Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Ashraf Owda
Ms. Moore
28 February 2017
Some murderers, rapists, and even child pedophiles are being let go free from prison
whilst only serving a shortened, lenient sentence. These some fall under juveniles, teens who
have committed a felony. For some reason, these teens deserve a second chance because they
didnt know the effect their adult crime would have. First of all, there is no such thing as an
adult crime, a crime is a crime and committing a crime means paying for it with time. Although
children are technically not adults, the enormity of their crimes is that of an adult's. Therefore,
they should be treated equally when it comes to them committing heinous crimes.
People ask, What if you were in their shoes? What if the rest of your life was taken away
from you? How would you feel? The same questions could also be said about the victims. What
if When people discuss this issue, they seem to forget that there are people who have been
personally affected, whod had their lives taken from them. Daniel Bartlam, 14, bludgeoned his
mother with a claw hammer, hitting her seven times. He then set her on fire, called the cops, and
lied by telling them a robber did it. He was charged with premeditated murder. How did the
mother feel during the act? It took Bartlam 7 hits to end her life while she was awake. How do
Some people believe that such harsh punishments shouldnt inflicted on minors, but how
old is thirteen to seventeen, and how much different is it from 18 and above? A seventeen year
old who shoots a school somehow deserves a chance to reform, but what if an eighteen year old
Owda 2
did the same? The fact that a one year age difference determiners a person's punishment is
ridiculous. Gail Garinger states that Brain imaging studies reveal that the regions of the
adolescent brain responsible for controlling thoughts, actions and emotions are not fully
developed. The changes that occur in a juvenile's brain is not drastic enough to dictate the fact
that they should not be treated equally in the eyes of the law, especially compared to an eighteen
year old who wouldve gotten the full fists of justice. Others argue that a teens upbringing affects
the way they deal with things, and is often used as an argument to defend child murderers. But
that isnt the case, many people have gone through worse things but have yet to commit rape or
murder.
The proper punishment of juveniles should be the same as that of an adult's. The enormity
of their crimes is not measured by their age, it should be measured by the crime itself. The brain
changes that teens go through is not a valid excuse for them to commit heinous crimes. Giving
them the opportunity to possibly undue their crimes could be a gateway for them to commit
crimes, knowing they could get out of it. Therefore, juvenile offenders should not be given
special treatment for committing crimes that an adult would otherwise pay for in full.
Work Cited
Owda 3
Guy, Fiona. Daniel Bartlam: A Teenage Boy Convicted Of His Mother's Murder. Crime
Traveller, Crime Traveller , 9 Feb. 2017, www.crimetraveller.org/2015/08/children-who-kill-
daniel-bartlam/. Accessed 28 Feb. 2017.