I,,
99 GALES & SEATON'S REGISTER
}I,. CLAY l'cnlotcd in bia nppooillon, and 010.1$1 lb.,
b. ,hould ...,ruW.... " <I"';';"" not to lok~ up the u.n.d 8lU
.. oq.....l....1 In .. dccioion to Ie.t.-re it .u...,ted "" ror Ihe
Not oflhe~ . He thpi!Mlherntlc ....... f ...... )lit-
_Ii looked ~ .... rb bly w' I, and. qw.ite """'l""ent to
C<lnlinue tt>e debate. He then ..,111001 ror tlte y... and
noy. u" the motion, . hich w .... e "",,r<iingly 01'<1<1'<;<1. '
Afte. " r.w r.m..ko rcoln M......
WE BST ER,
SP RA GUE, and PO&.'W TH, th.e qu ••lion lnlI tak e.. On
1M motion of Mr. W E BST E R, and decided at f.llo .... ,
Y...... _)I.-..lkn.on. Bibb, Blo.k. 8 .......", S ... k ......
Cllomb ....... D,U~ Dudl.,. !'on,th, G... nd,..
·H~rict ..
IfjU, 11 01", ... IU .... King. Millet. ~I oo"", }IolIinlOn. SOl.
be .. , Smith, T ipton, W eb,'er, W ilki .... Wbite-U.
Nn • . -~l<> •• ". lleU, Cl.y, CI.yton, ni~ke ..... n, EIO;08'.
'PnM. I'reiinghltyoen, Knight,. Nau.uin, Poindexter. I'.., .. ·
t .... Robbin .. Se,,,,,,,,., $""""'.- 1....
So th. s.e ....te 1I(I'Oe<l to ~r 1M bill; aoo the bill
being . h.... b< r_ th • .se..... , .. in C"",,,,,"'" of tbe
" hole:
l l '. W £DST ER, ,n 0 .".,c.b or .boul 1... 0 h.. , .., ,Ie.
y~l<>p.d Ihe pr'''''.i''l .. of Ih. bill, • .,d lhe ""","~. on
whieh il w" ~~t>o'l.d by l b. eommittrt, and 0"' whi~h he
,hwld -.l. ocal. ill pt._,e. . nn objectkin 10 Ihe 01)\' ....
M •. TVL F.R III~ upai...w. thee d,ffi"ully he felt in
bri~", his mil>d lo.mb~ .h;' iJaporu.nt ... bje." on.,.
"""....d
to lotl[{ an jnleTT70l hod t .... ,;nee he bd looke<l into
lbe ","joel; 0",1 '......01 10 1>y the bill on lIIe table.
~I'. WEDSTF,II '.'I"i"",.,1 in the motion, .. bicb WI.
e•• ried. • limite<! time, Ihe Vrocoed. 'If lb. . .I•• of . Ihe !,,,bl;,;
On motion of ~ I •. BENTO N, the Sen". II .. " lI"",e.d. bod., &0.
e<I to Ihe "",,"'1o..I1on of u<':e~ti.o b~",n .....
ARc. tloe doo.. ~.., U-Op"ntd, in IUppori or , h ...... ndm""1, (at ciYen .!><we. )
)... CALIIOUN laid "" tbe lobk! .It.. follo"';o, n.,..
1 ~ liotl,
RnoIwd, n..1 1100 P..,oident be req,,, •• te<1 10 l.y!>c.
fure Ih. Sen.te 0 copy or "i<!,roclo",ot,,,,, of the Hl1h or
n e.,.,mbe. IlISl; ond oJ"" t he • .,Ihc.. tie:oled c~pi .. of the
ordinon .. of the peeple of Ihe Stole of S<>ulh C.",li"..
wilh 110. doo"",."" oc.omp..,y .... r Ihe .. me; and of ,h.
procbIMtion of Ih ('''' .... ''''. or If... 101111. of SOIlJh C......
Ii ... 0( 'he 20th or O""eo\bet lut, whi.h ..... lruI .... itlw.
10 him by the Es"",,(,•• of I~I Sta", with the ..,qunt
Ib,t he t!>oak! I.y tI,em hef"", Convno.
The Sen.,e ,b.... dj""cn~d.
1')oIOC L.l.lU T ION.
'lbo ,...,Jut ..... 011'0""" rntordoy by l lr. CA LHOUN
.... , 100" t~k ... u!' for conoidention.
)1•. KtNG ,<>Ie, nOl, •• be .. i,l, fut th. p"rp_ of en_
te. I,,\!' inw . ")ioo,,,",on of n ... ..,'ol"lion, bul hi, objocl
In ri .. nr ..... m... 111e ota•• , fi .. th~ in fO""'otlon ,,( th ..
hnot"" from Sout Carol,,,", th ••••"'" ... hy he mil):ltl
, ..hap> \hi"k ,t 001 Uped"~1 10 p .... 'M eonbde,..t"",
or bi. ,...,I,,' ionol 110;' time. II m'thl lead 10 a d",,_
tion wl" <h would be round not to b. MCe... ry. A, .....
u.re fn>m the .. ...OWent ...... kI "" """',-.d, p"""po, t<>-
d.y o. t<HOO"""', ... bjeh would eom",,,n""" 'h o docu_
m.".....no<! for by lI,i• ..,..,Iulion. T hey "'.. ,~! hove
b~.n """,m~"ie>tcd to Ihe Senot. b.fo•• thi. time, but
Ih.t . d.l.~ I,ad tabn placo in ol>duronng 10 <>bllli" .n
auo...nti<;atod eopy of ",me of 110. d"""ICIen" frono South
Caroli..... Hellloutht, ther<:~ thot , h. p,..,.,.' <...,....
would be '01>1 110. . . ,lo.l"tion. f .... the rw-nl, on ' be
"".-
lift. GIlUN QY Ihon roo, . uftd rtalM Ihot he ..... au·
tbo. i •• d to ...). ' hOI the S."..lo, f",,,, SMlh Corolina
"'ould, nn Th'''~loy next, '" l>e.h.p, eArlier, •• e.i.e
oJl the doo:<"... nlO .onod fur by ,hi. ,..,.olu'ion, ',01 ',"""h
"''''''' in a ....... ,,,,,,,ieolion (ron! '''" .... >ioIenl. At><! 'be
.._ vhy ''''' i"'pu. hod _ beu o.,...",,,,,icolo<l ol'n
100
[J .....
,
I .... 15, 16. UC13.
-
~ ...Ii. c petiod woS, that a ooPY of the ..,t of Ahembly
could not be procured in OIl oullIenti<: fo.... : b,,1 do. do-
"''''''ntl .. ould' be eo<nlJl~nicated, whe'he1- ."'" copy
should be oblaiaod .... nM. He hoped the Se ... "", wO<dd
no<, under 'hll ' _ ..""e, i",,", on Ihe pl"<::K~''''''''''' <if
'he Senote ~p<>n bie o;eooluliooo, but would ... Wu it to lie
on ,4 tabl.. .
lib. C ALH OUN ..if1 he ~ertainl, ohould not objeCI,
~nde. the ....... rnou.nces, to th. IoY'"J or hi • •elOlution,
fo. tII. pretenl, 'on lIIe tablo. Ili, obJ'''' had been "",~.
Iyl<> obtain these dQc,,"'rnu, 10 .... !old before lhe Serfale.
And.~. tl ..... rhl " !,ro~'10 oay tho. be did POt upecl
" , ... eh crue~ooioto on Ihe ... bjc., .. genlle",U _",.d
'0 ,n! onl'oipa"d. It h.d M' heen h., obj.et 10 UIt
. en."re onr ... he.e, b"t onl, '0 b,inr the ,locomen .. into
tbe P"..., ... M of tb. S;'n .. t • . 11>cy .... ,..,. in hi' opinion,
"""n..,lcd with. ",o. l,i:nporu.nl ;"ue-on in".whi<:h in
impo ........ hod ....'.c b•• a ..rp.....w in ,t.. hitlO<'1 of
"""n'''', not ....
' his .~ 01 the time,.,heft IIw l)ec.lontion
of lot<lepe""._ .... pubr.....,.. Und•• Ihie i",prnoion,
he hod b"""A'hl f"" ... od hi..uol"llon '0 brint lbe P>P"'"
befort' lhe Senol';. I f onj' $, ",,'0. til""'rhl "rope? to
"" we 10 lor tbe ",.,Iulion on Ihe t.ble , l,e I huuld tI\It~
On ,...,.;"" of )1<. GR U ~l)y, .he ",..,l~'ion Wit then
1.;.\ on the tobk!. •
PUIlI.IC L A~US.
The Sen"" then ..." .... 01 110. biZ! '" ,ppmp,.;.M, f......
l lr. BUC KNE It contin"ed, ,nd ""',ol~de<l bie ", ,,,.,-1<0
T he Son'le -.ljou"..,d.
W U$"DH, J."uu 16.
soun l C.u:W Ll KA .
A me ..""" "'.1 .«.ive<! r""ID 110. 1·..,jd'''1 of Ih.
Uoiled Sto •.,., 'nn,mill;"1I' cOl'i ... or the proc!'n'I>l;""
and othtr dow"",,,,,, ~I";"r to Soulh COIO""', hOT ",.w.
....... e, &e. Ioe.
'"", . =l'ng "r
~ h ........ge """"P~ on bhr ontl 0
q" ... er. A. ooon •• i, "'0' hithed_
n •. GItU!'I"D \ ' """ ..d ~ n ..f • • Ih~ me ...;.... "",I doe, ...
n,o,," tu ,I,,,
Co",m;t..,,;,. Ih~ )"d,oi" ),, .,,<1 ,h.t tl,.),
b~ priM"'!' .
Mr. CA Ll IOUN 1100"' ...... ond "';u, th.1 \,i. o~,;o~1 ,n
t"king tI,. t\oo. wat noc 10 ",. to .n)' .. ..urk 0<1 the mo·
lion whicll .... Immediotely before .he lIe"':e. Wh.1 be
w .. "boo,-, \., .. ~, thc..,f""", ......!d, uOlde. , ... r,."",", •.,.
",,10, be c",' .. I), ... ,\ of Of'd... lIu, be ",,,,,~I, in Ihe 1""
cui; •• ei"""m"o.'" of Itit .iluOlioo, thro ... hi",scif <on tll<:
i .. d.. IS'~noe of Ihe Se .. ,,,, fo. hi. p"dOll fo. tl,. entire
icre lcvo .... of the ,..,m"k, "hleh h. would r.,1 bhn.df
bound 10 .... h . · .
li e r.1t "" d;.,....itlon to ""'ice "'""~ ~r .he errvn
.. h:.h the .........p' ..."tai... ,1 in ref"......,. I<> ,h. ,10<:" .
.... n .. by .. hi<~ " ".,.. 0"'_1'0"~, bll' It.. ... ..". Ott.
... hicb he ...... kI ,Ieem hl"". lf .. ..,ore,,' to hi' S"'le;r
be di<! not ri.e .mph.tic.llt end Pro:nptll I" "O)i<:c. I.
..... " . ,ed by 110. Chiof ll.lI'i .... le, in , ,,bOl'""" Ibot
11>0 mo...... nl. mado by the Silo" of S.... tlt C. "'\i01 .... '"
d 0 cl ..,...,_ hootil. '0 ,I", U.ion. W•• h. ~. in
"'ie i"'pr<etOion ! If· .... ~. would _y tho< 'h~'" ..,.. ,,01
0.1>0.<10 .. or r""..dolion for lloeho ""' ...... nl. , ...... ....
not . Sute in 110. Union Ie. ,10",-.1 tl ... " lJoulb C....I, ...
to 1'"' he,.<lf in ,,,eh oltilude of h",l:h,y. lIut ,100
ground. 0" ... I'ieh Ihe I'",oidenl f",,,,d .. Ihl. i"f..~n""
we'. ,,01 Ie .. u'to01',lin"" tloon Ihe i"fcr.""" i,..lf.
Wt>cn I, .... ted I~'t hottil o mo,·ome" .. h"d t_. meM,
it " ... to b. "'1'""tled Ih.l lh. Pl'ftid~~. ,,",I ~ ... "'Ie ,Ioe
... h3 1 ~ of th~ mo.-.m< nlO of Ih .. e!uoro<:lCI" .1oi<1. Md
 101 OF ·DEBATES 1N UONGRE SS. 102
,
"~rl""', nefon Soulh Ct.ro!iou. had tahn on)' pooi. round in "". i ...... ul""'"! ."d, " ..lea ;. un be ehul<~
"on ~ • .,.,,,fti,,,;ng choraeler, til .,.,. hod be,," ,.""",n· and ""...,eted In ;to eonrw, bl the wiodom of the F~r·•.1
U'1tiOll of Uniled SUt.,'
for the P"~ of """tf<l;I~.&'
''''''P',h. GtI two ""int., obv'''''''!y G ""ern"'~nt. iu 0p~"lion w,lI form 010 ""coptin" 10lhe

0 "" 0' ""<"",o,,to of the /;\01.. tORt",1 coune of evenUe T he Oftl,. .ouse of \OIOilder. in
lb .... eooo ..... _ ........... at AuJ'Ulo, ...d lbe his "I'inIOtl, ..... that 0111' t/,.;on bad «>ntinulOd to 10tl&';
",be . ot l:b .. l•• Ii:In. Pre.;ow to tbis cir..,."n.un~, \h. thaI, ,I the tflll of f0l11-foot. ya .... 0I1l' ~ ....... nt
.i.i,
Sute of S"',III Coroli". h,d look.d to notl,inr berund. o"""klotill ..,tal" ito origin.! f.".m. li e c"",.id.~ tbo',
P_.... oDd lI.,l "Mode<! ",udy 10 r". effeet to htt \0 Iho gtcat evont of 1801, tbe .u""... of l}>e p.rty 1,·l\ieh
opposotloo i. Ihe form of ...,il,,' \0, .. . h .... ",,11... hen h"d .le""l~ ) 1•. Je!f<""" .10 Ih~ !',.~e""y, ~.... ....;n·
"""Iiury for= .... diJ.pI."..s "" her 1o.onI~ ..... &n~ 'n her Ir 10 be .11".l>u~ lhis du .... llOn. Noth,nt: bu., 11>e ~~v".
limiu, o,od ... hen Ih~ mo"x ...... ,hm." .... , ap.not the \1>On "r that ''''''.;.1....1 hod " ........ nlwl1>e .... Iot. 'erm",..·
];... ef he< citi•• "••• ,>d or .hei...·i ......1 child,..,n, Ihal .ion or an upcriment. Uu, 'M lime hod.1 Jen,,~ corne
,he. r""nd tb..., .. I~. dri"en to on attitude of ..';.\a'lCe. when w. a", ""jUi. e,llo d.-cide wh~l h .. Ihi ••h.II~. a
nea i, ..... th.1 Ih.y .il ""'p1l"ed 10 O"e$dl. a .. y o~· """fed.ney an, ~ .... ","e,k. i, ....11 ]l"i......, '0
"........... • COfIooIiWoted Conn ....'''.t. He ...11fd "" Se".' ..... fO·
Bu. 110.. President 1,><1 .1.. tnlM hi. infc,""",". on .". lemnly.o ",u. . .nd d.libenl. on .his 'mporl.nt quu..
oth •• ground . II~ I,ad Laid it don'" , ,hd . he trib"".1 of ,iM. ,, " he li •• d, h~ beli"'ed It'lt U.. conlinu . .."" of
.be 8np",me eo...t of 110.. United S'at........ in 110.. I..t .ny eonlOlidal.d C"".rnm.n. "'.. impoqible. I. mutt
rdO>1, I~e .... 1» ....i ... of ,1>e dlll"eknet! ,n ,be _NC- i.... i\abl, 'tad to. miliu", deopotiom. At .hl. momen ••
lion of l hoc conol.;{uti.....:J;ty 01" tltc low.. On tIIis point ... ,.'-. ""vi~, bet!n bl"ODrh' into conbc:1 ...jth "ny ad·
th ...... m. to hue be.. .. a , ...t cho"l:'" in lI,e opinion •• roe c\l"<;UmtlO1lCCt, ... i,h"". ony "",,/!:c' ing Uti"', in 0
of tb. Y.x •• u.ive wil ru .. Ihe 1>.0. , ... I.e monlh.. "floe 'im. of pc.c<, "nd under 'he influence "fon "neumpl.d
Pralde"t bad _ held tbi. "I,in..... in ..f.re...,e '0 ,he,..,· r>_perily, ..... ' Union .1.-<10 on the u. "f di ... d"lion or
...... _ 01 the State of ~ " .......,... "'·.T ",,\, tlt.o ,·o~ of ....i. ".... lI o"· .... u .hi.1 w.. it t>ot at.
"'.ide, 1\,......i, ory of Ge<><p ftOmlh,. of S",,,10 Co",· .ributab~ .0 t1>e pow.rfu l "·orl.inp of Ihe cohM>l;dating
linl ; Y", no> lhe "". olde, 11,. ",,"e' nf Ihe Supreme p. iMi"I.!
Conl1. at Ibe orbiter in the bot _ ' , •• to he ,,,obined; I" Ihil ,.id.l)· nlen~.~ republic ,h.", 10.. b •• ", nf n~·
.-hi!<-, un .h. otl>e. <ide. 1M ... ill of tho J::1~11i,'" i,to be ~~ .. ilr.'" ""'i •• cOI>Aicl of "'to"'.... In 00 .. ~or'ion •
•up..........
nm. if 11.. S"~""'" Court .... 10 "" .10. 01"1>;'••, I.. . oj .... ;" ._lIe.
•. .... m work< ","n.Sciolly, ,.hid. io f"" ..\ '0 be "I'P''''
]>O'"Iion . • The .yst.m ofp~,clion .. soid
wiol,«! 10 kno .. '" ... h'l monn •• tbe d«i,j"" of tlo .. l.i .. IIO 01>•• OIC 10 tI,. ad",n'.g~ ~f 11 ...... 1'••1' of Ihe ~"',"I'r
~~".l, •• 1.0 ,b. con";lutionality of Iilo I.tif!" l>w .. " 1,,·l>i.h a~ the "rong<>I. It''ery OlIO said 10, . ",1, th~re·
.......... re ~r prol~C l io... " .• • '0 be ob ' .;,~d' lIow • .•• rcu, h...... 1>00",110 beH"'e 00. 8uI in .b. .... k••• I'OI· • .
an .... ,••0 b<: made up! Til;, mod" N4 "l ..,:edy been .;....,; of Ihe c""nlry Ib .... """ """,,,e1r'0 be r-rod one
ttkd in Ihe .... of 11»1 .... . . . .iti.~n 01 Ch.. Ie>lon, .",1 , .. 1>0 . ·",,1cI M'. if h. b&d .he powe., i",t do,,'" Ihe .y •.
•I,~ .~".t "",I ,!t-clo...,d'" '".'I'>ei:r 10 o.t, rot ~"n' of I"'" or protec'ion Tho,. we"" Ih". dill"oto,,1 .i..... on
ju.jtdi<;,..... , .n<!. ",f.""," '0 10k. eogn ... nocof .h~ ... bjul . . h,~h ,'01... 110 ... wu Ihi. 10 op.... to' H ~ inl.",led, ;"
lie .. i>Iocd '" ho .. ,..1" Ih.. c'rcu ...... oaeo. h.d !.ce" .... p. !""'hing ...Mch hoc .hould -r, 1.0 .... k. o..y pe ........1 ref....
p~-no, oopp ........ "':OS 100 ,Ironl: • te.m_rotg<>" ·e...... It ... his ... ishto.rt'"' the ... b~et ooItly on phi.
IOn in Ih. ''I<""50I0]1"" Qf Ibe '.1co"'i~.. It will he ""'1:m· 10lOphi...1 gtOUOOf. A I' • .,iden." eleuN, .0<1 . _ .
b.red tbot when Iho hiU of 18~8 """" i"l""ltoo«l, which '010 ""w." hi. 1'"liey ".""....ily co"f...",. 10 .h"l of tho
h.d b.... j ...Hy e.l1 ... by .he S... t.ar f .... " )I.. .uehu ...". ",,'ty b~ which to .. i. obo..". It c.nnol be other""", .
.. bilt of .1""",........... 0 ....1'......,. ,; •• fron, S....uh er...... T10c tonll" P"'Y. f.... nan,,,le. "'ppet\. .. ,bei. nndi<ls ..
]In, 10.;.<1 lnelr«tuotl, ~~01< •• _,1 '0 obl.lft an am.ndment a ~ntlcnu • •110 i. known 10 be in r...·o. of 1M" ,........
Qf .h•• i,l. ~ f it, III ,h •• il mijl"bt ~ ... on i.sf.oe .hec:",..cI.. He did not ... O>Ckmn .his: it w .. lb. ",,,, .. I 0"<1 un •• oid·
"..de •• Mh,,;," aRd <Ie"''''i''e nome. 11.".., th.", •.•• "r ...
of "rol.ctio.. , ,,'hid, belonged 1<> il. \Iu. it "' .. ,."" . brOO<l able ~ou,..e of Ihi",.. Th~ or1>",i' •• id~ mu st '~en I>ke
~ h.,. <.aMid.......·1..,.., opiniono on ,h .....b)<:<:t
Soo.h Caroli"" 10 Ity the 'l"Htioo,! t"~n if ",,,, load 0 P""'"", ........., leoo ma.ked, lou. ,,'10.0 mol" be ... o(>,ned
uety ,..Eo"". on 110. O"",,,ril, of . he &"1''''_ Courl, by. pwtion " fth. "";11"1""'" ~.,..'tM M" fur Ih.1 I,...
011. ceuld no< obl.i" 'he j"Jgmu., or .Ioat """rI. W~.t '.'" 10 • tertoin u te"!, .nd by. portion <>f"'b~ anl~t.orill"
"",,,... . hen, ..... I.n for S..."h C. ... >l i"., ~". ,~. which SI.I ... bo""u.~ h. i.I ... hO>lil. 10 .b.i, intete". th,,, hi •
.toe b..1 pur..flIl cem]>Otilor. By Ihi .... mbi""t;"', "triumph i. oIIt~i""d .
It ....... bo ou;(C'led i" the _go of the b «u'i<c. II~ who ........ i"to 1"''''.' In thio mann"r, ;f he io p_
, hot th~ Sta •• ""!til 10 h, •• "_ted to Ih. other .. "IC<!. _ d orso, i" ..)Iigon« «n nc~' b. ,iislodpd. lIow
... hkh 10" p<>:n,.d oul, and 'fk.~.t.u <•• Ii •• 1'•• ,,,,1 '0', "0 hQ' 110 •• k ••• midc\l. rround bo,,· . en .h. :>otlh
• ,,",,.enlio,, M ,h. St>tt:>, in oN<:, t" omoold .h.. ,,,",.i .. . "d tI,. Sooth. If OM ,,, ... est .\tempt..o mo.ke. for.
lUtiO". S"".h C,T<>Ii.. h..t b<td p",,,·en ... 1 rrom ,..k'ng ..·.m move...."'. 110.. other ';<1" b:o occnpied II.., poo, .. I.
~prlicat""' ... n 'hio ... bj.... Sb" I....... ,,1oed o..·.r and '\00, ~~ tlt .. mu .... bc,rdtM 1.0 .he ''''''',nt of Ib,tly mil.
o«r 0,.:" 10 ob:.\~ a ~ •• nti'''', buI .h~ I~ ",,;rormly lion ...... tOOut th~ p."''' Ollitc .Depo..lme~, •• nd, ;,.. Iudinlr
rou,\d " r'.H d m.),,,,,y. on both 1I,?,,,u .to""1 b~r. 11 ~,,". lhal ~'roTt""'nt, I\"rt)"·''''o m,lhon., arc ''''po.ed "pon the
I/>.n, .......10. '0 oblo'" ~h~ ~" .... <,nc. or Ibe C.... :.lo\u _ c."""loy, unde' 110.. p.<lencc of r• • uuo_o" ~m~'",1 '0"
IlOot>.I '!"jc.nly of ,,,",,,lb'NO u( ,he ... e !"'»<:_' ~nd.r .. I... bl, groot« u.." ,lie nlue of uy ,ingl. _ of the
tlle ....,........... n.u........ mod. ,,~ "p pl,... "", "nt~ 'h .. gm' inte ..... of tbe counl.,-• ..,c"d; .. ~ 'he .. hole
St..tc ,,,.If I.. I ~1«\ ...rI ,\ u"O/,,\OI'lu" ..... I•• nd Ihe ....... o""",nl or .he cotton ....,P. or 'he .n';", >"II"" or the ship ..
gonCJ ."''' ~·h,d, ."n.d fo,... pinr i"I...... T hu., i,Ie".if.ing him .. lf ".ilh • • w;lI,
T h........ all II .. re,....,.1:.0 whkh he cono,d.ted h,,,,· brill" nor •• ,; ... rifl', ban k nor onti::j,.nk , i,,'ern,l impro,·c .
.. Ir ...11ed "".0 moke at \h .. '_"~I I. rde •• _ '0 the ....... nor ... ,;";'Rlemol i'''p""e,"",,,', he .. nnot be di._
H"1"<In of Ih<: ""'...~ ur 110" f.U","I,n. 1Q«~d. "'....,;. ,h ........11' 1"11. ,,.Iom or ""F,_i""

..,:., . II ..... ..bo,... o .b.t 110•.<"""Ir, b:od no~ 1"U<~.ed • .eri. (Q't' 0". The w ...kc • .;,1..... i. i,. ho~lc ....... and
'" . . It had. bu" "n." .. ,d tho, r.• ~"y Ih 'nlO ...·h'ch 1~ ••• nuok .. re';'IOote. T he OIron(e' O1ill o<1h"",. 10 Ihe oyo .
co,:,","" .101. ,.... If the cl.men ... of ,.. own. ~lructiOn. ~m. Th. middl. po ....., II ,h"" Ih"''''\1 \0 the Jlronre"
T h".I.n....,.le.no .... k ... ppl~.J •• 0 r:h.oul,. th." \Q fide, ","I .tI .. otronrer ..11o In lOre" which pUll do .. n , e, .
phYIO""e_ruotlorl.. Tbe p",,,,,'ple 0 docoy~. to be _. n .....u tile prou. ofeOll101id.o.ion,. Ge"tI.men
 ,
103 GAI~E S & SEATON'S lillGlSTER '04
:'U::;'~'~'~'~~~~_~~~~~.;:&.
;;;"~C~
4ToliM:::.I~ Ltmd.. """""'" {Ju . 1 ~}833.
in\g~t ,contend (halthi, w.o ,,'" ~ qu~SI;on of cQn'~Ii<IlI;onl".'.io.n, en.\eo,'Xl<ed to d~mQ"~ule to II", S~n"'~ l~ dio-
but ,t .. c""",hda""". And he could o<¢ no d"(,,,": ,on t onct,on' ~.h.e"" tbe ' ''''' ~oses: he "'.. """,Iy 'p,n 10
M.lwecn • 0"'\501,,M<d Go • • mmell' .",1 One "'I,~h . .. . ~o w oj •• d .. ' incliQfl """w,."
110<"., ~",l I.., def.,><1 'll ju...
• "m~1 tho . ;gb! of jU<lging of the prop';"" of ill\""p"oi"g ",cos. 1"0 ",be .. it migl>t not be 00, h,,' t" ' ' ' ' ' / ' ' ' ' body
milit. ,.,. powe. 10 ea.""".Rtal.. · or the »,:ople of Goo";;. i. "'.. "b • .."" an I"'lp>bl•.
We (.. i,\ Mr. C.l nu de no ""ch GOfe,"menl. South T he h"""",ble S" .... ,01" hod ..... ,..,d I~e SC"" c thO! no -
C.roli.... .. nctioned no .n~b Government. She COI,e""" Stato lo~.d the Union mOTe 110." the SI~I. ofS"",b Co,.,.
the co" fed..... ey wil~ U,. und" ..,andinl \h. \ a SIMe, in lin.. ~Ir. F . he.rd ,hi, ded."ti"" rrum ... ,eb higl .... u.
,..,""tt,
thc.la.,
reooMa"e<; 10 oppr"";m" o. ""eoNion rrom .h.
11.. a 'ight to Judge of I 'e upe<!ie''''r 0 lhori,y wi,h "I . .. u. c. ,1 m",t .b"•• on fe~d " ..".'I,ecoo.....,
Un,on. of lhe St.lc h.J pb.«d the obJeol ofU, ... r.,.,.. ,R .xI,.., ~ e
And fonoo d";ng i. i. th. t we ".,.., Ibr~>I."ed to h.ve our d.nger . IJr. l'. conrh,laled Ihe Sc~lc , Ih.l, no, ... ,tI,.
\h .....t. cuI, and IhNe of QUr "'''el."d cbild,en. No--I "'RdillS" 'be Ih""~Rn'g 'pre-.... nce, ·\hore "'''"' RO'r."f<'
R"O too far. 1 d,d nOI i""nd 10 Uft rong"'ge SO I I'ORg". 10 'h~ public p •• te. ,·11. Chief M.W ..... '. pl<dg~. h,m·
t lle Chief M' gi.t ...,. hod no' y.t tce",",,,,,,.ded '"" d.,.. .. If "", to •.."" 10 .n)· buI ,Iofen.i<. f"''''', .,><1 Ihe s~·
p er~ a remedy . 1"l1e p ..... UI I, L gN'at '1ue,,'o .... nd ".10. f'om So",h CLrolino Icll& u' 'hOI S""U, C'I"\l~i".I ....
tbe libe,'i •• of 'he Am.,.,,,",,, """pie Jep.",1 upu" .h~ ole· ,,0 o.1"';,e 10 """ foTC<) u"k .. ...,.ibl. TI,~ h~I'. m,&ht be
cioi,,~ ofil. It .... impocoible ,h,t .. CU"fo!id.'eJ G"v~rn. itlduIS',j ,h'" .11 '''~'' pl«lg« "'ould L~ redeemed, .ftbe),
""' ~t could e~ist i" Ibtl cO"'''''y, il " • • e, eIIn. Hiot!""Y \I"e. · ~, f"re<! wo"M not be " ""d.
in Ihis co"n,ry? 11 ne."r COn u~t i" .... y cp"ntry. , f o"y The mot,,,,, ... as Ih<~ .gre.,1 10.
m>n would looi: inlo Ihe h',,,,..,.
or ,be wMM, .,~I fi,,,1 allY 0 " mOIm" of ~ Jr. G IIUKIIY, 3,000 e~l ... coyi.. of lite
,,"S,. c"'" ,n wh,ch Ih. go.""m ... 1 of ~h .... lut. m>.ju,ily, mc .... ~ ."d d"""mO,," ":c'"" .".<le,·..1 \0 be I,,,,!,,«J.
u"d'~ c!< ed I'r • • y """"i'u''''',.1 ",,, .. in", hod 1.",,0.1 .... ,. ) I r. l'OINJ.)t:XTtl! I"KI 0" Ihe "bl. co""'''
"00,,~,1 •
• en",rr , I, ......uIJ yiold I l '~ 'I"."in". . ·n. hi",. df, l,~ men," wi,;." h< p"'po".,,1 '0 m.ko i" Ihe bill "PP" 'P""·
h.d beo", r""" 1, •• "",Iiut life, deoply ,,,".h<"<.1 10 ,I,c ;"g, fCOl·' Iin,i,,,1 'in .. , 'h~ proee<d., "f \1,,, r',~lic Lo"J,.
Union; ... d he" relt, wi,h • p",po,tKon>lC in'cn,i,y, the $<c.
impOtta~cc of Ihi. '1".'''00 . h' hi. eorly y"",I, he haJ
cheri,hed. d~<p " nd enU,u, i• .,icadmi"lloro of II,is U"ioH_ " VIII. IC LA ).; ') S.
lie I.. d 1""lr;eJ Ufo its ptolr"''' ,vilh .. pI UN", oml ~""uu· The Se .... l. 11.." I'roct'e,kJ 10 'he eun,i,le""ion of ,he
..ged 'be moo, .. ng>""" "'peo,.,lon, of II. cml" ... ,c~. b,1I aI'WOI"i>ti"jJ", (y< 3 lim;I.J "m,·, II!e 1"..",,'...10 of Ibe
11 0 .Im "diey",l Ih .. ifi! .",,)d be co"ro'm~d 10 d,e p"'''. r"b!,c I~M" !ce .
c' ple. of 1798, "" th~)· "·C", then construed, il mighl en· Mr. III ,ACK, of Mi";";ppi, ",,,, bu' for Ihe 1'... "1,,, oi.
dure fo... ,·e. . ilri"1( bad; Ihe Go.e,nmenl to 'h""" prin. ,,,.I'o~;~ wl,iob I,. "'.. placetl, .tiet to much 1.. ,·inS" been
ciple., .nd he ",,,,,1<1 he ihe b" 10 "b,mlon iI, ",,!'Sm.lh ",id on ,hi, ""bj«" both at tI,e Pt~.''''t and I.., ....ion of
Cotolino "001<1 be om,,"!;", iI, Wanne .. '","oc~t<.. 1.1,,' C"ngt"e~ .nd .,id, ''''', b y ".,,~Ieme~ ", I" , ju.~I,· cu'!'.
,kp'" ftom II,t.., pr,ne,pl"...",1 in lloe 'ou",,, "f t. n ",.>nd ~ h'h-ll r'pu","on r"r tl,~" "'",<I,,tI, .,"1 . ~pc ...n.. ,"
y.... Wt .ban de<><-"t'''''e into ~ ",ili"'l ,k.poliom_ .ali<.>tul on:'i.-., I,e M,onM ",,' h,v~ lro~bkd the S<R~le
The cl")' h. d he •• , .. i.. d, "the Union i•. in 'nge'," I) e with " ny r~m"l, . If......,$!e<I, hO"·"YN, th .. ,I", inopo'.
knew of no 0,1 •• ,. Janl<"t but th,l of m,)itary .Je"l,o\i"",. tone ...f Ihe . "bjed, i" , ,,I.i.g, p •• h' 1», the l,""n'luiUi\,
H. would pt"OCbim il on Ihi, A""r, ,b~t ,hi. "... , ,h0ltt<at. of Il", 1;nio" , .. nd ctr,,,;,,ly II,. 1"",!, .. i1y of Ihe SlAt."
... danger ... jlh " 'hieh i, w .. mcn.o<d .......
eOl ,.b'C!' . ny counl'y h..! 10 ,pi' ... h.,,~.
""n. . .
·rl"" grcsI. he l,ad 'he ho"or ,tI part ,0. ",,,,.,,sc"',
" 'o,,ld p~ •.'l<1 h..
' rol~gy f",. ••ti,,!: r.... . fe .... mon",,, .. t~. al<C!l\i"" of Ihe
He begs.,1 pordo" for the "",,,mil, wid, wl,ielt he bad Sen ....
HP"'..."J him..,lr. Unb".oming" h. k "e"' tI, .. ,.,"",110 W e ,,·ho '''p«. enl 110. new Sla'~' (';'1 ~I '. !l.) I'a'·.
Iv W , he mn$! tll .... w ltim.<I f 0" hi. counlty and hi. CO"". b~en up«iall, i" ,·ited br Il""~tlt"mc" 10 .~h" w.lh lI'cHI
tryme~ r.". indulge""e. Sil""cd •• I.e ...." , .. d fceli,,!> i" thi. "'nic~ . To ""mc of u.I .... L•• n oOc,e<1 Ihe un.
.. II. did, be c<>lll~ not It."" 'polle" oth"rwi.e . p"'i~g cOl,.meuli<ln of f,ve I",,,,,, .. ,, lil"", ,,,,l .c.... of
Mr. I'ORS\ T tI .. id . on the moti"" to .er.., 0.11 00 .., · hnd , ,nd t ... <Ive pc, c<nl .", Ih. a,""un' of .. I.... buun·
.olion, on ,h . .... ";to of 'he !' rc';,len". me .... '" ..'~r~ tr; ."d ..... r- Ji,·;dc",J " i,l , ,h"m 1""l'o,","'nod .«"tdinS"
i...... lennl ond i""~g>.I", '0 f,,oJ,,,..1 no,nb ... , •• yearly !"r , F.,r nn., I to . ..., de-
)Ir. Co\UI OUI'f .. id Joe h..:! so &talcd iWlbe out,. , o( Ic,-mined ." ",r.,.., Ih ~ h OI''''}·, reJccI t1, ~ (>0)", M,rl \0
hi' remarks, and .pol ogi~"" fo, il. d.oIitt~ the .... ice. 10m ""II a",., • • ,h .. in'" duing, my
) 1•. FO H S YTI1 ._Tr,,~, Iho So ,l>.lor ftom So"th Cor... judgment win b. ""lIeJ in '1""""0" by "","y, e,· ~" of
Iina hod .dmi,ttd Ihe ui,le!l"" oflh. ruk, ",d h..:l1:i ,-." Iltooe ... 11Me .G"'?'I op,nlo"" J h.,e hcon ""cu.to,ned to
,,,.1><:,, p"";bleucuoc fur 'he .in!>.ti." ~fi'. Mr. F. 1».<1 .,Iu~. "1"0 ,"""lica',., U,~t"do,. , the cu"el,,';o .. , t" ~ ilkh
no ,uch ~""u ... 10 olf~" ,her.,ro .... , ",,,,,1.1 no' f~\I<>w ,I .., I I.• ,·. come in ' hi. '"'''or-, I ",ill . I~.o i" a b,ief, b~t I
e;.ampl. , f..... " Jo .. ,ltQI")' ............. 'he ...u o". wl.Le], I,,,,·. i",I"".d
Th e P ruidonl h .. in Ihe eI cc"lion oFl,i. ,)ul y, f,.,,,,kl)' Ihem.
aM openly up,... ..." I,i. opi"io ... . "d !he f,els .n,1 "'•. The ""rn ....."e.. w"h " "hi,,h ,1 .. , .neM"", .... '" bto,,&hI
...... upon wb.ell 'hry "·ere found.~. The S.".lo. f!"Om f..r-u, ~"I, and Ibe >c.l ,,·1,1, "·hiel, it I,u b~en preuod
Sou,b C.toli'l>, on Ih. part <>f hi, SI.'e, h. d int.'V".ed upu,. Ihe Se .. ,'", C"'HOot h.,·. coc.>pe,1 ,Joe ob •• " ·.. ,, ·,, of
h;" tk.iol. T ho: iuue i, r.irly n,od~; Ih~ eomp ... '" It;. '''y. It i, f"",d Ibal \bee 'Y'''I''om . ","nif." \O".,h.
bunal w,ll Melde. Ther... ., one or II, • ...,mo,ks Qf'h~ p. rt "f ""m. ~ "·1'" '0 pre .. tI,i. qu . .. io.~ th""'lI'I, Ihe
Se.... tor !II.. . '. fell him.elf I>ound pr<>mp\ly 10 n>.>tice, le.1 Sen, .. , 'h>I i, nuv h ..·• all impo,., . n. b~"ng 0'" ' "Qlh •.~
bis oikR"e might be oon.l ru<J inlO oc'l"i<!tCe"ce· T he ,""uure wl'ieto WIll pro\>. bl)- eume up. wilh ,,-I,,ch .• h, ...
I'",";denl;" du.rg«l witb ,nw",i,lency of opinion i" d,. i",ima",I,· ""nn,eted. My .Uusi~ " , li,·. i. 10 . "J.. <tion
cooe, of SOUlb C. ",Ii", or", G. uryp... of 11,e ,Iulioo on imporll, It is my inle~li~n 10 ~lntoi"
(~( •. C. n pl1in'-d. H co.llud<:d only 10 tbe opi"ion Ih.t from .~y ,""O)><lo <.>fI Ihi. l,,'~re .. i"g, lou u"i',,,S", And,
the S"p,..,meGoll" W' O " ~"'! .. bi'~r.l 11»<1 .Jm".1 .. id, . ,. ful .. ,bje<;t J I, .. ~ .n",le, l.o it for
Mr. F .... id it was""," impor'"'''' '0 Ihe .~t e,,' oflbe Ibe putpooe of giving it ~, my ol,inion, anJ J ... bm.i t it
a1ly"on. A, the sole ... p .... . "uti'-e at preHn! [Go"ern • .. iU, defe,...ne~ '" Ihe S~""t< , tl'~I, nll""r ui,;ting dr·
Or T llO C. i. co"fin,d by indispolilio,,) of Ooorg'" he "~m...,,¢e., no ob .... elc .hou ~ l b~ p~rmitt td t~ intotl'Ct><
.m...1 P'Ole" . p;".1 'h~ co ....r \;Mtgi. b~,ng con f""nd. bc,"-c~n u, and the :tdj""",,~nt , and Ihe 'pee,ly . djll '"
ed with tI .. t .'Sou,h C&r<llina . U. b. d, On 0 forme ... "". ruell', of \10., qu"'ion . It "'
tbwjSht .lhal ' be ."'~"''' of
,