You are on page 1of 20

www.pwc.

com/sg

Building Digital
Trust
The confidence to
take risks

December 2013
Trust has become essential in the digital age. It must
underpin how you organise and run your business
so that you can be successful. With high profile
international debates on data privacy and security
its not difficult to see why.
Grant Waterfall, PwC Partner

2 Building Digital Trust The confidence to take risks


Contents
5 Our point of view
7 How to build digital trust the right way
8 Our Digital Trust Framework
20 Our experience

Building Digital Trust The confidence to take risks 3


The new trust dynamic:
Opportunity + Trust = Growth

By building trust you will be able to maximise your growth


potential and manage the risks in the opportunities available in
the digital age.

ust
eed for tr
The n

Opportunity

Social media Mobile Analytics Cloud Hyper-connectivity Digital identity Speed of change

The trust dynamic that the digital age unleashes is huge embrace it or miss the next
digital growth opportunity
The digital age is here. The potential Trust means your customers will with resilience built into your systems,
for you to be fast, agile and creative buy your products on-line. It means and with the knowledge that your
is as never before. Embracing the theyre confident youll keep their digital transformations will succeed,
opportunities on offer is the only way data safe and secure. Trust means youll have the confidence to embrace
to stay competitive. your suppliers know your systems your digital future, and enjoy the
wont fail them. And it means you have exponential impact it has on
As your reliance on IT systems grows the confidence to move your business your growth.
and they become a fundamental part forward by embracing technology
of your organisation, they mustnt and the opportunities it has to offer. Growth = opportunity + trust.
fail. Technology is a key player in your Its the new equation for the digital
success. But you and your customers, Organisations need to build trust into age. Let us help you make it work for
shareholders and regulators need the fabric of their digital operation. your business.
to trust it. With trust in your data and security,

4 Building Digital Trust The confidence to take risks


Our point of view

Tap into the trust dynamics Social media Businesses can Hyper-connectivity you operate in
unleashed by digital. Or get understand and interact with customers a connected world. You share data, your
left behind. in new ways and can use social media to systems are accessed by your trading
build knowledge. partners, transactions flow in and out
Were in the decade of digital change in
with almost no intervention. Any
which only the fit will survive and thrive.
Businesses with a clearly defined collaboration of this type needs trust.
And to be digitally fit, you need to be
approach to social media and governance You cant afford to get it wrong.
digitally trusted by customers,
around its use will have an advantage.
suppliers, in fact by all the stakeholders Digital identity The next wave of
Social media interaction will increasingly
in your business. digital relies on knowing who you are
form part of the trust relationship
between a business and its stakeholders. dealing with. In addition, customers
More than ever before, the growth of your will want more access to, and control of,
Are you listening to them, engaging with
organisation depends on your ability to their own data their digital identity
them and driving the agenda to manage
embrace the new trust dynamic. as they share their consumption data
your reputation?
and transact on line.
Barely a week goes by without another
Mobile smartphones offer new
reminder of how the power of digital Emerging data protection legislation,
opportunities for businesses. Your
technology continues to disrupt the rapidly evolving cyber security threats
customers and your own users are
traditional way business is done and and issues of digital trust across
consuming information, transacting and
offers innovative opportunities to create international boarders will drive this to
communicating from the palm of their
new ways of creating value. Not the top of the agenda.
hand. Their mobile device has become an
embracing digital opportunities is no
essential, everyday experience for them. Speed of change your business is
longer an option. But acting too quickly
Mobile payments will underpin the becoming increasingly dependent on
and being unclear on your direction is
digital economy. Trust is essential for technology-driven transformation
dangerous and could harm your business.
them to feel safe using it. programmes. Only by seeking new ways
You need to manage risk and build trust
to feel secure in the choices you make. of delivering your products and services
Analytics data is everywhere, and its will you stay ahead of the competition
value to your business is on the increase. and maintain a strategic edge. You need
Weve identified seven key digital
Learn to exploit data, share it, manage a transformation process that will deliver
developments which are already
it and protect it or get left behind. You on business outcomes. Businesses that
changing the face of how your business
need to know what you can and cant are confident in their ability to deliver
operates. Theyre vital to the success
do with it. And your staff must be technology enabled transformation
story of your digital business, and theyre
well-versed in their data-handling will have a distinct advantage in this
all founded on trust.
responsibilities. Management need new world.
to trust the data and the analyses
that are driving business decisions. Digital trust combined with a new
attitude to risk will free you to
Cloud by storing data and sourcing unleash your potential in these areas.
services and applications through cloud Well help you develop a digital trust
operators, you lose the sense of security strategy for your business. Itll give
of a defined physical location. Cost and you the confidence to make the right
convenience will drive the adoption of choices for your organisation, and
cloud services far faster than most drive profitable growth.
businesses imagine. A cloud based
internet of applications is emerging and
users will switch seamlessly and
unknowing between in-house and cloud
based applications. Trusting providers to
manage your data and services requires
new approaches to managing and
sourcing services.

Building Digital Trust The confidence to take risks 5


What does it take to succeed?
We can help you develop the confidence
The new digital trust ecosystem youre more connected than ever
to be a leading player in the new,
expanded digital trust ecosystem. First,
Industry you need to focus on three key priorities:

Get the right attention in the


Re
l gu boardroom With digital
ba opportunities and risks becoming so
Industry

lat
o
Gl

ory
central to business strategy, boards
and audit committees must have the
digital expertise to set the level of risk
Suppliers
that they are willing to accept. They
Customer
must be able to ask the right questions
and hold management to account.
Environmental

Rethink your approach to

Legal
Enterprise
technology risk In the digital age
building trust will provide the context
for managing technology risk. Our
Service Digital Trust Framework helps
Consumer providers businesses achieve this. Managing
the risk in this ever changing world
needs new and more dynamic
approaches based on up-to-date
ral

JV/
Ge

lt u

o li Partners understanding of the situation.


op

-
cu

ti c
al cio Businesses should develop KPIs to
So
help them understand and measure
digital trust.
Technology
Now: Develop a business strategy for the
Connectivity and collaboration extend to all facets of business
digital age Whats certain is that
you will need a business strategy for
Integration with wide range of business stakeholders, competitors and trading
partners, in a dynamic environment built on trust
the digital age not a digital strategy.
Your organisation will need to foster
High risk, high opportunity
more collaboration, greater innovation
and faster decisionmaking than
Then:
youve experienced before. As part of
Few strands of connectivity and collaboration this you will need to master building
Integration limited to supply chain/consumer digital trust to have the confidence to
Low risk, low opportunity embrace your digital future.

Digital risk and the need to build trust should be treated as


an enterprise issue for which boards need to develop a clear
risk appetite to suit their specific business circumstances.
Alongside this, there needs to be a clear action plan and
frequent monitoring and assurance that the risks are
appropriately managed.

6 Building Digital Trust The confidence to take risks


How to build digital trust
the right way

Managing risk and building


trust underpins the digital
Confidence in your security
agenda as digital platforms
Confidence that systems are secure to protect customer
become increasingly central to and other data and that identity/privacy issues have been
Cyber
the delivery of business security dealt with.
strategy. To build trust you
will need confidence in each of
these five areas:

Confidence in your data


Confidence in the integrity of data and the ability to benefit
Data
confidence
from what it can reveal about a business.

Confidence in your systems


Confidence that business systems have the right controls
and monitoring to ensure that they do what they are
Business
systems supposed to, whether they are in-house systems or are
confidence delivered as cloud based services.

Confidence to take risks


Confidence that technology risks are understood and well
IT Risk
managed and that digital platforms will be available when
resilience required (24/7).

Confidence in your digital transformation


programme
Confidence to embark on and deliver the next complex
Transformation
confidence
digital transformation programme in a way that delivers the
expected benefits, on time and to budget.

Building Digital Trust The confidence to take risks 7


Our Digital Trust Framework

and Resilience
IT Risk No two businesses are the same.
Our Digital Trust Framework gives
us the flexibility to respond to the
IT Governance
specific needs of your organisation.
Compliance Technology
with regulation Well address all the segments of
mega trends
the Framework to decide what
help you need to protect your
IT processes business and enable profitable
Global IT o
t the pport and assets digital growth.
ec
un
t
Pro

ity

Digital Whether that means developing a


IT resilience & Trust cyber-risk strategy, optimising your
Sourcing risk
continuity control environment or reducing
g it
nt

al E n ble m e
Di

your overall IT risk profile, youll


a
receive the independent, expert
Insight and insight you need to build digital
Cyber security
data quality trust and succeed in the digital age.
Business Project
C y u rit

e
se

nfi ata
nc

systems
be

delivery risk
c

de
D

y
r

co
sys B io n
te m u s i n e s s n s f o r m at
a
s co Tr ence
nfidence confid

Insight and data quality Business systems IT resilience and continuity


Data is the lifeblood of an organisation. It Businesses are becoming ever more IT services are increasingly intertwined,
enables people to understand how well dependent on globally integrated systems with a complex combination of layers of
things are working and to decide what to both for internal operations and for infrastructure and service and process
do next? Manage your data well and this engaging with customers and suppliers. interdependencies, including legacy
can drive competitive advantage. It can Most invest significantly in these but do systems, mobile technologies and 3rd
improve efficiency and create not realise the promised benefits in terms party vendors.
transparent processes for managing data of process best practice, standardisation
which will deliver an enhanced and improved control. It is crucial that This complexity potentially leads to
reputation creating the foundation of controls and security are embedded into multiple and high impact IT outages
trust with your customers, suppliers and these systems and monitored. Traditional resulting from the failure of a single
staff. enterprise systems will increasingly component or process. Solutions for data
interface with cloud based web storage or applications in the cloud bring
Project delivery risk applications, introducing new risks. new dimensions of risk.

The volume, cost and complexity of IT


projects is increasing. However, one Cyber security Global IT
quarter of all projects fail completely and Cyber attacks are accelerating at an Operating a global IT system creates
half are delivered late or over budget. In alarming rate and businesses are not additional complexity and risk.
the digital age, business success will keeping pace. Governments are putting Differences in local approaches and
become increasingly dependent on unprecedented effort into raising attitudes can create global system
technology driven transformation and awareness with business. New approaches vulnerabilities. Inadequate global support
the speed of change increases. are required to deal with the evolving can lead to high levels of downtime and
business and threat landscape. Breaches reduced effectiveness. Complex global
or leakages can be financially devastating data protection legislation is increasingly a
and do significant damage to reputation. consideration for global IT.

8 Building Digital Trust The confidence to take risks


P wC provided a real focus on the issues,
a no-nonsense approach and an ability to
leverage their global experience on any
given issue. In addition, they have great
people on the ground.
CEO, Digital TV broadcaster

Compliance with regulation Technology mega trends Sourcing risk


Often multiple compliance requirements Analytics, big data, mobile, social media Cloud computing presents irresistible
are relevant, so a joined-up approach is and cloud together represent consumer- cost saving opportunities and a myriad of
essential. Otherwise, complexity can driven forces that will impact every risks linked to where data is stored and
create inefficient overlapping controls or business and increase the need for digital how it is segregated and secured.
gaps that lead to non-compliance. trust. Having a business strategy for the
digital age is important. Investments in Outsourcing often goes wrong and
IT governance technology can carry high risk exposure companies are rethinking their approach
but not responding will cause loss of to it. Some of the worst
Managing the structure and framework
competitive advantage. IT disasters in recent years have
within which IT operates can have a
been partly caused by badly managed
critical bearing on overall corporate
IT processes & assets outsourcing. Data protection
performance. An MIT study found
considerations are forcing businesses to
that businesses with below average Robust and consistently applied IT
rethink certain offshoring arrangements.
performance in IT governance were processes form a fundamental part
25 per cent less profitable than their of IT hygiene. An incomplete IT asset
peers whose performance was ranked inventory (hardware and software)
as good or above. can create problems for security, impair
investment and result in financial and
reputational damage from unlicensed
software. For example, 90 per cent of all
software licensing reviews carried out by
PwC have identified non-compliance.

Building Digital Trust The confidence to take risks 9


Cyber security

How we help
What does good look like? Cyber security confidence in your will give you that confidence by helping
You continually monitor your security. While cyber security risks have you manage risks, while staying connected.
risk profile. You understand dramatically evolved, the approach Well help you in shaping a broader strategic
what matters for the success of businesses use to manage them has not response to cyber risk by helping to
your business. You realise this kept pace. The traditional information understand current capability and putting
changes as you move forward security model one that is technology in place a focused plan to target cyber
with your business. focused, compliance-based, perimeter- security investment in the right places.
oriented, and aimed at securing the Our specialists will help also you respond
You understand in real time, the back-office does not address the realities to actual cyber incidents. And theyll
new threats within the digital of today. Cyber security isnt just about advise on the legal issues surrounding
landscape. And youre fully technology and computers. Its about breaches, data privacy and protection. To
people, information, systems, processes, target investment on what matters most
aware of the risks youre
culture and physical surroundings. PwC we focus on the six areas outlined below:
exposing the organisation
to as you execute your
You cant secure everything Seize the advantage
strategic plan.
We help you set the right priorities. We help you exploit digital
Enterprise security architecture opportunity with confidence.
You understand how digital Protect what matters Risk
Digital trust is embedded in
Priorities
the strategy
is changing the fabric of your Strategy, organisation and
Privacy and cyber security
business, introducing new governance
legal compliance
Threat intelligence
threats and changing your Risk management and risk
risk profile. appetiteThreat intelligence

nfi dence in
Co
Your eyes are fully open to Crisis
digital threats. Connections

You recognise boundaries ou


ur
y

rd
igi ta l f u t
have shifted: your business Its not if but when Their risk is your risk
architecture has changed, We help you build an intelligenceled We help you understand and
defence, enabling rapid detection manage risk in your
so have the risks within your andcontainment. People interconnected business
Technology
digital supply chain. The threats Continuity and resilience ecosystem.

come from within your Crisis management Digital channels


Partner and supplier
organisation and outside. Incident response and forensics
management
Monitoring and detection
Robust contracts

Fix the basics People matter


We help you use technology to your advantage, We help you build and maintain a secure culture,
deriving maximum return from your technology where people are aware of their critical security
investments. decisions.
Identity and access management Insider threat management
Information technology, operations technology People and moments that matter
and consumer technology Security culture and awareness
IT security hygiene
Security intelligence and analytics

Cyber security services

Assess Build Manage Respond

10 Building Digital Trust The confidence to take risks


The benefits
Operate in the Our team will help you build a strong
know security foundation and an agile
management framework integrated
with your wider business plans, so you
can operate knowing your risks and
opportunities.

Be prepared Every organisation will be breached at


some point. Understanding this will
help you prepare for the worst. Our
team can help you prepare, prevent and
protect what matters most to you.

Take control Our team will help you take control


and keep you up to date on regulatory
and legislative changes. Our legal
experts will also help you with your
data privacy and protection concerns.

Feel confident Your people are important, and their


actions have a direct impact on your
business and its security. Well advise
you on how to create the right culture
where your people instinctively do the
right thing.

Not all assets are equal.


Information, digital transactions and smart devices
continue to proliferate at an extraordinary rate.
Safeguarding all at the highest level is not realistic or
possible. Incidents in some areas can be troubling;
others can destroy key elements of your business.

Building Digital Trust The confidence to take risks 11


Data confidence

How we help
What does good look like? Data confidence confidence in your data test your systems and processes to ensure
You know what data is important is fundamental to an efficient and agile that your data is accurately processed and
to you and you have the organisation. When you exploit your data properly reported. For completeness we
confidence to exploit it for and implement good governance, it cover where data is stored, how long it is
competitive advantage. provides the basis for others to trust you kept and who should have access.
and want to do business with you. We can The result is a transparent and reliable
You understand how to use third help you to know what data you need and governance process, enabling your
party data, where it works and how good it needs to be. We can ensure employees and customers to make the
where it doesnt. that you get your data right, focussing on right decisions.
whats important. We can help you embed
You know the impact on your good governance and also independently
data of system change.

Your staff know their


responsibility to your data
ensuring it is right for your
business needs.

You have the controls and Competitive Good decision


Compliance
processes to know when data advantage making
quality is compromised and its
impact on reporting, decision
making and your customers.

You know what data to secure Outcomes


and when to get rid of it.

Insights

Availability Governance Quality


of data of data of data

12 Building Digital Trust The confidence to take risks


The benefits
Peace of mind Knowing your data meets your business
needs.

Being systems- Understanding what your systems and


savvy processes are actually doing to your
data, and knowing its right.

Trusting your Youll be confident your employees


staff know their role in managing your data,
from capture through to destruction.

Protecting the Our team will help you prioritise the


important data security and protection of the data that
matters for your business.

Safeguarding Having data governance at the heart of


your people your change management process will
ensure that the role of your employees
is understood and managed.

Clear-headed Confidence in your data, based on good


decision-making governance, to make the right decision
at the right time.

Changing data Youll prioritise changes to the way you


systems with manage and protect your data.
confidence

Well help you understand the value of


your data, ensuring you focus your efforts
on the data that matters.
With quicker, better informed decisions,
your business will be agile, remain
competitive and be trusted.

Building Digital Trust The confidence to take risks 13


Business systems
confidence

How we help
What does good look like? Business systems confidence systems landscape, including a range of
Your control environment Confidence in your systems: design, ERP, EPM and GRC technologies, and
provides you sustainable, strengthen, sustain. You need an extensive experience in defining and
reliable and cost-efficient integrated and holistic approach to deploying risk and control frameworks.
management of your risks. Its designing, deploying, operating and This is how weve been able to help
efficient, effective and optimising your control environment. As address financial and operational risk for
integrated with, underlying the business system landscape changes clients across a whole spectrum of
(ERP) and Enterprise with users moving seamlessly between processes and industries. Working across
Performance Management in-house systems and cloud based web the entire control life-cycle, well apply a
(EPM) systems, internet/cloud services and mobile applications, a risk and controls lens to your processes
based and mobile applications. comprehensive approach to business and system design, strengthen your
systems control becomes even more overall design, and help you increase the
important. Youll benefit from our deep reliability and maturity of your existing
Management carries out
technical expertise of the business control environment in a cost-effective
real-time monitoring and
and sustainable manner.
periodic assessment of your
systems, strengthening the ERP
Standardisation
systems. Dedicated Governance,
Risk and Compliance (GRC) Confidence in your systems and processes
technology provides vital Process and control
support strengthening the ERP
and EPM systems.
Quality Automation Adherence
You have thorough insight on
performance, process adherence
and compliance by continuously
monitoring transactional data.
Outcomes
Controls culture

Documentation
Continuous
GRC Control monitoring and
technology design auditing

Business systems landscape

Mobile Internet/cloud Other enterprise ERP and EPM


applications based applications business systems systems

Integration

Controls maturity

14 Building Digital Trust The confidence to take risks


The benefits
The right focus Well help you understand which risks
really matter so you can focus your
efforts in the right places.

Prevention rather Our team will help you focus on


than detection preventing problems upstream, so you
wont have to detect and correct them
downstream.

Prepared for the Well help you arm your people with
worst the skills and tools they need to
respond in a crisis.

Demystifying Well help you cut through the


technology complexity to express risk in simple
business terms.

A fresh Well provide a fresh and independent


perspective point of view, benchmarking you with
peers.

Deep expertise Our leading experts in industry,


emerging technology and digital risk
will complement your existing team.

Efficiency Well help you streamline and automate


your IT governance, risk and
compliance activities to deliver value
for money.

Boards and senior management are demanding


greater insight into the control and compliance
culture of their organisations.
With our help, you can optimise your systems
control, giving you better management of risk and
improved decision-making.

Building Digital Trust The confidence to take risks 15


IT risk resilience

How we help
What does good look like? IT risk resilience giving you the changes faster at lower cost and an
Your digital risks are proactively confidence to take risks. Businesses increasing need for real time data
identified, assessed, owned, across sectors have recently been shaken transfers means that approaches to
managed and monitored. by the impact of several high profile IT managing risk and resilience must adapt
outages and glitches, eroding digital fast. Well help you identify a complete
The information you need to trust. IT services are increasingly set of IT risks and to design the IT
make risk-aware decisions is intertwined with a complex combination governance and risk management
available at the click of a button. of: layers of infrastructure, service and processes to better manage them. The
process interdependencies, including PwC Risk Assurance Framework provides
You are well placed to mitigate legacy systems, mobile technology and a comprehensive and proven approach to
and avoid high impact system 3rd party vendors. This combined with managing this process. Being good at this
fragmented understanding of the IT will give you the confidence to embrace
outages.
landscape, pressure to implement digital the next digital opportunity.
When IT incidents or disasters
do occur, you are fully prepared
and able to respond quickly.

You are fully compliant with


regulatory requirements that are
dependent on IT.

Your total cost of compliance is


reducing.

IT risk is an implicit part of the risk landscape


Risk landscape

Risk

Strategic Organisational Financial Compliance


commercial operational regulatory
reputational

Risk, control and assurance continuum

Approach

1 2 3 4 5 6
Risk Risk Design Monitoring Assurance Outcomes
strategy assesment implementation
management

Lines of defence

Response
1 2 3 4

1st line: people, 2nd line: 3rd line: 4th line:


process & management internal audit external assurance
technolgy & oversight

16 Building Digital Trust The confidence to take risks


The benefits
C-Suite insight Deep insight for the C-Suite into how to
improve technology-related investment
decision-making.

Change delivery You will understand how effectively


wellness check your IT will be able to support and
deliver a business critical change
programme.

Management You will know where your weaknesses


trouble-shooting are and have a plan in place to monitor
advice the effectiveness of your governance
and IT risk resilience processes.

Identify and Our team will help develop a strategic


prioritise improvement road-map aligned with
improvements industry good practice, and
benchmarked against peer
organisations.

Unbiased risk Independent assurance to the board


resilience and third parties on the effectiveness
assurance of your risk resilience environment.

Well help you make more informed


decisions in managing the risks and
delivering business value from your
IT and technology investments.

Building Digital Trust The confidence to take risks 17


Transformation
confidence

How we help
What does good look like? Transformation confidence confidence You need to focus on the right
Technology-enabled in your digital transformation program. opportunities and maximise your
transformation is complex but Your business is becoming increasingly chances of achieving them by aligning
delivers strategic change to your dependent on technology-driven your projects and programmes
business. You can realise the full transformation programmes. You need to appropriately. Acting as your critical
extent of your investment and take the lead in these digital change friend well give you insight and
position yourself ahead of the agendas. Doing so will give you the challenge to help you make those
competition. strategic edge, competitive advantage, tough decisions and support you in
lower operating costs, and greater agility. realising your digital future.
Shareholders and market
analysts recognise your
commitment to evolving or
Executive board External
innovating your business and Audit
are confident in your approach

Digital Transformation Assurance


Steering Committee Audit
to maximising value from your committee
digital investments.
Internal
Programme Management Team Audit
Digital change agendas are
Project or workstream
delivered on time and to budget delivery teams
and they achieve the outcomes
your stakeholders want. Implementation roll out teams/
capabilities work streams
operational teams
Your organisation is focussed on
Systems Other Software
the technology changes that will integrator Business partners vendor
provide most value to your
business, so you can commit
your finite resources to game-
changing solutions.

Solution assurance and deep dives


Continuous assurance
Gate reviews
Programme assessments

Because many change programs fail to deliver the


business outcomes, boards are left with the dilemma
of knowing they need to change but not having
confidence in their ability to deliver the outcomes.

18 Building Digital Trust The confidence to take risks


The benefits
An unbiased An independent view of the key
perspective technology programme activities and
deliverables. Leadership will get
impartial insight into the state of your
digital transformation.

Focus on what Youll learn to concentrate on the


matters business reason for the change
from inception to delivery.

Work towards a Youll be equipped to concentrate on


commercial the business outcomes of the project.
outcome

Get a Youll be forward looking, and get early


heads-up on risk warning of the key issues and risks.

Expert Our experts in industry, technology


enrichment and digital transformation programme
delivery will enrich your existing
project team.

Top to bottom We offer the broadest coverage of


assurance assurance, guaranteeing you a
high-performance technology
transformation programme
from top to bottom.

Effective digital transformation assurance works as


the conscience of the transformation.
Well ensure everyone works together to deliver
business outcomes not implement technology.

Building Digital Trust The confidence to take risks 19


Contacts

Dominic Nixon
Singapore Risk Leader
dominic.nixon@sg.pwc.com

Greg Unsworth
Asia Pacific Technology Leader
greg.unsworth@sg.pwc.com

Tan Shong Ye
IT Risk and Cyber Security Leader
shong.ye.tan@sg.pwc.com

Mark Jansen
Singapore Risk Partner
mark.jansen@sg.pwc.com

www.pwc.com/sg
2013 PricewaterhouseCoopers LLP. All rights reserved. PricewaterhouseCoopers and PwC refer to the network of member firms of
PricewaterhouseCoopers International Limited (PwCIL), or, as the context requires, individual member firms of the PwC network.
Each member firm is a separate legal entity and does not act as an agent of PwCIL or any other member firm.

You might also like