Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at .
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
.
JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range of
content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new forms
of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org.
Sage Publications, Inc. and University of Utah are collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend
access to Political Research Quarterly.
http://www.jstor.org
Political Research Quarterly
Volume 63 Number 1
March 201Q 203-217
Olga Avdeyeva
Loyola University Chicago
The article explores government compliance with international pressures measured as policy adoption and institu
tional reform.The findings reveal that government compliance is determined by the domestic political system and
depends on the configuration of political actors mobilized in support of reform.Legislative reform is facilitated by a
strongwomen's movement and mobilized female parliamentarians. Institutional reform depends on the strengthof
thewomen's movement and its ability to form coalitions with political actors within government elites, most impor
tantlygoverning parties. Finally, the effectofwomen's movements' actors on the institutional reform ismoderated by
the ideology of political parties in power.
May 1, 2004, eleven countriesentered the governments are more likely to transpose EU equality
On European Union (EU) after almost a decade of directives in domestic legislation than establish viable
accession negotiations and considerable reform of institutions to enforce new equality policies, which
domestic institutions and legislation. Eight of these reveals a decoupling between two stages of compli
newly accepted members represented countries of the ance. To investigate this gap in government compli
former communist block. After the collapse of com ance, I propose analysis of domestic political systems
munism across Central and Eastern Europe (CEE) in that takes into consideration multiple political actors,
1989, the prospects of achieving membership in the their positions in the policy-making process, and their
EU becamea strong incentive for these countries to level of mobilization in support of or in opposition to
implement all social, economic, and legal chapters of new international requirements. In this project, gov
Community Law, including provisions on the equal ernment compliance with international requirements is
opportunities of women and men in the workplace. viewed as a government input in a policy-making pro
Despite the strong interest in achieving membership, cess rather than an outcome of the government reform.
however, national reforms on gender equality demon Thus, I concentrate on government action or inaction
strated surprising variation in terms of scope, com to change and enforce policies on gender equality in
prehensiveness, and implementation. Why did the the workplace, but I do not study the effects of the
governments of postcommunist states respond differ reform at the level of theworkplace.
ently to EU pressures to adopt policies on gender The findings reveal that five factors determine the
equality in the workplace and establish government degree of government compliance: (1) level of mobi
institutions to oversee the implementation of these lization of civil society advocates, or women's move
policies? ments, in support of compliance with international
To answer this question, I conceptualize govern
ment compliance with EU accession requirements as
a two-stage process that consists of adoption of poli Author's Note: I am grateful to Laurel Weldon, Amy Mazur,
Richard Vincent Mahler, three anonymous
cies on gender equality in theworkplace, or transpo Matland, reviewers,
and editors for their helpful comments and suggestions on this
sition of EU directives in domestic legislation, and
article. An earlier version of the article was presented at the 2006
reform, thought of as developing
institutional an
annual meeting of theAmerican Political Science Association in
institutional capacity to enforce these policies. Data Philadelphia. The data can be accessed at http://www.luc.edu/
from ten postcommunist countries demonstrate that politicalscience/publications.shtml.
203
204 Political Research Quarterly
requirements; (2) proportion of women in national the application of innovation and diffusion to institu
parliaments;(3) the ideologyof dominantparties in tional structures and cross national comparisons in
national parliaments; (4) level of countries' prepared their analysis of organizational and structural simi
ness for accession (determined by the round of acces larities across different countries (Meyer and Rowan
sion negotiations); and (5) level of unemployment in 1977;Meyer and Scott 1992;Meyer et al. 1997).This
the country (it has a negative effect). These findings research investigates the effects of wider social envi
support major explanations of government compli ronment on the goals and composition of organiza
ance with international requirements in international tions arguing that structural attributes and goals of
relations and comparative literature. one organization are correlated with structures and
The examination of government compliance by goals of other organizations at that time and lead to
stages?policy adoption and institutional reform?re structural and formal convergence (Meyer and Rowan
veals several interesting nuances of these major find 1977;Meyer and Scott 1992).
ings: different factors influence the degree of reform In general, political science scholarship recognizes
in these two stages. Four factors determine the degree three important mechanisms of policy diffusion?
of policy adoption: the strength of women's move coercion, persuasion, and acculturation (Hafner
ments, number of women in parliaments, level of pre Burton and Tsutsui 2005; Goodman and Jinks 2004).
paredness for accession, and level of unemployment. Coercion implies military measures and economic
Ideology of governing parties in parliament does not incentives and benefits in inducing change in state
matter for policy adoption. Parliaments, regardless behavior (Keohane 1984; Downs, Rocke, and
of their ideological makeup, change domestic legisla Barsoom 1996; Waltz 1979). In this regard, condi
tion in response to EU requirements. For institutional tional requirements to comply with EU Directives
reform, however, the ideology of governing parties in imposed on candidate states is a coercive measure
parliaments matters: women's movements and party that seeks to change state policies and practices
ideology facilitate the creation of viable institutions on (Kelley 2004). Persuasion is another mechanism for
gender equality. Moreover, the interaction between the inducing policy innovation and diffusion that seeks to
strength of women's movements and party ideology is change state policies
and practices through normative
statistically significant and confirms that the ideologi change among key state actors (Risse-Kappen 1995;
cal makeup of national parliaments determines the Risse and Sikkink 1999). Acculturation describes the
ability of women's groups to access the policy-making process of social pressures imposed on state actors by
process. The study advances the thesis that interna other states or international governmental and non
tional pressures are refracted by the domestic political governmental organizations that forces them to adopt
system, specifically by the configuration of actors new policies. This process relies on various strategies
mobilized in support of compliance. of social influence including, but not limited to,
social rewards and punishments (shaming, social
exclusion, publishing best and worst practices) and
Theoretical Explanations of policy emulation (mimicking policies and practices
State Compliance in other states) (Avdeyeva 2007; Goodman and Jinks
2004; Keck and Sikkink 1998).
The question of government compliance with Policy diffusion literature is not new to scholars of
international treaties speaks to the large literature on gender politics and comparative feminist policy.
policy innovation and policy diffusion that received Skocpol et al. (1993) investigated the effect of wom
much attention in political science scholarship (Berry en's grassroots associations on the enactment of
andBerry 1990;Gray 1973;Meyer andRowan 1977; mothers' pensions in the United States. Katzenstein
Meyer and Scott 1992; Mintrom 1997; Skocpol et al. and Mueller (1987) looked at the role of women's
1993;Walker 1969). Policy diffusion is generally movements in the diffusion of feminist ideas in the
defined inWalker's terms as a state adoption of a law United States and Europe. Berkovitch (1999) offered
which is new to the state (Gray 1973;Walker 1969). a detailed account of the critical role played by inter
In particular, early research on policy diffusion stud national organizations in the promotion of women's
ied the process of policy adoption in the U.S. states rights in individual nation-states. Boyle and Preves
explaining the speed, timing, and patterns of policy (2000) considered the importance of local constituen
adoption (Gray 1973; Lockard 1968; Skocpol et al. cies versus international normative influence in creat
1993; Walker 1969). Sociological accounts expanded ing and enforcing laws against female genital cutting.
Avdeyeva / States' Compliance with International Requirements 205
Zippel (2006) investigatedtheemergenceof sexual content of public policy, changing social values, and
harassment policy in the United States and its travel transforming government institutions (Dryzek 1990;
across the Atlantic, where this concept was taken up Rochon andMazmanian 1993; Weldon 2002). Scholars
first by the European Union, the United Kingdom, of international relations have studied the effects of
and Ireland and latermore gradually in other European transnational NGOs as promoters of policy change on
countries. the domestic level (Clark 2001; Keck and Sikkink
This studywill build on theliterature
of policy dif 1998; True and Mintrom 2001). Within the compara
fusion, concentrating on states' formal response to tive field, the impact of civil society actors has been
EU pressures to adopt policies on gender equality in studied by scholars of social mobilization and social
the workplace and create government institutions to movements (Diani and McAdam 2003; Rochon 1998;
oversee the implementation of this policy. Formal Rochon andMazmanian 1993; Tilly 1997).Work on
and structural similarity as a result of policy diffusion women's movements mirrors the broader social move
across nation-statesis emphasized in the sociological ment literature and relies on its theoretical foundations,
account of diffusion, which recognizes decoupling such as political opportunity structure, resource mobi
between states' formal commitments to international lization, and cultural framing (Beckwith 2000). Using
treaties and domestic practice (Meyer et al.
1997; themodels developed by social movement theories in
Hafner-Burton and Tsutsui 2005). Interestingly, pol sociology, women's movement scholarship concerned
icy scholars have predicted the decoupling between itself with compiling data on specific campaigns and
EU member-states commitments to gender equality movements, studying the sequence of events, and
policies and their actual enforcement of these policies explicating conditions formovement success and fail
as well (Hoskyns 1996).What this study seeks to ures (Beckwith 2000). Another large set of literature
in states' responses to
reveal is that there is variation links women's movement activities and women's pol
the EU formal pressures to adopt policies on gender icy-generating recommendations about how to make
equality, even when the candidate states know that women-friendly policies (e.g., Kaplan 1992; Lewis
gender equality law is not high on the EU agenda. 1997;Meehan and Sevenhuijsen 1991; Singh 1998;
What thismeans is that ultimately policies and insti Hantrais 2000). Some studies use social movement
tutions matter, even if they are intended as symbolic theory to analyze a single movement (Costain 1992;
and formal responses to international pressures. Laws Ferree and Hess 1994; Hellman 1987; Lovenduski and
and policies can create opportunities for social actors Randall 1993;Ray 1999).Many otherstudiesfocuson
to demand change from state actors and enforce de movements in different countries, but they usually
jure commitments (Hafner-Burton and Tsutsui 2005; employ historical and descriptive methods and have
Keck and Sikkink 1998). relaxed criteria for comparison (e.g., Bull, Diamond,
The case of EU Enlargement is interesting for dif andMarch 2000; Bystydzienski1992;Dahlerup 1986;
fusion study for another reason: it demonstrates that Ferree and Martin 1995; Katzenstein and Mueller
conditional requirements do not explain variation in 1987). There are very few studies that employ system
state responses despite scholarly expectation that atic cross-national analysis of women's movements
coercion generates compliance. Despite all candidate and their impact on policy making and the state (e.g.,
states receiving similar incentives and facing similar Women's Movement and Reconfigured States
punishments in case of noncompliance, we find [WMRS], Research Network on Gender Politics and
variation in the levels of their domestic legislative the State [RNGS], Enlargement, Gender and
and institutional reform. I argue this variation can be Governance: The Civic and Political Participation and
explained by differences in domestic political envi Representation of Women in Central and Eastern
ronment and propose to look inside candidate states Europe [EGG], Gendered Citizenship inMulti-Cultural
to find out which factors impeded or facilitated gov Europe: The Impact of Contemporary Women's
ernment capacity to comply with international Movements [FEMCIT]; formore details on these and
requirements on gender equality. I draw on several other systematic comparative projects, see the review
important explanations put forward in comparative by Mazur 2007). Of these projects, only one focuses
politics and comparative gender policies literature, on EU Enlargement countries (the EGG project); how
which I discuss below. ever, it largely relies on descriptive analysis in examin
It is widely acknowledged that social movements ing the contribution of women's movements to
have an impact on government policy making. Social women's policies in these countries. This article
movements have been credited with changing the seeks to fill the gap in the literature and examine the
206 PoliticalResearch Quarterly
impact of women's movement actors on the levels of In general, the scholarship on social movements
government compliance with EU Enlargement require and women's movements views political parties as a
ments in systematic comparative analysis. This leads political opportunity for explaining the success or
us to the following hypothesis: failure of themovement (Banaszak 1996; Bashevkin
1998; Costain 1992; Hellman 1987; Katzenstein
Hypothesis 1: Governments are morelikely to 1987; Katzenstein and Mueller 1987; Ray 2000).
comply with international requirements on gen Political parties provide or deny access to political
der equality when they face a strong women's participation by social actors, including women's
movement, mobilized in support of adoption movement actors, and create realignments within the
and implementation of gender equality policies. political system, which can be negative or positive for
the women's movements. They also can bring influ
Societal factors other than women's movements ential allies in support of women's policies. The
can influence government decisions to stall or pro focus of my analysis on labor rights of female work
mote policy reforms on gender equality. Activist civil ers will enhance our understanding about the effects
groups in support of conservative values or groups of party ideologies on this policy issue. First, I will
that embrace norms of neoliberalism focused on examine an independent effect of political parties on
unregulated market can advance ideological positions the degree of government compliance with EU gen
opposite to those of women's groups. Conservative der equality requirements, and second, I will examine
activism can divert governments' attention from gen the interaction effect of party ideology and the
der equality policies to traditional family values poli
strength of women's movements to test the hypothe
cies, thus impeding the course of reforms (P.Watson sis that parties provide political opportunities to
2000). Conservative activists include religious organ social movement actors.
izations, nationalist movements, conservative labor
organizations threatened by the expansion of wom Hypothesis 3: Governments are more likely to
en's rights on the labor market, and conservative comply with international norms on gender
public (Fuszara 2003; Lohmann and Seibert 2003; equality when left parties dominate national
Matynia 2003; Nowakowska 2000). parliaments.
Hypothesis 2: Governments are more likely to Feminist research that has emerged within politi
comply with international requirements on gen cal science has investigated issues of social represen
der equality when there is no strong conserva tation (Pateman 1988; Phillips 1995; Pitkin 1967).
tivemovement in the country. Alone the arguments that the exclusion
with of
women from the political decision making is undem
The ideological composition of national parlia ocratic, more and more research evolves around the
ments has an impact on policy outcomes. National issue of differences in interests between male and
parliaments are composed of elected deputies nomi female parliamentarians that affects their policy deci
nated by different political parties. Political parties sions (Bratton and Ray 2002; Lovenduski and Norris
have established agendas on issues of gender equality 1994; Norris, Vallance, and Lovenduski 1992; Purdy
in the workplace. Research demonstrates that the 1992; Sclozman et al.
1995; Vega and Firestone
left-right ideology influences party position on gen 1995). Women are believed to have a common inter
der equality and equal opportunity of men and est as a group that can be overlooked by male politi
women (Esping-Andersen 1993; Mazur 2002). Left cians (Wangnerud 2000). Thus, the lack of women in
parties are found to be supportive of gender equality, political decision making reflects not only a "politics
whereas right parties are less responsive to demands of presence" but also an impact generated by their
to accommodate women workers on the labor market presence (Phillips 1995).
(Christensen 1999; Costain 1992; Stetson and Mazur Some researchers credit gender with a considerable
1995).Morgan and Zippel (2003) found thatright effect on policy preferences. In their study of the
wing parties supported family care leave policies in British parliament, Lovenduski and Norris (1994)
several West European countries; similarly we can found thatwomen have more feminist and leftist radi
find that right parties supported maternity and paren cal values thanmen. They concluded that the election
tal leave policies but opposed other gender equality ofmore women to parliament makes more than "just a
policies promotedby theEU. symbolic difference" (p. 224). Similarly, Wangnerud
Avdeyeva / States' Compliance with International Requirements 207
(2000), in her analysis of parliamentary surveys from Montgomery2003; Rene-Roe 2003; Saxonberg2000;
1985, 1988, and 1994 conducted in the Swedish Siemenska 2004; Silovic 2004). This article will inves
Rikstag, found that female politicians to a greater tigate if female members of parliaments make a differ
extent thanmale politicians advance policies on social ence in changing and enforcing policies on gender
welfare and gender equality. Gender equality policies equality in EU Enlargement countries.
are almost exclusively pursued by the female MPs.
Bochel and Briggs (2000) found that femaleMPs Hypothesis 4: Governments are more likely to
bring women's concerns for consideration of the par comply with international requirements on gen
liament and gave an example of an act against female der equality when there is a greater proportion
circumcision and an attempt to abolish taxation on of female MPs in national parliaments.
programs have been adopted by the Scottish parlia policy adoption and implementation in ten postcom
ment thanks to a strong 37 percent female representa munist countries, I propose to control for several
tion (Ross 2002). Linos (2003) finds thatnumberof additional factors that can have an impact on govern
women in power has a direct influence on the improve ments' compliance with international requirements.
ment of policies and institutions related to gender in First, I propose to account for countries' general
Spanish regional governments. Similarly, Swers (2002) readiness to enter the European Union. Cowles,
demonstrated that, even though representatives often Caporaso, and Risse (2001) argued that the degree of
vote a party line, their gender is politically significant Europeanization, or countries' ability to adhere to the
and does indeed influence policy making. Swers EU policy standards in different policy areas, depends
argued that gender ofmembers of Congress moderates on the fit between existing national policies and EU
their party identification. requirements. This proposition asserts that countries
Some other researchers are more
skeptical about where domestic policies are closer to the EU stand
the effect of gender on policy preferences of mem ards tend to quickly adopt and enforce policies pro
bers of parliaments (Reingold 1996). Esaiasson and moted by theEU Community Law (Cowles, Caporaso,
Holmberg (1996) reviewedpolicy attitudesof female and Risse 2001). All accession countries were divided
and male members of the Swedish Rikstag and con by the EU experts in two categories?early and late
cluded that overall the difference between men's and accession states depending on their relative readiness
women's attitudes was small on most of the investi for accession, which, among many factors, also
gated issues; however, regardless of party identifica accounted for the fit between domestic policies and
tion, female MPs demonstrated somewhat different the EU requirements. The European Commission
takes on policies related to social welfare, environ (EC) started accession negotiations with countries of
ment, and morals. Weldon (2002) found that a per the first round for accession (Hungary, Poland, Czech
centage of women in legislature is a weak predictor Republic, Slovenia, and Estonia) in 1998. The EC
of policy outcomes in the area of violence against started negotiations with countries of the second
women. McAllister and Studler
(1992) found very round in 1999: Romania, Slovakia, Latvia, Lithuania,
limited differences between female and male parlia and Bulgaria. These countries were considered less
mentarians of one party inAustralia. The only policy prepared for accession. This leads to the following
area where women's views were different from those expectation:
of men was gender-related policies. This conundrum
in the literature suggests that contribution of women Hypothesis 5: Governments are more likely to
in parliaments depends on whether female parliamen adopt and implement international requirements
tarians endorse a feminist agenda. on gender equality in the workplace in those
Most of the research on representation, interests, countries that were initially better prepared for
and policy preferences has been done on Western accession.
labor markets are marked by high levels of unemploy the European Union, which established a single stan
ment, governments will be more reluctant to adopt and dard of policy across the countries.
implement policies on gender equality in the work Gender equality policies create another important
Hypothesis 6: Governments are less likely to com Usually these provisions implied equal access towork
ply with international requirements on gender and education by women and men but did not include
unem an antidiscrimination clause. Communist recognition
equality when they face high levels of
ployment in the country. of equality was symbolic and worked only under a
planned economy of full employment. Under this
In addition, countries' overall socioeconomic devel regime, individuals could not exercise their right to
opment can have an impact on the speed and scope of employment or promotion, for instance by taking their
states' compliance with international requirements. cases to courts if they felt discriminated; the right to
Gross domestic product is a good proxy formeasuring employment and education was granted by the state
levels of economic development and their impact on and, thus, could be easily removed by the state. In terms
government action/inaction over time. of specific job protection provisions, all states had
some form of maternity and parental leave either fully
Hypothesis 7: Governments in countries with or partiallypaid by thestatewith job protection;
most
higher levels of GDP and growing levels of states also had some form of protective labor laws for
GDP over time are more likely to comply with women, for example, women were excluded from cer
international requirements on gender equality in taintypesof jobs,which includedheavyweight lifting
theworkplace. or underground work. No state had recognition of
particularly important for capturing those ideological training and promotion, safety and health of pregnant
struggles that evolved in postcommunist societies, and breastfeeding workers, parental leave regula
including an ideological divide around gender equality tions, equal treatment of part-time and self-employed
and equal opportunities formen and women. Third, all workers, equal treatment of men and women in occu
these countries went through a process of accession to pational and statutory social security schemes, and a
Avdeyeva / States' Compliance with International Requirements 209
shift of burden of proof (Commission of the European equality; this concept refers to various government
Communities 2003). Despite strong conditional institutions established to enforce policies on gender
requirements, I find variation in government compli equality. Three criteria for comparison include the
ance with EU requirements. What, then, can we expect following components: (1) The institutional status
in cases where international organizations rely on gov considers where in the hierarchy of governmental
ernment voluntary participation in treaty compliance? institutions the offices on gender equality are placed.
Very few other international organizations (IOs) can Gender equality offices placed within Ministries on
impose similar conditional requirements on their Labor and Social Affairs, or other relevant ministries,
member-states. Although the generalization of find are defined as low-profile institutions. These institu
ings can be problematic for those IOs thatheavily rely tions have very limited policy-making capacities and
on socialization strategies and states' voluntary com do not have access to other branches (the of power
pliance with treaties, the study suggests thatwe should Czech Republic). High-profile institutions are those in
expect low government compliance with such treaties the status of a ministry, or placed within the Cabinet
ifno other incentives are present (e.g., economic coop of the President or the Cabinet of the Prime Minister
eration or trade benefits). Thus, the findings of this (Lithuania, Hungary, Poland from 2001 to 2005).
research can be of interest not only to scholars of (2) Functions of gender equality offices include advi
Europeanization but also to those public policy sory, coordinating (between various government min
researchers who are interested in the interaction of istries), legislative, of legislation on
enforcement
international policy and domestic policy change. gender equality, monitoring of discrimination, and
provision of legal help to victims of discrimination.
(3) Connection and collaboration with women's non
consider two main groups of substantive variables to the activity of movement actors in regard to
test the theory. Z is a matrix of domestic political policies and government institutions on gen
system variables that I offer to test my theoretical der equality. It is assessed on a 0 to 1 scale: no
framework, and X is a matrix for all other control fac activity, lobbying for traditional family values
tors that influence levels of government compliance policies, protesting against gender equality
with international requirements. I review these groups policies.
of variables in detail below. Equations 1, 2, and 3 3. Proportion of female members in parliament:
assert that two stages of states' compliance with Measures the percentage of women in national
international requirements (policy adoption and pol parliaments for each year of observation.
icy implementation) in every observed year is a func 4. Ideology of governing party: Utilizes a tradi
tion of the strength of women's movements, the tional ideological division between parties
strength of opposition movements, ideology of gov centered on their socioeconomic policy plat
erning party in national parliaments, proportion of forms. I utilize Bugajski's (2002) operational
women parliamentarians, a series of control variables, framework of party ideology in CEE coun
and a stochastic term. The fourthmodel will present tries. It refers to ideology of the governing
the effect of all aforementioned variables and the (majority) party in national parliaments or
effect of interaction between the strength of women's governing coalition. This variable is assessed
movement and the ideology of ruling majority in on a scale from 0 to 4: right, center-right,
national parliaments on institutional reform. Thus, it center, center-left, and left.
will test for specific links between these two factors
and possible effects of this link on the level of state Control variables. I introduce three control vari
ables identified by scholars as having effect on states'
compliance with international requirements.
To estimate parameters, I employ the linear cross compliance with international requirements. Two of
sectional times-series random effects models because these variables measure socioeconomic development:
the data set ismore suitable for random effects mod gross domestic product of the country and level of
els as it has an equal number of cases and periods, unemployment. The third one describes overall coun
tries' preparedness for accession: those countries that
whereas data sets with relatively fewer cases and
signed the accession agreement early are considered
larger periods are suggested for fixed-effects analy better prepared for accession; those that signed acces
sis. The Hausman test supports the use of random sion agreements with EU later are considered second
effectsmodels: I receive insignificant p-values, prob. > round accession countries.
= =
X2 larger than .05 (prob. > %2 1.000; prob. > %2 .06; A variety of primary and secondary sources was
> =
prob. %2 .2735). used tomeasure these variables. Original data were
collected during my field research in Poland and
Czech Republic (spring2005). They include inter
Independent Variables and Data
views with governmental officials and officers in
Domestic labor inspections and trade unions; interviews with
political systems (Z). I introduce four
variables that measure dimensions of the domestic activists from nongovernmental organizations; and
political system that can have impact on states' com interviews with scholars and experts on gender and
pliance with EU accession requirements: social policy. A broad array of documents surveyed
in this study include transcripts of
parliamentary
1. Strength of women's movements: Following debates pertaining to gender equality issues and
Stetson and Mazur (2003), it concentrates on EU directives in this area. Governmental programs
the activity of women's movements actors. and electoral platforms of governmental officials
This operationalization is centeredspecifi and winning parties and party coalitions in regard
cally on the activities of women's groups in to the social policies in question were analyzed in
regard to policies and government institutions all ten countries. Independent monitoring reports
on gender equality. It is assessed on a 0 to 1 and EU monitoring and assessment documents in
scale: no activity, symbolic cooperation with regard to domestic gender politics and statistical
governments, lobbying for powerful institu information on socioeconomic development in the
tions, protesting against government inaction. ten countries of analysis were obtained from the
2. Strength of conservative movement: Follows International Labor Organization and the World
similar operationalization concentrating on Bank.
Avdeyeva / States' Compliance with International Requirements 211
Table 1
Cross-Sectional Times Series Analysis on Government Compliance with
EU Accession Requirements on Gender Equality, 1995-2004
*p<.05. **p<.001.
significant positive effects on government compli security systems, which is explained by states' commit
ance as a combined score of policy adoption and ments to maintain communist pension privileges to
institutional change, and it is a statistically significant working women, who did not establish personal pen
effect for each individual process?policy adoption sion plans.
and institutional reform in candidate countries. This Thethird finding of the analysis develops along
finding is remarkably consistent with scholarly expec similar lines: female members of parliament have
tations about the role of social movement actors in stronger influence over legislative changes rather
ensuring government compliance with international than the creation of institutions on gender equality.
cally significant in explaining the scope of policy adop mentary systems), members of parliament have deci
tion, but itdoes matter for government compliance as a sion-making power on the legislative agenda; but the
combined process and for institutional change in the institutional enforcement of new laws, including the
direction thathas been expected inmy hypothesis: left establishment of government institutions that oversee
parties tend to facilitate the reform of policies and insti the implementation of policies, is a prerogative of the
tutions on gender equality in ten EU candidate states. executive branch. Thus, women parliamentarians are
This finding suggests an interesting observation: to effectively excluded from ensuring institutional
facilitate the accession process, ruling parties in parlia reforms on gender equality by the political system
ment change national legislation regardless of their itself. Case study analysis reveals that it is not only
ideological stands, but they tend to stall institutional the number or female parliamentarians, but also their
reform if gender equality policies are not consistent organization within parliament, thatmatters for pol
with their ideological positions. This observation is icy change. In Poland and Lithuania, where female
very important for emphasizing the usefulness of a two MPs were catalysts of policy reform, theywere orga
the largest presence in parliaments?26 percent? The level of countries' economic development
theywere not organized in support of gender equality expressed in GDP does not influence states' compli
reform, which explains the state failure to adopt ance with EU accession requirements on gender
equality legislationinBulgaria by 2004. equality. The level of countries' preparedness for
The fourth important finding is the significant accession positively affects government compliance
interaction between ideology of the ruling parties in as a whole and for the process of
policy adoption, but
parliaments and the strength of women's movements it produces counterintuitive results for institutional
on the level of institutional reform in EU accession reform: better prepared countries are less likely to
countries. This finding confirms my hypothesis that establish strong institutions to ensure the implemen
women's movement advocates are not single actors on tation of gender equality principles. This puzzling
the domestic political arena: the impact of their activ result has yet to be explored.
itydepends on other political actors, most importantly
the ideology of governing parties. Thus, parties in
parliaments moderate the impact of women's move Ideology of Governing
ment actors on the degree of government compliance Parties and Women's Movements
with international requirements, specifically on the
degree of institutional change in accession countries. It is simplistic to assume that all right-wing
parties
This finding is consistent with evidence from feminist are not supportive of gender
equality policies and insti
comparative policies literature, which views political tutions and all left-wing parties are supportive of them.
parties as political opportunity for women's move The examples of Bulgaria, where ex-communist
parties
ments (Bashevkin 1998; Costain 1992; Katzenstein were quite strong, but gender were not
equality policies
andMueller 1987;Ray 2000). implemented and an institution on gender issues was
Among other findings, it is interesting to note that not created until 2004, and Lithuania, where
right-wing
conservative movements have a statistically signifi parties initiated several important reforms in the area of
cant positive effect on the degree of institutional gender equality, pose several questions: (1) Under
reform on gender equality. This puzzling effect can which circumstances do left-wing parties support gen
be understood in the context of Poland, Hungary, and der equalitypolicies and institutions?
(2)Underwhich
Slovenia, where we find strong conservative move circumstances do right-wing parties oppose reforms in
ments inspired by the Catholic Church. Case studies the area of gender equality?
demonstrate that oppositional movements can pro In this section, I analyze the interaction between
duce activating impact on women's movements, as ideology of ruling parties in parliaments and the
happened, for instance, in these three countries: when strength of women's movements and its effect on the
the conservative sentiment intensified, it led to a levels of institutional reform. Close analysis of country
clash between liberal and conservative camps. Thus, cases reveals that strongwomen's movements are able
paradoxically, strong conservative movements can to influence government decision when they find ideo
have positive effect on the maturation of women's logical supporters within the government, specifically
movements inCEE countries which reinforced social when themajority in parliament does not oppose their
contestation and better policy enforcement. demands. This finding supports my argument thatgov
Another interesting finding is that levels of unem ernment compliance with international
requirements is
ployment influence both stages of government com determined by the configuration of political actors
pliance with EU requirements in the area of gender mobilized in support of new policies. Specifically,
equality in the workplace in the predicted direction. institutional reform can be understood through the
Higher levels of unemployment lead to lower levels process of coalition building between social movement
of policy adoption and institutional change. This actors and government actors. Case study of policy
finding confirms the importance of socioeconomic reforms supports this conclusion.
factors for the degree of state compliance with inter Changes of parties in power from left-wing to
national requirements, but it has a specific implica right-wing explain notable variation in women's
tion for gender equality policies. When countries movement access to policy making in Poland and
experience high unemployment rates, they become their outcomes for the status of government office on
reluctant to adopt equality principles from their labor gender equality. The first Polish Government
regulations (almost all EU directives on equality per Plenipotentiary forWomen was established in 1986
tain to labor market regulations). under the communist government, but in the past
Avdeyeva / States' Compliance with International Requirements 213
rights, and personal freedoms. After the revolutionary the European Commission sent an official warning to
events of 1989, a right-wing government reorganized the Polish government that itwas not going to con
the office on women's affairs into the Government clude accession negotiation with Poland in the area of
Plenipotentiary for Family andWomen, reflecting the social policy if thePolish governmentdid not adjust
importance of the family component in policymaking legislation to the EU standards in the area of equal
(GovernmentPlenipotentiary2004). In 1992 the opportunities for women (N. Watson and Lindberg
office was closed down on the grounds that there was 2002). Although the conservative government reacted
no gender discrimination in Poland and, therefore, to the EU warning and initiated a legislative change, a
there was no need for such office (Nowakowska new office on gender equality was opened only under
2000). Ironically, the first female prime minister of the left-wing government that won parliamentary
Poland, Hanna Suchocka, proposed to shut down the elections at the end of 2001. A left-wing government
Government Plenipotentiary forWomen and Family. established theGovernment Plenipotentiary forEqual
In 1993, new elections brought a reformed ex Status forWomen and Men in accordance with its
communist party back to the Polish
Sejm. For left electoral program. Initially the new
government
parties in Poland, the connection with women's orga planned to place this office in theMinistry of Labor
nizations is traditional: Polish left-wing parties, and Social Affairs, but under the pressure from liberal
including postcommunist parties, relied on the sup women's organizations, the Council of Ministers
port of women's organizations, which made the Polish established the plenipotentiary in the rank of the sec
left susceptible to their demands. Under pressure from retary of the state, as part of the Chancellery of the
women's organizations, ex-communists reestab Prime Minister, which became one of the highest
lished the office on women and family in 1994 before ranked offices in the region. The very name of the
the Beijing Conference on Women. The Beijing office expressed on gender equality and
its focus
Conference became a catalyst for the office develop equal opportunity and reflected the change in policy
ment. It legitimated the activity of women's organiza agenda (Wilkowska 2003). The role of women's
tions, which put pressures on the government to act in groups in promoting policies and institutions on gen
accordance with the UN requirements. The office der equality in Poland was important.Without wom
became quite active in establishing connections with en's NGOs demands and active lobbying, left-wing
international and domestic women's organizations in government would not have established a high-status
strategies and plans (Government Plenipotentiary In countries with weak women's movements, left
2004; Nowakowska 2000). Itdraftedand adopted the parties in parliament did not ensure the implementa
National Plan of Action in response to the Beijing tion of policies on gender equality. In 1998, Czech left
Platform forAction and established the Forum for the social-democratic parties came to power and estab
Cooperation of the Government Plenipotentiary for lished the first office on gender equality. Pursuant to
the Family and Women's Affairs and of Non Government Resolution 8/98, theMinistry of Labor
Governmental Women's Organizations. and Social Affairs has been charged with special com
But it all changed when the 1997 elections brought petence to coordinate policy concerning the status of
right-wing parties back to power, which had an imme women in society. As a result, theMinistry of Labor
diate effect on the office. A conservative right-wing and Social Affairs established the lowest organiza
politician was
appointed the plenipotentiary. The tional office?Unit for Equality between Men and
office name changed to the Plenipotentiary for Family Women?within theministry as part of theDepartment
Affairs. Most of the programs were shut down, includ for Integration to the European Union (Maksova
ing cooperation with women's NGOs, the UNDP Tominova 2003; Linkova 2003). The very status of this
program against domestic violence, work on the adop unit suggests that ithas been established to satisfy the
tion and implementation of the National Plan of EU conditional requirement for the accession, not to
Action, development of the regional network of gov promote gender equality principles. It is not surprising
ernment offices on gender equality, as well as the bill that in three years of its existence, the government has
on equal status of women and men (Zielinska 2002). accepted only one recommendation of theCouncil?to
Overall during this period, the Polish government publish a methodology on gender budgeting, which
214 PoliticalResearch Quarterly
Table 2
InstitutionalReform by StrengthofWomen's Movement and Ideology ofRuling Party
Party Ideology
Women's Left
Movement Center-Left Center Center-Right Right
Strongwomen's movement High (Poland,Hungary) High (Slovenia) Low (Slovenia) Low (Slovakia,
Poland, Hungary)
Weak women's movement Low (Czech Republic, High (Lithuania) Low (Estonia) Higha (Lithuania) Low (Latvia,Bulgaria)
Romania, Bulgaria)
a. Lithuania is an exception with right parties in power initiating and promoting gender equality policies and institutions.
depends on three important variables in the domestic Princeton, NJ: Princeton Press.
University
political arena: (1) the strength of the women's move Bashevkin, Sylvia. 1998. Women on the defensive:
Living through
ment, (2) theideologyof parties inpower, (3) and the conservative times. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Institutional reform is more comprehensive in those Bochel, Catherine, and Jacqui Briggs. 2000. Do women make
difference?Politics 20 (2): 63-68.
accession countries where strongwomen's movements
Boyle, Elizabeth H., and Sharon E. Preves. 2000. National poli
coincided with a left rulingmajority in national parlia
tics as international process: The case of anti-female-genital
ments. Left parties are more supportive of gender
cutting laws. Law and Society Review 34:401-35.
equality policies than right parties; thus, women's Bratton, Kathleen A., and Leonard P. Ray. 2002. Descriptive
movements were more successful in influencing gov representation, policy outcomes, and municipal day-care
left parties dominated in Norway. American Journal of Political Science
ernments' decisions when coverage
46 (2): 428-37.
national parliaments. Social movements, regardless of
Bugajski, Janusz. 2002. Political parties of Eastern Europe: A
strength and organizational capacities, were not suc Guide to politics in the post-communist era. Armonk, NY:
cessful in changing domestic policies under right par M.E. Sharpe.
ties in power. Thus, I conclude, the effect of social Bull, Anna, Hanna Diamond, and Rosalind March, eds. 2000.
movements' actors on domestic policies ismoderated Feminism and women's movements in contemporary Europe.
New York: St. Martin's.
by the ideology of political parties in power. Thus, J. M. 1992. Women
Bystydzienski, transforming politics:
international pressures are refracted by the configura
Worldwide strategies for empowerment. Bloomington: Indiana
tion of domestic political actors mobilized in support Press.
University
of promoted policies. Christensen, Ann-Dorte. 1999. Women in political parties. In
To some extent, the findings are specific to the EU Equal democracies? Gender and politics in the Nordic coun
and Europe. The insightsmost readily apply to candi tries, ed. Christina Bergqvist. Oslo, Norway: Scandinavian
University Press.
dates such as Turkey and the Balkan states seeking
Clark, Ann Marie. 2001. Diplomacy of conscience: Amnesty
accession to theEU. The implications, however, can be International and changing human rights norms. Princeton,
broader, including those international organizations that NJ: Princeton University Press.
rely on conditionality in accession negotiations (e.g., Commission of the European Communities. 2003. Comprehensive
NATO and theWorld Trade Organization). However, a monitoring report of the European Commission on the state of
rights requirements for accession. Ifwe consider gender Costain, Ann. 1992. Inviting women's rebellion: A political pro
Diani, Mario, and Doug McAdam. 2003. Social movements and Kelley, Judith Green. 2004. International actors on the domestic
networks: Relational to collective action. Oxford: scene: Membership and
approaches conditionally socialization by inter
Oxford University Press. national institutions. International Organization 58:425-57.
Downs, George, David M. Rocke, and Peter Barsoom. 1996. Is Keohane, Robert O. 1984. After hegemony. Princeton, NJ: Princeton
the good news about compliance good news for cooperation? University Press.
International Organization 50:379-406. Lewis, Jane, ed. 1997. Lone mothers in European welfare
Dryzek, John S. 1990. Discursive democracy: Politics,policy, and regimes:Shiftingpolicy logics.London: JessicaKingsley.
political science. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Linkova, Marcela. 2003. The institutional framework for equal
Esaiasson, Peter, and Soren Holmberg. 1996. Representation opportunities enforcement. In Women's political civic and
from above. Members of Parliament and representative participation in the Czech Republic and the role of European
democracy in Sweden. Aldershot, UK: Dartmouth. Union gender equality and accession policies, ed. Hana
Esping-Andersen, G.
1993. Changing classes: Stratification and Haskova and Alena Krizkova, 31-41. Sociological Papers.
mobility in post-industrial societies. London: Sage. Prague: Institute of Sociology, Academy of Sciences of the
Ferree, Myra Marx, and Beth B. Hess. 1994. Controversy and Czech Republic.
The new feminist movement
coalition: across three decades of Linos, Katerina. 2003. Are socialists a woman's best friends?
change. Rev. ed. New York: Twayne. Equality policies in theSpanish regions.JournalofEuropean
Ferree, Myra Marx, and Yancey Martin, eds. 1995. Feminist Public Policy 10 (3): 438-62.
organizations: Harvest of the new women's movement. Lockard, Duane. 1968. Toward equal opportunity: A study of state
Philadelphia:Temple UniversityPress. and local anti-discrimination laws. New York: Macmillan.
Fuszara, Malgorzata. 2003. History of women's organizations. In Lohmann, Kinga, and Anita Seibert, eds. 2003. Gender assessment
Civil society inPoland, ed. Jasek Kurczewski, 31-44. Warsaw, of the impact of European Union accession on the status of
Poland: Center for Social Research. women in the labour market in Central and Eastern Europe.
Goodman, Ryan, and Derek Jinks. 2004. How to influence states: National Study: Poland. Warsaw, Poland: Karat Coalition.
Socialization and international human rights law. Duke Law Lovenduski, Joni, and Pippa Norris. 1994. Gender and party
Journal 54:621. politics. Thousand Oaks,
Sage. CA:
Government Plenipotentiary for Equal Status for Women and Lovenduski, Joni, and Vicky Randall. 1993. Contemporary feminist
Men andMinistry of Foreign Affairs,Republic of Poland. politics: Women and power inBritain. Oxford: Oxford University
2004. Questionnaire on of the Beijing Press.
implementation
Platform ofAction (1995) and the outcome of theTwenty Mackie, Jack, and David Marsh. 1997. The comparative method.
Third Special Session of the General Assembly (2000). In Theory and methods in political science, ed. David Marsh
Warsaw, Poland: Government Plenipotentiary for Equal Status and Gerry Stoker. New York: St. Martin's.
forWomen and Men and Ministry of Foreign Affairs. Maksova-Tominova, Michaela, Gender assessment
ed. 2003. of
Gray, Virginia. 1973. Innovation in the states: A diffusion study. the impact of European Union Accession on the status of
American Political Science Review 67:1174-85. women in the labour market in Central and Eastern Europe.
Hafner-Burton, Emilie, and Kiyoteru Tsutsui. 2005. Human National Study: Czech Republic. Prague, Czech Republic
rights in a globalizing world: The paradox of empty promises. Gender Studies, o.p.s.
American Journalof Sociology 110 (5): 1373-1411. Matland, Richard E. 2004. The representation of women in
Hantrais, Linda, ed. 2000. Gendered policies in Europe. London: political parties in Central and Eastern Europe. Presented at
MacMillan. the European Consortium for Political Research, Joint
Haskova, Hana. 2005. Implementing the equality acquis: Czech Sessions ofWorkshops, Uppsala, Sweden, April 13-14.
Republic. Enlargement, gender and governance (EGG). EU Matland, Richard E., and Kathleen E. Montgomery. 2003.
Framework 5, Project no. HPSE-CT-2002-00115. Belfast, Women's access topolitical power inpost-communist Europe.
Northern Ireland: Queens University, Belfast. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Hellman, Judith Adler. 1987. Journeys among women: Feminism Matynia, Elzbieta. 2003. Provincializing global feminism: The
infive Italian cities. New York: Oxford University Press. Polish case. Social Research 70 (2): 499-530.
Hoskyns, Catherine. 1996. Integrating gender: Women, law and Mazur, Amy G. 2002. Theorizing feminist policy. London:
Katzenstein, Mary Fansoid. 1987. Comparing the feminist move McAllister, Ian, and David Studler. 1992. Gender and representa
ments of the United States and Western Europe: An overview. tion among legislative candidates in Australia. Comparative
In The women's movements of the United States and Western Political Studies 3:388-411.
Europe, ed. Mary Fansoid Katzenstein and Carol Mueller, Meehan, Elizabeth, and Selma Sevenhuijsen, eds. 1991. Equality
3-20. Philadelphia: Temple University Press. politics and gender. London: Sage.
Katzenstein, Mary Fansoid, and Carol Mueller, eds. 1987. The Meyer, JohnW, John Boli, George M. Thomas, and Francisco O.
women's movements of the United States and Western Europe. Ramirez. 1997. World society and the nation-state. American
Philadelphia:Temple UniversityPress. Journal of Sociology 103:144-81.
Keck, Margaret E., and Kathryn Sikkink, eds. 1998. Activists Meyer, JohnW, and Brian Rowan. 1977. Institutionalized orga
beyond borders: Advocacy networks in international politics. nizations: Formal structure as myth and ceremony. American
Meyer, John W., and W. Richard Scott. 1992. Organizational Institute for Democracy and Electoral Assistance/CEE
environments: Ritual and rationality. 2nd ed. Newbury Park, Network for Gender Issues Conference, Budapest, Hungary,
CA: Sage. October 22-23.
Mintrom, Michael. 1997. Policy entrepreneurs and the diffusion of Silovic, Dasa S. 2004. Lobbying for quotas: The experience of
innovation. American Journal of Political Science 41 (3): 738-70. the CEE Network for gender issues. Paper presented at the
Morgan, Kimberly J., and Kathrin Zippel. 2003. Paid to care: The International Institute forDemocracy and Electoral Assistance/
origins and effects of care leave policies inWestern Europe. CEE Network for Gender Issues Conference, Budapest,
Social Politics: International Studies in Gender, State, and Hungary, October 22-23.
Society 10 (1): 49-85. Singh, Rina. 1998. Gender autonomy in Western Europe: An
Norris, Pippa, E. Vallance, and Joni Lovenduski. 1992. Do candi imprecise revolution. London: Macmillan.
dates make a difference? Gender, race, ideology and incum Skocpol, Theda, Marjorie Abend-Wein, and
Christopher Howard,
bency. Parliamentary Affairs 4:496-517. Susan G. Lehmann. 1993. Women's associations and the
Nowakowska, Ursula. 2000. Government mechanisms for the enactment of mothers' pensions in theUnited States. American
advancement of women. In Polish women in the 90s, ed. Ursula Political Science Review 87 (3): 686-701.
Nowakowska. Warsaw, Poland:
Women's Rights Center, http:// Stetson, Dorothy McBride, and Amy G. Mazur, eds. 1995.
Minneapolis, Minnesota: Minnesota University Press. works and policy diffusion: The case of gender mainstream
Reingold, Beth.1996. Conflict and cooperation: Legislative strat ing. International Studies Quarterly 45:27-57.
egies andconcepts of power among female and male state Vega, A., and J. Firestone. 1995. The effects of gender on con
legislators. Journal of Politics 58:464-85. gressional behavior and the substantive representation of
Rene-Roe, Joanna. 2003. The representation of women in the women. Legislative Studies Quarterly 2:213-22.
political decision-making process in Poland: Existing problems Walker, Jack L. 1969. The diffusion of innovations among
and advocated solutions. Presented at the ECPR Joint Session American states. American Political Science Review 63:
ing Gender Relations," Edinburgh, UK, March 28 toApril 2. Waltz, Kenneth. 1979. Theory of international politics. Reading,
Research Network on Gender Politics and the State (RNGS). MA:Addison-Wesley.
(2005). RNGS project description/May2005. Unpublished Wangnerud, Lena. 2000. Testing the politics of presence: Women's
Stephen C. Ropp, and Kathryn Sikkink, 1-38. Cambridge: Watson, Peggy. 2000. Politics, policy and identity: EU eastern
Academy of Political and Social Science 528:75-87. Wilkowska, Anna. 2003. Gender equality standards in Poland:
Ross, Karen. 2002. Women's place inmale space: Gender effect The results of the enlargement process. NEWW-Polska.
in parliamentary contexts. Parliamentary Affairs 55:189-202. http://www.eonet.ro (accessed April 14, 2005).
Saxonberg, Steven. 2000. Women in East European parliaments. Zielinska, Eleonora. 2002. Monitoring the EU accession process:
Journal of Democracy 11 (2): 145-58. Equal opportunities for women and men in Poland. Budapest,
Sclozman, K, N. Burns, S. Verba, and J.Donahue. 1995. Gender Hungary: The Network Women's Program and the Open
and citizen participation: Is there a different voice? American Society Foundation Romania.
Journal of Political Science 2:267-93. Zippel, Kathrin. 2006. The politics of sexual harassment: A com
Siemenska, Renata. 2004. The implementation of quotas: parative study of the United States, the European Union, and
European experience. Paper presented at the International Germany. Cambridge: Press.
Cambridge University