI, a standard extract injection of Shan-
(Temp. 30 1C) with Diamonsil ODS C18 column (5 mm, dong Buchang Pharmaceutical Co. Ltd. (10 ml each,
200 mm, 4.6 mm). Detection wavelength was 288 nm containing Radix Salviae Miltiorrhizae 7.5 mg and Flos
and ow rate 1.2 ml/min. Mobile phase: acetonitrile- Carthami 2.5, mg respectively), 30 ml in 250 ml normal
o-phosphoric acid (0.026%). saline was additionally administered intravenously to
Gradient elution ratio was: patients in the trial group, once daily for 7 days as one
therapeutic course, for 2 successive courses.
0 min: acetonitrile 2, o-phosphoric acid 98
30 min: acetonitrile 22, o-phosphoric acid 78
60 min: acetonitrile 26, o-phosphoric acid 74 Glasgow coma score (GCS) and Glasgow outcome
score (GOS)

Each patient was scored by a specically appointed


Study design
person according to GCS (Jennett et al. 1981) and GOS
pre-treatment and on the 14th day of the therapy. The
This study was a random clinical study, which
short-term efcacies of treatment in the two groups were
was approved by the Medical Ethics Committee. The
judged according to GCS (Philipp et al. 2008) and the
patients were randomly assigned to two groups of
intracranial hemorrhage volume. The long-term efca-
40 each. In the trial group, there were 31 males and
cies of treatment in the two groups were evaluated
9 females, aged 1664 years, 38.23714.25 years on
according to GOS: (1: death; 2: persistent vegetative
average; among them were 13 cases of epidural
state; 3: severe disability; 4: moderate disability; 5: good
hematoma, 10 of subdural hematoma, 10 of TICH,
recovery). 3 months post-treatment was set as the
and 7 of multiple hematoma. The average intracranial
evaluation time.
hemorrhage had a volume of (28.2377.89) ml. There
were 32 males and 8 females in the control group,
aged 1765 years, 38.58712.79 years on average; Detection of hemorheological indexes
among them were 12 cases of epidural hematoma, 12
of subdural hematoma, 11 of TICH, and 5 of multiple Blood samples were collected according to routine
hematoma. The average intracranial hemorrhage had clinical protocol. Venous blood was withdrawn pre-
a volume of (27.2878.84) ml. Differences in age and treatment and on the 14th day of the therapy to detect
ARTICLE IN PRESS
686 M. Sun et al. / Phytomedicine 16 (2009) 683689

the hemorheological indexes of the two groups, using an Results


automatic analyzer (Zhongchiweiye, ZL9000 plus),
including whole blood viscosity (1 S 1, 5 S 1, 30 S 1, Effect on GCS
and 200 S 1), plasma viscosity, and erythrocyte aggre-
gation index. The equipment was operated according Table 1 showed signicant difference in GCS of the
to the protocols by the technicians at the Department trial group between pre- and post-treatment (po0.01);
of clinical laboratory in Second Hospital afliated to and an obvious difference in GCS of the control group
Zhejiang University. between pre- and post-treatment (po0.05). The post-
treatment score of the trial group was clearly higher
Coagulation detection than that of the control group, with signicant
difference (po0.01).
5 ml venous blood was withdrawn pre-treatment and
on the 14th day of the therapy to detect prothrombin Comparison of hemorheological indexes in the two
time (PT), PT international normalized ratio (INR), groups pre- and post-treatment
activated partial thromboplatin time (APTT), thrombin
time (TT), brinogen (Fbg), D-dimer (DD). The Table 2 showed that each hemorheological index in
equipment was operated according to the protocols the two groups pre-treatment increased with no
by the technicians at the Department of Tests (Sysmex signicant difference. There was signicant difference
CA-7000) in Second Hospital afliated to Zhejiang in the hemorheological indexes of the trial group pre-
University. and post-treatment (po0.01). There was obvious
difference in the hemorheological indexes of the control
Assess of intracranial hematoma volume group pre- and post-treatment (po0.05). The improve-
ment of each index in the trial group was obviously
The hematoma volume was calculated using Tadas superior to that in the control group with signicant
formula (Tada et al. 1981) according to head CT difference (po0.05 or po0.01).
(16-row spiral CT, Siemens). Head CT examinations
were conducted pre-treatment, on the 7th and 14th days Comparison of coagulation indexes in the two groups
post-treatment to ascertain the absorption of intracra- pre- and post-treatment
nial hematoma. The patient data of the two groups pre-
treatment showed no signicant difference (p40.05). Table 3 showed signicant difference in the brinogen
and D-dimer in the trial group between pre- and post-
Monitoring of adverse reaction treatment tests (po0.05). There was also a signicant
difference in the two indexes between the two groups
During the study, various side-effects (i.e. dizziness, post-treatment (po0.01). There was no signicant
cardiopalmus, fever, rash, et al.) were monitored. 5 ml difference in the rest of the indexes between the two
venous blood was withdrawn pre-treatment and on the groups pre- and post-treatment (p40.01).
14th day of the therapy to test the blood routine
(Beckman coulter LH9000), liver and renal functions Comparison of intracranial hematoma absorption in
(OLYMPUS AU4000) in the two groups pre- and post- the two groups pre- and post-treatment
treatment. The equipment was operated according to the
protocols by the technicians at the Department of Tests Fig. 2 shows that the post-treatment hematoma
in Second Hospital afliated to Zhejiang University. volume of the trial group was signicantly reduced
as compared with pre-treatment volume (po0.01).
Statistical analysis

All experimental data are presented as mean7 Table 1. Comparison of GCS score in the control and trial
standard deviation. A paired t-test was used for pre- groups (Score).
and post- treatment comparisons. An independent- Group Pre-treatment Post-treatment
samples t-test was used to compare the post-treatment
data between the trial group and the control group, Trial 9.9871.31 11.8870.97a,b
and a Chi-square test was taken for nonparametric data. Control 10.0371.23 11.1071.15c
All analyses were performed using the SPSS statistical a
po0.01, pre-treatment vs. post-treatment.
software package (version 16.0), and po0.05 was b
po0.01, trial group vs. control group of post-treatment.
considered statistically signicant. c
po0.05, pre-treatment vs. post-treatment.
ARTICLE IN PRESS
M. Sun et al. / Phytomedicine 16 (2009) 683689 687

Table 2. Comparison of hemorheological indexes in the two groups pre- and post-treatment.

Group Whole blood viscosity (mpa s) Plasma Viscosity Erythrocyte


(mpa s) aggregation
1 1 1 1
1S 5S 30 S 200 S

Trial
Pre-treatment 20.8671.14 9.1870.19 5.4870.19 4.2170.21 1.6270.67 7.4670.67
Post-treatment 17.6170.85a,b 7.1670.15a 4.8070.23a,b 3.5470.25a,c 1.3770.06a,b 5.3470.25a,b

Control
Pre-treatment 20.6571.21 9.1070.22 5.3670.24 4.2070.19 1.6070.11 6.8770.78
Post-treatment 19.8371.22d 8.5770.30d 4.9970.29d 3.9870.24d 1.4870.82d 5.9170.42d
a
po0.01, pre-treatment vs. post-treatment.
b
po0.05.
c
po0.01, compared with the control group post-treatment.
d
po0.05, pre-treatment vs. post-treatment, control group.

Table 3. Comparison of coagulation functions in the two groups pre- and post-treatment.

Group PT (s) INR APTT (s) TT (s) Fbg (g) DD (ug/l)

Trial
Pre-treatment 12.0370.42 1.0270.55 27.7877.01 15.7073.05 4.4870.59 240.327181.03
Post-treatment 12.0970.63 1.0870.44 28.1275.12 16.2175.51 3.8970.48a,b 189.207101.74a,b

Control
Pre-treatment 12.1070.81 1.0570.30 27.5377.15 15.3976.62 4.5670.67 230.087155.42
Post-treatment 12.0870.51 1.0470.52 27.4478.11 15.6275.37 4.2370.61 214.147144.62
a
po0.05, pre-treatment versus post-treatment.
b
po0.01, compared with the control group post-treatment. PT: prothrombin time; INR: international normalized ratio; APTT: activated partial
thromboplatin time; TT: thrombin time; Fbg: brinogen; DD: D-dimer.

Fig. 2. *po0.05, comparison of intracranial hematoma volume after 1 week and 2 weeks of treatment, vs. pre- and post-treatment.

The post-treatment hematoma volume of the control Comparison of GOS in the two groups pre- and post-
group was signicantly reduced as compared with pre- treatment
treatment volume (po0.05). There was a signicant
difference in the hematoma volume between the two The post-treatment GOS in the trial group was
groups post-treatment (po0.05). (4.4871.11), with total effective rate of 100%, while
ARTICLE IN PRESS
688 M. Sun et al. / Phytomedicine 16 (2009) 683689

that in the control group was (4.0270.91), with total According to the mechanism of action, the clinical
effective rate of 87.5%. There was signicant difference therapeutic efcacy of DHI was observed in this study.
in GOS between the two groups. GOS in the trial group Routine treatment of TICH in combination with DHI
was superior to that of the control group (po0.05). was proved able to promote the early absorption of
intracranial hematomas, shorten the course of disease,
and improve the prognosis. Its mechanism of action
Adverse reaction may be achieved by lowering whole blood viscosity and
brinogen content, promoting brolysis, and improving
No abnormal changes in blood routine examination, microcirculation. No obvious adverse reaction occurred
liver or renal functions were seen in all patients. Only during the whole therapeutic course. No abnormal
one patient reported a mild rash which resolved without intracranial hematoma expansion or rehemorrhage was
symptomatic therapy. Apart from this, no other obvious detected during the therapeutic course. No abnormality
adverse reaction occurred. was found in the dynamic observation of the patients
coagulation spectrum, indicating DHI was effective
and safe in treatment of TICH, with no possibility
of hemorrhage. These results indicate that DHI maybe
Discussion considered as an effective agent in the treatment of
TICH.
TICH belongs to the category of blood stasis in Brain injury requires comprehensive treatment. The
traditional Chinese medicine (TCM). When the brain importance of routine medicinal treatment cannot be
suffers from external force, its blood vessels are injured. ignored. Although our study indicates that DHI is
According to TCM theory, blood stasis may block effective in the treatment of TICH, further, randomized,
the upper orices, resulting in qi and blood disorders, double-blind and multi-centered studies are still neces-
which is basically in accordance with the recognition of sary to conrm our conclusions. Further studies are also
modern medicine (brain edema and cerebral circulation needed to verify its precise mechanism of action, the
disturbance are secondary to the compression of brain therapeutic dose and course, and opportunities for
tissue by hematoma). Extensive clinical application of medical use.
Chinese materia medica known to activate blood circu-
lation and resolve stasis can improve microcirculation,
eliminate toxic products, and attenuate cerebral edema, References
thus promoting the absorption of intracranial hemato-
ma and improving the functions of the nervous system Cao, M., Hou, Z.M., Yan, Y.S., et al., 2002. Clinical study
(You et al. 2003). of microcirculation alterations after brain injury. Chin. J.
DHI consists of the well known Chinese material Clin. Neurosurg. 7, 3638.
medica herbal Radix Salviae miltiorrhizae and Flos Chen, W., Shao, J., 2005. Clinical observation of Xuesaitong in
Carthami. As the principal agent, Radix Salviae treatment of severe brain injury. J. Emerg. Tradit. Chin.
miltiorrhizae (bitter taste) promotes blood circulation Med. 14, 443444.
and dissipates stasis; while as the assist agent, Flos Den, F., Hu, C.L., Xie, Y.L., 2006. Effect of Danghong
Injection on nitrioxide synthase in rats after local cerebral
Carthami (pungent taste) resolves blood stasis and
ischemia. Chin. J. Integr. Med. Cardio-/Cerebrovasc. Dis.
unblocks collaterals. The two herbs act in combination 4, 880881.
to promote blood stasis and unblock collaterals, Daniel, F.K., Neil, A.M., Rouzbeh, K., et al., 1997. Cerebral
removing stasis and regenerating with scientic compat- blood ow as a predictor of outcome following traumatic
ibility according to TCM theory. Some studies show brain injury. J. Neurosurg. 86, 633641.
that DHI plays a role in dilating vessels, clearing oxygen Holm, L., Cassidy, J.D., Carroll, L.J., et al., 2005. Summary
free radicals, and inhibiting lipid oxidization, and may of the WHO collaborating centre for neurotrauma task
protect blood vessel endothelium, improve microcircu- force on mild traumatic brain injury. J. Rehabil. Med. 37,
lation, anticoagulate, and inhibit thrombopoiesis (Jin 137141.
2003). DIH may lower the cerebral capillary perme- Jennett, B., Snoek, J., Bond, M.R., et al., 1981. Disability after
ability, cerebral index, and cerebral water content in rats severe brain injury: observations on the use of the Glasgow
Outcome Scale. J. Neurol. Neurosurg. Psychiat. 44,
with cerebral ischemia, thus attenuating brain edema
285293.
induced by brain ischemia (Zhang et al. 2007). DIH Jin, J.Z., 2003. Observation of the therapeutic effect of
may lower total and activities of nitric oxide synthase, Danhong Injection in treatment of bertebrobasilar arterial
thus reducing the production of nitrogen monoxide insufciency. Chin. J. Gerontol. 23, 839.
and attenuating tissue injury, showing signicant anti- Li, C., Liu, W.G., et al., 2003. Comparison of standard large
oxidative injury. It has a protective effect on brain cells craniotomy with routine craniotomy in treatment of acute
secondary to local cerebral ischemia (Den et al., 2006). subdural hematoma. Chin. J. Traumatol. 6, 305308.
ARTICLE IN PRESS
M. Sun et al. / Phytomedicine 16 (2009) 683689 689

Liu, Y.X., Gao, J.Z., Wang, G.W., et al., 2007. Clinical Wang, Z.C., 2005. Neurosurgery, vol. 26. Hubei Science and
observation of ligustrazine in early treatment of acute brain Technology Press, Wuhan, pp. 435436.
injury. Chin. J. Clin. Neurosurg. 12, 755. Xin, Q., Li, X.F., Si, D.Y., 2004. Protective effects of
Philipp, T., Hans, R.W., Jukka, T., Javier, F., 2008. Outcome Danshen Honghua Injection on experimental
after acute traumatic subdural and epidural haematoma in cerebral ischemia in rats. Chin. Tradit. Patent Med. 26,
Switzerland: a single-centre experience. Swiss Med. Wkly. 222224.
138, 281285. You, H.X., Qiu, J.D., Yang, W., et al., 2003. Clinical study of
Tada, A., Hisada, K., Suzuki, T., et al., 1981. Measurement ultra-early application of dongshen root injection in
volume of intracranial hematoma by computed tomogra- treatment of brain injury. Chin. J. Clin. Neurosurg. 8,
phy. No Shinkei Geka 9, 251256. 118119.
Tai, M.H., Liu, L.M., Ma, R.Q., 2005. General pharmacology Zhang, M.L., JIN, J.W., DU, X.F., 2007. Effects of Danhong
of Danhong Injection. J. First Mil. Med. Univ. 25, 335338. Injection on cerebral capillary permeability and cerebral
Teasdale, G., Jennett, B., 1974. Assessment of coma and impaired water content in the experimental rats with cerebral
consciousness. A practical scale. Lancet 7872, 8184. ischemia. Hebei Med. J. 29, 204205.

You might also like